Stephen John Angyal 1914–2012

Professor Stephen Angyal OBE FAA was a world authority on carbohydrate chemistry. He was known for his discoveries on inositol, international collaboration and leadership at UNSW.

Image Description
Stephen John Angyal 1914–2012

Stephen Angyal was born in Budapest, Hungary, on 21 November 1914 and died in Sydney on 14 May 2012. He had a distinguished career as an organic chemist as a lecturer in chemistry at Sydney University (1946–52), as an associate professor in organic chemistry at the New South Wales University of Technology (1953–9), and as Professor of Organic Chemistry at the University of New South Wales (1960–79) where he served as Head of School (1968–70) and Dean of the Faculty of Science (1970–9). He was internationally recognised for his contributions in the fields of inositol and carbohydrate chemistry, being appointed as the Haworth Memorial Lecturer of the Chemical Society, London, in 1980 and as the recipient of the Claude S. Hudson Award of the American Chemical Society in 1987. He was elected as a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1962 and as an External Member of the Hungarian Academy of Science in 1990 and his contributions to science in Australia were acknowledged in the award of Officer of the Order of the British Empire (OBE) in 1977.

Family background

Stephen John Angyal was born in Budapest on 21 November 1914, the first child of Charles Engel and Marie Engel (née Szanto). His father, Professor Charles Engel, was born in a village in the North of Hungary in 1879. Charles studied in Budapest, received his medical degree in 1902 and became a highly respected specialist in syphilis. He published two books on the subject. Stephen married Helga Ellen Steininger in 1942. They had two children, Annette (b. 1944, now Associate Professor Annette Gero, a biochemist) and Robert (b. 1949, a barrister at law, married Abby Bloom, two daughters, Chloe and Claire). Helga came from Vienna where her father, Dr Jacques Steininger practiced as a lawyer. Her mother was Augusta Steininger. As a keen reader of literature, Charles told young Stephen about his books while they were on Sunday morning walks, introducing him to the works of one of his favourite authors, Somerset Maugham. Charles was an accomplished pianist and regularly played chamber music with several string players (including some of Hungary’s now famous twentieth-century composers, who came to the house) Stephen often turned the pages for his father. These sessions introduced Stephen to nineteenth-century chamber works and laid the foundation for his life-long love of music. To speak several languages was important in Central Europe, and his parents engaged German nannies, usually young country girls. Stephen spoke German before Hungarian. Later, for his last three summer vacations at school, he was sent to a Swiss institution to learn French, and he also took lessons in English at home in the afternoons. This early facility with several European languages was to stand him in good stead through his long life in academia.

Stephen had one brother, Charles Leslie Angell (1926–2007) who migrated to Sydney in 1947. After completing a MSc degree from the University of Sydney in 1951, Charles obtained a PhD degree in chemistry from Cambridge University in 1955. He worked as a Research Scientist with Union Carbide in New York. He was an expert in the field of infrared spectroscopy and was President of the Coblentz Society from 1969 to 1971. He is survived by his wife Margee, son Stephen and daughter Catharine. 

Education

At 10 years of age, Stephen enrolled in the prestigious high school of the Piarest order where he studied Latin and Greek, much literature and essentially no chemistry. During this time, Stephen joined the school’s scout group where he learned to swim and also the art of skiing, two activities that he practiced with much enthusiasm until very late in life. He hung up his skis at the age of 92. After high school, he enrolled at the Royal Hungarian University of Science in Budapest where he studied chemistry, physics, mathematics, geology and mineralogy. For the PhD degree, Stephen moved to the other university in Budapest, the University for Technology and Engineering, where he enrolled under Professor Géza Zemplén, although most of the supervision was done by an assistant, Z. Csürös. The research work on glucose derivatives which led to the award of the Doctors degree Summa cum laude in June 1937 did not spark the imagination of Stephen and he vowed never to work with carbohydrates again.

Prior to enrolling with Zemplén, Stephen changed his name from the German spelling (Engel) to the Hungarian version, Angyal. His formal education was completed by one year’s military service, graduating from officers’ school as a Lieutenant in the reserve. 

Early work

Stephen’s first job after graduation was as a research chemist with Chinoin, one of Hungary’s leading pharmaceutical manufacturers. Here he worked on the production of synthetic oestrogens and sulfathiazole. Knowledge of the latter would later lead to his first job when he arrived in Australia. With great foresight, Stephen obtained a landing permit for Australia, which he received on 3 July 1939. September 1939 saw the start of World War II and Stephen was called up for army duty. Again, luck was with him as Hungary kept out of the conflict until November 1940 and Stephen was demobilised. He immediately made preparations for his emigration and left Hungary early in 1940, travelling to Milan and boarding in Genoa the passenger ship Viminale, which happened to be the last Italian ship to leave for Australia as, soon after, Italy entered the war on the Axis side. 

After arriving in Sydney, Stephen met a fellow Hungarian, Dr Andrew Ungar, with whom he started a small company, named Andrews Laboratories. Although at the time little came of this venture, the association was of considerable significance in later years. To keep in touch with the local chemistry community, Stephen used to visit the Chemistry Department of Sydney University where he met Dr Frank Lions who told him of their synthesis of sulfathiazole as part of the war effort. Stephen noted that he had also made that drug, and after this was reported in a local newspaper he received a phone call from a Melbourne pharmaceutical company, Nicholas Pty Ltd, in which Stephen was offered a job as a research chemist. During the five years that Stephen worked in Melbourne, he became aware of a compound, inositol, thought at the time to be a member of the vitamin B group. He decided that as very little was known about its chemistry, it may be worth studying some day. In connection(1) with the synthesis of a new sulfa drug, marfanil, Stephen noted an unusual reaction that had been discovered by the French chemist, Sommelet. He decided that this reaction warranted further study and the  results led to a series of papers and a review.(2)

A particularly happy event that had life-long ramifications for Stephen was his meeting in Melbourne with a lovely young girl, Helga Steininger. Originally from Vienna, Helga had arrived from England six months earlier. She worked as a dress designer. They were married in Melbourne in February 1942 and remained an inseparable couple for the rest of Stephen’s life.

Academic appointments

In 1946, Stephen secured a lectureship in chemistry at Sydney University and here he started a study on the Sommelet reaction as well as the early work on inositols. During that year, he was admitted as an Associate of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute (RACI) and later (1953) was elected as a fellow of the RACI. As a result of Australia being geographically isolated from the northern hemisphere countries where most chemical research is carried out, it was usual for Australian academics to be given a year’s paid leave every seventh year to allow them to study overseas. During his sixth year at Sydney University, Stephen was invited by Alexander Todd, who was a Visiting Professor at the university, to spend his study leave at Cambridge University. As Todd was one of the trustees of the prestigious Nuffield Dominion Travelling Fellowship, he suggested that Stephen should apply for one which in due course he was awarded. During his stay in Cambridge, Stephen met an Australian chemist, John Mills. From their mutual interest in conformational analysis, they wrote a review(3) for Reviews of Pure and Applied Chemistry. They later collaborated on several aspects of metal ion complexes. 

In 1952, Stephen obtained a grant-in-aid from the Carnegie Corporation of New York. This allowed him to visit several institutions in the USA on his way back to Australia in February 1953. Among the chemists that Stephen met were Hermann Fischer with whom he spent his next study leave and Ernest Eliel, a fellow contributor to the well known book, Conformational Analysis.(4)

While Stephen was on his study leave in Cambridge, an advertisement for an associate professor in organic chemistry appeared from the New South Wales University of Technology. He applied for that position and was successful, taking up the appointment in March 1953. In 1958, the name of the institution was changed to The University of New South Wales (UNSW hereafter) and Faculties of Arts and of Medicine were established in 1960 and 1961 respectively. In 1960, Stephen successfully applied for the newly created chair of organic chemistry and he became the first Professor of Organic Chemistry at UNSW. 

Stephen was now in a position to start work on the inositols. Few aspects of cyclitol chemistry escaped the attention of the Angyal group. In over 60 papers, cyclic acetals, sulfonic esters, phosphoric esters, aminocyclitols and their deamination, 5-carbon cyclitols, acyl migration, tritium labelling, and selective protection were dealt with. Of the nine possible isomers of inositol, only the common one, myo-inositol, which is widespread in nature, is available at a reasonable price from commercial sources. The preparation of acetal derivatives of inositols, in particular, acetone derivatives, was the key to the interconversion of the various isomers. Satisfactory acetonation of myo-inositol was achieved only after a detailed study(5) of the reaction conditions. Two of the nine isomers had not been prepared at the beginning of this research. The first one, neo-inositol, was prepared(6) from the tosylate of levo-inositol diacetal. The remaining isomer, cis-inositol, proved to be the most difficult to prepare. Initially isolated(7) by chromatography over cellulose powder from the multitude of products formed by hydrogenation of hexahydroxybenzene, later prepared(8) in 25% yield in seven steps from epi-inositol and finally obtained(9) in 31% from hydrogenation of tetrahydroxyquinone using an improved catalyst and separation of products on an ion-exchange column. 

A most significant result that emerged from these early studies involved the interaction between the inositol hydroxyl groups and sodium borate in aqueous solution.(10,11) The products were shown to be tridentate boric esters. From the equilibrium constants determined for this reaction, the free-energy changes of complex formation were calculated. As the different non-bonded interactions determined the extent of complex formation, it was possible to calculate these various energies of interaction. Another reaction discovered at this time involved treatment of inositols with acetic acid containing sulfuric acid. For those inositols in which a cis-trans sequence of hydroxyl groups occurs, it was found(12) that epimerisation occurs at the middle carbon atom. A reasonable mechanism for this reaction was described. Again, non-bonded interaction energies could be calculated(13) from the differences between the free energies of the epimers. 

A detailed review on the cyclitols was written with Laurens Anderson(14) at this time and RACI recognised(15) the research by the award of the H. G. Smith Memorial Medal in 1958. 

With the values for interaction energies for inositols in hand, Stephen applied these values to the pyranose forms of reducing sugars in order to explain the α: β ratios for aqueous solutions(16) and the ratios of reducing sugars and the 1,6-anhydrides in equilibrium(17) and later extended this work to acyclic compounds.(18) At this time Stephen published an article on the composition and conformations of sugar in solution.(19) He regarded this as his most successful paper, as it was used in several universities as a teaching aid with every student being given a copy. A much more detailed review on conformational analysis as applied to carbohydrates was published in the well known textbook.(20) Stephen was awarded the Archibold D. Ollé Prize by RACI for this publication.

As part of a study leave in 1962, Stephen gave a lecture tour in Israel on the way to Paris where he spent six weeks at the Institute for the Chemistry of Natural Products. He then travelled to London to take up an appointment as temporary senior lecturer in D. H. R. Barton’s department at the Imperial College of Science and Technology. During this study leave, Stephen attended the first International Symposium on Carbohydrate Chemistry (that meeting is now regarded as number II). Subsequently, he attended almost all of these biannual meetings and after his retirement from UNSW in 1979, he organized and hosted the 10th meeting which was held at UNSW in Sydney. Participants remember this meeting with much fondness. An historical account(21) of these meetings was published in 2008. 

Stephen’s interest in carbohydrates was rekindled when he was invited to review the topic for Annual Reviews of Biochemistry.(22) At this time, the award of a research grant enabled the purchase of a Varian A60 nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometer. Now a method was available to him for the determination of the composition of many aldoses in aqueous solution using 1H NMR spectroscopy. These studies were extended to ketoses(23) after a 13C NMR spectrometer became available. This work led to a comprehensive review(24) of sugar compositions in solution, followed by a supplementary review(25) seven years later. As a prelude to this experimental work, Stephen published a detailed paper(26) on the conformational free energies of aldopyranoses in solution in which the interaction energies mentioned above were applied to the reducing sugars. 

Following up on electrophoresis studies by John Mills in which he showed that various polyols complexed with a variety of salts, Stephen commenced a study,(27) using 1H NMR spectroscopy, of the complexing of sugars with metal cations. This led to a significant series of papers which covered a diverse range of topics such as the modification of glycosidation using acidified methanol plus salts to give less readily obtained glycosides(28–30) and dimethylacetals,(31) and application of cation-exchange resins,(32,33) commonly in the Ca2+ form, to effect separation of glycosides,(34) inositols,(35) and, in his last experimental paper, applied to the preparation of L-ribose.(36) These studies were the subject of several reviews(37–40) and formed his topic for the Haworth Memorial Lecture,(41) delivered on 31 March, 1980 and also for the C S Hudson Award Address.(42) Support for the proposed structures of metal cation complexes deduced from NMR spectra was obtained by single-crystal X-ray diffraction studies.(43–45) In a detailed paper(46) on methyl aldofuranosides, Stephen extended his studies on conformations to five-membered ring compounds. In this paper, extensive 1H NMR data were collected and the conformations deduced therefrom were correlated with optical rotation values. In a short series of papers, the application of chromium trioxide in acetic acid was described in which O-methyl groups were converted(47) into O-formates. Acetylated methyl glycosides gave(48) acetylated methyl 5-hexulosonates, acetylated acetals of alditols gave(49) derivatives of 3-hexuloses and cyclic methylene acetals gave cyclic carbonates.(50) Building upon the discovery by Koch and Stuart that the methyne hydrogen of secondary alcohols can be exchanged for deuterium using deuterated Raney nickel in deuterium oxide, Stephen applied the procedure to a variety of compounds, including inositols and inositol methyl ethers,(51) methyl glycosides,(52) and 1,6-anhydrohexoses.(53)

Many research students and collaborators contributed over the years to the realisation of the large body of experimental work recorded in Stephen’s publications. His joint work with John Mills and Laurens Anderson documents important understanding of the inositols and the work of Dennis McHugh, to select just one of the many research contributors in Stephen’s group, on the determination of interaction energies,(54) played a key role in predicting the conformations of polysubstituted six-membered ring systems. As a world expert on inositols, Stephen was chosen to chair the IUPAC committee dealing with inositol nomenclature.(55) Stephen’s role as a leading Australian chemist was recognised by RACI when he was interviewed in 2011 as a ‘living luminary’ (Chemistry in Australia, March 2011).(56)

The Andrews Lectures

During the course of the first International Symposium on the Chemistry of Natural Products which was held in Australia in 1960, Stephen decided to invite one of the participants to give a series of lectures over a two-week period. Professor E. R. H. Jones accepted the invitation and became the first Andrews Lecturer. Funds for the lectures were provided by Dr Andrew Ungar and the lectures were named after his company, Andrews Laboratories. Over the next 50 years, 26 eminent organic chemists have been appointed as Andrews Lecturer, each one delivering three lectures, generally over one to two weeks. It was an essential part of the Lectureship that the lecturer should spend a period between lectures at UNSW and be available for discussions with staff and advanced students. Until his retirement in 1979, Stephen made all the arrangements for these lectureships with significant help from Helga for the social engagements. After he retired, management of the Andrews Lectures was passed to University of New South Wales Chemical Society and they continue to arrange biannual lectureships. 

Administration

Stephen served as Head of the School of Chemistry at UNSW from 1968 to 1970. He was appointed as Dean of the Faculty of Science in 1970 and kept that position until he retired in 1979. Stephen enjoyed being involved in the organisation of conferences. After the Natural Products meeting in 1966, the next major conference was the XXII International Congress of Pure and Applied Chemistry held at the University of Sydney in 1969. Stephen was the convener of the Social Program and Helga chaired the Ladies’ Program Committee. Finally, after his retirement, Stephen organized the Xth International Symposium on Carbohydrate Chemistry, held in 1980. 

Throughout his academic career, Stephen was a keen traveller. He was Visiting Professor at the University of California, Berkeley in 1957, Visiting Lecturer at the Imperial College of Science and Technology, London in 1962, Visiting Professor at the Universities of Oxford and Grenoble in 1968, Visiting Lecturer at ETH, Zurich in 1972 and Visiting Professor at the University of Grenoble in 1977. Besides attending the International Symposia on Carbohydrate Chemistry, Stephen attended several the Bürgenstock Conferences on Stereochemisty and several of the Gordon Conferences on Carbohydrates. 

Although his early papers were published in the Journal of the Chemical Society (London), Stephen later favoured the local publication, the Australian Journal of Chemistry. He served as a member and in turn, chairman, of its editorial board. Despite early reservations on the introduction of a journal devoted solely to carbohydrates, Stephen supported Carbohydrate Research, serving on the Editorial Board for many years and publishing more than 40 papers there. 

Stephen was elected as a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1962 (he served on the Council from 1967 to 1970), awarded the first UNSW DSc degree in 1964, having been admitted to the degree of MSc ad eundem gradum in 1941, appointed as the Haworth Memorial Lecturer of the Chemical Society, London, in 1980 and received the Claude S. Hudson Award of the American Chemical Society in 1987. In 1990, he was honoured by the Hungarian Academy of Science, being elected as an External Member. His contributions to science in Australia were acknowledged in the award of Officer of the Order of the British Empire (OBE) in 1977 and in 2001 he was awarded a Centenary Medal ‘for service to Australian Society through science and stereochemistry’. More recently, his daughter Annette has endowed UNSW with the Angyal Medal, which is awarded each year to the top Honours student of the year in Chemistry, as a permanent memory of Stephen in the School of Chemistry at UNSW. 

Outside interests

Stephen enjoyed several interests besides chemistry. He had learned to ski while at high school and this became a life-long activity until his early nineties. Not surprisingly, most of his study leaves were taken at places close to snow-fields and he also made full use of the skiing facilities in the Australian ski fields. Another life-long pleasure for Stephen was swimming, which he enjoyed year round in the mild climate of Sydney. Both Stephen and Helga were lovers of music. They regularly attended performances of the Sydney Symphony Orchestra and musica viva. Both were staunch supporters of the Australia Ensemble (resident at UNSW) for which Helga was a member of the Advisory Board for many years and it was rare for them to miss a performance. 

Stephen died peacefully on 14 May 2012, aged 97. His beloved wife, Helga, after seventy years of marriage, died peacefully and unexpectedly six months later. 

Bibliography

  1. S. J. Angyal and S. R. Jenkin, ‘Sulphonamides.I. Marfanil and its o- and m-Isomer,’ Australian Journal of Scientific Research A, 3 (1950), 463–465.
  2. S. J. Angyal, ‘The Sommelet Reaction’, Organic Reactions, 8 (1954), 197–217.
  3. S. J. Angyal and J. A. Mills, ‘The Shape and Reactivity of the cyclo-Hexane Ring’, Reviews of Pure & Applied Chemistry, 2 (1952), 185–202.
  4. S. J. Angyal, ‘Conformational Analysis in Carbohydrate Chemistry’ in Conformational Analysis, (New York, 1965), pp. 351–432.
  5. S. J. Angyal, P. T. Gilham and C. G. Macdonald, ‘Cyclitols. Part IV. Methyl Ethers of myo- Inositol’, Journal of the Chemical Society, (1957), 1417–1422.
  6. S. J. Angyal and N. K. Matheson, ‘Cyclitols. Part III. Some Tosyl Esters of Inositols. Synthesis of a New Inositol’, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 77 (1955), 4343–4346.
  7. S. J. Angyal and D. J. McHugh, ‘Cyclitols. Part VI. The Hydrogenation of Hexahydroxybenzene’, Journal of the Chemical Society, (1957), 3682–3691.
  8. S. J. Angyal and R. J. Hickman, ‘Cyclitols. XXXIII. A Practical Synthesis of cis-Inositol’, Carbohydrate Research, 20 (1971), 97–104.
  9. S. J. Angyal, L. Odier, and M. E. Tate, ‘A Simple Synthesis of cis-Inositol’, Carbohydrate Research, 266 (1995), 143–146.
  10. S. J. Angyal and D. J. McHugh, ‘Interaction Energies of Axial Hydroxyl Groups’, Chemistry & Industry (London), (1956), 1147–1148.
  11. S. J. Angyal and D. J. McHugh ‘Cyclitols. Part V. Paper Ionophoresis, Complex Formation with Borate, and the Rate of Periodic Acid Oxidation’, Journal of the Chemical Society, (1957), 1423–1431.
  12. S. J. Angyal, P. A. J. Gorin and M. E. Pitman, ‘A Stereospecific Epimerisation of Cyclitols’, Proceedings of the Chemical Society, (1962), 337–338.
  13. S. J. Angyal, P. A. J. Gorin and M. E. Pitman, ‘Cyclitols. Part XV. A Stereospecific Epimerization of Cyclitols: Conformational Free Energies’, Journal of the Chemical Society, (1965), 1807–1816.
  14. S. J. Angyal and L. Anderson, ‘The Cyclitols’, Advances in Carbohydrate Chemistry, 14 (1959), 135–212.
  15. S. J. Angyal, ‘Inositols: Chemistry, Stereochemistry and Biochemistry’, Proceedings of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute, 27 (1960), 32–38. (Text of the H. G. Smith Memorial Lecture, 16 July, 1959).
  16. S. J. Angyal, ‘Conformational Analysis in Carbohydrate Chemistry. I. Conformational Free Energies. The Conformations and α: β Ratios of Aldopyranoses in Aqueous Solution’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 21 (1968), 2737–2746.
  17. S. J. Angyal and K. Dawes, ‘Conformational Analysis in Carbohydrate Chemistry. II. Equilibria between Reducing Sugars and their Glycosidic Anhydrides,’ Australian Journal of Chemistry, 21 (1968), 2747–2760.
  18. S. J. Angyal and K. James, ‘Conformations of Acyclic Sugar Derivatives. Acetylated Methyl 5-Hexulosonates and keto-Hexuloses’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 23 (1970), 1223–1228. (Part I of the series.)
  19. S. J. Angyal, ‘The Composition and Conformation of Sugars in Solution’, Angewandte Chemie International Edition in English, 8 (1969), 157–166.
  20. Angyal, already cited (n. 4).
  21. S. J. Angyal, ‘International Carbohydrate Symposia – A History’, Advances in Carbohydrate Chemistry and Biochemistry, 61 (2007), 29–58.
  22. S. J. Angyal, and D. Rutherford, ‘Carbohydrates – Mono- and Oligo-saccharides’, Annual Reviews of Biochemistry, 34 (1965), 77–100.
  23. S. J. Angyal, G. S. Bethell, D. E. Cowley and V. A. Pickles, ‘Equilibria between Pyranoses and Furanoses. IV. 1-Deoxyhexuloses and 3-Hexuloses’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 29 (1976), 1239–1247.
  24. S. J. Angyal, ‘The Composition of Reducing Sugars in Solution’, Advances in Carbohydrate Chemistry and Biochemistry, 42 (1984), 15–68.
  25. S. J. Angyal, ‘The Composition of Reducing Sugars in Solution: Current Aspects’, Advances in Carbohydrate Chemistry and Biochemistry, 49 (1991), 19–35.
  26. Angyal, S. J., ‘Conformational Analysis in Carbohydrate Chemistry. I. Conformational Free Energies. The Conformations and α: β Ratios of Aldopyranoses in Aqueous Solution’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 21 (1968), 2737–2746.
  27. S. J. Angyal and K. P. Davies, ‘Complexing of Sugars with Metal Ions’, Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications, (1971), 500–501.
  28. M. E. Evans and S. J. Angyal, ‘Complexes of Carbohydrates with Metal Cations. II. Glycosidations of D-Allose in the Presence of Strontium and Calcium Ions’, Carbohydrate Research, 25 (1972), 43–48.
  29. S. J. Angyal, C. L. Bodkin and F. W. Parrish, ‘Complexes of Carbohydrates with Metal Cations. V. Synthesis of Methyl Glycosides in the Presence of Metal Ions’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 28 (1975), 1541–1549.
  30. S. J. Angyal, M. E. Evans and R. J. Beveridge, ‘Complexes of Carbohydrates with Metal Cations – Methyl β-D-mannofuranoside’, Methods in Carbohydrate Chemistry, 8 (1980), 233–235.
  31. F. W. Parrish, S. J. Angyal, M. E. Evans and J. A. Mills, ‘Complexes of Carbohydrates with Metal Cations. VI. Formation of Dimethylacetals of D-Glucose, D-Xylose, and L–Idose in the Presence of Strontium Ions’, Carbohydrate Research, 45 (1975), 73–83.
  32. S. J. Angyal, G. S. Bethell and R. J. Beveridge, ‘The Separation of Sugars and Polyols on Cation-exchange Resin in the Calcium Form’, Carbohydrate Research, 73 (1979), 9–18. (Complexes of Carbohydrates with Metal Cations. X.)
  33. S. J. Angyal, ‘Chromatography on Cation Columns: a Much-Neglected Method of Separation,’ Australian Journal of Chemistry, 55 (2002), 79–81.
  34. S. J. Angyal, M. E. Evans and R. J. Beveridge, ‘Complexes of Carbohydrates with Metal Cations – Methyl β-D-mannofuranoside’, Methods in Carbohydrate Chemistry, 8 (1980), 233–235.
  35. S. J. Angyal, L. Odier and M. E. Tate, ‘A Simple Synthesis of cis-Inositol’, Carbohydrate Research, 266 (1995), 143–146.
  36. S. J. Angyal, ‘L-Ribose, an Easily Prepared Rare Sugar’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 58 (2005), 58–59.
  37. S. J. Angyal, ‘Complex Formation between Sugars and Metal Ions’, Pure and Applied Chemistry, 35 (1973), 131–146.
  38. S. J. Angyal, ‘Complexes of Sugars with Cations’, Advances in Chemistry Series, 117 (1973), 106–120.
  39. S. J. Angyal, ‘Complexing of Polyols with Cations’, Tetrahedron, 30 (1974), 1695–1702.
  40. S. J. Angyal, ‘Complexes of Metal Cations with Carbohydrates in Solution’, Advances in Carbohydrate Chemistry and Biochemistry, 47 (1989), 1–43.
  41. S. J. Angyal, ‘Haworth Memoiral Lecture – Sugar-cation Complexes: Structure and Applications’, Chemical Society Reviews, 9 (1980), 415–428.
  42. S. J. Angyal, ‘The Effect of Cations on the Properties of Sugars and Polyols (C. S. Hudson Award Address)’, Abstracts of Papers, American Chemical Society, 193 (1987), 28.
  43. R. A. Wood, V. J. James and S. J. Angyal, ‘The Crystal Structure of the epi-Inositol–Strontium Chloride Complex’, Acta Crystallographica, Section B, 33 (1977), 2248–2251.
  44. J. Ollis, V. J. James, S. J. Angyal and P. M. Pojer, ‘An X-ray Crystallographic Study of α-D-Allopyranosyl α-D-allopyranoside. CaCl2·5H2O (a pentadentate complex)’, Carbohydrate Research, 60 (1978), 219–228.
  45. S. J. Angyal and D. C. Craig, ‘Complex Formation between Polyols and Rare Earth Cations. The Crystal Structure of Galactitol. 2PrCl3·14H2O,’ Carbohydrate Research, 241 (1993), 1–8. (Complexes of Carbohydrates with Metal Cations. XVII).
  46. S. J. Angyal, ‘Hudson’s Rules of Isorotation as Applied to Furanosides and the Conformations of Methyl Aldofuranosides’, Carbohydrate Research, 77 (1979), 37–50.
  47. S. J. Angyal and K. James, ‘Oxidative Demethylation with Chromium Trioxide in Acetic Acid,’ Carbohydrate Research, 12 (1970), 147–149.
  48. S. J. Angyal and K. James, ‘Oxidation of Carbohydrates with Chromium Trioxide in Acetic Acid. I. Glycosides’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 23 (1970), 1209–1221.
  49. S. J. Angyal and K. James, ‘Oxidation of Carbohydrates with Chromium Trioxide in Acetic Acid. II. Acetals. A New Synthesis of Ketoses’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 24 (1971), 1219–1227.
  50. S. J. Angyal and M. E. Evans, ‘Oxidation of Carbohydrates with Chromium Trioxide in Acetic Acid. IV. Conversion of Cyclic Methylene Acetals into Cyclic Carbonates’, Australian Journal of Chemistry, 25 (1972), 1513–1520.
  51. S. J. Angyal and L. Odier, ‘Selective Deuteration. The Rate of Protium–Deuterium Exchange in Inositols with Raney-Nickel Catalyst and the Effect thereon of O-Methylation’, Carbohydrate Research, 123 (1983), 13–22.
  52. S. J. Angyal, J. D. Stevens and L. Odier, ‘Selective Deuteration over Raney Nickel in Deuterium Oxide: Methyl Glycosides’, Carbohydrate Research, 157 (1986), 83–94.
  53. S. J. Angyal, J. D. Stevens and L. Odier, ‘Selective Deuteration over Raney Nickel in Deuterium Oxide: 1,6-Anhydrohexoses’, Carbohydrate Research, 169 (1987), 151–157.
  54. S. J. Angyal and D. J. McHugh, ‘Interaction Energies of Axial Hydroxyl Groups’, Chemistry and Industry (London), (1956), 1147–1148.
  55. S. J. Angyal (chairman), L. Anderson, R. S. Cahn, R. M. C. Dawson, O. Hoffmann-Ostenhof, W. Klyne and T. Posternak, (IUPAC Joint Cyclitol Nomenclature Sub-committee), ‘Nomenclature of Cyclitols, IUPAC Recommendations, 1973’, Biochemical Journal, 153 (1976), 23–31; European Journal of Biochemistry, 57 (1975), 1–7; Pure and Applied Chemistry, 37 (1974) 283–297.
  56. S.Angyal, ‘Living luminaries of Australian chemistry: Stephen Angyal’, Chemistry in Australia, 78 (March 2011), 18–19.

Download memoir

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 26(1), 2015. It was written by John D. Stevens, School of Chemistry, University of New South Wales.

Acknowledgements

In preparing this obituary, I have drawn upon extensive biographical notes prepared by Stephen in 2000 and on an interview by Mr David Salt on behalf of the Australian Academy of Science in 2003. 

Spencer Smith-White 1909–1998

Professor Spencer Smith-White was a botanist who pioneered the study of cell physiology in Australian plants.

Image Description

Spencer Smith-White's research group at the University of Sydney was for many years the foremost laboratory studying the cytology, cytogenetics and cytoevolution of the Australian flora. He pioneered this field with his chromosomal studies on major Australian families, such as the Rutaceae, Myrtaceae, Proteaceae and Epacridaceae. His cytogenetic analyses underpinned his discussions of the origins and distribution of the major elements of the Australian flora.

Download the memoir

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 22(2), 2011. It was written by Jim Peacock, Bryan Barlow and Roger Carolin.

Shirley Winifred Jeffrey 1930–2014

Shirley Jeffrey was a pioneer in oceanographic research, identifying chlorophyll c, and was a worldwide leader in the application of pigment methods to quantify phytoplankton as the foundation of the oceanic food supply.

Image Description

Australian scientist Shirley Jeffrey was a pioneer in oceanographic research, identifying the then-theoretical chlorophyll c, and was a worldwide leader in the application of pigment methods in quantifying phytoplankton as the foundation of the oceanic food supply. Her research paved the way for the successful application of microalgae in aquaculture around the world. 

Jeffrey earned bachelor's and master's degrees at University of Sydney, majoring in microbiology and biochemistry, followed by a PhD from the King's College London Hospital Medical School. Returning to Sydney, she was hired by the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) to research chlorophyll c. Following this successful effort, she became a research fellow at the University of California, Berkeley from 1962 to 1964. She then became affiliated with the Scientific Committee on Oceanic Research. After a 1973 sabbatical at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography in San Diego, she returned to CSIRO, where she spent the rest of her career.

Download the memoir

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 27(1), 2016. It was written by Simon W. Wright, Gustaaf M. Hallegraeff and R. Fauzi C. Mantoura.

Sefton Davidson Hamann 1921–2009

Dr Sefton Hamann FAA was an internationally recognised chemist who studied how pressure transforms materials. He helped invent Australia's counterfeit-resistant polymer banknotes and their security features.

Image Description
Sefton Davidson Hamann 1921–2009

Introduction

Sefton Hamann was born in Christchurch, New Zealand, on 8 January 1921 and died in Melbourne on 12 January 2009. He had a distinguished career in Australia’s CSIRO as a scientist, as Chief of the Divisions of Physical Chemistry (1960–1966) and Applied Chemistry (1966–1974) and as Chairman of the Applied Chemistry Laboratories Committee (1974–1978). He was internationally recognised for his lifelong contributions to the physico-chemical effects of pressure. He made a major contribution to the nation through his work on the polymer banknote.

Family background

Sefton Davidson Hamann was born in Christchurch, New Zealand, on 8 January 1921, the third child of Conrad Gustavus Hamann and Margaret Elizabeth Hamann (née Wilson), who had married in Dunedin in 1902. Conrad Hamann was a pianist, piano tuner and salesman. In 1908 the family lived in Sefton Street, Timaru, about 160 km south of Christchurch, but they had moved to Christchurch in 1917. By 1921, the family was living in the Christchurch suburb of Fendalton. Sefton’s mother was 42 years old, his father 48, his sister Margaret (‘Mollie’) 16 and his brother Conrad 14 when Sefton was born.

Sefton married Elizabeth Wayne Boden, daughter of Charles Wilfred Boden, an insurance officer, and Olive West, at St Anne’s Parish Church, Strathfield, Sydney on 11 September 1950. They had met in 1944 at a dance in Sydney and were engaged to be married before Sefton went to England in 1947 to study for his PhD at the University of Manchester. It was a long engagement! Elizabeth Boden was deputy play editor and acting chief editor with the Australian Broadcasting Commission. They moved to Melbourne when Sefton became the Chief of the Division of Physical Chemistry in 1960. Elizabeth became a librarian and worked at the Presbyterian Ladies College in the Melbourne suburb of Burwood for many years. She and Sefton were married for 52 years until her death in 2003.

They had one child, Conrad Charles Hamann, born on 28 November 1951. Conrad married Christine Kathryn Corrigan in 1975. They have two children.[1] Conrad is a distinguished art historian who ‘bridges what is usually the gap between the architectural profession and academic art history, by a very thorough, erudite and refreshed study of Australian architectural consciousness and its buildings’.[2]

Secondary education

Sefton commenced his secondary education in Christchurch in 1934 at Christ’s College, Canterbury. This was a school established in 1851, modelled on the public schools of England; many of the original English settlers of the region sent their sons to it.

Sefton Davidson Hamann 1921–2009

Figure 1. Sefton Hamann in his Christ’s College blazer with Elizabeth Boden (1950?).

Sefton attended the school as a day-boy. The school records and family stories indicate that while he was not an outstanding student he did pass the Matriculation examination at the end of Form V in 1936. He was too young to enter university so went into Form VI in 1937, but left after one term.[3] He was not in any of the ‘first’ sporting teams although he did claim to his family that he was captain of the 7th eleven! Although he left the school without completing Form VI, he did seem to be proud to be an ‘old boy’ of the school. He wore the blazer while courting Elizabeth in Sydney (Fig. 1) and was an active participant in the Victorian Branch of the Christ’s College Old Boys’ Association.

After leaving school, Sefton began work as a clerk at the National Pensions Office in Wellington. Although this was clearly filling in time until he could enter university, his Certificate of Service in the Royal New Zealand Navy has an entry under the heading ‘Trade brought up to’ where it says ‘Clerk’.[4]

Canterbury University College

In 1938, Sefton commenced a BSc course in Chemistry at Canterbury University College (then a constituent college of the University of New Zealand, now a separate institution, the University of Canterbury). His subsidiary subjects were Physics I and II, Pure Mathematics I, Applied Mathematics I and Psychology. In 1941, when he had qualified for his BSc degree and was part of the way through his MSc, he enlisted for war-time service in the Navy. With the war over, he returned to Canterbury University College in February 1946 and completed his MSc with First Class Honours in Chemistry. The title of his thesis was ‘The Solubility and Thermodynamic Properties of Lead Bromide and Lead Iodide in Various Methanol-Water Mixtures’, his supervisor being the then Associate Professor Hugh Parton.

In a reference for Sefton, the Head of the Department, Professor John Packer, wrote: ‘His written thesis showed an excellent grasp of the theory underlying his work, and a mark of 80 per cent was awarded by the external examiner, Dr R. A. Robinson.’[5] No refereed publications resulted from this work.

Service in the Royal New Zealand Navy

Sefton volunteered for naval service and was enlisted in Auckland on 23 October 1941. The Royal New Zealand Navy had been established only shortly before, on 1 October 1941; prior to that date, New Zealand naval forces were a division of Britain’s Royal Navy.[6] Sefton was sent immediately to the Radar Branch and served there until his discharge on 24 February 1946.

New Zealand played its part in the development and deployment of radar during the Second World War. The New Zealand effort was directed by Dr (later Sir) Ernest Marsden and included Professor F. W. G. White (later Sir Frederick White, Chairman of Australia’s CSIRO) and C. N. Watson-Munro (later Chief Scientist of the Australian Atomic Energy Commission and Professor of Plasma Physics at the University of Sydney). The work took place in the Radio Development Laboratory (RDL) and has been well documented.[7]

Sefton’s role in this work was as a Radio Mechanic. He rose to the rank of Petty Officer. He was under the command of Lieutenant Commander E. J. Marklew who wrote:

During this period he was under my command and displayed an outstanding knowledge of Radar technique. He was responsible for independent development and scientific investigation and contributed in no small manner to the success of Radar sets developed and produced in New Zealand as well as submitting constructive criticisms and improvements to Admiralty sets. He was seconded to the Radio Development Laboratory in Wellington where his standard of work was equal to that of the leaders of the sections of the laboratory. He served in the Solomon Islands and carried out important duties in the fitting of sets in cruisers and small ships at the Devonport Naval Base.

As part of Sefton’s secondment to the RDL, he spent six weeks at the Australian war-time radar research laboratory, the Radiophysics Laboratory in Sydney. In the Solomon Islands he had some encounters with the enemy, described in his own words:

I arrived in Guadalcanal from New Caledonia early in January 1944 in a party of about 10 members of the Royal New Zealand Navy, with the object of setting up a 240 MHz New Zealand designed radar station to provide sea warning and gun-laying support for a US Army artillery post at Cape Esperance, on the northern tip of the island (shore-based radar stations were then quite scarce in the South Pacific). At this stage, land fighting had ended on Guadalcanal but there were still incursions of Japanese aircraft and radar installations were among their natural targets. So we suffered recurrent alerts that slowed our work but did no other harm and the radar was working well within a few weeks.

After the land-based radar was set up, I was seconded to a small group of New Zealand corvettes patrolling the Coral Sea and the Solomon Sea, where the Japanese land forces still held out on some of the surrounding islands. In particular, I was on board HMNZS ‘Matai’ in, I think, late March 1944, when it joined some American warships to shell entrenched Japanese positions on the south-west coast of Bougainville. My recollection of the engagement is that the enemy returned our fire without success for a few hours and then appeared to have been silenced. In this action, my job was to help keep the ship’s radar working on a rather shaky platform.[8]

University of Manchester

After his discharge from the Royal New Zealand Navy in February 1946, Sefton completed his MSc at Canterbury University College and worked for a time at the Dominion Laboratory in Wellington, where he is listed as being employed as a Technical Officer Grade 1 for three months during 1947. During this time he revisited the Radiophysics Laboratory (by now the Radiophysics Division) in Sydney.

At this stage of his career, Sefton chose to develop his interest in solution chemistry by going to England to pursue a PhD in chemistry at the University of Manchester. Michael Polanyi had been the Professor of Physical Chemistry at Manchester from 1933 to 1947, when he moved to a chair in social sciences that was created for him. By the time he left, Polanyi had built a department in large part devoted to the study of the molecular basis of reactions. Sefton’s supervisor, Dr Alwyn G. Evans, was part of this group and was interested in the kinetics and mechanisms of organic reactions in solution; he continued work in this area until 1959. One of Sefton’s contemporaries was Michael Polanyi’s son, John C. Polanyi, who won the 1986 Nobel Prize for Chemistry (with D. R. Herschbach and Y. T. Lee) for his contributions concerning the dynamics of chemical elementary processes.

Sefton’s PhD thesis was a combination of theory and experiment, a characteristic of his whole scientific career. He developed a conductometric technique for measuring the rates of organic halide reactions and interpreted the results using transition state theory (1–6). The rest of his publications were from a CSIRO address except the last one, which was from his private address.

CSIR/CSIRO

Recruitment

While in Sydney for short periods between 1944 and 1947, Sefton had become engaged to Elizabeth Boden and so was keen to return to Australia after completing his PhD. In July of 1948 he wrote to the Chief of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research’s Division of Industrial Chemistry, in Melbourne, enquiring whether any positions would become available in the Division in about one year’s time.

The Chief at the time, Dr (later Sir) Ian Wark, replied saying that he was having more difficulty in finding physical chemists than organic chemists and for Sefton to keep in touch. Sefton wrote again in April of 1949 and Wark immediately dispatched Dr Keith Sutherland, who was then spending time at the Royal Institution in London, to talk to him. Sutherland was the officer-in-charge of the Division’s Physical Chemistry Section at that time. He thought highly of Sefton but did not think him the best fit for the possible vacancy in the Organic Chemistry Section. However, a position did become available in the Division’s High Pressure Laboratory, which was housed in the Chemical Engineering Department at the University of Sydney. Sefton applied for this and was appointed. He commenced duty on 5 January 1950.

Scientific achievements

The High Pressure Laboratory’s location in Sydney suited Sefton from a personal point of view. The scientific field was quite different, however, from his PhD area, so before returning to Sydney he spent the first few weeks of his appointment in England and Holland, where he was able to visit Professors E. A. Guggenheim, J. E. Lennard-Jones, D. M. Newitt and A. Michels. All were leading experts in the theoretical and experimental study of the properties of fluids, this being what Sefton was going to be working on, for the first time, in Sydney.

He rapidly made contributions to his new field. By 1952 he had published eight papers, five in the Journal of Chemical Physics, two in the Transactions of the Faraday Society and one in Nature (7–14). He had measured the second virial coefficients of some organic molecules, measured the dielectric properties of compressed fluoromethane and written a theoretical paper on intermolecular force models.

Before the development of molecular beams allowed the measurement of differential scattering cross-sections, most of our knowledge of intermolecular forces came from the analysis of gas properties. The virial equation of state was important because of its theoretical connection with the forces between molecules. Sefton developed a differential compressibility apparatus in which he compressed both the reference gas and the experimental gas so as to keep their volumes equal and then measured the resulting pressure difference between the two gases. He used this method to measure the second virial coefficient of a number of compounds including benzene, carbon tetrafluoride, silicon tetrafluoride and sulphur hexafluoride. He, with his colleague J. A. Lambert, devised a new model to describe the interaction between quasi-spherical molecules such as those of sulphur hexafluoride (21, 22).

The officer-in-charge of the High Pressure Laboratory at the time, Dr J. F. Pearse, resigned in February 1952 and, at the age of 31, Sefton was appointed to the position. This commenced a very productive decade during which he published 47 papers (9–55) and a major monograph. The papers published during this decade had 1,064 citations until 15 January 2009 and established his international reputation in the chemical effects of pressure. In this time he completed his work on virial coefficients and developed his work on the physicochemical effects of pressure. The latter combined his earlier interest in the molecular basis of chemical reactions and his new-found skills and interest in the study of phenomena at high pressures. In recognition of his growing international reputation, in 1955 he was granted six months’ leave to visit leading high-pressure laboratories in the USA, the UK and continental Europe.

Sefton’s monograph, Physico-Chemical Effects of Pressure, was published in 1957. The book has been cited consistently over the years and was last cited in 2008. The intention of the book was to bridge the gap between the physics of high pressure and the practical uses of pressure in the chemical industry. It provided a comprehensive survey and analysis of the effects of pressure on volume, phase changes, viscosity and diffusion, dielectric and optical properties and chemical kinetics. In the preface, Sefton provided an insight into his approach to science: 

On the principle that it is better to have a rough guiding theory than none at all, I have tried to give molecular pictures of the underlying causes of the pressure effects, even though they are sometimes crude and underdeveloped. It is likely that time will prove some of the models wrong but in the meanwhile they will have a use if they merely stimulate further research.

They certainly did for him! He measured the effects of pressure on electrical conductivities, on the rates of electrophilic reactions, on micelle formation, on the polymerisation of maleic anhydride and on polyesterification reactions. He was not an inventor of new techniques; rather, he adopted and adapted techniques to suit the particular problem at hand. For example, in his paper with D. W. Coillet on the effects of pressure on the rates of electrophilic aromatic nitrations in solutions (55), the apparatus is similar to that described in the literature but modified because of the corrosive nature of the reaction mixture. This paper has a good example of some of the risks involved in this research: ‘We made only a few measurements in nitromethane because we found that this solvent forms extremely explosive mixtures with nitric acid. Pure nitromethane can be detonated by sudden compression to 150 atm, and we found that the addition of nitric acid makes it both a more sensitive and a more powerful explosive.’ They did complete enough experiments, however, to estimate the activation volume.

Sefton’s work was receiving international recognition, as indicated by his being invited to the 1956 and 1959 Gordon Research Conferences on High Pressure and to the 17th IUPAC Congress in Munich in 1959 (46), and to write chapters in major reviews (60, 61, 64).

Sefton published papers with 99 co-authors, mainly from Australia, the USA, France and Russia. He typically did not seek collaboration; others sought collaboration with him. His most frequent co-author was the CSIRO scientist Max Linton, with whom he published 15 papers. This collaboration led to a series of papers, ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra of Hydrogen Bonded Solids’ (105–108, 113, 119, 141), published between 1975 and 1988 – the last several years after his retirement in 1983.

Sefton Davidson Hamann 1921–2009

Figure 2. Sefton Hamann operating his new plotter (early 1970s).

The series presented their measurements of the influence of pressures up to 40 kbar (4 GPa) on the hydrogen-bonded OH stretching and bending frequencies of solids whose hydrogen bonds covered the full range of strengths from very weak to very strong. The most usual change in the vibrational spectra of solids resulting from an increase in pressure is an increase in the frequencies of fundamental molecular bands. This ‘arises because compression increases the forces of repulsion between neighbouring molecules and between atoms and groups within individual molecules and so steepens the curvature of the potential wells that govern the vibrations’ (105). The series of papers analysed exceptions to this general pattern and used the experimental results to build models of interatomic potentials (Fig. 2).

Sefton’s international standing was further recognised in 1979 when the Swedish Academy of Sciences invited him to present a paper at the Nobel Symposium entitled ‘Chemistry and Geochemistry of Solutions at High Temperature and Pressure’ that they were organising to mark the bicentennial of the birth of Jöns Jacob Berzelius. Twenty-five experts drawn from various fields discussed the chemistry of solutions at high temperatures and pressures; Sefton’s paper was on ‘Properties of Electrolyte Solutions at High Temperatures and Pressures’.

Sefton as Chief

In October 1958, the Division of Industrial Chemistry of what was now called CSIRO was divided into independent Divisions and Sections under the umbrella of the Chemical Research Laboratories. Ian Wark was appointed Director of the CRL and Keith Sutherland the Chief of the Division of Physical Chemistry. However, Sutherland left CSIRO in November 1959 to become Director of Research at Commonwealth Sugar Refineries Limited. The position of Chief was advertised and re-advertised in 1959 and 1960 but none of the applicants was considered worthy of appointment. Wark was then authorised to invite Sefton to accept the position. Sefton did so on the understanding that he would be able to continue with some of his personal research interests. He took up the position on 10 October 1960. It was typical of Sefton not to seek a position of power.

When Dr J. R. Price, who was the Chief of the Division of Organic Chemistry, was appointed a member of the CSIRO Executive in 1966, it was decided to combine the Divisions of Organic and Physical Chemistry to form the Division of Applied Chemistry. Sefton accepted the invitation to be the Chief of the new Division. In 1973, he announced his intention to resign as Chief but he remained in that position until 1974 when the Division was divided, to form the Divisions of Applied Organic Chemistry and Chemical Technology. Sefton continued as chairman of the Applied Chemistry Research Committee until December 1978 when the reorganisation of CSIRO into Institutes made the position redundant. He remained a Chief Research Scientist until his retirement in January 1984, aged 63, when he was offered a two-year Post-Retirement Research Fellowship in the Division of Applied Organic Chemistry. He continued as an Honorary Research Fellow in the Division and its successor Divisions (Chemicals and Polymers and Molecular Science) until ill-health prevented him from coming into the laboratory in 1999.

Sefton was a reluctant Chief. He did not apply for the position of Chief of the Division of Physical Chemistry in 1962 and was invited to become Chief of the Division of Applied Chemistry in 1966. These invitations were made on the basis of his scientific achievements and his broad interests in chemistry. In his letter to the CSIRO Chairman recommending the 1962 appointment, Ian Wark mentioned that in taking over the Division, Sefton ‘would not at first make any changes in organisation or research programme’. He was uncomfortable with the notion that CSIRO needed to generate external business. When asked what the newly appointed Assistant Business Manager was going to do, he answered: ‘I don’t know what the Business Manager does but whatever it is the Assistant is going to help him.’ He was also not particularly interested in developing formal plans or strategies. Indeed, when it appeared that CSIRO would need to justify its existence to Government and to explain its value to the community, he resigned from the position of Chief.

Sefton’s habit of coming to work on the first available public transport in the morning and leaving before 3 o’clock to spend time in a pub reduced his opportunities to interact with the rest of the Division, who tended to work the standard CSIRO hours of 9 am to 5.06 pm. He was very interested in the scientific standards of the Division and read and commented on all the papers leaving the Division for publication. He also took the responsibility of staff promotion very seriously. He wrote all cases for promotion himself, with the person concerned not knowing anything about the process until 30 June, when Sefton would send a letter informing him or her of the promotion. His interest in the science of the Division and in the fair treatment of his staff was appreciated and created a supportive atmosphere. This was especially appropriate in the immediate post-war decades when CSIRO was building up its and the nation’s scientific capacity.

The Bank Project

A meeting was held on Monday 9 April 1968 at the Reserve Bank of Australia’s Melbourne office that would change the course of Sefton’s career as well as the careers of many other CSIRO scientists.[9] The then Governor of the Bank, Dr H. C. (‘Nugget’) Coombs, called the meeting between his top note-printing staff and seven of Australia’s leading scientists to discuss techniques to produce notes that would be difficult to counterfeit. Decimal currency had been introduced in Australia on 14 February 1966 and shortly afterwards, substantial counterfeiting of $10 notes was detected (ironically as the convicted forger Francis Greenway was depicted on the note). A metallic security thread in the centre of the note was a security feature in the new notes but it soon deteriorated with the folding of the notes, reducing its value as a security feature. (It was moved away from the centre in 1974, making it less susceptible to deterioration and hence simulation by forgers.)

The scientists invited to the meeting were Sefton Hamann, Dr A. K. Head, Dr J. R. Price, Dr A. Walsh and Dr J. P. Wild (all from CSIRO), Professor K. G. McCracken (Professor of Physics at the University of Adelaide) and Professor J. C. Ward (Professor of Physics at Macquarie University). Of those present, only Sefton stayed with the project to its conclusion.

Many ideas were discussed at this first meeting, including the use of non-paperlike materials for currency notes and the use of diffraction gratings or Moire patterns to indicate inaccuracies in printing to register. It was agreed that someone with expertise in photography should be invited to the next meeting.

The next meeting of the group was held at the Thredbo Alpine Hotel over the weekend of 15–16 June 1968. The original members were joined by Dr N. B. Lewis, recently retired from the position of Director of the Kodak Research Laboratories in Melbourne (the person with photography expertise) and Dr D. H. Solomon (a CSIRO polymer scientist and co-author of this memoir, who had been consulted by Dr Price prior to the April meeting and recommended by Price to join the group). Solomon had suggested the use of ‘plastic paper’ as the substrate.

No formal project resulted from the Thredbo meeting, but the Reserve Bank’s Note Issue Department continued informal contacts with Hamann and Solomon. These contacts were to do with printing technologies and with special papers or ‘synthetic’ papers. The early research was done in the Divisions of Applied Chemistry, Mineralogy and Forest Products but was eventually confined to the Division of Applied Chemistry and then the Division of Applied Organic Chemistry. The early work was all funded from CSIRO’s own appropriation funds but in June 1971 J. P. Shelton from CSIRO’s head office wrote to the Bank: ‘Finally, may I mention that we are a little out of pocket in preparation of these samples and perhaps we should discuss at some time the possibility of a small grant from the Bank if further work along these lines seems to be desirable.’

The arrangements between the two organisations were eventually formalized in 1972 and the first meeting of the CSIRO–Reserve Bank Committee was held at Fishermen’s Bend in August 1972. The project was officially named the Currency Notes Research Development (CNRD) project in 1974 and the first meeting of the CNRD Committee was held in October 1974.

Sefton Hamann remained an important contributor to the project until his retirement in 1983 and during his period as a post-retirement Fellow and as an Honorary Fellow. His main interest was in the development of optically variable security devices.

From the notes of the first meeting in Melbourne, it is clear that diffraction gratings and Moire patterns were discussed in the context of their use in controlling printing rather than as security devices. However, between the Melbourne and Thredbo meetings some idea of their use as security devices appears to have emerged because in the notes prepared for the Thredbo meeting it is noted that ‘some simple experiments have been done to obtain photographic simulation of diffraction grating effects’. Sefton’s own recollection was that Dr Alan Walsh suggested the use at the Thredbo meeting.

The Bank’s interest in diffraction gratings was further catalysed by a letter from Dr E. G. Bowen (Chief of the CSIRO Division of Radiophysics) who had sent a diffracting film that he had bought from the Army and Navy Store in London in September 1971 and a sample note prepared by D. H. Solomon that included a metallized patch on a polyester film. Bowen had been involved with the Bank in the earliest discussions of possible scientific work on forgery-proof banknotes but was not involved in any of the subsequent meetings.

Sefton Davidson Hamann 1921–2009

Figure 3. Sefton Hamann showing the Minister his work on Moire interference patterns (ca. 1978). Left to right: J. B. Ross, D. H. Solomon, M. Linton, Minister J. J. Webster and S. D. Hamann.

Sefton devoted much of the next decade to working on optical variable devices. He was personally interested in Moire interference patterns – patterns created when two grids are overlaid at an angle or when they have slightly different mesh sizes – and also helped supervise the work of Dr Bob Lee who was recruited by CSIRO to develop diffraction gratings suitable for incorporating into banknotes (Fig. 3). Sefton was the co-inventor with D. H. Solomon and M. F.W. Brown of the patent ‘Improvements in or relating to security tokens’ lodged in September 1973.

No account of Sefton’s career would be complete without some reference to the court case that arose from an Operational Health and Safety issue involving the use of a laser. The case was a source of great distress to Sefton. One of the experimental officers working with Sefton on setting up a newly purchased laser claimed that Sefton had allowed reflected light to injure his eye. Sefton vigorously denied the charge. It went to trial by jury but was quickly settled out of court.

Professional activities

Sefton seldom applied for or volunteered for positions or activities. He was usually enlisted by others. He joined the Royal Australian Chemical Institute (RACI) as a Fellow in 1964 and was awarded the RACI’s prestigious H. G. Smith Memorial Medal in 1969. The conditions for the award are that ‘The major proportion of the work shall have been done in Australia or its Territories while the candidate was a member of the RACI. The Candidate shall be and have been a financial member of the RACI for at least three years.’ It is difficult not to draw the conclusion that his nominator for the award approached him assuming that he was a member of the RACI, discovered otherwise, nominated him as a Fellow and waited the due time! Sefton encouraged his staff to be involved in RACI activities but was not actively involved himself.

Sefton was elected a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1966 and was actively involved in the work of the Academy until 1981. He was a member of the Board of Standards of the Australian Journals of Scientific Research (1968–1971) and Chairman (1972–1974). He was loyal to the journals, publishing nearly half of his papers in the Australian Journal of Chemistry. He was a member of the Academy’s Sectional Committee for Chemistry (1969–1973), including being Chairman (1971–1972). He was also on the Sectional Committee for Applied Physics and Chemistry (1971–1973), and for Applied Sciences (1978–1982). He was a Member of Council (1969–1972), a member of the Standing Committee for Scientific Information (1972–1978) and a member of the Standing Committee for International Relations (1979–1981).

When the Australian Government established the Australian Research Grants Committee in 1965, Sefton and Dr D. L. Ford (Chief Research Chemist, Union Carbide Australia Ltd) were the only non-university members. He remained a member of that Committee until 1970 when he was replaced by Dr N. K. Boardman.

Contradictions and errors (by others)

Sefton had a keen eye for contradictions and mistakes in the published literature. His last paper (145) was a detailed analysis and refutation of the claims by a US scientist that ‘phantom activation volumes’ exist in certain organic reactions. His penchant for correcting mistakes did earn him a rebuke from Keith Sutherland in 1959. It started with a letter to the Sydney Morning Herald by Associate Professor R. C. Bosworth of the University of New South Wales on Tuesday 17 February 1959. Bosworth had calculated that if the world continued to burn coal and oil at the current rate, we would be asphyxiated by carbon dioxide in less than 1,000 years. Sefton and a colleague, H. G. David, wrote a quick response pointing out that Bosworth had grossly miscalculated the amount of oxygen in the earth and that there was no need for concern.[10] They gave the CSIRO Division of Physical Chemistry as their address. Sutherland was quick to remind Sefton that he should not use the CSIRO address without permission!

Finally

Sefton’s legacy is his science. His first paper was published in 1951 and his last in 2004, 53 years later. In writing his case for promotion to Senior Principal Research Officer in 1957, Keith Sutherland summarised Sefton’s contribution succinctly: ‘Hamann has the ability to strip problems to a few essential features which, when investigated, clearly illuminate a wide group of phenomena.’

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 20(2), 2009. It was written by:

  • Thomas H. Spurling. Faculty of Life and Social Sciences, Swinburne University of Technology, PO Box 218, Hawthorn, Vic. 3122, Australia. Corresponding author. Email: tspurling@swin.edu.au
  • David H. Solomon. Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Vic. 3010, Australia.

Numbers in square brackets refer to the notes, and numbers in brackets refer to the bibliography.

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Dr A. H. Ewald, Professor R. G. H. Prince, Dr A. F. A. Wallis and the Hamann family for their assistance.

Notes

  1. Family details were kindly supplied by Dr Conrad Hamann and Mrs Christine Hamann.
  2. www.architecture.com.au/i-cms_file?page=6625/Conrad_Hamann.
  3. Information on Hamann’s school career was provided by Ms Jane Teal, Archivist, Christ’s College, Christchurch.
  4. Navy discharge paper.
  5. With the permission of Dr Conrad Hamann, the authors had access to the CSIRO files relating to Sefton Hamann’s career.
  6. Despite the change, all the stationery used to record Sefton’s enlistment and discharge was from the New Zealand Division of the Royal Navy.
  7. Fraser, G. J., ‘The antecedents and subsequent development of scientific radar in New Zealand’, Journal of Atmospheric and Solar-Terrestrial Physics 67 (2005), 1411–1418.
  8. Details of Hamann’s naval career were obtained from a submission for benefits that he made to the Australian Department of Veterans’ Affairs dated 25 June 2002. HMNZS Matai was a merchant boat converted to a minesweeper, commissioned in 1941 and decommissioned in 1946.
  9. Information concerning the ‘Bank Project’ has been obtained from Hamann’s personal files made available to the authors by Dr Conrad Hamann and from notes given by Hamann to Dr Spurling.
  10. Sydney Morning Herald, Friday 20th February 1959, page 3.

Bibliography

Book

Hamann, S. D., The Physico-Chemical Effects of Pressure. Butterworths: London, 1957. ix+246 pp.

Patents

  1. Cope, A. F. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Process for the Demineralization of Water by Ion Exchange’, British Patent 1428207 (17 March1976).
  2. Hamann, S. D., Solomon, D. H., and Brown, M. F. W., ‘Improvements in or Relating to Security Tokens’, Australian Patent 488652 (27 May1978).
  3. Hamann, S. D., ‘Improved Novelty or Security Device’, Australian Patent 503862 (7 September1979).

Papers

  1. Evans, A. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Spectroscopic Evidence for the Presence of Carbonium Ions in Mixtures of Olefins and Friedel-Crafts Catalysts’, Sci. Proc. Roy. Dublin Soc. 25 (1950), 139–140.
  2. Hamann, S. D., Plesch, P. H., and Skinner, H. A., ‘Suggestions Concerning the Ionic Polymerisation of Vinyl Ethers’, Sci. Proc. Roy. Dublin Soc. 25 (1950), 141–145.
  3. Evans, A. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Energy and Entropy Changes of Organic Reactions. Part I –Two-Stage Reactions’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 47 (1951), 25–30.
  4. Evans, A. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Energy and Entropy Changes of Organic Reactions. Part II – One-Stage Reactions’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 47 (1951), 30–34.
  5. Evans, A. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Energy and Entropy Changes of Organic Reactions. Part III – Ionization Reactions’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 47 (1951), 34–39.
  6. Evans, A. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Energy and Entropy Changes of Organic Reactions. Part IV –Theoretical Considerations’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 47 (1951), 40–49.
  7. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Interpretation of Intermolecular Force Parameters’, J. Chem. Phys. 19 (1951), 655–656.
  8. David, H. G., Hamann, S. D., and Pearse, J. F., ‘The Dielectric Constant of Ethylene at High Pressures’, J. Chem. Phys. 19 (1951), 1491–1495.
  9. David, H. G., Hamann, S. D., and Pearse, J. F., ‘Dielectric Loss in a Polar Gas near its Critical Point’, Nature 169 (1952), 1106. Sefton Davidson Hamann 1921–2009 267
  10. David, H. G., Hamann, S. D., and Pearse, J. F., ‘The Dielectric Properties of Compressed Fluoromethane’, J. Chem. Phys. 20 (1952), 969–972.
  11. Francis, P. G., McGlashan, M. L., Hamann, S. D., and McManamey, W. J., ‘The Second Virial Coefficient of Benzene’, J. Chem. Phys. 20 (1952), 1341.
  12. David, H. G., Hamann, S. D., and Prince, R. G. H., ‘The Third Virial Coefficient of Ethane’, J. Chem. Phys. 20 (1952), 1973.
  13. Hamann, S. D., and Pearse, J. F., ‘The Second Virial Coefficients of Some Small Organic Molecules’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 48 (1952), 101–106.
  14. Hamann, S. D., ‘A Quantum Correction tothe Lennard-Jones and Devonshire Equation of State’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 48 (1952), 303–307.
  15. Hamann, S. D., and McManamey, W. J., ‘The Second Virial Coefficient of Ethane’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 49 (1953), 149–152.
  16. Hamann, S. D., McManamey, W. J., and Pearse, J. F., ‘The Forces between Polyatomic Molecules’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 49 (1953), 351–357.
  17. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘The Quantum Behaviour of Compressed Gases’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 49 (1953), 711–716.
  18. Buchanan, J., and Hamann, S. D., ‘The Chemical Effects of Pressure. Part 1’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 49 (1953), 1425–1433.
  19. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘The Chemical Effects of Pressure. Part 2’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 50 (1954), 1181–1191.
  20. Hamann, S. D., ‘Quantum Effects in Compressed Liquid Hydrogen’, J Amer. Chem. Soc. 76 (1954), 4244.
  21. Hamann, S. D., and Lambert, J. A., ‘The Behaviour of Fluids of Quasi-spherical Molecules. I – Gases at Low Densities’, Aust. J. Chem. 7 (1954), 1–17.
  22. Hamann, S. D., and Lambert, J. A., ‘The Behaviour of Fluids of Quasi-spherical Molecules. II – High Density Gases and Liquids’, Aust. J. Chem. 7 (1954), 18–27.
  23. Hamann, S. D., ‘A Suggestion Concerning the Pressure Induced Contraction of Muscle’, Aust. J. Chem. 7 (1954), 120–121.
  24. Hamann, S. D., and Lambert, J. A., ‘The Behaviour of Fluids of Quasi-spherical Molecules. Part III – Surface Tensions’, Aust. J. Chem. 7 (1954), 219–224.
  25. Hamann, S. D., and Lim, S. C., ‘The Volume Change on Ionization of Weak Electrolytes’, Aust. J. Chem. 7 (1954), 329–334.
  26. Hamann, S. D., and Lambert, J. A., ‘The Behaviour of Fluids of Quasi-spherical Molecules. Part IV – Concerning Trouton’s and Hildebrand’s Rules’, Aust. J. Chem. 8(1955), 21–25.
  27. Hamann, S. D., ‘Die Kinetik Einiger Organischer Reaktionen bei Hohen Drucken’, Angewandte Chemie – International Edition 67(1955), 755.
  28. Hamann, S. D., Lambert, J. A., and Thomas, R. B., ‘The Second Virial Coefficients of some Gas Mixtures’, Aust. J. Chem. 8 (1955), 149–157.
  29. David, H. G., Hamann, S. D., and Lake, S. J., ‘Reaction Kinetics at 30000 atmospheres’, Aust. J. Chem. 8 (1955), 285–288.
  30. Hamann, S. D., and Strauss, W., ‘The Chemical Effects of Pressure. Part 3 – Ionization Constants at Pressures up to 12000 atm. ’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 51 (1955), 1684–1690.
  31. Ewald, A. H., and Hamann, S. D., ‘The Effect of Pressure on Complex Ion Equilibria’, Aust. J. Chem. 9 (1956), 54–60.
  32. Hamann, S. D., and Strauss, W., ‘Ionization of Piperidine in Methanol to 12000 atm. ’, Disc, Faraday Soc. 22 (1956), 70–74.
  33. Duff, R. E., Buckingham, R. A., Ubbelohde, A. R., Hamann, S. D., Guggenheimer, K. M., Rowlinson, J. S., Vodar, B., Bell, R. P., Galatry, L., Dekluiver, H., Alder, B. J., Franck, E. V., Whalley, E., Jeener, J., Lambert, M., and Sutton, L. E., ‘The Physical Chemistry of Processes at High Pressures – General Discussion’, Disc, Faraday Soc. 22 (1956), 75–87.
  34. Hamann, S. D., and Teplitzky, D. R., ‘The Kinetics of some Organic Reactions under Pressure’, Disc, Faraday Soc. 22 (1956), 114–121.
  35. Laidler, J. K., Weale, K. E., Hamann, S. D., Burnett, G. M., Ewald, A. H., Laird, R. K., Ubbelohde, A. R., Lachowicz, S. K., Runge, A., Buchdahl, R., Morrell, A. G., Bell, R. P., and Whalley, E., ‘The Physical Chemistry of Processes at High Pressures – General Discussion’, Disc, Faraday Soc. 22 (1956), 144–154.
  36. Hamann, S. D., ‘A Critique of the Views of Gonikberg and Povkh on the Role of Solvation in a Menschutkin Reaction’, Aust. J. Chem. 9 (1956), 533–535.
  37. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Thick Walled Cylinders under Internal Pressure’, Engineering 182 (1956), 324.
  38. Ewald, A. H., Hamann, S. D., and Stutchbury, J. E., ‘The Effect of Pressure on some268 Historical Records of Australian Science, Volume 20 Number 2Free-Radical Reactions of 1, 2-dichlorethylene’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 53 (1957), 991–996.
  39. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘The GasIm perfections of Hydrocarbons’, Proc. Joint Conf. on Thermodynamics and Transport Properties of Fluids (London: Inst. Mech. Eng., 1958), 74–78.
  40. Hamann, S. D., ‘Quantal Factors in the Joule-Thomson Cooling of Hydrogen and Deuterium’, Aust. J. Chem. 19 (1957), 373–380.
  41. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Chemical Effects of Pressure. Part 4 – The Role of Viscosityin Bimolecular Reactions at High Pressure’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 54 (1958), 507–511.
  42. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Sulfur: a Possible Metallic Form’, J. Chem. Phys. 28(1958), 1006.
  43. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Electrical Resistivities of some Semiconductors at High Pressures’, Aust. J. Chem. 11 (1958), 391–398.
  44. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘The Chemical Effects of Pressure. Part 5 – The Electrical Conductivity of Water at High Shock Pressures’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 55 (1959), 72–78.
  45. David, H. G., Hamann, S. D., and Thomas, R. B., ‘The Second Virial Coefficients of some Cyclic Hydrocarbons’, Aust. J. Chem. 12 (1959), 309–318.
  46. Hamann, S. D., ‘Reactions at Ultra-High Pressures’, Proc XVII IUPAC Congr., Munich, 1959, Vol 2 (London: Butterworths, 1960), 277–290.
  47. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘The Chemical Effects of Pressure. Part 6 – TheElectrical Conductivity of Several Liquids at High Shock Pressures’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 55 (1960), 1043–1060.
  48. Hamann, S. D., ‘A Corresponding States Treatment of the Speed of Sound in Simple Liquids’, Aust. J. Chem. 13 (1960), 325–331.
  49. Hamann, S. D., ‘General Discussion on Reaction Mechanisms’, Zeit. für Elektrochem. 64(1960), 197.
  50. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Use of Explosions in High Pressure Research’, Rev. Pure Appl. Chem. 10 (1960), 139–168.
  51. Hamann, S. D., ‘Some New Techniques for Chemical Research at Very High Pressures’, Chemie-Ing. Techn. 32 (1960), 52–53.
  52. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Some Properties of Compressional Waves in Lennard-Jones and Devonshire Liquids. I –Weak Sound Waves’, Aust. J. Chem. 14(1961), 1–7.
  53. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Some Properties of Compressional Waves in Lennard-Jones and Devonshire Liquids. II –Shock Wave’, Aust. J. Chem. 14 (1961), 372–386.
  54. Hamann, S. D., and Teplitzky, D. R., ‘Influence of Pressure on Cationic Polymerization of Isoamyl Vinyl Ether’, J. Phys. Chem. 65(1961), 1654–1655.
  55. Coillet, D. W., and Hamann, S. D., ‘The Chemical Effects of Pressure. Part 7 – The Rates of Electrophilic Aromatic Nitrations in Solution’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 57 (1961), 2231–2238.
  56. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Influence of Pressure onthe Formation of Micelles in Aqueous Solutionsof Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate’, J. Phys. Chem. 66 (1962), 1359–1361.
  57. Coillet, D. W., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Influence of Hydrostatic Pressure on Orientation in Electrophilic Aromatic Substitutions’, Nature 200 (1963), 166–167.
  58. Ewald, A. H., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Double Refraction of Water and Some Other Liquids in Strong Shock Waves’, Appl. Phys. Lett. 2(1963), 49–50.
  59. David, H. G., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Lennard-Jones and Devonshire Equation of State at Low Temperatures’, J. Chem. Phys. 38(1963), 3037–3039.
  60. Hamann, S. D., ‘Chemical Equilibria in Condensed Systems’, in High Pressure Physics and Chemistry, ed. R. S. Bradley (London: Academic Press, 1963), Vol. 2, 131–162.
  61. Hamann, S. D., ‘Chemical Kinetics’, in High Pressure Physics and Chemistry, ed. R. S. Bradley (London: Academic Press, 1963), Vol. 2, 163–207.
  62. Hamann, S. D., ‘Ionization of Water at High Pressure’, J. Phys. Chem. 67 (1963), 2233–2235.
  63. Hamann, S. D., Pearce, P. J., and Strauss, W., ‘Effect of Pressure on Dissociation of Lanthanum Ferricyanide Ion Pairs in Water’, J. Phys. Chem. 68 (1964), 375–380.
  64. Hamann, S. D., ‘High Pressure Chemistry’, Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 15 (1964), 349–370.
  65. Hamann, S. D., ‘Khimiya vysokikh davlenii’, Uspekhi Khim. 34 (1965), 1674.
  66. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Influence of Pressure on Electrolytic Conduction in Alkali Silicate Glasses’, Aust. J. Chem. 18 (1965), 1–8.
  67. Coillet, D. W., Hamann, S. D., and McCoy, E. F., ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Kinetics and Orientation of Friedel-Crafts Benzoylations’, Aust. J. Chem. 18 (1965), 1911–1917. Sefton Davidson Hamann 1921–2009 269
  68. Hamann, S. D., ‘Diminished Solubility of Dodecylamine Hydrochloride in Water at High Pressures’, Review Phys. Chem. Japan35 (1965), 109–110.
  69. Hamann, S. D., and McCay, I. W., ‘Ion Exchange Equilibria Under Pressure’, Amer. Inst. Chem. Eng. J. 12 (1966), 495–498.
  70. Hamann, S. D., ‘Effects of Intense Shock Waves’, in Advances in High Pressure Research, ed. R. S. Bradley (London: Academic Press, 1966), Vol. 1, 85–141.
  71. Hamann, S. D., ‘Anomalous Effect of Pressure on Protolytic Dissociation of Excited States of Nitrophenols’, J. Phys. Chem. 70(1966), 2418–2420.
  72. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Electrical Conductivity of Water in Shock Compression’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 62 (1966), 1–8.
  73. Hamann, S. D., ‘Polymerization of Maleic Anhydride by an Intense Shock Wave’, J. Polym. Sci. A-1 5 (1967), 2939–2941.
  74. Hamann, S. D., ‘Solid-Phase Polymerization of Maleic Anhydride at High Pressures’, Aust. J. Chem. 20 (1967), 605–609.
  75. Hamann, S. D., and King, N. K., ‘Supposed Anomalies in Thermal Properties of Water and Aqueous Solutions’, Nature 215 (1967), 1263–1264.
  76. Hamann, S. D., and Johnson, C. H. J., ‘Theory of Titration of Polybasic Acids. 1 – Dibasic Acids that Form Ion Complexes’, Aust. J. Chem. 21 (1968), 2695–2702.
  77. Hamann, S. D., Solomon, D. H., and Swift, J. D., ‘The Kinetics and Mechanism of Esterification and Polyesterification Reactions’, J. Macromol. Sci., A 2 (1968), 153–174.
  78. Hamann, S. D., ‘Shock Compression and Melting of Solid Argon’, Aust. J. Chem. 22(1969), 637–639.
  79. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Viscosity of Water under Shock Compression’, J. Appl. Phys. 40 (1969), 913–914.
  80. Edwards, G. R., Evans, L. F., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Nucleation of Ice by Thermal Shock’, Nature 223 (1969), 390–391.
  81. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Ionic Nature of Liquid Ammonium Fluoride’, J. Chem. Phys. 51 (1969), 1660–1661.
  82. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Electrical Conductivities of Aqueous Solutions of KCl, KOH and HCl, and Ionization of Water at High Shock Pressures’, Trans. Faraday Soc. 65 (1969), 2186–2196.
  83. Brasch, J. W., Melveger, A. J., Lippincott, E. R., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Spectroscopic Monitoring of High Pressure Effects on Trioxane’, Appl. Spectr. 24 (1970), 184–186.
  84. Bradbury, M. G., Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Solid-Phase Polymerizations at High Pressures’, Aust. J. Chem. 23 (1970), 511–523.
  85. Hamann, S. D., ‘Second Dielectric Virial Coefficient of Fluoromethane’, J. Chem. Phys. 53 (1970), 474.
  86. Hamann, S. D., ‘Titration Behaviour of Monoprotic and Diprotic Acids’, J. Chem. Educ. 47 (1970), 658–659.
  87. Hamann, S. D., ‘Theory of Titration of Polybasic Acids. II – Conditions for the Existence of Inflexions near Equivalence Points’, Aust. J. Chem. 23 (1970), 1749–1765.
  88. Gardiner, R. G., Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Oxidation States of Ferric Salts at High Pressures’, Aust. J. Chem. 23 (1970), 2369–2373.
  89. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Failure to Produce Anomalous Water by Shock Compression’, Search 2 (1971), 204.
  90. Hamann, S. D., ‘A Model for Thermal Regeneration of Ion-Exchange Resins. I’, Aust. J. Chem. 24 (1971), 1979–1992.
  91. Hamann, S. D., and Smith, F., ‘Effect of Pressure on Volumes and Excess Volumes of Aqueous Solutions of Organic Liquids’, Aust. J. Chem. 24 (1971), 2431–2438.
  92. Hamann, S. D., ‘AModel for Thermal Regeneration of Ion-Exchange Resins. II’, Aust. J. Chem. 24 (1971), 2439–2447.
  93. Hamann, S. D., ‘Exact Kinetic Equations’, J. Macromol. Sci. – Chem. A6 (1972), 684–687.
  94. Hamann, S. D., Solomon, D. H., Willing, R. I., and Murphy, A. J., ‘The Mechanism of Polymerisation of Styrene by Perchloric Acid’, J. Macromol. Sci. – Chem. A6 (1972), 771–787.
  95. Hamann, S. D., ‘Volume Changes for the Ionization of Weak Electrolytes, and the Effects of Pressure on Ionization’, CSIRO Div. Appl. Org. Chem. Tech. Paper 3 (1972), 1–20.
  96. Hamann, S. D., Linton, M., and Pistorius, C. W. F. T., ‘Infrared and Volumetric Studies of the High-pressure Phase Transitions of Ammonium Acetate and Formate, Trioxaneand Trithiane’, High Temp.–High Press. 5 (1973), 575–580.
  97. Hamann, S. D., ‘Electrolyte Solutions at High Pressure’, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry, ed. B. E. Conway and J. O’M. Bockris(New York: Plenum Press, 1974), Vol. 9, 47–158.
  98. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Influence of Pressure on the Ionization of Substituted Phenols’, J. C. S. Faraday Trans. I 70 (1974), 2239–2249. 270 Historical Records of Australian Science, Volume 20 Number 2
  99. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Influence of Pressure on the Ionization of Substituted Anilinium Ions’, . J. C. S. Faraday Trans. I 71(1975), 485–490.
  100. Hamann, S. D., ‘Effect of Pressure on Rates of some Substitution Reactions of Alkyl Halides’, Aust. J. Chem. 28 (1975), 693–700.
  101. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Influence of Pressure on Electronic Absorption Spectra of some Aromatic Molecules and Ions’, Aust. J. Chem. 28 (1975), 701–713.
  102. El’yanov, B. S., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Some Quantitative Relationships for Ionization Reactions at High Pressures’, Aust. J. Chem. 28 (1975), 945–954.
  103. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. Part 1’, High Temp.–High Press. 7 (1975), 165–175.
  104. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. Part 2’, High Temp.–High Press. 7 (1975), 177–186.
  105. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra of Hydrogen-bonded solids. I – Compounds with O-H · · · O Bonds’, Aust. J. Chem. 28(1975), 2567–2578.
  106. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra ofHydrogen-bonded solids. II – Bihalide Salts’, Aust. J. Chem. 29 (1976), 479–484.
  107. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra ofHydrogen-bonded solids. III – Compounds with N-H · · · X Bonds’, Aust. J. Chem. 29(1976), 1641–1647.
  108. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra of Hydrogen-bonded solids. IV – Miscellaneous Compounds’, Aust. J. Chem. 29 (1976), 1825–1827.
  109. Hamann, S. D., Pompe, A., Solomon, D. H., and Spurling, T. H., ‘Steric Effects in Cyclization Reactions’, Aust. J. Chem. 29 (1976), 1975–1977.
  110. Hamann, S. D., ‘Comments on “Ion-ion and Ion-water Interactions at High Pressure”’, Rev. Phys. Chem. Japan 46 (1976), 95.
  111. Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. 3’, High Temp. –High Press. 8 (1976), 317.
  112. Le Noble, W. J., Miller, A. R., and Hamann, S. D., ‘A Simple Empirical Function Describing the Reaction Profile and Some Applications’, J. Org. Chem. 42 (1977), 338–342.
  113. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra of Hydrogen-bonded solids. V – The Formation of Fermi Resonance “Windows”’, Aust. J. Chem. 30 (1977), 71–79.
  114. Hamann, S. D., and Spinner, E., ‘The Effect of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra of the Formates of the Alkali and Alkaline Earth metals’, Aust. J. Chem. 30 (1977), 957–970.
  115. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘The Influence of Pressure on Rates of Deuteration of Formate and Acetate Ions in Liquid D2O’, Aust. J. Chem. 30 (1977), 1883–1889.
  116. Hamann, S. D., and Spinner, E., ‘The Effect of Pressure on the Infrared Spectrum of Ammonium Formate: HCO2NH4, DCO2NH4, HCO2ND4, DCO2ND4. An Unusual Intermolecular Coupling of Nonidentical Vibrations in Phase II’, Aust. J. Chem. 30 (1977), 2591–2596.
  117. Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. 4’, High Temp. –High Press. 9 (1977), 57–61.
  118. Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. 5’, High Temp. –High Press. 9 (1976), 63–69.
  119. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra of Hydrogen-bonded solids. VI –Ammonium Salts’, Aust. J. Chem. 31 (1978), 11–18.
  120. Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. 6’, High Temp. –High Press. 10 (1978), 97–103.
  121. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Dependence of the Free Energy of Micelle Formation on Aggregation Number and Critical Micelle Concentration’, Aust. J. Chem. 31 (1978), 919–921.
  122. Hamann, S. D., ‘The State of Ionic Micelles atHigh Pressures’, Review Phys. Chem. Japan48 (1978), 60–61.
  123. Hamann, S. D., and Linton, M., ‘Electrical Conductivities of Shock-compressed solutions of KI in Organic Solvents’, J. C. S. Faraday Trans. I 74 (1978), 2742–2749.
  124. Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. 7’, High Temp. –High Press. 10 (1978), 445–451.
  125. Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. 8’, High Temp. –High Press. 10 (1978), 497–501.
  126. Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids Under Pressure. 9’, High Temp. –High Press. 10 (1978), 503–510.
  127. Hamann, S. D., and Pilkington, N. H., ‘An Ion-exchange Process with Thermal Regeneration. Part 13. Treatment of Feedwater Containing Bicarbonate by Adjustment of the Sefton Davidson Hamann 1921–2009 271pH of the Regenerant with Carbon Dioxide’, Desalination 28 (1979), 43–64.
  128. Hamann, S. D., Linton, M., and Sasse, W. H. F., ‘High-pressure Photodimerization of a Naphthalene Derivative’, Aust. J. Chem. 33 (1980), 1419–1423.
  129. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Role of Electrostriction in High Pressure Chemistry’, Review Phys. Chem. Japan 50 (1980), 147–168.
  130. Hamann, S. D., ‘Properties of Electrolyte Solutions at High Pressures and Temperatures’, Phys. Chem. Earth 13 (1981), 89–111.
  131. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Influence of Pressure on Ionization Equilibria in Aqueous Solutions’, J. Solution Chem. 11 (1982), 63–68.
  132. Hamann, S. D., ‘Thermodynamics of Chemical Equilibria at High Pressures’, High Temp. –High Press. 15 (1983), 511–515.
  133. Hamann, S. D., Mazerolles, P., Faucher, A., and Manuel, G., ‘Effects of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra of Some Heterocyclic Organosilicon and Organogermanium Compounds’, Aust. J. Chem. 37 (1984), 23–28.
  134. Hamann, S. D., ‘A Fallacy in some Interpretations of the Quasi-thermodynamics of Reaction Kinetics’, Aust. J. Chem. 37 (1984), 867–869.
  135. Hamann, S. D., and Le Noble, W. J., ‘The Estimationof Activation Parameters: Corrections and Incorrections’, J. Chem. Ed. 61 (1984), 658–650.
  136. Hamann, S. D., ‘Influence of Pressure on Activity Coefficients of Electrolytes in Solution’, J. C. S. Faraday Trans. I 80 (1984), 2541–2548. http://www.publish.csiro.au/journals/hras
  137. Hamann, S. D., Shaw, R. M., Lusk, J., and Batts, B. D., ‘Isotopic Volume Differences: the Possible Influence of Pressure on the Distribution of Sulfur Isotopes between Sulfide Minerals’, Aust. J. Chem. 37 (1984), 1979–1989.
  138. Alam, S., and Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids under Pressure. 10 – LiNH4SO4 and LiND4SO4’, High Temp.–High Press. 16 (1984), 683–688.
  139. Hamann, S. D., ‘Infrared Spectra and Phase Transitions of Solids under Pressure. 11:Polyphenols’, High Temp. –High Press. 18(1986), 99–105.
  140. Hamann, S. D., ‘Chemical Equilibria in Liquids’, in Organic High-Pressure Chemistry, ed. W. J. Le Noble (Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1988), 50–99.
  141. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Influence of Pressure on the Infrared Spectra of Hydrogen-bonded Solids. VII – Deuterated Ammonium Salts’, Aust. J. Chem. 41 (1988), 1935–1941.
  142. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Thermodynamics of Chemical Reactions at High Pressures’, Bull. Chem. Soc. Japan. 62 (1989), 2126–2127.
  143. Hamann, S. D., ‘The Effects of Pressure on Partial Molar Volumes in Binary Liquid Mixtures of Non-electrolytes’, High Temp.–High Press. 24 (1992), 489–503.
  144. Henderson, D., Hamann, S. D., and Chan, D. Y. C., ‘A Simple Theory for the Partial Molar Volumes of a Binary Mixture’, Molecular Physics 96 (1999), 1145–1149.
  145. Hamann, S. D., and Le Noble, W. J., ‘Comment on “Phantom Activation Volumes”’, J. Phys. Chem. A 108 (2004), 7121–7123.

 

Scott William Sloan 1954–2019

Professor Scott Sloan AO FAA FTSE FRS was a geotechnical engineer and internationally renowned expert in soil stability analysis who pioneered new methods to predict the collapse states of geostructures.

Image Description

Scott Sloan (1954–2019) was a leader of academic engineering in Australia and beyond, as evidenced by his numerous professional accolades and important research achievements, which have had significant impact on his chosen profession of geotechnical engineering. 

Educated in Australia and the United Kingdom, he returned to Australia in 1984 and developed a large and active research group at the University of Newcastle, and tackled a wide range of important problems in civil and mining engineering. These include the development of computational methods to predict the mechanical behaviour of soil and rock masses, and his pioneering methods to predict the collapse states of structures made of, on, and in, earth materials, allowing engineers to design cheaper and safer civil infrastructure around the globe. 

Sloan established long-standing international collaborations and was awarded many honours for his research achievements. He was also a keen and skilful fisherman and a more than competent blues guitar player.

Download the memoir

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 33(1), 2022. It was written by John. P. Carter, David. M. Potts and Antonio Gens.

Sarah Elizabeth Smith 1941–2019

Professor Sally Smith was a botanist and mycologist recognised as a world authority on the mycorrhizal symbiosis between plants and fungi.

Image Description

Sally Smith (she was never known as Sarah) was a world leader in the study of arbuscular mycorrhizal symbioses between plants and soil fungi that allow a wide range of plants to grow in soils low in nutrients, especially phosphate. Her work has been relevant to both plant ecology and agricultural productivity. 

Sally obtained a tenurable position at the University of Adelaide after many years’ employment on short-term contracts. She rapidly developed a large and active group that researched at scales ranging from advanced microscopy through molecular biology and physiology to plant ecology. 

Sally established long-standing international collaborations and was awarded many honours. She was a keen cook and gardener, and became an avid birdwatcher, travelling the world with her husband Andrew in pursuit of their hobby.

Download the memoir

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 32(2), 2021. It was written by F. Andrew Smith, Tim Cavagnaro and Sandy Dickson.

Samuel Warren Carey 1911-2002

Professor S. Warren Carey (as he preferred to be known) personified a philosophy of synthesis/integration that lies at the heart of large-scale disciplines such as geology and astronomy.

Image Description

Written by Patrick G. Quilty and Maxwell R. Banks.

Samuel Warren Carey 1911-2002

Introduction

Professor S. Warren Carey (as he preferred to be known) personified a philosophy of synthesis/integration that lies at the heart of large-scale disciplines such as geology and astronomy. This philosophy is complementary to but sometimes seen to be in conflict with the reductionist approach that characterises so much modern science. He was also a strong proponent of the mantra of 'We are blinded by what we think we know; disbelieve if you can'.

Samuel Warren Carey entered this world under slightly unusual circumstances in 1911, near Campbelltown, then a small country centre some 45 km southwest of Sydney. He attended primary school near his birthplace but entered high school at Canterbury, only 8 km from the city. After a record of distinction at high school, he won a scholarship to the University of Sydney.

As a result of perceptive advice, he enrolled at university in geology, in which he achieved outstanding results in his undergraduate studies. He did not, however, restrict himself to scholarly pursuits but participated in and initiated other worthwhile activities. For Honours and MSc, he carried out research on Carboniferous and Permian rocks in northern New South Wales in which he demonstrated initiative, close observation, and logical and creative thought. His research influenced thinking on these rocks for several decades. While at university, he became familiar with the concept of continental drift, a concept that he pursued and expanded through much of the rest of his life.

The research he had carried out fitted him well for the position of geologist in the petroleum industry in Papua New Guinea, in which capacity he produced geological maps and reports that were highly sought after for many years. His work in New Guinea also inspired him to produce an outstanding thesis for his Doctor of Science degree demonstrating his ability to think clearly and widely, and to introduce novel concepts – although he always claimed that he had to omit certain matters because some examiners would have opposed them.

Field work in New Guinea also provided an excellent background for the next stage in his career, a spell in a special commando unit within the Australian Army. He achieved some celebrity status as a result of his work with this unit.

From the Army, he went to Government service as Government Geologist of Tasmania, in which capacity he revitalised the Geological Survey and produced order in the understanding of Tasmanian economic and general geology where little had been seen before.

When the University of Tasmania decided to found a Department of Geology in 1946, Carey became the Foundation Professor and regular courses in geology began in 1947. Professor Carey rapidly developed a reputation as an inspiring teacher, a successful administrator, an outstanding researcher and director of research, an important member of the academic community, and a respected promoter of his subject in the Tasmanian community. He now had the opportunity, possibly a duty, to develop his interest in continental drift and the broad field of the structure of the Earth's surface. He rapidly achieved worldwide recognition for his work in this field, although his ideas were not immediately regarded as orthodox and some still are not. As a result of his work he became convinced that the Earth had expanded and continues to expand. From the expanding Earth he went on to think about the Universe and the Cosmos. Although his views on these latter topics have not been universally accepted, they have challenged orthodoxy and stimulated research.

Even as early as his last year in high school, S.W. Carey stood out among his fellows and he did so through the rest of his life. He was a member, and commonly an active and executive member of many organisations, mainly but not exclusively scientific. Many of these organisations, in Tasmania, in Australia and internationally, recognised his contribution with honours such as Honorary Membership, invitations to Fellowships, and medals. He was appointed an Officer of the Order of Australia in recognition of his services to science. He died on 20 March 2002, aged 90.

Early days

Samuel Warren Carey was born on 1 November 1911 at Campbelltown in New South Wales, to Tasman George and Hannah Elspeth Carey. He was born at home with his father and a neighbour in attendance, several days after his mother was thrown from a sulky when the horse bolted. The family had built a small stone cottage on a 4 ha farm on the Georges River. His name was chosen by his father to honour his own father. He was the third of six surviving children in a family of nine. As primary school students at Campbelltown, he and his siblings had to walk the five kilometres to school whatever the weather or their state of health. When he was six or seven years of age, the family moved to Campbelltown where his father had a job as typesetter for a local newspaper. Carey attended the prestigious Canterbury High School, where like so many students throughout history, he was strongly influenced by his teachers, especially James (Jerry) Jervis (chemistry) and Frank Gillogley (physics). His enrolment paper of 28 January 1924 lists his mother as shopkeeper on the corner of Queen and George Streets, Hurlstone Park, where the family moved in about 1922. He was a prefect in his final year at school. In the 1928 School Leaving examinations, Carey earned one of the few University Public Exhibitions to the University of Sydney, so he entered the University of Sydney in 1929. He also obtained a Teachers' Training College Scholarship.

It is worth noting that economic depression was beginning to take effect about this time and that, as a small shopkeeper with a family of five, his mother was not likely to be able to afford many luxuries. Carey was attracted to medicine but this was an expensive course. By enrolling in science, he could avoid the more costly option and the teaching scholarship helped with his and the family's finances. Students enrolling in science had to study chemistry, physics and mathematics in the first year of their course, leaving them a choice of one other subject. On the advice of his teacher, Jerry Jervis, he chose geology. And thus are careers determined!

University of Sydney – the undergraduate

Carey was a very good student. He obtained a high distinction in first-year geology (sharing second place in the course with Alan Voisey, both behind Dorothy York), in a class of 83 students, in a department that included Professor L.A. Cotton, Drs W.R. Browne and G.D. Osborne and Mr L.L. Waterhouse among its staff. In the background was Professor T.W. Edgeworth David who had retired in 1924. David had a large and continuing influence on Carey. Throughout Carey's academic career, a large photograph of David held pride of place above Carey's desk and still hangs in the tea room of the School of Earth Sciences in Hobart. Carey proceeded to obtain high distinctions in second- and third-year geology, an honour shared with Voisey, who was also to be a long-serving Professor of Geology in Australia. They graduated together, both with First Class Honours, in 1933. Carey won the Deas Thomson Scholarship for Mineralogy and the Science Research Scholarship. They shared the John Coutts Scholarship for proficiency in science but Carey had to withdraw because of limitations on the number of scholarships that could be held by one student. The friendly competition continued throughout their lives, even extending to comparison of the state of their respective knees as they turned 80 within a few months of each other.

While an undergraduate, Carey became aware of Wegener's concept of continental drift. An English translation of Wegener's book The Origin of Continents and Oceans had been published in 1924, thus making available to a much wider audience his ideas on continental drift. Cotton published a paper in The American Journal of Science in 1924 in which he referred to polar wandering, an aspect of geology with connections to continental drift, and he taught a course, Principles and Problems of Geology, in Geology III in which there was particular emphasis on continental drift which he saw as being 'a logical answer to many Southern Hemisphere problems' (Branagan 1973, p. 30). During Carey's Honours year, Cotton ran a seminar course on the same topic. Further, in 1928, Edgeworth David published, in The Australian Geographer, a short paper on drifting continents. Carey could thus not have been unaware of the concept, which influenced his interpretation of what he saw in New Guinea, was reflected in his doctoral thesis, and underlay much of his academic career. Carey's first paper – on water divining – was published in the Sydney University Science Journal in 1933.

During his Honours year, Carey developed an abscess in his ear and had an operation that he was not expected to survive, but did. This had the consequence that, now partially deaf, he surrendered, with considerable relief, his Sydney Teachers' Training College Scholarship. The operation left him with an ability that he used later to impress indigenous New Guineans. He could exhale cigarette smoke through his deaf ear.

Carey's family was not wealthy and he entered the University as the Great Depression deepened. This not only affected his career choice but, in addition, he had to augment his scholarship income with extracurricular activities to supplement the family income. This was achieved by a variety of tasks including stints as a milkman, iceman, conjurer in Saturday afternoon children's entertainment and night clubs, and coach to high school students in science subjects and even Latin. During his Second Year geology excursion, he participated in an evening concert: as Voisey notes, 'Another outstanding turn was a conjuring and memory session by the Great Mystic S. Warren Carey which left everyone dazed, incredulous and academically scared'. Because of the costs of travel for his Honours work, Carey even took on the task of 'cattle drover' on trains to his Honours area, Currabubula in northern NSW. He amazed local residents with his energy in pursuing his mapping project. He acted as a guide through Jenolan Caves. His extracurricular activities as an undergraduate and Honours student give evidence of self-reliance, creativity and a very well-trained memory. Because he couldn't afford the bus fare, he walked from Blackheath to Jenolan Caves for one excursion.

He was influenced in the choice of his honours project by W.R. Browne, and his honours mapping was followed up by geological mapping, supported by scholarships, in the Werris Creek area for the Master's degree. The particular contributions to geological knowledge he made during his Honours and Master's work were in Carboniferous and Permian stratigraphy and structural geology of the region, and earned him an MSc (1934). He published four papers on this work. The work was also the basis for a paper with W.R. Browne in which the Carboniferous stratigraphy, tectonics and palaeogeography of New South Wales and Queensland were discussed, and a paper with G.D. Osborne on stress analysis. All these papers had long-term influence on later studies and reveal his developing interests and the influence of Cotton, Browne and Osborne particularly.

His interests were not only academic. Since his school days, he had been active in outdoor pursuits such as scouting. Thus he was a member of the Sydney University Regiment and joined the University Rover Crew, and his memory training may be attributed in part to a Scout activity called 'Kim's Game'. The disciplined outdoor activities in the Rovers and the University Regiment were expressions of interests and attitudes that would influence later decisions and approaches, and the lifestyle choices that followed. Later, as Professor and Head of Department, his memory was a major advantage, a source of amazement and sometimes frustration to staff and students. He founded the Students' Geological Society at the University of Sydney and was its initial president. It was in this capacity that he first met Professor David – in Michaelmas term, 1931 – to invite him to deliver the first address to the Society. David had been a dominating figure in Australian geology for several decades and became a major influence on Carey.

Carey retained a strong interest in his alma mater throughout his life, giving the keynote address at the first of the annual Edgeworth David Days in 1988. From a more immediate point of view, his Honours and Master's studies were excellent experiences on which to base the next stage in his career, that of petroleum geologist in New Guinea.

And so to work – Papua New Guinea

Following the successful completion of his Master's studies, Carey planned to proceed to Cambridge to pursue a Doctor of Philosophy degree, possibly with an academic career in mind. He had applied for an 1851 Exhibition Scholarship, but in the year he applied, it was given to a competitor who would not be eligible in later years. Carey was told he had an excellent chance for the following year and so, sustained with a New South Wales Government Research Scholarship, late in 1933 he was actively collecting further material in the Werris Creek region, south of Tamworth, to take to Cambridge.

At this point, opportunism intervened and changed the direction of Carey's career, changing his future path from one that could have been mundane (unlikely with his personality) to the dynamic one that eventuated.

Oil Search Ltd needed more geologists in Papua New Guinea and, in the person of G.A.V. Stanley, came to Sydney recruiting, especially for someone with experience in stratigraphy and structural geology. Stanley himself was a highly regarded University of Sydney graduate, having obtained the Undergraduate Scholarship for Proficiency in 1923, and the Science Research Scholarship in 1925/26. Voisey and Carey were both interviewed but Voisey did not want to work in New Guinea and Carey was persuaded to accept a position after convincing Stanley that he was worth an extra £300 over and above the £250 he was offered, because of his

Master's experience in structural geology. This employment continued while the company evolved through Oil Search Ltd (1934-36), Papua Oil Search (1936-38) and Australasian Petroleum Company (1938-42).

Carey had made a choice between field and laboratory based studies and field work won. Two weeks later, he sailed on S.S. Montoro to his destination in Boram, 5 km east of Wewak in northern New Guinea. At the age of 23, he was thrown into the field, in many cases in areas where white men had never been and where the knowledge of the geology was, at best, rudimentary. He spent two years in the Sepik district working on foot, followed by two years in the Gulf region of central southern Papua where field work could be done by boat. During this time, he became fluent in both Pidgin and Police Motu.

Work in these conditions, where self-sufficiency for long periods in the field was absolutely necessary, brought out in Carey the attention to detail that was to mark the rest of his career. He was the sole white man supervising a field party of about 30 'boys', often including members of tribes who regularly were at war. Adaptability and flexibility were tested regularly, as was his ability to use his initiative to deal with natives who had not seen white men before, who had a deeply entrenched tribal approach with deep suspicion of neighbouring tribes, and among whom war and lack of western-style respect for human life were the norm. Much of the food supply had to be obtained locally and this involved learning the New Guinea values and trade system, and avoiding being 'taken for a ride'. He also needed to be field leader, surveyor, doctor, diplomat, trader, recorder of detail, and maintenance man for the equipment. Some examples to illustrate!

In many instances there were no base maps so theodolite, staff and plane tabling were the main survey systems. In the high humidity, the glass in the eyepiece of a theodolite telescope is subject to fungal growth, especially where etched with vertical and horizontal cross-hairs. The diaphragm with cross-hairs was thus replaced with glass bearing spider-web cross-hairs that lasted longer than the etched variety. He collected spider-web thread on a card with a slot in it, after a lengthy process of getting 'his boys' to collect the right type of spiders and choosing the individual spider that produced the best single thread (hence the personal word 'spidering'). Applying the spider web to the eyepiece often had to be done several times to get the spacing absolutely correct. He also preferred to make his own bamboo staffs because they floated if dropped in water and were light, cheap and easily replaced. Plotting the day's results was done after dinner by the light of a Tilley lamp. The advent of aerial reconnaissance flights late in 1937 allowed sketching of topography and other features from the air. Aerial photography then speeded up the mapping considerably.

Carey had many medical experiences including regular stitching of surface and deeper wounds. He also treated yaws and sexually transmitted diseases, malaria, pneumonia, diverse parasites, some measles, typhoid, deaths. All to be cared for by a non-medically-qualified geologist in his early 20s! His principal guidance came from a ship's captain's medical book and from the company doctor. His background in Scouts, Rovers and the Sydney University Regiment had given him some relevant experience. While taking so much care for others, he contracted tropical typhus and survived on beef tea until strong enough to walk out of the base camp.

He carried a few bags of rice, blue peas (soak overnight and carry damp in hessian bags during the next day so they sprout and produce vitamin C, to prevent scurvy) and some canned bully beef in case all else

failed. He made bread regularly but had to keep the yeast alive. Meat was what could be shot. Self-discipline was highly developed to prevent him developing any tropical diseases and camp routine was strict, including a daily bath, sick parade, and administration of 'bush justice'. He learned to identify key fossils in the field and developed his own means of polishing rock slabs to examine with hand lens the fossil foraminifera therein, using the field guide prepared for the purpose by Professor Martin F. Glaessner, also an employee of the Australasian Petroleum Company, who eventually also became a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science (McGowran 1994). This skill stayed with him through later years. In the first two years, there was no radio and mail commonly was two months old by the time he received it.

Carey made great contributions to the understanding of the geography and geology of Papua New Guinea and the country, in turn, left a very strong mark on him because, in contrast to the age and stability of the areas in which he had worked in his earlier research, it is geologically young and one of the most active places on Earth. It is a land of growing mountains, active volcanoes (and many others that have been active very recently), earthquakes, and vigorous erosion and sedimentation regimes. He experienced first-hand the natural violence of the local environment. He was very close to the epicentre of the Torricelli Earthquake of 20 September 1935. This was the then most violent earthquake recorded in Papua New Guinea and caused the seismograph recorder at Riverview Observatory in Sydney (3,500 km away) to go off-page and to react violently for many hours. His records of the earthquake illustrate again his attention to detail in that he recorded the frequency of various types of vibration, the effects on local material (suggesting acceleration greater than g), and the different types of vibration. There were major landslides and it took months for the shocks to die down and the effects to become fully evident.

His experience and observations of landslides and mudslides were to stand him in good stead in teaching about past environments when he eventually assumed a professorship. His few papers on the area are regarded as landmark works, but most of his work was recorded in company reports. He made predictions that took many years to be proven correct, and the knowledge base he left in company reports and papers has been an important element in the successful search for hydrocarbons in the area. His interests in tectonics were enhanced extremely and he never lost his interest in this part of the world.

A thesis finalised

At the end of four years, Carey took six months' leave in 1938, returned to Sydney, and completed and submitted a thesis for the Doctor of Science degree, based on his work in Papua New Guinea. It was entitled 'Tectonic Evolution of New Guinea and Melanesia'. The examination of the thesis was quite a saga. It was submitted at about the time of the declaration of the Second World War. The examiners included the very prominent overseas geologists Arthur Holmes (who had worked in oil exploration in Burma) and H.A. Brouwer, and in Australia, the Commonwealth Geological Adviser, W.G. Woolnough, another of David's students. Getting the thesis to them in the first instance, by sea mail, was difficult enough, but to complicate the process, Brouwer kept moving around the world, with the thesis following him and catching up with him only when he returned to his home university in the Netherlands. As a result of the long delay, Carey thought he had failed. Eventually the examiners' reports were all in and the degree was awarded in 1939.

He returned to and continued working in Papua New Guinea until 1942, when World War II intervened in his career. This led to another phase that was to produce its own fame, depending on those same personality traits of adventurous spirit, lateral thinking and attention to detail that had characterized his earlier experiences.

Marriage and family

Carey and Austral Robson, a nurse and portraitist, were married in her home town of Kempsey, New South Wales, on 15 June 1940. They had met through the Voisey connection. Austral and their four children (Tegwen Alice, Robyn, Harley and David), seven grandchildren and two great-grandchildren survive him.

War in the Southwest Pacific

In 1942, events in south-east Asia indicated clearly that life in Papua New Guinea was about to change. Carey, with his knowledge of conditions there, and with his network of contacts throughout the area, was seen as a valuable resource. He enlisted on 30 June 1942 and was given the rank of Acting Captain on 6 July 1942 (this was confirmed on 6 January 1944). His attention to detail came into its own during Carey's time in the army but his breadth of practical expertise had its drawbacks in gaining credibility with his military superiors in an institution that had it own way of doing things. There must have been a clash of philosophies between Carey and the military, because of Carey's history and belief in self-reliance and the military's call for obedience to a command structure.

Samuel Warren Carey 1911-2002

Captain S. Warren Carey, New Guinea Force Headquarters, 1942.

The Inter-Allied Services Department (ISD) had been established in March 1942 as an organization for subversion/sabotage behind enemy lines. Perhaps its most famous exploits were Operations Jaywick and Rimau in the Singapore region. The first unit formed in ISD was the Z Special Unit ('secret and unorthodox tasks'), which Carey joined on 1 July 1942. Training for this unit was held at Z Experimental Station a few kilometres inland from Cairns. His secret role was to act as liaison officer between the Commanders-in-Chief New Guinea Force (Lieutenant-General Edmund Herring) and Australian Military Forces (General Sir Thomas Blamey). His more public appointment was as General Staff Intelligence (Topographical), compiling topographical intelligence in Port Moresby, a task for which he was admirably suited (see his paper entitled 'The Morphology of New Guinea' published in 1938; paper No. 7 in his bibliography). This involved collating his own knowledge, transmitting coded messages, dealing with Coastwatchers, and recruiting appropriate candidates for the war effort. In this role he worked in Papua New Guinea through the latter half of 1942.

Carey's best-known role was with Operation Scorpion, his own brainchild. This operation was planned in fine detail to conduct a raid on Rabaul Harbour using folding boats (folboats) launched from a US submarine. The idea was to attack where the Japanese felt most secure. The force would enter the harbour, place limpet mines on enemy shipping, hide in local caves on Vulcan Island until the fuss died down, and escape later. His knowledge of the area was ideal and it was to be conducted only with others who knew the area or had been trained to know it in detail. The concept was treated initially with some scepticism but Carey eventually persuaded Blamey that it was worth an attempt, and Blamey gave Carey a very simple letter stating that what Carey did was with Blamey's approval ('Captain Carey is proceeding to Australia with instructions which I have given him personally. You will assist him in any way you can.'). Training for the ten men of Operation Scorpion began at headquarters in March 1943. Carey's initial task was in 'toughening up' the men to develop a high degree of stamina through an intensive regimen of swimming and running. They also had to develop a full capability in the use of folboats, and of attaching limpet mines quietly.

There were those who believed that Operation Scorpion could not succeed and would not be approved unless the concept could be proven viable. To show that it was, Carey decided that there had to be a test run – on shipping in Townsville Harbour, a harbour protected by a minefield – an appropriate training exercise for people and gear. Thus, at 11 pm on 19 June 1943, the Scorpion team left a train at a river crossing just north of Townsville. The group carried 45 sand-filled limpet mines and dehydrated food for three days. They carried no fuses, and the limpet mines could not be detonated. The river was not tidal as he had been led to believe, and it took some 30 hours to reach Magnetic Island, about 10 km from their destination. At 11 pm on 22 June, the commandos set off. They navigated through the mined Townsville harbour entrance with little trouble. With only a single potential problem, they retired quietly to Townsville at 7 am on 23 June, leaving fifteen ships, including two destroyers, with three limpet mines on each.

Unloading the vessels allowed the mines to become visible. The rumour mill was activated and the word passed to Townsville itself that the Japanese had limpet-mined the ships. Work in the harbour stopped. The military communication system came into play and the message eventually reached the offices of General Douglas MacArthur who was, by this stage, responsible for the ISD, now renamed Allied Intelligence Bureau. One of his officers was immediately suspicious of Carey and asked that he be found. He was, at 3 pm, asleep in the Officers' Club. He was arrested but released on production of Blamey's letter. He went through interviews with successively higher ranks in the Navy and ultimately to drinks on HMAS Arunta, the pride of the fleet. During drinks, it became clear that Arunta's captain was unaware that his ship had been limpet-mined, a situation that was then demonstrated.

The Townsville venture had been more successful than Carey had dreamed; it had shown that his training and forethought had worked. But Operation Scorpion, originally proposed as a raid on Rabaul, was not to be. US forces lost a submarine and Australian troops captured the Huon Peninsula, thus rendering the raid both logistically difficult and unnecessary. The Navy did not pursue any military legal action on condition that he be transferred; thus he did not have the chance to participate in other Z activities. The success of the exercise showed that such daring raids could work and ultimately led to acceptance of the idea that Operation Jaywick, employing Krait might work; it was very successful. Following Jaywick, another Z raid (Rimau) included Carey's brother Walter who was captured and beheaded by the Japanese, in Singapore, on 7 July 1945, one month before the atom bombs were dropped on Japan.

Following the disbandment of Operation Scorpion, Carey moved to Melbourne before returning to Papua New Guinea. He was appointed Director of Research in the Joint Planning, Training, Air and Technical Directorate, established in July 1943 under Major (later Sir) John Holland. He was Mentioned in Dispatches.

Carey qualified as a parachutist on 30 September 1943. He was actively involved in experimental work in parachuting, using the Liberator 'Beautiful Betsy', and retained his interest in parachuting throughout his life. As the war was coming to an end and policy was to take employment if it came available, he took the opportunity and was discharged on 6 November 1944. He remained in the Army Reserve.

His experiences during World War II illustrate well the developing Carey – creative thinking, attention to detail, personal faith in and commitment to what many saw as outrageous proposals, ability to adapt to changing circumstances, and desire to win – pure effrontery.

Tasmanian public servant

After demobilization from the military in 1944, Carey, at this time in Melbourne, accepted appointment as Government Geologist of Tasmania, following the move of the previous incumbent in that office, Dr D.E. Thomas, to Victoria. Carey was one of a group of highly trained, very able people who emerged from the war effort. He was perhaps exceptional in that he had had a period of being a high achiever before the war began and so had a head start over many of the others. Carey began to reorganize the Geological Survey, to investigate and write reports on mineral prospects, mines, groundwater resources and engineering projects, and to make a critical review of the literature and evidence involved in an understanding of the geology of Tasmania. He paid particular attention to the Cenozoic structure and sediments, both areas to which his earlier geological experience of structure and tectonics was relevant. The Palaeozoic was the Era in Tasmania during which most of the mineral resources were formed. As a result of his review, he brought for the first time a semblance of order to the conflicting views of the stratigraphy, structure and mineral potential of the early Palaeozoic rocks (particularly of the Cambrian volcanic rocks which later became known as the Mount Read Volcanics). He also produced for the first time a model relating Tertiary non-marine deposition to Cenozoic rift valley faulting. During his term of office, he arranged for up-to-date geological and mineral maps of the State to be prepared and published. He was not particularly happy at the Survey because the Director of Mines at the time had a policy of not publishing the results of the Survey's work. Carey eventually found a way around this restriction with his publication of the Report of the Government Geologist for 1945, a major advance in knowledge.

Professor of geology

Following the decision by the University of Tasmania to found a Department of Geology, Carey was appointed Foundation Professor and took up duties on 27 October 1946. Over the next six months, he designed courses, started a teaching collection of minerals, rocks and fossils, began to increase the library holdings of text and reference books, to organize office and laboratory space, and to arrange for appointment of a departmental secretary and a demonstrator. The structure of the first-year course was based on his experience at the University of Sydney – lectures, laboratory classes and a number of field excursions. He chose as first-year text Arthur Holmes' book Principles of Physical Geology (which included a chapter on continental drift). Students enrolled in the newly available subject, and teaching of science, engineering and agricultural students began in March 1947. In some of his subsequent lectures and excursions, 'The Prof.' referred graphically to the processes that he had seen in operation in New Guinea and the resulting rocks, when this was relevant to Tasmania. 'The Prof.' was always rather formally dressed, even on excursions, and addressed both staff and students very formally as 'Mr' or 'Miss' (or other appropriate term). Woe betide staff or students who were less formal in their address. This formality was a carry-over from his own school and university days. Close colleagues addressed him as 'Sam' but he always signed himself as 'S. Warren Carey', his chosen style.

Carey was housed for a brief period at the old University of Tasmania building on Hobart's Domain but moved almost immediately to the Second World War vertical-board 'huts' at the current campus, which had been a military rifle range. Teaching began in the old buildings on the new site and this continued until a new building was provided for Geology and Geography and occupied late in 1962. The building was planned in fine detail by Carey working with architects and incorporated his forward-looking perceptions of his subject. Teaching emphasis grew in the emerging disciplines of Geophysics and Geochemistry.

Carey's view was that geology is dynamic and best taught in the lecture room, laboratory classes and the field. The building was designed with high-impact aids. These included a Foucault pendulum in the foyer stairwell, a large terrestrial globe, a seismic recording drum, a mosaic on the foyer floor, specimens of Tasmanian minerals, rocks and fossils, and a growing gallery of photographs of graduates and former staff.

The globe (1.8 m diameter relief model) of the Earth had the geology of the seafloor painted on it incrementally as this became known through the 1960s. This sphere rotated once every three minutes and was designed to be lowered into and float in a water-filled mobile trolley, disconnected and wheeled across the corridor into the first-year lecture theatre for use during lectures. Unfortunately the idea was not totally successful because the sphere leaked when placed in the water. The sphere occupied its own glass-fronted room where it was visible to all, and Carey could work on it employing a specially built curved ladder that allowed him to access any part of the surface. The sphere is still there! Under his initiative, a seismic network was established in Tasmania in 1957, centred on the Geology Department. In the foyer of the new building, the rotating seismic drum continually records and displays Tasmanian seismicity from signals generated at four seismic stations. The Tasmanian Seismic Net was integrated into the World Standard Seismic Network. The floor of the foyer features an Escher 'Knights on Horseback' to demonstrate some elements of crystal symmetry. The specimen displays acted as a reference collection and a teaching aid for courses in Tasmanian geological history. The photographic record (the 'Rogues' Gallery') is of interest to current ('so that's what he/she used to look like') and past students (reminding them of past days, experiences and companions).

From his experience at the Geological Survey of Tasmania, Carey knew that there was a serious need for modern regional geological maps for use by the Survey, by the Tasmanian Hydro-Electric Commission, and by an expanding exploration industry. In a hint of things to come, he invited experienced geologists from all over Australia to come to Tasmania, to apply their particular geological skills, and to help extend knowledge of the geology of the island. Thus Professor R.T. Prider and Dr R.W. Fairbridge came to Tasmania from Western Australia, and Professor A.H. Voisey from Armidale, to map areas of interest to the Hydro-Electric Commission in its dam-building programme (Carey was consultant to the HEC for some years). The maps produced by these geologists were a significant part of the papers published on the areas concerned.

In the late 1940s, North Broken Hill Co. Ltd and some associated companies, interested in the matter by Dr C. Loftus Hills, became involved in an exploration programme in western Tasmania under the guidance of Dr M.D. Garretty. One result of this programme was the preparation of a photogeological map of the Zeehan area by Carey, using the skills he had acquired in New Guinea. As part of this exploration, Mr E. Gill was invited to Tasmania to examine the stratigraphy and palaeontology of the Siluro-Devonian rocks. Soon after the Geology Department started, Carey taught a course in air-photo interpretation to a group of professional geologists from Tasmania and other states. To assist further with production of regional geological maps, Carey developed a co-ordinated programme in which Honours and Master's students and staff produced geological maps of one or two 10,000 yard (9.144 km) squares at a published scale of one inch to the mile (1:63360). This programme lasted almost fifteen years during which 52 maps representing a total area of more than 4,500 km 2 (about 6.6% of the State) were published in colour. Many of the maps were produced by students using air photos and the slotted template method of map compilation. Many of the students were associated to varying degrees with the Geological Survey, the Hydro-Electric Commission or mining companies. The synergy between the Department and other bodies was very fruitful.

Teaching

In his role as teacher, Carey was very effective – he was inspirational. He gave a course on the broader aspects of geology (for example, tectonics) to first-year students throughout his career and courses in the same general area to second- and third-year students. In the early years, he ran all the excursions, but later restricted himself to first-year excursions. The excursions and many of the lectures were run on the 'disbelieve if you can' principle; he actively encouraged students to make close observations, to construct hypotheses consistent with their observations and previous knowledge, and to use multiple working hypotheses to explain what they saw. It was not 'I speak, therefore it is!', rather 'you look; you think; you defend your explanations against your fellow students and me'. At a time when most geology departments could count on a recruitment of 20-30% of first-year students to second year, his department was inspiring up to 60% to advance to higher levels of geological study. A number of graduates from his department, including several who studied geology as a fourth subject in first year (as Carey had done), reached eminence in the profession, in academia, in government service, and in industry. His graduates include several Professors of Geology, several Fellows of the Australian Academy of Science, and a Fellow of the Royal Society of London. He was a highly successful teacher.

In the academic community

His department grew and he steered it very well, but his connection with the academic community did not stop there. He was very assiduous in senior roles in the University – Dean of the Faculty of Science twice, Chairman of the Professorial Board, and President of the Staff Association. He played a significant role in the foundation of a Department of Geography in 1954 (shades of Professor David and Geography in the University of Sydney), and actively supported the introduction of an agricultural science degree in 1962. He was heavily involved in discussions on the planning of the University on the Sandy Bay campus, in the Royal Commission into the University in 1954, and in the Orr case. Although he was not a sympathiser with Orr, he initiated the 'Friends of the Orr family' to help Orr's widow after her husband's death. He was an energetic and respected member of the University community.

Spreading geology in the Tasmanian community

Carey had many roles in his capacity as spreader of knowledge of and about geology in the wider Tasmanian community. He founded the Tasmanian Caverneering Club, based on his experience in Jenolan Caves and in training for Z Force; this was the first such organization in Australia and the first use of the term. He maintained close links with the Australian Paratroopers' Association including active parachuting, and was strongly committed to Hobart Legacy.

He strongly encouraged the teaching of geology in schools, particularly secondary schools, a valuable source of recruitment for University geology. Following his early student membership of the Royal Society of New South Wales, he took an active role in the Royal Society of Tasmania, becoming its Senior Vice-President (the State Governor traditionally accepted the post of President). Subsequently, he was elected as Trustee, and later (1951/52), Chairman of Trustees of the Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery.

Research on Tasmania

Despite his ascent into the Ivory Tower, Carey remained interested in Tasmanian geology. He published at least eleven papers on this subject arising from work after he became Professor. These ranged from the very local to the regional, and from emphasis on Precambrian rocks to Pleistocene glacial effects, from mineralogy to variation of physical parameters in the subcrust. Some were factual reports, others wide-ranging syntheses. His contribution to the dolerite problem, and to analysis of structures in the Bass Basin, were typical.

Relations with industry

Carey was no armchair academic in an Ivory Tower. He believed that one of geology's important roles was in resource exploration for the nation's economic well-being. As both Government Geologist of Tasmania and Professor at the University of Tasmania, he saw the value of geology in exploration and in application to solving engineering problems in Tasmania. Economic geology was an important subject in his department, and examination of the Department's 'Rogues' Gallery' shows many who went on to successful and often very senior positions in mining and petroleum exploration companies, academia, geological surveys and similar organizations.

A continuing association was with Geopeko at its Tennant Creek mine in the Northern Territory. There is continuing controversy concerning the origin of some of the structures in the rocks there and Carey advised on this issue, eventually hiring staff at the University of Tasmania and having PhD research done on the problem. It was typical of his concept of integrating university and industrial needs for research.

Carey had worked for Oil Search and the Australasian Petroleum Company in Papua New Guinea for petroleum exploration for eight years.  Much of his field work and subsequent structural analysis laid the foundation for the modern success story there. His understanding of geological structures allowed predictions that are only now being proven correct. This interest was further expressed in the large Papua New Guinea project at the University of Tasmania during the 1960s.

Carey's publication record has many papers that are resource-related. What is less well-known is his role in the very successful exploration for hydrocarbons in the Gippsland Basin that has had a major impact on Australia's economy and reduced its dependence on imported oil. Lewis G. Weeks, consultant to BHP, sat in on one of Carey's 1959 lectures while Carey was Visiting Professor at Yale University.  Later, at Weeks' home, Carey sketched the extension of onshore Gippsland Basin anticlines to the offshore. This led, through Weeks, to BHP applying for permits to explore the offshore Gippsland Basin that led, in turn, to discovery of the major hydrocarbon province that is still producing and being explored further.

His main intellectual thrust

From the beginning, Carey taught continental drift. His attraction to the topic was initially because of his acquaintance with

Wegener's early work through lectures by L.A. Cotton at the University of Sydney, and later through the 1930s publications of the British geologist Arthur Holmes. His personal experience consisted of his undergraduate attraction to the topic and subsequent Papua New Guinea experience. What he taught in the early days at the University of Tasmania would now be regarded as plate tectonics. This was a time when fixity of the continents was orthodoxy. In addition to his teaching of the mobility of the continents, his research was related to some of the questions of properties of rocks involved in structural geology and continental movement.

His pioneering studies of the large-scale features of the Earth in the early 1950s led to many new concepts (sphenochasm, rheidity, orocline and many others) that required new expressions. These were defined very carefully, taking into account the best principles of etymology. For example, his concept of subsequently-rotated orogenic belts he originally named geoflex but he later rejected this term when he realised that it was a mixture of Greek and Latin roots; he replaced the word with orocline, purely Latin-based. His view of geoscience was the same. He had strong opinions on the pronunciation of words. One such word was 'kilometre' and he could be heard in presentations by others, correcting them loudly from the audience.

Carey developed an innovative approach to the study of continental drift and past supercontinental reconstruction. He arranged for construction of a hemisphere of Tasmanian endemic Huon Pine, 750 mm in diameter, and developed a system for making plastic overlays for this hemisphere. On these, he laboured long hours making detailed tracings of continents and moving these to past positions using palaeomagnetic data, geology and geography. This led to his detailed rebuttal in Geological Magazine of Sir Harold Jeffreys' 1929 assertion that South America and Africa did not constitute a proper fit of past continents. As he reconstructed past supercontinents, he found that there were gaps in what were probably originally continuous structures using an Earth of current diameter, and he became convinced that the Earth had expanded markedly with time. His demonstrations of the case for continental drift, evolution of rift valley to rift ocean and new seafloor, and the tracing of continental movement by volcanic chains (nemataths which he attributed to 'hotspots') are all legacies of his creative and pioneering research which have now become fully integrated into the plate tectonics model for the convecting, dynamic Earth. This was the integrative science that Carey taught through the 1940s and 1950s and which, when combined with seafloor spreading data, showed continents to be mobile, not fixed, in conflict with earlier dogma. It finally led to the 'plate tectonics' revolution in the mid-1960s. His later advocacy of an expanding Earth has not convinced the majority of his profession but the ability to lead with iconoclastic creativity is the characteristic for which Carey is best remembered.

In the mid-1950s, Carey began to convene a series of symposia on topics on which there was wide divergence of opinion. The first of these was on glacial marine sedimentation held in November 1955. Regrettably, papers presented at that meeting have not been published although, as a result of the meeting, a seminal paper on the topic was published by Carey and N. Ahmad in 1961. This paper, stimulated by the Permo-Carboniferous Gondwana glaciation in Tasmania, is still regarded as a classic.

Samuel Warren Carey 1911-2002

Near Hobart during the 1963 Symposium on Syntaphral Tectonics and Diagenesis. From left: Professor Carey, Professor Heezen, and Associate Professor John Bradley. (Photo: Dr H.J. Harrington)

The most famous, and most influential, of the symposia was the Continental Drift Symposium held in March 1956, attended by prominent overseas experts and published by the University of Tasmania in 1958. It was the time when a vast new body of oceanic data (sea floor bathymetry, earthquake distribution in three dimensions) was becoming available but continental drift was still not generally accepted. Carey assembled a group of leaders in various related fields, believers and non-believers alike, and produced a landmark volume. In the resulting publication, he introduced his belief in Earth expansion. Some see the results of this symposium as the most significant work on continental movement published in the twentieth century. It led to many converts and much follow-up study. Shortly afterwards, seafloor magnetic lineations were recognised, and major international initiatives such as the Deep Sea Drilling Project began with the object of testing some of the concepts. Also at about this time, Plate Tectonics, which explained the observations that Carey had taught in the late 1940s, became orthodox, as it still is.

Late in 1956, a symposium was held in Queenstown, western Tasmania, on the topic 'The Genesis of the Lyell Schists', the host rocks of the Mt Lyell copper ore body. This was not published. A little over six months later, in July 1957, the topic of dolerite was addressed. Dolerite is a very common rock type in Tasmania and, in the Australian context, a characteristically Tasmanian rock. It has been economically important, affecting the search for Tasmanian coal, and is an important determinant of the spectacular Tasmanian scenery. Despite its common occurrence, its mode of intrusion and structure were by no means clear at the time. Further, similar dolerites are prominent in Antarctica and South Africa. At the Dolerite Symposium, many aspects received attention and Carey introduced a novel concept – the isostrat – to help determine and explain its structure, a concept that triggered considerable geological and geophysical study that, in due course, led to the rejection of the isostrat concept. The Symposium stimulated research into the rock which continues today.

The success of the 1956 Continental Drift Symposium led to much international recognition for Carey. His Visiting Professorship at Yale attracted several PhD students who came to Tasmania for his New Guinea project (see below). His reputation as a proponent of his views grew and he received a large number of invitations to attend overseas meetings, to speak and to have his views published. He began to receive many international awards, culminating with the award of its 2000 Career Contribution Award by the Structural Geology and Tectonics Division of the Geological Society of America.

Some of the concepts Carey espoused made him realise again the importance of Papua New Guinea as a source of ideas on earth movement and he obtained funding for a serious study by a group of PhD students. Thus several students worked together in the 1960s studying field geology in critical regions, and also key aspects of the geophysics of the area.

The symposium on Syntaphral Tectonics and Diagenesis, in 1963, addressed the origin of unusual minerals and their textures developed in unconsolidated sand and finer sediments as they move under the influence of gravity and water pressure. An important topic was the key role of colloids and gel/sol in transitions in producing large crystals in sedimentary rocks, and the relationship to ore bodies. The symposium was held both in Hobart and in the field at Tennant Creek in the Northern Territory. It generated heated debate following presentation of unorthodox views on the origin of the porphyroblasts in the Tennant Creek rocks, but was consistent with Carey's philosophy of stimulating the debate.

Carey's publications became more concerned with tectonics as time passed, but occasionally he delved into other topics. Near 'retirement' and after, the scale of his thinking expanded and turned more towards the role of Earth and humanity in the universe. A 1988 review of his Theories of the Earth and Universe: a History of Dogma in the Earth Sciences noted that in this book 'Carey was back in comfortable territory: outside of the establishment'.

Scientific societies

Beyond the limits of Tasmania, Carey also was active and held executive roles in many scientific societies. He also promoted membership of such societies to students. He was prominent in the Geological Society of Australia, being a Foundation Member, later President and ultimately was elected to Honorary Membership. The Society struck a medal in his honour, first presented in 1992. He took a close interest in the Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science (ANZAAS), was Secretary for the 1949 meeting in Hobart, and President of the 1970 Port Moresby Conference (where he gave his presidential address accompanied by a gradually expanding balloon – the Earth – that he punctured at the end of the presentation). He was eventually awarded the ANZAAS Medal and Honorary Life Membership. He was an Honorary Life Member of the Royal Society of New South Wales, and Honorary Foreign Life Member of the Geological Society of America.

On retirement and soon after the establishment of the award, he was appointed an Officer in the Order of Australia (AO), reflecting the depth and diversity of his contributions to the Australian community.

In 1979, in company with two US scientists, Carey founded the Expanding Earth Exchange (EEE), a cyberspace network to promote the concept of the expanding Earth and to show that adoption of subduction was an 'unfortunate and regrettable mistake'. This evolved into the Central Expanding Earth Exchange which continued until just before Carey's death.

Relationship with the Australian Academy of Science

Carey's relationship with the Australian Academy of Science was stormy to say the least. The record will show that he accepted Fellowship of the Academy following a telephone call from Sir Rutherford Robertson on 27 April 1989. The Academy of Science, at its April 1989 Annual General Meeting, elected him under the by-law that allowed special election of a limited number of Fellows on the basis that such election honoured someone who 'has rendered conspicuous service to the cause of science, or whose election would be of signal benefit to the Academy and to the advancement of science'. This election brought to conclusion a controversial relationship. Carey responded by letter on 1 May 1989, accepting the honour but also pointing out that he was completely unaware that he was being considered, as he had been equally unaware of the honours bestowed on him by 'the Indian National Science Academy, Geological Society of London, ANZAAS, Geological Society of America, Geological Society of Australia, Royal Society of New South Wales', etc.

The long-running dispute between Carey and the Academy had begun several decades earlier.

Until the institution of the Australian Academy of Science in 1954, representation of Australia in international scientific bodies had been through the Australian National Research Council, of which Carey had been a Fellow since 1938. When the Academy of Science came into being, with twelve of the 24 Foundation Fellows being Fellows of the Royal Society of London working in Australia, Carey was not offered Fellowship. This, he believed, was because of objections by some Fellows who considered that his advocacy of continental drift was so outrageous that any adherent in its ranks would bring discredit to the Academy.

Carey submitted his orocline paper to the Journal of the Geological Society of Australia that year and it was reviewed perchance by three Fellows of the Academy, and rejected. In consequence, he wrote that he would never allow put his name to be put forward for election to the Academy, nor again submit a paper for publication by the Geological Society of Australia. The lines were drawn!

Following the success of the Continental Drift Symposium, Sir Harold Raggatt asked Carey's permission in 1958 to put his name forward for Fellowship. Carey declined, citing the issue of the rejection of his paper.

In February 1969, Professor Dorothy Hill, as President of the Academy, wrote to Carey saying that she had the numbers to have him elected. Again he declined nomination, comparing his earlier treatment with that of William Smith when publication of his Geological Map of the England and Wales was rejected by the Geological Society of London early in the nineteenth century (this map was subsequently published, coincidentally, by John Carey, who was found to be unrelated). He further stated that 'I do not think that the Academy will amount to anything geologically in my lifetime'.

Australia hosted, in August 1976, the 25th International Geological Congress, which was co-sponsored by the Academy and the Geological Society of Australia. The Congress was very successful and made a profit of some $70,000. The Organizing Committee of the IGC recommended to the Academy that this fund be used for a variety of geological purposes. These included contributing to organizations that had supported the Congress, paying for publication of the Congress reports, contributing to the cost of publishing a Tectonic Map of Australia, and establishing a fund for the purpose of assisting promising geologists from Australia and New Zealand to attend other IGCs, or for those from IGC-hosting countries to visit Australasia. In accordance with precedent, however, the Academy, as financial sponsor and guarantor of the Congress (which included responsibility for any losses incurred) decided that the profit should be available to support its continuing role of sponsoring international conferences in a variety of disciplines.

This decision was not acceptable to the Congress organizers, and particularly to Carey as president of the Geological Society of Australia. Much debate and strongly worded correspondence ensued, and Carey's energetic diplomacy led to his discussing the matter with the officers of the Academy in Canberra late on 20 April 1977. Later that year, the earlier Council decision was rescinded, the Congress organizers' recommendations were accepted, and a trust fund was established.

Carey followed this incident with a severe criticism of the Academy in The Australian Geologist. Until the establishment of the Academy, the Geological Society of Australia had been the Australian link to the International Union of Geological Sciences, but the Academy had now assumed that role. Carey was vehement in his criticism of the Academy, referring to it as a producer of reports that were eventually consigned to the waste-paper basket.

Outstanding achievements

Carey was foundation Professor of Geology at the University of Tasmania and held the position for thirty years, from appointment in 1946 until retirement on 31 December 1976. He was recognised internationally as a controversial extrovert who expounded vigorously his belief in Earth expansion as an explanation for what he observed in his studies of continental drift. He should perhaps be even more noted for his teaching and recruitment of students into geology. This approach caused the Geology Department at the small University of Tasmania to become Australia's leading department of earth science for many years.

As a scientist, Carey was an independent thinker, perhaps something of an intellectual 'loner'. He had several opportunities to leave Tasmania for posts at better known universities, both in Australia and overseas; however, he believed that operating in an environment with no history of commitment to geological orthodoxy provided a freer intellectual milieu. Tasmania was ideal.

While professionally deeply involved in studying first-order aspects of the way Earth functions, Carey's interest was never superficial, and he was fully conversant with the detail. This was a major philosophical conviction and applied to any interest he developed.

He was a showman and enjoyed making an impact. At a meeting in Hobart in the 1960s, at which virtually all Australian professors of geology were present, he hosted a small social gathering in the Geology Department. He entered a few minutes after the due time. All other professors referred to him as 'professor' and he addressed them (all male) as 'my boy'. All appeared to look up to him as the 'father figure'.

For all the high-level recognition he received, Carey was also highly interested in the ordinary needs of people and was an active member of Legacy for many years, organized support for the family of Sydney Sparkes Orr after Orr's death, and was available at all times to help any student who genuinely needed help.

Acknowledgements

We recognize that this review is one of many that will pay tribute to Carey and thank others in the throes of preparing such testimonials for their input. This summary should be seen as complementary to those tributes.

We thank the Australian Academy of Science and especially Professor Ross Day for this opportunity to contribute to commemorating someone who has had such a major role in our careers and way of thinking. A project such as this depends on contributions from many. Professor Carey's family, especially Mrs Austral Carey and Robyn Loughead, have been great supporters. Dr D. Branagan and Messrs J. Elliston and J.K. Davidson were sources of information and sounding boards for ideas and text. Drs K. McCracken and H.J. Harrington provided images and recollections that have improved the story. Nola Skillman of Canterbury Boys' High School helped with information on his enrolment and progress there. We thank reviewers Professors David Curtis, David Green and Ross Taylor and editor Rod Home for their very constructive comments.

June Pongratz, School of Earth Sciences, University of Tasmania, who worked closely with Carey for some forty years, helped with the production of images for this paper.

Awards

  • Honorary Life Member, Royal Society of NSW
  • Honorary Life Member, Geological Society of Australia
  • Honorary Life Member, ANZAAS
  • Honorary Foreign Life Member, Geological Society of London
  • Fellow of the Indian National Science Academy (FNI)
  • Honorary Fellow, Geological Society of America
  • Visiting Professor, Yale University (1959/60)
  • U.N. Technical Adviser, Israel (1963)
  • Chrestien Mica Gondwanaland Gold Medal (Geological Mining and Metallurgical Institute of India, 1963)
  • Visiting Professor, University of Western Ontario (1967/68)
  • Clarke Medal (Royal Society of NSW, 1969)
  • Honorary DSc, University of Papua New Guinea (1970)
  • R.M. Johnston Medal (Royal Society of Tasmania, 1977)
  • Honorary Doctor of Geological Science, University of Urbino (1977)
  • Officer of the Order of Australia (1977)
  • Browne Medal (Geological Society of Australia, 1982)
  • Lewis Weekes Medal (1996)
  • ANZAAS Medal (1998)
  • Medal of the Italian Geological Society
  • Gold Medal of the Australian Society of Exploration Geophysicists (1998)
  • Geological Society of America, Structural Geology and Tectonics Division, 2000 Career Contribution Award

Affiliations

  • Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science
  • Past President, Geological Society of Australia
  • Royal Society of NSW
  • Past Senior Vice-President, Royal Society of Tasmania
  • Royal Society of Western Australia
  • Linnaean Society of NSW
  • Past President, ANZAAS
  • American Association of Petroleum Geologists
  • Association of Photogrammetric Engineers
  • Australian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy
  • Geological Society of France
  • Legacy
  • Australian Paratroopers' Association

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol.14, no.3, 2003. It was written by:

  • Patrick G. Quilty, School of Earth Sciences, University of Tasmania
  • Maxwell R. Banks, School of Earth Sciences, University of Tasmania

References

In addition to family, diaries, and the World Wide Web, the following publications have provided a considerable amount of the material used here:

  • Banks, M.R., 1976. Professor S. Warren Carey – some biographic data. Journal of the Geology Students Club, University of Tasmania, 10: pp. 57-68.
  • Branagan, D.F. (editor), 1973. Rocks – Fossils – Profs. Geological Sciences in the University of Sydney 1866-1973. Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of Sydney, Sydney, 84 pp.
  • Branagan, D.F., Elliston, J., and Banks, M., 1990. Samuel Warren Carey. In Branagan, D.F. (ed.) 'Knight Errant of Science'. Sir Edgeworth David Memorial Oration. Australasian Mineral Heritage Trust and others. Parkville; The Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, pp. xi-xiv.
  • Branagan, D.F., and Holland, G., 1985. Ever Reaping Something New – a Science Centenary. Faculty of Science, University of Sydney. University of Sydney, Sydney, 256 pp.
  • Cooper, B.J., and Branagan, D.F. (editors), 1984. Rock me Hard…Rock me Soft…A History of the Geological Society of Australia. Geological Society of Australia, Sydney, 194 pp.
  • Davis, R., 1990. Open to Talent – The Centenary History of the University of Tasmania, 1890-1990. University of Tasmania, Hobart, 256 pp.
  • Elliston, J., 2002. Professor S.W, Carey's Struggle with Conservatism. The Australian Geologist, Newsletter No. 125: pp. 17-23.
  • Harrington, H.J., Yeates, A.J., Branagan, D.F., and McNally, G.H., 1991. Sixty Years on the Rocks: the Memoirs of Professor Alan H. Voisey. Earth Sciences History Group, Geological Society of Australia, Sydney, 124 pp.
  • Horton, D.C., 1983. Ring of Fire. Macmillan, Melbourne, 164 pp.
  • Jennings, I.B., 1976. History of the Geological Survey and the Geological Survey Branch, Department of Mines, Tasmania. In Johns, R. K. (editor) History and Role of Government Geological Surveys in Australia. Government Printer, South Australia, Adelaide, pp. 57-63.
  • Macintyre, S., 1992. S.W. Carey Symposium: after dinner address. The Australian Geologist, Newsletter No. 82: pp. 11-13.
  • McGowran, B., 1994. Martin Fritz Glaessner 1906-1989. Historical Records of Australian Science, 10: pp. 61-81.
  • McKie, R., 1960. The Heroes. Angus & Robertson, Sydney, 235 pp.

Bibliography

  1. Water divining. Sydney Univ. Sci. Jl, xii (Michaelmas term 1933), pp. 17-18.
  2. The geological structure of the Werrie Basin. Proc. Linn. Soc. N.S.W., 49 (1934), pp. 351-374.
  3. Notes on the implications of the irregular strike lines of the Mooki Thrust System. Proc. Linn. Soc. N.S.W., 49 (1934), pp. 375-379.
  4. Note on the Permian sequence in the Werrie Basin. Proc. Linn. Soc. N.S.W., 50 (1935), pp. 447-486.
  5. The Carboniferous sequence in the Werrie Basin. Proc. Linn. Soc. N.S.W., 52 (1937), pp. 341-376.
  6. (With W.R Browne) Review of the Carboniferous stratigraphy, tectonics and palaeogeography of New South Wales and Queensland. J. Proc. Roy. Soc. N.S.W., 71 (1938), pp. 591-614.
  7. The morphology of New Guinea. The Australian Geographer, 3(5) (1938), pp. 3-30.
  8. (With G.D. Osborne) Preliminary note on the nature of the stresses involved in the Late Palaeozoic diastrophism in New South Wales. J. Proc. Roy. Soc. N.S.W, 72 (1939), pp. 199-208.
  9. Notes on Cretaceous strata in the Purari Valley, Papua. Proc. Roy. Soc. Vict., 56 (1945), pp. 123-130.
  10. Report of the Government Geologist. Rep. Dir. of Mines Tas. for 1945 (1947), pp. 21-29.
  11. Geology of the Launceston district. Rec. Queen Victoria Mus. 11 (1947), pp. 31-46.
  12. Occurrence of tillite on King Island. Rep. Austral. New Zealand Assoc. Adv. Sci. 25th Congress 1945 (1947), p. 349.
  13. (With C.L. Hills) Geology and mineral industry. ANZAAS Handbook for Tasmania (1949), pp. 21-44.
  14. (With B. Scott) Revised interpretation of the geology of the Smithton district of Tasmania. Pap. Proc. Roy. Soc. Tas., 86 (1952), pp. 63-70.
  15. Geological structure of Tasmania in relation to mineralization. In Geology of Australian Ore Deposits: Fifth Empire Mining Congress, 1 (1953), pp. 1108-1128.
  16. (With B. Scott) Native copper at Smithton – a correction. Pap. Proc. Roy. Soc. Tas., 88 (1954), pp. 271-272.
  17. The rheid concept in tectonics. J. Geol. Soc. Aust., 1 (1954), pp. 67-117.
  18. Correlation of the post-Triassic history of Tasmania with secular variation of temperature and viscosity of the sub-crust. Pap. Proc. Roy. Soc. Tas., 88 (1954), pp. 189-191.
  19. The geoflex concept and the origin of the Indian Ocean. Rep. 2nd Pan Indian Ocean Sci. Assoc. Congr. (Perth), Sect. C (1)1954, p. 1.
  20. (With M.R. Banks) Lower Palaeozoic unconformities in Tasmania. Pap. Proc. Roy. Soc. Tas., 88 (1954), pp. 245-269.
  21. Fluid geotectonics. News Bull. Geol. Soc. Aust., 2(2) (1954), pp. 1-3.
  22. Wegener's South American-African assembly, fit or misfit? Geol. Mag., 92 (1955), pp. 196-200.
  23. The orocline concept in geotectonics. Pap. Proc. Roy. Soc. Tas., 89 (1955), pp. 255-288.
  24. A new record of glacial grooving near Queenstown, Tasmania. Aust. J. Sci., 17 (1955), p. 176.
  25. The tectonic approach to continental drift. Continental Drift Symposium, Univ. Tas. (1958), pp. 177-355.
  26. The isostrat, a new technique for the analysis of the structure of the Tasmanian Dolerite. Dolerite Symposium, Univ. Tas. (1958), pp. 130-164.
  27. Relation of basic intrusions to thickness of sediments. Dolerite Symposium, Univ. Tas. (1958), pp. 165-169.
  28. Note on the columnar jointing in Tasmanian dolerite. Dolerite Symposium, Univ. Tas. (1958), pp. 229-230.
  29. North-south asymmetry of the Earth's figure. Science, 130 (1959), pp. 978-979.
  30. The tectonic approach to the origin of the Indian Ocean. 3rd Pan Indian Ocean Science Assoc. Congr. (Madagascar) (1959), pp. 171-228.
  31. The strength of the Earth's crust. Trans. New York Acad. Sci., ser. 11, 22 (1960), pp. 303-312.
  32. (With N. Ahmad) Glacial marine sediments – their environment and nomenclature. In Geology of the Arctic, Proc. 1st Internat. Symp. on Arctic Geology (Toronto: Univ. of Toronto Press, 1961), pp. 865-894.
  33. Palaeomagnetic evidence relevant to a change in the Earth's radius. Nature, 190 (1961), p. 36.
  34. Folding. 3rd Honorary Anniversary Address. J. Alberta Soc. Pet. Geol., 10(3) (1962), pp. 95-144.
  35. Plegamiento. Extracto de Notas y Communicaciones del Instituto Geologico y Minero de España, 74 (1962), pp. 75-142.
  36. Scale of geotectonic phenomena. J. Geol. Soc. India, 3 (1962), pp. 97-105.
  37. Escala de los Fenomenos Geotectonicos. Extracto de Notas y Communicaciones del Instituto Geologico y Minero de España, 72 (1962), pp. 277-288.
  38. The asymmetry of the Earth. Presidential address, ANZAAS Sec. C. Aust. J. Sci., 25 (1963), pp. 369-383, 479-488.
  39. Syntaphral tectonics. In Syntaphral Tectonics and Diagenesis – a Symposium, ed. S.W. Carey (Hobart: University of Tasmania, 1963), pp. B1-7.
  40. 2000 A.D. – Prognosis. Med. J. Aust., 1 (1967), pp. 1235-1242.
  41. Orthodoxy, heresy and discovery. Stanley Memorial Lecture. Ann. Rep. & Proc. Papua & New Guinea Sci. Soc., 18 (1967), pp. 45-59.
  42. Tectonic framework of the Sydney Basin. In Advances in the Study of the Sydney Basin. Abstracts (University of Newcastle: Newcastle, 1969), pp. 53-59.
  43. Australia, New Guinea and Melanesia in the current revolution in concepts of the evolution of the Earth. Presidential address, 42nd ANZAAS Congr., Port Moresby. Search 1, (1970), pp. 178-189.
  44. The face of the Earth. Aust. Nat. Hist., 17 (1972), pp. 254-257.
  45. Major features of the Pacific and the “New Global Tectonics”. In The Eastern Pacific: Island Arcs, Marginal Seas, Geochemistry, ed. P.J. Coleman (Perth: University of W.A. Press, 1973), pp. 103-104.
  46. Review of 'A global approach to geology: the background of a mineral exploration strategy based on significant form in the patterning of the Earth's crust' by B.B. Brock. Tectonophysics, 18 (1973), pp. 391-393.
  47. Non Uniformitarianism. 4th Bertrand Russell Memorial Lecture, Flinders University. Flinders Science Journal,1 (1973), pp. 2-17.
  48. The expanding Earth – an essay review. Earth Sci. Rev., 11 (1975), pp. 105-143.
  49. Tectonic evolution of south-east Asia. 4th Indonesian Pet. Congr. Preprint, 1 (1975) pp. 1-31.
  50. Palaeomagnetism and Earth expansion. Chayanica Geologica, 1 (1975), pp. 152-195.
  51. Earth expansion: the face of the Earth; the necessity of expansion; the subduction myth. In Our Earth, eds H. Messel and S.T. Butler (Sydney: Shakespeare Head Press, 1975) pp. 105-167.
  52. Review of 'Gravity and tectonics' (the van Bemmelen Volume) ed. K.A. de Jong and R. Scholten, Tectonophysics, 27 (1975), pp. 297-298.
  53. The subduction myth. S. E. Asia Pet. Assoc. Proc., 11 (1975), pp. 41-69.
  54. The Expanding Earth (Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1976), 488 pp.
  55. A philosophy of the Earth and universe. Pap. Proc. Roy. Soc. Tasm., 112 (1978), pp. 5-19.
  56. Causes of sea-level oscillations. Proc. Roy. Soc. Vict., 92 (1980), pp. 13-17.
  57. The Expanding Earth – a Symposium, ed. S.W. Carey (Sydney: Earth Resources Foundation, 1981), 423 pp.
  58. Evolution of beliefs on the nature and origin of the Earth. Convener's introduction. In The Expanding Earth, pp. 3-7.
  59. Tethys and her forebears. In The Expanding Earth, pp. 169-187.
  60. Earth expansion and the null universe. In The Expanding Earth, pp. 367-396.
  61. The necessity for Earth expansion – Convener's review. In The Expanding Earth, pp. 375-393.
  62. Genesis of the Himalayan system from Turkey to Burma. Misc. Publ. Geol. Surv. India, 1 (1982), pp. 401-416.
  63. Genesis of Proterozoic banded-iron formation. J. Geol. Soc. India, 18 (1986), pp. 223-226.
  64. Diagenetic krikogenesis. In The Origin of Arcs, ed. F.C. Wezel (Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1986), pp. 1-40.
  65. La terra in espansione, trans. G. Scaleri (Laterza: Roma-Bari, 1986), 346 pp.
  66. Geotectonic setting of Australasia. In Second South-Eastern Australian Oil Exploration Symposium, ed. R.C. Glenie (Melbourne: Petroleum Exploration Society of Australia, 1986), pp. 3-25.
  67. Tethys and her forebears. In Shallow Tethys 2, ed. K.G. McKenzie (Rotterdam: Balkema, 1987), pp. 3-30.
  68. Theories of the Earth and Universe: a History of Dogma in the Earth Sciences (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1988), 413 pp.
  69. Knight Errant of Science. In Sir Edgeworth David Memorial Oration, ed. D.F. Branagan (Parkville; The Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, 1990), pp. 1-54.
  70. Fifty years of oil search. In Petroleum exploration in Papua New Guinea. ed. G.J. Carman and Z. Carman (Port Moresby: PNG Chamber of Mines and Petroleum, 1990), pp. 17-26.
  71. (as Keri, U.) V poiskakh zakonomernstei razvitiia zemli i vselennoi: istoriia dogm v naukakh o zemle. trans. B.A. Borisova, N.I. Kutuzovoi, and M.P. Antilova (Moscow: Mir, 1991), 447 pp.
  72. Earth, Universe, Cosmos (Hobart: University of Tasmania Press, 1996), 258 pp.

Rutherford Ness Robertson 1913–2001

Sir Rutherford Ness (Bob) Robertson was one of Australia's most distinguished, influential and respected scientists. He was eminent both for his contributions to scientific thought and knowledge and for the remarkable range of activities he undertook in the cause of science. His contributions to our understanding of the bioenergetics of inorganic ion transport in plant cells were widely recognised. In his other life he served in a number of key administrative-managerial positions, was the prime mover in a variety of major initiatives that had critical and lasting impacts on the development of Australian science and was a trusted friend and adviser to a generation of younger plant scientists. Known universally as Bob and almost universally addressed as such, it would seem odd and almost disrespectful not to refer to him in this way here.

Image Description
Rutherford Ness Robertson 1913-2001

Introduction

Sir Rutherford Ness (Bob) Robertson was one of Australia's most distinguished, influential and respected scientists. He was eminent both for his contributions to scientific thought and knowledge and for the remarkable range of activities he undertook in the cause of science. His contributions to our understanding of the bioenergetics of inorganic ion transport in plant cells were widely recognised. In his other life he served in a number of key administrative-managerial positions, was the prime mover in a variety of major initiatives that had critical and lasting impacts on the development of Australian science and was a trusted friend and adviser to a generation of younger plant scientists. Known universally as Bob and almost universally addressed as such, it would seem odd and almost disrespectful not to refer to him in this way here.

In the following account we shall draw heavily on four sources of information about Bob's life and work. These are a Personal Record submitted to the Royal Society,[1] the transcript of an interview conducted for the Australian Academy of Science,[2] an autobiographical article written for the Annual Review of Plant Physiology and Plant Molecular Biology[3 ]and a personal account of his involvement in the field of charge separation and energy transduction in biological membranes.[4]

Origins and early years (1913–1933)

Bob's path and philosophy in adult life was more than ordinarily influenced by his parents and childhood experiences. Hence, some account of this period is particularly relevant. Bob was born in Melbourne on 29 September 1913 and could trace his ancestry to migrations from Scotland and England to Australia in the mid-nineteenth century. He says his grandfather's generation failed as farmers in coastal Victoria and 'most became preachers instead', including his grandfather. Following in this tradition, his father (Joshua Robertson, E.D., M.A., Dip.Soc.Sci.) and two of his brothers chose to be preachers, his father being a Baptist. Bob said his father preached an unusual philosophy for those days 'that Christian people had to do something for the community as a whole and not just look after their own heavenly futures'. His father became an army chaplain during the 1914–18 World War so Bob did not see much of him until 1919.

In the interim his mother (Josephine Robertson, née Hogan) took Bob to stay with relatives in Brisbane, where he contracted poliomyelitis. This disease left him with a weak leg and a permanent limp. Bob recalled that the worst part was being dragged around from one person to another in a futile attempt to rectify the disability. After returning to Melbourne Bob spent the last three years of primary school at Carey Baptist Grammar School. He remembered this as an exciting and challenging place but also as a place where he began to learn 'what it was to have hard knocks with people with whom I didn't see eye-to-eye'.

The atmosphere in his home was 'strictly puritanical with church-going regular and constant'. However, his mother provided some counterbalance to this since he says 'her family were not strictly religious and broadened my horizons'. Clearly, his father's philosophies had a strong and lasting influence on the way that Bob saw things. He was appreciative of this influence which he said 'set standards of moral and ethical behaviour which I still respect' but added, 'I can no longer believe in the myths and allegories of Christianity'; on another occasion he wrote that 'I no longer believe that the behaviour of men and women is directed by any supernatural power'.

Apparently, his mother had the greater influence on Bob, especially with respect to intellectual matters and science in particular. She was well read and interested in a wide range of matters from art to science. She encouraged his interest in science and talked to him about the exciting developments of the time, including a public lecture she attended by the renowned Ernest Rutherford. When Bob showed a particular interest in chemistry, she helped him get together some chemicals and equipment 'to do some experiments at home'.

His father moved to a ministry in Christchurch, New Zealand, when Bob was 12. Bob very much enjoyed the secondary school he attended there, St Andrews College. He particularly remembered the companionship, the strong ethical outlook and good teaching 'in traditional British subjects'. There was also a strong emphasis on sport that Bob enjoyed to the best of his ability. He also remembered a strict discipline regime and recalled resenting being caned for making spelling mistakes and not having his name in his sandshoes. There was little science taught there, however, and that by non-trained people. He recalled getting into some bother at one stage by pointing out that the atom was not the smallest indivisible particle of matter, and being told finally 'You are quite right but that is not in the syllabus'.

His father's calling took the family to Sydney in 1930. At that time Bob had just completed his matriculation examination at the relatively young age of 16 years. The possibility of his repeating a final school year in Sydney was considered but in the end he enrolled in a science course at the University of Sydney. In retrospect, Bob believed this was a mistake. Lacking the solid science foundation provided by the New South Wales school system, he found first and second year hard going but, as he said, he did 'scrape through'. He also ruefully pointed out that the resulting need to work so hard to keep up, combined with his immaturity, prevented him from benefiting from the social life of the University.

As he proceeded through the course there occurred a critical change in his prime scientific interest from chemistry to botany. But what a prophetic and serendipitous combination of interests to take advantage of the emerging field of plant physiology! It was no surprise that Bob chose to do an Honours year in botany. He was asked by Professor Osborn to come back in the New Year with a suggestion about what area of botany he wished to focus on.

There followed in the intervening time one of those events that changes the course of one's life. During a holiday in Adelaide Bob met by chance one of the few plant physiologists in Australia at that time, Dr A.H.K. Petrie, who worked at the Waite Institute. He suggested that, with Bob's strong chemistry background, a future in plant physiology would be ideal. So, consulting with Osborn, Bob decided to work on the mechanism controlling the opening and closing of stomata, the pores on the surface of leaves that regulate the exchange of gases such as carbon dioxide and oxygen into and from leaves. This project worked out well enough for Bob to graduate with first-class Honours in 1934.

The fact that Bob was required to serve as a demonstrator to the first-year Botany class during his Honours year proved of more than usual significance. Amongst the several young ladies in that class who were attracted to this handsome young demonstrator was Mary Helen Bruce Rogerson. Later, she was to become his wife, his life-long companion and, as Bob has said, his 'keenest critic and wisest advisor'.

Graduate research era (1934–1939)

With the aid of a University of Sydney research scholarship and then a Macleay Fellowship from the Linnaean Society of New South Wales, Bob continued working in Sydney on the stomatal opening problem for the next two years. He felt progress was constrained by the lack of equipment and know-how on physiological matters in the department. However, in 1936 he was awarded a prestigious Science Research Scholarship of the Royal Commission for the Exhibition of 1851. This was awarded to promising students from the Dominions to study in Britain. At this point A.H.K. Petrie of Adelaide was to play a critical part again in the direction of Bob's career. He advised Bob that if he wanted to pursue a career as a physiologist then he should try to work with Professor G.E. Briggs in the Botany School at Cambridge.

Briggs agreed to accept this young colonial as a PhD student and so the course of Bob's scientific research career was set. He departed for Cambridge on a cargo ship in October 1936, but not before becoming engaged to be married to Mary Rogerson. They faced a separation of two or three years.

So Bob was thrust into the exciting biological environment of Cambridge in the 1930s. It was the heyday of the Cavendish Laboratory and of the great pioneering biochemists including Frederick Hopkins, Joseph and Dorothy Needham, Robin Hill, Gordon Pirie and Dick Synge. Another prominent plant physiologist in the Botany Department, besides Briggs, was E.J. Maskell. Bob said of Briggs that he was a most imaginative physiologist and 'one of the ablest thinkers, most acute minds, and most highly critical attitudes in the biology of the time'. Needless to say their collaboration prospered. Bob undertook the task of continuing the earlier study by Briggs of the mechanism of ion uptake by plant cells.

The primary aim of this research was to explain how the energy necessary to drive the active uptake of ions against a concentration gradient was made available from the process of respiration. The details of this project, and how it remained the primary focus of Bob's research for years to come, are outlined in a later section.

Bob's time at Cambridge was not totally dominated by his research. For instance, he served as the local secretary of the Association of Scientific Workers, a group aimed at advertising the contribution that science could make as well as acknowledging the social responsibility of scientists. Of course, these were difficult times politically with the Spanish civil war and the emerging threat of Hitler's Nazi Germany. In this environment he became associated with the Cambridge Scientists' Anti-War Group. It is not surprising that amongst those attracted to these groups were people from the left side of politics including communists of various levels of commitment. However, Bob admitted to having difficulty, then and later, in fathoming the political commitment of his communist friends. He was suspicious of the matters they took as articles of faith and had difficulty understanding why they remained faithful to that cause after Stalin made a pact with Hitler and after the various events that were to follow in the post-war years.

It is interesting that around this period of 1936 Bob was already thinking deeply about problems relating to religion and science and their impact on society and social relations. For instance, three talks he gave during that period were entitled 'Science and Religion', 'Immigration – the Australian Situation' and 'Dynamic Christianity'. Apparently, the influences of his parents, especially with respect to social and ethical matters, were the driving force in his involvement in these activities.

Towards the end of 1937, Bob's fiancée Mary Rogerson was able to make the trip to England and they were married in Cambridge in September of that year. They travelled extensively in Britain and also in Holland and Germany in the following year despite the looming war clouds.

In the latter part of 1938, the newly appointed Professor, Eric Ashby, offered Bob an Assistant Lecturer position in the Botany School at the University of Sydney. This set a deadline for completing his research at Cambridge and submitting a thesis. The mandatory oral examination was completed just before Bob and Mary sailed for Australia and news that his doctorate had been granted was received by radiogram as the boat approached Cape Town.

Sydney era (1939–1962)

Bob's intention was to continue his work on ion uptake in plant cells in Sydney but the Second World War intervened. The head of the Botany School, Professor Ashby, became involved in war-related matters that often took him away from the department. As a result, Bob took over some of Ashby's administrative duties, a great experience for what was to come. He also served as the liaison officer between the University of Sydney and the Ministry of Post-War Reconstruction, and as secretary to the Vice-Chancellor's Research Committee. Academics generally switched their research to aspects related in some way to the war effort. In what free time he had left, Bob devoted himself to two problems related to the storage and shipping of food. One was to develop procedures to prolong the storage life of apples and other fruit. The other was related to the open-air storage of the huge reserves of wheat in Australia. The problem was to determine why the wheat, stored in such large quantities, was getting hot. As Bob suspected, the generation of heat was not due to the respiration of the grain itself, which was very low, but rather, to the respiration of the insects infesting the wheat.

This appointment in Sydney also provided Bob with the opportunity to apply some of his thoughts on how science should be taught. The key feature of his philosophy was to teach science as an exercise in investigation, problem solving and thinking for oneself. Fortunately, these views coincided with those of Professor Ashby, and Bob acknowledged Ashby's great influence on him not only for these views but also for his approach to students and his abilities as an administrator and innovator.

At war's end Bob made a very significant career change, accepting a position as head of a research group in a Division of the Commonwealth Government's Council for Scientific and Industrial Research, later to become the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO). The concerns of this Division of Food Preservation and Transport included basic and applied aspects of fruit and vegetable storage. This move undoubtedly changed the course of Bob's career and, as he said, 'was not taken lightly'. His new position allowed him to continue his interest in the basic aspects of ion transport and respiration as well as his newly acquired, more applied interests in food technology.

Significantly, this appointment also allowed him to continue teaching plant physiology in the Botany Department at Sydney, an arrangement that was to continue for more than ten years. Besides the direct links with the Botany Department, where some of his staff with more physiological interests were located, the new position also involved collaboration with sections of the New South Wales Department of Agriculture. Meanwhile his concern with broader issues of science and society continued with articles such as 'The Future of Scientific Research in Australia' (87), 'Biology and the World's Food Crisis' (88) and 'Science in the Community' (89) appearing in University publications.

Later, the link with the University of Sydney was consolidated when Bob was appointed head of a unit created within the Botany School, and run jointly with that School, to study the physiology of plants including, of course, fruit and vegetables. This Plant Physiology Unit was set up in 1950, not long after Bob returned from an extensive overseas trip that was especially important for developing or consolidating contacts relating to his interests in the ion transport-respiration field as well as fruit physiology and technology. He also took the opportunity to meet the leaders in other areas of the then rapidly expanding field of plant physiology. The list of people he met read like the Who's Who of plant physiology of the time. Bob returned home inspired to 'foster research in the fields of plant physiology and biochemistry in Australia'.

There followed, through the decade of the 1950s, a remarkably productive period of research activity in the Plant Physiology Unit. Many of the students passing through during this time were to go on to significant independent careers. Bob's own work on ion transport, and especially the link with mitochondrial respiration, progressed substantially. He was also remembered for the pace at which he strode about the corridors of the Unit constrained only by his polio-induced limp, for his amazing Ford Prefect car which just managed to reach the city speed limit in top gear, and for his availability as adviser and counsellor.

As we shall see later, Bob was primarily responsible for setting up a number of structures and institutions critical to the future of Australian science. An early involvement was as secretary of the Australian National Research Council (ANRC) in 1952, when steps were taken to review the problems of Australian universities that in due course led to the formation of the Murray Committee and the subsequent transformation of the Australian university scene. He also played an important role in negotiations that led the ANRC, an organization with a somewhat chequered history, to make way for the foundation of the Australian Academy of Science in 1954. It was said of Bob that 'during meetings of the ANRC, only he was really familiar with all the business and he contributed greatly to the discussions'.[5]

Another initiative with which Bob was associated was the founding of the Australian Society of Plant Physiologists in 1958. After informal discussions with key colleagues, Bob wrote to a number of the leading physiologists of that time proposing that such a society be formed.[6] A draft constitution for the Society was drawn up by a group in the Plant Physiology Unit in Sydney headed by J.F. Turner and about 110 potential members were invited to the inaugural meeting of the Society held in August 1958 in Adelaide.

In late 1958 Bob accepted a visiting professorship at the University of California, Los Angeles. By this time he was numbered amongst the leaders in both research and speculation relating to the energetics of ion transport and accumulation in plant cells. His views were outlined in two important review articles (28, 32) and in book co-authored with G.E. Briggs and A.B. Hope (34) that appeared between 1957 and 1960.

While in the United States, Bob was asked if he would join the four-man Executive of CSIRO then headed by Sir Ian Clunies Ross. Bob reluctantly accepted this challenge, realising that it would seriously affect his research interests. He said 'I felt I owed it to the organisation to help where required, particularly since I had enjoyed such a satisfying research position'. This was the first of a number of instances where Bob undertook such responsibilities in the cause of science or public interest and at the expense of his research. In subsequently discussing such conflicts of interest he noted that 'research certainly flourishes best when the mind becomes filled, even obsessed, with the investigation'.[1]

After stopping in Cambridge on the way home from the United States to complete the book Electrolytes in Plants with Briggs and Hope, Bob joined the Executive of CSIRO in October 1959. At that time this organisation had a staff of more than 4,000. Research interests ranged from the most applied aspects of agriculture and secondary industry to the most esoteric basic research including astronomy. Bob saw the role of the Executive as being to serve the interests of the scientists at the coalface. But of course the Executive still had to deal with the Chiefs of Divisions, with politicians and with various outside bodies, and had the final say in the general direction of research and the allocation of funds.

The contacts Bob developed at that time, including the political ones, were very likely of great value in some of the activities and functions in which he was subsequently involved. Although Bob enjoyed serving science in this way it was not something he wished to make his life's work. So, after three years, he accepted the position of Professor and head of the Botany Department at the University of Adelaide.

By this time Bob's contributions to understanding the mechanism and energetics of active ion uptake were being widely recognised. Following his earlier election to the Fellowship of the Australian Academy of Science in 1954, he was elected to the Royal Society of London in 1961 and as a Foreign Associate of the United States National Academy of Sciences in the following year. Typically, he took a very active interest in the affairs of the Australian Academy of Science in those early years, serving as Secretary, Biological Sciences (1957–58) and as a member of Council (1961–62). Later, as detailed below, he was to serve as President.

Adelaide era (1962–1969)

Early in 1960, the University of Adelaide advertised the Chair of Botany rendered vacant by the death of Professor J.G. Wood. The Department was founded in 1912 and had had only two previous Professors, T.G.B. Osborn and J.G. Wood. Bob was invited to fill the chair with the understanding that, to complete his obligation to CSIRO as an Executive member, he would not take up the position until February 1962.

As soon as he took up the Adelaide position, Bob became actively engaged in first-year teaching and promoted the development of a Department that was active in research. Osborn had started ecological research and that tradition was still strong. Plant physiology, which had developed under Wood's influence, and phycology were also strong disciplines. Bob wanted to continue his research on ion transport but also to develop other areas. He expanded the Department's reputation in the physiology of ion transport by the appointment of Michael Pitman, introduced metabolic biochemistry with the appointment of Joe Wiskich, and established ecophysiology with the appointment of Russell Sinclair. He also took a keen interest in an arid zone vegetation reserve that was located on Koonamore station between Yunta and Lake Frome, established in 1925 by Osborn. An area of the sheep station had been fenced to exclude introduced animals such as sheep and rabbits, but not native animals. The intention was to study the regeneration of the vegetation inside the reserve and to compare it to the vegetation outside the protected area. Whilst much research and record keeping had been performed at Koonamore, it had become somewhat neglected in the few years before Bob's appointment. He resolved to restore it as a key research area. Annual photographic and data records were re-instituted and they persist to this day. It is the world's oldest arid zone research station with continuous records. Since it is located in a low-rainfall area, Bob was very interested in the water economy and efficiency of the plants native to the area. He instituted regular field trips to undertake ecophysiological experiments and a course in arid zone physiology for senior undergraduate students, which included a six-day practical session at Koonamore.

He enjoyed these excursions, finding time to lead his laboratory-bound colleagues, and visitors, to the Koonamore vegetation reserve. They recall guiding Bob's quite buoyant Mercedes across flooded creeks and that not all Bob's field projects achieved the expected outcomes. For instance, he had learned of possum problems in the Adelaide Botanic Gardens and was advised that possums were partial to mistletoes. He also knew mistletoes were adversely affecting trees at Koonamore. So began an experiment in biological control. The transported possums had absolutely no impact on the mistletoe at Koonamore. Moreover, there soon remained no trace of the possums, eagles and foxes having had a field day.

While Professor of Botany in the University of Adelaide, Bob came to play a key role in the development of the research capacity in Australia's university sector at a time when it was expanding most rapidly. Perhaps his most enduring role was in the creation of the Australian Research Grants Committee (ARGC) that survives today as the Australian Research Council. In April 1965, at the invitation of Senator (later Prime Minister) John Gorton, Minister in Charge of Commonwealth Activities in Education and Research, Bob accepted appointment as Chairman of a committee of ten academics, representing the natural sciences, engineering and the applied sciences, the humanities and the social sciences. Bob recalled Gorton, who knew his man, saying 'it will be a bloody awful job and I wouldn't advise you to take it, but I would be tremendously grateful if you would'. He served as Chairman until 1969. Until that time, Federal support for research had been largely channelled through CSIRO and the Institute of Advanced Studies at the Australian National University. The formation of the ARGC marked the turning point in research funding in Australian universities, from a system in which inadequate and largely State-derived resources were disbursed by Vice-Chancellors, to one based on competitive allocation of more generous Federal resources to individual researchers.

The creation of the ARGC was instrumental in releasing the intellectual potential of the nation's university sector at an early stage in its expansion. On the eve of the announcement of his appointment, Bob advised Senator Gorton that 'the panic among Vice-Chancellors was continuing' and reported 'I'll get cracking right away'. In the first year the Committee allocated resources to some 36% of 1001 applicants, using peer review principles tried and tested by the United States National Science Foundation, among others. The Committee 'concerned itself only with the quality of the project and of the investigator', and 'entirely disregarded the University status of the applicant, as distinct from his achievement and promise and significance of the specific project he had submitted'. Bob moved early to include CSIRO and industry representation on the Committee, and to establish triennial funding.

These principles of resource distribution were soon under assault. By the Committee's third anniversary, Malcolm Fraser, Australia's first Minister for Education and Science (and later Prime Minister), was asking 'would it be possible for your Committee to indicate areas in which it thought research would be of importance to Australia, thus giving a clear indication of the projects that, in your view, would be likely to receive support?' This request is annotated in Bob's hand as follows: 'This letter was not answered because the Minister agreed that our subsequent conversations on the subject were adequate'. Clearly, Bob was able to convince Fraser that the scientific merit of proposals should remain the first priority. This battle continues to the present day, many would say with diminishing success.

While in Adelaide Bob also became involved in discussions with the Victorian and South Australian Departments of Education about updating the school biology syllabus and textbooks. Following an approach to the AAS on this matter, he co-chaired an Academy committee with J.S. Turner of Melbourne, set up to supervise the creation of a new textbook and a new approach to teaching biology in Australian high schools. The resulting book, The Web of Life, went through three editions between 1967 and 1981 and sold over a million copies. This set the precedent for AAS-sponsored textbooks in chemistry, mathematics, geology and environmental science. At about the same time Bob also headed an ad hoc committee set up by the Australian Broadcasting Commission to look into educational television.

Some of his other projects took years of dedicated committee work. Bob was an early member (1962) of an AAS committee that conferred with CSIRO on the formation of a Museum of Australian Biology. This ultimately emerged in 1978 as the Australian Biological Resources Study (ABRS) in the Department of Science, with Bob as chairman of the Advisory Committee. Bob had also supported the Academy of Science in its project on the Australian flora in its early years, and had the satisfaction of handing over this project as a going concern in 1980 to ABRS. He was also the first chairman (1962) of the Australian Academy of Science Standing Committee on International Relations, formed to advise on the difficult issues of the rationalization of structures in the International Council of Scientific Unions and UNESCO. In this role he advocated, against opposition, that Australia must participate in the International Biological Program (IBP). Later, he achieved a coup in setting up an IBP committee convened by Sir Otto Frankel, initially a most strident critic of the program.[5]

In the latter part of his period in Adelaide, Bob wrote an important review (39) and his widely acclaimed book, Protons, Electrons, Phosphorylation and Active Transport (40). In his notes and records Bob draws attention to the distraction from research occasioned by the various committee activities that took him to Canberra so frequently. His students and colleagues, however, remember the extent to which he was able to keep his hand in research at the same time as he was building opportunities for others. Yet, these burgeoning responsibilities made it sensible to consider a permanent move to Canberra. He resigned from the Chair of Botany at Adelaide on 9 August 1969.

Canberra era (1969–1978)

Bob and Mary moved to Canberra in late 1969, after Bob accepted an invitation to become Master of University House, the original Faculty and graduate student 'college' at the Australian National University (ANU). This position went along with provision of laboratory space at the Research School of Biological Sciences (RSBS) and some research support. Bob was especially attracted by the opportunity for some uninterrupted research. University House had by then served its function in support of the nation's embryonic premier research university. As the second Master, he had to guide the transformation of the House into a financially self-sustaining entity and hospitality centre on campus, while retaining its collegial character. While moving the House in this direction, Bob became even more heavily involved in national scientific affairs, first as President of the AAS (1970–74) and later as second Director of the RSBS. He remained in Canberra until retirement in 1978.

As the President of AAS Bob found satisfaction in the completion of some long-standing goals and the initiation of some promising new endeavours. He saw the peak years of the Web of Life school biology project, the curriculum development that revolutionized the teaching of biology in Australia. He revived a Standing Committee on National Parks and Conservation, and nurtured relationships with the other Australian Academies to develop major interdisciplinary environmental conservation projects involving the Murray River basin and, later, the Botany Bay Project. During this period he was also joint leader of the delegation that initiated scientific exchanges with the People's Republic of China after the Cultural Revolution, a member of the Science Advisory Committee for the Australian Broadcasting Commission (1972-74) and a member of the first interim Advisory Committee for Science and Technology, set up in 1972 by the then Liberal Government. Changes of government saw such interim committees come and go and it was several years before its descendant, the Australian Science and Technology Council (ASTEC) was formally incorporated. As AAS President, Bob also solicited government support for a comprehensive survey of Australia's biological resources. Various interim bodies directed to this cause finally led to the official establishment of the government-funded Australian Biological Resources Study in 1978 (see below).

Still as President of the Academy in 1973, Bob presided over a very controversial period of assessment and recommendation with respect to continued French atmospheric nuclear testing in the Pacific. Frank Fenner[5] recalls that, during a crucial meeting of French and Australian scientists, a member of the Attorney General's Department passed a message to the chairman that if the scientists submitted a joint report it would be unacceptable to the Government. Fenner recorded that in response, 'The President asserted the Academy's independence by replying (rather sharply!) that the Academy was conducting this investigation and would do what it thought best'. In the event, separate reports were submitted, with the Academy report being positive in its condemnation of continued testing, on the ground that incompletely known effects of low radiation doses 'made it prudent to keep atmospheric radiation as low as possible'. The last atmospheric tests in the Pacific took place in July-August 1973.

Bob's career probably reached its greatest heights as second Director of the RSBS at the ANU. He took up the appointment in January 1973, a few months after the School moved into its new building, and retired in 1978. By then RSBS was an impressive institution moving from its foundation in 1967 under David Catcheside with 46 staff to an establishment with 290 staff on its tenth anniversary in 1977. Bob was again able to some extent to manage the distractions from research and lead by example, noting in the 1976 Annual Report that 'Directors of Research Schools do not get much time for research, so it is pleasing to note that the Bioenergetics Unit with which I am personally concerned has made considerable progress during the year'. His unit listed twelve projects in 1977, many involving collaborations with other groups, and he co-authored an important paper with N.K. Boardman on the link between charge separation, proton movement and ATPase reactions (44); a considerable achievement in austerity years when funding cuts consigned his carefully prepared plans for a Department of Membrane Biology, foreshadowed in his first Annual Report (1973), to the scrap heap.

Another important activity was Bob's 'bible class', the Membrane Discussion Group, which engaged researchers from all over the campus and from nearby CSIRO laboratories. It was a magnet that drew leading researchers to Canberra. Later, he produced an animated movie, A Vision of Membranes, which was shown at the 1976 International Congress of Biochemistry in Hamburg.

Bob's links to the ANU continued throughout his retirement. He served as Pro-Chancellor (1984–86) and made a point of commuting from his retirement home in Binalong to participate in the ANU-sponsored Robertson Symposia, named in his honour and held in RSBS. These were often timed to coincide with Bob's birthday and with the Australian Rules football Grand Final, the latter usually calling for an extended tea break on the Saturday afternoon of the meeting.

A busy retirement (1978–2001)

On reaching the mandatory retiring age of 65, Bob left his position as Director of the RSBS in 1978 and embarked on a very busy retirement. The Robertsons moved to Sydney where Bob was able to continue with his research interests as an honorary fellow in Michael Pitman's laboratory at the University of Sydney, especially looking at proton translocation by bacteriorhodopsin. During this time he was also writing his very popular book, The Lively Membranes, published in 1983 (52). Later, he pursued his ideas on the role of ubiquinone in proton transport in collaborative studies with B.A. Cornell and colleagues at the CSIRO Food Research Laboratories in Sydney (55, 56). Bob's interest in his field continued into the 1990s with a series of invited chapters and reviews focusing on reminiscences and historical aspects (57, 58, 104).

As a gesture to the fact that Bob was retired, he and Mary divided their time between Sydney and Mary's family farm at Binalong, south-west of Sydney. For Bob this meant a great deal of commuting to both Sydney and Canberra because, in addition to his scientific interests, he carried over into retirement several of his wide range of committee and related activities. Indeed, he also acquired some new ones, having never mastered the art of refusing. Bob recounts an occasion when a call was made to his secretary enquiring whether he could undertake a particular task and she immediately responded that he would. When the caller asked how she was so sure she replied, 'Because I have never known him to refuse'.

Amongst the more seriously demanding commitments that he carried over into retirement were his involvement as a member of the Australian Science and Technology Council, as the President and head of the organizing committee for the upcoming 13th International Botanical Congress, and as Chairman of both the ABRS Advisory Committee and the Editorial Board of Flora of Australia. His role in these activities is detailed below.

ASTEC was finally launched in 1977. This was after several earlier attempts to set up such an advisory body, in part thwarted by changes of government. Bob was a member of a precursor group set up by the Liberal government in 1972. Later, he was a member of the Syme Committee appointed by Prime Minister Malcolm Fraser to advise on the formation of a permanent science advisory body. Bob declined the invitation to chair the newly formed ASTEC when it was set up in 1977, but agreed to be deputy chairman. Bob commented that the work for this council turned out to be very demanding, taking up a large part of his retirement time over the following four years. Amongst his particular responsibilities was the chairmanship of a working party enquiring into marine science in Australia.

An overlapping responsibility was that of President and chairman of the organising committee of the 13th International Botanical Congress to be held in Sydney in 1981. Typically, Bob took this responsibility very seriously, as shown by the thick file amongst the documents in the Academy library. The very broad field covered by this particular Congress added to the difficulties. The Congress attracted more than 3,000 participants from 64 countries. In his remarks at the closing ceremony, Bob strongly endorsed his belief in the value of such large and broadly based congresses.

Bob was appointed chairman of the advisory committee for ABRS soon after he retired, serving from 1978 to 1981. This project evolved from earlier initiatives of the Australian Academy of Science, including its Fauna and Flora Committee set up as early as 1960. Bob was a member of that committee which was initially headed by M.J.D. White. Later, during Bob's tenure as President, the Academy proposed to Government that a comprehensive survey should be made of Australia's biological resources. After further meetings in 1973 with W.L. Morrison, the Minister for Science, the Government established ABRS. This body operated on an ad hoc basis until 1977 when ASTEC recommended it be set up on a permanent basis and suggested guidelines for its operation. ABRS was confirmed as a permanent body within the Department of Science in 1978.

Amongst the wide range of activities ABRS undertook was to assume responsibility for the preparation of a Flora of Australia. This particular project had its origins in an Academy of Science standing committee set up in 1972, during the time that Bob was President. He was also involved at that time in raising money from private sources to support the Flora project. Much later, in 1981, when ABRS assumed responsibility for the Flora project, Bob was appointed the first chairman of the editorial committee. It was during that time that the decisions and plans were made for the final implementation of this project.

Lest he be labelled as idle in his retirement, Bob also involved himself in several other activities. These included the Directorship of Earthwatch Australia (1980–85) and membership of the Science Advisory Board of the mining company CRA (1981–86). He was not only concerned with the big picture since he also served as treasurer of the Landcare group in the small rural community of Binalong.

By the early 1990s, Bob had shed many of these responsibilities and began to channel his energy in other directions. As already mentioned, there were invitations to write historical memoirs on his life and work. He was delighted when the Australian Society of Plant Physiologists honoured him with a named lecture, commencing in 1996. He also remained deeply concerned about prevailing social problems and injustices. Amongst the folders left at his Binalong home was one labelled 'A Fair Australia'. In it were notes, newspaper cuttings and drafts of dissertations relating to poverty, income inequities, youth unemployment, lawlessness, economic rationalism and the social consequences of these matters. It is clear that Bob struggled through several drafts, trying to define the problems and find solutions to them. He must have had in mind publishing these thoughts although apparently none of this reached the light of day.

Bob spent a good deal of time raising money to support what he regarded as important research areas, initially for projects at the University of Sydney. Later, he took a particular interest in the research of Professors Graham Cox and Frank Gibson and their group at the John Curtin School of Medical Research, ANU, on the mechanism of action of ATP synthase, the complex involved in biological energy production. Thanks to contributions from several influential friends, he was able to provide significant independent support for this project in its most creative years. One can trace the seminal molecular genetic contributions of this antipodean group to the recent direct evidence for rotary catalysis, so elegantly revealed by Japanese researchers. Bob is said to have all but danced in the street outside Binalong Post Office after opening the issue of Nature containing the crystallographic evidence from Cambridge that sealed a Nobel Prize in 1996.

During the last years of his life, Bob became preoccupied with the notion of modifying our use of sunlight by replacing plants with artificial photosynthetic systems. This involvement is worth recording here in some detail because it encapsulated the way he approached his life's endeavours. Here in his mid-eighties and with a diagnosed terminal illness, it was clear that he had lost none of the focus, zeal, imagination, lateral thinking and intellectual boldness that were evident throughout his career.

Bob's interest in this area was stirred initially by a report in 1998 of light-driven synthesis of ATP, the universal prime source of biochemical energy, in an artificial membrane system. He recognised the essential inefficiency of using plants as a source of food and other raw materials. With that in mind, he began to think about artificial systems that might be designed to generate some of these products. The aim was to free arable land for other purposes and to conserve water, so much of which is lost during plant growth.

There followed a concentrated effort to collect relevant information, to discuss these issues with colleagues and to formulate his ideas in a series of draft documents. These documents, together with other notes, records of meetings, workshops, correspondence and related activities were collected in a file in his Binalong office. Professors John Andrews, Jan Anderson and Barry Osmond were amongst the Canberra colleagues with whom he discussed these matters.

About this time a group at CSIRO's Division of Telecommunications and Industrial Physics in Sydney had quite independently begun serious considerations about the options for artificial photosynthesis. After some informal contacts between the physicists and the biologists, a meeting of interested parties was convened in Canberra in August 1999 to pursue these issues further. Bob was invited to open the meeting (in a wheelchair – he had just broken his hip in a fall!)

Bob continued to think about how to proceed with the project, especially in collaboration with John Andrews at ANU and Vijoleta Brach-Maksvytis from the CSIRO laboratory. Soon after, the project was supported by postdoctoral appointments in both the CSIRO laboratory and at ANU. Further workshops were organised and the Australian Artificial Photosynthesis Network was officially formed.

Amongst other things, Bob assumed responsibility for raising financial support for the developing research effort. In a final move in that direction, a meeting was arranged with the Chief Scientist, Dr Robin Batterham, at Bob's home in Yass. This was held on the morning of the day he entered hospital, virtually for the last time. Some measure of Bob's commitment to this cause can be gauged from a comment he made in a prior letter to the Chief Scientist. He wrote, 'I am not afraid of losing whatever reputation I may have. I hope that someone may be stimulated by my thoughts – right or wrong – and some revolutionary changes might follow'.

The Artificial Photosynthesis Group has now expanded, incorporating inputs from other Australian laboratories. Recently, the United States Ambassador to Australia convened a meeting to explore possible collaborations with interested groups in the United States and there are moves afoot to apply for a Centre of Excellence grant focused on this topic. Bob would have been delighted by these events.

Science – research and philosophy

The foregoing includes some account of the remarkable range of activities Bob undertook in the cause of science as well as some details of his research interests and contributions. These research interests were broad and varied but included one particular topic that remained his lifelong concern. It is on this topic, the energetics of inorganic ion uptake by plant cells, that we shall focus here. For more details, we refer the reader to two of Bob's own accounts of his involvement in this field (57, 58).

As already related, Bob's interest in ion uptake had its origins in his PhD studies with G.E. Briggs at Cambridge. There he set about looking at the link between the uptake of inorganic ions (KCl) by root tissue and the associated respiration of that tissue. His studies clearly confirmed a close link between ion uptake and release of respiratory CO2. At that time it had been suggested by others that this link between respiration and ion uptake was due to the respiratory carbon dioxide forming bicarbonate ions (HCO3-) and protons (H[+]) which could then support uptake by exchanging for the salt ions. Bob disproved this hypothesis by showing that the rate of carbon dioxide output could be greatly enhanced at the same time as salt accumulation was inhibited. He did this by adding methylene blue to the tissue (see Ref. 58). As we now know, the pyridine nucleotides reduced in respiratory metabolism would chemically reduce the methylene blue, which is then spontaneously oxidized by molecular oxygen.

Bob's thinking about the link between salt uptake and respiration was greatly influenced by an idea published by Henrick Lundegardh in Nature in 1938. This paper suggested that the accumulation of ions may be related to the movement of electrons along the cytochrome chain. Bob appeared to accept this redox hypothesis and even wrote a letter to Nature in support of this view and defending Lundegardh's ideas against some published criticisms (2). He also believed that if one properly understood a process, one should be able to make predictions – especially quantitative ones. He predicted that, since four electrons were required to reduce a molecule of oxygen, four anions should be moved at the same time. That is, the ratio of g.equivalents of salt uptake /g.mole of oxygen absorbed should be equal to four. Later he and Marjorie Wilkins provided evidence demonstrating a ratio close to four (10). Other studies using the inhibitor carbon monoxide (15) clearly established the role of cytochrome oxidase in both salt uptake and salt-induced respiration. At that time cytochromes were known only in mitochondria and chloroplasts, and cytochrome oxidase only in mitochondria, so they reasonably focused on mitochondria.

In the early 1950s, Bob proposed that 'the mitochondria in the intact cell, capable of accumulating anions themselves, could act as vehicles for the passage of ions from cell-surface to vacuole' (17). However, when he subsequently showed that uncouplers (such as 2, 4 dinitrophenol) could increase the rate of oxygen uptake and hence electron flow, but completely inhibit the rate of ion uptake, he realised that his simple hypothesis for linking the two processes had to be modified (16). Through much of the 1950s the research of Bob's group remained largely directed to the respiratory features, morphology and basic ionic relations of mitochondria isolated from plant tissue, including their favoured laboratory material, red beetroot. In studies more directly linked to active ion uptake, they examined the kinetics of ion equilibration with mitochondria and provided evidence for a link between increased chloride ion content and the rate of oxygen uptake (22, 23).

In 1960 Bob published a review in which he tried to summarize the conflicting views on respiratory electron transport and phosphorylation (32). By then there was general agreement about the effects of uncouplers but not about the mechanism of these effects. At this stage he might have linked salt uptake directly to the turnover of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) but instead he suggested other possibilities. Critical to these was the proposal that the separation of positive and negative charge might be a fundamental process of the respiratory electron transport chain that resides in the inner membrane of mitochondria. Bob suggested that this charge separation might then lead to either active uptake of ions or the phosphorylation of ADP to ATP, these processes being alternatives. This was a very novel idea. It was in line with, but preceded, Peter Mitchell's hypothesis of a chemiosmosis process involved in mitochondrial energy transduction, leading to the formation of ATP. However, in developing this theory Bob remained focused on the anion, because it was the accumulation of this species that was thought to be energy-dependent in plant tissues. By contrast, Mitchell's hypothesis focused on protons. Bob later admitted, 'I did not have enough insight to suggest that the breakdown of ATP might bring about charge separation and hence ion movement – but Mitchell did' (57).

Bob's charge separation ideas (32) may have had some influence on Mitchell's formulation of the chemiosmotic hypothesis. Bob's account of his correspondence with Mitchell (58) is a masterpiece of generosity. Certainly, the insights of the 'man from Australia' were highlighted by André Jagendorf at the 1964 International Congress of Biochemistry in New York, when he revealed the first and neatest demonstration of chemiosmosis in action (see Ref. 58). Jagendorf's team used light energy to pump protons across chloroplast thylakoid membranes, and demonstrated that this proton gradient could phosphorylate ADP in the dark.[7] Jagendorf's Congress presentations attributed concepts to Lundegardh and Robertson which, at that time, were not appreciated outside plant biochemical circles.

It was not surprising that Bob readily accepted Mitchell's ideas, but he was surprised that others did not (58). His related studies both before (22, 23, 25) and after (36, 37) this time showed that isolated plant mitochondria could accumulate ions and that this process was an alternative to ATP synthesis, but with ATP synthesis being favoured over ion uptake. He extended these studies with carrot root tissues provided with oligomycin to inhibit the mitochondrial enzyme that produces ATP, and measured ATP levels and rates of salt uptake into the tissue (38). He concluded that 'the best hypothesis to explain the observations is that the ion transport mechanism in this tissue is directly coupled to the electron transport system. It does not require the intervention of ATP and may be an alternative to ATP formation'. Later, the situation was confused for some time by reports of a cytochrome system in the plasma membrane (see Ref. 57).

In 1968 Bob published a book (40) in which he outlined his thoughts on oxidative phosphorylation and active ion transport and tried to demystify the essentials of Mitchell's hypothesis and expose its elegant simplicity. This book was well received generally and by Mitchell in particular (see Ref. 58). By the mid-1970s Bob was becoming much more interested in the nature of the membranes themselves. At that time he was invited to give the Burnet Lecture to the Australian Academy of Science, which he entitled 'Molecules, Membranes and Imagination'. In this lecture he attempted to give some idea of the nature, complexity and functions of living membranes; in particular, he wanted to portray the notion of molecular movements within membranes. He extended this idea by producing a short film (A Vision of Membranes) to demonstrate this motion (110) and later wrote a book on the subject entitled The Lively Membranes (52). He largely concentrated on the phospholipids in these works. Only later was the importance of hydrophobic a-helices of membrane proteins and their role in energy transduction fully recognised.

While he was still focusing on the membrane phospholipids in the mid- 1970s, one of Bob's ideas was that the zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine could bind with H[+] and Cl- ions at the membrane-water interface. Once neutral in overall charge, this complex could become buried deeper in the lipophilic layer where the H[+] and Cl- may combine to form free HCl in this anhydrous environment. Then, on diffusing to the other side of the membrane, the HCl could dissolve to form H[+] and Cl- again. He discussed this and related ideas based on the 'flip- flop' ion carrier hypothesis in several forums. Notably, when these ideas were put to Peter Mitchell he was less than enthusiastic. Bob also recounted details of correspondence and discussions he had with Mitchell about this and other matters over more than a decade (58). These ideas, centring on a critical role for HCl in proton transport, appeared in papers published with N.K. Boardman in 1975 (44) and T.E. Thompson in 1977 (48).

Later, in retirement, Bob became interested in ubiquinone and its movement within the membrane, especially with respect to its possible role in translocating protons out of the mitochondrial matrix. In particular, if ubiquinone was sufficiently mobile in the membrane lipid, it could eliminate the need for a smaller proton carrier such as HCl. NMR spectral studies and neutron diffraction studies, conducted in the laboratory of B.A. Cornell, indicated that the bulk of the membrane plastoquinone was aggregated in a separate phase not intercalated with or constrained by the membrane bilayer lipid chains (55, 56). This left the question of the need for a smaller proton carrier unresolved.

Shortly after this, Bob suffered a heart attack and decreased his involvement in active research. However, as already mentioned, he remained an enthusiastic promoter and supporter of the research being undertaken by others, especially younger scientists.

RNR – the person

As Barry Osmond so aptly said in an obituary, 'Descending from a long line of ministers of religion, Bob's tolerance, unselfishness and unswerving sense of duty is legendary'. In attempting to expand on these sentiments there is a risk of appearing trite. In fact, much of the picture will have emerged from the foregoing. Perhaps a few random comments and anecdotes will suffice to fill the gaps and round out the picture.

As already mentioned, there was a strong thread throughout Bob's life of social awareness and activism. Quite early in life he was convinced that he wanted to have a hand, in his own words, 'in the development of science as a social force'. Many of his lectures and articles on these matters have already been mentioned as well as his involvement in organizations such as the Association of Scientific Workers, first in Britain and then in Australia. Referring to Bob's election as Chairman of the Australian body in 1942, a major newspaper of that time, Smith's Weekly, welcomed this move under the headline 'Youth at the Helm' and described Bob as 'essentially human, a breezy Australian personality with a ready instinct for a smile rather than a frown. He is no sombre ponderer. Rather, he is an alert thinker, quick, logical and an eager advocate of the doctrine that science should not start and end in the laboratory but should be applied to all social questions and to every day living'. These views extended to Bob's teaching. For instance, graduate students at Adelaide during Bob's time there found themselves reading C.P. Snow as a background to discussions on The Two Cultures. Other authors such as J. Bronowski (Science and Human Values) also found their way on to graduate student bookshelves.

It is relevant here to recall an incident that occurred during the early days of the Second World War. Dr Victor Trikojus, a colleague of Bob's at the University of Sydney, was interned in Long Bay Gaol on charges of being a Nazi sympathiser. This was apparently the result of a malicious testimony relating to some prior association with German scientists. In a move showing considerable moral fortitude considering the times, Bob, with a small group of colleagues, testified in court on Trikojus' behalf and finally secured his release. Later, Trikojus was to make important contributions to the war effort and became head of the Biochemistry Department at the University of Melbourne, for many years the pre-eminent Biochemistry Department in Australia.

Bob and Mary made a vast array of lifelong friendships. For instance, Kathleen Wall, a friend of Mary's from the first-year Botany class of 1933, recalls meetings with Bob and Mary, and others from that class, during the Robertsons' regular visits to Sydney up until the late 1990s. In the later years of retirement there was a constant stream of visitors to the Robertsons' home in Yass, a reflection of how their friendship was valued. In one case, by arrangement with the Royal Botanic Gardens in Sydney, the visit was accompanied by a living specimen of the Wollemi pine. This was the famous 'living fossil' then only recently discovered in Australia and still held under very tight security. Such friendships were generated by a genuine warmth and consideration for people nicely illustrated by the first meeting of one of us (CBO) with Bob in 1962. This Honours student from a small regional university was encouraged to send a draft of his first research paper to Professor R.N. Robertson, recently moved to the University of Adelaide who, it was thought, might be willing to take him on for a PhD. A few weeks later, as that student was trying to find his way about the campus of the University of Sydney to register for his first-ever scientific meeting, a car slowed to a halt at the curb. The driver leaned across and extended his hand saying 'Bob Robertson. You must be Barry Osmond. I've looked over your paper and here are a few suggestions', all neatly penned in red ink.

In his spare time Bob was an avid reader and dabbled in watercolour painting. Despite his 'polio leg' he played hockey, captaining the Sydney University second grade team for many years. He is also remembered by colleagues and students from the Plant Physiology Unit days in the 1950s as a wily squash player. In later life, especially during his Adelaide and Canberra years, he returned to a boyhood love of horse riding. During these years Bob said his riding technique was transformed from that of an 'Australian bush rider' to that of 'the European schools of dressage'. He loved the challenge of training young horses to understand the subtle body language of the rider. This was at the expense of twice breaking his leg in riding accidents.

Throughout a remarkably busy and very influential life in science, Bob gained a reputation for his willingness to 'go the extra mile', for his fair-mindedness, his generosity, and his concern for friends and colleagues in all walks of life. He was equally at ease with Prime Ministers and just-hired laboratory assistants or cleaners. He had a personality and management style not common amongst those who took on the responsibilities and undertakings that he did. Interestingly, the only substantial criticism of Bob's personality that we are aware of is that he was not sufficiently tough or ruthless, especially with those of obvious ill will.

How would Bob like to be remembered? He put it simply and directly,[3] as was his wont. 'Perhaps, if it's not too much', he wrote 'to be known as a generous man, who, despite human failings, talked sense and occasionally showed signs of wisdom'.

Bob died in Yass, New South Wales, on 5 March 2001. A sad and unexpected addendum to this story is that his wife, lifelong companion and confidante, Mary, died soon afterwards. They are survived by their son Robert, his wife Jan, and two grandchildren, Andrew and Claire.

Degrees, honours and awards

Degrees

  • B.Sc. (Hons) (Sydney, 1934)
  • Ph.D. (Cambridge, 1939)
  • D.Sc. (Sydney, 1961)

Honorary Degrees

  • D.Sc. (ad eundem gradum) Adelaide, 1963
  • D.Sc. (Hon. Caus.) Tasmania, 1965
  • Sc.D. (Hon. Caus.) Cambridge, 1969
  • D.Sc. (Hon. Caus.) Monash, Melbourne, 1970
  • D.Sc. (Hon. Caus.) ANU, Canberra, 1974

Public honours

  • Companion of the Order of St. Michael and St. George, 1968
  • Knight Bachelor, 1972
  • Companion of the Order of Australia, 1980

Elected fellowships and memberships

  • Corresponding Member, American Society of Plant Physiologists, 1953
  • Fellow, Australian Academy of Science, 1954
  • Fellow, Royal Society of London, 1961
  • Foreign Associate, U.S. National Academy of Sciences, 1962
  • Foreign Member, American Philosophical Society, 1971
  • Honorary Member, Royal Society of New Zealand, 1971
  • Honorary Fellow, St. John's College Cambridge, 1973
  • Honorary Fellow, University House, ANU, 1973
  • Foreign Honorary Member, American Academy of Arts & Sciences, 1973
  • Honorary Fellow, Royal Society of Edinburgh, 1983
  • Honorary Member, Australian Society for Biophysics, 1986
  • Honorary Fellow, Royal Society of New South Wales, 1986
  • Honorary Fellow, Australian Institute of Biology, 1987

Medals and special lectures

  • Clarke Memorial Medal, Royal Society of New South Wales, 1954
  • Kearney Foundation Lecturer, University of California, Berkeley, 1959
  • Macleay Memorial Lecturer, Linnaean Society of New South Wales, 1962
  • Farrer Memorial Medal and Lecture, 1963
  • A.E. Mills Orator, Royal Australasian College of Physicians, 1966
  • ANZAAS Medal, 1968
  • Mueller Medal, Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science, 1970
  • Bertrand Russell Lecturer, Flinders University, 1971
  • J.G. Wood Memorial Lecturer, Australian Society of Plant Physiologists, 1971
  • Oscar Mendelsohn Lecturer, Monash University, 1973
  • Macleay Memorial Lecturer, Linnaean Society of New South Wales, 1974
  • Burnet Lecture and Medal, Australian Academy of Science, 1975
  • Three Societies Lecturer (The Royal Society of London, The Royal Society of Edinburgh, The Royal Irish Academy), 1988

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 14(4), 2003. It was written by:

  • Marshall D. Hatch, Honorary Fellow, CSIRO Plant Industry, Canberra, Australia.
  • Barry (C.B.) Osmond, President, Biosphere 2 Center, Columbia University, USA.
  • Joseph T. Wiskich, Professor, School of Biological Sciences, Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia.

Numbers in brackets refer to the bibliography.

Acknowledgments

We are indebted to Rosanne Walker for her help including word processing and to Bob Robertson's son Robert for assistance in our research.

References

  1. Personal records of Rutherford Robertson submitted to the Royal Society in 1991. Copy held by the Australian Academy of Science
  2. Transcript of an interview of Sir Rutherford Robertson by Dr Max Blythe for the Australian Academy of Science, 1993
  3. Robertson, R.N. A dilettante Australian plant physiologist. Annual Review of Plant Physiology and Molecular Biology 43, 1-24 (1992)
  4. Robertson, R.N. Charge separation: A personal involvement in a fundamental biological process. Comprehensive Biochemistry 38, 303-347 (1995)
  5. Fenner, F. (Editor). The Australian Academy of Science: The First Forty Years. (Canberra: Australian Academy of Science, 1995)
  6. Neales, T. 'Origin and early years of ASPP Inc.' Published by the Australian Society of Plant Physiologists in the Directory of Members (Canberra: ASPP, 1994)
  7. Jagendorf, A.T. and Uribe, E. ATP formation caused by acid base transition of spinach chloroplasts. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. (USA) 55, 170-177 (1966)

Bibliography

Salt accumulation, plant respiration and membranes

  1. 1939 Ion Absorption in Plant Tissue. PhD Dissertation, University of Cambridge
  2. 1940 Salt Accumulation and Plant Respiration. Nature 145, 937
  3. 1941 Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 1: Accumulation of Chlorides by Plant Cells and its Relation to Respiration. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci. 19, 265-78
  4. 1944 Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 2: Effects of Temperature on Accumulation of Potassium Chloride and on Respiration. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci. 22, 237-45
  5. 1945 (With J.S. Turner) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 3: Effects of Cyanide on the Accumulation of Potassium Chloride and Respiration; the Nature of the Salt Respiration. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci. 23, 63-73
  6. Scientific Method in the Evolution of New Drugs. Part 10: The Cell Surface and Drug Action. Aust. J. Sci. 7, 112-18
  7. 1946 (With M. Thorn) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 4: Reversibility of Salt Respiration. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci. 23, 305-309
  8. 1947 (With J.S. Turner and M.J. Wilkins) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 5: Salt Respiration and Accumulation in Red Beet Tissue. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci. 25: 1-8
  9. 1948 (With J. Milthorpe) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 6: Salt Respiration and Accumulation in Barley Roots. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci. 26, 189-197
  10. (With M.J. Wilkins) Quantitative Relation between Salt Accumulation and Salt Respiration. Nature 161, 101
  11. (With M.J. Wilkins) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 7: The Quantitative Relation between Salt Accumulation and Salt Respiration. Aust. J. Sci. Res. (B) 1, 17-37
  12. (With G.E. Briggs) Diffusion and Absorption in Disks of Plant Tissue. New Phytol. 47, 265-283
  13. 1950 The Absorption of Ions by Plants. School Science Review 31, 377-388
  14. The Last Haunts of Demons – A Comparative Study of Secretion and Accumulation. Presidential Address, Proc. Linn. Soc. NSW 75, 1-20
  15. (With D.C. Weeks) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 8: Dependence of Salt Accumulation and Salt Respiration upon the Cytochrome System. Aust. J. Sci. Res. (B) 3, 487-500
  16. 1951 (With M.J. Wilkins and D.C. Weeks). Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 9: Effects of 2,4-Dinitrophenol on Salt Accumulation and Salt Respiration. Aust. J. Sci. Res. (B) 4, 248-264. (Read by M.J. Wilkins at International Botanical Congress, Stockholm, 1950)
  17. Mechanism of Absorption and Transport of Inorganic Nutrients in Plants. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. 2, 1-24
  18. 1953 (With A.B. Hope) Bioelectric Experiments and the Properties of Plant Protoplasm. Aust. J. Sci. 15, 197-203
  19. (With J.L. Farrant and M.J. Wilkins) The Mitochondrial Membrane. Nature 171, 401-402
  20. 1954 Structure and Function within Plant Cells. Presidential Address, Section M. ANZAAS Canberra Meeting Report, 223-239
  21. 1955 The Struggle against Equilibrium – a Physico-chemical Problem in Life. Address to the Royal Society of New Zealand Congress. Trans. Roy. Soc. NZ 82, 851-859
  22. (With M.J. Wilkins, A.B. Hope and L. Nestel) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 10: Respiratory Activity and Ionic Relations of Plant Mitochondria. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 8, 164-185
  23. (With M.J. Wilkins and A.B. Hope) Plant Mitochondria and Salt Accumulation. Nature 175, 640
  24. 1956 Mechanism of Absorption by Plant Cells. Chapter IV in Vol. II, International Encyclopedia of Plant Physiology, 449-467. (Springer, Berlin)
  25. (With S.I. Honda) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 11: The Donnan Equilibration and the Ionic Relations of Plant Mitochondria. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 9, 305-320
  26. (With A.B. Hope) Initial Absorption of Ions by Plant Tissue. Nature 177, 43-44
  27. (With J.L. Farrant, C. Potter and M.J. Wilkins) The Morphology of Red Beet (Beta Vulgaris L.) Mitochondria. Aust. J. Bot. 4, 117-124
  28. 1957 Electrolytes in Plant Tissue. Endeavour 16, 193-198
  29. (With G.E. Briggs) Apparent Free Space. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. 8, 11-30
  30. The Uptake of Minerals. Chapter IV B in Vol. IV, International Encyclopedia of Plant Physiology 243-279. (Springer, Berlin)
  31. (With S.I. Honda and J.M. Gregory) Studies in the Metabolism of Plant Cells. Part 12: Ionic Effects on Oxidation of Reduced Diphosphopyridine Nucleotide and Cytochrome C by Plant Mitochondria. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 11, 1-15
  32. 1960 Ion Transport and Respiration. Biol. Rev. 35, 231-264
  33. (With J.T. Wiskich and R.K. Morton) Respiratory Chain of Beetroot Mitochondria. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 13, 109-122
  34. 1961 (With G.E. Briggs and A.B. Hope) Electrolytes and Plant Cells. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications, 212 pp.
  35. 1962 Living Membranes – Frontiers of Research at the Boundaries of Life. Sir William Macleay Memorial Lecture. Proc. Linn. Soc. NSW 87, 267-274
  36. 1964 (With D.L. Millard and J.T. Wiskich) Ion Uptake by Plant Mitochondria. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 52, 996-1004
  37. (With D.L. Millard and J.T. Wiskich) Ion Uptake and Phosphorylation in Mitochondria: Effect of Monovalent Ions. Plant Physiol. 40, 1129-1135
  38. 1966 (With M.R. Atkinson, G. Eckermann and M. Grant) Salt Accumulation and Adenosine Triphosphate in Carrot Xylem Tissue. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 55, 560-564
  39. 1967 The Separation of Protons and Electrons as a Fundamental Biological Process. Endeavour 26, 134-139
  40. 1968 Protons, Electrons, Phosphorylation and Active Transport. Cambridge University Press, 96 pp.
  41. 1970 Second impression of Ref. 40
  42. 1971 Proten, Electronen, Phosphorylierung, Activer Transport. (German translation of Ref. 40). Munich: William Goldman
  43. 1975 Molecules, Membranes and Imagination (Burnet Lecture). Records Aust. Acad. Sci. 3, 88-111
  44. (With N.K. Boardman) The Link between Charge Separation, Proton Movement and ATPase Reactions. FEBS Letters 60, 1-6
  45. 1976 A Vision of Membranes, in Biological Recognition, ed. R.B. Knox and A.E. Clarke, University of Melbourne, 27-31
  46. Energy Transformations in Biological Processes, in International Year Book, Science and Humanity, ed. E. Etingof, Znaie Publishing House, Moscow
  47. 1977 (With W.P. Anderson and B.J. Wright) Electropotentials in Carrot Root Cells. Aust. J. Plant Physiol. 4, 241-252
  48. (With T.E. Thompson). The Function of Phospholipid Polar Groups in Membranes. FEBS Letters 76, 16-19
  49. 1978 (With F.L. Bygrave and C. Ramachandran) The Interaction of Tributyltin with the Mitochondrial Calcium Transport System of the Rat Liver. Archiv. Biochem. and Biophys. 188, 301-307
  50. Membrane Energy Transduction. BioMembrane News, Biomembrane Committee, CSIRO 9, 14-16
  51. Charge Separation, Proton Pumps and the Hydrophobic Region of Bilayer Membranes, in Light Transducing Membranes, ed. D.W. Deamer, Academic Press, 215-231
  52. 1983 The Lively Membranes. Cambridge University Press, 206 pp.
  53. 1984 With A. Post and S.E. Young) Light- induced Proton Translocation by Bacteriorhodopsin at the Interface of an Octane-in-water Emulsion and Inhibition by a Retinotoxin. Photobiochem. and Photobiophys. 8, 153-162
  54. 1986 Purple Pigment, Bacteria, Sheep's Eyes and Serendipity. Proc. Amer. Philosophical Soc. 130, 374-381
  55. 1987 (With B.A. Cornell, M.A. Keniry, A. Post, L.E. Weir and P.W. Westerman) Location and Activity of Ubiquinone 10 and Ubiquinone Analogues in Model and Biological Membranes. Biochem. 26, 7702-7707
  56. 1990 (With B.A. Cornell, M.A. Keniry, R. Knott, A. Post, F. Separovic, L.E. Weir and P.W. Westerman) Localization of Ubiquinone in Membranes by NMR and Neutron Diffraction. Proc. Internat. Symposium 'Biochemistry, Bioenergetics and Clinical Applications of Ubiquinone', 27-32
  57. 1991 Early days of Oxidoreduction and Transport Hypotheses in Oxidoreduction at the Plasma Membrane: Relation to Growth and Transport Vol. 2, eds. F.L. Crane, D.J. Morré and H.E. Löw, CRC Press, 1-19
  58. 1995 Charge Separation: A Personal Involvement in a Fundamental Biological Process. Comprehensive Biochemistry 38, 303-348

Fruit physiology, biochemistry and storage

  1. 1944 (With S.A. Trout, E.G. Hall, F.V. Hackney and S.M. Sykes) Studies in the Metabolism of Apples. Part 1: Preliminary Investigations on Internal Gas Composition and its Relation to Changes in Stored Granny Smith Apples. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci. 20, 219-226
  2. 1949 (With D. Martin) Plant Growth Substances Related to Problems of Fruit and Vegetable Storage. Food Preservation Quarterly 9, 37-40
  3. 1950 Fruit Storage and Plant Physiological Research. Food Preservation Quarterly 10, 25
  4. 1951 (With J M Bain) The Physiology of Growth in Apple Fruits. Part 1: Cell Size, Cell Number and Fruit Development. Aust. J. Sci. Res. (B) 4, 75-91
  5. (With J.F. Turner) The Physiology of Growth in Apple Fruits. Part 2: Respiratory and other Metabolic Activities as Functions of Cell Number and Cell Size in Fruit Development. Aust. J. Sci. Res. (B) 4, 92-107
  6. 1952 (With J.A. Pearson) The Climacteric Rise in Respiration. Aust. J. Sci. 15, 99-100
  7. The Cooling of Fruits: Fruits as Living Organs. Refrigeration Journal 5, 9-16
  8. 1953 (With J.A. Pearson) The Physiology of Growth in Apple Fruits. Part 4: Seasonal Variation in Cell Size, Nitrogen Metabolism and Respiration in Developing Granny Smith Apple Fruits. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 6, 1-20
  9. 1954 (With J.A. Pearson) The Physiology of Growth in Apple Fruits. Part 6: The Control of Synthesis and Respiration Rate. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 7, 1-17
  10. (With J.A. Pearson) The Control of Respiration and Synthesis in Apple Fruits. Paper at 8th International Botanical Congress.
  11. 1955 Plant Physiological Research and Food Technology. Food Preservation Quarterly 15, 22-25
  12. (With H.S. McKee and J.B. Lee) The Physiology of Pea Fruits. Part 1: The Developing Fruit. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 8, 137-162
  13. (With H.S. McKee and L. Nestel) The Physiology of Pea Fruits. Part 2: Soluble Nitrogenous Constituents in the Developing Fruit. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 8, 467-475
  14. 1957 (With J.F. Turner) Changes in Developing Pea Seeds. Inter-Laboratory Symposium on the Maturation and Germination of Peas, Cambridge
  15. (With D. Martin) Apple Storage in Australia. J. Inst. Agric. Sci. Aust. 23, 183-188
  16. 1958 (With K.S. Rowan and H.K. Pratt) Relationship of High Energy Phosphate Content, Protein Synthesis and Climacteric Rise in the Respiration of Ripening Avocado and Tomato Fruits. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 11, 329-335
  17. 1959 (With M.D. Hatch, A. Millerd and J.A. Pearson) Oxidation of Krebs Cycle Acids by Tissue Slices and Cytoplasmic Particles from Apple Fruit. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 12, 157-174
  18. 1961(With H.R. Highkin, J. Smydzuk and F.W. Went) The Effect of Environmental Conditions on the Development of Pea Seeds. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 14, 1-15
  19. 1963(With J.F. Turner) The Biochemistry of Ripening Fruits in Connection with their Storage. Proc. 5th Internat. Congr. Biochem. 8, 154-160
  20. (With S. Ben-Yehosua and J.B. Biale) Respiration and Internal Atmosphere of Avocado Fruit. Plant Physiol. 38, 194-201

Stored wheat

  1. 1948 (With J. Milthorpe) Heating in Stored Wheat. Part 1: Respiration of Dry Grain, Insect Respiration and Temperature and Moisture Effects. CSIR Bulletin 237, 9-17
  2. Heating in Stored Wheat. Part 2: Heat Production, Heat Conductivity and Temperature Rise in Grain in the Presence and Absence of Insects. CSIR Bulletin 237, 18-29
  3. (With J. Milthorpe) Heating in Stored Wheat. Part 3: Two years' Temperature Records of Dry Grain in a Concrete Silo. CSIR Bulletin 237, 30-35

Ecology

  1. 1939 (With T.G.B. Osborn) A Reconnaissance Survey of the Vegetation of the Myall Lakes. Proc. Linn. Soc. NSW 64, 279-296

Scientific articles

  1. 1940 Potassium in Plants. Symposium Potassium Roy. Soc. NSW 24-25
  2. 1942 Photosynthesis (a review). Aust. J. Sci. 4, 150-151
  3. The Teaching of the Sciences in the University: The Method. Aust. J. Sci. 5, 53-55
  4. 1958 Photosynthesis. Sydney University Current Affairs Bulletin 22, 83-96

Science, society, government, etc.

  1. 1944 The Future of Scientific Research in Australia. Sydney University Union Recorder, April
  2. 1949 Biology and the World's Food Crisis. Sydney University Union Recorder, September
  3. 1951 Science in the Community. Sydney University Current Affairs Bulletin 8, 179-192
  4. 1964 Phytotrons, Spectrophotometers and Productivity. Farrer Memorial Oration. Aust. J. Sci. 26, 313-317
  5. 1965 Science and Leadership in Democracy. Presidential Address, ANZAAS. Aust. J. Sci. 28, 100-104
  6. 1966 From the Temples of Aesculapius to the Genetic Code. The A.E. Mills Oration. (Royal Australasian College of Physicians). Med. J. Aust. 2, 625-629
  7. 1969 Research and progress. Proc. 4th Aust. Computer Conference, Adelaide, 613-616
  8. 1971 Science: Its Scope and Limits. Second Bertrand Russell Memorial Lecture. Flinders University Science Association.
  9. How Good is Science? Annal. Aust. College of Dental Surgeons 3, 14-18
  10. 1972 Scientists and Government in Australia. Impact of Science on Society 22, 187-196
  11. 1973 The Future of Science in Universities and Colleges of Advanced Education. Search 4, 182-185
  12. Funding and Control of Australian Science. Nature 246, 252-254
  13. 1974 Survival – Science or Superstition. Third Oscar Mendelsohn Lecture. Search 5, 191-197
  14. 'A Society of Natural History – I hope they may succeed': The first hundred years. Sir William Macleay Memorial Lecture. Proc. Linn. Soc. NSW. 99, 69-78
  15. 1977Keynote Address, Eighth Triennial Conference, Australian Institute of Foresters. Australian Forestry 40, 243-254
  16. 1981President's Remarks: Closing Ceremony. Proceedings, XIII International Botanical Congress, 45-46
  17. 1989The Three Societies Lecture: 'Penal Settlement to High Technology and the Future'. Published on behalf of the Royal Society of London, the Royal Society of Edinburgh and the Royal Irish Academy, by the Royal Society of Edinburgh. 10 pp.
  18. 1992 A Dilettante Australian Plant Physiologist. Prefatory Chapter. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. & Plant Molec. Biol. 43, 1-24

Memoirs

  1. 1978 (With J. Barrett) Max Rudolph Lemberg. Rec. Aust. Acad. Sci. 4, 131-156
  2. 1985 (With F.V. Mercer) Obituaries: George Edward Briggs. The Eagle 70, 56-58
  3. 1986 George Edward Briggs 1893-1985. Biograph. Mem. Fellows Roy. Soc. 32, 36-64
  4. 1996 (With H.C. Minnett) Frederick William George White 1905-1994. Hist. Rec. Aust. Sci. 11 (2), 239-258
  5. (With H.C. Minnett) Sir Frederick William George White. Biograph. Mem. Fellows Roy. Soc. 42, 497-521

Film

  1. 1976 (With B. Parr) 'A Vision of Membranes'. Australian National University

Acronyms used

  • AAS – Australian Academy of Science
  • ABRS – Australian Biological Resources Study
  • ANU – Australian National University
  • ARGC – Australian Research Grants Committee
  • ASTEC – Australian Science and Technology Council
  • CSIRO – Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization
  • RSBS – Research School of Biological Sciences

Rossiter Henry Crozier 1943–2009

Ross Crozier was a population geneticist and leader in the study of the evolutionary genetics of social insects who produced the first sequence of the honey bee mitochondrial genome and contributed to kin selection theory.

Image Description

Ross Crozier, population geneticist and leader in the study of the evolutionary genetics of social insects, was born on 4 January 1943 in Jodhpur, India. He died of a heart attack in his office at James Cook University in Townsville on 12 November 2009. He is survived by his wife Yuen Ching Kok, who was his inseparable companion and collaborator in life as in the laboratory. 

Crozier was a pioneer in the application of molecular genetic markers to the analysis of social insect populations, and generated much of the theory that made these analyses possible. Ross and Ching Crozier produced the first sequence of the honey bee mitochondrial genome – the second insect mitochondria to be fully sequenced. From the sequence Crozier produced fundamental insights into the nature of DNA evolution, particularly directional mutation pressure towards particular nucleotides. Crozier contributed massively to the development of kin selection theory, which remains the most potent explanatory theory for the evolution of social behaviour in insects.

Download the memoir

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 22(1), 2011. It was written by Benjamin P. Oldroyd and Oliver Mayo.

Ronald Harry Wharton 1923–1983

Professor Ronald Wharton FAA was an entomologist who advanced global understanding of malaria and filariasis in Malaya, and pioneered cattle-tick control research at CSIRO.

Image Description
Ronald Harry Wharton 1923-1983

On a fine afternoon, 18 September 1983, Harry Wharton was slashing with his tractor on his beautiful property at Billinudgel, near Mullumbimby in northern New South Wales. No one knows what caused the accident which killed him. His family, friends and colleagues were suddenly and tragically bereaved.

Ronald Harry Wharton was born on 14 April 1923 in the small village of Arding, near Armidale in northern New South Wales. His father, William Frank Wharton, was the teacher in the one-teacher school at Arding, where Harry spent his early childhood days. In 1933 the family moved to Dunoon, near Lismore in the Northern Rivers District of New South Wales and he attended the Lismore High School until 1939. These were happy days, spent mainly in the bush – walking, fishing, swimming, shooting and cycling – with his four brothers and sister. It was probably at this time that he began his lifelong interest and enthusiasm for sport, especially cricket. Indeed, to play cricket where he lived, one had to be keen, because first one had to clear the land to make a pitch.

When the Second World War started Harry was attending the New England University College in Armidale as a sponsored student. The college was still in its infancy, with fewer than 200 students. He is remembered as an outstanding student in the Faculty of Science, president of the Students' Association and, as it was to be throughout his career, also remembered for particular activities, not necessarily related to his studies or his work. For example, he is remembered at Armidale also for the establishment of the first college shop, located initially in a cupboard in the Student Common Room.

It was probably at the New England College that Harry became interested in zoology, another lifelong interest no doubt engendered in the first place by his teachers, especially Dr H.F. Consett Davis, with whom he studied zoology in the first year. Up to this time he had not appeared to show any particular interest in this direction, but he was immediately successful, gaining a High Distinction and the Slade Prize in practical zoology. When Dr Consett Davis joined the Armed Services, Harry's zoology teacher was Mrs Margaret Spencer (née Cumpston) and it is probably due to her influence that Harry became an entomologist. He became so interested that he decided to take an honours course in entomology. As this course was not available at the New England College, he transferred early in 1943 to the Sydney campus of the University of Sydney to undertake an honours course in entomology in the Zoology Department. Here he came under the influence of Mr David J. Lee, later associate professor in the School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, but at the time a Commonwealth Research Fellow. Both the professor of zoology, W.J. Dakin, and the lecturer in entomology, Dr Anthony R. Woodhill, had been seconded elsewhere on war work and David Lee had been requested to supervise the entomology honours students. Harry also received guidance from Associate Professor E. A. Briggs, acting head of the department.

His work for his honours degree as outlined by David Lee comprised: (a) a taxonomic survey of the mosquito subgenus Finlaya, then about 25 species, including the preparation of a key to identification of the adults; although too tentative for publication, it was used by others in later attempts to clarify the subgenus; (b) observations on the bionomics of Aedes aegypti, including a comparison of the effect of winter temperatures (ambient in Sydney) with simulated summer conditions in the insectary, on the hatching of eggs, the duration of larval instars, and pupation; if this work had been published, it would no doubt have saved much speculation in later years concerning A. aegypti in Australia; (c) maintenance of a laboratory colony of A. aegypti and other species which had not previously been colonised. He was the first person to colonise Aedes notoscriptus, albeit briefly. The clue to success was provided by his colleague, Murray Wallace, who observed that oviposition took place on the rough surface of the fish-pond at his home. Harry then put a piece of sandstone in a Petri dish with water and got oviposition about the meniscus. This led to later studies by A.K. O'Gower at the School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine on oviposition responses to various surface textures.

By all accounts, Harry's years as a student were very happy. This was especially true in Armidale where the small close-knit group of students and staff in the old mansion 'Booloominbah' (which later formed the nucleus of the University of New England) maintained their friendships for many years. At Sydney, he and Murray Wallace (M.M.H. Wallace of the CSIRO Division of Entomology in Canberra) worked together in an old building, separated from the main Zoology Department in Science Road. The laboratory had a door at each end and a set of three cupboards in the middle. Harry and Murray became very expert at throwing dissecting needles over the cupboards and into the doors. There was also plenty of field work and when they were not on the roster for air-raid watch on the roof of the zoology building, the summer evenings were spent collecting mosquitoes with David Lee in the bush at Narrabeen. Lunch hours were spent mainly in the Union playing billiards.

He boarded at Moore Theological College during his undergraduate days and it is related that Harry, ever considerate, when he came back late used to relieve himself from the first floor balcony to avoid waking the principal by flushing the toilet. According to residents on the ground floor this was even more disturbing.

He graduated with First Class Honours at the end of 1943. His first professional assignment was a mosquito survey of the site of the Warragamba Dam. He and Murray Wallace delved into tunnels, wells and excavations in search of mosquitoes, and for the joint report they received the equivalent of about $12.00 each.

After graduation Harry joined the Royal Australian Air Force and served in a malaria control unit. He undertook a short course on mosquito control given in the Department of Entomology at the University of Queensland by Mr F. Athol Perkins and it was here that he first heard about DDT. He was posted to Darwin, then Milne Bay, New Guinea, and later to Morotai Island in the Moluccas. He had attained the rank of flying officer on discharge in 1945.

After the war, he returned to the Department of Zoology, University of Sydney, to work with David Lee as a teaching fellow in zoology. It was during the tenure of this position in the Department of Zoology that he became acquainted with several other entomologists who were to influence his scientific interests and work in later years, and who no doubt further strengthened his particular interest in the Diptera, especially Ian and Josephine Mackerras, and Elizabeth (Pat) Marks. Some of the mosquitoes and simuliids he described in his first three papers, he had collected while in the RAAF in Darwin and New Guinea. It seems likely that this work directed his interests toward a career in the tropics, no doubt amplified by a collecting trip with David Lee in New Guinea for the Department of External Territories. This was planned as an initial exercise for a proposed biological survey of Papua and New Guinea, but though officially approved, the proposal still had not received the minister's signature before the change of government in 1949.

In June 1948, Harry entered the British Colonial Service, taking up an appointment as entomologist at the Institute for Medical Research (IMR) at Kuala Lumpur in the Federated Malay States. He was put in charge of a field laboratory in a rubber plantation at Tampin, Negri Sembilan, Malaya, which was set up for the purpose of conducting field trials on the effectiveness of DDT and BHC as residual insecticides for the control of malaria.

Before the war, malaria control measures had been almost entirely directed toward the larvae and pupae of Anopheles mosquitoes. The new insecticides offered the possibility of control measures directed against the adult mosquitoes by spraying the walls of houses. The initial experiments were conducted in huts specially designed to allow mosquitoes to behave as they would in a domestic dwelling, the mosquitoes being caught as they left the hut through window traps. His early observations, in collaboration with Dr J.A. Reid, were published in Nature.

He spent his first leave (1952) in the United Kingdom continuing these studies in collaboration with Dr J.R. Busvine, at the Entomology Department of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. His observations had shown that marked variation in susceptibility in insecticides was manifested by different species of mosquitoes. For example, Anopheles maculatus was found to be much more susceptible than Culex fatigans. Field experiments showed that these differences were related to several factors such as innate susceptibility and behavioural characteristics influencing frequency and duration of contact. For these observations and experiments he was awarded an M. Sc. by the University of Sydney. The degree was awarded in 1958 and his thesis was entitled 'The use of residual insecticides in Malaya, with supporting papers on the systematics of Australian Culicidae and Simuliidae'.

On his return from England to Malaya on board SS Himalaya, Harry met Helen Pulling and they were married in Sydney on 6 June 1953. After a short stay in Tampin they set up house in Kuantan on the east coast of Malaya. These were the days when the communist insurgency was at its height and both Tampin and Kuantan were hotbeds of communist activities. Despite this, Harry did his field work taking long treks in the bush at considerable risk of ambush. In the early days, the people working at the IMR had been encouraged to volunteer in the local police activities, but later the director, Dr. J.W. Field, forbade them to undertake such activities. Indeed, Harry told his brother Alan that the communists recognised him as a scientist and, approving of his mosquito-catching activities, let him alone.

He was by all accounts an extremely able field worker and observer and amassed a wealth of new information on the biology and behaviour of Malayan mosquitoes. His observations on feeding habits, nesting, and house-entering of vector mosquitoes have served as a basis for the control of both malaria and filariasis.

In July 1953, Harry turned his attention to the mosquito vectors of filariasis. Whereas malaria is transmitted only by mosquitoes in the genus Anopheles, the carriers of filariasis in Malaya belong in both Anopheles and Mansonia. At one time, only one form of filariasis in man was recognised in Malaya, the so-called Bancroftian filariasis caused by Wuchereria bancrofti. Its distribution extends throughout the tropical areas of the world, but it is quite scarce in Malaya. It was later recognised that in South-East Asia, another form of filariasis occurs, so-called Brugian filariasis caused by Brugia malayi. This latter form was found to be endemic in the swamp forest areas of Malaya, especially along the lower reaches of the Pahang River which enters the China Sea just south of Kuantan.

Species of Mansonia were suspected to be the main vectors of this form of filariasis and as these mosquitoes were found to be susceptible to dieldrin sprayed on the walls of houses and as the micro-filariae (larval forms of the parasite found in the blood of patients) were highly susceptible to treatment with diethylcarbamazine, it was expected that these two control measures (i.e. spraying and treatment) would be effective in controlling the overall incidence of filariasis. Such measures were, however, found to be non-effective in reducing the infection rate in trapped Mansonia mosquitoes, thus indicating a source of infection other than man.

It had been discovered earlier that monkeys harboured the microfilariae of B. malayi, but Wharton and his colleagues, especially Dr J.F.B. Edeson, provided the basic studies which established that sub-periodic Brugian filariasis in the Pahang swamp forests is a zoonosis. They found that Brugia spp. occur widely in animals, especially monkeys, and that Mansonia mosquitoes tend to bite people at ground-level and monkeys in the forest canopies. This work forged a vital zoological link in the understanding of the epidemiology of filariasis in the region.

This collaboration between Wharton the biologist and his medical colleagues, especially J.F.B. Edeson, T. Wilson and A.B.G. Laing, involving field observations and laboratory experiments on the one hand, with diagnosis, clinical observations, and chemotherapy on the other, will long be remembered as a classic group study in the highest tradition of tropical medicine.

The first leave since their marriage was spent in Sydney at Palm Beach in a new house which Helen had designed. Their stay received some local interest because Harry was quoted in the Sydney Morning Herald of 2 November 1960 as stating that Palm Beach's mosquitoes were far more annoying than those in Malaya.

The observations and studies undertaken in Malaya were collected in a monograph comprising Bulletin No. 11 of the IMR and entitled 'The biology of Mansonia mosquitoes in relation to the transmission of filariasis in Malaya'. This report was submitted to the University of Malaya in Singapore as a part requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy under the supervision of Professor A.A. Sandosham. The degree was awarded in 1960.

In the early 1960s Harry Wharton and his colleagues became involved in studies on simian malaria. It was already known that Malayan monkeys harboured malaria parasites, but through their observations, led by D.E. Eyles of the U.S. Public Health Service, five new species were discovered and the complete development of two species was followed in Anopheles mosquitoes. Their studies showed that although malaria was highly prevalent amongst the monkey population in the jungle, it was not a significant source of human infection, though it has been subsequently shown that man can be infected from monkeys. During these malaria investigations Harry performed pioneer studies on the biology of Malaysian species of Anopheles and supplemented and confirmed his earlier studies on the effect of residual insecticides. He was the first to discover the daytime resting place of Anopheles maculatus and upset the long-held belief that this mosquito preferred human blood. With Dr D.E. Moorhouse, organiser of the World Health Organisation (WHO) Malaria Eradication Pilot Project, he obtained new and important information on the behaviour of anophelines.

The 15 years he spent in Malaya were a source of very considerable fulfilment. Working conditions were no doubt difficult and, especially in the early days, there must have been problems with inadequate equipment. There must also have been anxiety for Harry and Helen over raising a family in a land far from home. Their daughter Robin was born in 1954 and their son Geoffrey in 1957. But there were many compensations and when the family moved to Kuala Lumpur in 1960 when he was promoted to senior entomologist, life must have been extremely pleasant in all respects.

On the basis of the research carried out at Kuantan, he had submitted proposals for the control of filariasis and these had been accepted by the director of medical services, a source of considerable satisfaction to Harry. He had been deeply absorbed in his studies for their own sake, but now he had the added satisfaction that the studies had a social impact; they had provided basic epidemiological knowledge to be used for the control of a distressing disease. It is probably true to say that from his work was derived the basis of the control program against both malaria and filariasis subsequently undertaken by the Malaysian Government. By 1963 he was recognised as a world authority on the vectors of malaria and filariasis in South-East Asia.

Harry enormously enjoyed the social life, the tennis, cricket and golf, as well as all the other amenities offered by K.L. and the Royal Selangor Golf Club. There was an active community of research workers at this time in Kuala Lumpur, not only at the IMR, but also at the medical departments in the universities. Moreover, the IMR had established collaborative projects with the WHO, the Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, the U.S. Army Medical Research Unit, and the Hooper Foundation in California. All these collaborations meant more personnel and more funds for research. South-East Asia was fast becoming one of the most active zones in the field of tropical medicine, with other centres of investigation operating in Bangkok, Manila and Singapore.

Nevertheless, in spite of these interesting developments, working conditions in Malaya were changing. After Independence in 1957, the government had announced that British Colonial office personnel would gradually be replaced by Malayan staff, so that there occurred a gradual exodus of British officers from Malaya.

In 1963 Harry, Helen and their two children returned to Australia where Harry took up an appointment in the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) at the Veterinary Parasitology Laboratory, Yeerongpilly, Brisbane. This laboratory was transferred to Indooroopilly on completion of the Long Pocket Laboratories, where he had put much time and thought into the design of the buildings and surrounding grounds. His initial appointment was as principal research officer in charge of research on cattle-tick in the Division of Entomology. He was reclassified to senior principal research scientist in 1965 and to chief research scientist in 1968, when he also became officer in charge of all research activities of the Division of Entomology at the Long Pocket Laboratories.

It was not easy to change from being a research officer in the colonial service in Malaya to a CSIRO officer in Australia, and for several years both Harry and Helen found it difficult to adapt to the new life in Brisbane. An important difference was that in Malaya he had been involved with the main thrust of the research from the beginning and was part of a single team. By contrast, in Brisbane he came on the scene at a time when research on ticks had been long in progress, not only in CSIRO but also in the State Department of Primary Industry and in the University of Queensland.

His brief from Dr D.F. Waterhouse, chief of the Division of Entomology, was to lead a group of research workers investigating the serious problem of cattle-tick infestation. This involved the development of a broad study involving, on the one hand, the ecological factors influencing tick survival and dispersal and, on the other, the physiological and biochemical factors influencing their susceptibility to insecticides. This required a very wide spectrum of knowledge and only a person with an intuitive mind and propensity for leadership could have led so effectively this interdisciplinary field of research. He had of course had extensive experience in Malaya with the factors affecting susceptibility of arthropods to insecticides, but at the time of his arrival in Australia a new problem was posed by development of resistance to insecticides. It was therefore this aspect which occupied most of his attention.

Up to this time, control of the cattle-tick had mainly depended upon a combination of 'strategic ' dipping with acaricides and pasture 'spelling' (alternate grazing in separate paddocks, a control measure developed by Dr Paul Wilkinson at the Belmont Station of CSIRO). Such methods were however proving ineffective owing to development of acaricide resistance in the ticks, and to the long pasture spelling periods needed for effective control being not conducive to the most effective use of pastures.

As soon as he commenced his work at CSIRO, Harry's attention was focused on two main aspects of tick control: (1) the nature and heritability of resistance to ticks manifested by individual cattle among European breeds and by certain breeds, especially Zebu cattle; and (2) the recognition that ticks on certain properties in Queensland showed resistance to various acaricides which had come into use following the ban on the use of DDT on cattle in 1962. For both of these aspects of the tick investigation it was fundamental to develop first of all an accurate method of assessing tick populations on their hosts. The ensuing study of the engorgement of the cattle-tick on its host and its final detachment, when related to the assessment of tick numbers actually counted on the cattle, was directly applicable not only to field evaluation of acaricides, but also for comparing different control regimes, determining effects of ticks on cattle, and selecting and breeding for tick resistance.

The cattle-tick is distributed over a more or less defined area of Australia ranging from the Kimberleys in Western Australia, following roughly the curved line of the annual 20 inch (508 mm) isohyet, extending across the Northern Territory and Queensland to Lismore in New South Wales. One of the first successes in the ensuing campaign of CSIRO was to show that, although the attempts to eradicate the tick from New South Wales in 1956-57 had failed, ticks could be eradicated from an isolated area, such as Magnetic Island, off the coast near Townsville, in spite of the presence of native fauna. Over the next 15 years there followed a series of publications by Wharton and his colleagues, especially W.J. Roulston, B.F. Stone, R.W. Sutherst and K.B.W. Utech, which can mainly be classed into two groups.

In the first group were those directed toward the quantitative assessment of resistance of ticks to acaricides, especially in relation to methods of application and the various physiological and ecological considerations involved in the effective use of acaricides, the heritability of acaricide resistance in tick populations, and the distribution of strains of resistant ticks.

In the second group were those directed toward the understanding of tick resistance in cattle: 'how it is acquired, how expressed, how inherited'. It was this second series of investigations that appeared to Harry to hold the most promise in controlling the cattle-tick. Indeed, by 1970 he had despaired of control methods based on chemicals, because they had proved not only too expensive, but also ineffective owing to rapid development of resistance by the ticks.

The aim was to control tick populations by utilising host resistance as the acaricidal factor so as to establish in Australia the kind of host-tick equilibrium that prevails in areas of the world where the association has evolved, such as in South-East Asia where ticks do not reach infestations that are detrimental to cattle but are prevalent enough to immunise against tick fever. Two approaches to improving tick-resistance in the herd were followed: (1) selective breeding in a herd of European (Bos taurus) cattle of tick-resistant animals; and (2) the introduction of tick-resistant Zebu (Bos indicus) cattle into the herd. A simulatory model was constructed with a view to analysing all the factors that might influence the host-tick equilibrium.

This was a long-term investigation and took many years to yield quantitative results. It was continued by Harry's colleagues, especially R.W. Sutherst and K.B.W. Utech, while he was in Bogor. The work was successful and by 1982 it had been shown that a definite improvement in tick resistance in the Bos taurus herd had been achieved by yearly introductions into the herd of tick-resistant individuals and by culling tick-susceptible individuals. It was moreover demonstrated that genetic improvement for resistance to ticks was possible without affecting other factors such as milk yield.

In 1978 Harry was appointed as officer in charge of the Centre for Animal Research and Development at Bogor, Indonesia. This was a development project arising from an agreement between Australia and Indonesia to establish an institute for the purpose of conducting research in the field of animal health and production. The aim was eventually to staff the centre exclusively with Indonesian scientists trained in Australia to carry out first-class research. Harry went to Bogor with high hopes. He was ideally suited to the job, with his previous experience in Malaya, his ability to speak the Indonesian language, and his knowledge and experience in biological research. Preliminary planning of the project had proceeded for several years. The centre was to be financed through the Australian Development Assistance Bureau and to be managed by CSIRO, yet integrated with the Indonesian Government. The problems associated with launching this project were complex and the writer can only relate the impressions he received from Harry that there was failure on the part of the organisers to seek advice from the right quarters in the preliminary stages and that the managerial set-up was over-complicated, the Indonesian authorities were not fully conversant with the modus operandi, and communication between Bogor and Canberra was not as good as it might have been. Be these as they may, Harry was assailed from the outset by a multitude of administrative problems, when his real desire was to concentrate on training and research, and on furtherance of the primary aims of the project. So often he would be elated by the discovery of a promising recruit, only to be baulked by a tangle with Customs officials over the arrival of new equipment or by some delay over obtaining a decision from Canberra. Although he maintained his basic confidence in his staff and students until his term of office expired, he had many moments of disillusionment.

On returning in 1982 to Brisbane from his assignment in Java, Harry found himself in a vacuum. Four years is a long time to be separated from an ongoing research project in CSIRO. Excepting the position of chief of the Division of Entomology, to which position he did not aspire, he had ascended the promotion ladder as far as possible. He felt his motivation was unclear, but fortunately an interesting and worthwhile involvement with the WHO saved the situation. He had had a long association with this organisation. Since 1961 he had been a consultant on the Expert Committee on Filariasis and a member of the Expert Panel on Insecticides. In 1980 he was appointed as a member of the Expert Committee on Vector Biology and Control. This work involved ongoing consultation, preparation of working papers, and attendance at committee meetings and seminars in various countries. In 1982 he was appointed a member of the Scientific and Technical Advisory Committee of the UNDP/World Bank/WHO Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases. He became intensely interested in the work of this committee and admired the chairman, Dr A. Lucas, and his aims. All this work was pursued in addition to his full-time service in CSIRO, where he was by now transferred to the newly-formed Division of Tropical Animal Science.

In recognition of his work, Harry Wharton received many honours. The Chalmers Medal was awarded to him in 1967 by the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene in recognition of his outstanding contribution to knowledge of the epidemiology and control of malaria and filariasis. The medal was presented to him at a ceremony in the library at the School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine in Sydney arranged by Sir Edward Ford and David Lee; his mother and father were present.

In 1973 he was elected to fellowship of the Australian Academy of Science and in 1982 to the Australian Academy of Technological Sciences. In the latter year, Her Majesty the Queen awarded him the honour of officer of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire.

When he came to Brisbane, Harry took an active part in the Entomological Society of Queensland, and he was elected its president in 1966. He also played a key role in the formative years of the Australian Entomological Society, founded in 1965; he was secretary from 1966 to 1969. Although he regarded himself primarily as an entomologist, he was an active member of the Australian Society for Parasitology and was elected a fellow of that society in 1981. For historical reasons, entomology and parasitology have emerged separately as disciplines in Australia. Harry Wharton, like Ian Mackerras before him, did much to draw these two aspects of zoology closer together. He was acting editor of the International Journal for Parasitology in 1977.

In addition to being an eminent and honoured scientist and an able and wise administrator, Harry possessed the type of personality that kindled instant affection. He was fond of company, easy to talk to, fun to be with, a good listener with a sympathetic and kindly manner. His handsome features and distinguished bearing imparted just that degree of self-confidence and assurance for leadership. He was immensely fond and proud of his family and liked nothing better than working on his property at Billinudgel. This is what he was doing when he died. In one way he was lucky; but it is a tragedy to those he left behind that he was not able to enjoy this new phase of his life for longer.

He was planning a book on the cattle tick and contemplating a new version of the CSIRO film on the cattle tick. Furthermore it seems certain that had he been spared for more years, Harry would have contributed increasingly to the work of the United Nations and that his advice, based on his knowledge and wide experience, would have been increasingly sought in Australia and worldwide. Perhaps, however, his greatest pleasure would have come from the relatively simple activities which had been sources of pleasure to him from the beginning: family, friends, golf and gardening.

To the writer, Harry Wharton is remembered as a person who presented all those features which turn colleagues and acquaintances into cherished friends. As was aptly said by Dr D. F. Mahoney at Harry's funeral: 'he regarded his circle of friends as an extension of his own family.' He was an outstanding scientist and a fine man.

He neverë yet no vileynye ne saydë
In al his lyf unto no maner wight.
He was a verray, parfit, gentil knyght.

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 6(2), 1985. It was written by J.F.A. Sprent, Emeritus Professor of the University of Queensland.

Acknowledgements

The writer gratefully acknowledges help and advice provided by the following: Dr K.C. Bremner, Mr P.H. Durie, Dr J.F.B. Edeson, Associate Professor D.J. Lee, Dr D.F. Mahoney, Dr Elizabeth N. Marks, Associate Professor D.E. Moorhouse, Dr J.A. Reid, Professor A.A. Sandosham, Mrs Margaret Spencer, Mr M.M.H. Wallace, Professor T. Wilson, Mr Alan Wharton and Mrs Helen Wharton.