Donald Metcalf 1929–2014
Donald Metcalf was a colossus of science who introduced cancer research to the Walter and Eliza Hall of Medical Research, and spent 60 years making discoveries in haematology that changed cancer care for millions of patients worldwide.
Written by D. Hilton, W. Alexander and N. Nicola.
26 February 1929–15 December 2014.
Once more unto the breach, dear friends, once more,
Or close the wall up with our English dead!
In peace there's nothing so becomes a man
As modest stillness and humility,
But when the blast of war blows in our ears,
Then imitate the action of the tiger:
Stiffen the sinews, summon up the blood.— King Henry, Henry V (Shakespeare)[1]
Donald Metcalf – Don to most everyone with whom he worked – was a colossus of science who, working at the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute and supported by the Cancer Council of Victoria from 1954 to 2014, stood astride the world of haematology (the study of blood cells) for 60 years.
The achievements of Don, the scientist, are legion. Don introduced cancer research to the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute at a time when its Director, the Nobel Prize winner Sir Frank MacFarlane Burnet, viewed cancer as an "inevitable disease", with "anyone who wants to do cancer research, either a fool or a rogue".
Don politely ignored him.
Studying leukaemia in 1964, Don and Ray Bradley, from The University Of Melbourne, discovered it was possible to grow bone marrow cells in plates of partly set agar jelly. Don's genius lay not in this breakthrough, but in the realisation that it could be used to understand the cellular basis of blood cell production and to discover the hormones, which he named colony-stimulating factors, that regulate blood cell production in the body.
Don worked single-mindedly on this theme for the next 50 years. He characterised blood stem cells and their daughters cells, which are committed to producing the multiple types of white blood cells that fight infection and prevent bleeding. In doing so he made the blood cell system the 'poster child' of medical research and shone a light into the darkness for those who followed him to work on understanding other tissues such as the breast, skin and colon.
Don also understood his limitations. Although he was comfortable with cells, he was wary of molecules such as DNA and protein. Nevertheless, Don knew he needed collaborators who would take him out his comfort zone and help him fulfill his ambition of delivering health benefits from his discoveries and so he assembled a team of researchers who worked with him for 40 years. Don's ability to identify a glimmer of talent in younger researchers and mold them into a cohesive, loyal and vibrant team that consistently came up with groundbreaking discoveries, was remarkable. Decades ahead of its time, his model of collaborative, multidisciplinary science shaped the culture of the Walter And Eliza Hall Institute and is now seen as almost mandatory if big problems are to be tackled and significant breakthroughs are to be made in medical science.
After two decades of dogged progress, Don and his team succeeded in the Herculean task of isolating four of the blood CSFs, which were present in tiny quantities in the body. Despite Don's profound fundamental discoveries, which shaped basic understanding of how blood cells are made and work, he always recognised and espoused the responsibility of medical research to help those suffering illness and disease. Isolation and cloning the CSFs paved the way for their mass-production and clinical testing. Don found that injection of the hormones into animals resulted in a rapid increase in the number of blood cells responsible for battling infection and he surmised that they might be used to help cancer patients overcome one of the major side effects of chemotherapy: a loss of white cells and susceptibility to life-threatening infection. Don's hunch about clinical use was proven true – over the past 20 years, more than 20 million cancer patients, including Spanish tenor José Carreras, have been treated with CSFs and, as a result, have been given the best possible chance of beating their cancer. CSFs are now standard treatment and every year the number of people alive because of Don's work grows. There can be no greater legacy for a medical researcher.
Remarkable though his scientific achievements were – more than 750 scientific papers, 21 patents and receipt of almost every major international prize in medical research, they give only a skeletal outline of the man.
Don was practical – he eschewed the modern trend of senior researchers to move permanently from the laboratory to oversee a large team from the safety of an office. He was a man of scientific action. Many a young researcher was left with ears ringing after a spray from Don that would make John Kennedy senior's 1971 half-time grand final address to his Hawthorn players ("At least DO SOMETHING! DO! Don't think, don't hope, do!") seem like polite encouragement.
Don was hard working. He led from the front and expected his team to follow. From the day he entered medical research, until he was diagnosed with cancer four months ago, he would begin work early, between 7.00 am and 7.30 am either doing experiments or writing scientific papers solidly until 5.30 pm; his only compromise being a lunchtime or mid afternoon finish on Saturday. Upon a new recruit starting in his unit, it was mandatory for them to meet with Don who, at least until the mid 1990s, would be smoking a cigar, and would lull you with a question like "have you had a good holiday" – inviting a response like, "yes thank you Professor Metcalf, I have had a lovely two weeks camping at Wilson's Promontory" – which was then followed by "excellent, that's the last holiday you will have for three years, get to work". And it was the last holiday you took, not because Don would stop you taking leave, but because his hard work was infectious and the lab would become your world.
Don was loyal. He was loyal to the Walter And Eliza Hall Institute – working there almost continuously for 60 years from 1954 to 2014, despite lucrative offers from all over the world. Don enjoyed the tyranny of distance, which he believed made it easier for Australian scientists to pursue highly original research, away from the latest trends and fads. Don was steadfastly loyal to the four directors, under whom he worked and sometimes disagreed. His attitude approached a US-style respect for the office of the President. Although deeply suspicious and somewhat intolerant of people he called "prancers" or "strutters" once you had proven yourself to be practical, thoughtful, reliable, hardworking and collaborative, you were 'in'. Being 'in' meant a draft of a scientific paper would come back from Don's office with more red ink than black type. It meant you could be mercilessly interrogated about your science during a seminar or excoriated over some minor antisocial laboratory behavior. Being 'in' meant you would be defended to the hilt in front of visitors or other groups. You became part of the team. There was no greater honour.
Don was human – he was no uncaring science machine. He loved banter over afternoon tea, often laughing until tears streamed down his face, at some silly anecdote or remark. He loved an annual week on the Sunshine Coast with his wife, which included body surfing, into his late 70s, on waves of any size. He enjoyed a meal and a glass of wine with friends. And more than anything he loved his family – his wife of more than 60 years, Josephine (Jo), his four daughters and his six grandchildren, meant everything to him. He knew, and often publicly acknowledged, that without them he would have achieved little of note.
Other than a bad back, which was exacerbated by endless hours, days, weeks, months and years bent at the microscope, Don enjoyed relative good health until August this year. Feeling under the weather, he went on leave hoping some time away from the laboratory would rejuvenate him. He returned feeling worse and was quickly diagnosed with metastatic pancreatic cancer. Knowing the likelihood of cure was not high, his priorities were to undertake some treatment to give him a few extra weeks or months so as to avoid letting down his collaborators and, most importantly, to spend as much time as possible with his beloved Jo and his daughters – but how to do both of these things? The solution for the scientist and family man until the end – have his microscope moved into his home. Don performed his last experiment in October and died surrounded by his family on 15 December 2014. He would have wanted it no other way.
About this memoir
This memoir was written by:
- Professor Douglas Hilton FAA, Director of The Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research
- Professor Warren Alexander and Professor Nicos Nicola FAA, Heads of The Division of Cancer and Haematology, The Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research
Notes
[1] This was one of Don's favorite passages, the other being Tennyson's The charge of the light brigade. Don's autobiography was entitled Summon up the blood: In dogged pursuit of the blood cell regulators (AlphaMed Press, Dayton, Ohio, USA, 2000. ISBN 1-880854-28-7).
Donald Eric Weiss 1924–2008
Don Weiss devoted his career to applying science and technology for the benefit of the Australian economy. On the way, he made important contributions to separation science, carbon chemistry, polymer science and process engineering.
Don Weiss was born in the Melbourne suburb of St Kilda on 4 October 1924 and died in Melbourne on 30 July 2008. He was educated in South Australia, at Scotch College, the South Australian School of Mines and Industry, and the University of Adelaide.
He joined the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) in 1948 and worked for CSIR and its successor organisation, CSIRO, until his retirement in 1984. He was the Chief of the CSIRO Division of Chemical Technology from 1974 to 1979 and Director of CSIRO's Planning and Evaluation Advisory Unit from 1979 to 1984.
He was a highly imaginative and creative scientist whose work was always driven by his clear understanding of its application. He made important contributions to separation science but is best known for his contributions to technology for water and waste water treatment. His enduring legacy is the more than twenty MIEX plants that have been installed around the world.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 22(1), 2011. It was written by Thomas H. Spurling, Institute for Social Research, Swinburne University of Technology.
David Roderick Curtis 1927–2017
Pioneering neurophysiologist Professor David Curtis AC FAA FRACP FRS identified GABA and glycine as inhibitory neurotransmitters and laid the groundwork for L-glutamate's acceptance as the brain's key excitatory transmitter.
David Curtis was a pioneer in the identification of excitatory and inhibitory transmitters released at synapses in the central nervous system. He made major contributions to the identification of gamma-amino butyric acid (GABA) and glycine as inhibitory transmitters released at inhibitory synapses. His work laid the foundation for the subsequent acceptance that L-glutamate was the major excitatory transmitter. David’s scientific work led to him receiving many accolades and honours, including Fellowships of the Australian Academy of Sciences, the Royal Society and a Companion of the Order of Australia.
Download the memoir
Supplementary material
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 31(2), 2020. It was written by Stephen J. Redman and Robert Porter.
David Parker Craig 1919–2015
David Craig was an outstanding Australian theoretical chemist and served as President of the Academy 1990–94.
David Craig was an outstanding Australian theoretical chemist whose academic life oscillated between Australia (University of Sydney and Australian National University (ANU)) and the UK (University College London). The Craig Building of the Research School of Chemistry of the ANU was named in his honour in 1995. He was President of the Australian Academy of Science from 1990 to 1994, and the Academy's David Craig Medal, which recognizes outstanding contributions to chemistry research, was inaugurated in his honour. His best-known research is in the fields of quantum theory and spectroscopy of aromatic molecules, molecular crystals, quantum electrodynamics and chirality.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 28(2), 2017. It was written by Noel S. Hush and Leo Radom.
David James Kemp 1945–2013
David James Kemp was a molecular biologist and parasitologist best known for his pioneering malaria research. He co-developed key techniques like Northern blotting and was instrumental in launching the malaria genome project.
David Kemp's seminal contributions to molecular parasitology of malaria and scabies have placed Australian science at the forefront of research on these important human pathogens. Immunoscreening of expression clones led to the identification of several vaccine candidates against malaria. His contributions to scabies research are pivotal to our understanding of bacteria–parasite–human interactions.
Other notable achievements are: the discovery of one of the earliest known multi-gene families; the first cloning of linked variable-region genes in the immunoglobulin heavy-chain locus; the invention of highly cited molecular biology methods, namely Northern blotting and inverted-PCR; and contributions to ‘molecular public health' by his work on various bacterial infections relevant to the health of Indigenous Australians.
Kemp's manifest enthusiasm for science was highly infectious. He mentored many high-achieving scientists. In addition to his exemplary career as a scientist, he was a musician at heart and a passionate rock fossicker.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 25(2), 2014. It was written by Kadaba S. Sriprakash, and Michael F. Good.
David Forbes Martyn 1906–1970
Dr David Martyn FAA FRS was a physicist, wartime radar chief and Foundation Fellow at the Australian Academy of Science. His research contributions transformed our understanding of the ionosphere and upper atmosphere.
Introduction
David Forbes Martyn was born on 27 June 1906 at Cambuslang, Scotland, the son of Dr Somerville Martyn. He was educated at Plymouth College and Allan Glen's School before entering the Royal College of Science in London. He graduated BSc, ARCSc, in 1926, obtained his PhD from that institution in 1929, and the DSc in 1936. The great depression was on its way when he graduated and research posts were very difficult to obtain.
The Australian Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) had concentrated its work from its inception in fields of importance to the primary industries, since the export of wool, wheat and some other products of the land, earned virtually the whole of Australia's overseas income. It was surprising, therefore, that John Madsen, Professor of Electrical Engineering in the University of Sydney, was able to persuade CSIR to establish research in radio, through a Radio Research Board modelled on the British body with the same name, as the first departure from its original policy. His proposals were put forward in 1926. Following a conference and ministerial approval, the Australian Radio Research Board was established in 1927, and after the squabbles inevitable at that time, it set to work, with Madsen as Chairman, and a sum of £2,250 included in CSIR's estimates for 1927–29 for radio research. David Martyn was among the first four research officers appointed by the Board, with a salary of £450 p.a..
Research activities
Before leaving Britain for Australia, Martyn worked on the stability of the triode oscillator, publishing three papers on this problem. He also developed a new method for measuring extremely small alternating currents. Upon arrival in Australia he submitted to the Radio Research Board two detailed proposals for his work. The first was that an attempt should be made to observe the reflection of very high frequency radio waves from the moon; the second was the suggestion that Appleton's frequency-change method of studying the ionosphere might be modified by transmitting continuous saw-tooth shaped frequency sweeps. The Board arranged for him to work in the Physics Department of the University of Melbourne, with Professor T.H. Laby, but after a year he joined other members of the Board's staff in Sydney. His second proposed project had been approved by the Board and was developed there. He soon discovered that it involved a subtle fallacy, and abandoned it to concentrate on echo-pulse sounding techniques. However, this abortive investigation proved important for the subsequent development of radar in the United Kingdom (see section on wartime activities).
In 1934 Martyn collaborated with V.A. Bailey in a theoretical explanation of the newly discovered 'Luxembourg Effect', where, under certain conditions, the modulation of one radio wave becomes imposed on that of another. They showed that this was due to a non-linear effect in the ionosphere. This explanation of the "interaction of radio waves" was quickly accepted and their paper on the subject is now classical.
In 1935 Martyn collaborated with A.L. Green in a paper which showed that the effective reflection point of radio waves in the ionosphere sometimes moved quite rapidly. This appears to be the first discovery of moving disturbances in the ionosphere, a topic on which a large literature now exists. In that same year he developed a theorem relating equivalent height and reflection coefficient at oblique incidence to that at vertical incidence. This is now known as "Martyn's Theorem" .
This work was concerned with various aspects of the propagation of radio waves via the ionosphere, an understanding of which is essential for the provision of a satisfactory country-wide broadcast system. In this he worked in close collaboration with the Postmaster General's research staff responsible for such broadcasting. The study involved fading and its causes and remedies, and included measurements of the polarisation of the downcoming waves and how this might be utilised, in conjunction with a complex receiving antenna system, to improve reception.
He also widened the scope of his researches beyond the ionosphere to the study of all properties of the upper atmosphere above the stratosphere. Prior to that date the generally current view of the highest part of the atmosphere was that it consisted of hydrogen, and was very cold and still. There was however, evidence (from sound-ranging and meteor studies) that there might be a region at about 50 km that was slightly warmer than the stratosphere. In a now classical paper ('The temperatures and constituents of the upper atmosphere') communicated to the Royal Society of London by Lord Rutherford, the revolutionary views were put forward:
- that there must be a second still colder stratosphere at about 80 km – the coldest region in the whole atmosphere
- that above 80 km the temperature rose steadily to values of the order of 1000°C
- that the atmosphere at heights of up to at least 300 km consisted mainly of nitrogen, with a substantial proportion of oxygen
- that these upper regions were not still, but were subject to high velocity winds and turbulence.
This paper, which was highly commended by Rutherford, aroused vigorous discussion when read at the Royal Society.
All the conclusions mentioned above have been substantially confirmed by later workers, notably by numerous post-War rocket and satellite flights. It is no exaggeration to say that this paper, of itself, transformed all subsequent thinking on almost all aspects of the high atmosphere.
Towards the end of the War, Martyn recommenced his fundamental researches, at Mount Stromlo Observatory, Canberra, opening up the study of solar tidal effects in all regions of the ionosphere, and of lunar effects in the upper (F2) region. This work comprised, in the first place, a detailed statistical analysis of an enormous body of data in the form of equivalent heights of the ionospheric layers. The results were the magnitudes and phases of the tidal effects in the various layers which, for the first time, were accurately determined. These were later related by Martyn and others to the theories of tides caused by solar heating and lunar gravitation, the outcome being a greatly improved understanding of these effects.
Later Dr Martyn demonstrated the great variety and importance of electrodynamic effects in the ionosphere. It had long been recognised that at low levels where the density and collision frequency were relatively high, the gas could be treated as a conducting fluid, whose passage across the field lines induces an electric field. However, at greater altitudes, where the ion gyro-frequencies are much greater than their collision frequencies with neutral molecules, the ions are firmly fastened to magnetic field lines and do not move with the neutral molecules. They are caused to move by electric fields which are induced at the lower levels and conducted up magnetic field lines. This bi-polar drift, in turn, causes a drag on neutral molecules and so creates winds at the high levels. This basic work has subsequently been confirmed and extended to the earth's magnetosphere. Dr Martyn also pointed out that the magnetic equatorial anomaly (low F2 peak electron density) was almost certainly due to electrodynamic elevation of ionisation at the magnetic equator, coupled with diffusion down the geomagnetic force lines to latitudes on either side. This explanation is currently accepted. Finally, these electrodynamic investigations were adapted to the extension of the earlier work on small-scale moving disturbances. There was an error in the initial work in the conclusion that ion drift around a local inhomogeneity would lead to accumulation of ionisation in a particular region; in fact it leads to a wave motion. However, this work stimulated much further theoretical investigation, notably at the Cavendish Laboratory, a field of activity which is now very extensive.
In 1946 Martyn noted that bursts of solar radio waves were associated with sunspot activity. He concluded that such bursts almost certainly emanated from sunspot regions and that they would be circularly polarised. Accordingly he devised an experimental technique which immediately showed that certain radio radiations from active sunspots were circularly polarised. This discovery has opened up an entire field of research.
Because of close contact with solar astronomers, Martyn became aware of the structure of the corona and of its probable temperature (1,000,000 °C). He thereupon worked out the thermal radio radiation likely to be received from the solar corona and chromosphere. In particular he calculated that the sun would show a base thermal radiation corresponding to 1,000,000 °C at metre wavelengths; at shorter wavelengths a lower temperature running down to the chromosphere temperature of 10,000 °C; and that limb brightening should be observed at wave lengths of 60 cm downwards. All these predictions have been confirmed experimentally, and Martyn's work stands, not merely as the explanation of results already found, but as a prediction of what was eventually found experimentally. In his paper on this subject. Martyn referred to the 'Quiet Sun', a term chosen to indicate absence of spots on the solar surface. This term has now passed into international usage, as for instance the IQSY, the International Years of the Quiet Sun (1964–1965).
In 1882 Balfour Stewart suggested that the diurnal geomagnetic variations were due to electric currents in the upper atmosphere, produced by the dynamo action of solar tidal winds in a conducting region in the presence of a magnetic field. Subsequent calculations by Schuster, Chapman and Cowling had apparently shown that the conductivity of the ionosphere was inadequate to account for the necessary currents. In 1948 Martyn suggested that the necessary conductivity was present if account was taken of the Hall effect. In 1953 he worked this out in detail in collaboration with W.G. Baker, and established that the world-wide conductivity of the ionosphere was adequate to explain the diurnal geomagnetic variations, and also that it explained the electrojet at the magnetic equator, which he had already attributed to specially enhanced conductivity in that region.
In later works Martyn made the first clear study of the morphology of storm geomagnetic variations in the ionosphere, and suggested a theory of their occurrence which is still under active investigation.
In 1956 Martyn pointed out that current rocket estimates of air density in the high atmosphere were in conflict with those derived from observations of ionic diffusion at the 300 km level. He drew attention again to this matter in a talk before HRH the Duke of Edinburgh in a symposium held by the Royal Society of Victoria on 3 December, 1956. In October, 1957, the first sputnik was launched; it came to earth in a time consistent with Martyn's calculations; upper atmosphere densities have since been revised by a factor of 14.
Martyn established the Upper Atmosphere Section of CSIRO, in 1957, at Camden, New South Wales.
Wartime activities
In early 1939, following political negotiations with Britain about the newly developed techniques of radar, Martyn was chosen to follow up with a more technical study. He found that the secret radar work being developed under Sir Robert Watson Watt was using pulse techniques. On the other hand, the Royal Aircraft Establishment (Farnborough), with Sir Edward Appleton's support, was pressing an alternative development using continuous frequency change, and there was serious argument whether a substantial part of the country's effort should not be diverted to this alternative, which appeared likely to be more efficient. The files on the matter were shown to Martyn, who recognised at once that the latter involved the fallacy which he had himself found earlier in the decade, but had not published. Watson Watt and Appleton accepted his reasoning immediately, and no further attempt was made to divert a part of Britain's defence effort into this channel. He returned to Australia in August, 1939, reporting en route to the Cabinet of the New Zealand Government upon these secret developments.
Shortly after reaching Australia, he reported to the wartime Cabinet. Very rapid agreement was reached that CSIR should set up a Division of Radiophysics, with Martyn as its Chief.
A Radiophysics Laboratory was established just before the outbreak of war in an enlarged part of the Standards Laboratory, situated in the grounds of the University of Sydney. Its earliest members, later to become group leaders, were J.H. Piddington (radar systems design), J.L. Pawsey (basic research), H.J. Brown (laboratory services). The initial efforts were directed towards adapting British equipment to use in Australia, but it was soon realised that this equipment was quite unsuitable for conditions here. The first new system designed was called Shore Defence Radar, for detecting and accurately locating surface vessels. This system was successfully integrated with the 9.2 inch and 6 inch coast defence guns, and although these played little part in the war, the day and night warning system was important as insurance. Its qualities were recognised by the British Army, and units were ordered to be sited in Malaya, Hong Kong and Burma. Fortunately the equipment had not been delivered when these areas fell to the Japanese.
An important aspect of the Shore Defence set was its provision of a basic design framework for the Air Warning Radar. The necessity for such equipment was realised immediately following Japan's entry into the war, and a unit was designed, built, and put into operation within a week. This particular set provided Sydney with its only air warning system for some nine months, although by that time Martyn had left Radiophysics.
A major difficulty in the use of radar by the armed forces was the development of adequate liaison between the designers and the users. Martyn recognised this difficulty and spent a great deal of time travelling to radar sites, lecturing to groups of officers and developing close contacts. Of these, the earliest and most fruitful was with Colonel (later Major-General) J.S. Whitelaw, who was largely responsible for the early introduction of radar into the armed services, and who became a close personal friend of Martyn.
In 1942, for reasons which are not now clear, Martyn was replaced by F.W.G. White as Chief of the Division of Radiophysics. This action affected Martyn profoundly. It left him with bitterness which became, at times, an obsession, and it coloured both personal and institutional relationships. It did not, however, reduce his desire to contribute, as fully as he could, to the war effort. He left the Division of Radiophysics in June, 1942, to direct an Operational Research Group for the armed services.
The group was restricted to weapon research in general, and radar in particular. It was not concerned with design and maintenance of radar, but with the scientific principles involved in its efficient operational use. The major activity of the group was an investigation of the effects of severe atmospheric refraction of radio waves and the consequent malfunctioning of radar sets. These studies led to a general improvement in the operational efficiency of radar, particularly along the northern coast of Australia.
Influence on Australian science
In the 1930's, Australian physics had fallen into a backwater. Martyn and Pulley's paper ('The temperatures and constituents of the upper atmosphere') redirected world attention to physics in Australia. In particular, in 1936 Professor T.H. Laby, FRS, brought out to Australia Professor H.S.W. Massey, his former pupil, to study the implications of the new discoveries. Sir Harrie Massey, FRS, has since followed up these matters assiduously, and is now known internationally for his upper atmosphere and space research activities.
In 1950, because of his work on radio-emission from the sun, Martyn was recognised throughout the world as a leader in radio astronomy, and in consequence was elected at Zurich as President of the newly formed Radio Astronomy Commission of the International Union of Radio Science (URSI). He promptly invited URSI to hold its next General Assembly in Australia, although the necessary finance had not yet been obtained. Eventually this bold attempt achieved the necessary financial backing from the Commonwealth Treasury and Australian industry, and URSI held its next General Assembly in Australia, in 1952, the first time that any international scientific union met south of the Equator. This meeting showed the scientific world how far advanced Australia was, not only in ionospheric research, but also in radio astronomy.
At this time, discussions between CSIRO and the Department of the Interior resulted in an understanding that the Mount Stromlo Observatory would no longer pursue radio astronomical studies, to avoid duplication of effort with the Radiophysics Division of CSIRO. In consequence, Martyn reverted to ionospheric research, and after four years as President of URSI's Radio Astronomy Commission, was elected to a four year term as President of the Ionospheric Commission of URSI.
Martyn spent much effort in preliminary organisation of Australia's activities in the International Geophysical Year, and in securing funds for this notable enterprise.
In 1959 the Australian Broadcasting Commission inaugurated an annual series of ABC lectures, which 'A prominent member of the Australian community would be invited to present the results of his work and thinking on one of society's major problems.' Dr Martyn was invited to give the first of these lectures. He chose as his topic 'Society in the Space Age', a series of four lectures which has been published and recently reprinted by the ABC.
International activities
Mention has already been made of Martyn's Presidencies within URSI. In 1962 he was invited by the United Nations (following agreement between the US and USSR) to be Chairman of that body's Scientific and Technical Sub-Committee of the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space. (This Committee is attended by the leading space scientists of 28 nations.) The Committee is also enjoined to achieve its objectives by unanimous consent. It has provided unanimously agreed reports on such matters as contamination of outer space, and has also set up an international research rocket range in South India. It is unique to have Australia chairing a UN Committee for a decade. This is due both to Dr Martyn's scientific eminence, and to his tact and impartiality in dealing with countries from the so-called West, East, and unaligned regions.
Dr Martyn was also elected for a four year term to the Executive Committee of the International Council of Scientific Unions (ICSU), the body controlling the activities of all international scientific unions and the joint activities of groups of unions. It is known that he was nominated by several countries for the Presidency of ICSU; however, he refused these nominations, stating that at the present time he considered that the President of ICSU should reside closer to the current centre of gravity of international scientific activities.
Dr Martyn was editor (for the Southern Hemisphere) of the international journal Planetary and Space Science; he was also on the Board of Editors of Space Science Reviews, and a member of the Board of Trustees of the International Astronautical Federation.
During the last three years of his life, Martyn became increasingly concerned with problems of conservation of the biosphere as the milieu of all life of which there is knowledge. The importance of action to preserve what remained of 'natural' environment for wild flora and fauna, and to counter man's senseless and increasing contamination of the atmosphere, the waterways and even the sea, was brought home to him through international discussion of the contaminants which space-vehicles could carry to other planets and the moon. As he became aware of the nature and scale of man's spoilation and destruction of his own environment, and encountered apathy and distrust in officials of government and industry towards measures of control, he began to feel that little or nothing could be done to avert ultimate disaster. This was not characteristic of Martyn, for he was ever a fighter for any cause in which he became deeply involved, and it clearly contributed to the despondent mood which overcame him in the end.
The high esteem in which Martyn was held in the international field is reflected in the numerous letters and telegrams received by his widow. The Minister for External Affairs stressed how highly his Department valued its association with Martyn, which began on his election as Chairman of the Scientific and Technical Sub-Committee of the U N Committee in 1962. He added that Martyn did a great deal to advance Australia's standing in the United Nations, and that many officers of his Department remembered him with affection and with gratitude for the help and advice he gave them. The Minister for Education and Science wrote of his high opinion of Martyn and his feeling of a personal sense of loss. The Secretary-General of the United Nations wrote to the Australian Permanent Representative of the United Nations of Martyn's pursuit of the goal of international co-operation with devotion and scholarship, and added that his contribution within the United Nations and several international scientific organisations will long be remembered.
Honours
Martyn was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society of London in 1950, the first such election of a physicist in Australia for twenty years. He was awarded the Lyle Medal of the Australian National Research Council, and the Sidey Medal of the Royal Society of New Zealand, both in 1947. In 1950 he received the Burfitt Medal of the Royal Society of NSW, and in 1954 the Charles Chree Medal of the Physical Society of London.
The Australian Academy of Science
In 1951, as part of the celebrations of the fiftieth anniversary of Federation, the Australian National University organised a seminar on Science in Australia. Sir Edward Mellanby, Secretary of the Medical Research Council in UK, and Dr J.B. Conant, President of Harvard, with prominent Australian representatives of industry and science, took part in a comprehensive discussion of the state and role of science in the Commonwealth. The seminar emphasised the need for an Australian society of scientists of distinction; to serve as the body adhering to the international unions, and represent Australian science generally, both nationally and internationally; to bring the scattered scientific efforts of the Commonwealth together; to conduct seminars and conferences; to offer advice to the Government on questions concerning the welfare of science in Australia; and generally to promote and disseminate scientific knowledge. Martyn took part in the discussion, and subsequently he and Oliphant considered how an Australian Academy of Science, the constitution and objectives of which should be based on those of the corresponding body in Britain, the Royal Society of London, might be brought into existence. They considered the factors which had rendered abortive several previous attempts to found a society of this kind, and concluded that interstate jealousies and personal difficulties were responsible. They decided that as the twelve Fellows of the Royal Society resident in Australia had been elected by an outside, disinterested institution, there would be less objection to an attempt by them to establish a new society at high level. Eleven agreed to co-operate. One, who was elderly and an invalid, disillusioned by previous experience, said that he did not wish to be associated with yet another failure.
The Australian National Research Council, with wide membership, was the adhering body to the international scientific unions at that time. It was necessary to obtain its agreement to hand over these responsibilities to the proposed Academy. In the delicate negotiations which ensued, Martyn displayed remarkable statesmanship. He was never impatient, and showed great understanding of the feelings and attitudes of the officers and members of ANRC. It was largely Martyn's persistent advocacy which persuaded that body to co-operate and hand over all its responsibilities to the Academy.
So that it was more representative of science generally, the Fellows of the Royal Society invited 25 distinguished Australian scientists to join with them as Foundation Fellows of the Academy. In this task Martyn showed sound judgment, and worked to ensure that these men were as widely distributed, geographically, as the standards adopted would allow. The enlarged group then drew up and adopted statutes and rules. With the help of Mr. Norman Cowper (later Sir Norman), who had agreed to serve as honorary solicitor to the group, Martyn cast these into acceptable forms, spending much time and great effort to ensure that they correctly interpreted the wishes of the membership and the needs of the law. On the basis of these documents, and with the willing co-operation of the Royal Society of London and of the Prime Minister, application was made for a Royal Charter. This was granted in the record time of three weeks, so that Queen Elizabeth II was able to present it to the Interim President and officers, at Government House, Canberra on 16 February, 1954. Thus, largely owing to the continued effort of D.F. Martyn, the Australian Academy of Science came into being. He was the first Secretary (Physical Sciences). The Commonwealth Government agreed to provide an annual subvention, following an interview which the Prime Minister granted to the President and Sir David Rivett, on the basis of estimates for which Martyn was largely responsible.
Martyn was elected President of the Academy in 1969 in succession to Sir Macfarlane Burnet, and held that office when he died. Meanwhile, he had continued to serve the Academy on various committees, and always played a prominent part in the Annual General Meetings. He was truly committed to maintenance of the standards of the Fellowship, and to the part the Academy could play to promote Australian science, at home and in its international relations.
Personal
The standards which Martyn expected in scientific research were high and when work which he regarded as wrong was submitted for any purpose, or published, his judgement could be harsh. But he gave full acknowledgement of good work, and pressed strongly the claims for election to the Academy, or for the award of a prize, by men of science whose work he approved. If he had a model of a scientist of distinction, it was Sydney Chapman, whose opinion he valued above all.
Martyn never gathered round him a large group of collaborators. In essence he was a theoretician, preferring to work quietly and alone on problems which interested him, and at his own pace. Yet, it is clear from his notable success in international scientific bodies that he was a gifted chairman of meetings, who could be tactful, yet firm. This attribute was particularly apparent in the foundation of the Australian Academy of Science. There were occasions when obstruction, and the desire to reduce standards for Fellowship, threatened collapse of the proposal to establish an Academy. It was then that Martyn's persistence, powers of persuasion and great tact, prevented disaster, without relaxing in any way the high objectives of the founding group.
Martyn was a trout fisherman of great skill, and a connoisseur of food and wine. On social occasions he was a man of charm and good conversation. He will be missed greatly by all who won his warm friendship. In 1944 he married Margot Adams of Sydney. They had no children.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Records of the Australian Academy of Science, vol. 2(2), 1971. It was written by:
- John Hobart Piddington, PhD, Senior Principal Research Scientist, Division of Physics,CSIRO, Chippendale, Sydney, NSW. He was elected a Fellow of the Academy in 1963.
- Sir Mark Laurence Elwin Oliphant, KBE, DSc, FRS, Emeritus Professor, Research School of Physical Sciences, Australian National University, Canberra. He was a Foundation Fellow.
David Evan Thomas 1902–1978
A leading authority on graptolites and Palaeozoic geology, Professor David Thomas FAA helped shape modern geological science and mineral exploration in Australia.
David Evan Thomas was born on 4 August 1902 in Ammanford, Wales, the third son of Thomas and Margaret Thomas. His mother's family had included several ministers of the gospel, and his father, a Weshman born at Pontardulais, was an urban official who, although self-taught, was a brilliant organist and pianist. David himself had possessed a fine soprano voice as a young boy, and displayed a keen interest in music which he retained in later life. He attended primary school at Parcyrhun from 1908 to 1914, and gained Free Place Scholarships, renewable annually, for secondary schooling at the Amman Valley County School, where in the later years he developed into an outstanding figure as Senior Prefect (1920), Captain of Rugby (1917–19), Captain of Cricket (1920), and for a time Chairman of the Library and Debating Society.
From 1921 to 1924 he studied science in the University College of Wales at Aberystwyth, gaining some financial support by part time work as a coal miner. He graduated magna cum laude in 1923 as Bachelor of Science with Honours in Geography and Anthropology, further achieving Honours in Geology in 1924 when he was the Rudlen Exhibition Scholar in that subject. In geography he had studied under the distinguished human geographer H. J. Fleure, and in geology under W. J. Pugh, both of whom were subsequently to be elected to Fellowship of the Royal Society of London and Pugh to become Director of the Geological Survey of Great Britain, after both had held Chairs at the University of Manchester. A student colleague in geography, E. G. Bowen, later became Professor of the subject at Aberystwyth.
After graduation, the only posts available to Thomas were as underground surveyor at the Blaenau Colliery, South Wales, and again for a time as a miner at the Pantyffynon Colliery, Ammanford. He decided to emigrate, and sailed in mid-1925 for Australia under the Y.M.C.A. Migration Scheme. His arrival in Fremantle coincided with a seamen's strike, and he completed his journey to Melbourne by train.
Joining the Education Department in November 1925, he was appointed headmaster to a remote rural primary school at Kennedy's Creek in the Otway Ranges where as he was amused to recall, the staple winter diet in the region at the time was farm-salted mutton, and transport over the deep mud of the tracks was by sledge. But he was soon able to move as geography master to Nhill High School, although his stay was also short as he disagreed with the established teaching methods and applied for and in April 1927 was granted transfer to the Mines Department. He was appointed Assistant Field Geologist, working at first under the guidance of men of wide experience, notably R. A. Keble, J. P. L. Kenny and J. J. Caldwell in the Western District, Gippsland and Central Victoria until 1936 when he was promoted to Field Geologist. In this position he undertook regional mapping of a research nature carried out as the fundamental basis for the production of standard geological map sheets to be published in colour as part of the planned coverage of the State, and additionally made many underground surveys in mines, a practice in which he was highly skilled, as well as visiting regions for special surveys likely to be significant in relation to the geological structure and mineral deposits of Victoria. He always planned to reside close to his work and so had come to be familiar with much of the State from the Western District to Gippsland, and later central Victoria, especially around Lancefield, Romsey and Heathcote, moving to Castlemaine in 1937 where as senior field geologist he took charge of the Regional Office of the Mines Department from 1939 to September 1942.
It happened that the Palaeozoic rocks which Thomas mapped in the Victorian Highlands resemble in many ways those of his homeland, notably in their rich graptolite faunas with the general features of which he was already familiar when he arrived in Australia, so that he was quickly able to contribute important research findings using laboratory facilities set up in his home for palaeontology and petrology.
Losing no opportunity to familiarise himself with Victorian geology and fossil occurrences, he spent almost every summer vacation on long camping trips with geological colleagues who shared his enthusiasms - although few could compete with his skill as a trout fisherman - and who ventured with him into some of the most rugged and inaccessible mountain country in the State. But his constant companion on these reconnaissance expeditions was W. J. Harris, a secondary school teacher with the Education Department, who gained the degree of Doctor of Science in the University of Melbourne for his studies on the graptolites. Harris was able to transfer from Echuca to Castlemaine High School while Thomas was stationed there, and at this time their friendship became very close.
They collaborated in a most fruitful partnership elucidating important aspects of the structure, geological sequence and stratigraphical and palaeontological zonation of the Early and Middle Palaeozoic rocks of central Victoria, which, indeed, afford a succession the range and continuity of which is perhaps unrivalled in the world.
In 1940 Thomas, who was already recognised as a world authority on the graptolites, successfully applied for the Doctorate of Science in the University of Melbourne, his published works submitted in support of his candidature including not only scientific and technical papers, but also the geological map sheets, printed in colour, on which he had worked with such devotion and skill.
Within the Geological Survey of Victoria at that time, prospects of advancement were, however, slight, and Thomas, perhaps as much pour encourager les autres in Napoleonic style, as from any genuine desire to leave, had in 1939 applied for and been selected for appointment as Assistant Government Geologist of South Australia. At that time he was persuaded to stay in Victoria where so many of his interests lay, but later he applied for and accepted appointment as Chief Geologist with the government of Tasmania, where he took up his duties in October 1942.
There he was concerned mainly with the investigation of strategic mineral supplies of possible significance for the allied war effort, but was also able during his travels in the island to review the Early Palaeozoic succession. The presence of primitive Cambrian fossils such as also occur in Victoria, and which were at first regarded as hydroids but were later referred to the dendroid graptolites, was established. At that stage most other occurrences of graptolites in Tasmania were regarded as erroneous or doubtful, but it is of interest that Thomas was later to substantiate many new finds made by Tasmanian geologists.
In February 1944, doubtless influenced by many personal considerations, he returned to Victoria as Geologist with the State Rivers and Water Supply Commission, his main responsibility being the mapping and geological evaluation for engineering purposes of the site of the enlarged Eildon Dam on the Goulburn River, where he was also able to continue to refine the stratigraphic subdivision of his beloved Palaeozoic rocks.
Having completed his specific task at Eildon where he had lived with his family for the duration of the assignment, Thomas transferred as Senior Field Geologist to the head office of the Mines Department in Melbourne in May 1945, and in February 1946 was appointed Chief Government Geologist in succession to W. Baragwanath. In this position, however, he often found himself at loggerheads with senior administrative staff who had been promoted from within the clerical side of the Public Service, and who might have direct Ministerial access which in general he himself was denied. He was not a man to suffer what he regarded as a situation derogatory to the position of the chief scientific officer of the Department either gladly or in silence, and it was largely due to his insistence that in 1960 the title and duties of Director of Geological Survey were reinstated. He was forthwith appointed Director, a position he held until his retirement in 1967.
As a scientific administrator his strength, in his own estimation, lay chiefly in the support he consistently gave to what he could regard as being genuine effort on the part of his staff. But it was soon recognised that he was also always prepared to take a strong and positive stand in situations where he believed matters of principle to be involved, even though his views might then run counter to those of established authority, and this inevitably led many to regard him as 'difficult'. With this appraisal he would have been happy to concur in circumstances when his convictions, loyalties or scientific rectitude might appear to have been called in question. He was insistent on the recognition by Commonwealth and State authorities and by industry, that under the Constitution the States retain sovereign rights over mineral deposits within their boundaries, and he regarded the permission often granted by State Government for Commonwealth geologists and geophysicists to undertake surveys in Victoria as inhibiting the proper activities and growth of the State Geological Survey. Indeed, during his service as Director, the geological staff of the Survey was increased in established strength from three to twenty, and a high level of professional attainment among appointees was maintained although a loose interpretation of Public Service regulations might in fact have permitted some relaxation of standards in this regard. He was also able to provide for certain members of the existing staff to undertake post-graduate university studies, and he had a fatherly, even at times paternalistic interest in the progress of his younger associates.
As may be gauged from the considerable number of publications of which he was joint author, he worked in fruitful collaboration with many colleagues throughout his career. In addition to his long association with W. J. Harris, his earlier mentor on Victorian graptolites and the local Palaeozoic succession had been R. A. Keble, who was a senior member of the Geological Survey when Thomas first joined, but later became Curator of Fossils at the National Museum of Victoria. The major review of the brown coal deposits of the State made with W. Baragwanath was certainly responsible for much subsequent interest in the development of basins lying outside the area in Gippsland controlled by the State Electricity Commission. Baragwanath had long been the scientific head of the Geological Survey as well as Secretary for Mines for a short period, and was one of those 'old fellows' whose dedication and skills Thomas often praised to the 'young fellows' who arrived as hopeful recruits to the profession.
Thomas was author, or in many instances joint author, of more than a hundred published works on a wide range of geological topics, but he himself would have ranked equally, if not higher, his geological mapping published in twelve coloured parish plans, the maps for the Eildon project, and many smaller detailed plans of mines and mineral deposits.
In 1954 he spent several months overseas, mainly to obtain information in North America, the United Kingdom and Europe which might have been relevant to new legislation to be introduced in Victoria as to the utilisation of underground water resources, and to study methods of exploration for uranium deposits. He was also able to visit several classic areas for graptolite-facies rocks, and to broaden his personal contacts with colleagues having similar research interests.
In 1963 he was granted leave to take a United Nations post in Cyprus, as Project Manager in respect of underground water and mineral resources developments but the two years he spent there coincided with a time of intense civil disturbance and he was unable to achieve significant results. During field trips he had military protection, but armed conflict extended even into the district where he and his wife were housed, so that his initial enthusiasms for international aid were dimmed by the actualities of interracial strife, even in the island which gave its name to the metal he was engaged to seek to develop – copper.
Throughout his career, Thomas worked diligently in the cause of science and of geology in particular, through his active membership of and participation in the affairs of the societies and organisations appropriate to his scientific standing and professional status, which was one carrying considerable weight if only because of the small number of geologists working in Victoria during the early years of his service. He was a life member and for many years a councillor of the Royal Society of Victoria, and was a staunch supporter of the Geological Society of Australia, having been a founding member of the local geological club which, along with similar groups in the other State capitals, had formed one of the nuclei from which the Society evolved. He delivered the Clarke Memorial Lecture of the Royal Society of New South Wales in 1959, on The Zonal Distribution of Australian Graptolites, and this still remains the major review of the topic despite some modifications now required mainly in respect of the younger forms. His Presidential Address to Section C (Geology) of the Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science, delivered in Brisbane in 1951 was an important conspectus succinctly entitled Gold, illustrating the many types of lodes in Victoria and discussing their origins. In addition to his many papers describing other Victorian mineral occurrences, most of which he had been able to examine personally in his official capacity, he gave a general account of the mineral deposits of the State in relation to its geological history and structure, and reappraised our knowledge of the Bendigo and the Castlemaine-Chewton-Fryerstown Goldfields in the volume (Vol. I) on the Geology of Australian Ore Deposits published for the Fifth Empire Mining and Metallurgical Congress in 1953. In this volume Thomas also described the Blue Tier Tinfield, Tasmania, and additionally contributed a synoptic account of the geology of Victorian brown coals for the companion volume (Vol. VI) on Coal in Australia. The Congress was hosted by the Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy of which Thomas was a Member. He served for several years on the State Committee of CSIR (later CSIRO), and was also a member of many governmental advisory and interdepartmental committees during his tenure as Chief Government Geologist and later as Director of the Geological Survey of Victoria.
David Evan Thomas was elected to Fellowship of the Australian Academy of Science in 1963. His efforts towards the development of geology in his adopted land were emotive in relation to the earth, as well as strictly intellectual in relation to his science. The family into which he was born had been Welsh-speaking like most others in the Amman Valley, so that as a small child he had learned English virtually as a second language, and had grown up in close contact with miners and their families. He too then worked underground, and there can be little doubt that these influences in his formative years helped to determine the course of his later studies and career. His translation to Australia seems, in the circumstances obtaining at the time of his graduation, to have been fortunate in presenting him with opportunities which were unlikely to have come his way in Wales, and in placing him in a neo-Cambrian environment where his many-sided personality could freely develop in a modern colonial milieu. He was indeed, as one of his close associates has written, “always a little larger than life”, and his output of first class geological work was truly remarkable, as was the range of topics with which he treated.
In 1930 he married Mary (Maisie) Scanlon, whom he had met while surveying in the Romsey district. His wife predeceased him, and they are survived by their son John Roderick. In his later years protracted ill-health confined him more and more to his home, until his death on 26 November, 1978.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol.5(2), 1981. It was written by Edwin Sherbon Hills CBE FRS a Foundation Fellow of the Academy and Emeritus Professor of Geology in the University of Melbourne. He served on Council between 1962 and 1964.
Acknowledgement
I am indebted to members of the Thomas family, as well as to his colleagues in the Victorian Department of Minerals and Energy (formerly Mines Department), for information and advice on many matters referred to in the memoir.
Colin Wesley Ward 1943–2017
Dr Colin Ward FAA FTSE led the quest to determine the insulin receptor's structure, alongside major contributions to influenza sequencing, plant virus taxonomy and veterinary vaccines.
Colin Wesley Ward's professional life played out at the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) laboratory on Royal Parade, Parkville, Victoria, where he was a scientist, leader, raconteur, colleague and friend to several generations of staff who worked there.
Ward's scientific legacy encompasses large bodies of work on antigenic variation in influenza viruses, the taxonomy of plant viruses, veterinary vaccines and the structure and function of several growth factor receptors. On retirement from CSIRO he continued work on the insulin receptor with colleagues at the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research, conceived of and founded CSIRO pedia and compiled his family history.
Download the memoir
Supplementary material
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 29(2), 2018. It was written by Peter M. Colman and Antony W. Burgess
Colin Russell Austin 1914–2004
Colin Russell Austin, English by birth, initially graduated in Veterinary Science from the University of Sydney in 1936. The Second World War limited his career options, but he was fortunate to be employed by the CSIRO Division of Animal Health in Sydney. In 1954 he was invited to join the staff of the Medical Research Council’s laboratory in Mill Hill, London to study fertilization and early embryonic development in rats and rabbits.
Roger V. Short
Colin Russell Austin, English by birth, initially graduated in Veterinary Science from the University of Sydney in 1936. The Second World War limited his career options, but he was fortunate to be employed by the CSIRO Division of Animal Health in Sydney. In 1954 he was invited to join the staff of the Medical Research Council’s laboratory in Mill Hill, London to study fertilization and early embryonic development in rats and rabbits. As a result, in 1962 he was asked to teach Fertilization and Gamete Physiology at theMarine Biological Laboratory,Woods Hole, Massachusetts, and subse- quently became Professor of Embryology in the Medical School at Tulane University, New Orleans. This alerted the University of Cambridge to his potential and they created a special Charles Darwin Chair for him in 1967. This enabled him to support the work of his young student Robert Edwards on human in vitro fertilization and embryonic development that culminated in the award of the Nobel Prize to Edwards and Patrick Steptoe in 2010. Austin also devoted a great deal of his time to editing the 13-volume Cambridge University Press series of textbooks, Reproduction in Mammals, completing the series from his retirement home in Buderim, Queensland in 1986.
Colin Russell Austin, known from childhood as ‘Bunny’, was born in Sydney on 12 September 1914 and spent his early days in India where his father, a Lieutenant Colonel in the British Army, was stationed during the First World War. At the end of the war, the family returned to England and then emigrated to Australia when Bunny was 15. After finishing his secondary education he enrolled at the University of Sydney, where he obtained a Bachelor of Veterinary Sci- ence degree in 1936. Since veterinary practice did not appeal, he continued at University, completing a Bachelor of Science degree in 1938 and then working towards a Master of Science degree in Biochemistry that he was awarded in 1940. In that year, he became a member of the research staff of the Division of Animal Health of Australia’s Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR, later CSIRO), where he stayed on the payroll until 1954 except for a couple of years, 1941–3, during the Second World War when he was seconded to the Dried Fruits Section of the Council’s Division of Food Preservation and Transport, working on Army diets and nutrition. It was there that he met Patricia, a CSIR librarian, and they married in 1941. They had two sons, Mark and Richard. In 1947,CSIR sent Bunny towork at the Medical Research Council laboratory in Mill Hill, London, where he spent a year before returning to Australia. He clearly made a very favourable impression, because in 1954 he was appointed to a permanent post in the newly created National Institute for Medical Research at Mill Hill. In the same year, he was awarded a Doctor of Science degree by the University of Sydney for work on fertilization and associated phenomena in mammals. At Mill Hill, Bunny eventually became Head of the Laboratory Animals Division from 1958 to 1961. The Austin family lived in Hadley Wood, North London, for ten years, and it was during this period that his scientific career took off, building on the study of fertilization and early embryonic development in rats and rabbits that he had started in Australia in collaboration with Dr A. W. H. Braden. Between 1948 and 1956, Bunny published ten papers in Nature (8, 10, 15, 16, 21, 22, 28, 30, 39, 42), and there were more to follow. Perhaps he will be best remembered for his 1952 paper in Nature (21). He showed that neither rabbit nor rat spermatozoa can fertilize their respective ova without a period of maturation in the female reproductive tract, a process he described as capacitation. He also found the time to write a landmark book, The Mammalian Egg, summarizing all these early findings. This was published by Blackwell, Oxford in 1961. Bunny’s research in due course brought him transatlantic recognition. In 1962, he was made a F. R. Lillie Memorial Fellow and a member of the teaching staff of the Fertilization and Gamete Physiology Training Program at the Marine Biological Laboratory, Woods Hole,Massachusetts, USA, an appointment that lasted until 1968. For the first three years, he and Pat spent the months of June, July and August in that inspiring academic environment. But he also inspired those around him and so it was that he became Head of the Genetic and Developmental Disorders Research Program at the Delta Regional Primate Research Center, Covington, Louisiana and also Professor of Embryology in the Medical School at Tulane University, New Orleans, 1964–7. The availability of primates enabled him to start working on spermatozoa in the epididymis of monkeys (104), the liquefaction of primate semen (106), the preservation of primate spermatozoa by freezing (107), the use of a rectal probe for electroejaculation of apes and monkeys (111, 114) and, most importantly, the use of human postmenopausal gonadotrophin to stimulate ovarian follicular and oocyte development in monkeys (115). So humans must be next on the list! Thus it was that his most important career move came in 1967, when he returned to England to take up a Chair that had been specially created for him at the University of Cambridge, the Charles Darwin Professorship in Animal Embryology in the Department of Physiology, together with a Fellowship at Fitzwilliam College. Here he was able to provide the perfect research environment for an up-and-coming young zoologist, Robert Edwards, who Bunny took into his department to develop, with his clinician colleague Patrick Steptoe, the contentious subject of human in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer—work that would eventually earn Edwards the 2010 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. Edwards and Bunny published their first paper together in 1959, on the induction of oestrus and ovulation in rats (67), but their most significant joint publication was in 1972 (131) on ‘Initiation of human development in vitro and transfer of early embryos’, presented at a UNESCO conference in Paris. In 1986, Bob Edwards had this to say of Bunny: ‘I would like to stress my own deep debt to him during themost difficult period of human in-vitro fertilization, when he was a clear thinking supporter of the work, prepared to defend it publicly when there were few others around’. This refers to the fact that several senior Cambridge academics, including a Nobel Laureate, were deeply opposed to human in vitro fertilization and would have torpedoed all the efforts of Edwards and Steptoe, had it not been for Bunny’s unwavering support as Charles Darwin Professor. Darwin would have been proud of Bunny! Bunny retired in 1981 and afterwards he and Pat settled in Buderim, Queensland. In 1987 he was elected a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science, a fitting recognition of a great scientific career.
Scientific achievements
In 1986, Professor Ryuzo Yanagimachi, Professor of Anatomy and Reproductive Biology at the University of Hawaii and an extremely distinguished gamete biologist, summarized Bunny’s scientific contributions in the following words: ‘I, and I believe all reproductive biologists working on mammalian fertilization today, consider Dr Austin as the founder of the modern study of mammalian fertilization. Between 1948 and 1955, when he was in Australia, Dr Austin published 34 research papers on mammalian fertilization. His outstanding contributions to the field of mammalian reproduction are: the codiscovery of the phenomenon of sperm capacitation; the first description of the acrosome reaction of mammalian spermatozoa; the discovery of the zona reaction; and the first detailed descriptionofnormal andabnormal fertilization. Without the pioneering studies of Dr Austin we would be far behind where we are today in reproductive biology. If it were not for Dr Austin, the success of human in vitro fertilization, for example, would have been set back at least a decade, or perhaps never occurred. ’That is praise indeed.
Figure 1.Figure 1. Bunny Austin’s chapter ‘The Egg’ in Reproduction in Mammals, Second Edition, 1982,Volume 1, has on page 61 this beautiful drawing by John Fuller, taken from the frontispiece of William Harvey’s classic book De generatione animalium (1651). It shows the hands of Jove holding apart the two halves of an egg, from which are emerging a plant, an insect, an amphibian, a reptile, a bird, a ruminant and even a human being, beautifully summarized in the words ‘Ex ovo omnia’ that might have been Bunny’s motto.
Reproduction in Mammals
There can be no doubt that one of Bunny’s great- est achievements was as the Senior Editor and a major contributor to the Cambridge Univer- sity Press series Reproduction in Mammals that he and I brought together. When planning this series, we decided first and foremost to make the books highly readable to undergraduates, to intersperse the text with excellent illustrations drawn by our Cambridge colleague John Fuller and, if possible, to avoid using tables since these break up the flow of the argument.
The first volume, Germ Cells and Fertiliza- tion, was published in 1972. The other volumes were: 2. Embryonic and Fetal Development, 3. Hormones in Reproduction, 4. Reproductive Patterns, 5. Artificial Control of Reproduction, 6. The Evolution of Reproduction, 7. Mechanisms of Hormone Action, and 8. Human Sexuality. These were all published between 1972 and 1980. To write the chapters, we hand-picked scientists from around the world whom we knew personally and we never had a refusal! Either Bunny or I, and sometimes both of us, had a chapter in each volume, thereby giving us a sense of ownership of the series. It met with a very warm reception from both teachers and students.
Scientifically, however, things were changing fast, and so we decided to produce a completely new edition of Volumes 1–5 between 1982 and 1986, in response to requests from our readers for a more up-to-date and detailed treatment of the subjects. As a result, the volumes doubled in size and a few tables crept in, but John Fuller’s beautiful drawings continued to enlighten the text (Fig. 1). There were a few title changes, with Volume 3 becoming Hormonal Control of Repro- duction, Volume 4, Reproductive Fitness, and Volume 5, Manipulating Reproduction. Much of the work for the new edition was done in Australia, with Bunny now living in Buderim while I had moved from Cambridge via the University of Edinburgh to Monash University in Melbourne, meaning that we were still able to keep in touch. Appropriately, Bunny had the last word because he wrote the final chapter in the new Volume 5, which he entitled ‘Barriers to Population Control’—a prescient theme in a world in which human population growth is one of the major problems facing mankind.
Bibliography
- Books (written)
- The Mammalian Egg. Blackwell Scientific Publica- tions, Oxford. (1961).
- Fertilization. Prentice-Hall Inc.,Englewood Cliffs, NJ. (1965).
- Ultrastructure of Fertilization. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York. (1968).
Books (edited)
- Sex Differentiation and Development. Memoirs of the Society for Endocrinology No 7. Cambridge, at the University Press. (1960).
- Cell Mechanisms in Hormone Production and Action. Memoirs of the Society for Endocrinology No 8. Cambridge, at the University Press. (1961). With
- P. C. Williams.
- A Symposium on Agents Affecting Fertility. L. &
- A.Churchill, London. (1965). With J. S. Perry.
- Reproduction in Mammals. Cambridge University Press. With R. V. Short.
- Book 1. Germ Cells and Fertilization. (1972).
- Book 2. Embryonic and Fetal Development. (1972).
- Book 3. Hormones in Reproduction. (1972).
- Book 4. Reproductive Patterns. (1972).
- Book 5. Artificial Control of Reproduction. (1972).
- Book 6. The Evolution of Reproduction. (1976).
- Book 7.Mechanisms of Hormone Action. (1979).
- Book 8. Human Sexuality. (1980).
- The Mammalian Fetus in Vitro. Chapman and Hall, London. (1973).
- Mechanisms of Sex Differentiation in Animals and Man. Academic Press, London and New York. (1981). With R. G. Edwards.
- Reproduction in Mammals, 2nd Edition. Cambridge University Press. With R. V. Short.
- Book 1. Germ Cells and Fertilization. (1982).
- Book 2. Embryonic and Fetal Development. (1982).
- Book 3. Hormonal Control of Reproduction. (1984).
- Book 4. Reproductive Fitness. (1985).
- Book 5. Manipulating Reproduction. (1986).
Research Reports, Abstracts, Reviews, Chapters, etc
- The clinical examination of urine. Lab. J. Aus-tralasia, June, pp. 1–14. (1941). With J. H. Rofe.
- The thiamine (vitamin B1) content of the urine of Trichosurus vulpecular. J. Proc. R. Soc. NSW.,75, 118–121. (1941). With A. Bolliger.
- The reproductive hormones: a review of chemicaland physical aspects. Aust. Vet. J., 17, 222–228. (1941).
- The determination of carotene: a critical eval-uation. J. CSIR, 17, 115–126. (1944). With J. Shipton.
- Endocrinology and animal production.Aust. Vet. J., 22, 48–54. (1946).
- The metabolism of thiamine in the sheep. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci., 25, 147–155. (1947).
- The effect of hexoestrol on the food intake of sheep. Aust. J. Exp. Biol. Med. Sci., 25, 343–346. (1947). With W. K. Whitten, M. C. Franklin and R. L. Reid.
- Function of hyaluronidase in fertilization. Nature, 162, 534. (1948).
- Phase-contrast microscopy in the study of fertilization and early development of the rat egg. J. R. Micr. Soc., 68, 13–19. (1948). With J. Smiles.
- Number of sperms required for fertilization. Nature, 162, 534. (1948).
- Fertilization and the transport of gametes in thepseudo-pregnant rabbit. J. Endocr., 6, 63–70. (1949).
- The fragmentation of eggs following induced ovulation in immature rats. J. Endocr., 6, 104–110. (1949).
- The functions of the endocrine system in preg- nancy. Aust. Vet. J., August, pp. 190–193. (1949).
- The fecundity of the immature rat following induced super-ovulation. J. Endocr., 6, 293–301. (1950).
- Fertilization of the rat egg. Nature, 166, 407. (1950).
- Activation and the correlation between male and female elements in fertilization. Nature, 168, 558. (1951).
- Observations on the penetration of the sperm intothe mammalian egg. Aust. J. Sci. Res., Ser. B, 4,581–596. (1951).
- The formation, growth and conjugation of the pronuclei in the rat egg. J. R. Micr. Soc., 71, 295–306. (1951).
- The development of pronuclei in the rat egg, with particular reference to quantitative relations. Aust. J. Sci. Res., Ser. B, 5, 354–365. (1952).
- The development of the rat spermatid. J. R.Micr. Soc., 71, 397–406. (1952). With C. Sapsford.
- The ‘capacitation’ of mammalian sperm.Nature, 170, 326. (1952).
- Passage of the sperm and the penetration of the egg in mammals. Nature, 170, 919. (1952). With A.W. H. Braden.
- Nucleic acids associated with the nucleoli of living segmented rat eggs. Exp. Cell Res., 4,249–251. (1953).
- The distribution of nucleic acids in rats eggs infertilization and early segmentation. I. Studieson living eggs by ultraviolet microscopy. Aust.J. Biol. Sci., 6, 324–333. (1953). With A. W. H. Braden.
- The distribution of nucleic acids in rats eggs infertilization and early segmentation. II. Histo-chemical studies. Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 6, 665–673. (1953). With A. W. H. Braden.
- Fertilization and fertility in mammals. Aust. J.Vet., May, pp. 129–132. (1953). With A. W. H. Braden.
- The growth of knowledge on mammalian fertil- ization. Aust. J. Vet., July, pp. 191–198. (1953).
- Polyspermy in mammals. Nature, 172, 82. (1953). With A. W. H. Braden.
- An investigation of polyspermy in the rat and rab-bit. Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 6, 674–692. (1953). With A.W. H. Braden.
- Nucleus formation and cleavage induced in unfertilized rat eggs. Nature, 173, 999. (1954). With A. W. H. Braden.
- Reactions of unfertilized mouse eggs to someexperimental stimuli. Exp. Cell Res., 7, 277–280. (1954). With A. W. H. Braden.
- Time relations and their significance in the ovulation and penetration of eggs in rats and rabbits. Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 7, 179–194. (1954). With A.W. H. Braden.
- Induction and inhibition of the second polar division in the rat egg and subsequent fertilization. Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 7, 195–210.(1954).
- The reaction of the zona pellucid to sperm penetration. Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 7, 391–409. (1954). With A. W. H. Braden and H. A. David.
- Anomalies in rat, mouse and rabbit eggs. Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 7, 537–542. (1954). With A. W. H. Braden.
- The number of sperms about the eggs in mammals and its significance for normal fertilization.Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 7, 543–551. (1954). With A.W. H. Braden.
- Fertilization of the mouse egg and the effect ofdelayed coitus and of hot-shock treatment. Aust.J. Biol. Sci., 7, 552–565. (1954). With A. W. H. Braden.
- The fertile life of mouse and rat eggs. Science, 120, no. 3120. (1954). With A. W. H. Braden.
- Polyspermy after induced hyperthermia in rats. Nature, 175, 1038. (1955).
- Acquisition de la capacite fertilisatrice desspermatozoids (“capacitation”) dans les voiesgenitales femelles. In: La Fonction Tubaire, pp. 22–27.Masson et Cie, Paris. (1955).
- Observations on nuclear size and form in living rat and mouse eggs. Exp. Cell Res., 8, 163–172. (1955). With A. W. H. Braden.
- Study of fertility. Nature, 178, 185–187. (1956).
- An attempt to produce the Hertwig effect by X-irradiation of male mice. Studies in Fertility, 8, 121–131. (1956). With H. M. Bruce.
- Cortical granules in hamster eggs.Exp. Cell Res., 10, 533–540. (1956).
- Ovultation, fertilization and early cleavage in thehamster (Mesocricetus auratus). J. R. Micr. Soc.,75, 141–154. (1956).
- Effect of continuous oestrogen administrationon oestrus, ovulation and fertilization in rats and mice. J. Endocr., 13, 376–383. (1956). With H. M. Bruce.
- Activation of eggs by hypothermia in rats andhamsters. J. Exp. Biol., 33, 338–347. (1956).
- Effects of hypothermia and hyperthermia on fer-tilization in rat eggs. J. Exp. Biol., 33, 348–357. (1956).
- Early reactions of the rodent egg to sperma-tozoon penetration. J. Exp. Biol., 33, 358–365. (1956). With A. W. H. Braden.
- Environmental modification of oestrus in thevole. Nature, 179, 592–593. (1957). With H. Chitty.
- Preliminaries to fertilization in mammals. In:The Beginnings of Embryonic Development, pp. 71–107. Am. Assoc. Adv. Sci., Washington, DC. (1957). With M. W. H. Bishop.
- Sec chromatin in early cat embryos. Exp. Cell Res., 13, 419–421. (1957). With E. C.Amoroso.
- Fertilization in mammals. Biol. Rev., 32,296–349. (1957).
- Fertilization, early cleavage and associated phe-nomena in the field vole (Microtus agrestis).J. Anat., 91, 1–11. (1957).
- Fate of spermatozoa in the uterus if the mouseand rat. J. Endocr., 14, 335–342. (1957).
- Oestrus and ovulation in the field vole (Microtusagrestis). J. Endocr., 15, iv. (1957).
- Mammalian spermatozoa. Endeavour, 16, 137–150. (1957).
- Capacitation of mammalian spermatozoa. Nature, 181, 851. (1958). With M. W. H. Bishop.
- Research within the laboratory-animal division. In: Symposium. Organized by the Laboratory Animals Centre of MRC. Royal Society of Medicine, 5 May. (1958).
- Permeability of rabbit, rat and hamster egg mem-branes. Exp. Cell Res., 15, 260–261.(1958). With J. E. Lovelock.
- Some features of the acrosome and perfora- torium in mammalian spermatozoa. Proc. R.Soc., B, 149, 234–240. (1958). With M. W. H. Bishop.
- Role of the rodent acrosome and perforatorium in fertilization. Proc. R. Soc., B, 149, 241–248. (1958). With M. W. H. Bishop.
- Entry of spermatozoa into the Fallopian-tube mucosa. Nature, 183, 908–909. (1959).
- Differential fluorescence in living rat eggs treated with acridine orange. Exp. Cell Res., 17,35–43. (1959). With M. W. H. Bishop.
- The role of fertilization. Perspectives Biol. Med., 3, 44–54. (1959).
- Presence of spermatozoa in the uterine-tubemucosa of bats. J. Endocr., 18, viii–ix. (1959). With M. W. H. Bishop.
- Induction of oestrus and ovulation in adult rats. J. Endocr., 18, vii–viii. (1959). With R. G.Edwards.
- Prospective experimental animals for medicalresearch. J. Anim. Tech. Assoc., 10, 1–6. (1959).
- The mammalian egg. Endeavour, 18, 130–143. (1959). With E. C.Amoroso.
- Fertilization and development of the egg. In:Reproduction in Domestic Animals, eds. H. H.Cole and P. T. Cupps. Academic Press; New York and London. 1st Ed.Chap. 12; 2nd Ed. Chap. 13.
- Syngamy in a mammalian egg. Study by phase- contrast microscopy. Med. Biol. Illustr., 10, 62–63. (1960).
- Fate of spermatozoa in the female genital tract. J. Reprod. Fert., 1, 151–156. (1960).
- Capactitation and the release of hyaluronidase from spermatozoa. J. Reprod. Fert., 3, 310–311. (1960).
- Fertilization. In:Marshall’s Physiology of Repro- duction, 3rd edition, ed. A. S. Parkes, vol. 1, pt.2, chap.10. Longmans, Green; London. (1960). With A. Walton.
- Anomalies of fertilization leading to triploidy. J. Cell Comp. Physiol.,56, suppl. 1, 1–15. (1960).
- Egg. In: Encyclopedia of Biological Sciences,ed. P. Gray, pp. 327–328. Reinhold; New York.(1961).
- Significance of sperm capacitation. In: Proc. IVInt. Congr. Anim. Reprod., Hague. (1961).
- Fertilization of mammalian eggsin vitro. Int. Rev. Cytol., 12, 337–359. (1961).
- Sex chromatin in embryonic and fetal tissue. ActaCytol., 6, 61–68. (1962).
- Evidence against participation of a jelly-spittingagent in sperm penetration ofArbacia eggs. Biol.Bull., 123, 470. (1962). With J. Piatigorsky.
- Action of neuraminidase on Arbacia sperma-tozoa. Biol. Bull., 123, 471–472. (1962). With R.L. Brinster.
- Relationship of fertilizin to the acrosome reac- tion in Arbacia. Biol. Bull., 123, 473. (1962). With J. Piatigorsky.
- Passage of spermatozoa through the chorion of Ciona eggs. Biol. Bull., 123, 472. (1962). With S.D. Ezell, jr.
- Axial body and filament formation in oystersperms. Biol. Bull., 123, 474–475. (1962). WithD. H. Spoon and A. Forer.
- Introducing new animals to the laboratory. NewScientist, 17, 117–120. (1962).
- Fertilization in Pectinaria (=Cistenides) gouldii.Biol. Bull., 124, 115–124. (1963).
- Acrosome loss from the rabbit spermatozoon in relation to entry into the egg. J. Reprod. Fert., 6,313–314. (1963).
- Sperm morphology of Emerita talpoida. Biol.Bull., 125, 361–362. (1963). With K. R. Barker.
- Ultrastructure of Pectinaria gouldii gametes.Biol. Bull., 125, 364. (1963). With R. Lambson.
- Fine structure of Nereis limbata spermatozoa.Biol. Bull., 125, 362. (1963). With J. F. Fallon.
Download memoir (PDF)
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 25, no.2, 2014. It was written by Roger V. Short Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry and Health Sciences, University of Melbourne.
Colin Malcolm Donald 1910–1985
Introduction
Colin Malcolm Donald was born in Colchester in England on 21 March 1910, the son of a retired army Colonel. He had one sister and four brothers of whom two had careers in the army, one was a Professor of Medicine at Edinburgh University and one a forester. He spent his childhood with his parents on a small farming property and received his early education at Dover County School.
In 1926 he came to Australia as a boy migrant, under the Wembley Scheme, to Hawkesbury Agricultural College in New South Wales. The scholarship was for one year but he did so well that he continued for a second year and received a Diploma of Agriculture with first class honours. He won a scholarship to the University of Sydney and four years later graduated Bachelor of Agricultural Science, again with first class honours. While at Sydney University he met his future wife Margaret Voysey through a cousin who was also studying agricultural science. They were married in 1935.
Early research
As a young graduate in 1932, Colin Donald was appointed as an agrostologist to the New South Wales Department of Agriculture. However, a vacancy occurred in the CSIR Pasture Research Group, then located in the Department of Agronomy at the Waite Agricultural Research Institute, and in 1934 he moved to Adelaide. There, he worked initially on strain variation in subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum L), prairie grass (Bromus uniloides HB & K) and strawberry clover (Trifolium fragiferum L), and the soil and environmental factors that affected the distribution of different strains. These species are not indigenous to Australia and this caused him to wonder about their variation in their overseas centres of diversity in the Mediterranean region. Some of this research was carried out in collaboration with C. Neal Smith. In separate expeditions, and over a decade later, both were to play a major part in collecting and introducing pasture species from Mediterranean countries to Australia.
In the late 1930s Colin Donald was also interested in the mineral nutrition of pastures and worked with Professor H.C. Trumble (the Waite Professor of Agriculture) on phosphorus and David Riceman (CSIR) on trace elements. With Riceman he made the first discovery in Australia of a trace element deficiency of pastures. This was the copper deficiency that occurred in a region of calcareous soils near Robe in South Australia. The deficiency causes 'coast disease' in sheep. Although it was first recognised because of the symptoms in sheep, farmers of the region were unable to grow leguminous pastures or cereal crops and this alerted Donald and Riceman to the fact that the copper deficiency was affecting the growth of many species of plants as well. They found that supplying copper alone did not overcome all the problems and, in collaboration with C. Piper, established that there was an associated zinc deficiency. When these two elements were provided, there was a spectacular response in plant growth and the sheep disease was overcome. These discoveries led them to undertake many multifactorial field experiments with trace elements.
In 1939 Colin Donald submitted four of his papers to the University of Adelaide to meet the requirements for the degree of Master of Agricultural Science. Two were concerned with strain variation, one with the response of pastures to phosphorus and the fourth was the discovery of the copper deficiency causing the disease of sheep.
Donald's interest in pasture nutrition, which began in the 1930s, was long-standing, and focused especially on the combined effect of phosphate and subterranean clover in increasing the productivity of pastures. It was a subject to which he returned on several occasions in his own research and later with post-graduate students. He drew attention to the effect of this combination on soil fertility, the magnitude of the contribution from the clover's nitrogen fixation to millions of hectares of southern Australia, and the increase in yields of the cereal crops that followed. The historical trends, which he highlighted with the diagram reproduced as Figure 1, have been the subject of several reviews.
In important studies undertaken with C.H. Williams in the early 1950s on podsolised soils in eastern Australia, he also showed that the clover's requirement for sulfur was being only partially met by the sulfur present in superphosphate fertilisers and additionally that the soils under clover pastures fertilised regularly with superphosphate showed a progressive decline in pH with time. They suggested that an alternative source of sulfur should be considered. Both these matters subsequently have gained national significance. In Western Australia notably, but also elsewhere, farmers have been applying very high rates of superphosphate fertiliser to obtain good clover pastures. The high rates have led to run-off of phosphorus from the pastures to waterways and the occurrence of blue-green algal blooms with resultant environmental damage. Research in Western Australia has shown that good clover growth could be obtained with a lower level of phosphorus application if it were combined with timely applications of sulfur. The problem is most prevalent in Western Australia because of the sandy nature of the soils which readily permits leaching of sulfide. Elsewhere in Australia, and particularly in large areas of New South Wales and Victoria, the soil acidification resulting from long established clover pastures has led to problems of reduced cereal production which could only be ameliorated by expensive applications of lime.
In 1958, Donald co-authored a review paper in Advances in Agronomy with C.G. Stephens (CSIRO Division of Soils) on Australian soils and their response to fertilisers. Donald and Stephens had known each other from the early 1930s when both were working for CSIR accommodated in the Waite Institute. They remained close family friends. By 1958 both had had extensive experience of their respective fields; Stephens the pedology of Australian soils and Donald fertilisers and plant growth. Their review drew the attention of a large number of overseas workers to the origin of the soils of Australia, many of which were of great antiquity and had severe nutritional deficiencies for plant growth. These latter soils occurred over extensive areas and 'were considered almost sterile and worthless'. However, by applying superphosphate and trace elements and fostering subterranean clover, 'They are now being converted to soils of satisfactory productivity by what is possibly the most extensive fertility-building program in the world'.
Being aware of this, Donald was concerned not only with the nutritional effect of phosphorus but with Australia's phosphatic resources and requirements and the government bounties that affected the cost and use by farmers of phosphatic fertilisers. Many papers were published in Australian and overseas journals over a thirty-year period – the last was in 1969, on the Northern Territory – on the contribution to the national economy of a pasture fertilized with phosphorus.
During 1939 Colin Donald was awarded a Pawlett travelling scholarship from the University of Sydney to study pastures in Britain, the USA and New Zealand. It was a study tour severely affected by the outbreak of war. However it did provide him with personal insight into pastures in these countries and he was able to compare them with those he knew so well in Australia. He lectured on the subject on his return and wrote a small book based on his lectures, published in 1941 by Sydney University Press, entitled Pastures and Pasture Research. For many years it was essential reading for anyone wishing to understand and compare the pastures of southern Australia with those of temperate Europe and the USA, where most of the previous work had been done. Writing the book was for Donald an introduction to a form of writing different from the concise phrasing of the scientific papers he had written previously. It shows he had a flair for this type of communication at an early stage of his career. It has several most apt quotations. One deals with a proposed Eleventh Commandment, an oversight of Moses. It was first suggested by a person who had witnessed soil degradation in the Middle East and in America. The Commandment deals with soil and water and the protection of forests, and could be as much a stricture today for proponents of sustainable agriculture as it was 50 years ago. While in America, Donald met J.E. Weaver of Nebraska who had studied the habit and size of individual plants growing in communities and therefore in competition with each other for resources. It was a meeting that was greatly to influence Donald's interest in plant competition and the growth of plants in communities.
Division of Plant Industry
On his return to Australia in 1941 Donald moved from Adelaide to the CSIR Division of Plant Industry in Canberra. During the war years, from 1942 to 1945, he was seconded to the Department of War Organisation of Industry, at first with J.G. (later Sir John) Crawford in Sydney and then as Assistant Director of the Department in charge of the Rural Industries Division in Melbourne. His contact with Crawford was to be influential at a later time when the role of Australian scientists in agricultural development in the countries of South-East Asia was being considered. At the end of the war, in 1945, Donald returned to the Division of Plant Industry and became Assistant Chief of Division, responsible for pasture work right across southern Australia.
During this period, Donald carried out research on competition among annual pasture plants that has become classical. In the Mediterranean type of environment of southern Australia, seeds germinate in the autumn, plants grow during the winter and set seed before dying in the summer. The repetitive cycle depends on the reproductive capacity of the species involved. He was aware that many annual pasture species such as annual ryegrass, barley grass, subterranean clover and the annual medics were capable of high seed production in this environment. He was interested in the dynamics of competition that occurred when all the seeds germinated in the autumn and progressively formed a competing sward of plants. There could be as many as 60,000 plants per square metre. The interpretation of this competition that Donald was able to provide with his clear analytical mind was based on careful quantitative analyses. One seminal paper was published in 1951. It was followed by another in 1954 in which Donald drew attention to the inverse relationship between yield per unit area and yield per plant. These papers were classics and inspired much subsequent work, particularly in Japan and the United Kingdom. He highlighted the fact that to achieve rapid growth of a pasture in the autumn, plants needed to be at a very high density – so high a density, in fact, that each plant suffered intense competition. As a result, individual plants in productive swards were far smaller than a plant growing at a low density in a less productive sward. These papers also illustrated that, later in the year, seed yields rose with density to an optimum, beyond which seed yields would fall with further increases in density. In contrast, biomass rose with increasing density to a point where further increases were slight or the relationship reached a plateau. Donald suggested that light was the principal factor limiting growth when nutrients and water were present in sufficient amounts. This was not the first time he had drawn attention to the importance of competition for light, as he had discussed its significance in his book published in 1941. Then, however, he had referred mainly to interspecific competition such as occurred between a clover and a grass species in a mixed sward, whereas now he more fully considered intraspecific competition. This led in the late 1950s and early 1960s to his consideration along with colleagues and students, mainly J.N. Black and W.R. Stern, of the optimal leaf area of growing pastures and the concept that with increasing leaf area and progressive canopy closure, the lower leaves were shaded and a balance developed between the upper exposed leaves and the lower shaded leaves of the canopy. Although these initial studies were with pastures, Donald was later to apply similar analyses to competition among plants in grain crops.
During the late 1940s and the 1950s, Colin Donald's thinking about the appropriate species to grow in pastures was influenced by the research he had seen at the Welsh Plant Breeding Station, Aberystwyth, Wales. The results of this work had dominated the literature on pastures before the Second World War. It emphasized the part played by perennials in providing stability of production, preventing erosion and the infestation of weeds. Although carried out in Britain, it was claimed by its protagonists to have general applicability to pastures. From his own work, however, Donald was aware of the role in Australian pastures of plants of Mediterranean origin, many of which were annuals such as subterranean clover, strawberry clover, annual medics and annual ryegrass. The introduction of these species to Australia until that time had been largely accidental. In 1951, Donald led the first Australian plant-collecting expedition to the Mediterranean countries and with J.F. Miles collected extensively in North Africa. The expedition was co-sponsored by FAO. It was the forerunner of many other collecting expeditions that have followed. His collection, together with other material collected by C. Neal Smith in 1954, was the foundation of several large research programmes in CSIRO, the universities and state Departments of Agriculture carried out during the late '50s and the '60s. They resulted in many new cultivars. In retrospect these programmes were far more successful with annual than perennial species. Although many perennial pasture species were found in the Mediterranean countries, they survived as scattered plants often in protected areas. When the species were sown at densities appropriate to a pasture in Australia and constantly grazed as is the practice of Australian farmers, the plants thinned out during the first summer and were not capable of the high yields obtained from annual pastures that persisted through the summer as dormant seed at a high density. In general, only where the environment favoured plant growth for nine or more months of the year could perennials survive at a sufficiently high density to be as productive as annuals. This took some time to demonstrate, but was fairly well defined by the late 1960s by persons working with Colin Donald.
The Waite Institute years
In 1954, in succession to H.C. Trumble, Colin Donald was appointed the Waite Professor of Agriculture and Head of the Department of Agronomy at the Waite Agricultural Research Institute in the University of Adelaide. It was a position he held until his retirement in 1973, during a period of very rapid expansion of academic staff and postgraduate student numbers. For some time during the '60s his department was the largest single-chair department in the University of Adelaide, with 17 persons with academic status. He rebuilt the plant breeding group and fostered sections concerned with crop nutrition, animal nutrition and pasture utilisation, as well as supporting the strong core theme of agronomy and crop physiology. As a result of his farming background, his tertiary education at Hawkesbury College and the University of Sydney, his research in a state Department of Agriculture, CSIRO and the University and his perceptive intellect, he was able to make significant intellectual contributions to all sections of the Department. Understandably, his personal research and major interactions were with those staff concerned with plant competition and crop nutrition.
Within a few years of his arrival at the Waite Institute and the necessary expansion of his interests to crops as well as pastures he began applying his knowledge to competition among crop plants, notably in wheat or barley crops. In 1961 he wrote a review on competition for light in crops and pastures, and in 1963 another in which he considered all aspects of competition. It was the latter review of 118 pages in Advances in Agronomy that brought worldwide recognition of his clear exposition of the factors that influenced yields of plants when grown at the high densities of our commercial crops and pastures. This review arose out of a series of lectures he gave at Cornell University during a sabbatical leave. It emphasised, as had his earlier work on pasture plants, that the individual plants in a crop were severely limited in size and were often less than one-tenth the size of plants grown more widely spaced. But to obtain maximal yields per unit area, dense crops were needed. During the sabbatical in the United States, he saw the development of single-stalk maize crops producing single cobs under a high-nitrogen fertiliser regime and he was able to contribute to discussions of plant competition and growth.
In 1962 Donald was awarded the degree of Doctor of Science in Agriculture by the University of Sydney for his collected papers on 'Studies of the growth and ecology of pastures'. The collection had three main parts: pasture species in southern Australia, plant-soil interrelationships, and competition in pasture plants.
Colin Donald was aware that the person who had first encouraged farmers to grow subterranean clover in Australia was a farmer, Amos William Howard, who had lived at Littlehampton in the hills above Adelaide and had died in 1930. Donald had been curious about Howard and what had first caused him to recognise the merits of subterranean clover and to popularise its cultivation. Howard had found subterranean clover growing naturally on his property. It had probably arrived there as a contaminant in imported hay, as the plant is not indigenous to Australia but occurs extensively in the Mediterranean region. Howard had seen how its presence improved the productivity of his pastures. He wrote about its merits in the press and did everything he could to foster its adoption by other farmers. Howard's task had not been simple for, as the plant's name suggests, the seeds borne by the plant are subterranean and this presents difficulties to anyone wishing to harvest them. In 1963 Colin Donald suggested to the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science that Howard's name should be commemorated by a trust bearing his name. The Trust would disburse funds for research that would relate to the development, management and use of pastures. A public appeal for funds was launched and the Howard Memorial Trust came into being. It continues to be highly successful and more than a hundred research workers in Australia have had the benefit of its Fellowships since its inception.
Donald's ideas on competition led him to develop in 1968 the concept of the ideotype. This was a term he coined to be analogous to phenotype and genotype and which described an 'ideal' type. The concept was first introduced at the third International Wheat Genetics Symposium held in Canberra in 1968 and was received coolly by cereal breeders at the time. He believed it was possible to define a set of characters – the ideotype – which a crop or pasture plant should have if it were to perform well in the dense communities used by farmers when cultivating crops (see Figure 2).
He had noticed that cereal plants, early in the growing season, develop many tillers (branches), not all of which become culms and bear a head of grain at the end of the season. One of the characters of his cereal ideotype was that the plant should not tiller. He regarded the non-bearing tillers as a waste of resources and suggested that if uniculm plants could be produced by breeding, collectively they should be capable of a higher yield per unit area when grown at an appropriate density. The uniculm character, in conjunction with other characters, was the ideotype he proposed for wheat and barley. He suggested that the methods used by conventional plant breeders, when selecting for yield, would not select uniculms and were therefore inefficient in selecting plants that would give high yields in dense communities. For some years after his retirement, Donald worked on a programme to breed a cultivar of barley that conformed to his ideotype. He published one paper on this in 1979 but unfortunately ill-health terminated the work before there was any definitive outcome and comparisons with conventionally-bred cultivars of barley. His concept has remained contentious among breeders, many of whom believe the small loss of resources is not significant in relation to other issues such as the need for a higher seeding rate when sowing a uniculm. They also believe that an ability to tiller provides a plant with a degree of resilience or opportunism, given that growing seasons differ in their duration. They accept that if the growing season is abruptly terminated by dry weather, many tillers will die before they develop grain, but argue that if the season is prolonged, late tillers will develop grain. In 1991, a special issue of Field Crops Research (volume 26, part 2) was devoted to a review of the ideotype concept and touched on some of the aspects mentioned and evaluated its applicability to a wide range of crop and pasture plants. The term 'ideotype' that Colin Donald coined for desirable plant characters has earned him a lasting place in the international literature in crop science.
One of the other characters that occurs in Donald's ideotype for cereals is that they should have a high harvest index, by which he meant that the grain should represent a high proportion of the above-ground biomass at the time of harvest. In simple terms, there should be a lot of grain relative to the straw, which is not usually an economic product. The use of such an index was not new; it had been proposed by Bevan in 1914 and Niciporovic in 1956. Whereas Bevan thought the material in the grain was the result of transmission from the rest of the plant, more recent research had shown that a large proportion of it is the result of photosynthesis in the head itself. The consideration of photosynthesis in communities and competition among plants for light, and the idea that the lower parts of a plant could be a drain on the photosynthesis resources of other parts of the plant, were all part of Colin Donald's ideas on plants growing in communities. It was natural that a notion such as harvest index, despite its simple evaluation of a complex set of circumstances, should attract his attention. He believed that plant breeders should select those plants in their segregating populations that had a high harvest index. Again, as with the uniculm, the matter was contentious. Breeders did not deny that modern cultivars of wheat, barley and oats had a higher harvest index than cultivars produced 50–60 years before, but they were not prepared to accept the proposed physiological interpretation of this change. They had, after all, been breeding plants of shorter stature during that period to overcome lodging, which is the laying over of the crop that occurs near harvest if it is exposed to excessive wind and rain. Shorter crops were likely to have a higher ratio of grain to straw.
Colin Donald was very much a father figure in the department he led, with nearly all his staff being much younger in age, members of the expansion of the University in the 1950s. He was highly respected for his clear analytical mind, breadth of experience and ready wit. This wit always lay beneath the surface and could emerge even in the most serious moments of a university committee meeting. When an academic argued the value of assaying for weed seeds the filtrate coming from the Murray River's input to Adelaide's metropolitan water supply, notorious for its poor potability, Donald remarked that he thought the only objects filtered out by the Engineering and Water Supply Authority were the dead sheep.
During his busy period as the Waite Professor of Agriculture, Colin Donald only found time to write during the weekends. It was then he wrote several review papers that are notable for their insights and clarity and remain classics today. He encouraged his staff to publish, and would say to many that if they wrote just one sentence a day they would improve their rate of publication. No matter how busy he was, if asked to do so he would edit papers in a critically constructive way. Some were at first affronted by his suggested changes to their creations but they quickly realised that he had an exceptional flair for concise exposition of scientific subjects. Any paper he reviewed was unlikely to be rejected by a journal on editorial grounds.
Colin Donald was influential in several overseas programmes. In 1958, four years after his appointment as the Waite Professor of Agriculture, he was asked by the Bovril Company of the UK to provide an agronomist and to advise on pasture development for beef production in South America, especially Argentina. In 1959, he advised on pasture development in Sri Lanka during part of a study leave in that country. During the 1960s, several influential Australian agricultural scientists and economists suggested that Australia should be making a contribution to the agricultural development of the less developed countries of South-East Asia. In 1963 Donald led a mission to Indonesia and in 1965 he surveyed agricultural faculties in Malaysia, Thailand and the Philippines for the Department of External Affairs. The recommendations of these missions led ultimately to the formation in 1969 of the Australian–Asian Universities Cooperation Scheme (AAUCS) which became the Australian Universities International Development Program (AUIDP) and then the International Development Program (IDP) of Australian Universities and Colleges. The delay between the missions and the implementation of the scheme was due to the political unrest that occurred in the region during the mid 60s. The aim of the scheme was to foster agricultural development through the upgrading of the agricultural faculties and staffs of South-East Asian universities. The initial co-operation was in agriculture and demography as food production and population numbers were vitally important to these countries, but it later expanded and now covers all faculties of the universities. The missions realised that Australian aid was unlikely to be successful if targeted directly at farmers of the region. They were too numerous and there were cultural and language barriers to communication. On the other hand, if Australian scientists became involved with the academic and research communities of the countries in question and helped in their upgrading through higher degrees and specific courses, there would be a filter-down effect that would eventually improve farming practice. This has proved to be the case. Because of his own commitment, Colin Donald was strongly supportive of his staff who became involved in the programme in South-East Asia, and at an early stage he acted as supervisor to postgraduate students from the region. One of these, the late Professor Soetono of Brawijaya University in Java, developed some of the attributes possessed by Colin Donald and had a profound influence on agriculture development in east Java. From 1969 up to his retirement in 1973, Colin Donald was on the Standing Committee of the Australian–Asian Universities Cooperation Scheme. He hoped that after his retirement he would be able to be more deeply involved in AAUCS and overseas aid programmes, but regrettably this did not occur.
Donald served on many committees during the 1960s and 1970s. The most notable of these were the Advisory Council of CSIRO (1961–66), the Australian Research Grants Committee (1967–73) and the Wheat Industry Research Council (1973–75).
In 1961, Colin Donald was appointed a Fellow of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science and in 1962 he was president of the Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of Science (ANZAAS). He was a member of the Australian delegation to the United Nations conference on the application of science and technology in the less developed countries, held at Geneva in 1963. He was awarded the Farrer Memorial Medal in 1964 for outstanding service to Australian agriculture, and was elected a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1968. In 1984 the Australian Society of Agronomy, to commemorate him, instituted the C.M. Donald Medal which is awarded to persons who have made major contributions to agronomic research in Australia. One of the recipients described Colin Donald as the ideotype of an agronomist, a person with the ideal attributes and characters for agronomic investigation.
In 1979, Colin Donald was appointed by Her Majesty the Queen as a Commander of the British Empire.
On 13 March 1985, at the age of 75, Professor Donald died in Adelaide. He had profoundly influenced pasture development in Australia by understanding the limitations to pasture growth imposed by soils and environment, and had advanced our understanding of competition between plants when grown in communities. Because of his open nature and friendly disposition, he inspired many young researchers in agricultural science. He is the only agronomist yet to have been elected to the Australian Academy of Science.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 10(1), 1994. It was written by R. Knight, Waite Campus, University of Adelaide; and J.P. Quirk, Nedlands, Western Australia.