Hugh Bryan Spencer Womersley 1922–2011

Professor Bryan Womersley was recognised internationally for his work on Australia's macroalgae, describing more than 320 new genera and species.

Image Description

Hugh Bryan Spencer Womersley disliked the word ‘seaweed’, and objected every time it was spoken in his presence. To him algae were not ‘weeds’ but beautiful organisms, well worthy of making the subject of a lifetime of scientific study. 

As was common in the middle of the 20th century, Womersley did not begin his career as a phycologist, but rather found himself specialising in this life form after discovering how richly represented and little known it was along the coast of southern Australia. 

In his 70-year association with the University of Adelaide, Bryan transformed the study of phycology in Australia, attracting a pool of talented students to contribute to his grand project of a marine benthic flora of southern Australia, and to carry the study of algae forward into the next generation. 

Being a pioneer in the field gave him opportunities for groundbreaking research and an overview of the discipline as it developed, positioning him as the leading expert on Australian algae in the international phycological community.

Download the memoir

 

Supplementary material

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 30(2), 2019. It was written by Sara Maroske.

Howard Knox Worner 1913–2006

Professor Howard Worner CBE FAA FTSE was a brilliant metallurgist, industry leader and respected advisor to government.

Image Description

Howard Knox Worner was a renowned figure in Australian applied science and engineering. His successful career can be credited to his strong intellect, leadership and charisma. 

Coming from a humble farming background, he achieved a brilliant academic career in metallurgy and materials at the University of Melbourne. From the position of Dean of Engineering he moved into industry as Director of Research with BHP where his leadership led to significant improvements in conventional steel production and where he conceived his concept of continuous steelmaking. This was not put into practice but after moving to CRA he applied his concept to continuous copper production where it has largely been accepted around the world. 

Later he was a high-level adviser to Government on energy research and development, particularly the economic utilisation of brown coal for liquid and gaseous fuels. In his ‘retirement' he became deeply involved at the University of Wollongong in the application of microwaves to mineral processing and waste treatment. He died on 17 November 2006, aged 93.

Download the memoir

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol.25, no.2, 2014. It was written by W. J. McG. Tegart and B. S. Hickman.

Horace Waring 1910–1980

Professor Horace Waring FAA pioneered marsupial physiology research in Australia – establishing field stations, training generations of zoologists, and opening up adrenal, reproductive and ecological studies of native fauna.

Image Description
Horace Waring 1910-1980

Horace (Harry) Waring was born in 1910 on the outskirts of Liverpool. From the Holt High School he entered the University of Liverpool, graduating BSc in 1931, having specialised in parasitology. He completed his Master of Science in 1932 with a thesis on histology. Later (in 1938) he was awarded a Doctorate of Science from the University of Aberdeen.

In the years between 1932 and 1937 Waring held a Herdman Scholarship and an Edward Forbes Exhibition, both for marine work and tenable at the University of Liverpool and the Marine Station, Isle of Man. During this period he developed his interest in colour change, especially of the dogfish. Between 1937 and 1946 Waring was associated with Lancelot Hogben while on the staff of Aberdeen, first as an assistant (Agricultural Zoology), later as a Carnegie Teaching Fellow (Experimental Zoology), and finally as a lecturer. From 1941 he was the entomologist in charge of the Ministry of Food stores, North and North-East Scotland. In 1946 he took the post of Head, without professorial rank, of the Zoology Department, University of Birmingham.

These were the formative and developmental years. Waring always maintained that the study of marsupials was a youthful ambition and by 1948, when he came to occupy a post where he could fulfil his ambition, he had had a wide experience in all aspects of zoological teaching and research except marsupials!

G. E. Nicholls, Professor of Biology in the University of Western Australia from 1921 until his retirement at the age of 70 in 1947, was followed by Waring as the first Professor of Zoology in 1948. Waring's impact on the University at that time and the trepidation felt at having an experimental zoologist join the staff, are well conveyed by extracts of correspondence and quotations from papers cited by Alexander in 1963 in his Campus at Crawley.

… the Vice-Chancellor was deeply concerned lest the choice of an experimental zoologist with a brilliant research record might result in the University being saddled with a discontented occupant of the Chair. (pp. 421–422)

In a letter to Waring the Vice-Chancellor emphasised that teaching was 'the first essential; research next'; and

My whole point in writing to you is to tell you about the conditions so that if you feel you would not be likely to be contented under those somewhat primitive conditions in which a continual struggle for funds to do what you want with is inevitable, you should decide so and not accept. (p. 422)

Alexander expresses it as 'the University's decision to gamble on the importation of … a pituitary physiologist-cum-pharmacologist'.

In Western Australia Waring saw many of his ambitions and dreams realised. Most of this was achieved by a single-minded dedication to the pursuit at all costs of his curiosity about marsupials. This attitude is perhaps best illustrated by his reactions to suggestions that during the period of University expansion Zoology should have a new building – it was then, as now, housed in the first building constructed on the Crawley campus. But a new building was not one of his ambitions, and on every occasion that a move to a new building was suggested (for reasons ranging from the belief that biological science disciplines could be centralised to the notion that zoology should be adjacent to kindred departments), he always fought the issue on the premise that a shift to another site would deprive zoology of the yard space so necessary for the marsupial colonies upon which the research program depended.

On such occasions the rationality of any suggestion was overshadowed by Waring's personality in the role of a prima donna. These exhibitions probably reached their high point on an occasion when Waring's deepest suspicions that no-one understood the need for yard space were apparently justified by a suggestion that the biological sciences should occupy a multi-storied building and zoology keep its animals on the roof!

Waring's other deep-seated but unexpressed objection to a new building was, however, based on his belief that he could not afford the years of research time which would be lost while a building was designed, built, occupied and then found to be inadequate.

Waring began his research work on colour change with the dogfish and Xenopus, the South African clawed toad. When he came to Western Australia, one of his first actions was to establish an enclosure with concrete tanks and running water in which he could maintain a number of Xenopus. His affection for this experimental animal is perhaps well illustrated by the fact that even when his research interests had moved exclusively to marsupials and he was no longer actively associated with colour change studies, he still maintained Xenopus in the yards of the Zoology Department, despite the fact that the toads needed to be imported from South Africa, required quarantine clearance for importation and a licence to hold them in the state where it is declared as vermin, and his holding facilities and husbandry were subjected to continuous surveillance.

It was never Waring's intention that the Department of Zoology become specialised solely in marsupial studies. Accordingly he fostered the research interests of other staff members as well as maintaining a broadly-based undergraduate course in zoology which aimed at introducing students to both the classical and comparative anatomical bases of morphology as well as physiology and endocrinology. It is noteworthy that it was only after his retirement that a course on marsupial biology was instituted in the department.

Waring's approach to undergraduate teaching was, to many students, quite the most devastating experience of their undergraduate career. For example, all his practical endocrinology and physiology classes commenced with a virtual examination of students on their ability to identify correctly – with detailed reasons – a number of histological preparations made by Waring himself of endocrine glands such as the pituitary and adrenal which had been the subject of his early research. Even in the very rare event that a student could correctly identify the histologically-distinct parts displayed in these preparations, Waring was not satisfied and immediately launched into a long inquisition to establish whether the student understood the embryological development of the structure being identified in the microscope slide. Undoubtedly this method ensured real understanding and formed an admirable basis for the comparative physiology and endocrinology which followed.

Of all his teaching Waring enjoyed instructing in surgery most of all. There was a flamboyance about his surgery and experimental preparations which, depending on whether one's sympathies lay with the animal preparations or the replicability of the scientific results, could be quite stunning. Waring believed that a short operation and quickly-made preparations were more likely to lead to valid and repeatable results, a circumstance which was vitally necessary as he eschewed statistics and ignored variability, as one would expect in a person trained exclusively in classical methods.

Waring was proud and boastful of his youthful boxing prowess. He obviously carried the attitude of the boxer into later life, and dealings with people took on the appearance of the boxing ring, with Waring adopting the posturing and sparring characteristics of the boxer, much to the consternation and dismay of the uninitiated.

The boxer's trick of feinting to deceive and mislead or unsettle his opponent while seeking advantage was highly developed in Waring. He would often use the ploy of posing as a physiologist and then display his detailed knowledge of comparative anatomy or somewhat specialised taxonomic fields, especially agricultural parasitology and entomology – relics from the time he taught these subjects in Scotland.

It is therefore surprising that despite the tensions inherent in the adversary situation engendered by Waring's personality he developed such fruitful and lasting associations with collaborators as is evidenced in his published papers, first with Landgrebe, then Moir, and finally with Stanley. The association with the late A. J. Fraser (then Director of the Department of Fisheries and Fauna) and K. S. Sheard of CSIRO Fisheries in establishing the Rottnest Biological Research Station was pivotal in Waring's ambition to study marsupials. The later association of A. J. Fraser and the Hon. Graham Mackinnon (at that time Minister for Fisheries and Fauna) in obtaining the lease of the land and establishing the Jandakot field station for marsupial research are outstanding examples of how he could promote an ideal and work with people to achieve it.

A similar fruitful association for marsupial studies was his friendship with, and support from, Ian Clunies Ross and the Executive of CSIRO, as well as Francis Ratcliffe, at that time head of CSIRO Wildlife, for field studies in marsupials.

Waring's contribution to marsupial studies and his fostering of studies on the Australian biota as a whole is perhaps best expressed in a quote from the citation on the occasion of his award of the Mueller Medal by ANZAAS in 1980:

… a research worker can stimulate advances in knowledge in the following ways:

  1. By asking questions and performing the research himself.
  2. By establishing an ongoing research program.
  3. By training and guiding research students who in an appropriate research environment apply their skills and extend the frontiers of knowledge.
  4. By virtue of all the foregoing create an atmosphere of endeavour which attracts additional workers and support from fund-granting bodies.

Waring has done all these in respect to marsupial studies in Australia. Moreover, we believe that without his initiatives, knowledge of this characteristic Australian element would be very much poorer than it is.

When Waring arrived at the University of Western Australia to take up the Chair of Zoology in 1948, studies on marsupials were virtually restricted to comparative and anatomical studies. Waring's background was as a physiologist, and in the first years of his stay in Perth he continued to produce papers based on the skills and background with which he arrived in Western Australia.

However, by 1952 the first paper on adrenalectomy in the wallaby was published. By 1956, in his presidential address to Section D of ANZAAS, he was able to talk of fields of study in adrenal, reproductive and digestive physiology, temperature regulation and water metabolism, as well as ecological studies.

Subsequently Waring's interest in all these fields did not flag. His approach was based on two sorts of questions:

  1. Comparative: how does a marsupial compare with a eutherian in respect to certain physiological functions?
  2. Ecophysiological: how does a particular aspect of physiology relate to function and survival in a field situation?

In a sense Waring's contribution to Australian marsupial studies depended upon good fortune: marsupials were first regarded as pests by pastoralists and therefore had to be controlled; and more latterly as elements of the fauna to be conserved, and therefore to be studied in their own right. Both these aspects stimulated massive government support, and this happened at a time when there was a core of active workers trained by Waring or his department, capable of filling the research posts offered and actively exploiting the research environment provided.

The problem of the freemartin had always fascinated Waring, and life in the pouch posed problems which challenged his innate curiosity. These two interests led to his later immunological studies which were prompted first by the experimental possibilities offered by a readily accessible embryo and latterly in wondering how the very immature pouched young defended itself against the many pathogens which would seem to find the warm moist pouch an ideal site for proliferation.

Despite the apparent dissimilarity of Waring's early studies on colour change and his later ones on marsupial reproduction and immunology, one can see that the research was united by a common methodology, namely that of simple surgical manipulation followed by replacement therapy.

Waring was well known for his boisterous sense of humour, his unwillingness to suffer fools, and his dedication to education coupled with a belief that teachers should have a personal involvement in research, an ideal he pursued throughout his academic life.

Waring took his role as a teacher very seriously. He saw teaching as more than mere instruction or imparting of information, and strove at all times to enthuse students and impart a love of zoology. In his first year lecturing Waring achieved these aims by a flamboyant presentation designed to shock students into realising that teaching at University was different from that experienced at school.

To Waring the graduation of students was never an end to his interest in them. His liberal approach to education never tried to fit students into a mould, and he saw each graduand rather as an omniscient biological Deity might look upon a new gene combination being released into a world where natural selection would provide a test of adequacy. Yet Waring realised that chance and selection would both be at work, and he was always active and persistent in promoting all graduates lest chance rather than true worth determine their success in the more worldly situation outside the University.

Though Waring displayed a rough abrasive exterior, one often detected that this façade covered a liberal and humane personality. For those who endured misfortune his compassion was both deep and profound.

Despite outward appearances he was sensitive to recognition and he found election to the Academy in 1954, the participation in the 1963 UNESCO Conference in South America on Arid Regions, the receipt of the Britannica Australia Award in 1970, the Honorary Doctorate of Science from the University of Western Australia in 1970, and the Mueller Medal in 1980, particularly gratifying. He was a member of the Council of the Academy 1957–59 and Vice-President 1958–59. He died on 9 August 1980.

In 1938 Waring married Doreen Dickinson (deceased 1976). He is survived by a son (George) and a daughter (Linda) by his first marriage, and his second wife (Muriel Naomi Crapp).

At the memorial service in St. George's College Chapel the oration was given by his former professorial colleague Mervyn Austin.

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 5(2), 1981. It was written by Albert Russell Main CBE PhD FAA, Professor of Zoology at the University of Western Australia.

Acknowledgements

I am thankful to the following who read and commented on the manuscript: S. D. Bradshaw, B. D. Curtis, E. P. Hodgkin, R. J. Moir, N. F. Stanley and H. M. Vose.

Horace Newton Barber 1914–1971

Newton Barber was a distinguished botanist and geneticist who published widely across experimental cytology, taxonomy, genetics, ecology, forestry, biogeography, palaeobotany and mycology.

Image Description
horace barber

H. Newton Barber was born on 26 May 1914 at Warburton, Cheshire, England. He was educated at Manchester Grammar School and then at Emmanuel College, University of Cambridge (MA 1941, SeD 1963). From 1936 to 1940 he was Research Cytologist of the John Innes Horticultural Institute, London (PhD 1942). He worked during the war years as a Scientific Officer with the Telecommunications Research Establishment of the Ministry of Aircraft Production and served as a Flight Lieutenant (Hon.) with the Royal Air Force Volunteer Reserve (1943–5) in the Mediterranean and South East Asia Commands. In 1946 he was appointed Lecturer in Botany in the University of Sydney. In 1947 he became Professor of Botany in the University of Tasmania, where he remained until 1963 when he was appointed Foundation Professor of Botany in the University of New South Wales. He was planning to move in the year of his death to the University of Newcastle as Foundation Professor of Biological Sciences.

Barber brought with him to Australia his pre-war interests in cytology and genetics. He helped stimulate important research work in these areas after reaching Sydney. Because of the necessarily broad nature of his interests, his published papers include contributions to experimental cytology, experimental taxonomy, physiological genetics, protein genetics and the genetics of natural selection. He made especially important contributions to the studies of plant cytogenetics and extended the knowledge of chromosome behaviour. He was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1963.

As a teacher he was actively interested in new techniques in instruction for the biological sciences. He was first Dean of the Faculty of Science (1951–55) and Chairman of the Professorial Board (1956–59) in the University of Tasmania. In 1966 he became Head of the School of Biological Sciences in the University of New South Wales.

Barber was a Rockefeller Foundation Special Fellow at the California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, 1953–54, and Royal Society Visiting Professor in the University of Ibadan, Nigeria, in 1967. He was President of Section M of ANZAAS in 1956.

Download the memoir

Herbert Sydney Green 1920-1999

Bert Green's influence on the development of theoretical science in Australia during the nearly fifty years he lived here cannot be overestimated. From the time he arrived in Adelaide in July 1951, until his death on 16 February 1999, he produced articles and books covering topics as diverse as particle physics, environmental science and neurophysiology. In each of the areas in which he worked, his contributions were always marked by erudition and originality.

Image Description

Written by Angas Hurst.

Herbert Sydney Green 1920-1999

Introduction

Bert Green's influence on the development of theoretical science in Australia during the nearly fifty years he lived here cannot be overestimated. From the time he arrived in Adelaide in July 1951 until his death on 16 February 1999 he produced articles and books covering topics as diverse as particle physics, environmental science and neurophysiology. In each of the areas in which he worked, his contributions were always marked by erudition and originality. It is not surprising, therefore, that everyone who came in contact with him, from undergraduate students to international colleagues, wrote in warm and admiring tones about their contact with him.

So, although his official appointment was to the inaugural chair of Mathematical Physics in the University of Adelaide, physics was only one of the fields in which he employed his superb mathematical talent. As an example of some of the outer reaches of his interests, he once used some statistical analyses, prepared by the Dutch composer Henk Badings, of the compositions of some of the great composers to produce by computer (then the very rudimentary IBM1620) lines in the style of Beethoven and Mozart. The then Elder Professor of Music, John Bishop, was highly intrigued.

The Chair of Mathematical Physics in Adelaide was the first chair in theoretical physics in Australia, for, although the Professorial Board at the University of Melbourne in June 1949 had recommended, as a matter of urgency, that a chair of theoretical physics be created, it was not approved until December 1951. That chair was not filled until Associate Professor C.B.O. Mohr was appointed Professor in 1961. In Adelaide, the decision of the then Vice-Chancellor, A.P. Rowe, in consultation with Professor L.G.H. Huxley, Elder Professor of Physics, to create a chair in Mathematical Physics was based on the view that mathematics research in Adelaide had been languishing since the breakdown of Professor J.R. Wilton, and both of these men knew of the chair of mathematical physics in Birmingham held by the distinguished physicist R.E. Peierls. At that time the terms 'theoretical physics' and 'mathematical physics' were used more or less interchangeably. The name 'theoretical physics' was coined by Rudolf Clausius, while J.Willard Gibbs was appointed to a chair of 'mathematical physics' at Yale University in 1871. In recent years the names have begun to acquire slightly different connnotations, with mathematical physics tending to be associated with research having more emphasis on the mathematical structure of the theories, and theoretical physics with attempts to create new theories or to compare theory with experiment. Sadly, these distinctions, minute to an outsider, have begun to show signs of entrenchment, quasi-religious fervour and even vituperative comments. Certainly Bert Green never made distinctions in his choice of research fields, as will be seen from the account of his research work presented in this memoir.

School, university and the war

Bert Green was born on 17 December 1920 at Ipswich, England, the only child of Sydney and Violet Green. Sydney Green had been a mathematics teacher, but increasing deafness meant he had to give up that profession and turn to coach-building. After a period at West Winch, near King's Lynn, Norfolk, the family moved to Felixstowe in 1930. There Bert was a pupil at Langer Road Elementary School until 1932, and even at that early age his outstanding mathematical ability was evident. So it was no surprise when he was awarded a scholarship for Felixstowe County School, where he stayed until 1939. In that year he obtained scholarships to University Colleges at Hull and Nottingham, and passed his Higher School Certificate examination. His results in that examination were so good that he was awarded a Royal Scholarship at the Imperial College of Science and Technology, London. His teachers there included W.G. Penney, later well known for his leadership in the British nuclear bomb program, and Sydney Chapman, of Chapman and Cowling fame. He graduated with a BSc in mathematics with first class honours and a Diploma of Associateship of the Royal College of Science (ARCS) in 1941, a achievement which gave him great pleasure.

By then the war had started and in 1940 he took a summer job building coastal defences, and learnt to ride a bicycle. He also did firewatching on the roof of Imperial College, and filled in the many hours of inactivity by studying text books, with some consequent damage to his eyesight.

After graduation his first position was in the government Scientific Service, but he found the work so dull that he changed over to the Meteorological Office in the Air Ministry, and from there to the RAF in 1941 as a Meteorological Officer with the rank of Flying Officer. The rest of the war was spent on the Isle of Man in the Training Flying Control Centre, advising the RAF on flying hazards such as wing icing. This was clearly very responsible work, because many of the night operations over Europe, particularly in the northern latitudes, were very prone to extreme weather conditions, and the lives of many airmen depended on accurate forecasting. Bert's experience there remained with him throughout his career and gave him special insights into environmental questions and, more remotely, into problems in cosmic ray physics that were out of the normal run. For example, he pointed out that the statistics behind the Adelaide claims for the discovery of tachyons suffered from a defect due to truncating data. Such truncation was known to be a source of error in attempting long-range weather forecasting, because it could lead to spurious peaks. Tachyons are hypothetical particles that travel faster than light, and their discovery would greatly change our view of the universe. There was some evidence from cosmic ray showers being studied in Adelaide that some signals being received appeared to be tachyonic in character, and although the experimentalists could find no flaw in their acquisition of the data, the interpretation had to be reassessed. Bert suggested that a peak in the data, presumed to represent the arrival of tachyonic particles, was actually a truncation error. With this interpretation it was concluded that no evidence for tachyons had been found.

As would be expected by anyone who knew Bert, he was quite unlike the usual run of air force officers. He was not interested in social pastimes such as drinking in the Officer's Mess, finding pleasure more in solitary pursuits such as swimming off the not very attractive rock-strewn beaches.

As the war approached its end, he made plans for resuming his studies, and wrote to Sydney Chapman in March 1945 asking his advice on where he could go, and suggesting London, Cambridge or Edinburgh. For various reasons Chapman, in his reply, agreed that Edinburgh would be the best choice.

The exchange of letters which followed throws some interesting light on Bert's very considerable self-confidence, a trait which was very important for his decision to move to Australia. Enclosed in his letter to Chapman was a small calculation which Bert suggested might be suitable for publication. In his reply, Chapman enclosed a comment from George Temple, a very well-known theoretical physicist. Temple was quite negative in his assessment, saying that first of all the work had been done before, and secondly it was wrong! Instead of being crushed by such a reply, Bert wrote a two-page letter defending his work, and respectfully disagreeing with Temple's arguments. In response Temple acknowledged that he was wrong and Bert was right, and that the note should be published. Bert then wrote to Max Born at Edinburgh, asking whether he could work with him and enclosing this paper for possible publication (it never appeared). He left the RAF in September 1945, and started immediately in Edinburgh.

With Max Born in Edinburgh

Bert's time with Max Born was extraordinarily productive. He obtained his PhD in 1947, and DSc in 1949. Together they published six papers and a book summarising their work on a general kinetic theory of liquids. There were usually from six to eight research students working with Born over that period in rather primitive surroundings in the basement of the Old Infirmary in Drummond Street. Born's practice was to visit the research students' room every day, discussing each student's progress and offering constructive suggestions. He left talking to Bert till the last as their discussions were always very long and lively. In fact Born was once heard to say 'I can't stand Green – he is always right'. They would go to conferences together, and during talks Born would often interrupt and then say 'Green', and Bert would go out to the blackboard and expound the points being made. In a letter to Einstein,1 Born wrote: 'My collaborator Green is hard at work on elementary particles; he is a brilliant man, the best I have had since Pryce'.

Bert submitted his work on kinetic theory for his PhD thesis, and it was considered to be so outstanding that Born proposed that it should be awarded a DSc. However this suggestion was regarded as too radical by some of the conservative members of the examining board, and Bert had to be content with a PhD. However his DSc was not long coming because he submitted another thesis soon afterwards and received his DSc two years later.

Bert was no athlete in the usual sense, lacking the required co-ordination, but he was always very fit. On a working holiday in Europe he cycled over the Swiss Alps. Right up till his last illness he was a great walker, and walking companions often complained of the tremendous pace he used to set. He could be rather idiosyncratic, though, and could pose problems for those with him. Two of my correspondents, Professor L.G. Bowden and Professor A.G. McLellan, tell of a memorable walk in the Lake District when Bert insisted on wearing wellingtons instead of the conventional boots, even though they could at times be dangerous. He also attempted to carry back to Edinburgh a ram's skull as big as a bucket, in the belief that it would have anthropological interest, but was persuaded, much against his wishes, to leave it behind. At the memorial service held in Adelaide after his death, Harry Messel told of another excursion up Snowdon in poor weather, when Bert nearly slid to his death because of the unsuitability of his wellingtons for the terrain. After taking a couple of photographs, Harry pulled him to safety.

The Borns were very hospitable and made their students, who came from all over the world, very much at home. At that time they had with them an attractive au-pair girl from Holland, Marlies Friedheim, and she and Bert soon became very good friends. That friendship culminated in marriage in Dublin in 1951.

Institute of Advanced Study, Princeton

Bert spent one year, 1949-50, at the Institute of Advanced Study in Princeton, working on problems generated whilst in Edinburgh. His published papers from that time refer to models of quantum mechanics and quantum field theory initiated with Born. From reports, he did not like Princeton much; the only reference I heard him make to it was that he often used to walk in with Gödel and talk to him about mathematical logic. A possible relic of these encounters could be an interesting unpublished manuscript of Bert's on the foundations of mathematical logic. His decision to go to Adelaide rather than accept one of several offers he had received of appointments in the United States reflected his preference to be free to follow his own paths rather than those dictated by passing waves of fashion.

One lasting friendship he made there was with Roy Leipnik, who found his quiet manner and self-suffiency in strong contrast to the other members of the Institute. Roy Leipnik came to Adelaide in 1954 on a Fulbright scholarship, and there they started a collaboration on plasma physics that led to the writing and publication of their book Sources of Plasma Physics, and regular visits by Bert to the United States to work for the United States Navy on plasma physics problems associated with rocket research.

Institute of Advanced Study, Dublin 1950-51

After Princeton Bert went to the Institute of Advanced Study in Dublin and found the atmosphere there much more congenial. He particularly liked the way in which Schrödinger looked at physics, although he was not so impressed by the extent of religious bigotry that was still evident there. It was in Dublin that he met Harry Messel, beginning a life-long friendship and a frenetic period of research productivity into cosmic ray showers which continued on into Adelaide.

He also renewed his friendship with L.G. ('Dook') Bowden, whom he had met in the RAF on the Isle of Man, and, as already mentioned, he married Marlies in 1951 with Harry and Dook as attendants.

When the University of Adelaide advertised for a professor, a reader and a lecturer in mathematical physics, Bert applied from Dublin for the chair and was appointed. This was a great boost for Adelaide's mathematical research, for at a time when employment in the sciences was starting to rise following the wartime achievements of physicists, it would be expected that it would not be easy to attract an outstanding candidate to Australia. Bert Green was just the sort of person who could make such a 'courageous' decision work. He already had a proven research record over a wide range of mathematical physics and, as already mentioned, he was not attracted to the hot-house American research atmosphere. He also preferred to live away from large cities, while his strongly socialist leanings would find even the conservatism of postwar Australia more congenial than the rabid anti-communism leading into McCarthyism of the United States.

Adelaide 1951-99

It was no problem to find someone to fill one of the other positions in mathematical physics. Harry Messel had already started to collaborate with Bert in cosmic ray showers, and so he stepped immediately into the position of senior lecturer. He and Ren Potts, who was going to a lectureship in mathematics, travelled together to Australia by ship, arriving in September 1951, Bert having arrived in August. Bert and Harry were an oddly assorted couple, Bert being reserved and not very interested in socialising while Harry was extremely extroverted and tended to dominate any social gathering. But they got on famously, with their abilities complementing each other's very well. Their common interest was an intense absorption in their research, and one might say that Adelaide did not know what had hit it when they arrived. Harry Messel only stayed nine months before leaving to take up the long-vacant chair of physics in Sydney, but in that time they produced thirteen papers on cosmic rays, not to mention other papers that Bert wrote on other parts of mathematical physics.

During the North Sea Floods in 1953, the Greens' family home in Felixstowe was in danger of being flooded. Sydney Green moved the furniture upstairs to save it from damage, but sadly the effort was too much and he died soon afterwards from a heart attack brought on by his exertions. Bert and his family went to England by ship to look after the family's affairs and spent six months there. Whilst there, Bert made arrangements for his mother to come to Adelaide, which she eventually did.

During Bert's absence Otto Bergmann was acting chairman of the department, with the main responsibility of looking after Ian McCarthy, who had embarked on a PhD with Bert. This was a bold decision of Ian's because the PhD degree was still very new to Australia, there had been no regular teaching programme established in the department, and Adelaide was alone in doing research in mathematical physics. It was also not easy for Ian, as a beginning student, to be in close contact with such a formidable intellect as Bert's. Ian found that Bert was a kind and understanding supervisor, although the presumption that Ian could follow all of Bert's ideas was at times a bit too much, particularly as even the greatest of scientists have their off moments. Out of it came a very interesting thesis on the then new ideas of parastatistics, with Ian working out some of the detailed consequences of the assumption that particles could behave differently from the standard bosonic and fermionic types.

After Harry Messel left, his position was advertised, and it is interesting to see the quality of people who made enquiries about the position. Amongst them were S.F. Edwards, later Sir Sam Edwards, Chief Scientific Advisor to the British Government, and W. Israel and W. Güttinger, both of whom were to become well-known mathematical physicists. J. (John) C. Ward, widely considered as unlucky not to have been awarded a Nobel prize for his later work with Salam, was appointed in October 1953.

Bert's academic life in Adelaide can be divided into four sections, the first being from 1951 until 1959 when he ran what was essentially a research institute with first Harry Messel and then Otto Bergmann and John Ward. It is interesting to read two very contrasting opinions about this period in letters to Bert. They reflect clearly the personalities of the writers.

The first, from Harry Messel, written when he was touring the United States recruiting people for his new institute in Sydney, said: 'Everyone agrees that we have cracked cosmic ray theory and are most pleased with our work. Some of the big experiments now being planned over here (especially by Rossi) depend completely on our work.' The second, from John Ward, written just as he was preparing to leave Adelaide and while Bert was still overseas, paints a very different picture: 'There is no doubt that the state of affairs in theoretical physics is extremely bad (not in Adelaide, I mean everywhere)...One cannot therefore, with a good conscience, recruit students, especially in a place like Adelaide, where the possibilities of jobs are remote, and where the instruction is likely to be poor, and chances of decent research very slight.'

Both of these people only stayed nine months, and the University came to believe that the position was a short-term contract post rather than tenured. This led to a problem for me when I arrived in Adelaide, because the University Council decided that the post did not warrant long-term support such as housing loans and superannuation. The Registrar put the question as to whether it was my intention to stay longer than a year. I actually stayed until my retirement thirty-one years later!

In 1959 a formal Honours course in Mathematical Physics was started (there had been some sporadic teaching before that) with always at least three students each year, and in 1960 third-year courses were introduced. With my arrival in 1957, and Ian McCarthy's in 1961, the department started to be a regular university department with the regular administrative tasks that went with it. Bert was Head of the Department until 1964, and then, following my promotion to a personal chair, the duties of Head alternated until 1973, when departmental government, requiring election of the departmental chairman, was instituted in the University. From 1973 until his retirement in 1985, with departmental government in full swing, Bert shifted much more into the background, although continuing to be very active teaching, doing research and assuming various administrative duties such as Faculty Dean and President of the Australian Mathematical Society.

The final period, from 1985 until his death in 1999, saw no diminution in his research, and continuing activity in teaching and research supervision.

Scientific Work

The main body of Bert's scientific work will be dealt with under the following headings:

  1. Kinetic theory and plasma physics,
  2. Statistical mechanics,
  3. Quantum field theory and particle physics,
  4. Cosmic rays,
  5. Quantum mechanics,
  6. General relativity and gravitation,
  7. Mathematical methods,
  8. Environmental physics,
  9. Biophysics and neurophysiological models.

In addition, Bert published a number of far from trivial papers in nuclear physics [43], [61], [68], [69]; in biophysics with Casley-Smith, Vaccaro and Bass [88], [96], [110], [132], [133], [134]; and in electromagnetic propagation with Wolf [34], [38]. These, however, will not be discussed here.

(a) Kinetic theory and plasma physics

The theory of dilute gases, for which the molecules could be regarded as moving more or less independently of each other, was developed from slightly different standpoints by Maxwell in 1866 and Boltzmann in 1872, and remained the only dynamical theory of complex systems until after the Second World War when, independently, five people developed what came to be known as the BBGKY system of equations for the dynamical behaviour of fluids, with the important extension to dense liquids. These people were Bogoliubov (2) in Moscow, Born and Green [1]-[8] in Edinburgh, Kirkwood (3) at Cornell and Yvon (4) in Paris. Of these, Bert Green was exceptional for whereas the other four were distinguished physicists, he was a beginning research student. Moreover he was not just working under guidance from his supervisor, for Born took the unusual step of adding a footnote to paper [4] on the quantum mechanics of fluids in which he said 'I have signed this paper, as it is a part of the programme with which we started this series. My contribution consists of some general suggestions...The work itself is due to Mr Green.' There were six papers under the general title, 'A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids'. In the first paper their version of the BBGKY equations for classical systems was given, and in the second and third papers the equilibrium and dynamical properties of these equations were discussed (Bert was sole author of the second). The fifth paper gave a kinetic basis for thermodynamics and the last, again with Bert the sole author, was on the difficult question of how to explain the anomalous behaviour of liquid helium II. These papers, the publication of which spread over the years 1946-48, clearly tackled questions of fundamental importance, and the following year Cambridge University Press published them all as a single collection, A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids.

It is interesting to see that, apart from Yvon's, all the initial papers of BBGKY were published in 1946. However, neither Yvon's nor Bogoliubov's work was known to the others until later. Bert tells of going to a conference in France, and after giving his talk being approached by a small older Frenchman who told him of similar work he had done. It was Yvon.

Because these first papers of Born and Green set the pattern for the later work of Bert and his collaborators and students, they will be looked at in some detail. The essential difficulty was to find a way to take into account the much stronger mutual influences that molecules in dense fluids can exert on each other.

The starting point for these equations was Liouville's equation:

∂r/∂r/ t + {r, H} = 0.∂

It states simply that probability is conserved during the motion both in classical and quantum theory, and so is an exact but not very useful statement when there is a very large number of particles involved. In classical theory r is the probability of there being N particles present with given co-ordinates and momenta, written f(q1 ,…,qN ; p1 ,…,pN ; t), whilst in quantum theory it denotes the density matrix.

More useful are the partial probabilities associated with considering only some of the particles at a time, irrespective of what the remainder are doing, and these are written, for the classical case, as f(q1 ,…,qn ; p1 ,…,pn ; t) with n < N. The extreme case is to consider only one particle at a time, and that is as far as the well-known equation, due to Boltzmann, went. It was the object of BBGKY to construct equations in which more than one particle at a time is considered, and to do that Liouville’s equation can be replaced by an equivalent system of equations describing the behaviour of the partial probabilities. As a simplifying step that accords well with physics, it is always assumed that the particles interact in pairs – by pair potentials. With this assumption, the equation for the n-particle probability involves the (n + 1)-probability, but no more. These are the BBGKY equations and are still exact and still not very useful.

The important step is to find out how to proceed from here. The different authors proceeded in slightly different ways. Bogoliubov expanded r in powers of the density, and treated this parameter as a perturbation. Kirkwood used time averaging as a representation of the time spread involved in making a measurement. Born and Green, and also Yvon in a more rudimentary form, used what they called, following Kirkwood, the 'superposition approximation'. This supposed that the higher particle number densities depended explicitly on the lower ones. The simplest choice is to write f2(z1,z2) = f1(z1)f1(z2) where z denotes the pair q,p, and this leads back to the Boltzmann equation. Born and Green went further, assuming only f3(z1,z2,z3) = f2(z2,z3)f2(z3,z1)f2(z1,z2)/f1(z1)f1(z2)f1(z3). All of these approximations have their defects, and have been criticised for their rather ad hoc nature. It is sometimes said that this step signals the appearance of irreversibility, because the complete Liouville equation shows no preference for either direction of time, whereas the Boltzmann equation leads to the very fundamental H-theorem – the statement that entropy increases with time. (Boltzmann's suicide is supposed to have been partially caused by the very strong criticism he received following his proof of the H-theorem and his assertion that it was the source of irreversibility.) In the second paper [2] Bert proved, amongst other things, that the H-theorem followed from the superposition approximation. In a his book Molecular Theory of Fluids, he pointed out that, for irreversibility in gas theory, it was necessary to assume binary collisions together with an assumption about 'final encounters'. This was already well-known and not really fundamental enough, so he returned to it in [45], presenting a slightly different definition of H, for which the H-theorem followed more easily.

In [2] and [3], a very important observation was made concerning the difference between gases and liquids, or, in other words, the phenomenon of condensation. Bert observed that as the density of the fluid increased, a mathematical singularity appeared in the equations, and this was interpreted as heralding the onset of condensation. It is this property which still gives the BBGKY equations their significance, for alternative approaches fail in this regard. In [3], the Chapman-Enskog derivation of the equations of hydrodynamics and the coefficients of viscosity from the kinetic theory was presented from a more fundamental basis.

So well constructed were the first three papers on the classical theory of fluids that the transition to quantum theory went through with little fuss. It was possible to construct a quantum version of the equations of hydrodynamics, as well as expressions for the coefficients of viscosity and thermal conduction. The latter have special significance in the behaviour of liquid helium, which is the distinctive quantum fluid, whose paradoxical behaviour results from the special nature of these coefficients. In [5], [7] and [9], Bert showed that quantum mechanical corrections could substantially account for these strange properties. That work had surprisingly little impact, however, and is barely cited. Here Born's comment to Einstein (1) indicates that it missed out in comparison with Landau:

But the use of (sic) helium, which has a liquid phase that behaves curiously, was not as successful as we had hoped. The theory accepted today originated with the Russian Nobel prizewinner of 1962 L.D. Landau.

However it is quite clear that Bert's telling use of density matrix methods set a pattern that was widely followed in all later work.

Although the BBGKY equations went beyond the Boltzmann equation, there was nevertheless still much of interest to be obtained from the latter, particularly when charged fluids were considered. In 1957 Bert was amused to receive a manuscript by J.R. Cotter, who had devoted a large part of his life to trying to solve the Boltzmann equation when the molecules are rigid spheres, something Bert could see could be done much more simply. However he did not publish his solution, leaving it for ten years until a student, P.I. Brooker, took it over as a PhD project culminating in a number of papers, the first of which was [77]. Several times Bert returned to the question of how the Maxwell-Boltzmann equation could best be obtained from the BBGKY equations, both in the classical [71], [79] and quantum form. In the latter case he went beyond the usual rather crude process of simply inserting the quantum-mechanical cross section in the collision integral, and gave a purely quantum-mechanical derivation [32]. As a consequence he found corrections to the standard treatment by Chapman and Cowling.

In 1957, Roy Leipnik, then at the Michelson Laboratory of the US Navy at China Lake, was working on rocket-ground commmunication involving warm plasmas around rockets, and he quickly saw that Bert would be a valuable collaborator. It was natural that someone with Bert's outstanding expertise in the kinetic theory of neutral fluids should be able to consider the case where the fluid can consist of several charged species – a plasma. Bert first visited China Lake in 1958 and made regular visits until 1968. He very rapidly produced a series of papers that extended the theory from neutral to charged fluids: [54] dealt with small disturbances, such as plasma oscillations, in the neighbourhood of equilibrium, [55] constructed the hydrodynamic equations from the micrscopic theory and [59] the thermodynamics. With a student, T. M.L. Wigley, Bert constructed the Boltzmann equation for a charged fluid, with the Coulomb potential replaced by the much more realistic screened Debye potential. This and other work culminated in the book with Roy Leipnik, Sources of Plasma Physics, which brought order to a previously generally scrappily treated subject.

Apart from papers that might be regarded as written in response to practical questions, Bert retained his interest in deeper questions; this is very evident in [66], in which he derives a thermodynamics of complicated systems from general principles. Particular emphasis is placed on describing irreversible processes away from thermodynamical equilibrium but based on the idea that in sufficiently small regions there is equilibrium. Here he is in illustrious company such as Onsager, de Groot, Caratheodory and Born. Again and again we shall see how Bert, even from the remoteness of Adelaide, was prepared to tackle the deepest and most difficult problems of physics. Perhaps people in the bigger centres regarded this as presumptuous.

His early work on kinetic theory, prior to 1960, was presented in book form in several places. The first was the Cambridge collection already referred to, the second was The Molecular Theory of Fluids, originally published by North-Holland in 1952 and then later by Dover in 1969. This book has been very widely cited and is still regarded as the standard account of the kinetic theory of neutral fluids. In 1960 he contributed a chapter, 'The Structure of Liquids', to the prestigious Handbuch der Physik. There were also extensive articles in the Encyclopaedic Dictionary of Physics [63] and Research Frontiers in Fluid Dynamics [72].

(b) Statistical mechanics

Although the time-independent solutions of the BBGKY equations were shown by Bert and others to be, via the H-theorem, the well-known Maxwell-Gibbs expressions of statistical mechanics, the latter are much more general in their application. One very important case is the Ising model, which was solved, for the two-dimensional case by Onsager in 1944 in what was, and is still regarded as a tour-de-force of mathematical physics. This is a simple model of a magnetic material consisting of a rectangular array of elementary magnets that can point only up or down, and that can exert simple magnetic attractions on nearest neighbours. The value of this solution is that it gives an exact description of an interacting many-particle system and exhibits a phase transition at a particular temperature, the critical temperature. At this temperature the system changes from one in which the elementary magnets point predominantly up, or predominantly down, to one in which neither direction is favoured. So it describes a change in the material from a state of being magnetized to one in which it is not. As such, it provides deep insights into such important physical phenomena as melting, evaporation, magnetization and quark-gluon plasmas.

Because of the difficulty of Onsager's solution – which was not helped by the well-known obscurity of his writings – there was a need for a simpler treatment. The first people to provide this were Mark Kac and John Ward (5), using a clever combinatorial method based on the properties of determinants. Whilst trying to understand their paper, I constructed a graphical picture that seemed to describe their construction. However when this was shown to Bert, he first pronounced it a very interesting idea, and then later showed that it would not work in all cases. What followed is an illustration of what working with Bert could be like. Despite several urgings from him that this idea should be written up, I did nothing about it, and eventually Bert produced, without any preliminary discussion, a complete manuscript describing a new solution to the Ising problem. To do this he used the mathematical formalism of Pfaffians, which had been introduced by E.R. Caianiello (6) to describe fermions in quantum field theory and had already been used by me, and then the previous difficulty disappeared. The paper [58] made an immediate impact, leading quickly to the first solution of the complete dimer problem by H.N.V. Temperley and M.E. Fisher and P.W. Kasteleyn (7). (Bert independently also solved this problem, but the publication of his solution was delayed until the appearance in 1964 of the book, Order-Disorder Phenomena.)

This solution, eventually called the free fermion field, simplified the solution of the two-dimensional Ising model so much that it could easily be given in an undergraduate course. Ilya Prigogine asked Bert to prepare a review article, and this he started to do in collaboration with me, at a time when I was on sabbatical leave in Edinburgh. In the course of preparing this article, which soon turned into the book already mentioned, all the Ising models that had been solved up till that time were found to be particular cases of the free fermion model. No further essential progress was made in this field until 1967 when Elliott Lieb (8) solved the six-vertex model, leading on to Rodney Baxter's solution (9) of the eight-vertex model and the enormously significant Yang-Baxter relations.

Despite all these new results and the continued reference made to this book in the literature, there is a sense in which this work did not receive the recognition it perhaps should have. The primary reason for this was that a book is not the best medium for publishing new results. By the time the book appeared, many of the results had appeared elsewhere and priority was lost. Also it appeared that the cursory treatment given to approximate methods – included only as an afterthought in response to a request from Prigogine – did not go down well with those who had invested considerable effort in this important part of the understanding of the properties of cooperative systems. As approximate methods were outside the intended scope of the book, it would have been much more politic to have left them out completely.

(c) Quantum field theory and particle physics

In 1939 Born (10) suggested what he called the principle of reciprocity, which proposed that natural laws are symmetric under the interchange of position and momentum co-ordinates. He based this on the fact that the canonical commutation relations of quantum mechanics and the components of angular momentum display this symmetry. This idea was severely criticised by Peierls, who cited in particular that the principle does not apply to translations, as is very evident from the difference between the two in the actual world. Nevertheless Born remained attracted to this idea, which has still some relevance at the present day in the occurrence of 'duality' in string theory – although it is now quite unlike anything Born and his collaborators contemplated. The main idea as expounded in [8], [10]-[13], [18] and [75] was to use this symmetry to constrain the structure of relativistic wave equations, and consequently the possible values of the masses of the mesons known at the time. It was also hoped that this principle would ameliorate, if not remove, the divergences that still plague elementary particle theory. It is clear from Born's letters to Einstein (1) that he was very optimistic about the value of this program:

Now the divergences in quantum mechanics seem to indicate that an absolute length does exist in the world. I presume that this will have to be included in the general transformation group. We have gone to a great deal of trouble over this. My pupil Green, a highly gifted man (whom I am going to send to you in Princeton next year) may possibly make some progress with it; he has good ideas and great mathematical skill.

It is equally clear from Einstein's replies that he had little interest in what he regarded as the very deficient machinery of quantum mechanics.

Like most physicists who worked on particle physics in the 1950s, Bert had a great interest in trying to formulate the equations so as to be free from unacceptable infinities. At that time the work of Dyson, Feynman and Schwinger had shown that these equations could be expressed as a set of integro-differential equations, the Dyson-Schwinger equations, and if these equations could be made to behave, then one had a fundamental theory. Bert wrote several papers, [33], [39], [106] and [125], in which the divergent quantities could be removed, leaving behind some very complicated but putatively finite equations. In the process of doing this, he derived a generalization of the Ward identities, which are some of the most important constraints on the fundamental equations. However his priority in this has been only occasionally recognised, and they are usually called the Ward-Takahashi or simply the Ward identities. This failure to recognise him was a source of the very rare occasions when Bert showed what could almost be described as anger.

In 1953, Bert wrote a short paper [31] which, more than any other of his writings, has made his name widely known. In this paper he described what is known as parastatistics, which is a symmetry extending the well-known Bose and Fermi statistics. Bose statistics apply in particular to photons and are central to the operation of the laser, while Fermi statistics provide the mathematical foundation for Pauli's exclusion principle and hence the structure of the periodic table of elements. Parastatistics can be regarded as interpolating between these two, and for some time it looked as if they were the appropriate language for describing quarks. Even though they missed out on that score, they are still the subject of immense research at the present time, being re-expressed in terms of more and more exotic mathematical schemes. This theory has gradually assumed importance, more as an elegant framework on which to build other algebraic structures. Even since 1989, there have been well over several hundred citations of this single paper. The 'Green Ansatz' which appeared there for the first time is a standard tool in describing what are also called 'Generalised Statistics'. The 'para-Bose' algebra, in particular, can be seen today as an example of a 'Lie superalgebra', although superalgebras were not introduced formally into physics by others until much later (12). For the people, including Bert, who were working in Adelaide in the late '60s, trying to put internal and space-time symmetries together in a non-trivial way, the failure to spot the potential of superalgebras in this connection, rather than Lie algebras, surely represents what Dyson would have called a 'missed opportunity'. As is so often one of the ironies of life, this paper was written whilst Bert was in the midst of what he regarded as much more important work with Harry Messel on cosmic rays, and it was regarded by him as an amusing sideline. The work on cosmic rays is now part of history.

Bert, in association with A.J. Bracken and later P.D. Jarvis, continued to investigate paraparticles and their generalisations as models for the known collection of particles. In the paper [89], they constructed a generalised parastatistics in which the quarks did not have definite isospin or hypercharge. The advantage of this model was that the quark could be regarded as a simple parafermion, so that an additional colour label is not required. However it was a parastatistic model of order 3, and no consistent way of quantising this could be found that would respect the correspondence principle. This led Bert to a further generalisation called modular statistics, [94], [100] and [119], for which a consistent quantisation could be defined. This appeared to be a more economical model of quarks, without the multiplicity of colours. However as quarks are not observed there needs to be some explanation for this, and Bert made the bizarre suggestion that they are tachyons – particles that can travel faster than light, and that are certainly not observed. More conventionally, in association with Peter Jarvis, he constructed a model whereby all the standard particles, including quarks, were composites of modular particles, with quarks being more complex composites than electrons.

The problem of how to describe bound states in quantum field theory was advanced by the appearance of the Bethe-Salpeter equation and the related Wick equation (11), which however did not conform to the standard form of bound-state equations coming from the Schrödinger equation. Bert and S.N. Biswas obtained solutions [44], [46], [76] and [87] without making the usual instantaneous interaction approximation, and Bert showed in [48] that the Wick equation separated nicely in bipolar coordinates, with the consequent appearance of a separation constant called a relativistic quantum number, which might be interpreted as labelling the so-called 'strange' particles L and q. Later on, Biswas and collaborators showed (13) that this separability was due to the symmetry of the Wick equation under the group O(5).

Bert always had a fondness for using the non-compact de Sitter group SO(4,1) in cosmology and in particle physics. In the latter case it appears as the group generated by the G-matrices of the Bhabha equation, and it is this equation (with a modified mass term) that Bert employed to construct equations describing particles of higher spin [102], and in particular charged particles. This is not straightforward because the usual versions of such particles suffer from defects of non-causality and an indefinite metric. However, Bert was able to construct an electrodynamics of charged particles with higher spin [106] that was free from causality defects.

(d) Cosmic rays

The Green-Messel papers were written and published in the early 1950s when not much was known about the interactions of pions with nuclei, although by then the distinction between pions and muons had been demonstrated by C.F. Powell and co-workers. Strange Particles and Associated Production were under discussion, but the particle physics side of cosmic ray studies was still to settle down to the eight-fold way and the eventual quark model.

The theoretical issues of the day were concerned with the development of the cosmic ray cascade in matter in general and the atmosphere in particular. The electromagnetic cascade itself (via bremsstrahlung and pair production) was understood, but the nuclear cascade was still only vaguely understood, as was the way it affected the development of cascades in the atmosphere.

For example, the discovery of the p0 and its decay immediately gave a means to feed energy from the nuclear interactions into the electromagnetic cascade. It was not, however, clear how the primary nuclei distributed energy into the secondary nuclear cascade. A common question was whether the pions were produced by 'multiple' or 'plural' production. Angular distributions gave some clues.

Bert and Harry addressed these issues with an essentially analytical approach in [35] and [36]. Later on, cascade calculations used Monte Carlo methods with heavy computer back-up, such as Harry developed with the new Silliac computer. As a result, these papers, although a tour-de-force of mathematical analysis, have been superseded by less elegant methods and much more powerful computing resources. Unfortunately it therefore seems that this work was a decade or so too early, and most of this intense effort was wasted.

(e) Quantum mechanics

Running through most of Bert's work, and particularly in quantum mechanics, was a preference for using algebraic as opposed to analytic methods. Probably his undergraduate background did not develop a feeling for mathematical rigour, and algebraic methods usually gave a better understanding of what the mathematics meant. His book, Matrix Mechanics, which arose out of his third-year lectures but also reflected many of his research techniques, was translated into German, Russian and Japanese as well as appearing in two English printings. This book continues to provide a useful and remarkably compact introduction to quantum mechanics for the beginning student. In it, Bert solved a wide variety of problems in quantum mechanics by purely algebraic methods. Even the fine structure of the energy levels of the hydrogen atom was obtained by such methods, perhaps for the first time. However it is typical of Bert's approach to problem-solving generally that the solutions presented in the book are often not completely rigorous. On a close examination, many subtle difficulties reveal themselves, usually relating to the precise definitions of the algebraic objects being manipulated. But it is also typical that by examining these subtleties and attempting to find out how and why Bert's methods work, one can obtain new insights into the underlying physics as well as the mathematics of the problem at hand.

In 1958 Bert published one of his best papers [53]. It was entitled 'Observation in Quantum Mechanics' and addressed one of the outstanding problems of modern physics, namely the process by which indeterminate superpositions in quantum mechanics become converted to the determinate, although possibly unknown, alternatives of ordinary macroscopic physics. For many years the prescription of von Neumann, usually called the 'collapse of the wave packet', was the accepted view of how this happened. As it assumed that some processes outside quantum mechanics had to be invoked, even going so far as involving the brain of the human observer, people were not comfortable with it, although it seemed the only possible answer. The best known representation of this difficulty appears in the well-known Schrödinger's cat paradox. Bert, together with a number of others such as Wakita and Ludwig, found a much more satisfying explanation, which is basically still the received description, although nowadays in various forms. The idea was to suppose that a measuring apparatus could be of almost any form so long as it was very complicated, that is, contained a very large number (often for mathematical convenience taken to be infinite) of components such as molecules or electrons. The system being measured could be microscopic. When the two systems interact, any 'interference terms' in the state of the microscopic system become vanishingly small purely as a consequence of the size of the measuring instrument. There are, of course, many processes in nature in which a human observer is not involved – especially before homo sapiens evolved – and the von Neumann description is quite unable to say how these could happen. However with Bert's theory all one has to do is to replace the measuring apparatus by the environment to bring about the necessary disappearance of interferences. The only place where this very satisfactory explanation might run into some difficulty is in the early evolution of the universe, where there is no environment!

From his work with Born, Bert became convinced that quantum mechanics could only properly be discussed when states are described by density matrices rather than wave functions. (Perhaps even that can be a bit restrictive, as for example when dealing with supplementary conditions.) The paper just described emphasised the fact that the state of the measuring apparatus could not be known exactly, and a density matrix must be used. On a more general level, he presented an abstract formulation of quantum mechanics in terms of semi-groups [113] – he also considered semigroups in [108] – with states being given by density matrices. In the spirit of the comments made above, there is no attempt here to discuss the topological requirements of this theory, so it is not clear what sort of algebra of quantum variables is actually being defined.

(f) General relativity and gravitation

Although Bert wrote only three papers that could be clearly classified under this heading, they are so interesting that they deserve a separate classification. Bert had strong views about gravitation and cosmology, insisting right up to his last book that physicists were in error in not confining themselves to the de Sitter universe and de Sitter group.

In the first paper [51], he tackled the problem that occupied Einstein in the latter years of his life, namely to construct a unified theory of gravitation and electromagnetism. His approach was the opposite of that usually followed. Instead of setting up a gravitation theory and then incorporating the Dirac equation, he started with the Dirac matrices, spinors and Lagrangian, and from them constructed the metric tensor and the total Lagrangian including gravitation. The latter step is commonplace now under the heading of local gauge invariance, but it was quite unfamiliar at the time. But not only did this gauge-invariant Lagrangian include gravitation, it also contained the electromagnetic field! In a follow-up paper [52], Bert showed that this theory admits teleparallelism, meaning that vectors can be parallel transferred around the space, even though it is not flat. It also describes mesonic fields in addition to gravitation and electromagnetism. Bert never seemed to have followed up this paper, although several thesis projects came out of it.

(g) Mathematical methods

All the people who worked with Bert speak of his very strong mathematical ability, and there are at least fifteen of his papers that can be classified as mathematics rather than physics. But Bert was in no sense a mathematician, and would not have wished to be regarded as such. As Freeman Dyson in his talk to the Australian Academy of Science at its jubilee meeting in 1979 would describe it, Bert was engaged in what G.H. Hardy called 'schoolboy mathematics'. This is not as pejorative as it sounds, because he was in the company of almost all theoretical physicists. As already remarked in subsection (e), he was not concerned with nice points of mathematical rigour but rather with obtaining results. So long as the problems were essentially finite-dimensional or involved analytic functions, there was little to worry about, and his most elegant work was in this field. Also his collaborators Tony Bracken, Peter Jarvis and Denis O'Brien, having been educated under a more modern syllabus, were able to sound warning bells if necessary.

The schoolboy mathematics that Dyson referred to was mainly centred around the problem of how to classify the very large number of 'elementary' particles that appeared in the 1950s and later. The appropriate mathematical tools for this were finite-dimensional Lie algebras and their representations, and their study required expert and often ingenious algebraic manipulations – right in Bert's field. In collaboration with Tony Bracken, he developed what they called characteristic identities that are analogous to the more elementary Cayley-Hamilton theorems of matrix algebra [83], [84] and [95]. These identities are a very powerful tool for constructing representations of Lie algebras, and have applications to parastatistics [85]. They can be generalised to Lie superalgebras, [109] and [120], which had been found essential for the non-trivial combination of internal and space-time symmetries and particle physics.

(h) Environmental physics

On one of his regular visits to the United States, Bert became involved in studies in environmental physics, and his paper [90] discussed the spreading of pollutants. His extensive experience in kinetic theory and fluid dynamics was important in constructing the correct equations describing this process. The classical diffusion equation needed to be supplemented by the stochastic theory of Brownian motion. This work led to a dramatic confrontation with the South Australian government in 1984, following a decision by that government to construct a large petrochemical complex at Redcliff at the northern end of Spencer Gulf. The principal product of this enterprise would be dichlorethane, a rather nasty substance, and there was a risk that in loading this on to ships there could be spills into the gulf.

At the time Bert was a member of the Board of Environmental Studies at the University, which oversaw the work of the Department of Environmental Studies, under the direction of Dr J.R. Hails. This was a postgraduate department, and students were expected to undertake research in some environmental project. Bert suggested that a study could be made of the Redcliff project because he had been told about its possible hazards by Professor Rainer Radok, Head of the Horace Lamb Institute at Flinders University. Because of his previous work in this area, Bert eventually took over the study and wrote a submission to the Redcliff Environmental Inquiry in which he pointed out that the dangers were so real that the project should be discontinued. This caused such a stir that he appeared on the ABC television program, 'The 7.30 Report'. This report concluded with Bert sitting in a small and unsteady dinghy in the middle of Spencer Gulf with the ABC reporter Pru Goward, and saying in response to her asking what would happen if a spill occurred that 'Whyalla and Port Augusta would have to be evacuated'. He left for the United States shortly after appearing on this program, and the South Australian government felt obliged to reply. The relevant Minister, Roger Goldsworthy, cast doubt on Bert's report and interviewed comments, saying that they were nonsense. I regarded this as professional libel and contacted the ABC. I spoke to a very nervous Pru Goward, who was well aware of the ABC's vulnerability. I then wrote a letter to the Minister, taking strong exception to the tone of his remarks, and eventually received a three-page reply defending the Government's position and which was almost entirely beside the point. The letter was clearly written by a scientist but not an environmental physicist, and it later emerged that it had been written by a pair of chemists from Michigan, USA, who had been contracted by the South Australian Government. The final irony was that the chemists contacted Bert in the United States, asking his advice on the problem! The conclusion of the whole matter was that the petrochemical project at Redcliff was abandoned, and nothing further has been heard of it. This incident is a very good example of how independent academics can provide advice that is free from contractual pressures. It is to be regretted that now such independence is rapidly disappearing. This will be a cost to the community.

(i) Biological and neurophysiological models

Professor Terry Triffet met Bert at a Quantum Chemistry and Biology Workshop at Sanibel Island, Florida, in 1963 and began a friendship and collaboration that lasted until Bert's death. Among many common interests, the most fruitful was their belief in the influence quantum effects had on mental processes. Initially they concentrated on developing the mathematical, physical and chemical tools that they knew would be required [81], [97]-[99]. Here they looked at a model of a 'small interconnected group of neurons' from the point of view of the electrochemical dynamics, using Hamiltonian and matrix-operator notation. As this was unfamiliar to the neuroscience community, it was initially regarded with considerable suspicion. With the development of computing capacity, they were able to provide a sound basis for neural modelling by applying the laws and methods of theoretical and mathematical physics. The 'small interconnected group of neurons' was modified to represent 'unit circuits' known to constitute primary functional units throughout the brain, and these were interconnected to form an extensive network capable of simple image recognition and certain other simple basic brain processes.

As their methodology allowed them to extend the model into the quantum realm, they could bring digitalised information to bear on their linearised macroscopic model, leading to the concept of 'computing the uncomputable'. This led to the treatment of computational brain processes as a 'quantal Turing machine' and finally to a general theory of how the mind operates by gaining and creating information. This was all summarised in their book Sources of Consciousness, published in 1997. While far from a complete model of the mind's operation, the theory remains unique in its mathematically structured incorporation of physical laws and biochemical facts to describe interactions within the brain, extending from the quantally dependent interactions of metastable ions in the membrane channels of neurons, to the interactions of currents flowing in networks of these neurons with the electromagnetic fields they generate.

For some time Bert and Terry were convinced that the processes by which nerve signals were propagated could be explained by a Hamiltonian model of nonlinear oscillators, rather than by the opening and closing of membrane ion channels as proposed by Hodgkin and Huxley. However this part of their theory had to be recast when it became clear from experimental evidence that ion channels did exist and could open and close by way of conformational changes in proteins embedded in the membrane

There is an unpublished paper, 'Formation and Impairment of Sequential Memory: A Contribution from a Case of Transient Global Amnesia', that was written in response to a transient ischemic attack which Bert suffered in 1990 whilst attending a lecture at the University of Arizona. For a period of nine hours he suffered what is commonly called a 'black-out', and when he awoke the next morning, he had no memory from the middle of the lecture until 9 pm. His experience was incorporated into their model of brain processes.

The whole course of their investigations is described in twenty five papers [111], [112], [114], [115], [121]-[123], [126]-[131], [135], [136], [138], [140]-[144] and [149]-[151].

Personal Aspects

It is clear from what has been written here – which covers only a part of Bert's published scientific work – that he was a scientist of extraordinary breadth and depth. There was nothing routine or pot-boiling about any of his publications, so that even in areas such as general relativity, in which he published little, he produced material that could prove fertile for many years. In the preparation of this memoir, I received reports from a wide variety of people who found themselves both baffled and enormously impressed by Bert. The word 'genius' keeps appearing in comments by people who would not be expected to speak extravagantly. There are some reasons which can account for these strong reactions. First of all, Bert had a privileged upbringing in so far as he was a very talented only child, and although he always had a very friendly nature, he was perfectly satisfied with his own company. This self-isolating tendency was exacerbated when he started to go deaf in his twenties, which meant that his social exchanges became much less easy. For students this would mean a remoteness that they would find very hard to bridge, and for colleagues a difficulty in free exchange of ideas. So scientific discussions with him were rarely of the kicking-the-ball-around type, but rather a formulation of the problem, after which Bert would disappear, to return next morning, say, with it all worked out. Sometimes his solution would not be correct, and it could be quite tiring convincing Bert to change because, like most people, he did not take kindly to being corrected, and he could be very stubborn. Tony Bracken puts it admirably:

Sometimes his ideas were wrong, but he had the magical gift that, when he was wrong, it was almost always wrong in an interesting way. Those who worked with Bert sometimes had the feeling that our main task was to keep the locomotive on the rails. It was no good saying to Bert, 'I think this is wrong'. He would just say 'Oh?' and shrug. The only thing that worked was to produce a counterexample; then he would alter track slightly, and by repetitions of this process you could gradually come to a satisfactory conclusion.

Most of the time, though, the solution would be both ingenious and complete, bringing in ideas from unexpected directions. Bert had a very wide range of knowledge and could call up the relevant parts without difficulty, and with great clarity and cogency. He did not appear to search around for the correct path to a solution, so that there was rarely much sign of the usual false starts and well-filled waste paper basket. His use of University of Adelaide examination booklets, 16-page blue paper covered foolscap, in which to write his notes almost without blemish and apparently straight out, was legendary. Beginning research students repeatedly told of having a problem suggested to them, and of being given an examination booklet setting out in impeccable style, and in characteristic semi-neat writing, all the relevant points.

This leads to the most puzzling question of all when considering Bert's career. Despite his great scientific productivity and originality, he did not receive the sort of recognition that would be expected. There were no honorary doctorates, no elections to foreign scientific societies and academies (including the Royal Society of London), no invitations to give plenary addresses or to act as rapporteur at conferences, and no memberships of international committees. His deafness must not be discounted in considering his disinclination to feature at international meetings. It is not generally appreciated how disabling deafness can be in so much of ordinary intercourse. For example, on one occasion Bert gave an important seminar at Princeton that went well until question time, when, because he could not hear the questions, he simply smiled and nodded, giving the impression to the audience that he was not really on top of his subject. He was very reluctant to say that he was deaf, so people who did not know him would think he was very slow.

He was often invited to accept positions in the United States, both before coming to Adelaide and after, but he refused them all, saying that he much preferred the lifestyle of Adelaide, both at the University and elsewhere, and that his scientific work could function perfectly satisfactorily there. There is no doubt from his record that that is true, but there is also no doubt that his occasional visits to the United States and Europe were not sufficient to make a big impact on the international scene. Added to this was his very wide interests, which prevented him from making a strong impact in any one area, especially in such a highly competitive area as particle physics and field theory. His strongest reputation is undoubtedly in kinetic theory, in which he published not only fundamental papers, but also very highly regarded books and monographs. He was not particularly upset or bitter about his lack of recognition, feeling that he was very fortunate to do the things he wanted to do, surrounded by very bright young students, with periodic overseas visits to keep in touch. He certainly had no wish to push himself forward in any administrative role, no matter how prestigious. He took on the Presidency of the Australian Mathematical Society out of a sense of duty, and worked very hard then to assist Soviet refusniks. In the same way he took on the job of Dean of the Mathematical Sciences Faculty at Adelaide, and membership of Academy Sectional Committees, but had no interest in being on the University or Academy Councils.

At a personal level, Bert is remembered, despite his apparent remoteness, with great respect and often affection by those who worked with him, as students or as colleagues and often as both. Like a lot of people with introverted personalities, he found it easier to get on with extroverts as they would make most of the running. Two traits of his character that commanded great respect were his absolute integrity and his moral courage. He had very clear ideas about acknowledgement of other people's work, often to the extent of citing papers that were only marginally related to what he had done, and firm views about serving out a proper time after a job had been taken on. So not only did his students receive fine training in research but they were also given guidance on how to behave in later life. These instructions were given by example rather than precept.

As already mentioned, although Bert was not an athlete, he was a tremendous walker and he knew the Adelaide Hills and Flinders Ranges very well. He also walked extensively around Tucson, climbing the 2885m Mt Wrightson at the age of 67. Despite his deafness he was a very keen and discriminating concert goer, this being recognised by the choice of music at his funeral and memorial services. His favourite hobby was the game of Go, regarded by Japanese as their especial province so that defeat by a non-Japanese was a very serious matter. So it was not surprising that from time to time Bert would have to be regarded as an honorary Japanese in order for his opponent not to lose face. He organised a Go club in Adelaide, which used to meet regularly at his home.

Once when he was quite ill with a viral disease, and not able to concentrate on his beloved mathematics, Bert decided to write a detective novel. Instead of composing it as he wrote, he worked out the complete story, complete with racy dialogue, in his mind and then typed it out. He submitted the story to Penguin publishers but they did not accept it, and he did not bother any further. The manuscript is still in existence and it would be interesting to see whether a posthumous spy novel would have a sale now.

With the very strong support of his wife, Marlies, he made a point of regularly entertaining members of the department at their home. This produced a marvellous spirit within the department which had a great influence on the students. Even though the department no longer exists, this influence is still very noticeable in Australia, where so many of its graduates have risen to responsible positions. Bert always considered the existence of the Department of Mathematical Physics to be as great a contribution to the development of Australian science as his own research publications. Because of its special origin and the unique way in which Bert and his colleagues set it in motion, it was always regarded by the rest of the University with a mixture of pride, incomprehension and envy. Henry Basten, former Vice-Chancellor of Adelaide, once referred to it as the jewel in Adelaide's crown. Consequently it was a continuing source of sadness to Bert in his final years that what he had worked so hard to create should have been virtually destroyed, despite being given a resounding commendation by the Review Committee set up in 1984 to make recommendations for its future.

Bert was always a committed socialist of the Fabian variety and so believed in rule by an enlightened minority, sometimes being scornful of the 'tyranny of the majority'. His son, Roy, felt compelled at times to argue strongly that socialism not based on true democracy would be a stunted and dangerous form of political organization. Bert's answer to this was that no decisions of any significance should be left in human hands, and that artificial intelligence, rather than the market place, would be our saviour.

When Bert was in Dublin, he got to know de Valera well, because the latter, though president of the republic, maintained an interest in theoretical physics throughout his life – so much so that he intervened constantly in the seminar program that Bert co-ordinated, and if he had some political objection or score to settle he would strike the offending invitees off Bert's list! Despite their difference in age and religious belief, the two had many political views in common. Although Bert's religious views were agnostic, he believed in toleration and supported his daughter Johanne's marriage taking place in her husband's church, recognising its importance to him. Bert meditated regularly for the last half of his life. This was more for health and relaxation purposes than as any particular religious practice. He did, however, have some respect for certain aspects of Buddhism and at times referred to himself as a Humanist.

Acknowledgements

I wish to acknowledge the contributions made to this memoir by the twenty-five people who responded to my invitation to write about their association with Bert. They provided me with a wonderful range of impressions of Bert as an outstanding scientist, as a kindly mentor and as a warm and constant friend. I particularly want to thank his wife Marlies and children Roy and Johanne for details of their family life, and their experience of living in Adelaide. Professors Leon Bowden and Alister McLellan and Mr Arthur Birt were very helpful about Bert's life before coming to Adelaide, providing some very enjoyable lighter touches which were very revealing of sides of Bert's character. Professor Terry Triffet gave me a definitive account of their work together on neurophysiology and Professors David Hoffman, Tony Bracken and John Prescott helped to set Bert's work in the context of present knowledge. The detailed accounts of Bert's work from Associate Professors Peter Jarvis and Robin Storer were also much appreciated. Without their help I would have found it almost impossible to assimilate and judge the extraordinarily wide corpus of Bert's scientific writings.

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol.13, no.3, 2001. It was written by Angas Hurst, Department of Physics and Mathematical Physics, University of Adelaide.

Numbers in brackets refer to the references, and numbers in square brackets refer to the bibliography.

References

  1. The Born-Einstein Letters (Macmillan, 1971).
  2. N.N. Bogoliubov, J.Phys. (U.S.S.R.) 10, 256 (1946). An English translation is given in Studies in Statistical Mechanics, Vol.I (North-Holland, 1962).
  3. J.G. Kirkwood, J.Chemical Physics 14, 180 (1946).
  4. J. Yvon, La Théorie Statistique des Fluides et l'Equation d'État. Actualités Scientifique et Industrielles # 203 (1935).
  5. M. Kac and J.C. Ward, Phys.Rev. 88, 1332 (1952).
  6. E.R. Caianiello, Nuovo Cimento 11, 492 (1954).
  7. H.N.V. Temperley and M.E. Fisher, Phil.Mag. 6, 1061 (1961); P.W. Kasteleyn, Physica 27, 1209 (1961).
  8. E.H. Lieb, Phys.Rev. 162, 162 (1967).
  9. R.J. Baxter, Ann.Phys. 70, 192 (1972).
  10. M.Born, Proc.Roy.Soc.Edin. A59, 219 (1939).
  11. E.E. Salpeter and H.A. Bethe, Phys.Rev. 84, 1232 (1951); G.C. Wick, Phys.Rev. 96, 1124 (1954).
  12. J. Wess and B. Zumino, Nucl.Physics B70, 39 (1974).
  13. D. Basu and S.N. Biswas, J.Math.Phys. 11 (1970).

Curriculum vitae

  • Visiting Professorships, Dublin Institute of Advanced Studies, University of Florida, Michigan State University and University of Arizona.
  • Fellow, Australian Academy of Science 1954–99.
  • Fellow, Australian Institute of Physics.
  • Life Member, Australian Mathematical Society (Vice-President 1973–74 and 1976–77; President 1974–76).
  • Life Member, Royal Zoological Society of South Australia.
  • Editorial Boards: (sometime member and chairman) Australian Journal of Physics; (sometime member) International Journal of Engineering Science; (member) Mathematical and Computer Modelling.

Bibliography

Books

  • M. Born and H.S. Green, A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids (Cambridge University Press, 1949).
  • H.S. Green, Molecular Theory of Fluids, 264pp. (North-Holland Publishing Co., 1952).
  • H.S. Green, 'The Structure of Liquids', Handbuch der Physik, 10, 1–133, (1960).
  • H.S. Green and C. A. Hurst, Order-Disorder Phenomena, 363pp. (Interscience Publishers, London, 1964).
  • H.S. Green, Matrix Mechanics, 118 pp. (P.Noordhoff Ltd., Groningen, 1965).
  • H.S. Green, Research Frontiers in Fluid Dynamics, Ch. 4: Molecular Theory of Fluids, 105–143 (Editors, Seeger and Temple) (Interscience, New York, 1965).
  • H.S. Green, Quantenmechanik in Algebraischer Darstellung, 106pp. (Springer, Berlin, 1966).
  • H.S. Green, Matrichnaya Kvantovaya Mechanika, 163pp. (Ed. A.A. Sokolov) (Izdat. 'Mir', Moscow, 1968).
  • H.S. Green, Matrix Methods in Quantum Mechanics (Barnes and Noble, New York, 1968).
  • H.S. Green and R. B. Leipnik, Sources of Plasma Physics, 630pp. (Wolters-Noordhoff, Groningen, 1970).
  • H.S. Green, Matrix Methods in Quantum Mechanics (Japanese edition, with additional material) (Kodansha, Tokyo, 1980).
  • H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Sources of Consciousness (World Scientific, Singapore, 1997).
  • H.S. Green, Information Theory and Quantum Physics: Physical Foundations for Understanding the Conscious Process (Springer, Berlin, 1999).

Journal Articles

(Letters in parentheses refer to corresponding sections in the above discussion of Green's scientific work.)

  • [1] M. Born and H.S. Green, A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids I: The Molecular Distribution Functions. Proc. Roy. Soc. A188, 10–18 (1946).(a)
  • [2] H.S. Green, A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids II: Equilibrium Properties. Proc. Roy. Soc. A189, 103–117 (1947).(a)
  • [3] M. Born and H.S. Green, A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids III: Dynamical Properties. Proc. Roy. Soc. A190, 455–473 (1947).(a)
  • [4] M. Born and H.S. Green, A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids IV:Quantum Mechanics of Fluids. Proc. Roy. Soc. A191 168–181 (1947).(a)
  • [5] M. Born and H.S. Green, Quantum Theory of Liquids. Nature 159, 738–739 (1947).(a)
  • [6] M. Born and H.S. Green, A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids V: The Kinetic Basis of Thermodynamics. Proc. Roy. Soc. A192, 166–180 (1948).(a)
  • [7] H.S. Green, A General Kinetic Theory of Liquids VI: Liquid Helium II. Proc. Roy. Soc. A194, 244–258 (1948).(a)
  • [8] H.S. Green, The Relativistic Quantum Mechanics of the Elementary Particles. Proc. Cambridge Phil. Soc. 45, 263–274 (1948).(c)
  • [9] H.S. Green, Liquid Helium II, Nature 161, 391 (1948).(a)
  • [10] M. Born and H.S. Green, Quantum Theory of Rest-Masses. Proc. Roy.Soc. Edin. A62, 470–488 (1949).(c)
  • [11] H.S. Green, Recent Developments in the Theory of Elementary Particles, British Science News 3, 91–92 (1949).(c)
  • [12] H.S. Green, Quantized Field Theories and the Principle of Reciprocity, Nature 163, 208 (1949).(c)
  • [13] H.S. Green, On the Self-energies of Orthodox Quantum Mechanics, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A1197, 73–89 (1949).(c)
  • [14] H.S. Green, The Equations of State in Quantized Kinetic Theory and Quantum Statistical Mechanics. Physica 15, 882–890 (1949).(a)
  • [15] H.S. Green, The Kinetic Theory of Elasticity and Viscosity in Liquids. Proceedings of the International Congress on Rheology, Holland 1948, I, 12–28 (North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam, 1949).(a)
  • [16] H.S. Green, Remarks on a Paper by Riddell and Uhlenbeck, J. Chem.Phys. 18, 1123 (1950).(a)
  • [17] H.S. Green, The Quantum Mechanics of Assemblies of Interacting Particles. J. Chem. Phys. 19, 955–962 (1951).(a)
  • [18] H.S. Green and K. C. Cheng, The Reciprocity Theory of Electrodynamics. Proc. Roy. Soc. Edin. A63, 105–138 (1951).(c)
  • [19] H.S. Green and H. Messel, Differential Cross-Section for High Energy Nucleon-Nucleon Collisions. Phys. Rev. 83, 842–3 (1951).(d)
  • [20] H. Messel and H.S. Green, Mean Square Angle of Emission of Nucleons in High Energy Nucleon-Nucleus Collisions. Phys. Rev. 83, 1279 (1951).(d)
  • [21] H.S. Green, The Quantum Mechanical Partition Function. J.Chem.Phys. 20, 1274 (1952).(b)
  • [22] H.S. Green, The Second Virial Coefficient near Absolute Zero. Proc. Phys. Soc. A65, 1022 (1952).(a)
  • [23] H.S. Green and H. Messel, The Lateral Spread of Cosmic Ray Showers in Air and Lead. Phys. Rev. 85, 679 (1952).(d)
  • [24] H.S. Green and H. Messel, On the Spread of the Soft Component of the Cosmic Radiation. Phys. Rev. 88, 331 (1952).(d)
  • [25] H.S. Green and H. Messel, On the Theory of the Angular and Lateral Spread of the Nucleon Component of the Cosmic Radiation. Proc. Phys. Soc. A65, 689 (1952).(d)
  • [26] H.S. Green, H. Messel and B. A. Chartres, The Angular Distribution Functions for High Energy Cosmic Ray Particles. Phys. Rev. 88, 1277 (1952).(d)
  • [27] H. Messel and H.S. Green, The Angular Distribution of Scattered Nucleons in High Energy Nuclear Collisions. Proc. Phys. Soc. A65, 245 (1952).(d)
  • [28] H. Messel and H.S. Green, High Energy Nuclear Collisions and the Fermi Model. Phys. Rev. 87, 378 (1952).(d)
  • [29] H. Messel and H.S. Green, The Angular and Lateral Distribution Functions for the Nucleon Component of the Cosmic Radiation. Phys. Rev. 87, 738 (1952).(d)
  • [30] H.S. Green, First-Order Meson Wave Equations. Phys. Rev. 89, 965 (1953).(c)
  • [31] H.S. Green, A Generalized Method of Field Quantization. Phys. Rev. 90, 270–273 (1953).(c)
  • [32] H.S. Green, Boltzmann's Equation in Quantum Mechanics. Proc. Phys. Soc. 66, 325 (1953).(a)
  • [33] H.S. Green, A Pre-Renormalized Quantum Electrodynamics. Proc. Phys. Soc. A66, 873 (1953).(a)
  • [34] H.S. Green and E. Wolf, A Scalar Representation of Electromagnetic Fields. Proc. Phys. Soc. A66, 1129 (1953).(g)
  • [35] H.S. Green and H. Messel, On the Expansion of Functions in Terms of their Moments. Quarterly of Applied Mathematics 11, 403–409 (1953).(g)
  • [36] H. Messel and H.S. Green, The General Three-Dimensional Theory of Cascade Processes. Proc. Phys. Soc. A66, 1009 (1953).(d)
  • [37] H. Messel and H.S. Green, A Suggested Scheme for Meson Production, Phys. Rev. 89, 315 (1953).(d)
  • [38] E. Wolf and H.S. Green, A Scalar Method for the Investigation of Electromagnetic Fields. Canadian Journal of Phys. 31 (1953).(g)
  • [39] H.S. Green, Integral Equations of Quantized Field Theory, Phys.Rev. 95, 548 (1954).(c)
  • [40] H.S. Green and O. Bergmann, Core Structure in Soft Component Showers. Phys.Rev. 95, 516 (1954).(d)
  • [41] I. E. McCarthy and H.S. Green, A Method for the Solution of Nuclear Bound-State Problems. Proc. Phys. Soc. 67, 719 (1954). (c)
  • [42] H.S. Green, Goldstein's Eigenvalue Problem. Phys. Rev. 97, 540 (1955).(c)
  • [43] H.S. Green, Covariant Treatment of the Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction. Proc. Phys. Soc. A68, 577 (1955).(c)
  • [44] S. N. Biswas and H.S. Green, Radially Symmetric Solutions of Bethe-Salpeter Equation. Nuclear Phys. 2, 177–187 (1956).(c)
  • [45] H.S. Green, Molecular Theory of Irreversible Processes in Fluids, Proc. Phys. Soc. B69, 269–280 (1956).(a)
  • [46] H.S. Green, Cell and Cell-Cluster Models for Liquids, J. Chem.Phys. 24,732–737 (1956).(a)
  • [47] H.S. Green, Renormalization with Pseudo-Vector Coupling, Nucl.Phys. 1,360–362 (1956).(c)
  • [48] H.S. Green, Separability of a Covariant Wave Equation, Nuov. Cim. 5, 866–871 (1957).(c)
  • [49] H.S. Green and S. N. Biswas, Covariant Solutions of the Bethe-Salpeter Equation, Prog. Theor. Phys. 18, 121–138 (1957).(c)
  • [50] H.S. Green and C. A. Hurst, Parity Mixtures and Decay Processes. Nucl. Phys. 4, 589–598 (1957).(c)
  • [51] H.S. Green, Spinor Fields in General Relativity. Proc. Roy. Soc. A245, 521–535 (1958).(f)
  • [52] H.S. Green, Dirac Matrices, Teleparallelism and Parity Conservation. Nucl. Phys. 7, 373–383 (1958).(f)
  • [53] H.S. Green, Observation in Quantum Mechanics. Nuov. Cim. 9, 880–889 (1958). (e)
  • [54] H.S. Green, Propagation of Disturbances at High Frequencies in Gases, Liquids and Plasmas. Physics of Fluids 2, 31–39 (1959).(a)
  • [55] H.S. Green, Ionic Theory of Plasmas and Magnetohydrodynamics. Physics of Fluids 2, 341–349 (1959).(a)
  • [56] H.S. Green, Normalization and Interpretation of Feynman Amplitudes. Nuov. Cim. 15, 416 (1960).(c)
  • [57] H.S. Green and R. B. Leipnik, Exact Solution of the Association Problem by a Matrix-Spinor Method, with Applications to Statistical Mechanics. Rev.Mod.Phys. 32, 12 (1960).(b)
  • [58] C. A. Hurst and H.S. Green, New Solution of the Ising Problem for a Rectangular Lattice. J. Chem. Phys. 33, 1059 (1960).(b)
  • [59] H.S. Green, Statistical Thermodynamics of Plasmas. Nucl. Fusion 1, 69 (1961).(a)
  • [60] H.S. Green, Theories of Transport in Fluids, J. Math. Phys. 2, 344 (1961).(a)
  • [61] H.S. Green, Proton-proton Scattering at Relativistic Energies. Nucl. Phys. 27, 405–414 (1961).(c)
  • [62] H.S. Green, The Long-Range Correlations of Various Ising Lattices. Zeits. f. Physik 171, 129–148 (1962).(b)
  • [63] H.S. Green, seven articles contributed to Encyclopaedic Dictionary of Physics, Pergamon, Oxford (1961–2).(a)
  • [64] H.S. Green and R. G. Storer, Kinetic Theory of Second Order Effects in Fluids. Proc. International Symposium on Second Order Effects in Elasticity, Plasticity and Fluid Dynamics, Haifa 1962, 31–42 (Pergamon, Oxford, 1962).(a)
  • [65] H.S. Green and R. G. Storer, Theory of Higher Order Effects in Fluids. Phys. of Fluid 5, 1212–1218 (1962).(a)
  • [66] H.S. Green, Thermodynamics of Complicated Systems. Int. J. of Engineering Science 1, 5–22 (1963).(a)
  • [67] H.S. Green, Plasma Dynamics and Thermonuclear Reactions. Atomic Energy 6, 2–6 (1964).(a)
  • [68] H.S. Green, Structure and Energy Levels of Light Nuclei. Nuclear Physics 54, 505–515 (1964).(c)
  • [69] H.S. Green, Lambda-Nucleon Forces and Structure of Hypernuclei. Nuclear Phys. 57, 483–492 (1964).(c)
  • [70] H.S.Green, Theory of Reciprocity, Broken SU(3) Symmetry and Strong Interactions. Proc.International Conference on Elementary Particles, Kyoto, 159–169 (1965).(c)
  • [71] D. K. Hoffman and H.S. Green, On a Reduction of Liouville's Equation to Boltzmann's Equation. J. Chem. Phys. 43, 4007–4016 (1965).(a)
  • [72] H.S. Green, Research Frontiers in Fluid Dynamics, Ch.4: Molecular Theory of Fluids, 105–143 (Editors, Seeger and Temple) (Interscience, New York, 1965).(a)
  • [73] H.S. Green, Integral Equations for Distribution Functions in Fluids. Physics of Fluids 8, 1–7 (1965).(a)
  • [74] H.S. Green and R. B. Leipnik, Diffusion and Conductivity of Plasma in Strong External Fields. Intern. Jnl. of Engineering Sci. 3, 491–514 (1965).(a)
  • [75] H.S. Green, Theory of Reciprocity, Broken SU(3) Symmetry, and Strong Interactions, Proc. Int. Conf. on Elementary Particles, 159–169, Kyoto, 1965; Prog.Theor. Phys., Kyoto (1966).(c)
  • [76] H.S. Green and S. N. Biswas, Singularities of a Bethe-Salpeter Amplitude, Phys. Rev. 171, 1511 (1968).(c)
  • [77] H.S. Green and P. Brooker, An Exact Solution of Boltzmann's Equation for a Rigid Sphere Gas, Aust. J. Phys. 21, 543–61 (1968).(a)
  • [78] H.S. Green and D. Hoffman, Self-Consistent Approximations in Kinetic Theory, J. Chem. Phys. 49, 2600–2609 (1968).(a)
  • [79] H.S. Green and T.M.L. Wigley, New Kinetic Equations for Plasmas. Physics of Fluids 11, 2771–2773 (1968).(a)
  • [80] H.S. Green, Symposium on Kinetic Equations, Ch.1, The Kinetic Basis of Thermodynamics, 166–180 (Editors, Liboff and Rostoker) (Gordon and Breach, 1969).(a)
  • [81] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Codiagonal Perturbations, J. Math. Phys. 10, 1069–1089 (1969).(g)
  • [82] H.S.Green, Self-consistent kinetic equations, 3–19 (a)
  • [83] A. J. Bracken and H.S. Green, Vector Operators and a Polynomial Identity for SO(n). J. Math. Phys. 12, 2099–2111 (1971).(g)
  • [84] H.S. Green, Characteristic Identities for Generators of GL(n), O(n) and Sp(n). J. Math. Phys. 12, 2107 (1971).(g)
  • [85] A. J. Bracken and H.S. Green, Algebraic Identities for Parafermi Statistics of Given Order. Nuov. Cim. 9A, 349 (1972).(g)
  • [86] H.S. Green, Parastatistics, Leptons and the Neutrino Theory of Light. Prog. Theor. Phys. 47, 1400–1409 (1972).(c)
  • [87] H.S. Green and S. N. Biswas, Recent Developments in the Bethe-Salpeter Equation. Fields and Quanta 3, 241–261 (1972).(c)
  • [88] H.S. Green and J. R. Casley-Smith, Calculations on the Passage of Small Vesicles across Endothelial Cells by Brownian Motion. J. Theor. Biol. 35, 103–111 (1972).(i)
  • [89] A. J. Bracken and H.S. Green, Parastatistics and the Quark Model. J. Math. Phys. 14, 12 (1973).(c)
  • [90] H.S. Green, Pollution by Diffusive Processes. In Pollution: Engineering and Scientific Solutions (Ed. E.S. Barrekette) (Plenum, New York, 1973).(h)
  • [91] H.S. Green, G. R. Anstis and D. K. Hoffman, Kinetic Theory of a One-Dimensional Model. J. Math. Phys. 14, 1437 (1973). 101 of U(3), Int. J. Theor. Phys. 11, 157–73 (1974).(a)
  • [92] J. A. Campbell, H.S. Green and R. B. Leipnik, Bootstrap Equations with Restricted SU(3) Symmetry and the Cabibbo Angle. Phys.Rev. D9, 2451–2455 (1974).(c)
  • [93] H.S. Green and A. J. Bracken, Angular Momentum in Tensor Representations of U(3), International Journal of Theoretical Physics 11, 157–173 (1974).(g)
  • [94] H.S. Green, Quantization of Fields in Accordance with Modular Statistics. Aust. J. Phys. 28, 115–125 (1975).(c)
  • [95] H.S. Green, Spectral Resolution of the Identity for Matrices of Elements of a Lie Algebra. J. Aust. Math. Soc. 19B, 129–139 (1975).(g)
  • [96] H.S. Green and J. Casley-Smith et al., The Quantitative Morphology of Skeletal Muscle Capillaries in Relation to Permeability. Microvascular Research 10,43–64 (1975).(i)
  • [97] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, An Electrochemical Model of the Brain: General Theory and the Simple Neuron. J. Biol. Phys. 3, 53–76 (1975).(i)
  • [98] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, An Electrochemical Model of the Brain: Collective Behaviour, Irreversibility and Information. J. Biol. Phys. 3, 77–93 (1975).(i)
  • [99] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Quantum Mechanics and the Brain. Int.J. Quantum Chem: Quantum Biology Symp. 2, 289–296 (1975).(i)
  • [100] H.S. Green, Generalized Statistics and the Quark Model. Aust. J.Phys. 29, 483–488 (1976).(c)
  • [101] H.S. Green, C. A. Hurst and Y. Ilamed, The State Labelling Problems for SO(N) in U(N) and U(M) in Sp(2M). J. Math. Phys. 17, 1376–1382 (1976).(g)
  • [102] H.S. Green, Field Theory of Particles with Arbitrary Spin. Aust.J. Phys. 30, 1–14 (1977).(c)
  • [103] H.S. Green, Energy and Australia–Japan Relations. Pp.81–88 in Australia–Japan Relations Symposium (Eric White Associates, Canberra, 1977).(h)
  • [104] H.S. Green, Quantum Mechanics of Space and Time. Foundations of Physics 8, 753–591 (1978).(e)
  • [105] H.S. Green, Quantum Electrodynamics of Particles of Arbitrary Spin. Aust. J. Phys. 31, 219–231 (1978).(c)
  • [106] H.S. Green, J. F. Cartier and A. A. Broyles, Electron Propagator without Renormalization. Phys. Rev. D18, 1102–1109 (1978).(c)
  • [107] H.S. Green, Distribution of Arrival Times in Cosmic Ray Showers. Adv. Appl. Prob. 10, 730–735 (1978).(d)
  • [108] H.S. Green, Semigroups in Relativistic Quantum Mechanics. Structures of Time and Space 3, 183–194 (1979).(c)
  • [109] P. D. Jarvis and H.S. Green, Casimir Invariants and Characteristic Identities. J. Math. Phys. 20, 2115–2122 (1979).(g)
  • [110] S. Vaccaro and H.S. Green, Ionic Processes in Excitable Membranes. J. Theor. Biol. 81, 777–802 (1979).(i)
  • [111] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Mathematical Modelling of Nervous Systems. Math. Modelling 1, 41–61 (1980).(i)
  • [112] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Information and Energy Flow in a Simple Nervous System. J. Theor. Biol. 86, 3–44 (1980).(i)
  • [113] H.S. Green, Semigroups and the Density Matrix Formulation of Quantum Mechanics. Int. J. Quantum Chem. 17, 121–132 (1981).(e)
  • [114] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Non-linear Ion Dynamics. Dynamical Systems 2, 80–91 (1981).(i)
  • [115] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Ionic Currents in the Debye Layer, Mathematical Modelling 3, 161–178 (1982).(i)
  • [116] H.S. Green, Colour Algebras and Generalized Statistics. Pp.346–350 in Lecture Notes in Physics 180: Group Theoretical Methods in Physics (Springer, Berlin, 1983).(g)
  • [117] H.S. Green, Entropy and Human Activity
    in Environment and Population: Problems of Adaptation. (Ed. J. B. Calhoun), 85–89 (Praager Publishers, New York, 1983).(h)
  • [118] H.S. Green, Go and Artificial Intelligence. Ch. 9, pp. 141–151, in Computer Game-Playing: Theory and Practice (Ed. M. A. Bramer), (Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1983).(g)
  • [119] H.S. Green and P. D. Jarvis, Generalised Statistics and the Rishon Hypothesis. Aust. J. Phys. 36, 123–126 (1983).(c)
  • [120] H.S. Green and P. D. Jarvis, Casimir Invariants, Characteristic Identities and Young Diagrams for Colour Algebras and Superalgebras. J. Math. Phys. 24, 1681 (1983).(c)
  • [121] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Calcium Dynamics at a Plastic Synapse in Aplysia. J. Theor. Biol. 100, 649–674 (1983).(i)
  • [122] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, in Membrane Permeability: Experiments and Models. (Ed. A. H. Bretag), 31–35 (Techsearch, Adelaide, 1983).(i)
  • [123] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Ionic Currents and Field Effects in Neural Extracellular Spaces. In Nonlinear Electrodynamics In Biological Systems (Eds. W.R. Adey and A.F. Lawrence), (Plenum Pulishing Co., 1984).(i)
  • [124] H.S. Green, Fluid Transport Processes in Upper Spencer Gulf. Marine Geology 61, 181–195 (1984).(h)
  • [125] J. F. Cartier, A. A. Broyles, R. M. Placido and H.S. Green, Finite, Unrenormalized, Non-Perturbative Solution to the Schwinger-Dyson Equations of Quantum Electrodynamics. Phys. Rev. D30, 1742–1749 (1984).(c)
  • [126] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Mathematical Modelling of the Cortex. Mathematical Modelling 5, 383–399 (1984).(i)
  • [127] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Extracellular Fields within the Cortex. J. Theor. Biol. 115, 43–64 (1985).(i)
  • [128] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Electromagnetic Waves in Cortex Layers. Winner of Best Paper Award and Maxwell Prize in Proceedings, 5th International Conference on Mathematical Modelling, Berkeley, August 1985 (Pergamon, 1985).(i)
  • [129] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Information Transfer by Electromagnetic Waves in Cortex Layers. J. Theor. Biol. 131, 199–221 (1988).(i)
  • [130] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Information Processing by the Cortex. Comput. Math. Appl. 15, 743–756 (1988).(i)
  • [131] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Information Transfer in the Cortex. Mathl. Comput. Modelling 11, 832–836 (1988).(i)
  • [132] A.J. Bracken, H.S. Green and L. Bass, Groups Defined on Images in Fluid Diffusion. J. Austral. Math. Soc. B30, 101–119 (1988).(i)
  • [133] L. Bass, A.J. Bracken and H.S. Green, Boundary Layers and Images in Dispersed Flow Reactors: A Green's Function Approach. Chemical Engineering Science 43, 1583–1590 (1988).(i)
  • [134] L. Bass, H.S.Green and H. Boxenbaum, Gompertzian Mortality Derived from Competition Between Cell Types: Congenital, Toxicologic and Biometric Determinants of Longevity. J. Theor. Biol. 140, 263–278 (1988).(i)
  • [135] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, A Zonal Model of Cortical Functions. J. Theor. Biol. 136, 87–116 (1989).(i)
  • [136] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Unit Circuit Neural Networks of the Cortex. Mathl. Comput. Modelling 12, 673–694 (1989).(i)
  • [137] H.S. Green, A. J. Bracken and L. Bass, Harmonic Functions Satisfying a Radiation Boundary Condition. Computers Math. Applic. 22, 23–38 (1991).(g)
  • [138] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Quantum Mechanics, Real and Artificial Intelligence. Aust. J. Phys. 44, 323–334 (1991).(i)
  • [139] H.S. Green, A. J. Bracken and L. Bass, Harmonic Functions Satisfying a Radiation Boundary Condition. Computers Math.Applic. 122, 23–38 (1991).(g)
  • [140] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, A Model of an Artificial Electrochemical Synapse. Intelligent Engineering Systems Through Artificial Neural Networks (C.H. Dagli, L.I. Burke and Y.C. Shin, Eds.) 12, 51–60 (ASME Press, New York, 1992).(i)
  • [141] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Modelling Intelligent Behavior. Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 4, 35–42 (1993).(i)
  • [142] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Structured Neurobiological Networks. Mathl.Comput. Modelling 17, 75–88 (1993).(i)
  • [143] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Development of an Electrochemical Transistor for Use as an Artificial Synapse. Proc. of Third International Conference on Microelectronics for Neural Networks, 195–205 (Univ. of Edinburgh Technologies Ltd., Edinburgh, 1993).(i)
  • [144] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, Artificial Neural Processing. Mathl. Comput. Modelling 18, 1–18 (1993).(i)
  • [145] H.S. Green, A Cyclic Symmetry Principle in Physics, Aust. J. Phys. 47, 25–43 (1994). (e)
  • [146] H.S. Green, Statistical Symmetries in Physics, Aust. J. Phys. 47, 109–122 (1994). (e)
  • [147] H.S. Green, Contiguity and the Quantum Theory of Measurement, Aust. J. Phys. 48, 613–633 (1995).(e)
  • [148] S. N. Biswas and H.S, Green, Symmetry Breaking by Deformations, J. Phys. A28, L339–342 (1995).(c)
  • [149] T. Triffet and H.S. Green, Consciousness: Computing the Uncomputable. Mathl. Comput. Modelling 24, 37–56 (1996) (i)
  • [150] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, The Cortex as a Quantal Turing Machine. The Mathematical Scientist 21, 73–84 (1996).(i)
  • [151] H.S. Green and T. Triffet, The Animal Brain as a Quantal Computer. J.Theor.Biol. 184, 385–403 (1997).(i)
  • [152] H.S. Green, Quantum Theory of Gravitation. Aust. J. Phys. 51, 459–475 (1998).(f)

Unpublished Manuscripts

(In Green Papers, Department of Physics and Mathematical Physics, University of Adelaide.)

  1. H.S. Green, On the Foundations of Mathematical Logic.
  2. H.S. Green, Generation of Small Random Numbers.

Herbert George Andrewartha 1907-1992

Herbert George Andrewartha was born in Perth on 21 December 1907, the second of three children of George and Elsie Andrewartha. His father was a primary-school teacher, later a headmaster. The family moved often to country towns in Western Australia where his father was posted, but they maintained a base in a small farm at Gosnells, about 40 km from Perth.

Image Description

Written by L.C. Birch and T.O. Browning.

Herbert George Andrewartha 1907-1992

Abstract

Herbert George Andrewartha was born in Perth on 21 December 1907, the second of three children of George and Elsie Andrewartha. His father was a primary-school teacher, later a headmaster. The family moved often to country towns in Western Australia where his father was posted, but they maintained a base in a small farm at Gosnells, about 40 km from Perth. At the end of his primary schooling, Andrewartha was awarded a scholarship to Perth Modern School. He took up residence at the Gosnells home and lived alone. He travelled 5 km on horseback and 40 km by train each day to school. After several years, when his father retired to work the farm, his parents and two sisters returned. Andrewartha remained closely attached to his family throughout his life. His younger sister, Bon, died soon after marrying but his elder sister, Ethel, survived him. He was always very proud of her self-taught musical ability, taking an interest in the choral groups she led and for which she composed. He himself was tone deaf!

On completing his secondary schooling in 1924, Andrewartha was awarded a cadetship with the Western Australian Department of Agriculture and enrolled at the University of Western Australia, where in due course he took his Bachelor's degree in Agriculture. During his secondary schooling, and at University, he took little part in the social or sporting life because of the long journeys each day, but he played cricket and football for the local Gosnells teams, and tennis on a court made of clay from termite mounds - perhaps this led to his interest in insects. In any event, he continued to play tennis on his own grass court until he was laid low by a stroke a few years after his retirement in 1972.

After graduation, Andrewartha began work as Assistant Entomologist in the Department of Agriculture under the supervision of L.J. Newman, who had recently come to Western Australia from the Burnley School of Horticulture in Melbourne. He commenced a study of a weevil, Otiorrhynchus cribricollis, that infested fruit trees and this established his interest in the detailed analysis of life-cycles and behaviour of insects and in the phenomenon of 'diapause', in which an individual ceases morphological and reproductive development for a period and usually becomes highly resistant to inclement weather.

In 1933, Andrewartha took up a post in Melbourne with the CSIR as Assistant Research Officer and became part of a group of biologists studying the biology of the apple thrips, Thrips imaginis, which at that time was devastating apple crops in southern Australia. He worked in the School of Agriculture and Forestry at the University of Melbourne under the direction of Professor (later Sir) Samuel Wadham and was able to complete a thesis for which he was awarded the degree of Master of Agricultural Science. Through this work he met, worked with and married Hattie Vevers Steele, another young biologist.

In 1935, Andrewartha and his new wife moved to Adelaide, to the Waite Agricultural Research Institute, to join Professor James Davidson who was himself engaged in studies on T. imaginis. Andrewartha took some part in these studies, as did his wife for a time, but his main duties were the study of the plague grasshopper, Austroicetes cruciata, which was destroying field crops in South Australia and Western Australia in those days.

The plague grasshopper lived in the marginal farming areas of South Australia, lands where the mean annual rainfall was only just or not quite sufficient for growing wheat and the variability was great. Thus drought was frequent, and during the Great Depression much of the land had become badly eroded due to excessive cropping. Studies on the grasshopper entailed long journeys, often over very rough country, in a specially equipped utility truck – Andrewartha always carried two lengths of roof guttering-iron to help him negotiate landhills! His farm background and his innate ability to improvise enabled him to negotiate these trips without serious mishap, with his wife as diary-keeper and cook. However, on one occasion, when they did not arrive back in Adelaide as expected, Davidson asked the Australian Broadcasting Commission to send out a request for their whereabouts, which they did during a broadcast of a test-match, much to Andrewartha's chagrin! The broadcast stated that Andrewartha and his wife were last seen at Mount Hopeless!

In 1946 Professor Davidson died suddenly leaving unanalysed fifteen years of records of the numbers of thrips. Davidson and Andrewartha had discussed these data in detail over the years and had consulted E.A. Cornish of CSIR's Mathematical Statistics Section on the appropriate statistical analysis. So it was that Andrewartha was in a position to direct the very laborious statistical procedures, to appraise the results and to write the two papers that appeared under their joint names. These papers were to cause much controversy and were to be the forerunners of Andrewartha's general theory of population ecology.

At this time, Andrewartha made his first journey overseas, visiting England and the United States, where he met many of the influential scientists working with insects and in ecology. On his return, he wrote a review of the importance of diapause in enabling insects both to synchronise their life-cycles with the changing seasons and to persist in adverse conditions, and thus of its ecological significance. He also put forward a theory of the physiological nature of diapause but, unlike most of his work, this was based on inadequate data and did not stand up to critical analysis - a cautionary tale of entering into fields where one is insufficiently informed. We see similar instances when people, distinguished in other fields, pronounce on matters ecological.

Davidson and Andrewartha had been deeply engaged in an attempt to account for the often violent fluctuations in the numbers of individuals in populations. After Davidson's death, Andrewartha joined forces with his former graduate student, L.C. Birch, in a determined effort to construct a theory that would illuminate and unify the multifarious studies that had been published. The result was The Distribution and Abundance of Animals, which appeared in 1954. It was this book that established their reputations in the vanguard of population ecologists.

Soon after the publication of this book, Andrewartha moved from the Waite Institute to the Zoology Department of the University of Adelaide to become Reader-in-Charge of a small Unit of Animal Ecology, set up by Professor W.P. Rogers with financial support from CSIRO. Although Andrewartha while at the Waite Institute had taken a close interest in the work of the younger members of staff, and of the few postgraduate students in the Entomology Department, and had done some stints of lecturing, especially in statistics, he had not been in a position actively to supervise students nor to develop a course in ecology. So, on his move to Zoology, he began to set up a final-year unit in Animal Ecology and to gather round him a group of honours and postgraduate students. The undergraduate work was a considerable challenge because it is fair to say that no course in experimental ecology existed at that time, and Andrewartha was determined to introduce his students to the study of the distribution and abundance of animals through laboratory and field experiments that could be achieved within the restrictions of undergraduate time-tables. He also set out to design each exercise to be amenable to an appropriate statistical analysis, something with which zoology departments, at that time, were not at all familiar. His lectures were, of course, based on The Distribution and Abundance of Animals, but this was much too formidable a book for undergraduates, and contained a good deal of material that he did not consider relevant to his course. The result was the publication in 1961 of his Introduction to the Study of Animal Populations, a book containing a section on the theoretical treatment of populations and another consisting of a series of experiments, complete with representative data (much of which had been collected in his classes) and the detailed appropriate statistical analyses set out and explained. This course continued to attract large numbers of students until his retirement.

In 1962, Professor Rogers resigned from the Chair of Zoology and Andrewartha was appointed in his place. This was near the beginning of the great increase in funds available for postgraduate study, and so it was that during his tenure of the Chair, a large and flourishing school of research students and postdoctoral workers was built up. His agricultural background and his strong belief that good fundamental studies could always be done using animals of economic importance, either beneficial or detrimental, led most of his students into studies on abundant animals of importance in agriculture, medicine or households. A steady stream of PhD's emerged from the Department to go out into academia, industry or government research with thorough backgrounds in the theory and practice of experimental ecology, on which ideas like sustainable agriculture and forestry and conservation of natural resources depend.

The Distribution and Abundance of Animals had emphasised the importance, in trying to elucidate the causes of fluctuations in numbers, of a knowledge of certain aspects of the physiology of the animal being studied, and also of its behaviour. The Department of Zoology was fortunate in having strong groups in the early days in parasite physiology and biochemistry and in reproductive physiology, which helped broaden Andrewartha's understanding of these topics, to the benefit of his ability as a supervisor, and of his own thinking.

Andrewartha was a strong personality with strong convictions. He had very definite views about the supremacy of science as a way of thinking. This coloured much of his conversation with students and colleagues. The big difference of opinion he had with the so-called density-dependent school of regulation of animal numbers was due, he felt, to a misunderstanding on their part of the role of induction and deduction in science. He never accepted the premises that the density-dependent school regarded as fact. This misunderstanding was so important that he included a substantial statement on induction, deduction, hypothesis formation and theory in the book, The Ecological Web, that he later wrote with Birch.

Because of his strongly stated views, some people regarded him as somewhat abrasive or even pig-headed. Others found his position a wonderful anvil on which to hammer out their own views. The climax of the dispute between the density-dependent school and supporters of Andrewartha's views came at the 22nd Cold Spring Harbor Symposium in 1957 on 'Population Studies: Animal Ecology and Demography'. The symposium was largely organized by Theodosius Dobzhansky for the purpose of reconciling the opposing factions. The public dispute between Andrewartha and A.J. Nicholson became highly charged and personal, much to the dismay of the Americans in particular. Dobzhansky went away more confused than ever about these argumentative Australians.

Andrewartha's greatest influence was with his students, particularly his graduate students. They quickly warmed to his sincerity, humour and kind attention. Those whom he set on their life's path remained steadfast colleagues of his for the rest of their careers. They felt they had a mission to fulfil in making better understood the ecological thinking that had been so important for themselves. There was also a substantial group of ecologists, particularly in the Netherlands and the USA, who found in Andrewartha's theories concepts that guided their own research. Professor Daniel Simberloff, in writing the citation for the eminent Ecologist Award of the Ecological Society of America for 1988 to Andrewartha and Birch, said:

Both men have worked specially with insect populations, but their insights have informed our field to the extent that the "Andrewartha-Birch school" connotes a widely recognized viewpoint and suggests a distinctive research protocol. The Distribution and Abundance of Animals was the landmark synthesis of field population ecology that inspired a generation widely credited with constructing modern ecology...Their field and laboratory efforts were the starting points for a more general theory of population ecology that culminated in The Ecological Web...Andrewartha and Birch have been consistent skeptics, continually confronting fashionable models with hard-won field data on specific organisms...Their skepticism implies neither hostility to theory nor failure of their own viewpoint to evolve...Largely because of their books, Australian systems and Australian ecological research are part of the common vocabulary of ecologists throughout the world.

Andrewartha was ably supported by his wife Vevers until she died some years before his death. She was an entomologist and for some years worked on the embryology of the grasshopper Austroicetes cruciata when Andrewartha had this species as his main ecological project. She was always the gracious hostess at the many evening discussions of Honours and graduate students at their home in Netherby, near the Waite Institute. Together they worked long hours in their very large garden and looking after their grass tennis court, which was usually the venue of tennis games for friends throughout the tennis season.

Long before automatic garden watering systems had been invented, Andrewartha invented his own for their large garden. It was very much a 'Heath-Robinson' sort of contraption but it worked. Andrewartha was skilled at inventing all sorts of contraptions for the laboratory and field work as well. Scarcely any bit of laboratory equipment would come into the laboratory that 'Andy' did not alter and improve in some way. He designed the fine set of temperature controlled cabinets in his laboratory. On one occasion, when he was visiting Thomas Park at the University of Chicago, the Parks' toilet flushing system stopped working. Much to Tom's surprise, Andy got to work. It was going again in no time. 'Do all Australians do these sorts of things?' asked the somewhat abashed American host.

Especially in his younger days in Adelaide Andrewartha took a close interest in left-wing political matters. He was also active in the professional organizations associated with science and agriculture. He was a committee member of the Federation of Scientific and Technical Workers, a group interested in the working conditions of scientists and technicians, and he was active in and at one time president of the local branch of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science. His presidential address to the branch was a polemic about the laissez-faire system of farming, which he thought had been largely responsible for the devastating soil erosion that had occurred during the droughts of the 1930s. Later he resigned from the Society because he disagreed with a new policy of advocating studies in Agriculture as a profession, when the Society took no responsibility for the future employment of those who were influenced by its advocacy.

He was active in the conservation movement in its early days, being elected president of the Nature Conservation Society of South Australia, and was, for six years, chairman of the National Parks and Wildlife Advisory Council of South Australia.

Andrewartha shared (with L.C. Birch) the David Syme Prize of the University of Melbourne, the Clarke Medal of the Royal Society of New South Wales and the Verco Medal of the Royal Society of South Australia. He was elected a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1961. In 1987 he was awarded the Gold Medal of the Australian Ecological Society and in the following year was named (together with L.C. Birch) 'Eminent Ecologist of the Year' by the Ecological Society of America.

Andrewartha suffered a serious stroke in 1975 which left his left arm paralysed. However, with great fortitude and patience and helped by his inventive genius, he largely overcame the disabilities of this stroke and wrote his last book with Birch while still recovering. He died on 27 January 1992 at the age of 84, after a long illness that followed a broken knee sustained in a fall at his home. He is survived by his son Graeme and daughter Susan Dutch.

Scientific research

Andrewartha's first work was a study of aestivation of adults of the beetle Otiorrhynchus cribricollis in Western Australia. This became part of a later interest in the dormant phases of stages in the life-histories of insects. With CSIR in Melbourne he began work on the ecology of Thrips imaginis, a pest of some fruits. This work was to continue with Professor James Davidson as one of a number of projects when he moved to the Waite Institute in Adelaide. However, his first major research programme at the Waite Institute was on the population ecology of the plague grasshopper, Austroicetes cruciata, on which he published some dozen papers. In the 1960s he developed a programme in conjunction with J. Munro and N.L. Richardson on the use of sterile males to control populations of the Queensland fruitfly Dacus tryoni, which was a possible threat to fruit growing in the southern States if it became established there.

Two general principles motivated his ecological research. In the first place he was dedicated to doing something useful as well as adding to basic scientific information about the ecology of animals. Curiosity alone was not a sufficient reason for him to embark on a research programme. All the animals he worked with were of agricultural importance. He was convinced that success in helping the 'useful arts', as he called them, depended upon the quality of basic scientific research. The useful arts that depend on the science of ecology include the control of pests, the conservation of wildlife and the management of game. All these activities have a common goal, to control or to manipulate the reproduction and the life-expectancy of the animals in a natural population so that the density of the population remains between certain pre-determined limits.

Secondly, all his research was to contribute to a general theory of population ecology. Population ecology was a term coined by Thomas Park in Chicago. Andrewartha preferred to say that he was working on the principles that governed the distribution and abundance of animals. This phase comes directly from Charles Elton's classic Animal Ecology published in 1927. It became the title of his first book (with L.C. Birch) in 1954. Whether he used the phrase population ecology or the distribution and abundance of animals, Andrewartha made a clear distinction between the study of the ecology of a single species and community ecology. He was never persuaded that community ecology would contribute substantially to the science of ecology.

As he pursued his interests on the principles governing the distribution and abundance of animals, he was to find that in general the best work was done on animals that were either pests or were animals managed as game. This is borne out in the preponderance of examples from these areas in the book The Distribution and Abundance of Animals. It was simply true that the best work was in these areas. Much of it was done in Australia.

Andrewartha's long-term study on the ecology of Thrips imaginis was done in collaboration with Professor James Davidson. Davidson died in 1945, but their major findings on Thrips were published in two classical papers in the Journal of Animal Ecology in 1948. These were to be the focus of much debate amongst ecologists for years to come. The work on both Austroicetes and Thrips led Andrewartha and Davidson to develop a theory of population ecology that was at variance with the conventional wisdom of the day. Following Davidson's death, Andrewartha collaborated with a former student of his, L.C. Birch (who was no longer in Adelaide but at the University of Sydney), in further developing a theory of population ecology. This theory, together with supporting data and arguments, was published in two books jointly authored by Andrewartha and Birch, The Distribution and Abundance of Animals in 1954 and The Ecological Web in 1984.

The ecology of Thrips imaginis

The basic data for the ecology of Thrips was a daily estimate of their numbers in the rose garden of the Director's residence at the Waite Institute for fourteen years, together with daily meteorological data recorded in the meteorological station at the Waite Institute, just by the rose garden. Fourteen years is an unusually long time for the study of any population of animals, but such a long time turned out to be critically important in the analysis of the data. The method of partial regression was used to analyse the data in attempting to explain what were the main components of the environment that could account for the day-to-day and season-to-season changes. This was the first time partial regression had been used in population ecology. The regressions included the following independent variates: rainfall and temperature for each of the three days preceding the sampling of the population, the maximum temperature and rainfall for the day immediately before the day the population was sampled. These independent variates were chosen on the basis of what was known about the biology of Thrips. Food was not included in the analysis as it was never in short supply.

Some 78 per cent of the variance was accounted for by four quantities that were calculated entirely from meteorological records. This left virtually no chance of finding any other systematic cause for variation, since 22 per cent is quite a small residuum to be left as due to random sampling errors. All the variation was attributed to causes unrelated to the density of Thrips. Not only did Andrewartha find no 'density-dependent factor', but he claimed there was no room for one. This was the aspect of the analysis that created much discussion and controversy, since the dominant school of population ecology claimed that the numbers in natural populations can be regulated only by density-dependent factors. In their absence, the numbers were supposed to go on increasing without limit or to decrease to extinction. Neither of these things happen in the case of Thrips, since the seasons subject Thrips to a period that is favourable for increase in numbers to be followed by a season that is very unfavourable. One important reason why Thrips does not become extinct in the area studied is the heterogeneity of the places where it may live. It may become extinct in one locality only for this to be colonized again from a locality where it has not become extinct.

Andrewartha's conclusions about Thrips went against the conventional wisdom that dominated population ecology at the time. The two conclusions that the numbers of Thrips can be explained by the succession of good and bad seasons and by the heterogeneity of places where they lived, became central to the general theory of population ecology that Andrewartha was developing.

The ecology of Austroicetes cruciata

The ecology of this plague grasshopper was studied by Andrewartha, from 1935 to 1942 together with James Davidson, and with L.C. Birch. The life-cycle is characterized by an intense obligate diapause or state of dormancy in the egg stage. Consequently there is only one generation each year. Since diapause in the egg was critical to understanding the ecology of the grasshopper, Andrewartha studied the influences that determined the stage of onset of diapause and the influences that ended diapause. Soon after being laid, the embryos inside the egg developed up to an early stage, after which obligate diapause ensued. The embryo remained in that state during the winter. A particular sequence of cold temperature was responsible for the resumption of development at the end of the winter.

In this study, the numbers of grasshoppers were not determined precisely as was the case with Thrips. Qualitative or subjective estimates were made. It became clear quite early in the study that dryness during the spring was critical in determining the number of grasshoppers that survived in any year. In some seasons the drought was so severe that grasshopper populations crashed and only a succession of good years to follow enabled numbers to become abundant again. During drought years the stocks of food ran out, not because they were eaten by grasshoppers but because drought made the grass useless as food for grasshoppers. The supply of food was unrelated to the number of grasshoppers.

The rate of increase of grasshoppers was not determined by density-dependent factors, yet their numbers did not go on increasing to the limit of their resources of food. Calamity in the form of drought overtook the grasshoppers before this could happen. This sort of calamity occurred with a certain frequency that was calculated from the meteorological records. Grasshoppers became extinct in many localities during a dry season. However, some always survived in more favourable places. It was from these places that new colonies could be set up in subsequent years. Grasshoppers never became extinct over the whole range of their distribution. The explanation of numbers of Austroicetes was strikingly similar to the case with Thrips, and once again it challenged conventional wisdom about what determined the numbers of an animal.

Austroicetes was distributed in a belt of country that had been cleared of its native vegetation of plants such as saltbushes, which are not food for grasshoppers. However, the grasses that took the place of the original vegetation were suitable food for grasshoppers. Much of this country was marginal wheat country, and much of it had been abandoned for growing wheat. There was then a simple ecological solution to getting rid of grasshoppers, and that was to return the country to its original saltbushes. However, that turned out to be unacceptable politically and perhaps economically.

Diapause

Andrewartha's study of diapause in the eggs of Austroicetes led him to an intensive study of diapause in general amongst insects, as is indicated by the long chapter on the subject in The Distribution and Abundance of Animals. His study was the most complete that had ever been made up to that time. An important contribution of this study was his discovery that diapause in the egg stage characterized the life-history of plague grasshoppers around the world. These are grasshoppers that do not migrate. They cope with the hostile season by going into diapause. Locusts on the other hand were thought not to have a diapause at any stage and to cope with the hostile season by migrating huge distances. Andrewartha was able to study this on the spot in South Australia where the locust Chortoiocetes terminifera had its 'outbreak' areas in the northern desert of the state, from which the population at long intervals spilled over in huge migratory swarms to the southern areas of Australia. Most of the locusts did not survive long in these places, but some did. Andrewartha reasoned that eventually some of their descendents managed to get back to the dry outbreak areas where populations were permanent. This helped them to be permanent inhabitants of these places. Andrewartha assembled a great deal of data indicating that with plague grasshoppers, diapause in the egg enabled them to survive in the inhospitable season, and that with locusts, migration from inhospitable areas enabled them to remain extant. More recent work has shown this concept not to be as clear-cut as Andrewartha thought, though the two mechanisms of survival are well recognized.

The Queensland fruitfly Dacus tryoni

In most parts of Australia, with the exception of the central and western deserts and southern Tasmania, the climate is hospitable for the Queensland fruitfly. Its distribution, however, is much more restricted. This is probably due to the absence of a succession of fruits. Before fruit trees were cultivated in Australia, Dacus was restricted to tropical and sub-tropical forests. With the cultivation of fruit trees, it spread south as far as eastern Victoria. Occasionally, infested fruit has been found on trees further west and around Adelaide. In temperate areas, the chance of a female finding a mate becomes quite small during two periods. The over-wintering population of adults is quite small and is widely dispersed in a few sheltered localities. In early spring, the first generation that arises from the over-wintering adults is also small and dispersed. Moreover, most of the newly emerged adults leave the locality in which they originated.

Because of these facts, Andrewartha surmised that early spring would be a strategic time to liberate sterile flies with the objective of flooding the population with sterile males and so reducing the chance of females finding fertile males, a technique for the control of populations that had recently been proposed, and tested, by E.F. Knipling of the United States Department of Agriculture. This appealed to Andrewartha as a possible method of control, particularly in areas that might become newly colonized by the insect such as Victoria and South Australia.

Andrewartha, J. Munro and N.L. Richardson worked out a strategy for the control of fruitflies by releasing huge numbers of sterile males. Many millions of flies were bred in Sydney and pilot experiments were done in towns in western New South Wales. The work had to be terminated before it could be demonstrated that the method was economically feasible, though initial results were encouraging. The work is important as it was the first attempt to use this technique in Australia and showed its feasibility, if sufficient funds could be found to breed and release the huge numbers of insects needed.

General theory of the distribution and abundance of animals

The general theory of the distribution and abundance of animals was based on the original field studies of Andrewartha, Davidson and Birch, together with the analysis of many case-histories of the ecology of animals, many of them from Australia. In the course of these investigations, Andrewartha spent much time working through the data of other investigators who had accumulated a great deal of information but had never put it together in the form of a general theory. This applied, for example, to the work in the CSIRO on the European rabbit in Australia, on waterfowl and on the Australian magpie. In working on these case-stories and many others, Andrewartha not only made the work in question more accessible to ecologists but put it together in the context of a general theory. The results of this work were published in the two books with L.C. Birch, The Distribution and Abundance of Animals and The Ecological Web.

The central proposition of the theory is that the numbers of an animal (and therefore its distribution and abundance) depend upon its chance to survive and reproduce, which in turn depends on the animal's environment. It follows that the ecologist needs to have precise ways of defining and measuring the chance to survive and the chance to reproduce, and secondly to have a precise definition of environment and its components. The precise meaning of and measurement of the chance to survive and reproduce were established in The Distribution and Abundance of Animals. The meaning of environment was developed in the same book but became much more refined thirty years later in The Ecological Web. Indeed, this latter work presented the results of many years of discussion between Andrewartha, Birch, T.O. Browning and B.S. Niven. It was a unique contribution and basically different from what most ecologists had been working with.

The problem was how to define environment and how to split it up into components that did not overlap. The environment is not just anything that happens to be around the animal. It is anything that influences an individual's chance to survive and/or to reproduce. The word 'individual' is critical. In this theory there is no such thing as the environment of a population, for every individual may exert an influence on every other individual. The concept of the environment of the individual contrasts with the then current concept of the environment of the population. The importance of defining environment in terms of the individual took a long time to catch on and is still rejected by many ecologists. In these deliberations Andrewartha aimed to discover a precise and completely unambiguous way of defining each component of environment. This had never been done before. Terms such as 'biotic' and 'physical' were hopelessly imprecise. It was for this reason that he welcomed the contribution of Susan Niven, who used the symbolism of formal logic for this purpose. Her somewhat complex formal procedure was included as an Appendix in The Ecological Web.

The definition of the components of environment is summarised in Table 1.01 in The Ecological Web. This is a 2´2 table with four compartments depending on (a) the reaction, either negative or positive, of the component to the animal and (b) the response of the animal, either negative or positive, to the component. This gives four 'directly acting' components: resources, mates, malentities and predators. Anything that influences the activity of the directly-acting components is not in this centrum of directly acting components but is part of a web of influences extending outwards from the centrum. 'Malentity' is a rather new idea, and 'resource' has a more restricted meaning than is general in ecology.

The Ecological Web introduced the idea of the 'envirogram'. This is a diagram for the animal that shows the directly-acting components as the proximate causes of the condition of the animal, and the distal components as a web extending outwards from the directly-acting components. It shows any interactions there may be between components, and is basically simple to look at. This contrasts with the complicated flow diagrams that ecologists had up to then constructed.

The definition of environment, the analysis of the components and the envirogram were the subject of enthusiastic acceptance by some ecologists, but the object of much criticism by others. One problem was that you had to know quite a lot about your animal before you could correctly decide which were the four directly-acting components and which were the indirectly acting ones. Also, to get there required a lot of careful thought. While this turned out to be stimulating for some students, it proved too strenuous for others. Some critics so misunderstood the meaning of the envirogram that they incorrectly said it failed to show interactions. It is too early to say to what extent this analysis will be accepted by population ecologists, though there are some fine examples of its application by others, particularly in the ecology of birds, and Susan Niven has used it in her studies of a wide range of invertebrates and vertebrates.

A second main plank of the general theory is that populations are multipartite, that is to say the population is subdivided into local populations where environments differ widely. Moreover, each local population may be genetically different. The extent of dispersal from one local population to another is very important in understanding the dynamics of the whole process and its outcome. In The Ecological Web the term used for this was 'spreading the risk', which was proposed by P.J. den Boer of the Netherlands to indicate the way in which heterogeneity between local populations could confer stability and persistence in the natural population. The concept of the multipartite population and spreading of risk was illustrated by diagrams in both The Distribution and Abundance of Animals and The Ecological Web, each diagram representing a different way in which spreading of risk operates.

Andrewartha considered that the general theory of population ecology set out in these two books replaced the conventional wisdom that populations have to be regulated by density-dependent factors such as competition. He was happy to use the word competition when one genotype was shown to be superior to another, but in other contexts he felt the word confused or obscured what was happening. This again was quite a radical idea that was in opposition to conventional ecological thinking.

The general theory of population ecology that Andrewartha developed with his colleagues held that any component of environment could play a part in determining numbers, preventing numbers from increasing indefinitely and preventing extinction of the natural population as a whole. Each component of environment could be assigned a probability, none was completely deterministic. This was a probabilistic as contrasted with a deterministic approach. It was clearly in conflict with the widely held theory that populations could only be controlled by density-dependent factors and represented by deterministic models.

Unfortunately, the theory was widely misconstrued by some of its critics who supposed that it claimed that so-called density-dependent factors played no part in the regulation of animal numbers. On the contrary, according to the theory these took their place with all other components, as should have been clear from the examples given in which predators were critical in determining numbers. The arguments that ensued resulted in Andrewartha writing quite a lot about the role of induction, deduction and theoretical models in scientific method (e.g. pages 187-191 in The Ecological Web).

Andrewartha was convinced that the study of community ecology had not contributed to understanding the causes of the distribution and abundance of animals. He hoped that population ecology (the study of single species) would eventually displace studies in community ecology.

Andrewartha held that the first requirement of an ecologist was to be a good naturalist. You have to know something about your organisms before you can start to make theories about them. He was not opposed to theory but he was opposed to theories that made gross abstractions from the real world and seemed to depend little if at all on data from the field, going only to the field or the literature to find results that seemed to conform to the conclusions of the theoretical model. In his opinion the theoretical models of his day left out of account the idea of the multipartite population and the heterogeneity of the environment. This made them useless except for theoretical exercises in mathematics.

Andrewartha's contribution to population ecology was largely spread through the two books written with Birch. The Distribution and Abundance of Animals was widely used in ecology courses, particularly in the USA, and influenced a whole generation of ecologists. The influence of The Ecological Web has yet to be assessed. Andrewartha paid great tribute to Charles Elton, who put animal ecology on the map in the United Kingdom, particularly for his workmanlike approach to what ecology was about. The two differed greatly on the value of community ecology. Andrewartha had great respect for the work directed by Harry Smith at the Citrus Experiment Station at Riverside in California and used many of these studies in his writings. He was influenced in later years by the work of den Boer and his students in the Netherlands.

There is a sense in which Andrewartha's contribution to population ecology was ahead of its time. The conventional wisdom was against it. The sudden efflorescence of highly abstract theoretical models based on the ability of a computer to follow complex interactions tended to engulf the literature in the '70s and '80s, and biosphere studies emphasised community ecology until its practitioners realized that this did not answer the questions that were being asked. Through all this, there is beginning to emerge a new valuation of the long-term field study and the necessity of studying the multipartite population. One day this approach may become more dominant than it is at present. When that happens, we can thank Andrewartha for setting the direction with such skill and persistence.

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol.9, no.3, 1993. It was written by L.C. Birch, Emeritus Professor, University of Sydney and T.O. Browning, Emeritus Professor, University of Adelaide.

Herbert Cole Coombs 1906-1997

With the death of Herbert Cole ('Nugget') Coombs on 29 October 1997, Australia lost its greatest public servant, a man who spent his life as an employee of the Commonwealth initiating major civilizing activities in economic and cultural fields, and after his retirement became a great champion of the rights of Aboriginal Australians.

Image Description

Written by F. Fenner and S.F. Harris.

Herbert Cole Coombs 1906-1997

Introduction

With the death of Herbert Cole ('Nugget') Coombs on 29 October 1997, Australia lost its greatest public servant, a man who spent his life as an employee of the Commonwealth initiating major civilizing activities in economic and cultural fields, and after his retirement became a great champion of the rights of Aboriginal Australians. More than any other individual, he was responsible for the formation of the Australian National University, he was a most influential Governor of the Reserve Bank, he was the foundation chairman of the Australian Elizabethan Theatre Trust and of the Australian Council for the Arts and its successor, the Australia Council. From the time of his appointment as Chairman of the Office of Aboriginal Affairs in 1968 he became deeply interested in the welfare of Aborigines, and this became his major activity during the last thirty years of his life.

The account which follows is not a biography, but a biographical memoir of the Australian Academy of Science. In consequence, the discussion of his activities as a public servant and as an economist are only briefly mentioned, attention being concentrated on Coombs' contributions to science and environmental conservation, and to a lesser extent his influence in the promotion of the arts and the welfare of Australian Aborigines.

Early life

Coombs was born in Kalamunda, Western Australia, on 24 February 1906, the son of a country stationmaster and a well-read mother. After five years at Perth Modern School, he worked as a pupil-teacher for a year before spending two years at the Teachers' College. He then spent two years teaching at country schools, during which he studied for an Arts degree in the University of Western Australia, at the time the only university in Australia that did not charge fees. Transferring to a metropolitan school for the final two years, he graduated BA with first-class honours in economics and won a Hackett Studentship for overseas study. This was deferred for a year, at the end of which, in 1931, he graduated MA and married a fellow teacher, Mary Alice ('Lallie') Ross. He then proceeded to the London School of Economics, the staff of which then included Laski, Robbins and von Hayek. In 1933 he was awarded a PhD for a thesis on central banking. He was caught up in the ferment of the Keynesian revolution and as he later wrote: 'The publication in 1936 of John Maynard Keynes' General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money was for me and many of my generation the most seminal intellectual event of our time.' In 1934 he returned to a teaching position in Perth and combined this with part-time lecturing in economics at the University.

Career in the Commonwealth Public Service, 1935-1949

While in London, Coombs had met Leslie Melville, Economist for the Commonwealth Bank, with whom he discussed opportunities for obtaining work as an economist. In 1935 he resigned from the Education Department of Western Australia and moved to Sydney as assistant economist to Melville. At the outbreak of the Second World War in 1939 he was transferred to Canberra as an economist in Treasury. In 1942 he was appointed to the Commonwealth Bank Board and later that year Prime Minister Curtin appointed him Director of Rationing. In 1943 he was appointed Director-General of Post-War Reconstruction. In this position he was responsible for the Commonwealth Reconstruction Training Scheme (CRTS), and he took a particular interest in establishingfacilities for the rehabilitation of disabled service men and women. He played a major role in planning the 1945 legislation that established the Commonwealth Bank as a competitor with the trading banks and strengthened the authority of the central bank (the Reserve Bank). He was also an important figure in the international discussions that began in 1943 and culminated with Australia's signature of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade in November 1947. Throughout the negotiations he emphasised the importance of acceptance by the participating countries of a domestic policy aimed at full employment and rising living standards (Rowse, 1997).

While Director-General of Post-War Reconstruction, Coombs was deeply involved in the establishment of what became the Australian National University. The creation of this research university, with two of its initial four Research Schools being in the natural sciences and the subsequent expansion of Research Schools in science and mathematics to eight, was his principal contribution to science and an important component of the decision of the Australian Academy of Science to elect him as a Fellow by special election in 1969. Until 1944 education at all levels had been a jealously guarded State responsibility, but with the establishment of the Commonwealth Office of Education in that year, a move in which Coombs was deeply involved, the subsequent creation of the Universities Commission, and Commonwealth acceptance of financial responsibilities for CRTS trainees, the pattern of support for tertiary education in Australia was changed forever. During this period Coombs also initiated the long-term programme of biological and agricultural research that was needed for the development of northern Australia.

In 1948 the government became concerned about research on matters of military security being investigated by scientists employed by the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR). A move to convert CSIR into a government department had substantial support in Cabinet, not least from John Dedman. At Prime Minister Chifley's request, Coombs and W.E. Dunk (Chairman of the Public Service Board) reviewed the situation, and recommended that a separate Defence Science Organization should be established, and that CSIR should be expanded as the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO), free of any commitment to 'secret' research. Many years later, when in 1975 Coombs was Chairman of the Royal Commission on Australian Government Administration, he found that 'On the whole in retrospect the 1948 report, despite its compromises, stood up fairly well. Certainly the performance of CSIRO over the intervening years suggests that the rearguard action that we had fought to preserve appropriate conditions for scientific work had been reasonably effective.' (Coombs, 1981).

As Director-General of Post-War Reconstruction, Coombs maintained close contacts with Ian Clunies Ross, soon to become the first Chairman of CSIRO, advising him on means of stimulating the application of relevant research at the farm level. He had a continuing interest in fostering innovation in secondary industry and later was active in the Science and Industry Forum of the Australian Academy of Science. He was also concerned with environmental problems, and was President of the Australian Conservation Foundation from 1977 to 1979. In 1990 he published a book, The Return of Scarcity: Strategies for an Economic Future, dealing with some of the conflicts between ecology and the economy.

Governor of the Reserve Bank, 1949-1968

In 1949 Coombs was appointed Governor of the Commonwealth Bank and in 1951 Chairman of its Board. When central banking legislation was changed in 1960 he was appointed Governor of the Reserve Bank of Australia and Chairman of the Board, posts that he held until 1968. As he describes in Other People's Money, he used this position in a most innovative way, setting up a Banking Administrative Staff College and establishing regular meetings with the managers of commercial banks. Later he organized meetings of central bankers of various countries, especially those of South-East Asia, Australia and New Zealand, and was involved in the planning of the banking system of Papua New Guinea in anticipation of its independence. On the scientific side, he showed a great interest in the part played by the Rural Credits Development Fund in stimulating and assisting research projects and post-graduate education in the universities. The Rural Credits Development Fund also sponsored several academic positions in Australian universities, primarily to help apply agricultural and biological research to operations at the farm level.

Coombs had always been interested in the arts, and while he was Governor of the Commonwealth Bank he was instrumental in setting up the Australian Elizabethan Theatre Trust, of which he was Chairman from 1954 to 1967. He was a member of the Council of the Australian Ballet School from 1958 and a director of the Australian Ballet Foundation from 1962 to 1967.

Chairman of the Council for the Arts and the Council for Aboriginal Affairs, 1967-1976

Late in 1967, at the suggestion of Prime Minister Holt, Coombs retired from his position as Governor of the Reserve Bank and assumed two other onerous and important tasks, chairmanship of two new bodies, the Council for the Arts and the Council for Aboriginal Affairs. He held these posts until 1976. After his appointment as a Visiting Fellow in CRES in 1976 he devoted most of his energies to promoting the recognition of Aboriginal Australians. As he got older, Coombs escaped from the cold Canberra winter to the North Australia Research Unit, which on his initiative had been set up in Darwin as an outpost of the Australian National University in 1973.

Foundation of the Australian National University

Perhaps Coombs' major contribution to science and culture was his role in the establishment and development of the Australian National University, a topic recently discussed in detail by Foster and Varghese (1996), from whose book the following account, which is focused on the two science Schools, in medical research and physical sciences, is largely derived. Because of his background, he played an even more important role in setting up the Research Schools of Pacific Studies and Social Sciences.

The idea of a national university for Australia goes back to the 1870s, and in 1913 Walter Burley Griffin designated a site for a university for 'teaching and research' in Canberra near the foot of Black Mountain, on much the same site that it now occupies. His design for the university, as for so much of Griffin's Canberra, was a somewhat complex arrangement of concentric circles, symbolizing the extension of knowledge from a theoretical core outwards to the more applied aspects of each field.

In 1927 T.H. Laby, professor of natural philosophy at the University of Melbourne and a distinguished physicist, told a government commission that Canberra should have a national university devoted to teaching and research, something that would be for Australia what Oxford and Cambridge were for Britain. Between the two World Wars the idea of a university for Canberra was kept alive by the University Association of Canberra, of which Sir Robert Garran, a prime mover in the constitutional debates that preceded federation and the first Solicitor-General, was a prominent member. In 1929 the Association persuaded the government to establish Canberra University College, affiliated with the University of Melbourne, as a place to provide tertiary education for Commonwealth public servants and their children. The Association also tried to interest politicians in the establishment of an independent university in Canberra, but this idea did not blossom until John Curtin became Prime Minister in October 1941. In contrast to his predecessor, Robert Menzies, Curtin's vision extended beyond the immediate wartime needs; he wished to plan for a new social order that would ensure that every Australian would enjoy peace, security and employment. It was fortunate that at that period the Commonwealth government was supported by an outstanding group of public servants who shared this vision, prominent among them Coombs, then Director-General of Post-War Reconstruction.

John Dedman's Interdepartmental Committee

The first moves towards advances in education through Commonwealth initiatives came not from the Department of Post-War Reconstruction, but from the Department of War Organization of Industry, the deputy head of which, Ronald Walker (another economist), persuaded his Minister, John Dedman, to set up an interdepartmental committee to examine possible Commonwealth initiatives in education. The committee included Coombs, Sir David Rivett, the Chairman of CSIR, and R.C. Mills, professor of economics in the University of Sydney. The committee met several times in late 1943 and throughout 1944, and was assisted in its deliberations by C.S. Daley, representing the Department of the Interior which was at that time responsible for the government of the Australian Capital Territory. It was Daley who put the notion of a national university on the agenda. The committee's final report, handed to Minister Dedman in October 1944, accepted Coombs' suggestion for a Commonwealth Office of Education, which was set up under R.C. Mills early in 1945. It also stated in strong terms that there was a need for a national centre for higher learning, spelling out government, Pacific affairs, international relations and Australian history and literature as areas to be included. Dedman brought the report to Cabinet early in 1945 and it was referred to a subcommittee of ministers, which in turn referred it to another interdepartmental committee, with Mills as chairman, Coombs, Daley, George Knowles from the Attorney-General's Department, H.J. Goodes from Treasury and Garran present by invitation.

Sir Howard Florey's visit to Australia

In 1943 Sir Howard Florey, an Australian expatriate who was professor of pathology at the University of Oxford, had converted penicillin from a laboratory curiosity into a wonder drug, especially for the types of infections common in battle casualties, and by 1944 it was in use in the Allied armed services operating in Europe. Sir Thomas Blamey, Commander-in-Chief of the Australian Armed Forces, was anxious to see it made available for the Australian forces. Stimulated by Alfred Conlon and R. Douglas Wright of the Army Directorate of Research and Civil Affairs, he persuaded Prime Minister Curtin to invite Florey to visit Australia to advise on the production of penicillin and its use in the army and among civilians. Florey arrived in August 1944 and spent some months visiting all the mainland capitals, several country regions and all the major centres of medical research. From his survey he soon concluded that medical research in Australia was in a parlous state, and said so in public lectures that were widely reported. In response to an invitation from Curtin, Florey developed the idea of a national medical research institute, like the National Institute of Medical Research in London, suggesting that it should be located in Sydney since Melbourne already had a first-class medical research institute (the only one in Australia, in Florey's view), the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute.

The Directorate of Research and Civil Affairs of the Australian Army

Another factor, critical to the ultimate structure of the Australian National University, entered the scene. The Army Directorate of Research and Civil Affairs was a small think-tank headed by Colonel Alfred Conlon, who had direct access to the Commander-in-Chief. Conlon was a charming and charismatic man, without formal medical or military qualifications, who worked closely with R.D. ('Pansy') Wright, professor of physiology in the University of Melbourne and an honorary colonel in the Directorate. As Director-General of Post-War Reconstruction, Coombs made contact with the Army Directorate and found their company and approach congenial. As well as Conlon and Wright, the Directorate included Julius Stone, professor of international law and jurisprudence in the University of Sydney, the poet James McAuley, the anthropologist Bill Stanner and the lawyer John Kerr. Wright, who had worked with Florey in Oxford in 1937-38, held strongly the opinion that Australia had to improve its facilities for medical research so as to prevent so many of its promising research workers making their careers abroad. Conlon, who graduated in medicine after the war, supported him in this view; they were pursuing the idea of setting up a national institute of medical research, located in Sydney, and welcomed Florey's support for this concept.

Because of the illness from which Curtin was eventually to die, Florey was unable to meet him, and the idea of a national institute of medical research was conveyed to Curtin by Blamey, who was himself deeply interested in the promotion of scientific research in Australia (Hetherington, 1954). The idea was referred to the Minister for Health, who set up an expert committee consisting of Sir David Rivett, head of CSIR, J.H.L. Cumpston, the Director-General of Health, and H.J. Goodes of Treasury. The two technically qualified members of the expert committee, Rivett and Cumpston, were unsympathetic to the idea of setting up a new institute, and Cumpston was strongly opposed to any alteration to the existing system for the control of funding for medical research, namely through the National Health and Medical Research Council. However, their opinions were to be over-ruled by the intrigues of the Army Directorate of Research.

The National Medical Research Institute becomes part of the Australian National University

Conlon and Wright had been talking over Florey's ideas between themselves and with Coombs, when it occurred to Coombs that the medical research institute might form a part of the national university then being considered by the interdepartmental committee chaired by Mills, of which he was a member. He took the new idea to the first meeting of the Mills Committee in April 1945, which initially toyed with the idea of an institute of 'social medicine', which would appeal to economists and politicians but had little in common with the sort of medical research of which Florey was thinking. After several more meetings the Mills Committee came back to the ministerial subcommittee with a formal proposal that the government should establish a national university concerned mainly with postgraduate studies and research, with institutes of social sciences and social medicine. The committee had suggested that the new university should be called the University of Canberra, but Cabinet, while accepting the committee's other recommendations, proposed the name 'Australian National University'. Initially this proposal provoked much hostility, but despite representations from the committee of vice-chancellors and all the committees set up to advise on the development of the university, Cabinet insisted on their name, realising that if the university was to survive it had to proclaim its national purpose and demonstrate that it was not duplicating the work of the state universities.

Coombs now took a lead in defining the essential features of the new university. Realising that Cabinet would soon be facing a host of other pressing post-war objectives, he was anxious to get it on the statute books. Using draft legislation that had been prepared for the Canberra University College some months earlier, a detailed proposal was ready for Cabinet by the end of 1945. The core of this proposal was the setting up of the Research Schools. Coombs listed five of these, which after further discussion became social sciences, Pacific affairs, medical research, town and regional planning, and atomic (later nuclear) physics. In Cabinet, 'town and regional planning' was subsumed within social sciences, and there was some doubt about physics, but the other three Schools won acceptance. Panels of five or six experts were then set up by the Mills Committee to comment on such matters as the fields of research within each School, relations between Schools, ways of organizing research, staff numbers and salaries, financial and accommodation needs, and relations with other Australian universities.

Much remained to be done before the final proposals could be put to Cabinet and Parliament. In April 1946 Coombs visited London, Washington and Tokyo with the Prime Minister, Ben Chifley. Conlon and Wright talked with Coombs before he left, urging him to spare no effort to persuade Florey to take on leadership of the John Curtin School of Medical Research. Coombs had also to see whether it would be possible to persuade distinguished Australian expatriates to come back to Australia to head up the other Research Schools, and met and talked with the historian W.K. Hancock, the political scientist K.C. Wheare, the physicists H.S.W. Massey and M.L.E. Oliphant, and the economist R.L. Hall. Chifley met Oliphant, with whom he was greatly impressed. Although somewhat startled by the capital cost of Oliphant's concept of a Research School focused on nuclear physics (over four times the figure originally suggested to Cabinet), he told Coombs, 'If you can persuade Oliphant to head the school we will do whatever is necessary'. Coombs came back highly optimistic, telling the Mills Committee that there were good prospects of enticing Florey and several others of the expatriates whom he had met back to Australia.

Meanwhile, in Australia, the Australian National University Act was introduced in Parliament and gained assent in August 1946, the research schools being entitled Pacific Studies, Physical Sciences, Social Sciences and The John Curtin School of Medical Research. The functions of the University were defined in the Act as:

  1. To encourage, and find facilities for, postgraduate research and study, both generally and in relation to subjects of national importance to Australia;
  2. To provide facilities for university education for persons who elect to avail themselves of those facilities and are eligible to do so;
  3. Subject to the Statutes, to award and confer degrees and diplomas.

Until the Council could be constituted, the University was to be governed by an Interim Council, consisting of members appointed by the Governor-General.

The Interim Council and the Academic Advisory Committee

The Interim Council, which included all the members of the Mills Committee and, through Coombs' influence, R.D. Wright, met for the first time in September 1946, and elected Mills as chairman. It decided to invite Florey, Oliphant and Hancock to advise them on the development of the research schools of medical science, physics and social sciences respectively. Early in 1947 they approached R.L. Firth, a New Zealander who was professor of anthropology at the University of London, to advise them on the Pacific Studies school. All were expatriates who had grown up in Australia (or New Zealand), who had established international reputations in their respective fields and who had expressed an interest in the new research university.

Early in 1947 Wright, who by this time had become Honorary Secretary of the Interim Council, travelled to England to sound out the prospective directors, whom he found had many concerns. After a two-day meeting in London at the end of March, attended by Coombs, Wright and all four prospective directors, only Oliphant was unequivocal in his commitment to come. Wright then produced a strategy to keep the prospective directors interested and informed, but not to press them too hard until progress had been made on the University's buildings and academic structure. He suggested that they should be formally constituted in England as an academic advisory committee, to be serviced by an administrative officer, to advise the Interim Council regarding statutes, budgets, building design, acquisition of books and equipment and the like. Council would act on the recommendation of the Advisory Committee in making appointments, who could work in accommodation in various parts of the world until buildings were available in Canberra.

The Academic Advisory Committee met monthly after its first meeting in Oxford in August 1947, and thereafter every two or three months, usually in Hancock's rooms at All Souls College or in Florey's office at the Dunn School. For a time there was some concern in Australia as to whether the new Australian National University would be run from Oxford or Canberra. There was a great deal of discussion in both places about the kind of person who should be sought as Vice-Chancellor. Coombs was pressed to take the job, but he was too committed to the cause of post-war planning. Eventually, two names surfaced: Sir Douglas Copland, a 53-year-old former professor of economics who was then Australia's Minister to China, and Leslie Melville, who had since 1931 been economic adviser to the Commonwealth Bank. The Advisory Committee favoured Melville but the Council chose Copland, who served as Vice-Chancellor from 1 May 1948 to 30 April 1953; in November 1953 he was succeeded by Melville.

Oliphant's proposals for the Research School of Physical Sciences

Following their meeting in 1946, Coombs advised Chifley that Oliphant would come to Canberra only if he could do work of the same quality and standing as he was then doing in Birmingham. This would mean a capital cost of some £500,000 over five years, much more than Chifley had anticipated, but Coombs thought that if Oliphant's needs could be met there was a good chance of attracting Florey and Hancock (Adviser to the Research School of Social Sciences) as well.

The Academic Advisers met in Canberra in Easter 1948. Oliphant, who alone of the group had made up his mind to come to Canberra, outlined his plans for the Research School of Physical Sciences. In contrast to Florey, who proposed that the medical research school should cover a wide range of topics, Oliphant saw himself as the director of a school that would focus on his interests, namely research in fundamental nuclear physics and the chemistry of radioactive substances. At the meeting in Canberra he added a chair in theoretical physics, and before Oliphant took up duties as Director in 1950 the School grew by the addition of Richard Woolley, the Commonwealth Astronomer, and the Mount Stromlo Observatory as a Department of Astronomy.

Florey's proposals for the John Curtin School of Medical Research.

Florey liked the idea that his 'national institute of medical research' would become part of a research university, but realised that this raised problems about the role of the director, whom he now saw as a chairman of professors, who would try to achieve some uniformity of aim and some common standards of performance. He would provide the oil to lubricate the machine, he would watch carefully to ensure that no department would build itself into 'a little independent kingdom', he would encourage the departments to work together. Clearly, the director's position would be 'one of delicacy'.

After the Easter conference Florey met for two days with sixteen senior medical scientists from all over Australia, to try to dispel what he saw as the 'fairly widespread and somewhat justified' distrust of the idea of a research-only Australian National University. In this he had some success, his 1945 proposal for additional funding for research outside the new institute being appreciated. Florey's plan for a diversified research school, covering a wide range of disciplines, was well received.

Recruitment of staff commenced in 1948, and by 1950 the University had eleven professors, five readers and ten junior academic staff on its books.

Coombs on the University Council, 1946-1976

Coombs was a member of the Interim Council, and from the establishment of the Council in 1951 he was successively Deputy Chairman from 1951 to 1959, then Pro-Chancellor, a position created especially for him, and, after the death of the third Chancellor, Florey, in 1968, Chancellor. The first three Chancellors, Lord Bruce, Sir John Cockcroft and Lord Florey, were based in England. Although they were able to represent the University at ceremonial functions in Britain, help with senior appointments and occasionally visit Canberra, they were only rarely able to perform the most important of the non-ceremonial duties, namely presiding over meetings of the Council. This task fell to Coombs, and kept him continually involved with University affairs. His appointment as Chancellor in 1968 coincided with his impending retirement from the Reserve Bank, and he was able to give more time to the task, which he relinquished when he retired from the public service in 1976. After fifteen years of silence on University matters, however, Coombs spoke with vehemence and conviction at a rally in December 1991 to 'save the JCSMR', which, following a report by the Stephen Committee of Review, was threatened by a take-over by the National Health and Medical Research Council, a move that was seen as a threat to the continued existence of the University itself.

Among the initiatives in the ANU that can be directly ascribed to Coombs are the New Guinea Research Unit, established in 1957 and handed over to the autonomous Papua New Guinea Institute of Applied Social and Economic Research when the Territory won independence in 1975, the Creative Arts Fellowship Scheme, set up in 1964, and the North Australia Research Unit (NARU), set up as an outreach of the Research School of Pacific Studies in 1973.

Views on science and technology

Coombs' views on science and technology are outlined in his keynote address to a conference convened by the Academy of Social Sciences in Australia, the Australian Academy of Science and the Australian Academy of Technological Sciences in April 1979, entitled 'Science and Technology for What Purpose? An Australian Perspective'. This makes interesting reading even now, twenty years after it was written. He starts with a comment on the title, which he suggests implies that science and technology are directed to a single and common end. While acknowledging that this is the way politicians, bureaucrats, businessmen and even many scientists tend to justify the activities of scientists, Coombs notes that this is a recent development. As he puts it, 'there is science for understanding and science for manipulation'. He considers that science as a search for understanding does not need to be justified by the greater power it confers on mankind; rather, it is akin to the creative work of artists and, as a source of enlightenment and liberation, 'a noble expression of the human spirit'. 'A society which fails to give it opportunity and scope will thereby be the poorer'.

He goes on to deal at length with science as a substrate for technology, and emphasises that science for manipulation must be justified by its results, and should be required to demonstrate that the benefits it confers on mankind outweigh the costs: material, social and spiritual. Already, in 1979, he recognizes but deplores the growth of 'mammoth industrial corporations' that are dominated by market forces and focus on optimizing production, with little concern for the social or environmental aspects of their activities. Twenty years later we see these tendencies being vastly increased by the drive towards globalization. In answer to a question, he reiterated his support for creative science, but thought that manipulative science needed 'to reconsider its objective, to reorient to some degree its directions, and, particularly, to examine its impact upon the human and social aspects of society'.To use a phrase now in common parlance among environmentalists, development needs to have concern for three 'bottom lines', economic, social and environmental.

Research in social sciences

Coombs also stimulated research in the social sciences, for example by arranging for the Commonwealth Bank to set aside a portion of its profits as a fund for university-based research in economics. Much of the work that was carried out by consultants for the Royal Commission on Australian Government Administration incorporated original research. His Boyer Lectures in 1970 are a mature expression of his thoughts on the problems of institutionalizing intellectual creativity of all kinds, in the arts, the social sciences and the natural sciences. Some years later, in 1984, he persuaded the Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies to co-sponsor, with the Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, the University of Western Australia and the Stegley Foundation, the East Kimberley Impact Assessment Project. This was a multidisciplinary and policy-relevant programme carried out to assist Aboriginal people to deal with economic and social changes arising from resource development. It resulted in the production of 25 working papers and a book (Coombs et al., 1989), which provide information that remains relevant to the solution of some of the problems faced by Aboriginal Australians.

Interest in environmental problems

At a time when most economists ignored the environmental costs of the modern consumer society, Coombs realised that economic growth had generated substantial environmental problems. He first spoke about these concerns in a lecture to a symposium at the Twelfth Pacific Science Congress in Canberra in 1971 (Coombs, 1972). On his retirement in 1976 he became a Visiting Fellow at the Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies at the Australian National University, and for the next twenty years mixed daily with academics concerned with environmental problems. His concern for problems of conservation were underlined by his acceptance of the position of President of the Australian Conservation Foundation between 1977 and 1979. As a result, he became 'increasingly conscious of long-term structural changes in our own and the world economy – especially those arising from the interaction of ecological and economic concerns'. In 1990 he published his 1971 address and seven other papers on this topic that had been produced between 1978 and 1985, together with a chapter outlining his views in 1989, as a book, The Return of Scarcity: Strategies for an Economic Future (Coombs, 1990).

Visiting Fellow, Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies,1976-1996

The Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies (CRES) was established in 1973, with Frank Fenner as Director. Initially housed in the old Nurses' Home near the John Curtin School, early in 1976 it moved to occupy the upper two floor levels of the newly constructed Life Sciences Library Building. In May that year, after negotiations with the Vice-Chancellor (Sir John Crawford) and the Director, Coombs was appointed a Visiting Fellow in CRES, an appointment that was subject to annual reappointment based on his current intellectual, cultural and social contributions. On moving in, his appearance was transformed from that of the clean-shaven public servant, wearing coat and tie, to a bearded academic in open-neck shirt and pullover, as illustrated in the two full-page photographs of him on the front and the back pages of the book by Foster and Varghese (1996).

Coombs applied himself with vigour to promoting the cause of Aboriginal Australians. From 1989 he spent several months each winter at the North Australia Research Unit (NARU), which he had long before been instrumental in setting up in Darwin as an outpost of the ANU. In 1991 this arrangement was formalized so that his visiting fellowship was held jointly at CRES and NARU. He published extensively, in books (3, 5, 7, 8 and 10), reports, learned journals and newspaper articles, as illustrated in the select bibliography at the end of Aboriginal Autonomy (Coombs, 1994) and the publication list provided at the end of this memoir. In late 1995, while at NARU, he had a disabling stroke from which he never recovered.

Personal characteristics

From his earliest days in government office, Coombs was known as a 'controlled, low-key sagacious servant of the people'. His vision had been greatly influenced by the Great Depression of the 1930s, which imprinted on his mind the suffering of the under-privileged, to which he reacted with compassion and concern. When, after his appointment to the Council for Aboriginal Affairs in 1968, and especially after his retirement from the public service, he learnt more of the abysmal condition of many Aboriginal Australians, he became a passionate advocate for these disadvantaged people.

Besides having great influence in public affairs by virtue of the many influential positions he held, Coombs was an éminence grise, who worked behind the scenes to achieve results that would serve all Australians. He was a confidant of leading Australians in the arts, in science, in public affairs and in politics. As described in his book Trial Balance (Coombs, 1981), he was personal adviser to seven Prime Ministers, from Curtin to Whitlam, and for such a very busy man he was a prolific writer, producing no fewer than nine books and many published lectures and feature articles in the press.

On the lighter side, he had made a reputation as a rover in Australian Rules football in his youth (his nickname 'Nugget' derived from that), he remained a committed cricket fan all his life, and he regularly played squash into his early 80s. He was an excellent cook and he loved good wine, especially a good red.

Honours and awards

Coombs consistently refused to accept an imperial honour; he told his old teacher Sir Walter Murdoch that such an honour would not be 'in character'. When the Order of Australia system was instituted in 1975, he was among the first to be awarded its highest honour, Companion of the Order of Australia. However, in 1976, incensed by the introduction of a knighthood (AK), he resigned from the Order.

He was appointed a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1969, and was a Foundation Fellow of both the Australian Academy of the Humanities and the Academy of Social Sciences in Australia. He also received a number of honorary degrees: Hon. LLD (ANU, Macquarie, Melbourne, Sydney), Hon. DLitt (WA), and in 1961 he was appointed an Honorary Fellow of the London School of Economics. In 1963 the Royal Society of Arts (London) awarded him the R.B. Bennett Commonwealth Prize for services to 'banking, economics and the arts', in 1972 the newspaper The Australian named him as their first 'Australian of the Year' and in 1977 he was awarded the ANZAAS Medal at the 48th Congress of the Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science.

In 1962 the Coombs Building, housing the Research School of Social Sciences and the Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies of the Australian National University, was named after him. In 1992 funds were collected for a Nugget Coombs Forum at the North Australia Research Unit and in 1998 the University established the Nugget Coombs Aboriginal Studies Scholarship Scheme, to provide support at the North Australia Research Unit for undergraduate and postgraduate scholars who combined traditional academic disciplines with traditional indigenous knowledge.

He was given a state funeral and a service of thanksgiving was held in St Mary's Cathedral in Sydney on 14 November 1997. He wanted it known that the choice of a Catholic church should not be taken as a sign of a death-bed conversion, but because his wife Lallie would have delighted in it. Somewhat later he was accorded full Aboriginal funeral rites, with scattering of half of his ashes at Yirrkala in the Northern Territory, the only white person to have been so honoured. On 11 March 1999 the other half of his ashes were scattered on the garden at University House, where had lived for so many years. He was survived by three sons and one daughter.

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, Vol.13, No.1, 2000. It was written by:

  • F. Fenner, John Curtin School of Medical Research, Australian National University,Canberra, ACT 0200, and
  • S.F. Harris, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian NationalUniversity, Canberra, ACT 0200.

Acknowledgments

We are grateful to Professor H.A. Nix and Dr Tim Rowse for reading over the manuscript and making useful suggestions and to Ms Sigrid McCausland, Ms Ettie Oakman and Dr R. May for providing information. The photograph was taken by Bob Cooper, Coombs Photography, ANU. 

References

  • Coombs, H.C. (1971). Other People's Money: Economic Essays. Australian National University Press, Canberra.
  • Coombs, H.C. (1981). Trial Balance. Macmillan, Melbourne.
  • Coombs, H.C. (1994). Aboriginal Autonomy. Cambridge University Press, Melbourne.
  • Coombs, H.C., McCann, H., Ross, H. and Williams, N.L. (eds.) (1989). Land of Promises: Aborigines and Development in the East Kimberley. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, and Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra.
  • Foster, S.G. and Varghese, M.M. (1996). The Making of the Australian National University. Allen and Unwin, Sydney.
  • Hetherington, T. (1954). Blamey: The Biography of Field-Marshal Sir Thomas Blamey. Cheshire, Melbourne.
  • Rowse, T. (1997). The Paraguay Round? The rationales and fortunes of H.C. Coombs' approach to Australian trade diplomacy, 1942-8. In: 50 Years of Australia's Multilateral Trade Diplomacy and the Road Map for the Future. Australian National University, Canberra

Bibliography

The organization of a publication list for Coombs presents problems not encountered in the preparation of biographical memoirs of scientists. During his life as a public servant and, after his retirement, as a champion of the rights of Aboriginal Australians, Coombs produced many reports for government bodies and the like, gave many speeches and produced many newspaper articles. Below we have listed the books he wrote or edited, with commentaries on some of them, and then, by year, articles published as chapters in books and journals or as pamphlets listed in the catalogue of the Australian National Library. We have not included any of his many newspaper articles, nor sought to discover memoranda and reports that he produced as a public servant. 

Books and articles

Books

  1. Coombs, H.C. (1970). The Fragile Pattern – Institutions and Man. The Boyer Lectures, 1970. Australian Broadcasting Commission, Sydney, 59pp.
  2. Coombs, H.C. (1971). Other People's Money: Economic Essays. Australian National University Press, Canberra, 190pp. Based on fifteen addresses and papers presented or published between 1949 and 1968, during his term as Governor of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia and subsequently of the Reserve Bank of Australia.
  3. Coombs, H.C. (1978). Kulinma: Listening to Aboriginal Australians. Australian National University Press, Canberra, 250pp. Sixteen articles of varying length, produced between 1968 and 1977, twelve of them during Coombs' chairmanship of the Council for Aboriginal Affairs.
  4. Coombs, H.C. (1981). Trial Balance. Macmillan, Melbourne, 341pp. An autobiography covering Coombs' working life as a Commonwealth public servant between 1942 and 1976.
  5. Coombs, H.C., Brandl, M.M. and Snowden, W.E. (1983). A Certain Heritage: Programs for and by Aboriginal Families in Australia. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, 461 pp.
  6. Coombs, H.C. (1990). The Return of Scarcity: Strategies for an Economic Future. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, in association with the Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University. CRES Monograph No. 9, 171pp. A collection of essays, most based on addresses given to various audiences in Australia.
  7. Coombs, H.C., McCann, H., Ross, H. and Williams, N.L. (eds.) (1989). Land of Promises: Aborigines and Development in the East Kimberley. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, and Aboriginal Studies Press, Canberra, 165pp.
  8. Coombs, H.C. (edited by D. Smith) (1994). Aboriginal Autonomy, Issues and Strategies. Cambridge University Press, Melbourne, 251pp. Essays written by Coombs for various occasions since 1978, when Kulinma was published. Contains a select bibliography of writings by Coombs on issues regarding Aboriginal Australians, including many newspaper articles not entered in the publication list below.
  9. Coombs, H.C. (1994). From Curtin to Keating: the 1945 and 1994 White Papers on Employment: a Better Environment for Human and Economic Diversity? North Australia Research Unit, Australian National University, Darwin, 65pp.
  10. Coombs, H.C. (1996). Shame on Us!: Essays on a Future Australia. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 93pp.

Articles/book chapters

1944
  • Coombs, H.C. The economic aftermath of war. In: Campbell, D.A.S. (ed.) Post-War Reconstruction in Australia. Australasian Publishing Company, Sydney, pp. 67-120.
1948
  • Dunk, W.E. and Coombs, H.C. Report on Council for Scientific and Industrial Research: Organization, Administration and Related Problems. Australian Government Printing Service, Canberra.
1955
  • Coombs, H.C. The Development of Monetary Policy in Australia. University of Queensland Press, Brisbane.
  • Coombs, H.C. Central banking in Australia. Bankers' Magazine of Australasia, 69, 61-68.
  • Coombs, H.C. Economic development and financial stability. Economic Record, 31, 183-191.
1957
  • Coombs, H.C. Staff training in the Commonwealth Bank. Personnel Practice Bulletin, 13, 46-50.
1958
  • Coombs, H.C. Conditions of Monetary Policy in Australia. R.C. Mills Memorial Lecture, University of Sydney Department of Economics, Sydney.
  • Coombs, H.C. Banking in a developing economy. Bankers' Magazine of Australasia, 71, 142-147.
1959
  • Coombs, H.C. Rural Credit Developments in Australia. Australian Agricultural Economics Society, Sydney.
1961
  • Coombs, H.C. Balance of payments problems – old and new style. Bankers' Magazine of Australasia, 75, 36-41.
1962
  • Coombs, H.C. Other People's Money. Sir John Morris Memorial Lecture, Adult Education Board of Tasmania, Hobart.
1963
  • Coombs, H.C. Some Ingredients for Growth. Edward Shann Memorial Lecture, University of Western Australia, Perth.
1965
  • Coombs, H.C. Pennies and policies: a Reserve Bank in New Guinea. New Guinea, 1, 62-69.
1966
  • Coombs, H.C. Training for development. Economic Activity in Western Australia, 9, 8-12.
  • Coombs, H.C. Training central bankers. Far Eastern Economic Review, 53, 494-496.
1967
  • Coombs, H.C. Capital, Growth and International Payments. Australian Industries Development Association.
1969
  • Coombs, H.C. Science and the future of man: the role of the social scientists. Australasian Annals of Medicine, 4, 329-334.
  • Coombs, H.C. Does banking legislation need to be overhauled? Austfact, 1, 14-18.
  • Coombs, H.C. Central banking – a look back and forward. Economic Record, 45, 485-495.
1970
  • Coombs, H.C. The economics of the performing arts. Economic Papers, The Economic Society of Australia and New Zealand, 35, 32-46.
1971
  • Coombs, H.C. Changing economic and social perspectives in resource management. In: Costin, A.B. and Frith, H.J. (eds.) Conservation. Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, pp. 284-299.
1972
  • Coombs, H.C. Matching ecological and economic realities. Journal of the Economic Society of Australia and New Zealand, 48, 1-17. Also published as Australian Conservation Foundation Occasional Publication No. 9.
  • Coombs, H.C. The Future of the Australian Aboriginal. The George Judah Cohen Memorial Lecture, Sydney.
1973
  • Coombs, H.C. Ecologist and entrepreneur – Is reconciliation possible? In: Industry and the Environment. Science and Industry Forum Report No. 6, Australian Academy of Science, Canberra, pp. 7-11.
1974
  • Coombs, H.C. Decentralization trends among Aboriginal communities. Search, 5, 135-43.
1976
  • Coombs, H.C. Aboriginal Australians 1967-76: A Decade of Progress? Walter Murdoch Lecture, Murdoch University, Perth.
1977
  • Coombs, H.C. The Pitjantjatjara Aborigines: A Strategy for Survival. CRES Working Paper No. 1. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 53pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. The Quality of Life and its Assessment. Paper given at the Sixth Conference of Economists, University of Tasmania. Occasional Paper 11, University of Tasmania, Hobart.
  • Coombs, H.C. The Application of CDEP in Aboriginal Communities in the Eastern Zone of Western Australia. CRES Working Paper No. 3. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 15 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Report of the Royal Commission on Australian Government Administration. Government Printer, Canberra, 483pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. The Commission Report. In: Hazlehurst, C. and Nethercote, J.R. (eds.) Reforming Australian Government: The Coombs Report and Beyond. Royal Institute of Public Administration, Canberra, pp. 49-52.
  • Coombs, H.C. The future bureaucracy. In: Hazlehurst, C. and Nethercote, J.R. (eds.) Reforming Australian Government: The Coombs Report and Beyond. Royal Institute of Public Administration, Canberra, pp. 53-57.
1978
  • Coombs, H.C. Implications of land rights. In: Jones, R. (ed.) Northern Australia: Options and Implications. Research School of Pacific Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, pp. 121-129.
  • Costin, A.B. and Coombs, H.C. Australian conservation. Nature, 274, 528.
  • Coombs, H.C. Australia's Policy towards Aboriginals 1967-1977. Minority Rights Group Report No. 35, London.
  • Coombs, H.C. Some Aspects of Development in Aboriginal Communities in Central Australia. CRES Working Paper No. 5. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 59 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Scarcity, Wealth and Income. Presented when President of the Australian Conservation at Hobart, Tasmania, October 1978. CRES Working Paper No. 7. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 16 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Submission to the Commission on the Walpiri Land Claim. CRES Working Paper No. 8. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 34 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Implications of Land Rights. CRES Working Paper No. 9. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 15 pp. Reproduced in Coombs, H.C. (1994) Aboriginal Autonomy.
  • Coombs, H.C. Aggression and the Aboriginal environment. In: Aggression: Second Australian -Asian Pacific Congress of the Australian Academy of Forensic Sciences, Sydney. Also published as CRES Working Paper No. 6. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 9 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Aboriginal nutrition and the ecosystems of Central Australia: Summing-up. Aboriginal Nutrition , 2, 2-3.
  • Coombs, H.C. 'President's Report'. In Australian Conservation Foundation Annual Report 1977-78. Australian Conservation Foundation, Melbourne.
1979
  • Coombs, H.C. Science and technology for what purpose? In: Healy, A.T.A. (ed.) Science and Technology for What Purpose? Australian Academy of Science, Canberra, pp. 21-47. Also published as CRES Working Paper No. 12. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra.
  • Coombs, H.C. Is Democracy Alive and Well? CRES Working Paper No. 10. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 19 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Aboriginal Land Rights Teach-in. CRES Working Paper No. 11. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 9 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Guest of Honour Talk: Australian Broadcasting Commission. CRES Working Paper No. 13. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 5 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. The Proposal for a Treaty Between the Commonwealth and Aboriginal Australians. CRES Working Paper No. 14. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 9 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. 'President's Report'. In Australian Conservation Foundation Annual Report 1978-9. Australian Conservation Foundation, Melbourne.
1980
  • Coombs, H.C. The future of the outstation movement. In: Coombs, H.C., Dexter, B.G. and Hiatt, L.R. (eds.) The Outstation Movement in Aboriginal Australia. Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies Newsletter 14, 16-23. Also published as CRES Working Paper No. 15. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 9 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. The impact of uranium mining on the social environment of Aborigines in the Alligator Rivers region In: Harris, S.F. (ed.) Social and Environmental Choice: The Impact of Uranium Mining in the Northern Territory. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, pp. 122-135. Also published as CRES Working Paper No. 18.
  • Coombs, H.C. Signing an Australian peace treaty. Social Alternatives, 1, 63-64.
  • Coombs, H.C. Economic change and political strategy. Chamberlain Lecture, University of Western Australia. CRES Working Paper No. 19. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 26 pp.
1981
  • Coombs, H.C. Yirrkala Law Council. Social Alternatives, 2, 36, 60.
  • Costin, A.B. and Coombs, H.C. Farm planning for resource conservation. Trees and Victoria's Resources, 24, 21-22.
  • Coombs, H.C. Comment: Farm planning for resource conservation. Search, 12, 429-430
1982
  • Coombs, H.C. On the question of government. In: Berndt, R.M. (ed.) Aboriginal Sites, Rights and Resource Development. Proceedings of the Fifth Academy of the Social Sciences in Australia Symposium, Canberra 1981. University of Western Australia Press, Perth.
  • Coombs, H.C. The case for a treaty. In: Olbrei, E.K. (ed.) Black Australians: The Prospects for Change. James Cook University Students Union, Townsville, pp. 57-60.
  • Coombs, H.C. The three waves of Aboriginal identity. Aboriginal Treaty News, 4, 9.
  • Coombs, H.C. Technology, income distribution and the quality of life. Search, 13, 142-147.
1983
  • Coombs, H.C. The Yirrkala Proposals for Law and Order. CRES Working Paper No. 1983/11. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 14 pp. Reproduced in Coombs, H.C. (1994) Aboriginal Autonomy.
  • Coombs, H.C. Economic, Social and Spiritual Factors in Aboriginal Health. CRES Working Paper No. 1983/16. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 14 pp. Reproduced in Coombs, H.C. (1994) Aboriginal Autonomy.
  • Coombs, H.C. The economic and social impact of nuclear war for Australia and its region. In: Denborough, M. (ed.) Australia and Nuclear War. Croom Helm Australia, Canberra, pp. 119-135.
1984
  • Coombs, H.C. The Role of the National Aboriginal Conference. Report to the Hon. Clyde Holding, Minister for Aboriginal Affairs. Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra, 147pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. John Curtin: a consensus Prime Minister? John Curtin Memorial Lecture, Australian National University. Arena, 69, 46-59.
1985
  • Coombs, H.C. The Yirrkala proposals for Law and order. In: Hazlehurst, K.M. (ed.) Justice Programs for Aboriginal and other Indigenous Communities; Australia: New Zealand, Canada, Fiji and Papua New Guinea. Proceedings of the Aboriginal Criminal Justice Workshop No. 1, 29 April-2 May, pp. 201-205. Australian Institute of Criminology, Canberra.
  • Coombs, H.C., Bin-Sallik, M.A., Hall, F.L. and Mottison J. Report of Commission of Inquiry into Aboriginal Employment and Training Programs. Australian Government Printing Service, Canberra.
  • Coombs, H.C. Where do we go from here. In: Wright, J. (ed.) We Call for a Treaty. Collins and Fontana, Sydney, pp. 284-307.
  • Coombs, H.C. Resource management and environmental law. Paper presented to Environmental Law Association Symposium, Hobart, 1985. Published in Coombs, H.C. (1990). The Return of Scarcity: Strategies for an Economic Future. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 97-117.
1986
  • Coombs, H.C. Towards Aboriginal independence. In: Foran, B.P. and Walker, B.W. (eds.) Science and Technology for Aboriginal Development. Centre for Appropriate Technology, Alice Springs, pp. 38-43.
  • Coombs, H.C. Sustainable society will need a new ethic of responsibility. Habitat, 14(1), 29-31.
  • Coombs, H.C. The predecessors. In: The Whitlam Phenomenon. McPhee Gribble/Penguin, Fitzroy, pp. 41-59.
1988
  • Coombs, H.C. Aborigines and the Treaty of Waitangi. Boyer Lecture No. 6, Australian Broadcasting Commission, Sydney. Reproduced in Coombs, H.C. (1994) Aboriginal Autonomy.
1989
  • Coombs, H.C. Aboriginals and the Treaty of Waitangi. Land Rights News, 2(12) 18-20.
  • Coombs, H.C. Science and technology: for what – or for whom? Current Affairs, 56(4), 4-15.
1990
  • Coombs, H.C., Dargavel, J., Kesteven, J., Ross, H., Smith, D.I. and Young, E. The Promise of the Land: Sustainable Use by Aboriginal Communities. CRES Working Paper No. 1990/1. Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, 19 pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Aboriginal Employment: The Underlying Issues. Report to the Commissioner, Mr P. Dodson, Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody. Reproduced in Coombs, H.C. (1994) Aboriginal Autonomy.
  • Coombs, H.C. Aboriginal Education, Socialisation and the Underlying Issues. Report to the Commissioner, Mr P. Dodson, Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody.
1991
  • Coombs, H.C. Aborigines Made Visible: from 'Humbug' to Politics. Kenneth Myer Lecture. Friends of the National Library of Australia, Canberra. Reproduced in Coombs, H.C. (1994) Aboriginal Autonomy.
  • Coombs, H.C. Aborigines and Development in the Northern Territory. State Library of the Northern Territory, Occasional Paper No. 24.
1992
  • Coombs, H.C. Banana republic? No, banana colony. Australian Business Monthly, March, 26-29.
  • Coombs, H.C. A sundered country. Australian Business Monthly, April, 50-52.
  • Coombs, H.C. Miners still in dreamtime. Australian Business Monthly, April, 50-52.
  • Coombs, H.C. Black deaths – who has custody. Australian Business Monthly, June, 126-128.
  • Coombs, H.C. Towards a new federation. Australian Business Monthly, July, 146-148.
  • Coombs, H.C. Multifunction parks. Australian Business Monthly, September, 138-140.
  • Coombs, H.C. How the West was won. Australian Business Monthly, November, 74-77.
  • Coombs, H.C. Signing an Australian peace treaty. Social Alternatives, 6/7, 63-64.
1993
  • Coombs, H.C. Aborigines and development in northern Australia. Occasional Paper No. 24, North Australia Research Unit, Darwin.
  • Coombs, H.C. Science and technology – for what purpose? Questioning the future. Occasional Paper No. 3, Commission for the Future, Canberra.
  • Coombs, H.C. Issues in Dispute: Aborigines Working for Autonomy. Published jointly by the North Australia Research Unit, Australian National University, and The Age and The Canberra Times, 52pp.
  • Coombs, H.C. Willowra. Published jointly by the North Australia Research Unit, Australian National University, and the Nugget Coombs Forum for Indigenous Studies.
  • Coombs, H.C. Independence or bust. Australian Business Monthly, January, 60-63.
  • Coombs, H.C. Who owns the intelligentsia? Australian Business Monthly, February, 116-119.
  • Coombs, H.C. Grasping the Mabo options. Australian Business Monthly, August, 38-41.

Henry Robert Wallace 1924–2011

Professor Harry Wallace FAA was a nematologist who pioneered research into how nematodes move through soil and interact with plants, providing the blueprint that controlled Australia's devastating cereal cyst nematode.

Image Description

Harry Wallace was born in Lancashire, England on 12 September 1924 and died at Murray Bridge, South Australia on 26 July 2011. 

He had a distinguished career, as a scientist at the University of Cambridge, Rothamsted Experimental Station and CSIRO's Division of Horticulture, and as Professor of Plant Pathology at the University of Adelaide. He was internationally recognised for his pioneering work on the movement of nematodes and for his work on the interactions between nematodes, the environment and the plant. 

He made a major contribution to Australian agriculture by providing a blueprint for research needed to understand cereal cyst nematode, which was a major pest that significantly reduced yield. The blueprint led to efficient methods of disease control.

Download the memoir

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 23(2), 2012. It was written by Allen Kerr, Kerrie Davies, and Graham Stirling.

Henry Oliver Lancaster 1913–2001

Henry Oliver Lancaster made landmark discoveries linking UV radiation to melanoma and rubella to congenital deafness, while transforming mathematical statistics.

Image Description
Henry Oliver Lancaster 1913-2001

Henry Oliver Lancaster (1913–2001) was a pioneering Australian statistician and medical scientist. 

His most celebrated medical contributions include the first quantitative demonstration that melanoma rates increased closer to the equator due to UV radiation, and a groundbreaking study establishing the causal link between rubella infection during pregnancy and congenital deafness. 

As Foundation Professor of Mathematical Statistics from 1959 to 1978, he made major theoretical advances in the decomposition of the chi-square statistic and the theory of bivariate distributions, work that was incorporated into leading international statistical textbooks. 

He was also a prolific historian and bibliographer of statistics and medicine, producing the vast scholarly work Expectations of life (1990) among many other publications. 

He was elected a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1961, awarded the Lyle Medal, and appointed an Officer of the Order of Australia in 1992.

Download the memoir

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 15(2), 2004. It was written by:

  • E. Seneta, School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Sydney. Eugene Seneta, FAA, succeeded H.O. Lancaster as Professor and Head of Mathematical Statistics at the University of Sydney in 1979. Denoted by 'ES' in the sequel.
  • G.K. Eagleson, Australian Graduate School of Management, University of New South Wales. Geoff Eagleson was one of Lancaster's first PhD students in Mathematical Statistics (PhD, University of Sydney, 1967).

Harold George Raggatt 1900–1968

Geologist Sir Harold Raggatt CBE FAA helped transform Australia’s understanding of its mineral wealth and laid foundations for modern resource development.

Image Description
Harold George Raggatt 1900-1968

Harold George Raggatt was born at North Sydney on 25 January 1900. He had an elder brother and three younger sisters. Though the family lived at Lindfield, Harold Raggatt went to the Gordon State School where the headmaster, known as 'Cocky' Fry, had a particular enthusiasm for English expression which laid the foundation for Raggatt's continued emphasis on the value of speaking and writing good English.

Raggatt's mother was born in Swansea, Wales, and came to Australia with her parents; she was married in Australia. Wanting Harold to become a scientist or engineer, she had him enrolled at the Sydney Technical High School, a true secondary school which used by day the facilities that the Sydney Technical College used at night. He thus had access to the best high school facilities in New South Wales, and on matriculation he enrolled for a science course at Sydney University.

Mathematics, physics and chemistry were compulsory subjects: one other subject could be chosen. Raggatt was influenced in selecting geology by the reputation and personality of Professor Edgeworth David, who however was then serving with the AIF in France.

Raggatt was so taken with the optional subject, geology, that he made it his major subject. With one eye on his textbooks and the other eye on the war news he did well enough in his first year but, having in mind that his brother was fighting in France, Raggatt enlisted in the AIF a few days after his 18th birthday in January 1918. He went overseas in March 1918 with his unit, the 13 Field Company Engineers, but by the time his training was finished and he had reached France the war had ended.

In France he came into contact with German prisoners of war and seized the opportunity to improve his already sound knowledge of German. He could have gone on to Cologne with the Army of Occupation or to Cambridge to complete his geology course. Instead he preferred to return to Australia to resume his studies at Sydney University.

Arriving home in the second half of 1919 he was discharged only in time to attend third-term lectures and, like many another soldier, found it hard to settle down to the routine of undergraduate life. However he graduated with First Class Honours in Geology in 1922, and later in that year joined the New South Wales Public Service as a geological surveyor. He was the first university graduate for 30 years to join the Geological Survey of the New South Wales Mines Department, which had a tradition that geologists should be trained more or less on the job; it is not surprising therefore that at first he was regarded with some suspicion as being too academic.

In January 1927 Harold Raggatt married Edith Hellmers, a graduate in geology who had been a fellow student at Sydney University. Though they made their home at Epping, his work took him into the field for long periods, particularly in the Scone, Muswellbrook, Bathurst and Condobolin districts, and during the field season the family accompanied him and lived in those towns. They had one daughter, Marcia (now Mrs J.V. Lindesay), also a science graduate of Sydney University, who has one daughter and one son.

For the Geological Survey of New South Wales Harold Raggatt carried out field assignments in the districts referred to above: these included systematic geological mapping in several areas of the state, particularly in the Hunter Valley, Trunkey-Tuena district, Condobolin, Cadia, Coonabarabran and Bobadah. His maps are amongst the best examples of regional geological mapping within Australia up to that time. It has to be remembered that aerial photographs were not available then, and that geologists had to plot their observations on parish and other maps and necessarily spent a large part of their time in surveying work and in building up their own topographic base map as they went along.

It was in the course of this field work that Raggatt developed the love of field geology and the appreciation of the importance of systematic geological mapping that always influenced his attitude to mineral resources development. Twice during this period he obtained leave from the Geological Survey of New South Wales to carry out field assignments with oil exploration companies. On the first occasion he undertook in 1925 a geological reconnaissance of part of the Aitape district of the Mandated Territory of New Guinea on behalf of the Pacific Islands Investment Company of Sydney. During continuous field work from March to August, with no reliable map of the area on which to base this survey, it was first necessary to draw a reconnaissance map of the entire area. The positions of the more important villages were fixed using theodolite and star observations in conjunction with wireless time signals for the determination of longitude. Intermediate points were fixed by joint time traverses and occasional prismatic compass traverses. Aneroid readings were used for altitude determinations. This was one of the earliest geological surveys for oil in New Guinea, and surveys have been carried on with greater or less intensity ever since.

The second assignment, in which Raggatt was associated with Eric Rudd and the late Dale Condit, was with Oil Search Ltd. in Western Australia, when in 1934–35 a part of the Carnarvon Basin, then known as the North-West Basin, was mapped. Because his interest in the oil potential of the Carnarvon Basin was then generated, this assignment was to have a far-reaching effect on the development of oil exploration in Australia. This resulted in the selection of this area for the Bureau of Mineral Resources' first programme of systematic geological mapping after World War II. The establishment of [an] additional geological section in this area and also in the Kimberleys, where work was commenced shortly afterwards, played a vital part in influencing the companies which later became associated as West Australian Petroleum Limited to take up prospecting permits over the area and eventually to the drilling of the Rough Range No. 1 bore, Australia's first real oil strike.

From June to August 1937 Harold Raggatt, with Ken Mosher as assistant, made a survey of the geological features of the upper parts of the gorges of the Chandler, Oaky, Styx and George Rivers. This was made primarily to assist the state to choose dam sites and sites for power stations. This was the first time that Raggatt had used aerial photographs in a geological survey: he became most enthusiastic about their usage in geological work, and about the time saved in traversing and in plotting the results. It was also one of the earliest occasions when geologists were able to influence the selection of dam sites before design and construction of structures were undertaken.

During his period with the Geological Survey of New South Wales Raggatt was able to continue postgraduate studies with Sydney University; he was awarded the degree of Master of Science in 1932, and of Doctor of Science in 1939 for a comprehensive stratigraphical and structural study of the evolution of the Permo-Triassic basin of East-Central New South Wales. Though his thesis was not published it is one of the standard works on the geology of the Hunter Valley area, and is very frequently quoted.

Before World War II the geological advice to the Commonwealth Government was provided by the Commonwealth Geological Adviser, a Commonwealth Oil Advisory Committee, and the Commonwealth Palaeontologist. The Commonwealth Geological Adviser, Dr W.G. Woolnough, was also an early pupil of Professor Edgeworth David. In 1939 Raggatt applied for the position of Assistant Commonwealth Geological Adviser and was selected by Woolnough for this post; this involved moving to Canberra. Dr Woolnough himself retired in 1940 and Raggatt became Commonwealth Geological Adviser.

Almost immediately the wartime demand for strategic materials emphasised the need for a comprehensive minerals inventory of Australia, and Raggatt was able to assemble for this purpose a small group consisting mainly of geologists from the New Guinea and Commonwealth Services, geophysicists from the former Aerial, Geological and Geophysical Survey of Northern Australia, some Commonwealth geologists who had been working in the Northern Territory, and the Commonwealth Palaeontologists. This group became the Mineral Resources Survey (which eventually developed into the Bureau of Mineral Resources, Geology and Geophysics), and Raggatt's title was changed from Commonwealth Geological Adviser to Director, Mineral Resources Survey. In 1941 the group moved from the Department of the Interior to the Department of Supply and Development, which later became the Department of Supply and Shipping.

The objectives of the Mineral Resources Survey, as formulated by Raggatt and approved by the Government, were the survey, evaluation and development of the mineral resources of Australia, and, in conjunction with other departments and agencies, to study ways and means of utilising those resources. Its immediate attention was turned to the development of deposits of minerals required in the Allied War effort, minerals that were in short supply, or materials which formerly had been imported but which no longer could be obtained from overseas. Intensive work was carried out on a number of deposits which were either being brought into production or on which production was being increased considerably to meet the wartime requirements.

This was important work: projects included the development of Lakes Entrance oil, gas from the Balmain Colliery, the Arcadia oil-bore, Leigh Creek coal, sources of bauxite, sulfur, fertiliser minerals, mica, asbestos, fluorspar, wolfram, tin, bismuth, mercury, molybdenum, cobalt, zirconium and titanium minerals, antimony, chromium, manganese, cadmium, and iron ore. The Survey was concerned with the investigation of sources of these minerals to the point where measures for actual production were to be undertaken: production came under the Controller of Minerals Production, who worked closely with the Mineral Resources Survey and indeed shared an office and filing facilities with it in Canberra.

The Minerals Production Directorate was established in 1941 by the Commonwealth Government which on 21 March of the same year had set up a 'Copper and Bauxite Committee' 'to investigate the copper and bauxite resources of Australia with a view to their development'. Members of that committee were Sir Colin Fraser, Chairman; Dr H.G. Raggatt, Vice-Chairman; A.J. Keast, M.J. Martin, J.M. Newman and H.J. Horsburgh, with M.A. Mawby as Technical Adviser. Under its auspices several reports were prepared, and early in 1942 its title was changed to 'Commonwealth Minerals Committee', with functions 'to advise the Government and the Controller of Minerals Production on ways and means by which the output of strategic minerals might be increased in Australia to meet the needs, not only of Australia, but of the United Nations'. G. Lindesay Clark joined the committee and was appointed Deputy Controller of Minerals Production. Julius Kruttschnitt later became a member. This committee appears to have been phased out during 1944, after it became apparent that the Allies' foreseeable needs for strategic minerals were assured.

Of the many activities in which Raggatt was involved as a member of the Minerals Committee and as Director of the Mineral Resources Survey, one that turned out not to be so successful is worthy of special mention – the Lakes Entrance Shaft. During the war the Government paid special attention to Australian sources of petroleum, or petroleum substitutes, and every effort was made to investigate potential local supplies including Lakes Entrance, the only place in Australia up to that time where oil, albeit in small quantity, had actually flowed to the surface. In 1941, on the advice of the United States Bureau of Mines, L. Ranney and C. Fairbanks, who were reputed to have expert knowledge of methods of developing underground liquids by shaft sinking and horizontal drilling were brought to Australia to investigate the possibility of production by this method at Lakes Entrance. They strongly recommended that a shaft be sunk and a series of horizontal drill holes be put out from a chamber at the bottom of the shaft to develop the oil-bearing bed: they estimated that by this means a recovery of 1,160,000 barrels of oil could be obtained, consisting of 15% light oil, 72% lubricating oil, and 13% bitumen. Raggatt, who at that time had perforce to take risks, supported their recommendation, which turned out to be unsoundly based. Not enough oil was present, nor in fact had the technique or horizontal drilling under such conditions been actually demonstrated to be feasible. The shaft was sunk to 1,156 feet – very slowly, for a variety of reasons – but was not carried to completion and no production was achieved. The project was terminated early in 1946, the only tangible benefit being a magnificent geological section through the highly fossiliferous Miocene sediments that overlie the oil-bearing sand.

After the war J.M. Newman resigned as Controller of Minerals Production and Raggatt took over the position until the Directorate was wound up. Previous to this, on 8 September 1944, a Mining Industry Advisory Panel had been set up, consisting of H.G. Raggatt, Chairman; A.J. Keast, I.M. Newman, G. Lindesay Clark, G.B. O'Malley, F.B. Brinsden, A.J.P. Walter, F.C. Smith M.L.A. (W.A.), T.M. Jude (A.W.U.), with F. Canavan as secretary. Later the permanent heads of the State Mines Departments were added to the Panel, whose terms of reference were to examine all phases of prewar mining activities (excluding coal and oil), the wartime developments, the current condition of the industry and its problems, and to present advice leading to a sound Commonwealth post-war mining policy. Among its recommendations were that an Australian Mining Council comprising State and Commonwealth Ministers should be created, and that a Commonwealth Bureau of Mines should be set up. The first proposal, although it received ministerial approval, was not actually proceeded with at the time. The second one included a recommendation that Raggatt, together with J.M. Rayner, then Chief Geophysicist of the Mineral Resources Survey, should make a visit to the United States and Canada in 1945, largely to examine the organisation of the Geological Surveys and associated agencies of those countries. Their report laid the foundation for the setting up in 1946, instead of the proposed Bureau of Mines, of the Bureau of Mineral Resources, Geology and Geophysics, with Raggatt as its first Director. About this time – in May 1946 – in accordance with the wishes of his Minister, R.G. Casey, Raggatt moved the headquarters of the Bureau and the Geophysical Section to Melboume, while the Geological Section remained in Canberra, to which city Raggatt was to return in 1951 as Permanent Head of the Department of National Development.

Although various attempts had been made to establish a Commonwealth Geological Organisation ever since Federation, now for the first time the Commonwealth Government had a geological body with Raggatt at its head available for ready consultation on mineral resources and to promote its objectives in developing the mineral industry. The Bureau, which was to become an established part of the Australian scene, has played a major part in the geological mapping of Australia, in the search for oil and mineral deposits, and in the expansion of the mineral industry. It is one of the largest and most efficient organisations of its kind, ranking with some of the major geological surveys of the world.

In 1951 Raggatt accepted the post of Secretary of the Department of National Development, though he felt some reluctance at leaving the Bureau of Mineral Resources and direct contact with and participation in geology. However he was not a man to let an opportunity go by, and the possibilities of achieving the national objectives as Secretary of the Department were obviously very much greater than those which had been available to him as Director of the Bureau of Mineral Resources.

Raggatt saw Australia as a country with great natural resources and welcomed the opportunity to assist in the economic development of those resources, particularly mineral resources. He was convinced that geological conditions that were favourable for the deposition of oil existed in some Australian sedimentary basins, a conviction which had been confirmed by what he had seen in the United States and Canada in similar structures. He was optimistic that commercial oil would be discovered in Australia. He was one of the few geologists at that time who held this view, and he held firmly to the belief that the proper way to go about the search for oil was to start with systematic mapping of the sedimentary basins to determine the full stratigraphic sequence and the structures. He was also aware that the search for oil in Australia up to that time had been a somewhat haphazard affair and that drilling had not been based on proper scientific investigation.

By this time the Bureau of Mineral Resources was well established and had embarked upon its systematic surveys. However Raggatt soon found that he had undertaken a still more difficult task in trying to get the comparatively new Department of National Development on its feet: indeed he comments about this period:

The Department had a very inauspicious beginning. Its functions were ill-defined especially in relation to those of other departments. Its possible incursion into the affairs of other departments was viewed by them with considerable suspicion and there were many who thought the department would be short-lived. I was shocked to realise what I had taken on compared with what I had expected – Sir William Spooner, the new Minister, was likewise somewhat dismayed. We had to accept that not only was the concept of a Department of National Development rather difficult to fit into the Commonwealth departmental structure, but we also had to recognise the Loan Council procedures and the general financial arrangements between the States, we had to recognise also the sovereign powers of the States and the functions and capacities of their departments and authorities. It is clear however, that there are many aspects of development on which the information available to the Commonwealth was deficient and that if the Department set about establishing itself as an Authority on those matters other departments would be glad to consult it and seek its views. Inevitably also the Government would come to look to the Department for advice on those matters.

The Department was not well equipped even for the limited roles Sir William Spooner and I saw for it. It did of course include the Bureau of Mineral Resources which indeed was the Department's main strength. Some other branches were lopped off and gradually it gathered strength, collecting information about resources and producing specialised maps in an Atlas of Resources. We survived the early days and began to prosper. Because our work in the resources, fuel and power fields had become recognised the Minister was gradually given the responsibility for those Commonwealth authorities concerned with power, fuel and resources.

To its original responsibility for the Snowy Mountains Authority and the Joint Coal Board were added Australian Atomic Energy Commission, the Aluminium Production Commission (from the Department of Supply) and the Minister became President of the River Murray Commission. The logical corollary to the recognition of the Department's role was that other agencies concerned with mapping and resources should be transferred to the department and in due course we acquired the Division of National Mapping and the Forestry and Timber Bureau. The Northern Division was formed in 1963. It was the first section with a new kind of function which fits the pattern from now on. It has a positive responsibility for development.

During his first years as Secretary of the Department, Raggatt devoted a great deal of his time, energy and patience to the difficult and delicate task of negotiating the Snowy Mountains Agreement for the utilisation of the waters impounded by the Snowy scheme. He was Chairman of the Interim Snowy Mountains Advisory Council from its inauguration in 1953. When this was replaced by the Snowy Mountains Council he continued as Chairman until his retirement in 1965. The Snowy Mountains Authority was responsible for the construction of the Scheme, the Snowy Mountains Council was responsible for its operation. He was Deputy Chairman of the Australian Atomic Energy Commission from 1957 to 1965.

In the early 1960s one of his major interests was the establishment of the Australian Water Resources Council, and from 1963 until his retirement he was Chairman of the Standing Committee and ex-officio Chairman of the three technical committees, on surface water, underground water, and research and education respectively. Other posts he held included membership of The Coal Utilization Research Advisory Committee, The Council of the Australian Mineral Development Laboratories and The Export Development Council.

In 1965, when an honour was bestowed upon him by Australian colleagues, he said:

It happened that many things in which I was interested came to fruition in the closing years of my public service – discoveries of enormous quantities of bauxite and iron ore, large quantities of manganese, the discovery of the first commercial oilfield in Australia, the promise of large scale development of natural gas, the setting up of the Australian Mineral Development Laboratories, the Australian Water Resources and Forestry Councils and the National Coal Research Advisory Council.

There have been generous references to my contribution to these events. I am pleased to have had a hand in working out policies and procedures which have led to some of them.

In the Department of National Development we have urged that the Government contribution to discovery and the measurement of natural resources should be basic and systematic; and I think we can say we have been successful in convincing Governments that this is the right approach. As a result we now have a complete air photo cover of Australia, a nearly completed series of base maps at 1:250,000 scale, a steadily growing series of geological maps at the same scale, mineral statistics equal to those of any other country; a plan, with finance guaranteed, to establish a basic network of stream gauging throughout Australia in 10 years and to increase the rate of assessment of underground water resources. In all these undertakings I am glad to say that the States are our friendly partners.

Throughout all his demanding and wide-ranging activities Raggatt retained a close interest in geology – both in its application and in the teaching. He was a co-opted member of the Council of the Canberra University College and in 1960 was elected to the Council of the Australian National University.

Harold Raggatt was a member of the Geological Society of Australia; Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy; the Royal Society of New South Wales; Linnean Society of New South Wales; Society of Economic Geologists; American Association of Petroleum Geologists; Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science; and the Royal Institute of Public Administration.

With a small group of interested stratigraphers in Melbourne he was responsible for setting up the Australian Code of Stratigraphic Nomenclature, and remained Convenor of the Committee established first under ANZAAS, later under the Geological Society of Australia, to administer the Code, until its use by Australian geologists became firmly established. As part of this project he initiated a scheme for establishing a stratigraphical index of Australian geology. He always had some special geological interest and was an active member of the Commonwealth Territories Division of the Geological Society.

In the years 1946 to 1951 when he was living in Melbourne he spent a considerable amount of time at weekends and on vacation studying the Tertiary stratigraphy of southern Victoria and demonstrated the importance of careful sampling of strata as a basis for the determination of the stratigraphic ranges of fossil genera and species.

After his retirement from the Commonwealth Public Service in January 1965 Raggatt continued to play a very active part in the mineral industry. He accepted advisory positions with those Australian companies and organisations where he felt he could continue to make contributions in mineral exploration. These included the Broken Hill Proprietary Co. Ltd. (mineral exploration), the A.M.P. Society (mining investment), Ampol Exploration Ltd. (director), and the Australian Atomic Energy Commission (consultant). When the Australian Mining Industry Council was formed he was elected its first Vice-President. He made two visits to Africa in a consultative capacity on behalf of the United Nations, one to Botswana in 1967 advising on the Shashi River Development project and mineral development, and the other to Ethiopia in 1968, advising the Government on its minerals policy and the setting up of a Geological Survey. The report he presented to the United Nations on his mission to Botswana is regarded as something of a masterpiece. It was drawn up on the spot. In 1965, at the invitation of the Chase Manhattan Bank, he visited the US to take part in a seminar on Australian Development: many of the 200-odd American bankers and businessmen assembled were frankly incredulous when they heard his account of Australia's mineral resources.

During these very productive years before his death from a heart attack on 2 November 1968 he produced one book, 'Mountains of Ore', an authoritative description of the history, economics and present state of development of Australia's mineral deposits, was compiling editor of another, 'Fuel and Power in Australia', and worked on various papers and addresses.

In recognition of his work Raggatt received many honours. He was awarded a CBE in 1954 and a Knighthood in 1963. Elected a fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1954, he served as Treasurer in 1956 and Vice-President in 1956–7. The Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy elected him to Honorary Membership in 1961 and in 1965 granted him its major award, the Institute Medal, for his outstanding contribution to the exploration and development of Australian mineral resources. He was made an Honorary Member of the Geological Society of Australia in 1964. In 1947 and again in 1958 he was President of Section C (Geology) of the Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science.

Coming to more personal matters, Harold Raggatt was an impressive man physically as well as intellectually. Rugged of build, bright of eye, suntanned, and in his later years crowned by a shock of steel grey hair, he was alive and alert, acutely conscious of what was going on, quick to laugh and ever ready to join in a discussion. If there is one phrase to describe him best, it is that he was a man of action: never could he be dull. As a young man he played first grade tennis in Sydney; later he expended incredible energy in geological exploration; and when the move to Canberra came he gave the same detailed attention to his home and garden as had brought success to his outback expeditions. He and his wife had earlier designed their furniture; now they planned and built their Canberra home, with terraces, hedges, gardens and an orchard. Raggatt's powers of concentration carried him through long hours of mental work: these domestic activities he enjoyed – for him they provided the exercise and relaxation that he needed.

Raggatt knew Australia as few know their country. He loved it: his interests went far beyond his chosen subject, overlapping into plant life, the birds and animal life of all kinds. He had to be physically tough in the early years; strength of character guided his later days.

In these later years his canvas broadened, but the inevitable stresses never weakened his sense of values, his sense of justice, his sense of fair play. He had to distinguish between the genuine mining entrepreneur and the charlatan; he encouraged the former and discouraged the latter, and he was so good a judge of character that his decisions were rarely if ever astray. He became as well known to Commonwealth and State Ministers as to geologists, mining executives and bankers: they welcomed his advice, knowing it to be objective and impartial. Naturally he formed and expressed strong views, but his integrity was never in question.

People listened when Raggatt spoke: he could oppose a viewpoint objectively, and with that sense of humour that checks the incipient feud.

Raggatt was not a man to suffer fools gladly. Where praise was due it was given, but where advice or criticism was necessary it was also given, quite forcefully but with that touch of grace that made the recipient grateful. His command of English was excellent: he spoke with unusual clarity, had a flair for the picturesque and the vivid, and could infuse just the right amount of lightness into the serious debate.

One of his colleagues has said of him:

For all his achievements Harold Raggatt was a modest man, notable for his infinite good humour, patience and cheerful companionship, and down-to-earth good sense. He was a man of understanding, of great integrity and with a deep sense of the national interest.

Despite his heavy responsibilities Raggatt enjoyed life to the full and retained a boyish enthusiasm to the end. He died before he aged. Very few men are willing or able to embrace so many worthwhile activities so effectively and with such enthusiasm and wisdom as did he. Fewer still in any one generation have both the opportunity and the capacity to serve their country so well.

Raggatt's wife and his daughter survive him. To them we extend our sympathy, and hope that they may take comfort from his impressive record of achievements, to which no doubt they contributed.

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Records of the Australian Academy of Science, vol. 2(3), 1972. It was written by:

  • John Maxwell Rayner OBE BSc, who was Director of the Bureau of Mineral Resources, Geology and Geophysics, Canberra 1958–69 and Deputy Director 1952–58.
  • Sir Ian William Wark Kt CMG CBE DSc, who was a member of the Executive of CSIRO 1961–65 and first Director of the CSIRO Chemical Research Laboratories 1958–60. He was elected a Fellow of the Academy in 1954 and was a Counsellor and Treasurer, 1959–63.