Article—Does the knowledge base of today serve knowledge—the industry of tomorrow?
The following article by Professor Brian D O Anderson, President, was published in the Business/Higher Education Round Table Newsletter. It was published on the Academy's website on 26 July 1999.
The following article by Professor Brian D O Anderson, President, was published in the Business/Higher Education Round Table Newsletter. It was published on the Academy's website on 26 July 1999.
In the future, companies will build their success on the ownership or use of some sort of knowledge. The wealth of countries will also be built on knowledge.
Knowledge is what turns raw materials into marketable products. Knowledge is creating new materials and new types of products and processes. In many cases, knowledge itself is the product. Commodities that do not contain knowledge are worth very little, to importers and to consumers, and are declining in value.
On the other hand, clever products are precious and profitable. When products embody knowledge, the copying of that knowledge is often cheap. In a CD-ROM of the Encyclopaedia Britannica, retailing at about $200, the raw material from which the disk is fabricated might cost about $1 and reproduction might cost another $1. The rest of the value is knowledge. So if you have the knowledge, its cost of replication is in many cases almost nothing.
For a car, the cost of production is a much greater part of the final price. Even so, knowledge – incorporated into clever materials, aerodynamic design, lean production methods and computerised driving controls – is increasingly adding value to cars and differentiating luxury models from basic ones.
In agriculture, biotechnology may soon increase the knowledge that goes into growing the food we eat; indeed, the biotechnology revolution of the 21st century will over the medium to long term be profoundly transformational of world society
There are other areas of knowledge where advances have profound implications for our future. Examples include materials science and nanotechnology.
However, in this short paper I will concentrate on one area of knowledge that is also a key technology-computing and communications technology.
The lessons to be drawn from computing and communications technology could also be drawn, in very similar terms, from other areas of scientific and technological growth.
For most of this century, as people have moved from the country to cities and from factories to offices, service industries have been the fastest growing part of advanced economies. Knowledge is almost the defining characteristic of a service industry: think of stock brokers, travel agents, traders and the professions. One of the largest service industries of all is government, which is nothing if not a producer and user of knowledge.
The tool that has been used to apply knowledge to every area of business and government, and which as a result has become a major industry itself, is the computer. It is the most pervasive tool in modern society: farming, mining, manufacturing, banking, airlines, education and public services – all depend on computer hardware and software and communication networks.
On a scale of intelligence that goes from data, through information and then knowledge, to wisdom, computers have progressed from processing data to handling information, that is, organised data. In limited areas, such as medicine and law, inventors assert that their expert computer systems have knowledge. No computer system yet exhibits wisdom.
But computers and communication are the key technology of the information revolution. In a decade or two, the most successful companies will be those which manage knowledge the best, and much of their success will be based on computer systems which are knowledgable i.e. in some ways mimic human reasoning processes. The beginning glimmers can be seen, in medicine and law as mentioned above, and in technologies such as datamining. The internet search engine company, Yahoo, was recently valued by the stock market at billions of dollars – and in comparison with the knowledge engines we shall see in a few years, it is primitive.
Acquiring and using new knowledge of course means research, development and training involving a broad range of disciplines. But as well as discovering smarter processes and products, we need to find out how people gain and use knowledge within an organisation. In part reflecting the process of organisational flattening, but also because of its intrinsic value, the future outstanding companies will need the capability to extract and store tacit knowledge or relevant experience from their individual employees, and organise it into a framework that makes it easily accessible to others in the organisation to enhance how they can work. Today this is impossible, for we lack a workable theory of knowledge which embraces its representation, manipulation and transmission between one machine and another and between machines and people.
Because of the huge investment all industries are making in knowledge, information technology and telecommunications are forecast to become the largest sector of economic activity worldwide. If the same thing is to happen in Australia in a manner that confers the full benefits on our citizens rather than foreign shareholders, we have to act decisively and deliberately. A precondition to stay at the forefront of a knowledge industry, like any other, is research in its underpinning technologies.
In September 1998 the Australian Research Council published a review of the Australian disciplinary research base in information technology, prepared by the Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering, called Information Technology: Sink or Swim. This report sounds not just a muted alarm bell, but a deafening siren for Australia, a siren directed at governments, universities and business. The report says, in relation to our IT research capability, 'We are going backwards.' And at the same time the report notes that the ratio of IT imports to exports is 4:1 against us and worsening.
As the preface to the Sink or Swim report states, 'Either Australia embraces the Information Age wholeheartedly and moves towards a prosperous future in the 21st century or it continues to rely on primary industry exports to be able to import the high technology products which are so enthusiastically consumed. If Australia chooses the first option and "swims" with the tide, it can join other countries like Ireland, Israel, Finland, Sweden and Taiwan. But if Australia continues down its current path, it will "sink" in the face of ever increasing competition from emerging nations in agricultural and minerals markets.'
What are we failing to do? The report dwells mainly on the failures in training and shortcomings of the disciplinary research base – other reports have dwelt on the industry structure. First, Australia is moving backwards, relative to its competitors, in terms of the supply of professional IT staff and trained researchers for business and academia. The Sink or Swim report says that the number of computer science graduates needs to be increased, with six times as many postgraduate students by 2010! This newsletter has published figures (June 1998) showing that in 1992, compared to Australia, Japan had four times as many engineering graduates as a percentage of total graduates; it would be no surprise to see a similar figure in information science and technology.
Having qualified people for research and industry makes up one part of the supply chain. Maintaining the intellectual pace in the universities and CSIRO is another. Sink or Swim says our position in IT research and development is declining relative to other countries. Business research performance in the IT area is low and university research groups often lack a critical mass.
Many recent government actions have not helped. We have a government which significantly attenuated the financial attractiveness for industry to engage in research and development, notwithstanding the endorsement by the Industries Commission of the justice in public funding of R&D tax concessions, given the spillover benefits. Unfortunately this has also occurred when international surveys have demonstrated the significantly lower priority given to innovation by Australian company executives as compared to their foreign counterparts.
The government has also increased the price of a tertiary science or engineering education relative to the humanities.
Nevertheless, the Federal Government has initiated one significant development recently: setting up the Australian Partnership for Advanced Computing, headquartered at the Australian National University. This is a consortium of Australian universities established to operate a high-performance computing facility for research, training and the diffusion of techniques to industry.
Another round of Cooperative Research Centre grants will be decided in the near future. All the proposals for new IT cooperative research centres were knocked out in the preliminary screening. The only way to maintain the rather low level of IT research conducted through the CRC program is for all the existing centres seeking renewal to receive funding.
Governments have known for a number of years, through a variety of reports, that computer science as an intellectual discipline in Australian universities is weak. Both Labor and coalition governments have been unable to create policies to fix an area of national importance.
There seems a lack of systematic policy instruments to address the problem. The Australian Research Council cannot do it: its job is, broadly, the support of excellence. The Australian Partnership for Advanced Computing is confined to a small disciplinary area. The Cooperative Research Centre program is not designed to build up weak but important areas.
These problems have been exacerbated by the substantial lowering of government funding for universities. Because of the comparative sparsity of local outstanding academic talent, universities have desperate need of some outstanding talent from abroad in the IT area. The universities must have sufficient money to attract distinguished individuals to nucleate centres of excellence.
The starting salaries offered by industry to bachelor computer science graduates tempt them away from further study. To train the most talented graduates for research, we need to offer more attractive postgraduate scholarships in selected disciplines. A recent Government move to offer 50 new post graduate industry-linked scholarships is welcome, but obviously only a small component of fixing our problem.
The privatisation of government utilities such as Telstra has also meant that these utilities have reduced substantially the attention they give to conducting or subcontracting research and development with universities. They are understandably putting more effort into seeking to maintain a market share through better customer service, and lowering cost structures.
Last year I gave evidence to the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Industry, Science and Technology on behalf of the Australian Academy of Science. I argued that the government needs a mechanism to compensate for the loss of utility funding for IT research. The rural research funds could be a model: to reduce the demand on public funds, industry stakeholders contribute.
The problem of corporate under-investment in research and development needs addressing in the most determined way, and not just of course for the IT sector. The 150 per cent tax concession for research and development should be restored, or a variant of it introduced – there are plenty of international models. The Government should also implement the Ralph report proposals to move away from our punitive capital gains tax regime.
Australia will only remain among the advanced countries through the production and exploitation of knowledge. If a company has knowledge, it can make profits. If a nation has knowledge, it can survive and prosper in an information revolution. But we must have a change of public policy settings and private attitudes.
Article—Science and engineering faculties–from Federation to today and beyond
The following article was written by Professor Brian D O Anderson AO PresAA FRS FTSE, President, Australian Academy of Science. It was published on the Academy's website on 16 August 2001. An edited version was printed in Campus Review, September 12-18, 2001.
The following article was written by Professor Brian D O Anderson AO PresAA FRS FTSE, President, Australian Academy of Science. It was published on the Academy's website on 16 August 2001. An edited version was printed in Campus Review, September 12-18, 2001.
January 1, 1901 and a young Australia boasted four universities – Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide and Tasmania – all of which offered courses in science. During the year of Federation our fifth university, Queensland, was established, continuing the tradition of including science in its curriculum. Our newly formed nation was focused on developing roads, rail and building infrastructure, and already experiencing the impact of science and technology-based industry as telephone and electricity services expanded.
It was to be expected in those early years that researchers in our fledgling universities would look to Britain for recognition and acknowledgement. The establishment of the Rhodes scholarship in 1904 took some of our brightest graduates to England, many never to return. Not until after the Second World War would scientists working in Australia see themselves more in an Australian, rather than a British, context. And with the introduction of the PhD degree in the late 1940s, our own universities could at last supply a skilled scientific workforce.
The establishment of other publicly and privately funded scientific institutions outside the universities added to the critical mass of the science and engineering base in Australia. The most notable of these was the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR). After its establishment in 1926 and restructure to the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO) in 1949, the organisation played a significant role in diversifying the areas of scientific research in Australia, and provided career opportunities for our university graduates.
The establishment of the Australian National University (ANU) in 1946 as a research-only institution, and the injection of Commonwealth funds that allowed a significant development of university research schools in the 1960s, further enhanced the capability of scientific research in this country.
The myxomatosis story, that began with experiments by CSIR in the 1930s and unfolded during the subsequent decades, was an early example of what could be achieved by scientific collaboration between institutions. The virology expertise provided by scientists at the ANU, working in collaboration with the CSIRO, resulted in a story that has become a well-known part of Australian scientific history.
The last decade has seen a proliferation in the diversity of opportunity for young graduates across a wide range of areas encompassing pure, applied and strategic research. This has largely come about through the establishment in 1990 of the Cooperative Research Centres (CRCs) Program. CRCs play an important role in the Australian innovation system, bringing together researchers and research users from universities, the public sector and business.
Australian scientific research and development has historically been confined largely to public institutions. Notwithstanding initiatives such as CRCs, this remains the case today, with business investment in research and development ('BIRD') at a plateau. With the increasing acknowledgement that it is unrealistic to expect the public purse to provide fully the required increase in R&D funding, the role of business has become even more crucial. Close monitoring of 'BIRD' will be required to determine whether the new settings for tax incentives are working. If not, it will be vital to revise the settings as a matter of urgency.
If we reflect on the influence that Australian science and engineering faculties have had on Australia and the world we find an enormous contribution, not only at the practical level in terms of research outcomes, but also at the level of the Australian psyche. We have a record of producing outstanding graduates who make outstanding contributions. From world-class engineering feats such as the Snowy Mountains Hydroelectric Scheme in our own land, to scientific achievements that changed the course of history such as the development of penicillin by an expatriate graduate, we are confident that we can hold our own on the world stage.
Australians remain inventive researchers, skilled at delivering impressive achievements on what are, by international standards, modest budgets. The science and engineering faculties in our universities may be doing it tough economically, but they continue to produce graduates who make significant contributions by all conventional measures at the international level. We have had to come to terms with political and commercial influences and work in a world of complex and often competing demands.
The explosion in information and the technology that underpins it has had as significant an impact on science and engineering in Australia as any other single factor. The sequencing of the human genome and the rapid expansion of the internet makes today's world of science and engineering research one that our colleagues in the universities at Federation would scarcely recognise.
The selection criteria for a modern-day scientific researcher appears daunting – until we realise that we are producing people with just such a skill set. Not only must today's researcher excel at the bench; they must also be excellent written and oral communicators, able to deliver riveting presentations using cutting-edge audio-visual technology. They must be able to develop an international reputation, build networks, work effectively in teams as well as individually, and raise the funds to sustain their research.
From the very early days, Australians demonstrated the inventiveness and initiative that remained the hallmark of our scientific and engineering endeavour throughout the first 100 years of Federation. The Australian Academy of Science is uniquely positioned to appreciate the richness and diversity of the research occurring in Australia as we enter our second 100 years as a nation. In 2001, the Academy elected 17 new Fellows, working in some 13 different fields of research from organometallic chemistry and human disease through to materials engineering and coral reef ecology. These eminent researchers were drawn from 13 different institutions. Criteria for election to fellowship are rigorous, and those who are successful have made major contributions to their field of work and have an international reputation borne out in publications and invitations to conferences as plenary speakers.
We continue to applaud the talent and dedication of Australia's scientific researchers, those who were the pioneers through to today's brightest. We must in closing though, commend the institutions, in particular the universities, that have supported and enabled them to achieve all that has been achieved. In Benjamin Disraeli's words, 'Individuals may form communities, but it is institutions alone that can create a nation.'
Footnote: The Academy's bicentennial publication titled Australian Science in the Making provides an interesting and informative account of Australian science's first 200 years.
Vale: Former Academy President David Craig
Former Academy President and prominent Australian chemist, Professor David Craig, has passed away aged 95.
Former Academy President and prominent Australian chemist, Professor David Craig, has passed away aged 95.
Professor Craig was elected to the Academy's Fellowship in 1969 and was Academy President from 1990-1994.
He held the position of Professor of Physical and Theoretical Chemistry at the Australian National University for nearly twenty years until 1984.
The Academy's David Craig medal which recognises outstanding contributions to chemistry research was also named in his honour.
Apply for the chance to visit US National Institutes of Health
The Australian Academy of Science is encouraging young scientists to apply for a chance to visit the National Institutes of Health in the United States under one of its international scholarship programs.
The Australian Academy of Science is encouraging young scientists to apply for a chance to visit the National Institutes of Health in the United States under one of its international scholarship programs.
Expressions of interest are invited from scientists, 30 years of age or under, working in any health-related field of natural science. The 2016 visit would aim to help foster international collaboration and develop the winning applicant's career.
Only Australian citizens and Australian permanent residents living in Australia at the time of application are eligible to apply.
The closing date for expressions of interest is Monday 1 June 2015.
This scheme is funded by the Adam J. Berry Memorial Fund (PDF, 122KB) and is operated in collaboration with the Foundation for the National Institutes of Health.
For more information contact grants@science.org.au
'NIH Clinical Research Center aerial' by NIH. Licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons
Five Fellows chosen for new science council
Five Fellows of the Australian Academy of Science have been chosen to advise government through a new science council chaired by the Prime Minister.
Five Fellows of the Australian Academy of Science have been chosen to advise government through a new science council chaired by the Prime Minister.
Astrophysicist Professor Brian Schmidt, mathematician Professor Nalini Joshi, immunologist Professor Ian Frazer, physicist Professor Tanya Monro and Telstra CEO Catherine Livingstone will join other business leaders, ministers and the chief scientist as part of the newly established Commonwealth Science Council.
The council, which replaces the Prime Minister's Science Engineering and Innovation Council or PMSEIC, will be the pre-eminent government advisory body on scientific matters and was announced yesterday as part of the government's new industry innovation and competitiveness agenda.
The government's announcement also included new industry-led growth centres to connect researchers and business, funding for new science and maths education programs, and other industry reforms.
The council will meet twice yearly and for the first time before the end of the year.
Read the Academy's media release responding to the announcement
Mathematician and Fellow wins distinguished UK Fellowship
Academy Fellow and mathematician Professor Nalini Joshi has been awarded the London Mathematical Society Hardy Fellowship for 2015.
Academy Fellow and mathematician Professor Nalini Joshi has been awarded the London Mathematical Society Hardy Fellowship for 2015.
Named after former Soceity President G.H. Hardy, the Fellowship is awarded to a distinguished overseas mathematician and asks them to deliver the Hardy Lecture at the Society's annual meeting.
Normally the Fellowship is awarded in even numbered years but Professor Joshi has been awarded a special Fellowship in 2015 to coincide with the Society's 150th anniversary year.
The Fellowship includes a long list of eminent past winners, including Academy corresponding member Terrence Tao.
More information about the Hardy Fellowship
Caption: Professor Nalini Joshi has been awarded next year's Hardy Fellowship by the London Mathematical Society.
Vietnamese Ministry of Science and Technology
A delegation from the Vietnamese Ministry of Science and Technology visited the Academy on 4 December to share Australia’s experience in science, technology and innovation (STI) reform. The visit preceded the start of a new US$100 million FIRST Project (Fostering Innovation through Research, Science and Technology) with World Bank financing. This project will design and pilot STI policies, make R&D institutions more effective, and encourage innovative technology enterprises.
A delegation from the Vietnamese Ministry of Science and Technology visited the Academy on 4 December to share Australia’s experience in science, technology and innovation (STI) reform. The visit preceded the start of a new US$100 million FIRST Project (Fostering Innovation through Research, Science and Technology) with World Bank financing. This project will design and pilot STI policies, make R&D institutions more effective, and encourage innovative technology enterprises.
R&D institutions and innovative technology enterprises that invest in R&D will benefit from the project. It also supports spin-offs and start-up enterprises incubated from R&D institutions or universities, and the establishment of a public-private partnership research laboratory in Hoa Lac High-Tech Park.
IAP and IAMP joint statement on atimicrobial resistance
IAP - The Global Network of Science Academies, and the InterAcademy Medical Panel (IAMP) has issued a joint statement on ‘Antimicrobial Resistance: A Call for Action’.
IAP - The Global Network of Science Academies, and the InterAcademy Medical Panel (IAMP) has issued a joint statement on ‘Antimicrobial Resistance: A Call for Action’.
In the joint statement IAP and IAMP highlight the critical role that antimicrobial (including antibacterial, antiviral, antifungal and antiparasitic) drugs play in today’s medical practices, but also that there have been dramatic increases in the number of pathogens developing resistance to these drugs.
If the current major public health problem of antimicrobial resistance is to be reduced, and if a much worse crisis is to be averted, IAP and IAMP propose a series of 10 recommendations.
Among the recommendations are a call for immediate action to include the issue of antimicrobial resistance in the global sustainable development agenda; the promotion of integrated world-wide surveillance systems that should include both human and animal diseases (so-called “one-health”); education programmes for the prudent use of antimicrobials for medical and veterinary professionals, as well as for patients and the wider public; and the need for additional research – including building research capacity in developing countries, with the aims of better understanding the determinants of resistance and of devising new therapeutics, diagnostics and vaccines.
Read the full statement here.
Vale Peter Pockley
Long-time science journalist Dr Peter Pockley, a pioneer of science Peterpockley programs at the ABC, died at his home in Sydney yesterday.
Long-time science journalist Dr Peter Pockley, a pioneer of science Peterpockley programs at the ABC, died at his home in Sydney yesterday.
Dr Pockley was the first and only journalist to be awarded the Academy Medal. He was one of the founders of the ABC Science Unit in the 1960s, and has been called the father of science communication in Australia. He mentored many Australian scientists and science communicators over decades and was an established writer and broadcaster in his own right.
Dr Pockley died peacefully, while sitting in the sun. He is survived by his wife Jenny, daughter Kate and two grandchildren.
New Interviews with Australian Scientists available
The Academy's educational program Interviews with Australian Scientists has a new interview available with Dr Cyril Appleby, Plant biologist, in conversation with Jim Peacock.
The Academy's educational program Interviews with Australian Scientists has a new interview available with Dr Cyril Appleby, Plant biologist, in conversation with Jim Peacock.
Appleby describes how his interest in science began when when he was 8 years old watching smoke escape from his neighbour’s burning leaves. Despite being labeled as a ‘precocious’ student with a complete lack of sporting finesse, he successfully navigated school and went on to complete a PhD in yeast biochemistry. Appleby discusses a life studying plant and microbial cytochromes and haemoglobins, including how a brief bit of ‘carelessness’ lead to him crystallise the first ever cytochrome.
View the full interivew.