Paul Ivan Korner 1925–2012
Professor Paul Korner AO FAA was a cardiovascular physiologist who made major contributions to understanding the pathogenesis of hypertension and to improving the management of cardiovascular diseases.
Paul Korner's life's work centered on unraveling the sympatho-adrenal control of the circulation and applying this knowledge to understanding the pathogenesis of hypertension and to improving the management of cardiovascular diseases. He made major contributions as Foundation Professor of Physiology at the University of New South Wales (1960–8), as the first Scandrett Professor of Cardiology at the University of Sydney and the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (1968–74), and as Director of the Baker Institute for Medical Research (1975–90). After retirement in 1990, he undertook his last major work, writing an influential single-author text, Essential Hypertension and it Causes.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 24(2), 2013. It was written by John Chalmers, James Angus, Robert Graham, John Carmody, Roger Dampney, Garry Jennings and Nicholas Korner.
Otto Frankel 1900-1998
Sir Otto Frankel was a geneticist by training, plant breeder by occupation, cytologist by inclination and genetic conservationist by acclaim. His career in science was unusual in that his most widely acclaimed work was done after his official retirement.
Written by L.T. Evans.
Introduction
Sir Otto Frankel – whom I shall refer to as Otto because that is how we all addressed him – was a geneticist by training, plant breeder by occupation, cytologist by inclination and genetic conservationist by acclaim. Apart from his personal research, Otto was a highly effective builder and leader of research groups, Socratic gadfly to the scientific establishment, and high prophet of the genetic resources conservation movement. His career in science was unusual in that his most widely acclaimed work was done after his official retirement. A man of inexhaustible variety of opinions, Otto had a complex personality that could be rough or kindly, bored or engaged, impossible or altogether charming by turns, and he did not wish this memoir paint him otherwise. He refused to write an autobiographical sketch and did not keep many records. However, two interviews with him about his career were recorded, by Gavan McCarthy in 1985 [1] and by Max Blythe in 1993 [2]. Much of the information and views quoted here are from records of discussions I have had with him over many years.
Family background and early life
Otto Herzberg-Frankel was born in Vienna on 4 November 1900, the third of four sons of a prominent and wealthy lawyer. Frankel was a relatively uncommon name in Vienna at that time, but to differentiate himself from a more traditionally Jewish branch of the family, Otto's paternal grandfather, a well-known author, added Herzberg from his mother's name to become Herzberg-Frankel. After his father's death, Otto chose to drop the hyphen and revert to Frankel.
Ludwig Herzberg-Frankel, Otto's father, was a highly successful barrister in Vienna, effective both in the courtroom and as a public orator. Otto's enjoyment of, and effectiveness in, public debate and persuasion were clearly shared with his father. What he called his 'peasant instincts', so important in his motivation to make his career in agriculture, came from his mother's family. Thérèse Sommerstein was the youngest child of a family with several rural estates in Galicia. Her older sister Ann was an able and progressive farmer, and Otto's early rural experiences were associated with visits to his aunt's estate [3], where he was also impressed by the abilities and aristocratic manners of her husband, Joseph Bernstein vel Niemirovski. Their son, the British historian who later changed his name to Lewis Namier, also played a significant role in Otto's career.
Fin-de-siècle Vienna was a culturally sophisticated and affluent city which attracted the adventurous and talented in many fields to become a hot-bed of cultural change in art, architecture, music, theatre and philosophy. This was the background to Otto's life and a formative effect on his youth, which had many elements in common with that described by Victor Weisskopf [4] and others. But he also witnessed the collapse of the old Empire, along with the relative impoverishment of his family, at the end of the First World War. At its outset his father had volunteered for military service along with his motor car and his chauffeur. By its end there was no car but, as Otto's brother Paul put it, the brothers had acquired the incentive to work.
Max, Otto's oldest brother (1895-1983), qualified in law but after joining Otto in New Zealand in 1938 he became an accountant. Theo (1897-1986), who had to flee Vienna hurriedly in 1938, became a progressive paper manufacturer in Great Britain, establishing the Scottish Pulp and Paper Mills enterprise in the Highlands. Paul (1903-1992) also moved to Britain, from Poland in 1937. An economist by training, he founded Petroleum Economics Ltd. in 1955 and became a distinguished international authority on the oil industry. Their family home was not a happy one, according to Otto. Paul told me that Otto's youth was quite tempestuous and unhappy, more because of his own problems than of his father's domination. One of these was Otto's sense of 'homelessness' which he ascribed to his father's 'distance' and to not having a country to call 'home': they were Viennese Jews but not Jewish in any religious sense, nor Austrian, nor Polish.
Not only did Otto subsequently claim that he had no country, he also insisted that he had 'no education'. In Otto's early years, his father employed a tutor for his sons as well as a French governess. From 1910 to 1918 Otto attended the Piaristen Staatsgymnasiums Wien VIII, as did Karl Popper. Otto's claim to no education was based on this being a classical rather than a modern school [5], with poor mathematics and next to no science but eight years of Latin and four of Greek. None of his teachers inspired him.
University education
The end of school coincided with the end of the war, when there was little chance of a young man without military service being admitted to the University in Vienna. However, under Otto's leadership, a group of young people took over a disused military laboratory, obtained a copy of the practical course work from the Chemical Institute of the University, worked through it together without any lectures and were subsequently given credit for the course.
Besides chemistry, the young Otto had also become involved in communism, and was arrested on one occasion for addressing a street crowd. At about this time there had been a communist putsch in Munich and Otto went there to be interviewed by the celebrated professor of chemistry, Richard Willstätter. As a result he was admitted to Munich University (1919-1920) to study chemistry, botany and physics. However, after three semesters he had lost some of his enthusiasm for chemistry. The young idealist, concerned about the fight against hunger, wanted to do something more practical like agriculture.
The Agricultural Institute of the University of Giessen was recommended to Otto's father, and he studied there under Professor Paul Gisevius for two semesters in 1920/21. Otto did not find his professor congenial and packed his bags again. He was still determined to learn about farming, however, and in 1922 returned to his aunt Ann's estate in Galicia but soon decided he was not really interested in farm management. His aunt then persuaded him to go back to university, with her support.
In the autumn of 1922 he began his studies at the Agricultural University of Berlin, having been given credit for his earlier studies in Vienna, Munich and Giessen, as well as for his practical farm work [6]. Luckily, at this stage Otto attended a lecture on plant genetics by Professor Erwin Baur, a charismatic personality and lecturer [7], which opened a new and wholly fascinating world. He was challenged by Baur's claim to be able to work with genes and the genetic combinations of plants exactly like the chemist with his molecules and his formulae. Otto asked Baur in 1923 if he could begin research under him before his diploma was completed, and Baur agreed in view of the educational disruptions following the war. However, this arrangement entailed a lot of commuting between the city of Berlin, where he was completing his diploma studies, and the laboratories at Dahlem where Otto grew the large populations of Antirrhinum needed for his research, and this added to his sense of isolation from his fellow students.
In his book on the German genetics community, 1900-1933, Harwood divides them between the 'comprehensives' and the more practically-orientated 'pragmatics'. The former were drawn from the upper classes, had a classical education, and maintained broad biological and cultural interests, while the latter were of more lowly social origins, often with a modern education and more specialized interests, and wished to use their expertise to solve agricultural, industrial and social problems. By social and cultural background Otto could have been expected to join the 'comprehensives' like Kuhn, Goldschmidt and von Wettstein, but his wish to do something of practical value led him instead to Baur, the exemplar of the pragmatics but also with an active interest in 'racial hygiene' [8].
The research problem allocated to him by Baur was one of the earliest studies of genetic linkage in plants. Baur suggested that he clarify the linkage relations between one specific mutant (A, fuchsin red) and another nine mutants in Antirrhinum majus. In this Otto was rather unlucky because, after an extensive crossing and back-crossing programme, he found that all but one of the mutations segregated independently of A, and to a large extent of one another. However, the introduction to his thesis was a comprehensive review of linkage in plants that brought high praise from Baur, led to his first published paper (1) and earned his doctorate in agriculture from the University of Berlin in 1925.
When comparing his university experience with that of his later colleagues Otto concluded that while he had learned the value of self-reliance in research, he had missed out on many important elements of university education. His first degree courses were neither coherent nor comprehensive and he was left to himself in his research. Neither Baur nor Elizabeth Schiemann (his nominal supervisor) gave him significant attention, he was isolated by his work (and his genes) from the other students, and he was not taught cytological techniques. He did present a seminar on linkage in plants, and another on speltoid wheats, a subject he later revisited. And he spent his aunt's supporting grant on a psychoanalysis.
Itinerant post-graduate
Through a client of his father, Otto was then employed for two years (1925-1927) as a plant breeder on a large private estate at Dioseg, near Bratislava, after marrying his first wife, Mathilde Donsbach (1899-1989). Although sugar beet crops and their processing were the major activities on the estate, Otto began wheat and barley breeding programmes, which helped his subsequent appointment in New Zealand.
At this point his cousin Lewis Namier re-entered the scene. He had become an ardent Zionist and advisor to Chaim Weizmann. A British group had arranged for a small team of scientists to be sent to Palestine to establish a plant and animal breeding programme there and to act as a bridge between the Zionist Organization and the Empire Marketing Board under the direction of John Boyd Orr, then Director of the Rowett Research Institute, Aberdeen.
Namier had suggested his cousin as a potential recruit with experience in genetics and plant breeding and Otto was brought to London for interview and briefing. In Palestine Otto found that he was not fully occupied because the main emphasis of the project was on animal improvement. However, he made friends with J.D. Oppenheim who had a microscope on which Otto began his cytological career by counting the chromosomes of the Jaffa orange, which led to his third paper. The highly political nature of the Palestine project resulted in its being visited in 1928 by an influential group led by Walter Elliot, Under-Secretary of State for Scotland. In the course of this visit Otto apparently made it clear that he did not wish to remain in Palestine and temporary support for him in England was arranged until a permanent position became available.
Rowland Biffen, Director of the Plant Breeding Institute in Cambridge, arranged for Otto to work on fatuoid oats. In the course of his work at the Institute, Otto became friendly with A.E. Watkins, an excellent cytologist and evolutionist who introduced him to the cytological complexities of wheat. He also took Otto's still-imperfect English in hand, recommending that he should read all of Jane Austen, which Otto did with pleasure and profit. This brief period in Cambridge was seminal in developing Otto's interest in cytology and evolution, as well as his understanding of the English way of life.
During his stay in Cambridge Otto was invited to accompany F.B. Smith on a secret trip in August/September 1928 to Brazil and Argentina to advise the banking group Lazard Bros. on the establishment of a wheat industry in the southern state of Parana, a mission he enjoyed in many ways as 'my first real overseas trip'.
However, a more permanent position and home was what Otto sought, and it came about quite unexpectedly. His patron, Boyd Orr, was travelling across Canada by train on which he met the newly-appointed Secretary of the New Zealand Department of Scientific and Industrial Research (DSIR), Ernest Marsden. In the course of their discussions Marsden said he was looking for a plant breeder and geneticist for the newly-established Wheat Research Institute in New Zealand. Boyd Orr said he knew of one, and a cable was sent to Professor Biffen for Otto: 'Will you accept post New Zealand beginning £400 per annum plus passage?' There was no indication of what kind of work was involved, but Otto trusted Orr and accepted. Watkins encouraged him to take to New Zealand a subsample of his comprehensive collection of wheat varieties, many of which had been obtained by British government officers from overseas markets. Otto and Tilli arrived in New Zealand, after a month at sea, in March 1929.
Wheat breeding in New Zealand
In view of how significant his 22 years in New Zealand were for his scientific career, it is surprising that Otto says virtually nothing about them in his 1985 interview with McCarthy. He had come to New Zealand hoping to find a 'home'. Indeed, he did feel at home there with the countryside, and especially in the mountains, but 'I was never accepted in New Zealand, I always felt a foreigner and was made to feel that. Only in the ski huts was I accepted.'
At Lincoln College, near Christchurch, where he was to work until 1951, Otto was briefed on the role of the Wheat Research Institute (WRI) by Professor F.W. Hilgendorf, the director, with whom Otto was to have excellent relations. Hilgendorf had conceived of the Institute to improve New Zealand wheat, especially its baking quality, with support from levies on wheat growers, millers and bakers to be matched by government funding. After much proselytizing by Hilgendorf, all parties had agreed to its establishment in 1928, within the DSIR [9].
Hilgendorf had previously crossed the Canadian variety White Fife with Tuscan, and the progeny of the seventh cross were handed over to the newly established WRI. Otto began his breeding programme with these, introducing quantitative assessments of grain yield and of milling and baking quality, which eventually led to the release of the widely grown variety 'Cross 7' in 1934. Being more resistant to lodging and better suited to direct heading, this variety aided the mechanization of the wheat industry as well as improving the quality of New Zealand bread. Although the improvement of milling and baking qualities was the prime objective of his breeding programme, Otto also began an analysis of the yield components in wheat crops, reflecting the influence of F.L. Engledow's work at Cambridge (12, 17, 19).
However, further studies of the effects of selection for yield (26) showed that the efficiency of selection was not enhanced by using yield components rather than yield per se. Otto's overall experience in breeding for higher yield was summarized in an influential review (27) which, in the light of the striking advances in yield potential since that time, now seems far too conservative, indeed pessimistic. Like Farrer in Australia, he was much more confident of being able to improve the baking quality of New Zealand wheat, and put a considerable effort into optimizing the role of quality-testing in the selection process (8, 20). That this was highly effective was shown by the outstanding baking qualities of his cv. Hilgendorf.
Otto had hoped to use Watkins' varietal collection, which he enlarged in New Zealand, particularly for increasing grain size, but in the event this did not prove desirable because of associated loss of baking quality. However, the expansion and maintenance of the wheat collection put him in touch with the great Russian geneticist, N.I. Vavilov, and other plant breeders around the world, and led on to his later interest in genetic resources.
Early cytological investigations
Otto soon felt on top of the demands of his wheat breeding programme and sought the permission of his Director to undertake cytological research on native plants in the off season. Hilgendorf encouraged him and consulted New Zealand's leading ecologist, Leonard Cockayne, who suggested Hebe as a large genus with some interspecific hybrids. The Hebe-Veronica complex required considerable travel, often in the mountains, which was attractive to Otto and he began cytological research on it in 1929 although he was aware, as he indicated in a letter to the DSIR head office, that such 'fundamental' work 'is not the type of work I am here for'.
When Cockayne recommended Hebe for Otto's cytological investigation, he did so as an ecologist who considered it a diverse and interesting genus, but ecological and evolutionary significance do not bestow cytological suitability. In the event Hebe proved to be rather unsatisfactory from a cytological point of view, with its many small chromosomes. However, his cytological evidence suggested several taxonomic revisions, including the grouping of the New Zealand Veronica species with Hebe (14). Further cytological studies (21, 23) supported the establishment of Hebe as a separate genus, and suggested that the New Zealand species of Euveronica and the genus Pygmaea should also be included within Hebe, which subsequent taxonomic work has confirmed.
In wheat, Otto observed two abnormalities among the progeny of an F4 plant from a Tuscan x White Fife cross he made in 1928/29, which provided him with the material for his finest cytological research. The first involved two inverted duplications, one long and one short, that Otto interpreted as having arisen by breakage of dicentric chromatid bridges. The broken ends presumably then 'healed', becoming a functional telomere, thereby preventing sister reunion of chromatids (32). Homozygotes and heterozygotes for these duplications, as well as combined long/short heterozygotes, were analysed for their meiotic behaviour (33) in what M.J.D. White calls 'a piece of classic cytogenetics' [10].
In the same family that displayed the inverted duplications there also occurred a chlorophyll defect that Otto called striatovirescens, the leaves having alternate white and green sectors (35). The defect was shown to be due to three recessive mutations, presumably on homeologous chromosomes of the A, B and D genomes, but how these occurred is uncertain. The independent mutation of three genes, or the mutation of one which was then transferred to the homeologous chromosomes, was considered highly improbable. The association of the defect with the occurrence of the inverted duplication was presumably not coincidental, and the duplication may therefore have acted as a destabiliser of heredity, comparable with those found in maize, which Otto once referred to in a 1954 letter as 'the curious case of Barbara McClintock' [11].
Overseas visit to Darlington and Vavilov, 1935
Otto first canvassed the possibility of an overseas trip between wheat harvests early in 1934. He wanted to extend his wheat collection, have discussions with wheat breeders in Europe, and get some guidance and criticism in 'modern Karyology' which had 'grown up since I came here'. He hoped to finish off his work on Hebe during his stay of several months at the John Innes Horticultural Institution at Bayfordbury. In one sense Otto's work on Hebe was finished off there. C.D. Darlington took one look at his slides and said 'If you want to work on small chromosomes, go to Karpechenko. He likes small chromosomes.' Darlington then introduced him to the chromosomes of Fritillaria, 'on which you can do real cytology'. In any case, as Otto put it, 'the Hebe work was an evolutionary study and I'd got an inferiority complex about the taxonomy'. So although the work on Hebe continued for many years, this first overseas visit changed the direction of his cytological research. He made a systematic search for evidence of inversions among almost 30 species of Fritillaria, using Darlington's collection of slides. None were found in most species, but the results of crossing-over in the four species with them were analysed (13) and the nucleolar cycle examined (15).
Otto's overseas visit in 1935 introduced him to two of the scientists who most influenced his life. When Otto first met Cyril Darlington, he had written his highly influential Recent Advances in Cytology and was in the throes of discussing and revising it. Otto was also stimulated by the wide-ranging lunch time discussions at John Innes between J.B.S. Haldane, Darlington and others.
The other major impact of Otto's overseas trip in 1935 was his meeting with Nicolai Vavilov who warmly welcomed his visit to the USSR, arranged his visa and itinerary [12], and spent much of his time with Otto during the week he was in Leningrad (129). Otto was impressed by Vavilov's passionate drive to identify general principles, by his style of leadership and by his stamina, if not by the poor state of his experimental plots. At the time of Otto's visit Vavilov was preparing the second and third volumes of his Theoretical Bases of Plant Breeding, yet shared his time and ideas generously with Otto. Many years later Otto and Erna Bennett dedicated Genetic Resources in Plants (72) to Vavilov, of whom Otto always had a photograph in his office.
After Leningrad, Otto visited several of Vavilov's research stations, before continuing his visits to European plant breeding institutes on his way back to England. From Kiev Otto sent some 'friendly criticism and suggestions' that Vavilov took seriously in his reply. After his return to New Zealand Otto again wrote urging Vavilov to adopt Brabender's cereal chemistry procedures, criticising the Lysenkoist papers presented at the International Botanical Congress in Amsterdam, and letting him know of the discussions at the succeeding Imperial Botanical Conference in London.
Proselytizing for plant breeding
Otto's return to New Zealand opened a more than usually tempestuous phase in his life. He was divorced from Tilli in 1937, resumed his vitriolic exchanges with E. Bruce Levy (Director of the DSIR Plant Research Station in Palmerston North) over the question of who should oversee pasture plant breeding, and got into hot water for some off-the-cuff comments to a reporter about the Department of Agriculture. Like other extempore remarks by Otto, these found their way into The Press, to the delight of some and the chagrin of the DSIR headquarters.
From early in 1934, Otto had pressed for his wider involvement in DSIR plant breeding activities, initially in relation to pasture plants such as perennial ryegrass. After his return from overseas Otto put forward a more ambitious proposal for a Plant Breeding Section of DSIR, with five Divisions spread between Lincoln and Palmerston North. For a time, Otto held high hopes of its establishment. He had also formulated plans for a Genetics Bureau to undertake fundamental genetic research with both plants and animals and to collaborate with the various groups of plant and animal breeders in New Zealand. However, strong opposition from Levy and others on the plant side, and lack of interest by Dr Dry of Massey College on the animal side, led to these proposals being dropped.
Another activity in which Otto was engaged at that time (1937/9) was in trying to assist the immigration to New Zealand of Jewish refugees from Europe following the Anschluss. Otto was the secretary of a committee on which Karl Popper, who had come to Christchurch early in 1937, was also a member, one who tended to favour intellectuals whereas Otto had to deal with the Minister for Immigration who thought there were already too many of them in the country.
In 1939 Otto again went overseas by ship, on a second pilgrimage to the John Innes Institution, his research there resulting in a paper on chiasma formation in Fritillaria (22). This visit was less stimulating and significant than his first one. Darlington was preoccupied with his new duties as Director of the Institution. Haldane had left and laboratory discussions were less lively and wide-ranging. Otto was impressed by how quickly the research atmosphere of an institution could change.
Remarriage and recognition
Otto returned to New Zealand by ship in the early stages of the Second World War, and married Margaret Anderson (1902-1997), an artist and art teacher from a well-known Christchurch family, within a few hours of getting home on 8 December 1939. They had met many years before and theirs was a wonderfully enduring and happy marriage of two strong personalities. Unlike Tilli, Margaret was always welcomed by Otto's family and he, after they recognized his gardening skills, by hers. The Andersons lived in an historic house called Risingholme, set in large grounds, and Margaret's father gave them some of the land on which to build the first of the three houses and gardens from which they gained so much delight. When he died, Risingholme was given to the City of Christchurch, and Otto and Margaret suggested that it be turned into a community centre, in which they were active for many years. Their first house, completed in 1940, was designed by the great Viennese-born contemporary of Otto, Ernest Plischke, and is illustrated in two books on his architecture.
When Hilgendorf died in 1942, Otto was appointed Chief Executive Officer of the Wheat Research Institute and his powers of leadership, his capacity for planning and his vision were at last given some scope. He had already proved himself to be an able plant breeder whose varieties Cross 7 (released in 1934), Taiaroa and Tainui (1939) and Fife-Tuscan (1941), and subsequently WRI-Yielder (1947), had raised wheat yields, while Hilgendorf (1948) had quite outstanding baking quality [13]. Although the work of the WRI was appreciated by wheat growers, millers and bakers, it was not widely known until 1947 when the seed harvested from the experimental plots of a very promising line was stolen. Otto's appeal for its return received headline treatment, bringing the Institute and its work into welcome prominence. He was reminded of the opera diva who became more famous for her stolen pearls than for her singing.
Nevertheless, these years were among Otto's most scientifically productive. In 1947 he published a paper on plant collections (25), another on selection for yield in wheat (26), and an influential review on the theory of plant breeding for yield (27). Over the next three years his papers included accounts of two newly-released wheat varieties (28, 29) and of what he regarded as his best cytological work, on an inverted duplication in wheat (32, 33), as well as the first paper in his long series on base sterile mutants in speltoid wheat, which he had first observed in 1929 (31).
In 1948 he visited the John Innes for a third time, to find Darlington preoccupied with the controversy over Lysenko's presidential address to the Soviet Academy of Agricultural Science on 31 July. Darlington, S.C. Harland and R.A. Fisher had expressed deep concern over this development in a discussion on the BBC's Third Program and Otto entered the fray with a letter to The Listener of 9 December 1948 questioning J.B.S. Haldane's public defence of Lysenkoism. When they met a little later there was, as Otto put it, 'an exchange of grunts'.
In 1949 the wheat breeding section of the WRI was merged with the DSIR Agronomy Division, also based at Lincoln. For the first year, Otto was associate director of the combined group, becoming Director in March 1950. As he says in his interview with McCarthy: 'for the first time I was able to look for scientific staff...and I could think of the scientific content of a job rather than purely breeding barley or some root crop or other, and I could look for quality...' However, he encountered bureaucratic resistance to his attempts to build a stronger research group at Lincoln, and was soon tempted to leave New Zealand.
Although administrative frustrations precipitated his departure from New Zealand, his sense of intellectual isolation there would probably have led him to leave eventually, as well as the lack of 'old stones and modern art'.
Chief of the CSIRO Division of Plant Industry, 1951-1962
Although Otto felt less at home with the landscape in Australia than in New Zealand, he was 'never made to feel a foreigner', a welcome difference. Two other components led to his remembering his early years in Australia as the most rewarding of his career. Funding for research in the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO) burgeoned in the fifties, giving opportunities for recruitment and building that Otto seized. And in Sir Ian Clunies Ross he had an idealistic, cultured and brilliant but enigmatic Chairman with whom his relations remained warm. Otto's memoir of him [14] radiates appreciation, and a photograph of Clunies Ross was prominent in all the offices Otto later occupied.
Yet when Otto first visited the Division of Plant Industry in Canberra with Carl Forster (an associate of the then CSIRO Executive) before being interviewed in Melbourne, he was reluctant to be considered. It was much larger and more diverse than his Crop Research Division but the buildings were run down and the staff demoralized, and he thought the environment ugly. Forster must have conveyed Otto's impressions to Clunies Ross because when Otto went, still wavering, to see him, the Chairman cut off his retreat with 'Frankel, Frankel. I'm exceedingly sorry you won't take it – and that job is so terribly difficult'.
Clunies Ross had made it quite clear that Otto's major role was to strengthen the Division's research, especially the more fundamental research, particularly in genetics, all of which appealed to him. In fact, when Clunies Ross first joined the CSIRO Executive, one of his main goals had been the building of a national programme in genetics education and research [15], and in a paper to the Executive Committee in 1947 he had argued the need to strengthen genetic research in the Division of Plant Industry. Otto's efforts along similar lines in New Zealand must have encouraged Clunies Ross in his subsequent negotiations with him.
Prior to Otto's interview in mid-1951, there had been a review of the Division that had also recommended a strengthening of basic research, so his brief was clear and he set about it vigorously on a series of recruiting trips overseas. He was sceptical of the effectiveness of advertising positions: 'People who apply are rarely the best, they are footloose, they are available. You want to get people who are not available'. Much of the agrostological and associated research moved to Brisbane, where it eventually became a separate Division. Distinguished older scientists and promising young ones were recruited to give new life to old activities. In other areas, such as plant introduction, Otto simply challenged them to do better. The small Divisional unit in plant physiology already established at the Waite Research Institute in Adelaide was moved to Canberra and enlarged. Plant biochemistry also required extensive recruiting. Some projects were tapered off and the younger research staff given new opportunities, as in the case of the phytochemical survey staff in Queensland who were refocused on rainforest ecology.
The most profound changes, however, were in the area of genetics and cytology, Otto's own, where he felt most confident in his recruiting and where he had the strong support of Clunies Ross. Although the fields of quantitative genetics and cytology received initial emphasis, a powerful and wide-ranging group in evolutionary genetics was quickly established, and became highly influential both in Australia and internationally. Otto's personal commitment to his research on the genetics of floral development in wheat, the high standards he demanded, his interest in broader genetic issues and his provocation of their discussion made the genetics seminar a lively centre of Divisional activities.
As he sought to rejuvenate the Division and re-orientate it to 'science for the second half of the 20th century' there was, naturally, some resentment among some of the older staff. However, his efforts soon transformed the scientific life and standing of the Division by building up a range of strong discipline-based groups, such as that in agricultural physics under the leadership of J.R. Philip. The recruiting of additional staff in new fields greatly enlarged the Divisional requirements for additional laboratory space and new equipment, both of which proved hard to obtain. Looking back, Otto thought these were his greatest difficulties. When he became Chief, the Division was still largely housed in its original 1930s building and in spite of great efforts by Otto there was no major addition until the 'Genetics' building was completed in 1958. Even that required a personal visit by the Prime Minister, R.G. Menzies, to the Division. After that, the new buildings came more readily, the Genetics extension being completed in 1960, the Biochemistry building in 1961 and the phytotron in 1962.
The capstone to Otto's reconstruction of the Division was his campaign to build an Australian phytotron to serve as a national facility for research on the responses of plants to climatic factors. On his first visit to the phytotron at the California Institute of Technology in 1953, he was greatly impressed by its potential value for agricultural research in a country like Australia with such a wide range of climatic conditions. This would be an expensive facility, especially for the biological sciences at that time, and the 'big science' element was a challenge. But Otto also wanted the Australian phytotron to be novel and distinctive in both engineering design and architecture. Clunies Ross was supportive, and Otto soon enlisted the enthusiastic cooperation of R.N. Morse, officer-in-charge of the CSIRO Engineering Section, and his staff.
A novel design was developed, in which the major components were thoroughly tested before financial commitments were sought, and in 1958, the federal government decided to provide the requisite funds. The phytotron was officially opened in August 1962 by the Prime Minister, Mr Menzies, by which time Otto had joined the CSIRO Executive. Nevertheless, its scale, originality and style symbolized, for many, Otto's leadership of the Division of Plant Industry.
Other research areas in the Division were also stimulated and enlarged right up to the end of Otto's term as Chief. Perhaps his greatest disappointment as Chief was that Clunies Ross, not long before he died in June 1959, began to express concern that Otto had neglected, even impoverished, applied research by the Division. Yet Otto continually challenged his research staff to pursue their work within a framework of potential relevance to agriculture.
What particularly saddened him was that, as he makes plain in his interview, his initial attraction to the CSIRO culture was the enthusiastic and idealistic encouragement given by Clunies Ross and his Executive colleagues to basic research related to applied problems, and he sensed that such enthusiasm was faltering. Despite this, he told McCarthy that the biggest thing in his life, which he felt 'everyday in spite of all my wars and my arguments', was his admiration and respect for CSIRO. On one occasion when Otto expressed this rather forcibly in a comparison with the Australian National University to Lord Florey, its Chancellor, the latter was moved to comment: 'Frankel, I'm not here to award marks'.
On the CSIRO Executive, 1962-1966
Otto was persuaded by R.N. Robertson to succeed him in 1962 as a member of the Executive of CSIRO. He would rather have remained in the Division, preferring always to fight for something than against it, distrusting the 'management' of science, and enjoying the irreverence of young colleagues. But he sensed that a need to fight for basic research within CSIRO was emerging. He also sensed a need to protect the Division of Plant Industry, by then the largest in CSIRO, from being split, which would reduce the interactions and cross-fertilization between disciplines that he had tried to foster. He may also have had expectations of succession to the Chairmanship of CSIRO.
However, he found little satisfaction in his work, missed the contact with active researchers and missed his home and garden through having to spend most of his time in Melbourne. Otto's record as Chief made it clear that he was excellent at choosing staff given his subtle, merciless, multidimensional judgement of people, and he had expected to deploy those skills in the choice of new Chiefs of Divisions, but even there he was thwarted.
It was fortunate, therefore, that just at this juncture a subject in which he had long been interested, especially since visiting Vavilov in Leningrad, namely the conservation of genetic resources, began to emerge on agendas for international action. Otto soon became a key figure in the movement and remained so for thirty years after his official retirement from CSIRO in 1966.
Research after retirement
On retirement Otto returned to the Division of Plant Industry as an Honorary Research Fellow, which allowed him to resume active research in genetics and to play a more active role in the International Genetics Federation.
Throughout his life, after hearing that lecture by Baur when he was in his early twenties, Otto saw himself primarily as a geneticist. Altogether he attended ten International Genetics Congresses, beginning with the 6th at Edinburgh in 1939. He was a Vice-President and Treasurer of the International Genetics Federation from 1968 to 1973 and, according to M.J.D. White, 'played a large part in bringing together pure and applied geneticists in order to confront these most critical problems of the earth's biota in an intelligent, informed and humane manner' [10].
For Otto, as for François Jacob, 'genetics became a bastion of reason. To do genetics was to say no to intolerance and fanaticism' [16]. Many of Otto's closest friends were geneticists, and he admired the way Darlington, Dobzhansky, Haldane and others viewed humankind and its problems from a genetic perspective.
Otto's post-retirement research was focused on the base sterile mutants of speltoid wheats. In the evolution of wheat, the appearance of the free-threshing 'naked' grain character, was a highly significant step in domestication, associated with the presence of the Q-factor on the long arm of chromosome 5A. Speltoid mutants, with a brittle rachis, long internodes and tight glumes, arise by a cytologically-observable deletion of the Q segment.
Otto had found several speltoids in a crop of Yeoman wheat in 1929/30, among which one plant was sterile in most of the basal (first) florets. This sterility was found to be caused by the recessive allele of a single gene, subsequently called Bs and found to be located on chromosome 5D, and homeologous with the Q factor (31, 85). Even in a single dose, Bs prevents basal sterility in the second and higher florets, whereas sterility can extend up to them in the double recessive, to an extent depending on the polygenic background (68, 92). Eventually a series of speltoid lines was developed that ranged from full fertility to sterility of the first three florets, or even of the first eight or nine (65). At the other extreme of this scale of fertility were the 'compactoids', in which grains are found in the axils of the normally sterile basal glumes, associated with the addition of a second Q factor.
On the question of the relation between the genomes in floral morphogenesis of vulgare (bread) wheats, it is striking that the dominant Q factor is not present in any of the ancestral A, B or D genomes (50), which nevertheless had genetic systems ensuring the fertility of their first florets. According to Kuckuck [17] the Q factor may have arisen from unequal crossing over in chromosome 5A, and Frankel and Roskams (92) proposed that a gene homeologous to Bs was included in the multiple repeat. They also examined the effect of a period in short days at high temperatures at the beginning of floral initiation on the pattern of floret sterility in several normal and base sterile genotypes. These shock treatments increased basal sterility in the speltoid lines but not in the normal wheats. Further work identified the most sensitive period for each floret (94), and the stage at which cell division failed (113). Even the initiation of sterile floret primordia required prior lemma initiation (110). Although no further work has been done on them, the speltoid lines developed by Otto still have much to offer those interested in the molecular control of floret differentiation and fertility in wheat and other cereals and grasses.
FAO, IBP and genetic resources
As long ago as 1923, N.I. Vavilov had warned of the need to conserve, as well as to use, the range of genetic variation within crop plants in the face of agricultural change. With the initiation of the International Biological Program (IBP) in 1963, concern for such 'genetic erosion' was heightened. Otto had not been keen to be involved in the IBP, but at the urging of R.N. Robertson, of Ledyard Stebbins (who had introduced 'plant gene pools' as a major theme of IBP) and of C.H. Waddington (Vice-President of IBP and an old friend from his early days in Cambridge), he took part in the 1st General Assembly at Paris in 1964. The entry of the IBP, and of Otto, into the field resulted in a transformation in public awareness of the problem and plans for action. The programme, drafted by Otto in 1965, led to a clearer definition of the various kinds of genetic resources, a strategy for their conservation with priority on the land races, and an emphasis on information and availability. The realisation that IBP could not achieve this on its own led Otto to meet R.B. Sen, the Director-General of FAO, in 1965, to explore the prospects for joint efforts. Both the IBP and FAO welcomed the proposed collaboration, and Otto was invited by Sen to act as a consultant in 1966, to review the activities and responsibilities of FAO, and to prepare plans for a meeting in 1967. This integration of effort by IBP and FAO continued until the end of the IBP in 1974 [18].
During his consultancy at the FAO in 1966, Otto was visited by a fellow student from Baur's group, Professor Hermann Kuckuck, who painted an alarming picture of the accelerating loss of land races and wild relatives in Turkey and Ethiopia. His account brought home to Otto the need for urgent and comprehensive action, which he stressed in his report to FAO.
The 1967 FAO/IBP Conference on 'The Exploration, Utilization and Conservation of Plant Genetic Resources' was a landmark for the genetic resources movement. In both its planning and the reworking of its proceedings, Otto was joined, at his personal request, by Erna Bennett, and together they coined such phrases as genetic resources and genetic erosion. The conference itself led to a programme for FAO-initiated international action, while the book (72) had a substantial impact on the scientific community. In particular, the book emphasised the importance of what Otto liked to refer to as the 'generalist strategy' of Vavilov as against 'mission-oriented' collecting (122).
After the 1967 conference there followed a frustrating period of bureaucratic inaction by FAO. The Panel of Experts was reconstituted with a membership representing both IBP and FAO under Otto's chairmanship, and many issues were considered at their four meetings. The high priority for collection of endangered land races was retained. Consideration was given to the problems of evaluating accessions more broadly, to computerizing the information, to long-term seed storage, to the establishment of a global network of genetic resource centres, and to the respective roles of the various kinds of collection. Throughout the late sixties and early seventies it was the Panel of Experts under Otto's activist chairmanship, and Erna Bennett within FAO, who kept the genetic resources issues alive. As Otto wrote later: 'Conservationists who became so concerned in the eighties when the battle was essentially over were notably uninterested when their publicity might have been invaluable' (127).
Otto published several papers on genetic resources issues through this period, many of them aimed at increasing public awareness of the problems. One of the finest of these – in the estimation of Soulé and Mills [19] – was his Macleay Memorial Lecture entitled 'Variation – the essence of life' (77), in which he argues that the scale of human impact on genetic variation within both domesticated and natural communities is now such that we can no longer claim evolutionary innocence: 'We have acquired evolutionary responsibility' and must develop an 'evolutionary ethic'.
A conference of experts was convened at Beltsville, USA in 1972, to consider the proposal of the IBP/FAO Panel of Experts for the establishment of a network of regional genetic resource centres plus a coordinating centre to recommend priorities and organize training and other activities of the network, which would be associated with FAO. Otto was invited to present the report of the Beltsville meeting to the Technical Advisory Committee of the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) in April 1972.
Two months later Otto unexpectedly found himself given an opportunity to address the United Nations Conference for the Human Environment, in Stockholm, on genetic resources. He had been asked by FAO to prepare a background paper on this subject for the conference, with recommendations. Several delegates moved the adoption of these recommendations, and another requested that Otto be allowed to address the conference. He relished the opportunity, his recommendations were adopted in Articles 39-45 [20], and the world's news media carried his message. He became a cult figure at Stockholm and genetic resources became an international issue, requiring consideration by national governments and inviting the concern of public interest groups. The genetic conservation wave began to roll, fourteen years before the term 'biodiversity' was coined.
In 1973 the CGIAR established an International Board for Plant Genetic Resources (IBPGR). Otto, who was widely expected to be the first chairman of the Board, was not even a member. Moreover, FAO, which had sponsored the cause of genetic conservation when no other organization did so, abandoned its own Panel of Experts once IBPGR was established. Although the panel members had expected their accumulated experience in the area to be retained, the Panel was barred from contact by the Board, and disappeared (128). A round-up technical conference was held in Rome in 1973, the proceedings being edited by Otto and Professor J.G. Hawkes (88).
Otto's most widely admired and influential paper, 'Genetic conservation: our evolutionary responsibility' (84), presented at the 13th International Congress of Genetics in Berkeley, had already been published. Regarded by M.J.D. White 'as a landmark in the cultural evolution of the human species', and by Soulé and Mills as 'prophetic...(presenting) the conceptual and moral agenda for the discipline of conservation genetics', this paper signalled the end of Otto's most active, creative and influential role in the genetic resources movement. Otto then collaborated with Michael Soulé in the writing of Conservation and Evolution (109). Published in 1981, this was a pioneering book, particularly in placing the genetic resources movement within the wider context of the conservation of biological diversity and of the opportunity for continuing evolution.
Otto was now freer to speak out on genetic resources issues as he continued to think and write about them. He urged greater activity by the national gene banks (128) and more comprehensive evaluation and documentation of accessions. He proposed the use of representative 'core collections' as being more accessible for plant breeders (118). Nevertheless, Otto had always regarded the global network of base collections as the backbone of the genetic conservation strategy, and was appalled when one of his erstwhile colleagues suggested a shift of emphasis to the national collections. At the age of 90 he still responded vigorously (140). He had earlier engaged in public debate with P.R. Mooney on the subject of 'farmers' rights', and in 1988 locked horns with J.R. Kloppenberg and others on the 'sovereignty of seeds' and our 'genetic debts' to developing countries (131). He expressed his views on the FAO International Undertaking, on the Commission on Plant Genetic Resources, and on the Keystone International Dialogue (137). He became less and less sanguine about the role of botanic gardens in genetic conservation, and more and more convinced of the benefits of in situ conservation of wild species, while remaining unsure to the very end on where to draw the line between the impossible goal of conserving everything and the utilitarian approach of conserving only species of likely usefulness.
Otto's views on several issues in genetic conservation evolved, but his commitment to the effective conservation and use of genetic resources never wavered. However, there were times when the populist excesses and errors of Mooney, the genetic debts movement and the FAO commission made him want to dissociate himself from the issue: 'I sometimes wonder whether the ideas of the early days – which became the Genetic resources dogma – did harm through overstatement and over-acceptance' [21]. When political fashion and rhetoric displaced reasoned debate, or when bureaucratization and management issues predominated, he often wished to quit but continued to debate them to the very end. He was a worthy successor to Vavilov, and took great pleasure in the decision of the erstwhile IBPGR to establish a Vavilov-Frankel Fellowship Program in genetic resources, with the first awards in 1993. At 95 years of age Otto, with two younger colleagues A.H.D. Brown and J. Burdon, published The Conservation of Plant Biodiversity (142).
Other activities related to science
In New Zealand throughout the 1930s and 1940s, Otto was an outspoken advocate of high-quality basic research. He was elected to fellowship of the Royal Society of New Zealand in 1948, of the Royal Society of London in 1953 and of the Australian Academy of Science in 1954, becoming vice-president of the latter in 1959/60. He once observed, somewhat ruefully: 'I tend to be held at the Vice-presidential level, being too unpredictable to be made President'.
In 1956, when designs for an Academy building were first being discussed, a sketch in the classical style, decorated with columns, was produced by a member of Council. Otto found it appalling and suggested that a design committee should be appointed [22]. Otto, as a member of the committee under the chairmanship of the President, Sir Mark Oliphant, sought advice on architects to be approached and procedures to be followed and chaired the meeting at which the design by Grounds, Romberg and Boyd was recommended to Council. Otto was then appointed to the Building Committee where, as he later put it: 'In everything I was concerned with style and Oliphant with quality and I think we made a very good team'.
The bold, modern, symbolic design of the Academy dome delighted him. In his tribute to Roy Grounds [23] he wrote: 'The Academy building helped to generate a corporate consciousness and, thanks to its architectural distinction, it enhanced a growing pride in the Academy. For the public it became a symbol of Australian science.' Otto had enjoyed working with Roy Grounds. He became a close friend and Otto and Margaret asked him to design their third house, built in 1971.
In the early 1960s when the International Biological Program was first being discussed, Otto had been an outspoken critic of the proposed projects. However, he was persuaded by R.N. Robertson to convene the Academy's ad hoc committee to report on the advisability of Australian participation in the IBP. Given the strength of local research in many areas of the IBP, Otto's committee recommended that Australia should take an active part, and Otto was made chairman of the National Committee for IBP. Despite his early reservations, he provided sustained and dynamic leadership of the Australian efforts, and was a member of ICSU's Special Committee for IBP.
Through his service on Council and on several committees, Otto had opportunities to shape the practices as well as the architecture of the Academy. In his 1972 Falk memorial lecture (79), Otto had suggested the establishment of a 'Science and Society Forum' by the Academy, to concern itself with scientific issues of likely or emerging public impact and to provide a forum where 'dissent and constructive criticism are given the orderly freedoms of institutionalization'. The first such Forum, however, was not under his chairmanship and proved to be disastrously disorderly and the experiment was abandoned [24].
In 1979, Otto was appointed chairman of a committee of review to report to the 25th anniversary meeting of the Academy on the appropriateness of its activities and structure for the next decades. Here the canvas was much wider and the committee made a lot of recommendations for change, many of which were acted upon. 'Whatever the Academy is now, it ought to be something better', was the attitude Otto took to the review. He wished the Academy to become more outward-looking and responsive in its second quarter-century and, looking back later, he felt it had.
Sir Otto (far left, holding the basic science poster), participating in a protest against cuts in government funding for research, at the age of 89.
The man
Complex, mercurial, charismatic, acerbic, persuasive, polarizing, practical, ironical, elegant, concerned: these are some of the adjectives that spring to mind when colleagues and friends recall Otto. His complex mixture of practical peasant and intellectual aristocrat flowered when he played host in the elegant houses and gardens he and Margaret had created. Clunies Ross had once suggested that the corner of the CSIRO land where Otto hoped to build his second house was not regarded as an appropriate environment for a Chief, to which Otto replied: 'We don't mind. We make our own environment' – which they did.
Whatever opinion you expressed, whatever side of an issue you took, he would challenge it to sharpen both your thinking and his, a practice he learned from his uncle Joseph Niemirovski. Where some focus on points of agreement, Otto homed in on points of disagreement. It could be tiresome, but also illuminating, because he was quick and resourceful in debate and liked to test all facets of any idea. Arguments with Otto were 'energetic', as Boswell found those with Dr Johnson. Such a man does not have heroes. He would always want to argue with them. He told me he had none, but for many years there were photographs of Clunies Ross, Darlington, Dobzhansky and Vavilov displayed in his offices. They were friends, and they had influenced him at various stages, 'played God in his life' as he had with others.
His friends were mostly men and mostly scientific colleagues. Science was important to him, but so also were music and the arts, architecture and skiing, in all of which he had cherished friends. He particularly relished the company of young colleagues who would argue with him irreverently yet seriously about their research and his, and about science in general. Otto cherished these generations of intellectual offspring, not having had children of his own.
He also enjoyed meeting the great and famous but once wrote to a social scientist: 'I am no longer top brass, which in my eyes I never was, nor do I feel the need to listen to it. It might be a problem for your consideration why inescapably we turn to the Establishment when we organize a serious discussion of social problems...I hope I am right in thinking that in the natural sciences on the whole we have slightly better ways of discerning and using talent at a less exalted level' [25].
Otto was always quick to remind protégés of the dangers of the 'slippery slope' away from the real world of science, whenever they were tempted to take on organizational responsibilities or international commitments. Life was theatre for him, and like Picasso he would play games with people, especially those he cared about. Picasso's reply to Max Jacob as to why he did this could have come from Otto: 'Since I cared very much about my friends, it seemed to me I should put our friendship to the test every once in a while just to make sure it was as strong as it needed to be' [26].
Whenever Otto called himself a peasant, it was partly out of pride in his practicality. He enjoyed the manual skills needed in cytological work, 'doing his root tips' as his wife referred to it, and he often noted the absence of such skills in his colleagues with surprise. Dobzhansky was 'clumsy', while Vavilov was 'not terribly good on techniques, and plant breeding with which I was familiar was not second nature to him' [27], a comment as revealing of Otto as of Vavilov. One look at Otto's hands, or at his gardening tools, sufficed to indicate that he was a practical man, expert in the arts of pruning (both plants and people). At the entrance to the Canberra phytotron he had inscribed 'Cherish the earth for man will live by it forever', which truly reflected his values and concern for the world's resources. He cherished his garden and the fruits of it, even the imperfect ones. He was a true husbandman.
Music was also important to him and even in his nineties he enjoyed hearing new compositions. Trout fishing was, for a time, a consuming hobby, in which he enjoyed playing the fish, much as he enjoyed playing his colleagues at times. Besides gardening, skiing was his most abiding joy, which he practised whenever he could in Europe, New Zealand, Australia and the USA. Near the Blue Cow Club, which he helped to found at Guthega, there is a slope now called 'Sir Otto's run', on which he was to be seen each year until he was 90.
Otto's practicality was also expressed in his attitude to research. He was an unwavering proponent of the need for basic research, provided it was 'first class', as the key to enlarging our understanding of the world about us. His loyalty to CSIRO and to Clunies Ross derived from their support of that approach in the CSIRO culture of the 1950s, when he joined. Nevertheless, he was also an agriculturist at heart, deeply concerned with the world's food and population problems, and he encouraged long-term research with a bearing on those problems. The long term was his 'time scale of concern', and the internationality of science his delight.
Humane was an important word in Otto's vocabulary. Not having grown up with English as his native language, he savoured his subsequent mastery of it and was resourceful in his use of words. His early exposure to Jane Austen left its mark on his unremitting search for elegance of expression, fine manners, and love of irony, the salt of life to him. Always fluent and persuasive in speech, especially extempore speeches such as his address to the Stockholm conference in 1972, he nevertheless laboured hard – with pencil, eraser and scotch tape – on his written drafts. To the end of his career, he envied those scientists who wrote with an elegant style, such as E.O. Wilson and his colleague J.R. Philip. Elegance of expression was as significant for him as perpetual challenge, and he sought both to the very end.
In old age he remained determinedly active, alert, involved and irreverent, consciously exercising both his body and his mind. He would 'not go gentle into that good night', as Dylan Thomas had urged his own father. He died on 21 November 1998.
Degrees and honours
- D. Agr. (Berlin, 1925)
- D. Sc. (New Zealand, 1951)
- FRS NZ (1948)
- FRS (1953)
- FAA (1954)
- Knight Bachelor (1966)
- Correspondant Štranger, French Academy of Agricultural Science (1969)
- Honorary Life Fellow, Pacific Science Association (1979)
- Distinguished Economic Botanist (1983)
- Honorary Member, The Japan Academy (1983)
- Foreign Associate, US National Academy of Science (1988)
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol.12, no.4, 1999. A shorter version of this memoir is also published in Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society of London, 1999. It was written by L.T. Evans, Honorary Research Fellow, CSIRO Division of Plant Industry, Canberra, ACT.
Acknowledgements
Reminiscences and comments from many colleagues and friends of Otto and Margaret have shaped this memoir. For detailed comments on earlier drafts I am grateful to Dr R.D. Brock, Dr A.H.D. Brown, Professor R.W. Home, Dr Elizabeth Whitcombe and Professor S.G. Wildman. The photographic portrait of Otto was taken in his seventies by Colin Totterdell; that of him participating in the protest was published in Search, 21(2) (1990), 47.
Notes and references
- McCarthy, G. (1985) Transcript in Frankel papers, to be deposited in the National Library of Australia, Canberra.
- Blythe, M. Videotaped interview, 15 September 1993, deposited in the Australian Academy of Science.
- Otto's aunt Ann and the Niemirovski estate at Koszylowce where he worked are described by Julia Namier in Lewis Namier, A Biography (London, 1971).
- Weisskopf, V. The Joy of Insight – Passions of a Physicist, (New York, 1991).
- In his book Styles of Scientific Thought: The German Genetics Community 1900-1933 (Chicago, 1993), J. Harwood describes the difference between the 'classical' and 'modern' schools of Germany and their relation to the later careers of German geneticists.
- Such frequent shifts from one university to another, and between subjects, were not uncommon in Germany at that time, cf. R.B. Goldschmidt, Portraits from Memory (Seattle, 1956).
- Schiemann, E., 'Erwin Baur', Berichte der Deutschen Botanischen Gesellschaft, 52 (1934), 51-114.
- Baur had come to genetics from the practice of psychiatry and believed that the new knowledge of genetics should also be applied to human populations and to the question of racial hygiene, as discussed by R.D. Harvey in 'Pioneers of genetics: A comparison of the attitudes of William Bateson and Erwin Baur to eugenics', Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London, 49 (1995), 105-117.
- The background to the establishment of the WRI and the work which led to it becoming one of the early successes of DSIR are described more fully in DSIR: Making Science Work for New Zealand, by Ross Galbreath (Wellington, 1998).
- White, M.J.D., 'Otto Frankel – contributions to wheat genetics', pp. 279-283 in Wheat Science – Today and Tomorrow, ed. L.T. Evans and W.J. Peacock (Cambridge, 1981).
- Frankel to S. Smith-White, 15 June 1954.
- Vavilov to E. Marsden, 29 September 1934. A notebook records the details of Otto's visits to the USSR and European wheat breeders.
- Copp, L.G.L., 'Wheat breeding in New Zealand', New Zealand Wheat Review, No. 10 (1967), 78-86.
- Frankel, O.H., 'The very human touch', pp. 131-135 in Ian Clunies Ross, Memoirs and Papers, with some Fragments of Autobiography (Melbourne, 1961).
- McCann, D.A. and Batterham, P., 'Australian genetics: a brief history', Genetica, 90 (1993), 81-114.
- Jacob, F., The Statue Within (Transl. F. Philip) (New York, 1988).
- Kuckuck, H., 'Neuere Arbeiten zur Entstehung der hexaploiden Kulturweizen', Zeitschrift fur Pflanzenzüchtung, 41 (1959), 205-226.
- Worthington, E.B., The Evolution of IBP (Cambridge, 1975).
- Soulé, M.F. and Mills, L.S., 'Conservation genetics and conservation biology: a troubled marriage', pp. 55-68 in Conservation of Biodiversity for Sustainable Development, ed. O.T. Sandlund, K. Hindar and A.H.D. Brown (Oslo, 1992).
- Pistorius, R., Scientists, Plants and Politics (Rome, 1997).
- Frankel to M.F. Day, 19 March 1985.
- Fenner, F., ed., The Australian Academy of Science: The First Forty Years (Canberra, 1995).
- Frankel, O.H., 'Sir Roy Grounds, 1905-1981', Historical Records of Australian Science, 5 (1982), 89-91.
- Johnston, R., 'Social responsibility of science: the social mirror of science', pp. 308-325 in MacLeod, R. (ed.) The Commonwealth of Science (Melbourne, 1988).
- Frankel to S. Encel, 20 November 1977.
- Gilot, F. and Lake, C., Life with Picasso (New York, 1964).
- Frankel to B.M. Cohen, 31 August 1977.
Bibliography
- 1925 Frankel, O.H. Faktorenkoppelung bei Pflanzen. Zeitschrift für induktive Abstammungs-und Verebungslehre 38: 324-348
- 1929 Baur, E., Herzberg-Frankel, O., Husfeld, B., Saulescu, N. and Schumann, E. Koppelungserscheinungen bei Antirrhinum majus. Zeitschrift für induktive Abstammungs-und Verebungslehre 50: 314-343
- 1929 Oppenheim, J.D., Frankel, O.H. Investigations into the fertilization of the 'Jaffa Orange'. I. Genetica 11: 369-374
- 1929 Frankel, O.H. Pflanzenzüchtung in Neuseeland. Der Züchter 1:9
- 1930 Genetics and plant-breeding. New Zealand Journal of Science & Technology 11: 401-408
- 1930 Frankel, O.H. Analytical yield investigations of New Zealand wheat. 1. Wheat Research Institute Annual Report pp. 42-59
- 1932 Frankel, O.H. Analytische Ertragsstudien an Gertreide. Der Züchter 4: 98-109
- 1933 Frankel, O.H. and Donald, H.P. Some critical observations on quality testing in wheat breeding. Proceedings of the World Grain Exhibition and Conference 2: 400-408
- 1933 Frankel, O.H. A case of mass-occurrence of non-inherited chlorophyll defects in wheat. Transactions of the Royal New Zealand Institute 63: 141-143
- 1934 Frankel, O.H. 'Cross 7' wheat. A new combination of high yield and baking-quality. Bulletin New Zealand Department Scientific Industrial Research 46
- 1935 Frankel, O.H. The differentiation of grain samples of closely related varieties of wheat by means of a simple mechanical test for grain quality. Journal of Agricultural Science 25: 461-465
- 1935 Frankel, O.H. Analytical yield investigations on New Zealand wheat. 2. Five years' analytical variety trials. Journal of Agricultural Science 25: 466-509
- 1937 Frankel, O.H. Inversions in Fritillaria. Journal of Genetics 34: 447-462
- 1937 Frankel, O.H. and Hair, J.B. Studies on the cytology, genetics and taxonomy of N.Z. Hebe and Veronica (Part 1). New Zealand Journal of Science Technology 18: 669-687
- 1937 Frankel, O.H. The nucleolar cycle in some species of Fritillaria. Cytologia 8: 37-47
- 1938 Frankel, O.H. The evolution of cultivated plants. Journal of the New Zealand Institute of Horticulture 8: 27-34
- 1938 Frankel, O.H. and Hair, J.B. Analytical yield investigations on N.Z. wheat. III. Nine years' observations on two varieties. New Zealand Journal of Science Technology 20A: 224-259
- 1939 Frankel, O.H. Tainui, a new spring wheat variety. New Zealand Journal of Science Technology 20A: 319-323
- 1939 Frankel, O.H. Analytical yield investigations on N.Z. wheat. IV. Blending varieties of wheat. Journal of Agricultural Science 29: 249-261
- 1940 Frankel, O.H. A critical survey of breeding wheat for baking quality. Journal of Agricultural Science 30: 98-112
- 1940 Frankel, O.H. Studies in Hebe. II. The significance of male sterility in the genetic system. Journal of Genetics 40: 171-184
- 1940 Frankel, O.H. The causal sequence of meiosis. I. Chiasma formation and the order of pairing in Fritillaria. Journal of Genetics 41: 9-34
- 1941 Frankel, O.H. Cytology and taxonomy of Hebe, Veronica and Pygmaea. Nature (London) 147: 117-118
- 1941 Frankel, O.H. 'Fife-Tuscan' wheat: a new variety for 'Tuscan land'. New Zealand Journal of Science and Technology 22A: 303-308
- 1947 Frankel, O.H. Plant collections. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 13: 122-124
- 1947 Boyce, S.W., Copp, L.G.L. and Frankel, O.H. The effects of selection for yield in wheat. Heredity 1: 223-233
- 1947 Frankel, O.H. The theory of plant breeding for yield. Heredity 1: 109-120
- 1948 Frankel, O.H. Hilgendorf wheat of outstanding baking quality. New Zealand Journal of Agriculture 76: 117-119
- 1948 Frankel, O.H. A new high-yielding wheat variety – WRI-yielder. New Zealand Journal of Agriculture 76: 221-222
- 1948 Frankel, O.H. Wheat varieties in New Zealand. Canterbury Chamber of Commerce Agricultural Bulletin No. 22
- 1948 Frankel, O.H. and Fraser, A.S. Basal sterile mutants in speltoid wheat. Heredity 2: 291-397
- 1949 Frankel, O.H. A self-propagating structural change in Triticum. I. Duplication and crossing-over. Heredity 3: 163-194
- 1949 Frankel, O.H. A self-propagating structural change in Triticum. II. The reproductive cycle. Heredity 3: 293-317
- 1950 Frankel, O.H. The development and maintenance of superior genetic stocks. Heredity 4: 89-102
- 1950 Frankel, O.H. A polymeric multiple gene change in hexaploid wheat. Heredity 4: 103-116
- 1951 Frankel, O.H. The multiple mutation in wheat. Heredity 5: 349
- 1954 Frankel, O.H. Genetic adaptation of cultivated plants in Australia. Proceedings Pan Indian Ocean Science Congress pp. 71-74
- 1954 Frankel, O.H. Invasion and evolution of plants in Australia and New Zealand. Caryologia Supplement 6: 600-609.
- 1957 Frankel, O.H. The biological system of plant introduction. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 23: 302-307
- 1958 Frankel, O.H. The biological system of plant introduction. Indian Journal of Genetics and Plant Breeding 17: 336-342
- 1958 Frankel, O.H. The dynamics of plant breeding. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 24: 112-123
- 1958 Frankel, O.H. and Williams, J.D. A record of natural crossing in subterranean clover. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 24: 162-163
- 1958 Frankel, O.H., Gani, R. and Munday, A. Two independent gene systems for floral induction in wheat. Proceedings 10th International Congress of Genetics 2: 86
- 1959 Frankel, O.H. Variation under domestication. Australian Journal of Science 22: 27-32
- 1959 Morley, F.H.W. and Frankel, O.H. An ecogenetic research program with introduced plants. Monographiae Biologicae 8: 577-586
- 1960 Brock, R.D. and Frankel, O.H. Plant improvement. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 26: 170-182
- 1960 Frankel, O.H. and Munday, A. The genetics of floral development in wheat. Journal of the Wheat Information Service, Biology Laboratory, Kyoto University 11: 1-3
- 1961 Frankel, O.H. The F.A.O. Freedom from Hunger Campaign. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 27: 79-84
- 1962 Frankel, O.H. Agricultural science and productivity in the next decade – plant science. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 28: 84-91
- 1962 Frankel, O.H. and Munday, A. The evolution of wheat. In: The Evolution of Living Organisms (Royal Society of Victoria, Melbourne) pp. 173-180
- 1963 Frankel, O.H. Agricultural scientists among scientists. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 29: 95-103
- 1963 Frankel, O.H. Concluding remarks – the next decade. In: Environmental Control of Plant Growth (L.T. Evans ed., New York, Academic Press) pp. 439-441
- 1963 Frankel, O.H. The social responsibility of agricultural science. Australian Journal of Science 25: 301-307
- 1963 Frankel, O.H. and Munday, A. Canalization of flower morphogenesis in wheat. Proceedings XIth International Congress Genetics 1: 10.31
- 1963 Frankel, O.H. The role of long range research in agricultural development. Proceedings of the World Food Congress, 4-18 June, 1963. FAO, Rome.
- 1964 Barnard, C. and Frankel, O.H. Grass, grazing animals, and man in historic perspective. In: Grasses and Grasslands (C. Barnard ed.) (London: Macmillan) pp. 1-12
- 1965 Frankel, O.H. Agricultural education for research workers. Agricultural Education. (Australian Institute of Agricultural Science, Melbourne) pp. 35-41
- 1966 Frankel, O.H. Adaptability of crops. New Scientist 31: 144-145
- 1966 Frankel, O.H. Internationalism in agricultural science. Australian Journal of Science 28: 314-320
- 1966 Frankel, O.H. The international biological program. Australian Journal of Science 28: 324-325
- 1967 Frankel, O.H. Guarding the plant-breeder's treasury. New Scientist 35: 538-540
- 1968 Frankel, O.H. Human welfare and international cooperation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science of the United States of America 60: 33-41
- 1968 Frankel, O.H. International collaboration in plant exploration and conservation. Journal of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science 34: 22-27
- 1968 Frankel, O.H. Man in the biosphere – an international study. In: Biology in the Modern World (Canberra: Australian Academy of Science) pp. 4-12
- 1968 Frankel, O.H. and Shineberg, B. The genetic system of basal fertility in wheat. Proceedings 3rd International Wheat Genetics Symposium (Canberra: Australian Academy of Science) pp. 279-281
- 1969 Frankel, O.H. Pacific centres of genetic diversity. Malayan Forester 32: 356-360
- 1969 Frankel, O.H. The dynamics of plant breeding. In: Proceedings XII International Congress Genetics (C. Oshima ed.) 3: 309-325
- 1969 Frankel, O.H., Shineberg, B. and Munday, A. The genetic basis of an invariant character in wheat. Heredity 24: 571-591
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. Genetic conservation of plants useful to man. Biological Conservation 2: 162-169
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. Genetic dangers in the green revolution. World Agriculture 19: 9-13
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. Save the genetic treasuries in the Sabrao region. Sabrao Newsletter 2: 1-6
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. and Bennett, E. (eds.) Genetic resources in plants – their exploration and conservation. In: Genetic Resources in Plants – Their Exploration and Conservation (Blackwell: Oxford and Edinburgh) IBP Handbook 11, 554 pp.
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. Preface. In: Genetic Resources in Plants – Their Exploration and Conservation (O.H. Frankel and E. Bennett, eds.) (Blackwell: Oxford and Edinburgh) IBP Handbook 11, pp. 1-4
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. and Bennett, E. Genetic resources. In: Genetic Resources in Plants – Their Exploration and Conservation (O.H. Frankel and E. Bennett, eds.) (Blackwell: Oxford and Edinburgh) IBP Handbook 11, pp. 7-17
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. Evaluation and utilization – introductory remarks. In: Genetic Resources in Plants – Their Exploration and Conservation (O.H. Frankel and E. Bennett, eds.) (Blackwell: Oxford and Edinburgh) IBP Handbook 11, pp. 395-401
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. Genetic conservation in perspective. In: Genetic Resources in Plants – Their Exploration and Conservation (O.H. Frankel and E. Bennett, eds.) (Blackwell: Oxford and Edinburgh) IBP Handbook 11, pp. 469-489
- 1970 Frankel, O.H. Variation – the essence of life. Proceedings of the Linnean Society of New South Wales 95: 158-169
- 77a. 1971 Frankel, O.H. The International Biological Program. Frontier Research on our Biosphere. The Australian Science Teachers Journal 17: 13-19
- 1972 Frankel, O.H. Australia and the international biological program. Search (Sydney) 3: 105-108
- 1972 Frankel, O.H. Genetic conservation – a parable of the scientist's social responsibility. Search (Sydney) 3: 193-201
- 1972 Frankel, O.H. Only one earth: the United Nations conference on the human environment, Stockholm, 5-16 June 1972. Search (Sydney) 3: 406-408
- 1973 Frankel, O.H. Introduction. In: Survey of Crop Genetic Resources in Their Centres of Diversity (O.H. Frankel, ed.) (Rome: FAO/IBP) pp. ix-xiv
- 1973 Frankel, O.H. (ed.) Survey of Crop Genetic Resources in Their Centres of Diversity (Rome: FAO/IBP) 164 pp.
- 1973 Frankel, O.H. The citizen in the knowledgeable society. Public Administration 32(2): 128-130
- 1974 Frankel, O.H. Genetic conservation – our evolutionary responsibility. Proceedings XIII International Congress Genetics 78: 53-65
- 1975 Frankel, O.H. Base-sterile speltoids – the location of the Bs gene of Triticum aestivum. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B Biological Sciences 188: 163-166
- 1975 Frankel, O.H. Conservation in perpetuity: ecological and biosphere reserves. In: A National System of Ecological Reserves in Australia (F. Fenner, ed.) (Report 19) (Canberra: Australian Academy of Science) pp. 7-10
- 1975 Frankel, O.H. Genetic conservation – why and how. In: South East Asian Plant Genetic Resources (J.T. Williams, C.H. Lamoureux and N. Wulijarni-Soetjipto, eds.), Proceedings Symposium Bogor, 1975 (Bogor: International Board for Plant Genetic Resources and others) pp. 16-32
- 1975 Frankel, O.H. and Hawkes, J.G. (eds.) Crop Genetic Resources for Today and Tomorrow (International Biological Programme 2) (London: Cambridge University Press) 492 pp.
- 1975 Frankel, O.H. and Hawkes, J.G. Genetic resources – the past ten years and the next. In: Crop Genetic Resources for Today and Tomorrow (O.H. Frankel and J.G. Hawkes, eds.) (International Biological Programme 2) (London: Cambridge University Press) pp. 1-11
- 1975 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources survey as a basis for exploration. In: Crop Genetic Resources for Today and Tomorrow (O.H. Frankel and J.G. Hawkes, eds.) (International Biological Programme 2) (London: Cambridge University Press) pp. 99-109
- 1975 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources centres – a cooperative global network. In: Crop Genetic Resources for Today and Tomorrow (O.H. Frankel and J.G. Hawkes, eds.) (International Biological Programme 2) (London: Cambridge University Press) pp. 473-481
- 1975 Frankel, O.H. and Roskams, M.A. Stability of floral differentiation in Triticum. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B Biological Sciences 188: 139-162
- 1976 Frankel, O.H. Biological structure of the landscape. In: Man and Landscape in Australia – Towards an Ecological Vision (G. Seddon and M. Davis, eds.), Symposium Canberra 1974, Australian UNESCO Committee for Man and the Biosphere, Publication 2 (Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service) pp. 49-62
- 1976 Frankel, O.H. Floral initiation in wheat. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B Biological Sciences 192: 273-298
- 1976 Frankel, O.H. IRRI phytotron – science in the service of human welfare. In: Proceedings of the Symposium on Climate and Rice (Los Baños, Philippines: International Rice Research Institute) pp. 3-9
- 1976 Frankel, O.H. The time scale of concern. In: Conservation of Threatened Plants (J.B. Simmoons, R.I. Beyer, P.E. Brandham, G.L. Lucas and V.T.H. Parry, eds.) (New York: Plenum Press) pp. 245-248
- 1977 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources. Annals of the New York Academy of Science 287: 332-344
- 1977 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources as the backbone of plant protection. In: Induced Mutations Against Plant Diseases, Proceedings of a symposium held in Vienna 1977 (Vienna: International Atomic Energy Agency) pp. 3-12
- 1977 Frankel, O.H. Natural variation and its conservation. In: Genetic Diversity in Plants (A. Muhammed, R. Askel and R.C. von Borstel, eds.) (New York: Plenum Press) pp. 21-44
- 1978 Frankel, O.H. Value of wilderness to science. Proceedings National Wilderness Conference, Canberra. ed. G. Mosley, Australian Conservation Foundation. pp. 101-105
- 1978 Frankel, O.H. Germplasm 'preservation'. Plant Genetic Resources Newsletter No. 34: 18-19
- 1978 Frankel, O.H. Natural resources and technology – evaluation, use and conservation of biological resources. Proceedings 3rd Inter-Congress Pacific Science Association (Bali, Indonesia: July 1977) pp. 303-323
- 1978 Frankel, O.H. Philosophy and strategy of genetic conservation in plants. Forest Tree Breeding. In: Third World Consultation of Forest Tree Breeding, Canberra 1977, Documents (Canberra: CSIRO) 1: pp. 2-11
- 1978 Frankel, O.H. Biosphere reserves: the philosophy of conservation. In: Conservation and Agriculture (J.G. Hawkes, ed.) Duckworth, London. pp. 101-106
- 1978 Frankel, O.H. Conservation of crop genetic resources and their wild relatives: an overview. In: Conservation and Agriculture (J.G. Hawkes, ed.) Duckworth, London. pp. 123-149
- 1980 Frankel, O. Our evolutionary responsibility. UNESCO Courier, May 1980 pp. 25-27
- 1980 Frankel, O.H. Trees in the Australian rural landscape. In: Focus on Farm Trees. The Decline of Trees in the Rural Landscape (N.M. Oates, P.J. Greig, D.G. Hill, P.A. Langley and A.J. Reid, eds), Proceedings of a National Conference, Melbourne 1980 (Melbourne:Organising Committee) pp. 14-18
- 1981 Frankel, O.H. Evolution in jeopardy: the role of nature reserves. In: Evolution and Speciation: Essays in Honor of M.J.D. White (Atchley, W.R. and D.S. Woodruff, eds.) (Cambridge University Press: New York.) pp. 417-24
- 1981 Frankel, O.H. and Soule, M.E. (eds.) Conservation and Evolution. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) 327 pp.
- 1981 Frankel, O.H., Knox, R.B. and Considine, J.A. Development of the wheat flower: genetics and physiology. In: Wheat Science – Today and Tomorrow (L.T. Evans and W.J. Peacock, eds.) (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) pp. 167-190
- 1981 Frankel, O.H. Definition of gene pools. In: Evolution Today. Proceedings of the 2nd International Congress of Systematic and Evolutionary Biology. (G.G.E. Scudder and J.L. Reveal, eds.) Hunt Institute of Botanical Documentation, Pittsburgh. pp. 385-386
- 1981 Frankel, O.H. Maintenance of Gene Pools: Sense and Nonsense. In: Evolution Today (G.G.E. Scudder and J.L. Reveal, eds.) pp. 387-392
- 1982 Considine, J.A., Knox, R.B. and Frankel, O.H. Stereological analysis of floral development and quantitative histochemistry of nucleic acids in fertile and base-sterile varieties of wheat. Annals of Botany (London) 50: 647-663
- 1982 Frankel, O.H. Role of conservation genetics in the conservation of rare species. In: Species at Risk: Research in Australia (R.H. Groves and W.D.L. Ride, eds.) pp. 159-162
- 1982 Frankel, O.H. Can genetic diversity survive? Advances in Cytogenetics and Crop Improvement (R.B. Singh, R.M. Singh and B.D. Singh, ed.) Kalyani, New Delhi.
- 1983 Frankel, O.H. The place of management in conservation. In: Genetics and Conservation (C.M. Schonewald-Cox, S.M. Chambers, B. MacBryde and W.L. Thomas, eds.) pp. 1-14
- 1984 Frankel, O.H. Genetic diversity, ecosystem conservation and evolutionary responsibility. In: Ecology in Practice. Part l: Ecosystem Management (F. Di Castri, F.W.G. Baker and M. Hadley, eds.) (Dublin/UNESCO Paris: Tycooly International Publishing Limited) pp. 414-427
- 1984 Frankel, O.H. Genetic perspectives of germplasm conservation. In: Genetic Manipulation: Impact on Man and Society (W. Arber, K. Illemensee, W.J. Peacock and P. Starlinger, eds.) (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) pp. 161-170
- 1984 Frankel, O.H. Genetic principles of in situ preservation of plant resources. In: Conservation of Tropical Plant Resources, Proceedings Regional Workshop on Conservation of Tropical Plant Resources in South-East Asia, New Delhi, 1982 pp. 55-65
- 1984 Frankel, O.H. and Brown, A.H.D. Current plant genetic resources a critical appraisal. In: Genetics : New Frontiers, Volume IV Applied Genetics, Proceedings XV International Congress of Genetics, New Delhi, 1983, V.L. Chopra, B.C. Joshi, R.P. Sharma and H.C. Bansal, eds.) (New Delhi: Oxford and IBH Publishing Co) pp. 3-13)
- 1984 Frankel, O.H., Brown, A.D.H. Plant Genetic resources today: a critical appraisal. In: Crop Genetic Resources: Conservation and Evolution (J.H.W. Holden and J.T. Williams, eds.) (Allen & Unwin, London).
- 1985 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources: the founding years [Part One]. Diversity 7: 26-29
- 1985 Frankel, O.H. Into the second decade: genetic resources and the plant breeder. Proceedings International Symposium South East Asian Plant Genetic Resources, Jakarta, 1985 (K.L. Mehra and S. Sastrapradja, eds.) pp. 26-31
- 1986 Frankel, O.H. Conservation – science, ethics and society. N.W. Briton Oration, Queensland Agricultural College, 1986, 8 pp.
- 1986 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources – museum or utility. In: Plant Breeding Symposium DSIR 1986, Agronomy Society NZ, Special Publication 5: 3-8
- 1986 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources: the founding years. Part Two: the movement's constituent assembly. Diversity 8: 30-32
- 1986 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources: the founding years. Part Three: the long road to the International Board. Diversity 9: 30-33
- 1987 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources: the founding years Part Four: after twenty years. Diversity 11: 25-27
- 1987 Frankel, O.H. Nikolai Ivanovich Vavilov 1887-1943: a memoir. Plant Genetic Resources Newsletter 72: 1-2
- 1987 Frankel, O.H., Gerlach, W.L. and Peacock, W.J. The ribosomal RNA genes in synthetic tetraploids of wheat. Theoretical and Applied Genetics 75: 138-143
- 1988 Frankel, O.H. Genetic resources: evolutionary and social responsibilities. In: Seeds and Sovereignty – The Use and Control of Genetic Resources (J.R. Kloppenburg (Jr), ed.) pp. 19-46
- 1988 Frankel, O.H. Nikolai Ivanovich Vavilov 1887-1943 a memoir. FAO/IBPGR Plant Genetic Research Newsletter 72: 1-2
- 1989 Appels, R., Reddy, P., McIntyre, C.L., Moran, L.B., Frankel, O.H. and Clarke, B.C. The molecular – cytogenetic analysis of grasses and its application to studying relationships among species of the Triticeae. Genome 31: 122-133
- 1989 Brown, A.H.D., Frankel, O.H., Marshall, D.R. and Williams, J.T. (eds.) The Use of Plant Genetic Resources (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) 382 pp.
- 1989 Frankel, O.H. Principles and strategies of evaluation. In: The Use of Plant Genetic Resources (A.H.D. Brown, O.H. Frankel, D.R. Marshall and J.T. Williams, eds.) (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) pp. 245-260
- 1989 Frankel, O.H. Point of view: perspectives on genetic resources. In: CIMMYT 1988 Annual Report: Delivering Diversity (International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center: Mexico) pp. 10-17
- 1989 Frankel, O.H. The Keystone international dialogue on plant genetic resources: A scientist's evaluation. Diversity 5: 59-60
- 1990 Frankel, O.H. Cultivation and conservation. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 5: 129-130
- 1990 Frankel, O.H. Germplasm conservation and utilization in horticulture. In: Horticultural Biotechnology (Wiley-Liss, Inc.) pp. 5-17
- 1990 Frankel, O.H. The future of the global genetic resources network: Activation or dissolution? Diversity 6: 59-60
- 1995 Frankel, O.H., Burdon, J.J. and Peacock, W.J. Landraces in Transit – The threat perceived. Diversity 11(3): 14-15
- 1995 Frankel, O.H. Brown, A.H.D. and J.J. Burdon. The Conservation of Plant Biodiversity. Cambridge University Press 500 pp.
Oscar Werner Tiegs 1897–1956
Professor Oscar Tiegs FAA FRS was a zoologist who traced the ancestry of insects to myriapod origins and uncovered a novel muscle type powering the extraordinary speed of Dipteran wings.
Oscar Werner Tiegs (1897–1956) was a Queensland-born zoologist whose research centred on neuro-muscular histology, arthropod embryology, and the flight muscles of insects.
Through an extensive series of studies on myriapod and insect development, he built the case for the myriapod-Campodea theory of insect ancestry, tracing insects' origins back through myriapods to a Peripatus-like precursor.
His work on wing musculature identified a previously unrecognised type of muscle in Diptera, in which rapid unfused contractions – rather than conventional tetanic shortening – drive their wings' unusual speed, and he further showed that the striations in this muscle run in a spiral, or helicoid, pattern.
He held the chair of Zoology at the University of Melbourne, was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1944, and was a Foundation Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science.
Download the memoir
Norman Alan Walker 1929–2013
Professor Alan Walker was a plant physiologist who developed pioneering electrophysiological methods to make major contributions to our understanding of how solutes are transported across plant cell membranes.
Alan Walker (he never used ‘Norman') developed pioneering electrophysiological methods to make major contributions to our understanding of mechanisms and energetics of transport of solutes across plant cell membranes. He used giant cells of characean algae to measure membrane electrical potential differences and conductances that were combined with measurements of fluxes of inorganic ions and organic nutrients obtained with radioactive tracers.
Alan built up a strong research group at the University of Sydney and had many external collaborations that considerably widened the scope of his research in relation to membrane biology of characean cells and well beyond. His considerable skills in mathematical modelling contributed significantly to research led by others on plant-fungal (mycorrhizal) symbiosis, movement of solutes through the cytoplasmic connections between plant cells (plasmodesmata), the membrane transport mechanisms that regulate the release of nutrients from coats of developing legume seeds, and even nutrient cycling in Arctic ecosystems.
Alan had strong political views and definite aesthetic tastes that included aspects of visual arts (ceramics and impressionist paintings) and music. He was very interested in good food and wine, and other interests included vertebrate palaeontology and bird-watching. He had many friends with similar tastes, who share fond memories of him.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 26(2), 2015. It was written by F. Andrew Smith and Mary J. Beilby.
Nancy Fanny Millis 1922–2012
Professor Emeritus Nancy Millis AC MBE FAA FTSE was a trailblazing scientist who broke barriers as one of Melbourne's first women professors. She pioneered microbiology in Australia and shaped the nation's genetic technology regulation over 20 years.
Professor Emeritus Nancy Millis AC MBE FAA FTSE died on 29 September 2012 at the age of 90.
She was one of the first women to be appointed professor at the University of Melbourne, had been president of the Australian Society for Microbiology and after her retirement was chancellor at La Trobe University.
Nancy introduced the teaching of industrial microbiology into Australia and by her research and involvement with various organisations promoted a continuing analysis of water utilisation and the environment.
She will also be remembered for her role, over 20 years, in guiding the committees responsible for overseeing the development of recombinant DNA research in Australia. Her tireless dedication to the service of others, her wit and her forthright approach endeared her to many.
Nancy Millis was elected to the Australian Academy of Science in 2004 by Special Election in recognition of her conspicuous service to the cause of science with her outstanding career in microbiology.
This report chronicles some of the very significant and far-reaching contributions that Nancy made to the discipline of microbiology and to the larger Australian community during her long and very productive life.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 24(2), 2013. It was written by A. J. Pittard.
Mollie Elizabeth Holman 1930–2010
Professor Mollie Holman was a physiologist who advanced understanding of how the autonomic nervous system controls smooth muscle at a cellular level.
Mollie Holman was a biophysicist whose work on the autonomic nervous system and the innervation of smooth muscle was seminal in advancing knowledge of its behaviour at a cellular level.
She was particularly known for her technical expertise in microelectrode recording of membrane potential from single smooth muscle cells, and the interpretation of their electrical activity, both spontaneous and in response to transmitters released from their autonomic nerves.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 24(2), 2013. It was written by Elspeth M. McLachlan and G. David S. Hirst.
Michael James Denham White 1910-1983
Michael White put chromosomes into evolutionary thinking and made a primary contribution to the emerging neo-Darwinian evolutionary synthesis. He emphasised cytogenetic systems and argued that genic and chromosomal evolution were of seminal importance in the process of speciation and evolution. His major scientific contribution was Animal Cytology and Evolution (1945), a book that summarised, analysed and synthesised current information on animal chromosomes.
Written by W.J. Peacock and D. McCann.
- Place in science
- Early life and education
- Early scientific career
- The United States—science and politics
- Australia—an intellectual and cultural home
- Research on morabine grasshoppers
- Stasipatric speciation
- Epilogue
- Awards and positions
- About this memoir
Place in science
Michael White put chromosomes into evolutionary thinking and made a primary contribution to the emerging neo-Darwinian evolutionary synthesis. He emphasised cytogenetic systems and argued that genic and chromosomal evolution were of seminal importance in the process of speciation and evolution. His major scientific contribution was Animal Cytology and Evolution (1945), a book that summarised, analysed and synthesised current information on animal chromosomes. White held a somewhat parallel place in cytogenetics to C.D. Darlington, whose book Recent Advances in Cytology (1932, 1937) had earlier synthesized observations on plant chromosomes. For many years from the late 1930s there was a lively competition between these two industrious, innovative and self-assertive figures. Undoubtedly White found satisfaction greater than that of science alone when (contra Darlington) he described an achiasmate meiosis in a mantid during his first period of research in the United States in the late 1930s.
White had an enormous personal capacity for research that was matched by a voracious appetite for the literature of his subject. He had an extraordinary ability to absorb and retain essential technical information, and this contributed towards the integrated approach he achieved in his books. White's contributions to Australian science were largely the result of his own research efforts. He was one of the most consistent and effective participants in meetings of the Genetics Society of Australia and of the Australian Entomological Society. Apart from the impressions that he made on students and other research workers in presenting his results and ideas, he contributed more generally to Australian science by taking a leading role in the Flora and Fauna Committee of the Australian Academy of Science in preparing policies for the development of the biological sciences in Australia. His concerns for taxonomic studies on the Australian fauna eventually led to the fauna work initially carried out by the Australian Biological Resources Study. White worked with colleagues such as Fenner, Waterhouse and Ride on these causes, and later was involved in the early plans for the development of a Museum of Australia. He was a strong advocate of the formation of a Research School of Biological Sciences in the Institute of Advanced Studies in the Australian National University.
Particularly in his later years, Michael White appeared a rather formidable person on first meeting. His unique voice and manner of speaking and somewhat craggy appearance belied what was underneath, an emotional, shy and endearing man for whom many people had a real affection. White was a major figure in the fields of cytology, genetics and evolution. In Australia, where he spent the major part of his scientific life, he was one of the principals in biology, one of a small group of individuals who brought new standards of rigour into Australian cytology and genetics. In presentations to professional societies, he set high standards both as to content and in his mode of delivery. He was a fine example for students and young scientists to emulate, although his manner of presentation was so unique that one was always tempted to listen to the way in which he said things rather than to what he was saying. He liked to be the centre of attention, to create a presence, but he had a wonderful sense of humour and his persona was always softened by mischievous comments and wry smiles. White was an erudite, literate man whose writings even on complex scientific subjects were a pleasure to read. Papers, grant proposals and books were always written longhand in the first draft, and more often than not his first draft was a close approximation to the last.
White's career involved work in many countries, but probably he identified principally with Australia and the country of his boyhood, Italy. In his last years Michael showed particular enthusiasm for Italy. He had been honoured by election to the Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, but in addition he had active research programmes that took him back to Italy several times. He organised a meeting for the Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei and was obviously delighted to be part of the senior scientific community of that Academy during the meeting, which involved visiting scientists from other parts of the world. His principal leisure activity, one of few, was to read the classics of Italian literature, in the language in which they were first published. It was a unique experience to travel in Italy with White and to benefit from the manifest pleasure he derived in imparting some of his knowledge and observations on the history and culture of the country.
Early life and education
Michael White was born in London on 20 August 1910 to James Kemp White and Una Chase White. James White made a modest living tutoring students who were about to enter Oxford and Cambridge universities or the civil Service, in mathematics, Greek and Latin. In 1915, when Michael was five years of age, the family migrated to the Tuscany region of Italy. His father, who held fairly bohemian values, did not favour a formal education for Michael and nurtured his education in the home environment. Although, as described in Michael's own writings, his father could not be regarded as having been a successful man in the formal sense, he apparently was a capable teacher and certainly inculcated a desire for the acquisition of knowledge in his son. Michael learned a great deal of natural history in his surroundings in Tuscany and even at the age of seven made some incisive observations on local insects and their life histories, and so gained an early interest in entomology. He was also a keen observer of the native flora and made collections in a systematic manner. His father fostered his developing interest in natural history by providing him with books on appropriate subjects. He admired his father greatly and was distressed when his father died when Michael was only 14 years of age. Before this the family had moved to southern France close to the Italian border, after five years in Italy. They lived a total of seven years in France, although during this period the major cultural influence remained that of Italy. As well as cultivating an interest in natural history, Michael had by this time formed an emotional attachment to Italy and the Italian people. After his father's death, an uncle supported Michael's interest in natural history and provided him with books on botany. His mother, loyal to her late husband's wishes, arranged that his schooling continue through a correspondence course with the University Correspondence College in Cambridge.
In 1927, after almost three years of secondary school studies by correspondence, Michael returned to London to study for a degree at University College (part of the University of London). He was initially disposed towards a botanical career, but under the influence of the Professor of Zoology, D.M.S. Watson, he became enthralled with the possibilities presented in this area of science. In particular, Michael was influenced by Watson's discussions on evolutionary biology and his interest was strengthened by a young lecturer of the College, Richard Palmer, who added a genetic aspect to Michael's thinking about evolution. In his third year of university life White made a special effort in entomological subjects, perhaps because of his childhood interests. He supplemented his University College studies with courses in entomology at the Royal College of Science, where one lecturer, O.W. Richards, had a particular influence. Richards lectured on evolution and discussed problems of the nature of species and speciation. Michael was awarded a prize for excelling in his third year and in choosing his gift made a decision that was to influence the direction of his whole career. Instead of receiving the Gold Medal to which he was entitled as a top student he chose instead to receive a copy of E.B. Wilson's classic book The Cell in Development and Heredity. Wilson's book influenced his choice of his first research topic. In his book Wilson mentioned that there were seeming contradictions between the genetic and cytological data concerning sex-linked inheritance in birds, so White decided to conduct an investigation into the chromosomes of the domestic chicken. Although he encountered technical difficulties in this study, it did confirm his interest in chromosomal and genetic questions. During these and subsequent studies at University College, he was able to take advantage of the University of London system and attend lectures in other colleges in various aspects of biology and evolution. In this way he was exposed to a variety of evolutionary ideas ranging from Lamarckian to Darwinian.
Early scientific career
White was awarded a Master of Science degree in 1932 for his cytogenetic studies in chickens. Probably the most important outcome of his Master's degree was that he became convinced that he had special interests and abilities in analyzing genetic and evolutionary matters from a chromosomal observational starting point. Given this realisation it was natural that he might turn to the Orthoptera (an insect group including grasshoppers, locusts, crickets, coackroaches etc.) for his subsequent studies because they presented excellent cytological advantages; in particular, large chromosomes.
His first studies also showed that his mind was attuned to the genetical implications of cytological phenomena. He studied the effect of external environmental factors on the frequency of recombination in grasshoppers, first by looking at the influence of temperature on chiasmata frequencies and later at the consequences of x-irradiation. These studies were important because they were experimental in character. This emphasis on experimentation was an underlying theme in all of White's subsequent research. However, what attracted him most were the puzzles presented by cytological observations on natural populations. He believed that seemingly anomalous observations were likely to provide a key to understanding the normal and later often referred to his 'treasured exceptions'. The first unusual situation that attracted him was the strict centromeric localization of chiasmata in Mecostethus, a grasshopper found in some of the sphagnum bog areas within striking distance of London. These investigations brought him into contact with a figure who was to have a major influence on him, namely J.B.S. Haldane.
Haldane had arrived at University College in 1932, already a charismatic figure in genetics and evolutionary biology. Although White later denied that Haldane had a strong influence on his work, there is no doubt that he was greatly impressed by him, perhaps as much by his behaviour as by his ideas. White was to develop into a colourful figure himself. Many of White's acquaintances had the pleasure of listening to Michael in some of his memorable feats of story telling, and many of those centred around incidents involving J.B.S. Haldane. Haldane was unquestionably impressed by White and in 1938 invited him to move from the Department of Zoology to the Department of Genetics for his research, but White chose to stay in the zoological milieu, perhaps indicative of his conviction that one always had to study genetic systems in a biological framework. Also, Haldane's department emphasized population and analytical genetics with a mathematical slant which was not one of White's major interests or strong points. However, White maintained close contact with Haldane, who accompanied him on some of his collecting trips. Rigour in analysis of experimental results was certainly one conviction that White absorbed from Haldane's approach to science.
In these first years of study, White cemented the major directions of his research and intellectual interests for the next several decades. It was clear to him that he wanted to work with chromosomes and that the Orthoptera was an ideal group to work with because they were cytologically amenable. Nevertheless, his interest in chromosomes was not in them as cytological objects per se but because they provided a key for some incisive thinking about genetic systems and the role of genetic processes in speciation and evolution. His analytical and genetical approach to cytology differed substantially from the more descriptive outlook of most other cytologists of the day. In this early period, too, he worked with grasshoppers, one of the three groups of insects that would be his dominant experimental material throughout his research career. In later research, as a consequence of his first visit to the United States, he would add mantids and gall midges.
1932 was an eventful year in White's life. He married Margaret Thomas, a fellow student with similar scientific and political interests to his own. This was also the year that Darlington's Recent Advances in Cytology was published, as too was Haldane's book, The Causes of Evolution. Darlington's synthesis of cytological studies in the plant kingdom was of major importance in cytology and cytogenetics. There is no doubt that it had a strong influence on White, probably triggering a desire to make a comparable mark with the chromosomes of animals, particularly insects. Just as White was impressed by Haldane's behaviour he was also impressed by the demeanour of Darlington. Above all, Darlington's book strengthened White's conviction that chromosomal observations were of value in developing an understanding of genetics and evolution. However, Darlington's approach to cytology, genetics and evolution differed markedly from White's, and several times during their careers they clashed with some relatively intense disputes emerging in the scientific literature.
As a young academic, White briefly became involved politically, and although he was dedicated primarily to his research it is not surprising that, as an intellectually active person, he responded to political concerns of the day. The radical physicist J.D. Bernal had a particular influence in White joining the Communist Party in 1932. Although White was politically concerned, it is clear that he was not a great enthusiast. He was more a supporter than an activist, and was criticised by his political peers for his apparently indifferent attitude. A couple of years later he resigned and joined the British Labour Party.
White went through a troubled period when his marriage effectively ended in 1933 and it was not until 1936 that he fully regained his drive in research and life. At that time he met Sally (Isobel Mary Lunn), whom he would later marry and who for the remainder of his life was an influential and supportive colleague and partner. In 1935, too, he was made a lecturer at University College. In his research he began demonstrating one of his characteristic traits, that of thinking beyond his own immediate experimental studies and placing them in a broader picture, looking for any appropriate generalizations that they indicated. Darlington was of the same conviction but went far beyond the experimental data with many of his generalizations. White was more conservative in this regard and additionally saw the value of experimental cytology in assisting in general understanding. A very good example was work he published on the nature of distributed centromeric activity in the chromosomes of Ascaris, in which he settled contemporary differences of opinion with an unambiguous experimental analysis.
White first synthesised his thoughts about the nature and importance of chromosomes in a small monograph, The Chromosomes, first published in 1937. Although this book did not contain the theoretical insights and major tracks of conceptual thinking that were prevalent in his subsequent book Animal Cytology and Evolution, it filled a niche in the field at the time and went to seven editions. It was published in several languages and for many years was used extensively in universities throughout the world. In this small monograph White signalled his appreciation of the genetic consequences of meiotic events. The book included what was essentially his first public discussion of the importance of chromosomal systems in evolution. This was quite an achievement for a young scientist of 27 years. The publication of his book undoubtedly contributed to his gaining a Rockefeller Fellowship in 1937 to travel to the United States for a period of research and study.
White went to work at Columbia University with Franz Schrader and Sally Hughes-Schrader, two insect cytologists. He took with him some cytological material and slides from his London studies and carried out an analysis of this material that established that the direction of chromosome coiling was basically random. This contravened generalizations made by Darlington. After the completion of this work, White saw no way to take it any further and began searching for new problems. Through contact with one of the Schraders' students, Kenneth Cooper, he became interested in one of the central cytogenetic problems of the day, the question as to whether meiosis could proceed regularly if there were no chiasmata between homologous chromosomes at metaphase 1. Cooper's views differed markedly from those of Darlington, who insisted that chiasmata were essential to the normal and orderly progress of meiosis. White studied meiosis in a male mantid, Callimantis antillarum, and discovered that there was a complete absence of chiasmata in meiosis in the male. White was excited by this discovery and promptly published his findings in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, shocking the Schraders with what they viewed as a precipitous approach to science. When reminiscing about working with the Schraders, White always compared their thorough Germanic descriptive approach with his own, which was more dynamic and always genetically oriented.
At Columbia, White made another vital contact. Theodosius Dobzhansky was visiting Columbia from the California Institute of Technology where he worked in association with T.H. Morgan and colleagues in Drosophila genetics. Dobzhansky had just published his seminal book Genetics and the Origin of Species, and already it was obvious to White that he was one of the world's most dynamic evolutionary geneticists. Dobzhansky and White quickly established a rapport and, discovering that they both planned to travel to Mexico on collecting trips, arranged to rendezvous in Mexico City. This they did and participated in a lecture series at the Instituto Politcnico Nacional in Mexico City. White had a vivid memory of one of his lectures in which he discussed sex chromosome systems involving either two or three X chromosomes. He was surprised at the enthusiastic applause that punctuated his lecture, not realising at the time that 2 X's and 3 X's signified brand names of popular Mexican beers.
While in the United States, White met a large number of cytologists and geneticists and was clearly influenced by the high level and freedom of academic exchange of ideas. This stimulating period probably strongly influenced his subsequent decision to write what was to become a major book, Animal Cytology and Evolution. His somewhat idyllic academic experience in the United States as a Visiting Fellow also influenced his later decision to return to work in that country. However, the Rockefeller Fellowship required him to go back to England. He returned accompanied by Sally, who had come over to the United States to spend some time with him towards the end of his stay, while he worked at the Woods Hole Laboratory.
Not long after their return to England war broke out. Although for a while his research work continued at University College, the Zoology Department then closed down. After a brief time at an entomological laboratory in Slough, White was placed as a statistician in the Ministry of Food, where he served for the duration of the war. Michael and Sally had married only a few months before war broke out. An amusing episode in an otherwise sombre year of political crises occurred at this time. Michael found himself standing in a queue in order to acquire the marriage license, and only after some considerable time discovered that he was in fact in the wrong queue. He had unknowingly joined the one for petrol coupons!
So far as his scientific work was concerned, White was frustrated by the inconveniences caused by war-time restrictions. His cytogenetic research languished. He was not intellectually stimulated by his war duties and generally resented the interruption to his career. Nevertheless, this wartime hiatus paradoxically led to one of his most important contributions to science. In the evenings and on weekends he worked on his book, Animal Cytology and Evolution, and he had a manuscript ready by the end of the war. It was published in 1945.
A chapter he wrote for the book Cytology and Cell Physiology (1942) signalled many of the concepts that he further developed in Animal Cytology and Evolution. White recognised that chromosomes were complicated organelles and that ultimately a molecular understanding of them was going to be fundamental to both physiological and evolutionary biology. In the 1942 review he struggled with the fragmentary state of nuclear chemistry and was not able to attach any conceptual meaning to what was then known of nucleic acids and proteins in the chromosome. In this he was not alone. However, this section of his paper was in marked contrast to the masterly sections dealing with structural behaviour of the chromosome. The latter was his field and it is what he understood best. It would not be until the last couple of years of his life that White would fully return again to the recognition that the control of gene expression was central to an adequate understanding of development and evolution. The review was of interest too because, although White had considerable empathy with the wonderful work of the Drosophila geneticists, he was able to question their notion of equating heteropyenotic chromosomes with genetic inertness. White's analysis came from a cytological viewpoint and it was interesting that he did not feel overwhelmed by the genetical studies. His paper contained other important ideas. For example, he concluded that polytene chromosomes of insects' salivary glands and other tissues represented a particular form of endopolyploidy and suggested that there were probably different levels of replication of the chromosome thread in different regions of some polytene chromosomes. Again this was a suggestion stemming from his cytological knowledge of chromosomes, extending far beyond the salivary chromosomes of Drosophila. In this review paper he contributed a penetrating consideration of induced chromosome structural rearrangements in terms of their consequences as mutations. He also emphasised that not all was known in genetics and he pointed to some significant holes in the knowledge fabric.
Animal Cytology and Evolution gathered into a coherent whole a mass of descriptive cytology and conflicting theories of cytogenetics and evolution. In this respect it paralleled Darlington's earlier plant-oriented book, Recent Advances in Cytology. White's Animal Cytology and Evolution was the first critical survey of cytology since E.B. Wilson's The Cell in Development and Heredity published twenty years earlier, the book that initially inspired White to enter the field. It integrated the cytological approaches of Belar, Dobzhansky and Darlington. White's book must be regarded as the foundation of modern animal cytogenetics and it established him as one of the major conceptual contributors to the neo-Darwinian evolutionary synthesis. White examined cytological and evolutionary observations of diverse sources from a genetical viewpoint, and the resulting synthesis probably provided his single most important contribution to the development of modern evolutionary theory.
Animal Cytology and Evolution ranks with Dobzhansky's Genetics and the Origin of Species as one of the seminal treatises in animal evolutionary biology. White's book emphasized that the principles of evolution applied to individual chromosomes and the chromosome complement just as they did to more classical morphological characters. He also stressed that the chromosome complement, principally through its meiotic properties, could influence the course and rate of evolution of any taxon. White had a great understanding of the mechanism of meiosis and its significance, and an almost intuitive grasp of the complexities and consequences of chromosomal rearrangements, especially in regard to speciation. The various chapters of the book testify to what were his major areas of creative study. One of the dominant themes in the book concerned the evolution of sex chromosomes, sex-determining mechanisms, and the phenomenon of thelytoky, the subject on which he concentrated for many of his later research years. Before the war had interrupted White's research, he had published his first papers on sex chromosome mechanisms in both mantids and grasshoppers. He retained an experimental and theoretical interest in sex chromosome systems throughout his career and made many contributions in this area. This topic and his stimulating experiences in the United States were major factors in convincing him to write Animal Cytology and Evolution.
In various editions of the book, as in his research career generally, White's focus was always the chromosome and the chromosome complement. This was true whether he was concerned with a particular aspect of an insect's genetic system, whether he was probing the causes of speciation, or thinking even more widely about mechanisms of consequence for evolution. White personally attached a great deal of importance to the book and put in an enormous effort in later years into producing a second and third edition of comparable quality. The third edition published in 1973 demonstrated that he was attempting to keep abreast of the vast changes that were occurring in genetics with the advent of molecular biology. It revealed his strong interest in molecular analyses of genetic events and showed his determination to embrace these findings within an evolutionary perspective. All three editions of the book bear witness to White's encyclopedic knowledge and familiarity with the published work of animal cytogenetics. White wrote in the preface to his third edition: 'If the present book helps to re-establish chromosomal mechanisms in the centre of the evolutionary stage, the labour of writing it will not have been in vain.'
The United States—science and politics
In 1946 White was elevated to a readership in University College, but he remained dissatisfied with the scientific community in England. He felt deeply the interruption the war had brought to his research career. While writing Animal Cytology and Evolution his ideas were developing rapidly, but he felt he was extremely isolated in the English academic environment. He was becoming increasingly annoyed at what he perceived to be personality cults surrounding a few central figures who dominated the scene in British biology such as Darlington, Mather, Ford, Fisher and to some extent Waddington. As soon as an opportunity presented itself, he travelled again to the United States, looking for a suitable position there. His favourable memories of the stimulating academic environment in the pre-war United States were confirmed by his return visit to the Genetics Department of the Carnegie Institute of Washington at Cold Spring Harbour. It was thus not surprising that he accepted an offer of a job at the University of Texas at Austin, one of the strongest centres of genetics research in the United States. In 1947 White spent six months as Visiting Fellow at the Cold Spring Harbor laboratories, then, accompanied by Sally, moved to Texas to begin a new phase of his career.
For most of the time at the University of Texas White was engaged in productive research. He appreciated the opportunity of working with colleagues such as Patterson, Stone, Wheeler, Griffiths and Wagner. It was during this time that he studied the peculiar meiotic systems of the gall midges, Cecidomyidae, a group to which he had been introduced by the Schraders while at Columbia University. White saw that study of the bizarre meiosis of these organisms could further advance the understanding of regular meiotic systems. He also continued work on the chromosomes of grasshoppers which confirmed for him the pleasure to be derived from working with natural populations of insects, particularly those living in arid environments. While at Texas White commenced regular annual summer collecting trips in the deserts of the south-west. These regular and extensive collecting pilgrimages to outback areas were also to be a feature of his later research work in Australia. In Australia, even in the years of his 'retirement', White mounted major collecting trips into the arid Nullarbor Plain in the heat of summer. His wife, Sally, proved to be his only durable companion on these arduous safaris.
Some of the south-west grasshopper taxa had chromosome rearrangements that were polymorphic in various populations. His study of these, particularly in Trimerotropis, kindled his interest in population cytogenetics. During a prolific period, he published not only his own experimental results but also commentaries on a range of other cytological and evolutionary matters.
But White's time at Texas was to be troubled, and this phase of his career was brought to an end by political issues. The McCarthy era of political witch-hunts had begun. Michael was investigated by the US Immigration Authority because of his connections with the Communist Party during his student days in England. His problems were acute largely because a state law had been passed that required employees of public universities and other institutions to sign an oath indicating that they had never had any Communist affiliations. Of course White was unable to do so and this ultimately resulted in his resignation. In the end it was a matter of White either resigning or being deported. During this period he found himself in an untenable situation at Texas. Once again White found safe haven in the intellectual cocoon of the Cold Spring Harbor laboratories. He took sabbatical leave, without pay, and for a year was personally and materially supported and provisioned at Cold Spring Harbor by Miloslav Demerec, Barbara McClintock and others. This gave the White family some respite, allowing them to regain a measure of equanimity before Michael returned to teach again at the University of Texas. However, shortly afterwards this excruciating and deplorable political saga came to a conclusion when in 1953 the White family voluntarily left the United States for Australia.
Australia—an intellectual and cultural home
Through the efforts of Dobzhansky and other colleagues, in 1953 Michael White was offered an appointment in the Genetics Section of the CSIRO Division of Plant Industry in Canberra. Dobzhansky made contact with Otto Frankel, who had recently been appointed Chief of the Division, requesting his help. Frankel, himself a prominent geneticist, was happy to provide a position for White because he was attempting to build up the research strength of the Genetics Section of his Division. Frankel made the full facts of White's predicament known to CSIRO's senior executive officers, Frederick White and Ian Clunies Ross, who had no hesitation in supporting Frankel in his efforts to secure a position for White. There is no doubt that White would have warranted the appointment through his scientific reputation alone, but they were also sympathetic to the unfortunate political intrusions into his career. It was a courageous decision by Frankel and colleagues because anti-Communist sentiment was also raging in Australia. At Canberra, White was put under no pressure to work on plants. Frankel felt that White's presence and active research would be of general benefit to the programme at CSIRO and it certainly proved to be so, with White providing an international perspective and the setting of new standards for other geneticists. He played an important role in raising the standing of the Division's genetics group as a whole.
White spent three productive years in the Canberra laboratories. In 1956, the final year of his appointment, he began working on the morabine grasshoppers. This proved to be a turning-point in his career. This large group of endemic, wingless grasshoppers would be his central experimental organisms in subsequent years. One piece of work he carried out in Canberra was an extension of his observations on pericentric inversions in the trimerotropine grasshoppers of the south-west United States. He collaborated with another CSIRO geneticist, Fred Morley, in exploring the genetic consequences of polymorphism for pericentric inversions in populations of a species of local grasshoppers. White was proud of this paper which demonstrated his ability to collaborate with other workers who had complementary skills - in this case, Morley's conceptual mathematical thinking. White also unearthed some other remarkable chromosomal rearrangements in the morabine grasshoppers and this resulted in the first of a series of papers published over many years.
Although his work was stimulating and he was well pleased with his colleagues and the environment, White was not completely satisfied at CSIRO. The CSIRO was a purely research institution and he found himself missing the stimulation and pleasures of teaching. During his time at Canberra he received entreaties to return to the United States where his genetical colleagues fully appreciated his capabilities and his stature as a scientist. No doubt they were anxious to redress the wrongs of the McCarthy period.
With McCarthy's decline in late 1954 the United States returned to a saner political environment and White decided to return to a university position where he hoped to experience the stimulation of both research and teaching. He accepted a position as Professor of Zoology at the University of Missouri, which was one of the strong centres of genetic research in the United States, having an impressive history of both Drosophila and maize genetics. But unfortunately it was not a good choice for White. His particular brand of cytogenetics was not well represented there. Both he and Sally found the general culture and religious environment of Missouri not to their liking. White realised that he and the family had been much more at home in the social and scientific environment of Australia. With the intervention of Frankel and Clunies Ross, an invitation came to White to return to Australia as Professor of Zoology at the University of Melbourne. So, after just eighteen months in Missouri, in 1958 White once again found himself a major figure in the Australian genetics community.
White built up a strong genetics section within the Department of Zoology at the University of Melbourne. In 1964 he became the foundation professor of genetics at the University, moving in 1973 to a separate building of which he was, perhaps uncharacteristically, very proud. He put a considerable effort into raising money for the building and insisted that it made a statement about the importance of genetics as a discipline. White built up a first class genetics department, something much needed in Australia at that time. His personal reputation allowed the department to maintain a strong international flavour, attracting a succession of visiting scientists and scholars. Nevertheless, from the perspective of a dynamic research scientist not all was ideal for him at the University of Melbourne. Particularly onerous were the administrative duties associated with the heavy bureaucracy of the University. White was one of the outstanding scholars in the faculty and this was probably under-recognised by the University. During his professorship he maintained an active research effort and found himself in touch with a wealth of cytogenetic opportunity, particularly with the morabine grasshoppers. He also 'travelled and collected' the Orthoptera of other countries, for example in South Africa and Madagascar.
White had a succession of graduate students during this period, some of whom including Ross Crozier, Jon Martin, John Thomson and Graham Webb, went on to academic and research positions in Australia. However, he personally supervised relatively few postgraduate students. This was perhaps due to his single-minded concern with his own research programme and his lifelong tendency to operate as a lone-worker. He required complete freedom in his own work and thinking and granted the same to others. He was not orientated towards building a strong 'school' as such, although he certainly hoped that this would happen naturally, as a by-product of his own inspiration and devotion to the cause. He was driven on by a desire to uncover yet another piece of the genetic puzzle and fit it into the larger picture. Nevertheless, he made a huge contribution to Australian genetics. Apart from his own students, he also influenced others elsewhere in Australia, primarily through his presentations at the annual meetings of the Genetics Society of Australia. By his later years he had developed into a wonderful example of an idiosyncratic but gifted academic. His addresses at the Genetics Society meetings were inevitably of a high standard with new findings from his experimental programme presented every year. Above all they were colourful and entertaining and fired the imagination of his audience. Along with Otto Frankel, Jimmy Rendel and Spinny Smith-White, Michael White stimulated many of us to aspire to excel in our quests for understanding of the mechanisms and consequences of genome dynamics in plants and animals.
Following his retirement from Melbourne in 1975, White accepted a visiting fellowship in the Research School of Biological Sciences at the Australian National University (ANU) in Canberra. Along with David Shaw he was a major figure in an active cytogenetic team headed by Professor Bernard John, an ex-Darlington student. Even though nominally retired, White attracted, on merit, research grants from both Australia and the United States. He published a substantial part of his total research papers during a very active period at the ANU. During this time he also renewed associations with the CSIRO laboratory at Plant Industry in which he had worked in earlier years. The CSIRO laboratory and the ANU collaborated in seminars and the organization of journal clubs. Jim Peacock and his colleague, Elizabeth Dennis, molecular biologists in CSIRO, were able to provide him with another set of complementary skills to probe the evolutionary puzzles of the morabines.
In this period in Canberra, his last major period of research, he also renewed his ties with Italy. In 1978 he was elected a Fellow of the Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, an honour he prized above almost any other, and he took every available opportunity to lecture and conduct research in the country that along with Australia he had identified as homeland territory. It was in Italy, in what proved to be his last visit, that he was stricken with a cancer that not long afterwards ended his life. From his last visit he returned elated because he had been able to visit Corsica and Sardinia, islands he had long wanted to see.
Research on morabine grasshoppers
Michael White had an extremely wide knowledge of genetics and evolution. He was a walking encyclopaedia of research in cytology and cytogenetics of the animal kingdom; but to many scientists he was 'the grasshopper man'. Many of his major contributions to science and particularly to an understanding of the modes of speciation and evolutionary change came from his research in the Orthoptera. His particular interest was in the short-horned grasshoppers and particularly the Australian group of Morabine species. He began his work on the Morabines in Canberra, interrupted it when he returned to the USA for the period in Missouri, and then re-established it when he returned to Australia as Professor of Zoology at the University of Melbourne. White's research intensified when he returned to Canberra on retiring from the University of Melbourne.
Population Cytology of Moraba scurra
In his first paper on the morabine grasshopper Moraba (later Keyacris) scurra, White analysed hybrids of chromosome races in an attempt to explain their distribution in the field, carrying out both laboratory and field experiments. Here we have once again evidence of White's experimental approach to cytogenetics. This modus operandi delineated him as a major figure in the field. White analysed the heterotic effect of the polymorphisms he had identified and related his work to the extensive studies made in various Drosophila groups. He was intrigued by the positive heterosis that was associated with chromosome rearrangements in Moraba scurra and postulated negative heterosis for hybrids between races with different chromosome numbers, arguing that this could provide a basis for raciation even in small geographic areas. Incidentally, White did often work with the morabines in small geographic areas. He frequently studied these wingless grasshoppers in cemeteries of country towns that provided 'islands' of natural vegetation. More than one citizen in Australia was startled by the figure crawling around on hands and knees in the local cemetery. White summarised his findings on chromosomal polymorphisms and their effects in a major paper in the Cold Spring Harbour Symposium of 1958. This paper marked a milestone in his contributions to primary concepts of population dynamics.
In his prolonged and productive interaction with the morabine grasshoppers, White was fortunate in having a series of colleagues with complementary sets of expertise. Ken Key, an orthopteran taxonomist in the CSIRO Division of Entomology was associated with White for many years. They first published together in 1957 on the grasshopper genus Austroicetes, a genus of some economic importance in Australia, but the Key-White axis really matured during the long-term collaboration on the subfamily Morabinae that provided a series of papers on the systematics, genetics and evolutionary biology of these remarkable species. In his first period in Canberra, as well as working with Ken Key on the taxonomic side, White formed an association with Fred Morley, a stimulating geneticist in the CSIRO Division of Plant Industry. Morley contributed a quantitative and analytical dimension to White's study of the effect of pericentric inversion polymorphisms in natural populations of Moraba scurry. The White-Morley work was published in 1955.
When White returned to Australia in 1958 to take up the post as Professor of Zoology at the University of Melbourne he continued his analyses of the biological effects of various chromosomal arrangements in Moraba scurra, searching for evidence for heterosis and its basis. In collaboration with Richard Lewontin, he constructed a series of adaptive topographies for various inversion frequencies. They published their results in a strong theoretical paper in 1960. Lewontin, one of the brightest of Dobzhansky's students, provided a link back to the Dobzhansky-White interaction of earlier years. Indeed, Lewontin strongly influenced a number of Australian geneticists during his sabbatical period in the late 1950s in Australia. At a personal level White and Lewontin got on exceptionally well. Before White's work on Moraba scurra it was generally thought that chromosomal polymorphisms in natural populations were maintained in equilibrium by simple heterozygote superiority. His research indicated that the situation was far more complex. The research on Moraba scurra, and especially the work carried out in collaboration with Lewontin on adaptive topographies, was extensively cited and discussed in the literature. The Moraba scurra project was one of the most detailed studies of chromosomal polymorphisms in natural populations beyond the standard Drosophila work.
William Atchley, another visitor to Melbourne, provided biometrical analyses in some of the Moraba work, and another visiting scientist, Robert Blackith, collaborated with White in the mid-1960s, applying multivariate analyses to some of the population studies. Of White's students, probably Graham Webb made the major direct contribution to White's own research area, in particular on the parthenogenetic grasshopper Warramaba virgo. Later, in Canberra, Webb was able to bring molecular-biological analyses to bear on the research through his associations with Liz Dennis and Jim Peacock.
These were fruitful collaborations, and in many cases were crucial in the development of White's scientific work, but throughout there was no doubt in the minds of any of the collaborators that White was in charge! Although his own research work always had priority, he did appreciate the contributions of others and collaborated only with scientists whom he respected and trusted.
Parthenogenesis in Warramaba virgo
White's tireless fieldwork on the morabines further paid off when he happened on the first example of a parthenogenetic species of grasshopper. On a field trip in western New South Wales in January 1961, White discovered a population of a Moraba (later Warramaba) species and was surprised that he could locate only females. After a fruitless additional search for males by his observant son Nicholas, White became convinced that this was possibly a parthenogenetic species. No mind could have been better prepared to come to such a conclusion. In an earlier study in Austin on the mantid Brunneria borealis White had described an exclusive parthenogenetic reproduction system and had pondered on the genetic consequences of parthenogenesis for a number of years. He sent off a short note to the Australian Journal of Science about his discovery, which was published in August 1962. White enthusiastically took Ken Key, his taxonomist colleague, to look at the all-female population. Key was initially sceptical that this would prove to be a valid species. However, he was soon convinced that no males were present and provided a suitable taxonomic place for the species, with a joint publication in the Australian Journal of Zoology in 1963.
White's first public announcement of his finding of the parthenogenetic grasshopper was at the Genetics Society of Australia meeting in Sydney in 1962. Many Australian geneticists have fond memories of Michael describing what was then called Moraba virgo, which he had discovered in two populations by that time, in New South Wales and north-western Victoria. The scientific excitement was accentuated by his presentation, and in particular his enunciation of the word 'femalllllllllle', this word sometimes using many seconds of his valuable presentation time! White was clearly fascinated by thelytoky, as he persisted in calling it in the scientific meetings of that time (perhaps because of the resonance he could give to that particular word rather than because of its precise biological meaning). White studied Warramaba virgo not just for its own sake, however, but because he felt that a detailed study of this unusual species would lead him to an understanding of processes involved in regular speciation events.
Ironically, his initial conclusions about the origin of Warramaba proved to be incorrect. Along with his graduate student, Graham Webb, White studied the patterns of chromosomal replication and concluded that the difficulties they had in recognising homologous pads of chromosomes in the genome were due to differential heterochromatisation that had occurred since the origin of the parthenogenetic species. It was a prevalent concept in the cytological literature of the day. Another of White's students, David Porter, suggested that perhaps the puzzling chromosome complement was a result of a hybrid origin of the parthenogenetic species. But it was not until 1975 that Godfrey Hewitt, a visiting scientist at the Australian National University, made the convincing suggestion that Warramaba virgo originated as a hybrid between two particular Western Australian sexual species of the grasshopper. Initially White's work on Warramaba virgo had been only in eastern Australia but he subsequently found that it also occurred on the other side of the arid centre of the continent in Western Australia, where there was a complex of related sexual species. His results were recorded first in 1973 in a paper in Chromosoma. Hewitt, of course, was able to propose a hybrid origin only because of White's extensive data on the sexual species P169 and P196 from the Western Australian location. White, who had earlier dismissed a hybrid origin, gradually came to accept this as a real possibility. His experimental hybridisation studies using bisexual relatives led him in 1977 to publicly admit that the hybrid origin was a distinct possibility, and indeed, a high probability.
White had also surmised that the parthenogenetic species undoubtedly had a single origin and he developed elaborate hypotheses as to the probable point of origin and the rate and directions of subsequent migrations to extant localities. But work with Graham Webb on chromosome banding patterns showed two clones of Warramaba virgo which were clearly different, and White was forced to consider the possibility that there had been two separate hybrid origins of Warramaba virgo. This was confirmed in Canberra, following his retirement as Professor of Genetics in Melbourne. He established a collaboration with Jim Peacock and Elizabeth Dennis at the nearby laboratories of CSIRO's Division of Plant Industry. Here, analyses on repeated DNA sequences established beyond any doubt that there had been more than a single origin of Warramaba virgo and that there were probably many.
Michael White's place in the Australian scientific landscape was paralleled by his seamless fit into the Australian physical landscape. Collecting with him in the harsh sunlight, of the Mulga and Cassia country near Broken Hill left an indelible imprint of a dedicated, excited scientist perfectly at home in that demanding, xerophytic ecosystem.
Stasipatric speciation
In addition to his experimental studies on Moraba scurra and Warramaba virgo, White conducted a third major analysis with morabine species. This was based on the Vandiemenella (formerly Moraba) viatica species group of morabines in the Eyre Peninsula and the surrounding region of central southern Australia. This research sharpened his ideas on the mechanisms by which speciation occurs and provided the stimulus for his last book Modes of Speciation.
White's work on Moraba scurra and his other cytogenetic studies had strengthened his conviction that the chromosomal and genetic system of a taxon was of considerable importance to its future. In thinking about how new species developed, White adhered to the basic genetico-biological view that a species was a collection of individual organisms that could be considered to have an interchanging gene pool, so that a species perimeter was drawn by the limits of freedom of exchange of genetic information. Conceptually, he accepted that the gene pool of a taxon could differentiate into two or more subsequent distinct gene pools, that is new species, with genetic mechanisms playing a primary role as isolating mechanisms. He gradually modified his early acceptance of the generally accepted proposition that geographical isolation was a prerequisite to speciation. In several of his publications, White commented on the complexity of biological mechanisms involved in speciation. He recognised that geographic, behavioural, and genetic and cytogenetic mechanisms could all play a role, and in different incipient speciation complexes these factors could have different weightings.
During his studies on the morabines, with their low vagility, he found that he was dealing with taxa associated with small geographic areas, often intimately interdigitated. In his earliest writings on Moraba scurra it is possible to see that he was moving towards the ideas that genetic barriers could be the major isolation mechanism needed for the development of two subsequently independent gene pools. In the viatica species group in the Eyre Peninsula in South Australia, he was confronted with a mosaic of karyotypic chromosomal systems with very little geographical separation. Not only could he find situations where it seemed that new taxa, as defined by the cytogenetic system, arose from an apparent peripheral population isolate of an existing group, but he found other situations where individuals with a new chromosomal system seemed to have arisen within the distribution of another taxon. He coined the term stasipatric (stationary place) speciation to describe the latter situation as apparently demonstrated in the viatica species group.
Vandiemenella viatica was a regular single species over much of its distribution range, but in the coastal region of central South Australia White found a multitude of chromosomal forms. These forms or races were often contiguous (or parapatric in White's terminology). Because the hybrids could be identified cytologically he was able to determine that in many situations the hybrid zones could be extremely narrow, a matter of one or a few metres. This emphasized to him that chromosomal rearrangements could function as strong primary genetic isolating mechanisms. White saw that chromosomal variants with the appropriate properties did not always occur on the geographic peripheries of the species distribution. Rather, White found situations which he interpreted as meaning that the origin had been within the distribution with a subsequent expansion on one or more fronts. This convinced him that geographic isolation was not a mandatory requirement in the speciation process. He developed his stasipatric speciation concept in a lead article in Science in 1968, realising that in doing so he was throwing up a challenge to what he considered to be an overly narrow concept of geographically based speciation promulgated by orthodox neo-Darwinian contributors to this field such as Ernst Mayr. White developed his ideas further in his 1978 book, Modes of Speciation, where he went to some lengths to explain why we might envisage many different paths of speciation, dependent on chromosomal, genetic, behavioural and other biological factors as well as geographic considerations. In developing his concept of stasipatric speciation, White emphasised his lifelong view of the importance and complexity of cytogenetic processes in population dynamics and hence in evolution.
White, an admirer and colleague of Mayr, felt that Mayr had underestimated the importance of genetics related processes in the mechanisms of speciation and evolution. The viatica group of the morabines gave him the opportunity to illustrate his view of the many factors involved in speciation. Characteristically, he drew on data derived from his own field collections and experimentation. Although White may not have succeeded in achieving a general acceptance of his views on speciation processes and may not have convinced the broad range of taxonomists and evolutionists that stasipatric speciation may occur, he certainly re-established the importance of genetic mechanisms in the isolation processes involved in the generation of species. Mayr, in a thorough review of Modes of Speciation in Systematic Zoology in 1978, paid tribute to White in this regard.
Epilogue
Michael White was one of the most distinguished scientists of his generation to work in Australia. Throughout his career he made important contributions to many aspects of cytology and cytogenetics and to evolutionary biology, including speciation theory and systematics. He had an awesome capacity for unremitting hard work and continued his research activities up until a few days before his death. He died from cancer on the 16 December 1983 at age 73, still at the height of his career. At the time of his death he was acknowledged as the world's leading cytogeneticist. His importance to science is indicated by his membership of many of the world's most prestigious academic societies and in the variety of international honours bestowed on him (see below). White was honoured by a Festschrift on his seventieth birthday (Evolution and Speciation, 1981; edited by W.R. Atchley and D.S. Woodruff).
Michael is survived by his wife Isobel (Sally), an anthropologist who specialises in research on the Australian aborigines. In addition to her own academic work, Sally had an extensive involvement in Michael's field work. Michael is also survived by his three children: son Nicholas, a virologist, son Jonathan, a university lecturer in humanities, and daughter Charlotte, a medical practitioner. Michael White's passing was a major loss to Australian and international science and to family and friends. His legacy, however, is immense.
Awards and positions
Degrees
- BSc in Zoology and Human Physiology (First Class Honours), University of London, 1931
- MSc, University of London, 1932
- DSc, University of London, 1940
- MSc, University of Melbourne, 1959
- Dottore in Science Biologiche honoris causa, University of Sienna, 1979.
Fellowships of Learned Societies
- Fellow, Australian Academy of Science, 1955
- Member of Council, AAS, 1960-1962
- Fellow, Royal Society of London, 1961
- Honorary Foreign Member, American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 1963
- Fellow of University College, London, 1962
- Foreign Member, American Philosophical Society, 1978
- Socio Straniero, Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, 1978
- Fellow of the Linnean Society of London honoris causa, 1979
- Foreign Associate, U.S. National Academy of Sciences, 1981.
Medals
- Mueller Medal, Australian & New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science, 1966
- Silver Medal for Research, Royal Society of Victoria, 1979
- Linnean Medal for Zoology, Linnean Society of London, 1983
- Minerva Medal of the University of Rome, 1983.
Academic appointments
- 1976 Visiting Fellow, Department of Population Biology, Australian National University
- Jan.-Mar. 1968 Visiting Agassiz Professor, Harvard University
- Aug. 1964-1975 Professor of Genetics, University of Melbourne
- July 1958-July 1964 Professor of Zoology, University of Melbourne
- 1963 Visiting Fellow, Witwatersrand University, South Africa
- Jan. 1957-June 1958 Professor of Zoology, University of Missouri
- July 1953-Dec.1956 Senior Research Fellow, CSIRO, Canberra
- Sept. 1947-June 1953 Professor of Zoology, University of Texas
- Mar.-Sept. 1947 Guest Investigator, Department of Genetics, Carnegie Institution of Washington, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y.
- Jan.-Mar. 1947 Reader in Zoology, University of London
- 1940-1945 Wartime positions as Statistician and Entomologist in British Ministry of Food
- 1937-1938 Rockefeller Research Fellow, Columbia University
- 1935-1946 Lecturer in Zoology, University College, London
- 1932-1935 Assistant Lecturer in Zoology, University College, London.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, Vol.10, No.2, 1994, and also in Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society of London, 1994. It was written by:
- W.J. Peacock, who works in the CSIRO Division of Plant Industry; and
- D. McCann, who works in the Department of History and Philosophy of Science, University of Melbourne.
Acknowledgements
The authors are indebted to Philip Batterham, Linden Gillbank, Rod Home and Sally White for advice and critical comments on this manuscript.
Mervyn Silas Paterson 1925–2020
Professor Mervyn Paterson FAA was an engineer by training whose pioneering work in experimental geology – designing specialised instruments for studying rocks under high temperatures and pressures – furthered understanding of the Earth's crust and mantle.
Mervyn Paterson exploited a background in metallurgical engineering and the physics of metals as the basis for a long and influential career in earth sciences, mainly at the Australian National University.
Recognising the need for specialised equipment for experimental rock deformation, Mervyn made a highly distinctive contribution through his design and construction of a series of machines of progressively increasing sophistication for laboratory studies of the mechanical behaviour of rocks under conditions of high pressure and temperature. The new insights thus obtained in the laboratory have found widespread application in understanding the behaviour of the Earth’s crust and underlying mantle, notably within the disciplines of structural geology and geodynamics.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 33(1), 2022. It was written by Ian Jackson.
Maxwell Frank Cooper Day 1915–2017
Max Day AO FAA was an ecologist whose pioneering research spanned entomology, virology, ecology and forestry. He served as the founding chief of CSIRO’s Division of Forest Research and worked on nationally significant challenges, such as deploying myxomatosis to control rabbits.
Max Day (1915–2017) entomologist, scientific diplomat and conservationist, was a national scientific leader across the 20th century, a time that spanned the rise of the idea of the environment and of concern about ecological limits. He was a pioneer in Australia of integrated, cross-disciplinary science and an important advocate of evidence-based policymaking. His fundamental disciplinary work in entomology, virology, ecology and forestry focused on nationally significant problems and their international context.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 31(1), 2020. It was written by Libby Robin and Jon C. Day.
Max Rudolf Lemberg 1896–1975
Rudi Lemberg was a biochemist who made significant contributions to the study of biological pigments, especially porphyrins. He was a Foundation Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science.
Written by J. Barrett and R.N. Robertson.
Introduction
Max Rudolf Lemberg, who died on 10 April 1975, was one of the Foundation Fellows of the Australian Academy of Science. Known to a wide circle of friends around the world as Rudi, he was affectionately referred to by his younger Australian colleagues as Lemmy. Born and educated in Germany, he made Australia his home for the latter half of his life and adapted himself well to the ways of his country of adoption. Other accounts of Lemberg's life and influence have appeared elsewhere: his autobiographical chapter written at the invitation of the Annual Review of Biochemistry (1965); Encounter with Rudi Lemberg published privately by his friends (1975); the Royal Society (London) Memoir (1976) compiled by C. Rimington FRS and C.H. Gray.
Early life
Lemberg was born in Breslau on 19 October 1896, into a cultured, educated family. His father was a leading lawyer specializing in civil law and law was in the family tradition, particularly on the maternal side. His younger brother became a lawyer. However, many relatives and close family friends were noted scientists such as Albert Neisser, bacteriologist, Martin Freund, organic chemist, Minkowski and 'Augen' Cohn, medical scientists, and Cohn's son who, under the name of Emil Ludwig, became an internationally known writer. Thus as a small boy he was exposed not only to an intellectual heritage but also to contact with many professional and academic adults. He was educated at the same liberal, humanist gymnasium in Breslau as Bonhoffer, who became an eminent protestant theologian and was later killed by the Nazis. This gymnasium gave excellent instruction in mathematics, Greek, and Latin – much of which Lemberg retained in his later years despite his modest disclaimers. As might have been expected he was more attracted to the intellectual glories of the Greek civilization than to the majestic splendour of the Roman heritage.
Lemberg had a keen love of music mostly of the middle Germanic tradition, music by composers such as Telemann, whose music he greatly enjoyed, Bach, Mozart, and Beethoven. He was not drawn much to the creations of the French and English schools, though he loved Purcell and had some attachment to the works of Britten. He has recorded that there was a great deal of music in his home. His beautiful mother, who was later to die in a concentration camp, had a fine alto voice and his younger brother who also migrated to Australia played the viola and continued to do so until his death two years before that of Lemberg. Though Rudi Lemberg was never a practising musician, he had great ability for analysing music immediately on hearing it.
Aesthetic appreciation was an important component in his mental disposition. Though a somewhat overprotected and frail child, he escaped to experience the joys of the open countryside and the woods beside the River Oder. Thus from childhood and throughout his student days he was keenly aware of the beauty of natural surroundings. In his autobiographical chapter (1965) there are several references to the beauty of the countryside he experienced in all countries he visited. He also enjoyed the colour and rhythm of verse, and frequently read Goethe, Morgenstern, and Rilke. He has recorded that he dreamt in colour and certainly he enjoyed the splendid reds of his porphyrin compounds.
His religious background was Jewish, although not strict or orthodox. His mother, who had a great influence on his cultural life, had a protestant education. He had many contacts with the Lutheran Church and was converted to the Christian faith during World War I. Thus he experienced the flexibility of the Jewish spirit combined with protestant application and uprightness which probably accounted for his strong conscience throughout his life.
War and universities
His high school education veered to the classics but he was impressed by his mathematics master and responded to his teaching. On leaving school he studied chemistry, physics, mineralogy, and geology at Breslau University, but the war came and, believing in the justice of the German cause, he tried to enlist. Twice he was refused on medical grounds and so continued his studies at Breslau, Munich, and Heidelberg until 1917. He was attracted to chemistry but recalled the teaching of this subject in both Munich and Heidelberg at that time as being dull. He enjoyed his period in Munich because of opportunities for skiing and walking in the Alps. In 1917 he was finally able to enlist in the German army. He served in the trenches as a telephonist. Like so many of his time, he gave loyal support to the Fatherland but the brutal experiences in the German army left him a confirmed pacifist with a keen contempt for the military establishment and the mentality of its officers. He was repelled by the brutalization of men by the war, not only by the crudity of the trenches, but also by the senseless cruelty of the officers and sub-officers. He was no coward, being able to face up to the hardships and death of the front line, and was awarded the Iron Cross (2nd class) for a daring attempt to repair a telephone line during the Somme battle of March 1918, being wounded in the attempt.
In 1919 he was able to resume his university work at Breslau University, where he studied methyl-substituted uric acid derivatives with Heinrich Biltz, working towards a PhD. Lemberg remarks that he had not been fitted to become a biochemist. He had had no lectures on biological subjects and, except for a few hours teaching in microbiology and botanical class work, his extensive knowledge of biology was self-taught. Following the award of PhD (summa cum laude) he went to Mannheim in 1923 to work with Bayer, the pharmaceutical manufacturer. Biltz had told him that he was not suited to an academic life and should go into industry. On 21 December 1924 he married Hanna Claussen who was to share the rest of his life in Germany, in England, and in Australia. In 1926 following retrenchment in the prevailing economic crisis, he went to Heidelberg, obtaining a grant from the Notgemeinschaft der Deutschen Wissenschaft which was supplemented by a three-year severance allowance from Bayer. Encouraged by Freudenberg, whose courage and kindness he greatly admired, he began research for his 'venia legendi', a qualification which would permit him to give lectures. Freudenberg recalled recently that he liked Lemberg very much because of his modesty. In Freudenberg's laboratory in the old Institute in the Märzgasse, the organic chemistry was directed to the solution of biochemical as well as physiochemical problems, and there Lemberg had his first contact with the borderland between chemistry and biology which became his future working field. At that time there was a great interest in metallo-organic compounds. Karl Ziegler, later to become a Nobel laureate for his researches on organo-metal complexes, provided many ideas for Lemberg's fertile mind. Hieber was then working on metal carbonyl compounds and Werner Kuhn had begun his studies on the optical rotatory dispersion of macromolecules. Kautsky had recently come from Warburg's laboratory to carry out fluorescence studies which became of importance in the understanding of photosynthesis.
With Freudenberg, whose work on the stereochemistry of organic compounds he admired, he worked on catechins for about six months, but then began independent work on the chromoproteins of red algae, stimulated by Czapek's accounts of them in his Biochemie der Pflanzen. Freudenberg recalls that they ordered a sample of seaweed from Japan, a most precious plant material in Heidelberg, which arrived in two trunks, one of which contained a crab. The algal chromoproteins largely occupied Lemberg's research efforts until 1934 but he retained a lasting interest in these pigments and was particularly pleased when one of his later colleagues (Barrett) took up the study of the interaction of the chromophores with the protein moiety in phycocyanin. Intuitively he recognized that the phycobiliprotein pigments were pyrrole-derivatives and was forced to immerse himself in the work of Hans Fischer whose school at Munich was prodigious in its output of tetrapyrrole literature, sometimes unfortunately premature and incorrect. Lemberg has recorded that there was some disagreement – or polemics – between Fischer and himself over the question of the structure of certain bile pigments. Lemberg and Fischer were antithetical and, though he recognized the immensity of Fischer's achievement, he was more drawn to the imaginative explorations of the Cambridge school of biochemistry, although inclined there to be critical of what he regarded as a lack of chemical thinking by Hopkins and Barcroft and certain of their associates. His Habilitation as Privatdozent at Heidelberg was awarded in 1930 for his demonstration that the prosthetic groups of the algal chromoproteins, phycoerythrin and phycocyanin, were bile pigments. The zinc complexes of the split products were like those of urobilin and 'mesobiliviolin', giving him the first clue that the prosthetic groups of these crystalline chromoproteins were bile pigments. This study also familiarized him with work on proteins.
On Freudenberg's recommendation he applied for a Rockefeller Foundation fellowship to go to the biochemistry department under Gowland Hopkins at Cambridge. At that time Cambridge had outstanding scientists such as Barcroft, Robin Hill, Hopkins, Szent-Györgi, and the Needhams. Lemberg had been greatly impressed by the work of Keilin, Barcroft, and Robin Hill on haem compounds and cytochromes, and elected (1930-31) to continue his studies on the bile pigments rather than to participate directly in the work of the Hopkins school. This decision he later somewhat regretted. However there was interchange of ideas particularly between the departments of physiology and biochemistry and the Molteno Institute. One day Keilin told him that Barcroft had a green pigment in the placenta of the dog. It turned out to be 'uteroverdin', which was identical with oocyan, the green pigment that Lemberg had isolated from gull's egg shells. The 'uteroverdin' was more readily purified than oocyan and was analysed as tetrapyrrolic dehydrobilirubin. In Cambridge Lemberg worked in the same laboratory as Robin Hill, who at that time was doing his brilliant pioneering work on photosynthesis.
Retreat from Germany
Lemberg was a Christian socialist who had been a member of the democratic socialist party. Freudenberg recalls that he displayed no political divergences and no student agitated against him. However the end of his scientific career in Germany came in 1933 when he was compelled by the encroaching Nazi antisemitic oppression to flee from Heidelberg. His English friends were aware of the danger he was in and had sent a message by Szent-Györgi personally for him to leave immediately for Cambridge. Freudenberg had obtained orders from the authorities in Karlsruhe to dismiss him but, though he felt he had to pass on the information to Lemberg, he did not feel he had to serve him notice. However, though Lemberg was a qualified lecturer, he was working only as an assistant and, from that position, Freudenberg was obliged to give him notice. To the Lembergs' everlasting gratitude, Freudenberg gave them shelter in his own home during their last few days in Heidelberg. The Freudenbergs arranged a small farewell party attended by Dr and Mrs Ziegler, Dr and Mrs Kautsky and Werner Kuhn, who was a bachelor. Before his departure they all took a short walk through Heidelberg and accompanied him to the railway station. It had been a pleasant evening but Freudenberg recalls that though the departure was quite unsentimental, they were all overwhelmed and in a very reflective mood.
An associate of David Keilin during his second stay at Cambridge, Lemberg was increasingly aware of the excitement associated with the rediscovery of the cytochromes, first observed by McMunn in the nineteenth century, and of the beginnings of the unravelling of the complex pathways of biological oxidation.
The Australian opportunity for Lemberg to obtain some measure of financial and political security and to be established as a completely independent worker came through the foresight of Dr Wilson Ingram of the Royal North Shore Hospital, Sydney. Dr Ingram, a Scot, of great pioneering spirit, travelled as surgeon to Antarctica with Mawson, and then in the mid-1920s founded the biochemical laboratories that were to grow into the Institute of Medical Research, containing the Kolling Laboratories. There in the crises of 1935 Lemberg found a haven and a base for his future growth as a scientist. The Academic Assistance Council of the UK sought all over the world at that time to resettle academic refugees in academic positions and Ingram had responded to their enquiries. Lemberg, who had been recommended by Sir Frederick Gowland Hopkins as an outstanding scientist with a good command of English, accepted an offer to become a director of the Research Biochemical Laboratories, a position which had been advertised both locally and overseas. Ingram's decision to appoint Lemberg was both courageous and farsighted at a time when xenophobia and a lingering dislike of German nationals, even though many were victims of Hitlerism, still existed in some Australians. The appointment of Lemberg was subject to questions and protests by the Australian Medical Association and chauvinistic scientists; questions were also asked in Federal Parliament. Fortunately, the Australian immigration authorities were more humane and Ingram himself persisted with the appointment and protected Lemberg from those who criticized him for lack of a medical degree. Lemberg and Ingram both originated in the Northern Hemisphere, but were different in personality. They were nevertheless complementary so that their combined organizational and scientific strengths contributed greatly for 40 years to the output of research from the Institute. A bond between them was their love of exploration and both men had suffered the miseries of the western front of World War I.
The experience of travel to the far distant Sydney was a shock for the Lembergs and, during the long ship voyage, provided many doubts on the wisdom of isolating themselves from the centre of western learning and research. However the Australia of the thirties and forties provided a fertile, if unfamiliar, soil for the growth of Lemberg's ideas in biochemistry and gave him an opportunity to provide intellectual leadership in his branch of science. Cast out of his homeland he sought, perhaps, to play a fuller role as an exemplar of liberal humanistic thought and to contribute to his adopted country some of the intellectual heritage of European society. Lemberg was quick to find support for his research and, though funds were modest, he considered himself fortunate to have obtained such support so soon after his arrival, when some others, who were less fortunate than he, had proceeded westwards after their ejection from Germany by the Hitler regime, and had languished alone. In their turn, he and his wife, Hanna, working particularly with the Hon. Camilla Wedgewood, assisted refugees who had come from Europe to Sydney. This involvement with displaced people of that period and from the later upheavals and political disturbances of Europe, with the consequential loss of personal liberty of many scientists, gave the Lembergs much opportunity for challenging humanitarian work. This also caused him to think deeply about the wider issues of human liberty and in his later years the increasing violence and barbarities of the post-war scene. He sought to avoid allying himself to any movement politically inclined to the right or to the left but rather applied himself to the furtherance of humane missions through the Society of Friends.
Early years in Australia
The first few years were difficult, as he had inherited little equipment in his laboratory. The staff consisted of one graduate doing hospital analyses, one research graduate, R.A. Wyndham, and one technician, M. Norris, later to become a distinguished industrial chemist. He had to set about acquiring staff and was fortunate in obtaining the help of two very able younger colleagues in J.W. Legge and W.H. Lockwood who joined him in 1937 and 1938 respectively. At this time his eminence in the area of biological pigments had received international recognition, and he was invited to be author of the first review on animal pigments for the Annual Review of Biochemistry of 1937. The first X-ray crystallographic study on an azaporphyrin – a tetrapyrrole closely related to biological porphyrins – had just been completed by J.M. Robertson. The recognition of its planar structure led Lemberg to speculate on the binding of the iron-complexes of porphyrins to protein as in the oxygen carriers, haemoglobin and myoglobin, and in the haematin enzymes. Here he showed his brilliant insight and the beginning of his later preoccupation with the intimate relationship of the haems with their associated proteins, leading him to emphasize the importance of the conformational changes of the protein moiety of haemoproteins in determining and controlling the reactivity of the central iron of haematin enzymes, particularly cytochrome oxidase.
Those were the days of the threat of Nazism. Legge the Marxist and Lemberg the social democrat argued through the historical antagonism of ideologies to form a united front of two. Lemberg's pleasure at finding someone who spoke the same language and Legge's respect for his intellect developed into an understanding and affection that was life-long.
The advent of war in 1939 and the consequent increased isolation of Australia hindered the development of his laboratory researches. The exigencies of the war, particularly Australia's isolation from her normal sources of pharmaceuticals and other chemicals, provided a stimulus to find effective local means to overcome deficiencies of supply. To that end many notable scientists including Lemberg were coopted to give advice. He and his colleagues carried out a number of ad hoc investigations which arose from wartime needs. It was during this period that he isolated an orange pigment from a fungus gathered on his frequent walks in the Sydney bush. Named by him polystictin (now cinnabarin), it was the only nitrogen-containing fungal pigment then discovered. Lemberg studied its decarboxylation and later a colleague, Dr Peter Clezy (now associate professor of organic chemistry in the University of NSW) established cinnabarin to be 2-amino-phenoxazin-3-one and thus related to the antibiotic actinomycins.
During this period Lemberg intensified his survey of the accumulated literature of tetrapyrrole chemistry and biochemistry for his writing of the text on the haematin compounds and bile pigments – a book which was firmly to establish his authority in the field of tetrapyrrole biochemistry. Within this book he sought to bring into relation the many and varied biochemical manifestations of the porphyrin molecule as well as the linear tetrapyrroles, the animal bile pigments and the algal phycobilins, which had first drawn him into this diverse realm of chemical biochemistry. The book, Hematin Compounds and Bile Pigments, was published in 1949 with J.W. Legge as co-author and some collaboration from J.P. Callaghan. This book was a high-water mark in Lemberg's scientific development and thinking. It led to the shaping of his future major lines of personal research, which included the elucidation of the structure of porphyrin a and his investigations into the complexities of the interaction between molecular oxygen and the two haem a components of cytochrome oxidase (cytochromes a + a3). Quite early, Lemberg realized and put forward the view that the haem of the haemoproteins must lie in a crevice formed by the polypeptide chain of the protein.
Post-war years
The immediate post-war period brought to the research programmes of Lemberg some more very able men when Ernest Foulkes and John Falk joined his research group. Foulkes later became professor of physiology at Cincinatti, USA. Falk, who made important contributions to our knowledge of the biosynthesis of porphyrins and was the author of a classical book on porphyrins, later became Chief of Division of Plant Industry, CSIRO.
Lemberg committed himself and his colleagues for the next 14 years to the study of the structure of the prosthetic groups of cytochrome oxidase (cytochromes a + a3), cytochrome a2 (the terminal oxidase of many bacteria), lactoperoxidase and myeloperoxidase, and the interaction of these haems with their protein moieties. Significant contributions were made to the determination of the structure of these porphyrin prosthetic groups, some of which were first identified and isolated by Lemberg's school. The achievement was all the more remarkable considering the relatively simple apparatus and paucity of technical assistance. Great use was made of the hand spectroscope and the Hartridge reversion spectroscope, supplemented in 1951 by the first manual electronic spectrophotometer. Previously the quantitative spectral analysis – then a vital method in the determination of porphyrin structure – had been carried out using an optical spectrophotometer.
The haem moiety of cytochromes a + a3, the Atmungsferment of Warburg, proved hard to isolate and purify. Warburg chose to attempt to purify the haem, but Lemberg with his greater command of tetrapyrrole chemistry elected to purify the porphyrin. The task was difficult because of the extreme lipophilic nature of the molecule and the presence of complex lipid impurities from the heart tissue, and even obtaining enough fresh hearts was not easy! However, by the late forties Lemberg in Sydney, C. Rimington (with John Falk) at University College, London, W.A. Rawlinson of Melbourne University (in collaboration with Hale of St Mary's Medical School, London) had achieved the isolation of porphyrin a from heart muscle and bacteria, and had demonstrated that it had formyl and vinyl functions. Appropriately a joint communication was presented, in the presence of the pioneer, David Keilin, at the first International Congress of Biochemistry at Cambridge. The complete purification and crystallization of porphyrin a (as the dimethyl ester) and the definitive determination of the complete structure and subsequent synthesis of the porphyrin at the Cambridge Chemical Laboratories, under Alan Battersby, in collaboration with one of us (J.B., a former member of Lemberg's research group) and at the University of NSW chemistry school under Clezy, required 25 more years during which major contributions to the elucidation of the structure were made by the Lemberg school.
In 1949 Lemberg went overseas for the first time since his arrival in Australia – a span of 14 years. The international biochemical scene had changed greatly since his departure from Cambridge. With the stimulus provided by the post-war revival of biochemical research, there were advances in instrumentation, such as those of Britton Chance in spectroscopy, which were to have a profound influence on the development of dynamic studies in bioenergetics. New vistas were opening like that of Perutz at Cambridge, who had begun his X-ray crystallographic study of haemoglobin, of immense interest to Lemberg. By 1948 also, Shemin and Rittenberg in the USA, and Altman, had experimentally confirmed Lemberg's prediction that glycine and succinate were precursors of porphyrins and had opened up the whole problem of the complex biosynthesis of the natural tetrapyrroles.
Following the first International Biochemistry Congress at Cambridge, where he met several of the English and Continental porphyrin biochemists and investigators into bioenergetics of the cell, Lemberg proceeded to the USA. He was there also to meet several of the leaders of research into porphyrin biosynthesis and into bile pigment metabolism. As a former Rockefeller scholar of the 1930s, he visited the Rockefeller University. He then worked for two months in Chicago with David Shemin whose recent work with Rittenberg had shown by labelling with 14C that glycine and succinic acid were the precursors of the tetrapyrroles. Shemin(1) has recounted that they sought to identify the C1 compound that escaped on the splitting of the ring when haem was degraded to biliverdin. He recalls that they mistakenly looked for CHO rather than correctly for CO. Lemberg also encountered Watson and Schmidt of Minnesota who have spoken of their immense admiration for Lemberg's scientific insight, wide-ranging intelligence, and personal charm.
Lemberg journeyed to the west coast visiting Berkeley and the laboratory of Calvin, who was later to receive a Nobel award for his discovery of the C3 photosynthesis cycle. Although not engaged in photosynthesis chemistry, apart from his earlier discoveries of the nature of the chromophores of the algal phycobiliproteins, Lemberg thought of and contributed to the discussion of the specific features of the chlorophylls which were especially pertinent to the primary act of photosynthesis.
On his return to Australia Lemberg was enabled by a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation to purchase a modern high speed centrifuge and other equipment for a joint investigation with his next generation of colleagues into the bioenergetics of animal and microbial cells. The same year brought to the laboratory the first manual electronic spectrophotometer of high optical resolution. This instrument, and its successors, were to play an important role in the elucidation of the structure of porphyrin. Though Lemberg gradually acquired, and used with great skill, the new equipment that more sophisticated technology made available, he was a master of simple improvization which he maintained could often solve difficult technical problems. He would recount, with some glee, how his analytical chemistry teacher, 'old' Jannash at Munich, had removed the starched shirt cuffs from his wrists to demonstrate their use as shields when grinding refractory silicates in a mortar. He had a delicate, artistic approach to bench work which accounted for much of his success, exemplified by the great skill that enabled him to crystallize the dimethyl ester of biliverdin which had defied purification since its discovery in the 1850s.
Lemberg was catholic in his acceptance of people with innate scientific ability. Not overly impressed by formal degrees, he would give opportunities to those who had not experienced the particular scientific disciplines encompassed by his school. Because of his attitude, two of his colleagues, Frank Moss, a medical bacteriologist (later associate professor of biochemistry, University of NSW) and one of us (J.B.), formerly a microbiologist, were enabled to make significant contributions to the work of the Lemberg school. Lemberg's relationship with his co-workers was that of a gentle aristocrat and savoured of the enlightened court of a nineteenth century German principality, echoing another era. 'Let a thousand flowers flourish' could well have described Lemberg's laboratory in its most creative period.
His undoubtedly high reputation for his work on tetrapyrrole chemistry and biochemistry was recognized by the Royal Society of London which elected him to its fellowship in 1951.
Later years
Because of his dominant interest with the organic moieties of the many fascinating tetrapyrrole-proteins investigated at Royal North Shore Hospital, his laboratory was essentially a natural-product style organic chemistry laboratory until the advent of David B. Morell, a student of David Keilin. Later, the grants of large NIH funds enabled support of research, particularly in the protein field, so that work in the sixties and seventies was directed towards topics in haemoprotein and phycobiliprotein biochemistry rather than porphyrin chemistry per se. Perhaps the turning point can be seen to be marked by the Haematin Enzyme Symposium organized under the auspices of the Australian Academy of Science and held in Canberra in 1959. Lemberg was the president and principal editor of the proceedings; R.K. Morton was the convener, and Falk the local organizer. The proceedings were published under the title of Haematin Enzymes. This international symposium was something of a watershed in the development of haematin biochemistry, bringing together for the first time on this subject, workers from mathematics, physics, and biology. It was important for another reason also, for it was the first time that a party of Japanese scientists had visited Australia since before World War II and marked the beginning of the collaboration between Australian and Japanese biochemists working in this field. The Japanese delegation was headed by Professor K. Kaziro who had been at Cambridge University. Others who attended included Y. Ogura and F. Egami, and the younger, brilliant T. Horio. By then most of the purely organic-type chemistry on the porphyrins and bile pigments in Lemberg's laboratory had been carried out and the later sustained interest in the interaction of their metal complexes – or the free tetrapyrroles in the case of the phycobiliproteins – was developing. Lemberg himself had just returned from a six months visit overseas where, during 1958, he had worked on the biosynthesis of porphyrin a for two months in Rimington's laboratory at University College Hospital, London. He had also visited university departments in Europe, including those of Lynen and Kiese in Munich. He had also lectured at the Academia Anatomica-Chirugica di Perugia (and in 1959 took much pleasure when membership of the ancient Academy was conferred on him, so reinforcing his 'European identity').
That invigorating confrontation in 1959 with many eminent workers on the area of cytochromes and haematin enzymes stimulated his research into the complexities of cytochrome oxidase, for him perhaps the most important of haematin enzymes – or of any – because of its vital role in respiration. This study of a highly sophisticated haem-copper protein complex absorbed Lemberg's attention to the end of his working life. From that time on he was also increasingly involved in international collaboration. In 1966 he was guest professor with Britton Chance at the Johnson Foundation, University of Pennsylvania, where he continued the collaboration with Dr Marion Gilmour who had been a visiting fellow in his laboratory in Sydney. He contributed vigorous discussions on cytochrome oxidase during his USA visit, particularly at the Heme and Hemoproteins Colloquium in Philadelphia (a colloquium dedicated to him) and at the first Gordon Conference on porphyrins which was also attended by four of his collaborators – Falk, Barrett, Sinclair, and Gilmour.
In 1967, accompanied by two of his associates, he went to Japan as chairman of the Symposium on Structure and Function of Cytochromes honouring Okunuki, the leader of haematin-enzyme research in Japan. He prepared himself (aged 70) by learning some Japanese. His preeminence in tetrapyrrole biochemistry was generally recognized and he was sought after by many Japanese scientists both at Kobe and at the Congress of Biochemistry in Tokyo. He was accorded the status of Dai Sensei (distinguished teacher). On his part, Lemberg admired the Japanese scientists for their experimental skills and keen powers of observation. As always, he embraced new experiences with appreciative vigour and attended the classical theatres, One of us (J.B.) remembers both the vigour with which he scaled the hills above Lake Hakone to arrive at the sulphurous plateau of Ohwakidani and to examine enthusiastically the bubbling sulphur vents, and his enjoyment of the solitude at a wayside eating place. In his final year of professional life (1972) he revisited the centres of haemoprotein work in Japan, en route to the symposium on porphyrin chemistry convened by the New York Academy of Sciences.
In his last decade he was particularly engrossed with the problem of the interaction of the two molecules of haem a (not rigidly proven to be identical in every structural detail) and the two copper atoms of the complex mammalian cytochrome oxidase (cytochrome a,a3). This phase of his life work culminated in a definitive and encyclopaedic review in 1969 in Physiological Reviews, which brought some thousand requests for reprints from many countries. A final and more synoptic account of his views was given in his second book, Cytochromes, with J. Barrett, published in 1973. There he expressed his standpoint that, though the evidence did not support the view that cytochrome oxidase consisted of two separate haem a proteins, there was strong evidence for two different types of binding of the two haem a groups to protein in cytochrome-oxidase. In this view he differed from the eminent and admired Okunuki school. In his later experimental work Lemberg intensively studied, with Professor Ron Williams of Canada and Dr Marion Gilmour of the USA, the ferric state and the oxygenated state (discovered by Okunuki) of solubilized cytochrome oxidase. He concluded that mechanistically the oxygenated state was important as being indicative of a highly reactive, transient Fe3+, or ferryl (Fe IV) state of membraneous cytochrome oxidase in the mitochondrion.
Influence on Australian science
Lemberg had experienced, in the 1930s, the value of the frequent meetings of the British Biochemical Society as a forum of interchange of ideas for spreading the burgeoning knowledge of biochemistry. In Sydney he actively participated in the late 1940s and early 1950s with his colleagues in the (now defunct) Society for Experimental Biology of NSW. From the time of World War II he attended regularly the weekly forum at the Botany School, Sydney University, inaugurated and led by one of us (R.N.R.). The appreciation of this reading group (affectionately termed the bible class!) for the critical discussion and dissemination of current international research, particularly in what is now termed bioenergetics, is attested to by the assiduous weekly attendance of the 'Lemberg group', considering the time and hazards of travel across Sydney. Lemberg's contributions to the education of many younger scientists at that reading group over about 15 years were of great value.
The Australian Academy of Science was founded in 1954 by a group of scientists most of whom were fellows of the Royal Society of London. Lemberg, who had become an FRS in 1952, was much concerned with the discussions leading up to the foundation of the Academy and regarded it as a very important development for Australian science. He subsequently took part in various activities, being a member of Council (1956-58) and vice-president (1957-58). When the Academy began it took over the National Committee for Biochemistry which had been under the auspices of the Australian National Research Council and on which he had been serving. Lemberg was elected to the National Committee for Biochemistry of the Academy and served until 1966 and took part in the activities of the Sectional Committees. He was particularly interested in the Academy building, both before and after it was completed and welcomed the addition of its imaginative architecture among the more conventional Canberra buildings; he referred to it as the 'mushroom'. He regularly attended the dinners of the Sydney fellows' dining club. Lemberg was also active in the affairs of the Royal Society of NSW and was its president in 1956.
The growth of biochemistry in Australia, largely in the capital cities, was brought about by increased funding by the Federal Government through the National Health and Medical Research Council and, later, the Australian Research Grants Committee. It was assisted also by the formation of several special disease-oriented medical funds and by the expansion of that fount of biological research in Australia, the CSIRO. The growing interest in biochemistry and the increasing number of biochemists resulted in a search for a more general venue for an exchange of current biochemical research within Australia. At the national level this had previously been effected to some extent at ANZAAS. Lemberg was a strong supporter of that organization and in 1954 he was president of the section comprising biochemistry and physiology at the ANZAAS Congress. By this time there was a strong feeling that biochemists needed a specialist association to advance their science. Extensive consultation led to the formation in 1955 of the Australian Biochemical Society, of which Rudi Lemberg became the first president, and subsequently its first honorary life member. Recently the principal annual lecture of the Society and its associated gold medal were named after him.
From his viewpoint as director of the Biochemical Laboratories of the Royal North Shore Hospital, Lemberg realized the need to upgrade the standard of clinical biochemical analysis. He saw particularly the need to achieve complete biochemical values for normal subjects to assist the clinician in his diagnosis of pathological states. Following consultation with D. Roman of Adelaide and other clinical biochemists, he encouraged his deputy in the clinical area, F. Radcliff, to collaborate in this task with K.M. Mattocks (Sydney), J. Owen (Melbourne), and D.H. Curnow (Perth). Having provided a stimulus to action, Lemberg left this task to his younger confreres, while continuing to play the role of an elder statesman. He was gratified to see shortly the formation of the Association of Clinical Biochemists – and to become its patron.
Lemberg served on the Advisory Committee of the NH&MR Council for ten years: he was always concerned about the financial plight of the young and promising research worker at the threshold of an independent career. For some years Lemberg was also on the Advisory Committee of the NSW State Cancer Council, where he sought to apply strict scientific principles to the assessment of applications for grants.
It is appropriate to record that, throughout his scientific career in Australia, he was generously supported – in the context of the limited funds available – by grants, first from the National Health and Medical Research Council, and later from the Australian Research Grants Committee. Between 1961 and 1969 the National Institutes of Health (USA), Heart Division, gave considerable amounts of money for major equipment, salaries, and substantial alteration and refitting of part of one floor at the Kolling Institute. The successful development and redeployment of the research within the scientific ambit of Lemberg and his colleagues during that period was dependent on this foreign aid which, thereby, made an important contribution to advancing biochemistry in this country.
It is a significant comment on the university scene in Australia, and in Sydney in particular, that Lemberg received no official recognition from any university until the University of Sydney conferred on him an honorary DSc in 1970, largely due to the representations made by L.C. Birch and R.J.W. Le Fèvre. Though he contributed in many ways to university life, his potential as a teacher and leader of thought in the biological sphere was never recognized by any formal academic affiliation or by a personal chair, such as would have happened in other countries. His scientific eminence was recognized by his peers in this country and especially overseas. In 1956 his old university, Heidelberg, conferred on him the status of Professor Emeritus, and he was a foreign member of the Heidelberg Academy of Science. In 1965, he was awarded the James Cook Medal of the Royal Society of NSW and, in 1971, the Walter Burfitt Prize and Medal of the same Society.
His philosophy
Lemberg thought deeply about life, the significance of man's existence in the cosmic scheme, and his personal role therein. He was a deist and his philosophical thinking was influenced and permeated with the light of his particular understanding of man's existence. Although a protestant and a member of the Society of Friends, shaped by his education and his long association with his gifted and devoted wife Hanna, he had within him elements of the Hebraic faith and would often emotionally identify with the Jewish cause in controversial issues.
As a scientist he thought critically about the physical origin of life, devoting a chapter in each of his books to discussion of the evolution of tetrapyrroles and haematin enzymes. Lemberg accepted the geobiological evolutionary theories of I.A. Oparin, who has expressed his great respect for Lemberg and his exploratory discussions of this topic.
He was preoccupied with the truths of human life. He was not only analytical in his approach but also thought creatively. He was emancipated, humane, and compassionate in his approach to social questions, but elements of the Jewish concept of a just, albeit strict and righteous, God would obtrude into the more generally tolerant vein of his attitudes. His stature as a theological thinker was recognized by the invitation of the Society of Friends of Australia to give the annual Backhouse Lecture in 1966. This lecture 'Seeking in an age of Imbalance' has been widely acclaimed.
His desire for open discussion of the philosophical and sociological, on a real-world plane, led him for many years to participate actively in and often lead the wider discussions provided by the Friday evening forum of the Society of Friends, to which not only senior members of the community came, but also many students. For some young people these discussions, especially in the 1960s, left an indelible impression. Men such as Dr H.C. Coombs, chairman of the Reserve Bank and later chairman of the Australian Council of Aboriginal Affairs, Thomas Keneally, novelist, Charles Birch, biologist and theologian, Peter Mason, physicist, women such as Faith Bandler, aboriginal leader and spokeswoman, and Dorothy Butler, the mountaineer, presented their views on major contemporary issues at these forums, the venue of which was a Meeting House given by Lemberg to the Society of Friends, and set in the beautiful native bush garden of his home at Wahroonga. This Meeting House had been built from the money of his Britannica (Aust.) Prize for Science, presented in 1965.
As his life advanced, he became increasingly concerned with the spiritual crises of western technological man and with the problems increasingly encountered by the Asian countries confronted with the impact of this technology. He raised his voice against the abuse of scientific knowledge, against its misuse by military-economic juntas, and against political power-blocks' ability to lay waste man's environment, and his artistic and social heritage. He was troubled by the use of violence in political and social disputes, and saw in the unbridled uses of violence and torture as political tools the possible ultimate destruction of humane rationalistic western society. As a pacifist, his conscience led him to protest against the dangers to the peace of the world caused by the development of the H-bomb. He deplored the idiocies and cruel suffering of the Vietnamese war. His convictions were such that when he was in his seventies he endured a silent vigil throughout the night outside the Sydney Town Hall.
His character
In his early years, Rudi Lemberg had a private teacher who was a naturalist; his mother also knew the names of nearly all the local species of wildflowers and, in his university years, he received some instruction in botany. Freudenberg recalls he was a gardening enthusiast in Heidelberg where he rented a small garden to grow flowers and vegetables and a few grape vines. His early interests matured into a great love of the flora of the native bush of New South Wales and of the alpine slopes of the Snowy Mountains. With loving meticulousness, he plotted the distribution, and catalogued the identity and appearance of the many wildflowers, bushes and trees that filled the one-acre native bush garden of his home in the hills of Sydney. His special love was for the wild orchids; these beautiful, sometimes solitary plants, he photographed systematically.
Lemberg was a very warm person despite his sometimes austere attitudes, and was sincerely interested in the continuing fortunes of younger scientists with whom he had had association either as supervisor of their research in his own laboratories, as an adviser to a PhD student, or later as examiner. He took pride in their achievements even if they were not his own pupils. On one occasion he was heard to refer to his own scientific entourage as his 'science children' and the students of John Falk, who was then heading a flourishing porphyrin and chlorophyll biochemistry research group in Canberra, as his 'science grandchildren'. If there was a slight possessiveness in this remark, it was far out-weighed by his sense of continuing responsibility to those he had guided in their careers.
He took great interest in imparting his knowledge to his associates, to students, and to children. Though never having formal teaching responsibilities in Australia, he gave many authoritative lectures in the scientific field, characterized by insight and breadth of scholarship and which were delightful and endearing in their delivery.
Lemberg had tremendous powers of concentration, and the ability to exclude all extraneous distractions when working at the bench or writing, to the extent that it was sometimes impossible to break into his consciousness if he was approached without prior arrangement. During the writing of the book The Cytochromes, in his seventies, after a day in his laboratory going through his card index and journals he would work every evening until late at night, collating and writing the text of the chapter currently in hand.
When in deep consideration of some of his favourite scientific principles, Lemberg was oblivious of the mechanical and organizational machinery of society. Colleagues remember, with fond amusement, his presidential address to the Royal Society of NSW. Having filled the blackboard, he sought only briefly for the duster before, to the sudden consternation of the secretary of the Society, he firmly grasped the scarlet side curtains with the very evident intent of putting them to practical use as dusters! Likewise, he was not interested in, or good at, the mundane administrative tasks which he rarely delegated but simply by-passed, believing usually correctly, that someone would take over.
Similarly, Lemberg did not organize the members of his research groups into a coordinated multi-faceted attack on a problem. Unless frustrated by his personal inability to cope with the necessary scale of operations, he worked frequently as a 'one man band' thus allowing his colleagues to work with him or on (sometimes rather distantly) related topics, as they chose. Thus, it was difficult to imagine Lemberg as the motivating head of a university department with all its organizational as well as human needs. Nevertheless, he was exceptional as one who would motivate his colleagues through his ad hoc 'think sessions' in the research laboratory or the discussion group where his leadership stemmed simply from the high quality of his probing and postulating mind.
Never having a large staff, at the most four senior colleagues with an equal number of supporting assistants and the occasional visitor, he was an assiduous bench worker and only in his later years delegated his experiments to others.
Trained as a chemist, though by nature drawn to the enormous variety of form and range of colour of the biological realm, he delighted in the coloured solutions of porphyrins and bile pigments and the formal beauty of their crystallized state. Until his death he retained, and displayed with great pleasure, the first crystals of phycocyanin prepared in 1932 at Cambridge. To his great joy, his wife Hanna, through her sensitive skill, was able to capture the colour and form of the Australian bush in her remarkable tapestries.
Lemberg gave a distinctive and intellectual stature to the science of biochemistry in Australia equalled by only a few others in his time. He brought to his adopted country a rich heritage from the associations of his youth and early manhood. In his life he bore himself with a dignity and was an exemplar of the value of reason and scholarship. He conducted himself with no interest in personal gain or in the acquisition of power. He brought with him the impress of his years at Cambridge where he had grown to love the gentleness and warmth of his many Cambridge friends, some of whom were of the Society of Friends. He invested any office he held with a sense of dignity and purposefulness to deal with the tasks ahead, committing himself with zeal to the furtherance of its cause.
Though Lemberg was sure of his position as a scientist and aware of the esteem with which his work was held by those familiar with the field of haematin enzymes he, nevertheless, bore some evidence of the insecurity of his younger years. This in part had been generated by the economic collapse of the new German Republic and by the destruction of his career in Germany due to the emergence of the Nazi regime. As his wife has noted, the shock of having to fight for his very existence, because he had been publicly stamped as a Jew, contributed greatly to this sense of insecurity.
His insecurity appeared also in later life because he seemed to feel that he had not been accepted by the establishment at Cambridge, despite his two periods in that mecca of biochemists, and he never revisited Cambridge after the first Biochemical Congress in 1949. At some stage in his earlier life, he had prepared a paper for the Proceedings of the Royal Society and it had been rejected and returned with comments which he regarded as unscientific.
Perhaps compensating for this uncertainty made him appear arrogant at times. Though somewhat autocratic in approach and somewhat impatient with specious arguments, which he would contemptuously dismiss, he was not arrogant but rather was committed to maintaining standards of excellence and intellectual probity, sometimes in situations where these standards had been obscured. He was a somewhat reticent person, though accurately described as an intellectual elitist. Although quick to speak his case in any discussion, private or public, he did not appear to be fitted to participate in the hurly-burly of academic politics and certainly would never engage in 'horse-trading' to secure personal or professional advancement.
With the passage of time perhaps his greatest contribution to science (and above all to its quality) in this country may be seen not only in his intellectual scientific achievements, great as they were, but also in the leadership he gave and in the maintenance of the highest standards of conduct and judgement, often before conflicting claims. This he did with firmness but with an essential humility only by which a man can advance the causes of enlightenment of humanity and of even partial comprehension of the universe.
Sir John Eccles, Nobel laureate, has written to one of us:
Rudi Lemberg was one of the most gracious and gentle men I have ever known. In a wonderful way he adopted his new homeland with a deep love and understanding of nature. He became an expert in Australian wildflowers, particularly in the great national parks of the Sydney area. I remember vividly several long walks with him in the enchanting Kuringai Chase, in August, in wildflower time. Out of his love grew his acre of beautifully planted wildflowers and trees in his paradisal 'Sanctuary' at Wahroonga.
He was deeply religious and extremely sensitive to the wonder and mystery of existence. After much effort he was able to develop a philosophy in which science and religion had a complementary relationship at a mystical level. It was a synthesis of vital interest to this present age of disillusionment, where it has been assumed that science had destroyed religion and yet had not replaced it by a system of beliefs whereby human individuals could live in harmony and dedication and face death with serenity.
I had long ago urged him to write his message to mankind, and at last he started, but unfortunately too late. It was to be a great enterprise and was entitled Complementarity of Religion and Science. Alas, he died after completing only 8 of the projected 50 chapters. Here is a brief extract:
'We are creatures of the earth and part of nature, and also made in God's image in a sense deeper than that nature is also God's creation. We are in a special way God's helpmates to whom some creativity has been delegated. We remain as part of nature and can as such enjoy its beauty. The knowledge of the really great scientists has not diminished but enhanced their sense of wonder and mystery. Far from being a hindrance to the freedom of our souls, matter is in fact the complement, providing the handholds and footholds on the mountain of our spiritual climb.'
I believe that this fragment of eight chapters gives a unique message by a great scientist. I hope for a publisher who will link these eight chapters with some six earlier publications by him on religion and science.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Records of the Australian Academy of Science, vol. 4(1), 1978. It was written by:
- Jack Barrett MSc, who was a member of the Biochemical Research Group of the Kolling Institute, Royal North Shore Hospital, Sydney, 1953–73, and is at the time of publication a Visiting Fellow with the CSIRO Division of Plant Industry, Canberra.
- Sir Rutherford Robertson CMG DSc FRS, who was director of the Research School of Biological Sciences, The Australian National University, and is at the time of publication Emeritus Professor of Botany in the University of Adelaide. He was elected to the Academy in 1958, was secretary (Biological Sciences) in 1958, a member of Council 1961-64, and president of the Academy 1970–74.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to a number of people who helped us with material and comments when we were writing this biographical memoir. Special thanks are due to Mrs Lemberg for her substantial and thoughtful help at all times and to Mrs Katherine Carson, secretary of the Institute for Medical Research at Royal North Shore Hospital, who played such an important role over many years in the research group.
Former research colleagues of Lemberg who have helped are P. Clezy, J.W. Legge, W.H. Lockwood, D.B. Morell and Norma Scott (Newton). Helpful comments also came from C. Appleby and the letter quoted came from Sir John Eccles. We are indebted to Dr G.F. Kolar for obtaining and translating into English the reminiscences of Professor Karl Freudenberg.
Notes
(1) Personal communication.