Alexander Killen Macbeth 1889–1957
Alexander Killen Macbeth was an Irish-born organic chemist who became a major figure in Australian chemistry.
Alexander Killen Macbeth (1889–1957) was an Irish-born organic chemist who became a major figure in Australian chemistry. He was appointed Angas Professor of Chemistry at the University of Adelaide in 1928. There, he rebuilt and modernised the Chemistry Department, helped establish the Johnson Chemical Laboratories, and played a central role in improving pharmacy education in South Australia.
Macbeth was a leader in applying ultraviolet spectroscopy to organic chemistry. During World War II, he led vital applied research efforts, including local production of pharmaceuticals such as sulfamerazine, phenacetin, and caffeine. He was elected a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1955.
Download the memoir
Alexander John Nicholson 1895–1969
Dr Alexander Nicholson CBE FAA was an entomologist who developed foundational theories of population regulation and natural selection, transformed Australian entomology into a rigorous science, and led CSIRO's Division of Entomology.
Alexander John Nicholson was born at Blackall, Co. Meath, Ireland, on March 25th, 1895. His parents had also been born in Ireland, although both came from English yeoman families of, at least on his mother's side, powerfully Methodist convictions. His father was a successful designing engineer, his mother a woman of acute and independent mind, and his elder brother an inventive member of the Royal Flying Corps. Of his two younger sisters, Nan, a trained kindergarten teacher, lived in Canberra for some years during the 30s and established the first preschool centre on the northern side of the young city.
The Nicholsons moved to England, where John (he appears never to have been known as Alexander) spent the rest of his childhood, except for holidays in Ireland. He shared the family bent for mechanisms and gadgets and the exciting new motor cycles, cars and aeroplanes, but his special interests were in photography and natural history. He became a member of the Birmingham Field Naturalists' Club (annual subscription one shilling) when 12 years old and, to balance it, joined the Midland Aero Club at 15, although there is no record that he actually flew. He entered the Waverley Road Secondary School, then remarkable for its new science laboratories, in 1908, and, despite some concern by his masters that he was more interested in natural history than in his formal subjects, matriculated with honours and an entry prize into Birmingham University in 1912. He graduated BSc in 1915 with First Class Honours in Zoology, Chemistry as a second subject, and Botany as a minor. He was not impressed with the course in chemistry, which consisted almost entirely in covering the board with structural formulae of dyestuffs, nor with what he termed the 'necrological approach' to zoology, which was concentrated on comparative anatomy and ignored physiology and the activities of living animals. Still he did get a grounding in classical evolutionary theory.
Then came the 1914–18 war. Already a member of the University OTC, Nicholson was commissioned 2nd Lieutenant in the Royal Field Artillery in 1915. He spent most of the next two years instructing – strenuous, because they were only allowed six weeks in which to produce gunners – and the rest of the war on active service in France and Belgium. He was promoted to 1st Lieutenant, twice mentioned in despatches and awarded the King's Commendation for bravery. The war left him with a cardiac lesion that limited strenuous activity for the rest of his life, and it was characteristic that even his closest friends did not know of this until after his death.
He returned to Birmingham in 1919 to begin postgraduate research on two entomological problems: ecology of the natural enemies of Chermes, an homopteran pest of pine trees; and development of the ovaries in the mosquito Anopheles maculipennis. The latter was a particularly neat piece of work, which has been referred to as a source of information even in recent publications, and he received an MSc for it in 1920. In March 1921 he was appointed the first McCaughey Lecturer in Entomology in the University of Sydney and given permission to spend some months studying entomological research and teaching in USA on his way to Australia. He was profoundly impressed by all that he saw, and especially by the high quality of applied entomology in that country. That trip was a sound investment by the senate of the university.
When Nicholson arrived in Sydney in October 1921, he was a slim, fresh-faced, rather shy young Englishman. He seemed at first to be rather hesitant, but nothing was further from the truth: he knew exactly what he wanted and (although he would never have thought to say so) intended to get it. He began with one great local advantage. The nominally independent McCaughey lectureship was associated with the Department of Zoology, which had recently been taken over by Launcelot Harrison who was rapidly transforming it into what was, during his too brief tenure of the Chair (he died in 1928), probably the keenest and most friendly department in the Faculty. Harrison welcomed Nicholson to his academic family. It was not difficult, because they were both first-class naturalists, they had both served in the British Army (the one in Palestine, the other in Europe), they were equally determined not to rear their students on an undiluted diet of morphology, and, although temperamentally poles apart, they were both fundamentally friendly people. In any case, no one could remain shy or inarticulate for long in the atmosphere that Harrison was fostering, and Nicholson was very responsive to goodwill.
Up to 1921, entomology was taught as a fragment of the Arthropoda in Zoology, and (by W.W. Froggatt) as a mixture of rather primitive natural history and blunderbus control measures in Agriculture. It was Nicholson's job to give it substance in both faculties, and this was urgent, because, as his observations in America had shown him, training by apprenticeship was just not good enough any longer in either the academic or the economic field.
It is useful to pause at this point to consider the state of entomology in Australia, particularly in Sydney, 50 years ago. The professionals were all self-trained or had served some form of apprenticeship. Thus, W.W. Froggatt, Government Entomologist in New South Wales from 1896 to 1923 and a most prolific writer, got most of his training as a collector for Sir William Macleay; his successor, W.B. Gurney, joined the department in 1900, but did not obtain a BSc (presumably as a part-time student) until 1925. In fact, A.R. Woodhill (who had the best of both worlds by taking Froggatt's course in 1920 and Nicholson's in 1923, and who succeeded Nicholson in the University in 1930) was, when he joined Gurney in 1924, probably the first graduate entomologist to be appointed to a Department of Agriculture in Australia. The situation was similar in the museums, and in the Commonwealth there were only F.H. Taylor and G.F. Hill who, up to that time, had been mostly concerned with medical entomology. Almost all these people who were paid for being entomologists had built their careers on a very modest level of secondary education.
The insects attracted few students in the universities. In Brisbane T. Harvey Johnston had two young graduates, Josephine Bancroft and O.W. Tiegs, who later became eminent, and in Sydney Harrison had done notable work on Mallophaga (most of it, actually, while he was in Cambridge). By far the most distinguished was R.J. Tillyard, a Cambridge graduate, who must rank in part with the amateurs, for he was a school teacher for several years before resuming academic life in Sydney University in 1913 as a Research Scholar and subsequently a Linnean Macleay Fellow. He went to the Cawthron Institute in New Zealand in 1920, was elected to the Royal Society of London in 1925, produced his classical Insects of Australia and New Zealand in 1926, and returned finally to Australia in 1928.
In fact, productive work in entomology at that time was predominantly taxonomic and predominantly in the hands of educated amateurs, mostly professional men with rather more leisure than is common today. Some of the most productive, in terms of publication, were A.J. Turner (Lepidoptera) and A.E. Shaw (Blattodea) in Brisbane; G.A. Waterhouse (Lepidoptera), H.J. Carter (Coleoptera), E.W. Ferguson (Diptera and Coleoptera), and R.J. Tillyard from 1907 to 1913 (Odonata) in Sydney; and the Reverend Thomas Blackburn (Coleoptera) in Adelaide. Of these seven, three were medical practitioners, one a metallurgical engineer, two schoolmasters, and one a clergyman. All were active in the local scientific societies, the Sydney group particularly in the Linnean Society of NSW and a small but lively entomological section of the Royal Zoological Society of NSW.
To return to the University, Nicholson was given a detached laboratory at the western end of the Zoology School, sufficient McCaughey funds to equip it modestly, the services of Miss Gwen Burns, a very competent photographic assistant in the Zoology School, and the task of preparing two sets of classes. The more urgent, first given in 1922, was a short introductory course in first year and a full one in second year in Agriculture; the other a two-term course that could be taken by Science students as an alternative to vertebrate zoology. Nicholson described his plan, in retrospect, in the following words:
The basis of both courses was general systematics, morphology, and general biology. Only sufficient of this was given to Agriculture students to provide a firm basis for an intelligent development of the subject of economic entomology, to which I naturally had to devote as much time as I could. With Science students I made little more than passing reference to insect pests and their control, treating entomology simply as a component of Zoology and going into greater detail with morphology, systematics and biology.
He had to face three problems in putting his plans into effect. He had to obtain a knowledge of the strange Australian fauna that he was seeing for the first time, to devise means to bring his courses to life, and to learn about the pest species and their control. The last was the easiest. Many of the pests were immigrants (or at least related to northern-hemisphere species), he already knew something of the situation in Europe and America, and he was able to obtain state departmental help, particularly from Gurney, to fill in the local picture. The need was to foster a new approach, rather than to look for new pests.
The only solution to the first problem was to go into the field and learn for himself. His first trips were to Woy Woy and the Blue Mountains with Tillyard and A.L. Tonnoir, who were visiting Australia to fill gaps in their own research material, and Harrison took him to the Blue Mountains and Mt Kosciusko; but he received the greatest help from the band of able, enthusiastic amateurs mentioned earlier. He was quickly elected to the Linnean and Royal Zoological Societies and joined in their discussions (especially over coffee after the meetings), but, more important, somebody was always going off in the weekends, or even during the week, to collect in some favourite spot. G.M. Goldfinch, a lepidopterist, had a roomy Essex car which he regularly filled with congenial entomologists. Waterhouse and Ferguson had cars too and Nicholson later acquired a Morris Cowley of his own. There were frequent parties to the Zoological Society's cottage in the National Park (especially in the early spring), to many other parts of the Hawkesbury Sandstone area at all seasons, and sometimes further afield. A notable later trip that he made was with P.D.F. Murray to Papua and New Guinea. On these trips Nicholson always seemed to be dawdling behind the rest of the party, but he regularly ended up with a greater number and variety of specimens than any one else. There was, too, considerable mutual stimulation, the specialists widening their interests to all orders under his influence and he learning a great deal about their own groups from them. That was not always true, for sometimes he could show them something they had not known about the biology of their own species.
The results of these activities were a remarkably wide knowledge of Australian insects (second only to Tillyard's) acquired in a remarkably short time, and a notable teaching collection of which Mrs J.W. Evans (a daughter of Tillyard and herself an entomologist) wrote much later:
… it became my responsibility for a year or two to care for the [Zoology] Department's entomological collections. A great deal of this had been collected by Nic across his Sydney years and I was amazed at the industry and the vastness of the field he had covered. It goes without saying that it was all, over 30 years afterwards, perfectly mounted and preserved and it brought alive most vividly A.J.N.'s early field trips in Australia.
There remained the problem of balancing his teaching with an adequate leavening of general biology. The special physiology of insects was little known at that time, but Nicholson taught what he could, sometimes, he thought, rather rashly. He inaugurated field excursions to show his students how insects lived and what they did, but there was not room in the timetable for enough of them. As well as pinned adults, his collections included immature stages and the results of insect activity, and these could be used in practical classes; but that was still not enough, so he resolved to supplement his efforts by photography. This could be done in the laboratory, where he was ably assisted by Miss Burns, or in the field, for which he developed an ingenious telescopic range-finder for his camera and learned to use flashlight effectively both in shade and at night. He photographed everything of interest that he saw, and thus was able to illustrate his lectures by a remarkable series of lantern-slides of larval and adult insects going about their normal business in their natural habitats. Nearly 40 years later he adapted a Leica camera to do the same work in colour.
The history of entomology in Australia has been divided (1) into four periods: Fabrician (1770–1860) when explorers sent their material to Europe for study; Macleayan (1861–1890) when the study came increasingly to be done in Australia; the period of the amateurs touched on earlier; and the period of the professionals. Nicholson's arrival marked the beginning of the transition between the last two. He put university teaching on a firm scientific foundation, and provided the first agricultural graduates to bring a new approach to economic entomology in this country. He had few students in pure science (Mary Fuller, who died young, was the most promising), and it was not until a separate honours year was instituted by the Faculty of Science after he left that the foundation he laid could be built on effectively. Nevertheless, the wind of change was blowing steadily and with increasing strength. Lectureships (and one Chair) were established in other universities, the demands of state departments grew steadily, and the Commonwealth established the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) in 1926 with G.A. Julius, A.C.D. Rivett and W.J. Newbigin (succeeded in 1927 by A.E.V. Richardson) as its first Executive. Young people interested in insects no longer became doctors or schoolteachers and devoted their leisure to their hobby; they took an appropriate degree in a university and made entomology their profession, with ever widening fields of research and ever increasing technical and financial resources before them. It could fairly be said that, so far as Australia is concerned, Nicholson in a sense began it all.
In 1927 he found himself with the task of preparing a presidential address for the Royal Zoological Society of NSW. He looked through his slides to find what subject he could illustrate best, and decided on mimicry. At about the same time a bright student had raised doubts about the generality of the rather crude concepts of population dynamics that then prevailed. This concurrence of unrelated events led to the production of a very important paper which has not received the attention it deserved. He not only gave a comprehensive review of mimicry and concealing coloration in Australian insects and demonstrated the reality of the phenomena, he also stated the basic principles and hypotheses that he was to spend much of the rest of his life in testing and amplifying. In brief, the thesis he developed was that animal populations could not survive in nature unless their densities were governed by some regulatory (feedback) mechanism that was density-dependent in its operation; that success in searching for essential resources was the only mechanism that was truly density-dependent, all others being merely modifying; that the 'power of discovery' of natural enemies could regulate the abundance of both parasites and hosts; and that natural selection did not determine survival and abundance, it merely ensured that any form of a species that acquired an inheritable advantage, however slight, would progressively replace the previously successful form. In the immediate context, survival and abundance of the mimetic or procryptic insects studied seemed clearly to depend on density-dependent stresses operating on their immature stages, the perfection of their concealment or mimicry on quite minor selective pressures imposed by predators on the adults. The theory was well documented, it gave a credible explanation of the phenomena observed, and it was free from the objections that had been raised against previous theories, some of which, as Nicholson pointed out, were due to failure to understand what Darwin had meant by natural selection. For this work he was awarded a DSc of Sydney University in 1929.
He then concentrated on theoretical population dynamics, using arithmetical models of situations approximating to ones that he knew occurred in nature, and examining more particularly, though not exclusively, various kinds of host-parasite interactions. He soon found, to his surprise, that the equilibrium produced was not a steady one, but generally more or less violently fluctuating. V.A. Bailey came into collaboration with him at this time, using more sophisticated mathematical treatment that gave generality to the results, and they found that the fluctuations were due to time displacements associated with length of life cycle. They wrote a book (finished in 1931) on the theory and its implications, but it was 'too theoretical' to find favour with the publishers' readers of the day, and their results ultimately appeared in a rather scattered series of joint and separate papers.
In the mean time, R.J. Tillyard had returned to Australia in 1928 as Chief of the newly established Division of Economic Entomology of CSIR. He gathered the nucleus of a staff about him, and they set about helping him to plan the research and the laboratories at Canberra. Tillyard proved to be an extraordinarily stimulating scientist, but an unpredictable administrator. To balance this, the Executive appointed G .A. Waterhouse (then Curator of the Division) as its Executive Officer. He remained only a year, and in 1929 Nicholson was offered the position of Deputy Chief. He accepted on the condition that he should spend most of 1930 in England as he had already planned. He undertook a number of enquiries for the Division while abroad, and arrived in Canberra towards the end of that year.
He found his position difficult, and the times were difficult too; no new developments could be planned, so he sought transfer, as a Senior Entomologist, to the sheep blowfly investigations, which had been established before the depression began. During the next year and a half, he helped to guide the entomological side of the Section's work and began two pieces of personal research. One was a study of traps and baits, for which he designed ingenious ways to reduce the action of external variables, and the other a study of the effects of temperature on the activity of the adult flies. Tillyard became ill before the trapping studies were completed (2), Nicholson was appointed Acting Chief in April 1933, and from then on he had little opportunity for personal research until after the war.
In 1933 he married Phyllis Heather Jarrett, MSc, a former CSIR research student and at the time a plant pathologist in the Division of Plant Industry, and she assisted him for some years thereafter as an unofficial technical secretary. They had two sons, Garth Alexander, who was a CSIRO scholar at Geelong Grammar School and graduated MB, BS (Sydney) in 1967, and Peter John, who graduated BEc (Sydney) in 1968.
The financial situation was still precarious in 1933, and the Executive had not been happy about some of the Division's work. Nicholson, aided by his senior staff (G.F. Hill, I.M. Mackerras, G.A. Currie, A.L. Tonnoir), gave it stability during this period. He planned with great care, and strove especially, as he did in all subsequent years, for a judicious balance between fundamental and applied research. He emphasised, indeed, that the need for fundamental research was probably greater at that time in economic entomology than in any other applied science. The Executive were irritated by the, to them, inordinate time he often took to develop his proposals, but they came to respect the final clarity of their presentation, their wisdom, and his unswerving scientific integrity. His appointment was confirmed in 1936. The same qualities – and Rivett's support – held the Division together during the following years, when there were moves to abandon taxonomy to the museums and distribute some of its other activities among the sister Divisions to which they were relevant.
Tillyard's main theme had been biological control of weed and insect pests. Some of his people had already found it necessary to approach their problems more broadly, and Nicholson further widened the approach and the range of problems under study. Biological control remained an important activity, but on a more cautious and critical basis; ecology, with emphasis on the interactions of the animals rather than the physical background, became the major theme in most investigations; biochemical studies increased; physiology and toxicology found a specific place in 1938; important protozoological and virological investigations were undertaken for the Division of Animal Health; and taxonomic research expanded. It was a fertile period, too, in the studies of life histories and general biology of the insects. In 1938 he visited research institutions abroad, and gave a paper to the 7th International Congress of Entomology in Berlin, in which he stressed the fundamental importance of detailed ecological studies of pest populations in planning the use of pesticides and assessing the results achieved. This paper was the forerunner of the modern concept of strategic pest control.
The war affected the Division in two ways: it took away nearly a third of the scientific staff on active service, and it caused a reorientation of the efforts of those that remained. In particular, a strong team, initially under F.N. Ratcliffe, was directed to studies of the pests of stored products, with results of substantial value to the general war effort; and D.F. Waterhouse did very valuable work in collaboration with the army medical services on the development of repellents and other entomological aspects of the control of malaria and scrub typhus. Ratcliffe became an Army malariologist; Waterhouse was appointed to the Reserve of Officers to be called up as needed, and so close was the collaboration that it was difficult to know at any given moment whether he was on active service or a civilian scientist. Nicholson strongly supported all these activities, served on the Medical Services Advisory Committee, and, in his spare time designed an acoustically controlled torpedo for use against submarines.
The atmosphere became more favourable after the war. The Division had made its mark, there were increasing demands for a greater range and diversity of studies, and the Executive had come to appreciate the importance of Nicholson's own field, and his reputation in it, more fully than they did before the war. Cattle tick research (begun during the war) became a major activity; the work on pests of stored grain was continued, ecological studies were extended to pasture, forest and fruit pests not previously investigated; much was to be learned about the new insecticides that had been developed during and after the war; the concept of integrated control was beginning to take shape; a distinguished school of insect physiology and biochemistry was growing up in the Division; studies of the transmission of plant viruses were begun; and a small unit of experimental population dynamics was set up for Nicholson's own work. The rate of staffing shows the overall growth most simply. In 1929, when the Canberra laboratory was occupied, the scientific staff (including graduate assistant and equivalent) was 12; in 1933, when Nicholson took over from Tillyard, it was 16, rising to 23 in 1939, and falling (in effect) to 14 during the war. It rose again to 29 in 1946, 37 in 1949 and 43 in 1959 (3). All this expansion threw additional burdens on the Chief, and he was given progressively increasing administrative assistance to cope with them. This enabled him to do some personal research, though never as much as he could have wished.
Nicholson disliked rigid sectionalisation of research and an hierarchical arrangement of staff. His policy was 'to give each research worker full responsibility and great freedom within his allotted field of investigation', and to draw all members of a team into the planning of that team's activities. To these ends, he gradually abolished most of the pre-war sections, replacing them by three broad groups – taxonomic, ecological, physiological-biochemical – and substituting leadership resulting from recognised ability for direction. Of the three groups, taxonomy and physiology-biochemistry were relatively clearly defined, ecology more loosely linked and occupied with a less coherent range of problems and activities. There was, however, considerable flexibility. Thus, veterinary entomology and termite research retained much of their sectional identity, but with links in all three directions, and some more isolated investigations, such as the earth mite and lucerne flea studies in Western Australia, remained relatively discrete. He stressed, too, that physiological and biochemical problems could usually be defined with comparative precision and lead to the production of neat, scientifically acceptable papers, though also revealing very quickly the deficiencies of an inadequate worker; whereas ecological work generally lacked an established theoretical foundation, and was consequently likely to be relatively diffuse and productive of long, less immediately satisfying publications. The assessment of merit in these divergent fields worried him. Nevertheless, he had a keen eye for work that was intellectually demanding and likely to be intellectually rewarding, and his policy seemed, in general, to work very well. The Division was successful, which is the crucial test.
Nicholson completed his term as Chief in March 1960, and was appointed to a Senior Research Fellowship to continue his twin studies of population dynamics and natural selection. His unit was also retained for long enough to finish the experiments he had already planned, but his main task was to prepare his findings for publication. This had not been completed when he became ill, his damaged heart failed, and he died on October 28th, 1969.
It is difficult to give a brief account of his population studies because they are inherently complex and have been bedevilled by criticism and misunderstanding. It is, in fact, necessary at the outset to repeat his basic postulate in purely general terms, as all his major conclusions follow from it and it has been completely ignored by all his major critics. It is simply that no intrinsically variable phenomenon can continue to exist in the absence of a feedback mechanism to limit its variability; in the specific context, animal populations, in places where they can exist at all, are governed fundamentally by processes that are density dependent, all other influences being merely modifying, and the actual population level at any moment being the result of interaction between the governing and modifying processes. It is to be noted, too, that the differences between the two sets of processes are qualitative, not quantitative, a fundamental point that critics have also failed to appreciate.
In the first, rather extended phase, as already noted, he developed a complex structure of theory by applying his basic premise to a variety of imagined natural situations. After the war, he was able to test many of his conclusions on experimentally manipulated populations. Initially, following I.S. Srnith and his colleagues of Riverside, California, who had arrived independently at essentially similar conclusions, he used housefly puparia and the parasite Nasonia vitripennis. These gave trouble, so he turned to the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina, which had proved itself to be a remarkably biddable laboratory animal, and he abandoned the examination of host-parasite interactions (temporarily, he thought) for a detailed study of intraspecific competition. Most of the results of this phase were presented, at least in outline, to various congresses and symposia, of which he attended no less than six between 1947 and 1959. It is worth noting, in view of criticisms that have been made of laboratory ecology, that the field ecology of L. cuprina had been studied in considerable detail by Mary Fuller (4), and that Nicholson's findings, though quantitatively much more precise, were completely in accord with hers.
In his mimicry paper he had developed the theme of random search and discovery as the basis of density-dependent reactions, but he soon transferred the emphasis to the competitive element that is inherent in the search, and he used the word 'competition' in this sense (sometimes to the confusion of his critics) in all his subsequent work. Basically, in his view, populations of any species are governed (not determined) by some form of intraspecific competition for essential resources (nutrients, places to live, and so on) (5), but this can produce two distinct results. Usually (as with flies in carrion) provision of the resources is independent of the population, so their varying level in the environment serves simply as a modifying influence: only the single population is governed. When, however, the resource is itself a living organism and the association is sufficiently specific and destructive, the populations of both predator and prey (or parasite and host) are governed by the competition among the attackers for their essential living resource, each population interacting with the other. This is what has happened, for example, with Cactoblastis and prickly pear. On the other hand, in more usual forms of interspecific competition (as between different species of blowflies in a carcass) each species acts merely as a modifying influence on the others' populations.
Balance is the resultant of two opposing 'forces', the reproductive capacity ('power of increase') of the organisms on the one side, and the governing + modifying stresses on the other, the level of balance varying with changes in any of the three components. Thus the 'steady density' is always more or less unsteady in natural populations. Reproductive capacity is always greater, generally very much greater, than is necessary to maintain populations under favourable conditions, and Nicholson stressed that this gives the population great resilience in coping with adversity, as was abundantly demonstrated in his experiments. For example, in a stabilised population governed by competition for larval food, destruction of 99% of the adults before they could lay eggs resulted (through relaxation of the larval competition) in a compensatory sixfold increase in the number of pupae maturing in the next generation. This effect could be maintained indefinitely by continuing the destruction of adults in succeeding generations, and it could be produced equally well by replacing mechanical destruction by competition between the adults for limited supplies of the protein food necessary for them to mature their eggs. That last series of experiments was particularly interesting, because it was found that larval competition could be replaced completely by adult competition; and, when mutant adults capable of maturing eggs on progressively smaller quantities of protein appeared and became selected in these cultures, balance was still maintained, but at progressively altered levels; until, finally, mutants able to mature eggs without any protein food also appeared and the population showed evident indications of beginning to explode.
These are the broadest of Nicholson's conclusions (with some illustrative examples) and they should be applicable to all animal populations – and presumably to plant populations too. However, his models were insects, in most of which there is a sharp ecological dissociation between the larval and adult populations of the species, and some of his subsidiary findings may depend upon that fact. The phenomenon of oscillation, which he examined in great detail in his later work, may be one, and so too may be some of the detailed results mentioned above. On the whole, however, it would appear that the disadvantages of using models with specialized life cycles were more than offset by the advantages of being able to define and measure their population structure with accuracy and precision.
Other aspects of intraspecific (and some of interspecific) competition could have been quoted, and the interactions between natural enemies and their hosts were studied in similar detail, though only at the theoretical level. In short, by his meticulous examination of the ways in which both governing and modifying processes could act, and of the manifold effects of altering them, Nicholson provided a system of thought which could serve as a basis for modern work on integrated control and pest management. This, indeed, was an aim that he himself had clearly in mind.
He was a slow worker (each experiment had in any case to run for at least eight months and often much longer) and an even slower writer. He was greatly concerned with the use of words and spent a great deal of time in choosing exactly the right ones to convey his meaning – and perhaps even more in eliminating redundancies and compressing what he had to say into the minimum amount of space. This made for clarity, but not always for easy reading. He was, too, sensitive to criticism, and inclined to spend more time than it warranted in answering it. The famous controversy with Andrewartha and Birch is a case in point. However, the crux of the problem lay in the complexity of his subject. Knowing, as a realist, that the time before him must steadily be growing shorter, he endeavoured to break his material into a series of papers to be completed sequentially, but at every turn he found himself faced with points that required cross-reference to other parts still not written. This grew so distracting that he reverted to his original plan to put it all into a single book. He was still organising this when he died. He left notes, graphs, and experimental records in very good order, and it is to be hoped that some one expert in the field may be found to integrate them into something resembling the treatise that he did not finish.
His studies of natural selection were more complete, though not all of his experimental evidence got into his published reports. What he did, in essence, was to clarify what Darwin and Wallace meant by natural selection and show how it worked. His thesis may be summarised in five statements.
- Fitness, in the sense of Darwin and Wallace, is relative, like the fitness of the tall player who can manipulate a basket-ball over the heads of his shorter fellows.
- There are two kinds of natural selection: environmental (Wallacean) in which the less fit are eliminated in periods of adversity; and competitive (Darwinian) in which the more fit displace the less fit in the struggle for existence, whether the environment varies or not. Both operate, alone or in conjunction, the Darwinian being the more powerful and the only one that can, by itself, lead to improved exploitation of the environment.
- Natural selection operates in balanced populations which have inherent resilience in coping with variations in environmental stresses – that is, a substantial degree of homoeostasis. Consequently, any variant that possesses an inheritable quality giving it an immediate advantage, however slight, will progressively displace the previously successful members of the population, and the governing mechanisms will progressively adjust the balance to meet the new circumstances. Selection, in fact, is limited only by the capacity of the gene pool to produce advantageous variants, and hyperadaptation is the normal end result. All these occurrences were observed in the experimental populations of Lucilia cuprina, of which an example has been given above.
- There is nothing purposive in natural selection. Population levels are not determined, nor necessarily much influenced, by it, nor has it necessarily anything to do with survival of the species. It can produce novelties, which may be ultimately disadvantageous like the antlers of the Irish elk, or potentially advantageous like his own strain of flies that could mature eggs without a protein meal; it does ensure 'biological improvement' of the population; and it can assist indirectly (as well as directly) in the process of speciation.
- The post-Darwinian concept of selection producing a precise fit between organism and environment, like the exact fit of a complicated key in its lock (Fisher), is false. There is no need for this kind of 'fitness', no evidence that it exists, and no way in which either Darwinian or Wallacean natural selection can produce it. Inferences that have been based on it should therefore be re-examined.
Looking at his publications as a whole, three stand out as having all the qualities of enduring classics: the 1927 study of mimicry, which has been too badly neglected; the 1933 statement of population theory, of which C.A. Fleschner, of Riverside, wrote (in litt.) in 1970 that it was far superior for teaching the principles of biological control to anything that has been published since; and the 1960 analysis of natural selection, which is so well documented that it should have a deep influence on modern thinking in population genetics and evolutionary theory.
Like his father and brother, Nicholson was an inventive designer of equipment. He delighted in gadgets, as he did in words and their uses, but always for the functions they could perform in solving problems that concerned him. His own were aesthetically pleasing, because they did exactly what was required of them with a minimum of complication and effort. A few have been mentioned on earlier pages, the remainder were developed for his population studies. They included simple tissue grinders (published in 1951) that disintegrated all cells and most nuclei, photoelectric equipment to count blowfly eggs, a fractionator for separating the stages of Lucilia cuprina, a pneumatic method of capturing living flies, and an instantaneous vacuum cleaner for collecting empty puparial shells. Descriptions of the last two were left in a sufficiently advanced state to be completed as a posthumous publication.
He had another great interest, but lightly touched on so far, and that was his love of natural history. Wherever he went, he observed, photographed, and collected. After the war, he and his wife acquired a weekend cottage at Bawley Point on the coast, where they spent most of their leisure, and where he brought his colour photography to its highest level. He did not confine himself to insects, but photographed birds, frogs, plants, and indeed any living thing that caught his eye; he even developed underwater equipment to record the doings of marine animals, and used it to great effect when he visited a coral cay. He extended his records of mimicry, made new observations on pollination of orchids by male wasps, and studied the stridulatory mechanism of the whistling moth. His opportunities increased after he retired as Chief, and still more when his research fellowship ended officially in 1966, although he continued to work in the laboratory. The last nine years, when he was free from responsibility and could do what he thought most satisfying, were probably the happiest in his life.
His love of natural history was reflected also in his strong support of conservation in ANZAAS and Academy deliberations, and in the very active part he played in the successful effort of the Royal Society of Canberra to get the Tidbinbilla Fauna Reserve established.
Nicholson had his share, too, in the gregarious activities of scientific societies. He was elected to the Linnean Society of NSW in 1922, served on Council in 1928–29, and remained a member until his death. He was a member of the Royal Zoological Society of NSW (President 1926–27) and of the Royal Society of Australia (6) (President 1951, Council for several years); foundation member of the Australian Institute of Agricultural Science, the Ecological Society of Australia, and the Australian Entomological Society; foundation President of the National Parks Association of ACT; and a Fellow of ANZAAS (President of Section D 1947). He was a Foundation Fellow of the Academy, its first Biological Secretary in 1954–55, Vice-President in 1955–57, the first 'amicus curiae' appointed to serve as a link between the young Council and the even younger Sectional Committees, and the initiator of the Academy's proposal to the Commonwealth government for establishment of a research museum of Australian biology in Canberra. He made a significant contribution to the stability and steady growth of the Academy in those early difficult years.
He received several awards in addition to his higher degrees: the Clarke Medal of the Royal Society of NSW in 1952; CBE in 1961; Honorary Fellowship of the Royal Entomological Society of London in 1961; and Honorary Membership of the British Ecological Society in 1963, the only worker in Australia to have been so honoured. He will be long remembered for initiating the professional era in Australian entomology, for his contributions to the development of the Division of Entomology in CSIRO, for the publication of three enduring classics, and, by those who knew him, for his quiet friendliness, wise counsel, and complete integrity.
This account of John Nicholson's life and times was based on his own notes, on information provided mainly by Mrs Phyllis Nicholson and Dr D.F. Waterhouse, and on the memories of my friendship that lasted for 48 years.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Records of the Australian Academy of Science, vol. 2(1), 1970. It was written by Ian Murray Mackerras, FRACP, Research Fellow in the Division of Entomology, CSIRO. He was elected a Fellow of the Academy in 1954 and was on the Council in 1955–57.
Notes
(1) Proceedings of the Royal Society of Queensland, 60 (1949). pp. 69–71.
(2) In any case, concurrent studies in the field were beginning to throw considerable doubt on the potential value of trapping as a control measure.
(3) CSIR became CSIRO and the Division dropped 'Economic' from its title in 1949. Its scientific staff has since grown to 95 in 1969.
(4) CSIR Bulletin No. 82 (1934)
(5) He distinguished between two kinds of competition: 'scramble', a continuing struggle which is wasteful of resources and leads to violent oscillations in population density; and 'contest', as in territorial animals, which conserves resources and results in steadier population levels.
(6) Royal Society of Canberra from 1955.
Alexander George Ogston 1911-1996
Alexander George Ogston, the first of six children, was born on 30 January 1911, in Bombay, India, where his father, Walter Henry Ogston, of firmly Aberdonian ancestry, was a businessman for twenty years. His mother, nee Josephine Elizabeth Carter, fourteen years younger than her husband, trained at the Froebel Educational Institute as a teacher, won silver and gold medals at University College, London, studying biological sciences, but married before completing her degree.
Written by O. Smithies.
- Science
- Early days
- World War II
- Postwar work at Oxford
- The Australian years, 1960-70
- Trinity College, 1970-78
- Retirement years, 1978-96
- A well-balanced life
- Family
- About this memoir
For science is more than the search for truth, more than a challenging game, more than a profession. It is a life that a diversity of people lead together, in the closest proximity, a school for social living. We are members one of another.
A. G. Ogston, 1970 lecture to the Australian Biochemical Society
In 1984, at the age of 73, Alexander ('Sandy') Ogston, with the gentle encouragement of Professor R. B. ('David') Fisher as an interviewer, recorded a video tape of his life and science (now in the Biochemistry Society Archives). A few years later, in 1988, he completed a more comprehensive written account in his 'Reminiscences, 1911-1988' (now in the Royal Society Archives in London). These eloquent records and a published lecture given in 1970 to the Australian Biochemical Society (119a) have provided much of the material for the present biographical memoir and are quoted or paraphrased extensively. Unannotated 'quotes' are from Sandy's own accounts or his papers.
Science
Ogston published his first three scientific papers in 1935 (1–3); in them he used a physical chemical method (potentiometric titration) to investigate the nature of several biologically relevant substances (amino acids, vitamin B1 and xanthines). Almost fifty years later, in 1982, he published his last paper (127), of which he was the sole author; it also applied physical chemical principles (kinetic and equilibrium parameters) to a biologically relevant problem (enzymatically catalyzed reversible reactions). Essentially all of Ogston's work between these publications had this same theme – the application of physical chemistry to biology. He claimed not to be irrevocably committed to any particular biological problem or to any particular physico-chemical method, and described the span of his work in typically self-deprecating terms as 'rather a kind of grasshopper existence' putting his 'oar into this or that thing'. In reality he was a deeply committed physical chemist who found many puzzling problems in biology irresistible, and who constantly kept himself informed in a variety of fields. Not surprisingly, therefore, any selection of Ogston's most significant publications spans a wide range of problems. Most of them also illustrate Sandy's intellectual signature – an ability to arrive at simple solutions to complex problems. And, despite his assertions to the contrary, there is one long-term problem to which he returned many times – the complex physical chemistry and biology of hyaluronic acid.
Perhaps the foremost example of Sandy's intellectual ability is a brief one column letter to Nature (37), published in 1948 at a time when biochemists were deeply involved in deciphering the intermediary chemical steps in carbohydrate and amino acid metabolism. The Krebs citric acid cycle, originally proposed by Krebs & Johnson (1937), was being subjected to detailed tests by many investigators including Wood et al. (1941). These investigators studied the fate of the isotopic carbon following the biosynthesis of oxaloacetate from pyruvate and isotopically labelled CO2. Hans Krebs had postulated in his cycle that oxaloacetate condenses with a second pyruvate molecule to yield citric acid and eventually a-keto-glutaric acid. Because citric acid is a symmetric molecule, the expectation was that the CO2-derived isotope in a-ketoglutaric acid would be found equally distributed between its two carboxyl groups: one next to a methylene group and the other next to a carbonyl group. Wood et al. found all the isotope in the latter; they therefore excluded the symmetrical molecule citric acid as an intermediate. A comparable situation arose when Shemin (1946) found that serine isotopically labelled in both its amino and carboxyl groups yielded glycine with the two isotopes still in the same proportion as in the input serine; he concluded that amino-malonic acid (a symmetrical molecule) was thereby excluded as an intermediate.
Ogston, in his videotaped interview, describes how he initially accepted these conclusions, but suddenly realized the fallacy of the premise on which they were based: that two identical groups of a symmetrical molecule cannot be distinguished. 'On the contrary, it is possible that an asymmetric enzyme which attacks a symmetrical compound can distinguish between its identical groups'. (37) He demonstrated this with a simple diagram accompanied by a brief explanation showing how two seemingly identical elements in a substrate will behave differently when acted on by an enzyme if combination between the symmetrical substrate and the enzyme occurs at three points with the catalytic activity being at only one of the points.
The Ogston concept of 'three-point attachment', conceived in two seconds and written the next day, was widely and rapidly accepted. Indeed, shortly after publication of the idea, Krebs wrote excitedly to Sandy and subsequently spent much of his 1949 Harvey Lecture (Krebs 1949) on the topic. Krebs' lecture included the statement that the 'ideas which Ogston has initiated thus offer a satisfactory explanation for the mechanism of formation of optically active substances in biological material'. Sandy was always somewhat embarrassed by the importance others placed on an idea that had been conceived in such a brief time!
A problem that occupied Ogston's attention for a much longer time but eventually yielded to his theoretical treatment was prompted by an observation by McFarlane (1935). Sandy described the situation succinctly in his 1970 lecture to the Australian Biochemical Society (119a) as 'an apparent conversion in the ultracentrifuge of the globulin fraction [at that time only two fractions had been described in plasma proteins] into the albumin fraction to an extent that increased as the total concentration increased'. Ogston was intrigued by this problem to the extent that in the late 1930s he performed experiments on the osmotic pressures of mixtures of proteins, their ultraviolet absorption spectra, potentiometric titration curves and salting out. No explanation was forth-coming. However, the problem continued to interest Sandy sufficiently that after World War II he and his doctoral student J. P. ('Johnny') Johnston carefully surveyed the behaviours of mixtures of proteins in the ultracentrifuge. In his reminiscences, Sandy modestly records:
The following June found us with an accumulation of results but still with no satisfactory explanation. I went on holiday leaving 'Johnny' to write a thesis. Within a week he wrote to me what in qualitative terms was clearly the correct explanation. I had only to put what became known as the 'Johnston-Ogston effect' into mathematical form.
The resulting paper by Johnston and Ogston (27) is an elegant restatement of the problem and of earlier attempts at solving it. Their words (slightly paraphrased) are:
The idea is a very simple one. If molecules of the slower protein move faster in the absence of the faster protein, behind the faster boundary, than in its presence ahead of it, then...the concentration of slower protein above the faster boundary must be greater than below it. So the size of the slower boundary is actually increased, while that of the faster is apparently decreased – when observed refractometrically – by an exactly equivalent amount. It looks as if faster protein is being converted to slower. Since the effect on velocity increases with total concentration, it looks as if conversion increases with concentration.
This is comparable to the way that traffic speeds are affected by traffic density. Automobiles can travel faster when traffic density is low than when it is high and the effect becomes greater as the traffic density (its 'concentration') increases. Johnston and Ogston validated their theoretical treatment by demonstrating that the coloured protein carboxyhaemoglobin mixed with g-globulin (a larger molecule) was more concentrated above than below the sedimentation boundary of the faster-sedimenting protein.
Sandy could transform questions from his students into significant contributions to knowledge. I recall my admiration when an essay describing an obviously impossible metabolic scheme (to generate by cyclical oxidation and reduction an energy-rich phosphate bond in phosphoenoloxaloacetate from an energy-poor phosphoester bond in phosphomalate) was transformed by Ogston into a respectable article in Physiological Review (35). This review extended the thermodynamic and kinetic understanding of metabolic sources of energy by developing the idea that gradients of chemical potential can generate energy. Ogston showed that suitable carriers could allow energy to be derived from the coupled transfer of hydrogen from a low partial pressure of oxygen at an initial site of substrate oxidation to a higher partial pressure close to that of molecular oxygen. However, he also stressed that constraints imposed by the kinetics of the system should not be overlooked.
The relationship between thermo-dynamic and kinetic factors remained a life-long interest to Ogston: his last theoretical paper (127), one page in length, was titled 'A New Relationship Between Kinetic and Equilibrium Parameters of Reversible Reactions'. Less brief was his collaborative treatise with C. C. Michel (125) in which a non-equilibrium thermo-dynamic treatment led to 'General Descriptions of Passive Transport of Neutral Solute and Solvent Through Membranes'. Its twenty pages, the result of three years of work at a time when Ogston was also the President of Trinity College, Oxford, are packed with difficult and somewhat impenetrable equations.
Ogston had a scientific love affair with hyaluronic acid, which first began in 1938 with studies of the oestrus-dependent swelling of the sexual skin of Rhesus monkeys (with his brother-in-law John Philpot and Solly [later Lord] Zuckerman), and continued with work on the contents of synovial fluid, initially with his student and friend Jean E. Stanier. Later work was with J.P. Johnston, B.I. Aldrich, C.C. Curtain, J.H. Fessler, B.S. Blumberg, C.F. Phelps, T.F. Sherman, M. Davies, B.N. Preston, T.C. Laurent, L.W. Nichol and P. Silpananta. In summarizing this work, Ogston wrote in his Reminiscences that a 'variety of physico-chemical methods established...[the] particle weight [of hyaluronic acid] and its random chain-polymeric structure' and demonstrated 'its capacity to prevent surfaces from coming into contact under compression'. This last property is vital to the physiology of joints, and might not have been considered by a less biologically inclined physical chemist. 'Each molecule ...occupies an enormous volume of solution. Consequently, at concentrations of physiological interest, neighbouring molecules must overlap or interpenetrate extensively, forming a continuous mobile network of intertangled molecular chain'. However, when mixtures of hyaluronic acid and serum albumin were studied, it became clear 'that the albumin behaves as if it occupied only a fraction of the total volume of solution, i.e. that the hyaluronic acid excludes the albumin from a part of the solution' (119a). Subsequent attempts to determine the exclusion volume turned out to give too low a value, but they stimulated Ogston in 1957 to do 'what proved to be a rather fruitful calculation' (77).
The resulting and elegantly simple equation states that the fraction of volume (f) available to spheres of radius R in a solution containing a length L of fibres of radius r ml-1 is exp[-¼(r+R)2L]. Tests of the equation by Ogston and Phelps (88) over the next two years established its validity. The relevance of this work to the theory of gel partition chromatography by Sephadex beads is obvious, and to the behaviour of solutions such as synovial fluid that contain mixtures of proteins and hyaluronic acid. The effect can be quite spectacular, as illustrated by Sandy's experiments with B.S. Blumberg (74) in which a high concentration of protein (but not of glucose) caused hyaluronic acid to 'sediment' upwards in the ultracentrifuge.
The exclusion of proteins from that part of the solution space occupied by hyaluronic acid
increases the osmotic pressure of a mixed solution above the value expected from the contributions of its components. Osmotic measurements made with Laurent in Uppsala [(94)] and with Preston and Davies at the ANU [(96)] on mixtures of hyaluronic acid and albumin gave values for excess osmotic pressures in good agreement with the exclusion theory and with the results of dialysis experiments.
(Here Ogston is still investigating the osmotic pressures of mixtures of high-molecular-mass solutes – a physical chemical problem that he had suggested to the writer for a thesis problem twenty years earlier!) Anomalously high osmotic pressures generated by this type of phenomenon help explain how polysaccharides trapped in a collagen network allow cartilage to support heavy loads.
By no means were all of Ogston's contributions theoretical. He greatly enjoyed experimental simplicity. A combination of this enjoyment with theoretical considerations led to a series of papers in which he described how to measure osmotic pressures by observing changes in the diameters of single Sephadex beads (117). Sensitivities were later improved (122), in the same way that bimetallic strips are used in thermostats, by measuring the curving of a bilayer strip of osmotically sensitive polyacrylamide on an insensitive backing (Kleenex).
More complex but no less valuable forays into the design of scientific apparatus included improvements in the optical systems for following the behaviour of boundaries during diffusion (29, 40) or ultracentrifugation (38) and for measuring refractive indices (48). And the need to measure the viscosities of dilute solutions of hyaluronic acid led to improvements in the Couette viscometer (58).
In all, Ogston published over 125 papers. The scientific time span of these is revealing. They began at a time when so little was known of protein structure that serious consideration was given to the possibility that under some circumstances 'globulin' can dissociate into elements that reassociated to generate albumin. They ended at a time when determining the three-dimensional structures of proteins at the atomic level and the nucleotide sequences of their genes was rapidly becoming routine.
Early days
Alexander George Ogston, the first of six children, was born on 30 January 1911, in Bombay, India, where his father, Walter Henry Ogston, of firmly Aberdonian ancestry, was a businessman for twenty years. His mother, nee Josephine Elizabeth Carter, fourteen years younger than her husband, trained at the Froebel Educational Institute as a teacher, won silver and gold medals at University College, London, studying biological sciences, but married before completing her degree. Although neither of Sandy's parents was an academic, his paternal family had a strong academic bent. In the early seventeenth century William Ogston was Professor of Moral Philosophy at Aberdeen. Sandy's great-grandfather, Francis Ogston, was Professor of Medical Jurisprudence, also at Aberdeen. His grandfather, (Sir) Alexander, became Surgeon in Ordinary to Queen Victoria but did not wish his sons to become doctors. Sandy's oldest sister, Flora Jane (married to John St.L. Philpot), trained in biochemistry at Cambridge and became a professional biochemist; his brother Walter Mactavish, an engineer, obtained first class honours at Oxford; his third sister, Josephine Alice Coreen, married to M. Weatherall, was Reader in Pharmacology at the London Hospital.
When Ogston was three, his family returned to the UK and lived in and around London. From ages eight to thirteen years he attended Kingston Hill Preparatory School, where his headmaster thought his classics good enough to get him into Eton, although his mother had thought that, as a potential scientist, he might go to Oundle. He was, in the end, offered scholarships at both, at Oundle for his Latin and at Eton for his scientific promise. This was recognized by the Eton head science master on the basis of Sandy's answer to a question on tides and trade winds in the general paper, a topic that had been covered by the only formal scientific subject (physical geography) taught at Kingston Hill! At Eton, Sandy began as a classics scholar but 'drifted into chemistry'. Although initially considering Cambridge, he was urged by his chemistry teacher, himself an Oxford graduate, to try for Balliol College, Oxford. Partly as a result of mathematical prowess (one of the three best at Eton), illustrated by his scoring an a- on an optional additional mathematics paper on which no question was familiar, Sandy was awarded a Brackenbury Scholarship (Balliol's highest). An unfearful use of mathematics remained another Ogston characteristic throughout his scientific life.
At Balliol, Ogston's first (eight-week) term, 1929, under the tutorial guidance of Harold (later Sir Harold) Hartley, proved to be a formidable introduction to the principles of physical chemistry. It was entirely spent studying methods for determining the atomic masses of elements, with all reading confined to original papers, some more than fifteen years old. After Hartley left for industry shortly thereafter, Ogston was tutored by David Murray-Rust, a temporary lecturer at Balliol, with electrochemistry, quantum chemistry and stereochemistry as particularly enjoyed subjects. Despite being 'only a moderately diligent student' for much of his undergraduate period, Ogston worked hard towards the end and in 1933 achieved first-class honours in chemistry. His appetite for research had been whetted by a term in his second year during which he performed 'unconvincing' experiments in electrochemistry in the Balliol/Trinity laboratory originally set up by Harold Hartley in the cellars of staircase XVI at Balliol.
As a means towards a career in academic science, in 1933 Sandy applied for and was granted a limited-period Junior Demonstratorship in Balliol. He was now a don and a member of the college Senior Common Room – at least for two years! One of his duties was to help supervise the work of undergraduates in the Balliol/Trinity laboratory, and he was also responsible for the first-year University lectures on electrochemistry. His enjoyment of electrochemistry and questions asked by his sister Flora, who was reading biochemistry in Cambridge, were the causes of Ogston's transition into biochemistry, and of his first scientific paper in 1935, in conjunction with a Balliol undergraduate J. F. Brown (1), aimed at determining whether amino acids in aqueous solutions were doubly charged zwitterions.
This work in turn led to Ogston being invited to move his site of work from the Balliol/Trinity laboratory to the Department of Biochemistry with the task of investigating the electrochemical behaviour of vitamin B1 (2), the structure of which Professor R. A. (later Sir Rudolph) Peters was trying to determine.
By now Ogston was married and hoping for more permanent work at Oxford. None being forthcoming, in 1935 he accepted a Freedom Research Fellowship to work on proteins with Ensor R. Holliday at the London Hospital. Their joint attempts to understand how antibodies differed from normal serum globulins using spectrographic (Ensor) and titration (Sandy) methods were twenty years in advance of the necessary knowledge and technology to yield any relevant data. But it was during this period that Ogston first became interested in apparent anomalies in the ultracentrifugal behaviour and osmotic pressures of mixtures of proteins that became a recurring theme in his research.
To pursue what he now recognized as his preferred field of research, the physical chemistry of biological systems, Ogston decided that, to become independent, he would need some systematic knowledge of physiology and biochemistry, and was planning to take a year off work to do this at Oxford. He was also trying to arrange for an Oxford DPhil, on the basis of previous and continuing research to be performed under the pro-forma supervision of R. P. Bell (by then Hartley's successor at Balliol). The opportunity to accomplish all these aims presented itself in 1937 when Balliol offered him a Fellowship and agreed that he could spend the first year reading honours physiology while at the same time performing the tutorial teaching of first-year and second-year medical students. 'David' Fisher and Humphrey Leach were his tutors. He chose to sit the final examination, a voluntary choice because he was overstanding for honours, but was unable to obtain any measure of his success because his examiners were barred from revealing this and in any case on encountering an Ogston script had said, 'Oh, we needn't read that'.
After completing honours schoolwork, Ogston was able to take up fully his duties as a Tutorial Fellow in Balliol and was appointed Departmental Demonstrator at the Department of Biochemistry in 1939. These two appointments carried with them heavy teaching responsibilities. During the three eight-week terms, he was responsible for as many as forty students and had primary responsibility for selecting biology students for admission to Balliol on the basis of their scholarship and entrance examinations. My first remembrance of Sandy (in 1943) was when he asked me, while attending the annual scholarship examinations, whether I would take an intelligence test, the results of which would not be used in making decisions on the scholarships. This test, administered by Sandy, and a mathematics paper similar to his own at the same stage, are all that I remember of the proceedings. Like Sandy, I later heard the results of my mathematics paper, but I never did hear how (un)intelligent I was. For Sandy, terms were busy, but he made a resolution that he kept for all his scientific life: never, except for teaching or college business, to work after dinner or between Saturday lunch and Monday morning. The generous Oxford University vacations were the time for research.
For twenty-two years from 1938 to 1960 (with a few breaks during the Second World War) Ogston carried the full load of tutorial teaching of medical students and later of biochemists. The challenge of covering the whole of the field, not just his own specialty, was always there; and watching and helping students mature never became dull. Teaching and learning from his cleverer students was exciting, but 'it was the less able that [he] felt best able to help'. His pupils became to him, almost like his own children. '[He] was delighted by their successes, hopeful for their hopes, distressed by their failures, anxious about their anxieties'.
World War II
Somewhat exhausted from the intense first year of Balliol teaching and his own studies, Sandy cast around in 1939 for a new line of research. John Philpot and David Fisher, knowing of his interest in osmotic pressure, thought he might enjoy working on the exudate that could be obtained from the swollen sexual skin of female Rhesus monkeys during oestrus. In typical fashion, he guessed the nature of the expressed 'mucin' and devised ways of fractionating it. This was his introduction to hyaluronic acid.
When war broke out, Sandy, although reserved from military service as a teacher of medical students and a scientific researcher, joined R. A. Peters' external research team of the Ministry of Supply. The team's aim was to find a non-toxic reagent able to compete with tissue substances in converting mustard gas into a non-toxic derivative. John Philpot and Lloyd Stocken devised and made reagents; Sandy investigated the ratio of the reaction of activated mustard gas with the test substances relative to water; and Ensor Holliday tested their biological effectiveness. Although the best were 10,000 times more reactive than water, none proved biologically effective.
After the chemical warfare work ended in 1943, Ogston worked for the Inter-Service Research Bureau (ISRB) for about two years. The only recorded work that he did in this context included the direct testing, by himself during a solo expedition up the side of Ben Macdui, of the utility of compact rations devised by ISRB. He was also assigned the job of designing medical packs to accompany French doctors parachuting to aid the Maquis. On protesting his unsuitability for this assignment, since he was not a medical doctor, he was told that if he would not do the job someone even less suitable would have to.
In 1944, at age thirty-three, he chose to return to Oxford, believing that the war would end before anything more that he could do would have any effect. To my good fortune, this meant that he could resume his teaching, including lectures on the application of physical chemistry to biological problems. I was enthralled, and decided to take a second degree in chemistry and to work for my doctorate under Sandy's guidance.
Postwar work at Oxford
For sixteen years from 1944 to 1960, the Ogston family (himself, Elizabeth, three young daughters and later a son) lived in a modest college house at 5 Mansfield Road in Oxford. During this period, Sandy developed his professional life. In college, he had his tutorial duties. At the department, he devised and conducted experimental and lecture courses. In the early 1940s, he also first suggested the desirability of having the Honours School of Biochemistry and helped to develop it. Before establishment of the school in 1948, biochemistry was included as an unnamed part of the Honours School of Physiology. For his research laboratory he chose a pattern to which he adhered for many years. The theme of the laboratory was physical biochemistry. He aimed at having at any one time several (never more than three) pre-doctoral research students and a more senior post-doctoral collaborator. He had 'inherited' from John Philpot the Svedberg ultracentrifuge – one of fewer than half a dozen in the world at that time. Its optical system extended through two rooms and it was installed on a deep concrete pier. With it went the obligation of making ultracentrifuge measurements for other investigators. This obligation was made less onerous, and even enjoyable, by Sandy's being able to enlist the services, as a graduate assistant, of Rupert Cecil. Rupert, a distinguished ex-bomber pilot, understood the intricacies of this monstrous machine, and worked harmoniously in maintaining and operating the instrument while still developing his own research.
The decade 1945-1955 was Ogston's most enterprising and productive period. It was during this time that the long-sought solution to the ultracentrifugal anomaly was reached, as the Johnston-Ogston effect (1946), and the Ogston three-point attachment paper was written (1948). He was elected to Fellowship of the Royal Society and appointed as a Reader in Oxford in 1955.
A window into Ogston's view of science and scientists is opened by his description of his attendance at a 1950 Gordon Conference in New Hampshire, USA, on the Physical Chemistry of Proteins. These annual conferences with rarely more than 100 attendees cover a wide range of special topics and are held in isolated small rural colleges (the American equivalent of English public schools) with quite austere accommodations. Sandy greatly enjoyed this particular conference with its sessions held in the mornings, between tea and dinner, and after dinner. The informal afternoons allowed him to teach other participants how to play croquet 'properly' (more likely ruthlessly).
In the same year he was asked, as a result of his having written the review of oxidative phosphorylation, to substitute for R.A. Peters at the annual Solvay Conference in Brussels. It was 'as different an affair from the informality of the Gordon Conference as could be imagined'. The sessions were held in a large room, and the papers were delivered with great formality. Sandy must have conveyed to his students his sense of the difference between these ways of approaching science. Certainly I continue to enjoy the informal atmosphere and rigorous science of the compact Gordon Conferences (still held) infinitely more than the formalities and inaccessible science of the gargantuan International Congresses that now pervade the biological-medical field.
In 1955 Ogston attended a conference in Australia, the First International Wool Conference. He clearly enjoyed this visit to Australia and spent a week in Canberra at the Australian National University (ANU). He was asked by Professor Hugh Ennor, acting dean of the John Curtin School at ANU, whether he might be interested in joining the university, and responded that he 'would certainly consider such a proposal'.
By now Ogston was being sought by other universities. He visited Birmingham and received an offer of the Chair in Biochemistry, another from Imperial College and a third from Edinburgh. Understanding well, but having little relish for the financial and administrative tasks of large teaching departments, he refused all three. However, the offers made him question whether he wished to continue at Oxford for the remainder of his working life (perhaps twenty more years), and whether he would remain effective for so long. As a result, when in 1958 he received a firm invitation to establish a small new department of physical biochemistry in the John Curtin School at ANU (in contrast to taking over a large old one), he accepted the job for at least five years. He was fortunate to be able to appoint Hugh A. MacKenzie as his second-in-command, who would start to set up the department before the move to Australia.
The Australian years, 1960-70
For the whole of their stay in Australia, the Ogstons lived in a house, 27 Lawson Crescent, Canberra, that belonged to ANU, and was only a few minutes' walk from the John Curtin School (one of the four research schools comprising the university). Ogston organized his new department in four groups. Each group had a permanent head and was able to carry out independent work in the field of macromolecules. Under the group heads were research fellows, research scholars, graduate assistants, and technical assistants.
The group heads, in addition to Ogston, were McKenzie (milk proteins), A. B. Roy (sulphatase enzymes) and J. R. Dunstone (cartilage components). In his own research, Sandy followed up previous lines of thought and, in the absence of teaching medical students, tended to revert more to pure physical chemistry. Hyaluronic acid once again held his attention, and with B. N. Preston as a Research Fellow and M. Davies as a Research Scholar he carried out a concerted attack on its physicochemical properties. With J. R. Dunstone and students Elizabeth Edmond and Susan Farquhar he returned to his fruitful investigation of the interpenetration or the lack thereof of various polymers in solution, in this case the exclusion of randomly coiled high-molecular-mass linear dextran from slightly cross-linked polymers (Sephadex beads). With the use of P. J. Flory's treatment of the swelling of gels, the internal osmotic coefficients of the Sephadexes were shown to be similar to those of high-molecular-mass dextran. One outcome of this type of thought was the single Sephadex-bead osmometer, which Sandy devised (117), and its 'bi-metallic strip' improvement (122). In his reminiscences, Sandy laments that 'of the forty-six papers based on work during this period, only ten were under my name alone, and only one of those was experimental'. Few chairpersons of even small departments can look back at ten years of work in the 1960 to 1970 time period and find any, let alone ten, papers on which they were the sole authors!
Ogston's initial promise of staying at ANU for five years was fulfilled by the time that in 1966 he was offered the (Whitley) Chair of Biochemistry at Oxford in succession to Sir Hans Krebs. For reasons similar to his earlier refusal of chairs of large departments, he declined the invitation. But again the invitation made him think, this time of returning to teaching as a lecturer at one of the new universities in England. Quite unexpectedly, however, he was shortly thereafter asked if he would allow himself to be considered for election as President of Trinity College (over the wall from Balliol and a long-time rival). With no hesitation, he accepted. Knowing something of the life of the head of a college at Oxford, he felt that he could do the job and would enjoy it. So began in earnest the phase of Sandy's life devoted to helping others carry out their vocations, presaged already by his chairmanship at ANU, and by his service from 1952 as a member and subsequently from 1955 to 1959 as chairman of the editorial board of the Biochemical Journal.
Trinity College, 1970-78
Something around half the time of the president of an Oxford college is likely to be spent on college business, with the allocation of the remaining time depending on the tastes of the individual, including university business or scholarly or worldly or even leisure activities. Sandy, with enormous help from his wife Elizabeth, chose to make the college the centre of his interest, as had been hoped by the Governing Board of Trinity. Research was to be secondary, to be performed in the Department of Biochemistry as time allowed. Because Trinity in the early 1970s was a relatively small college (about two hundred undergraduate and fifty graduate students) Sandy could resume the direct contact with students at their transition into adulthood that had been such an important part of his earlier Oxford days but had been lacking at ANU. Past custom at Trinity College was for the tutors (Fellows and Lecturers) to meet with the President during the last week of term and report on their students' progress, or lack thereof. Sandy continued this custom but changed the time of seeing the graduate students to the beginning of term, when written reports from their supervisors on their previous term's performance would be available and the pressure of time was less. However, an average of four minutes for each meeting was not sufficient to satisfy Sandy's overriding wish to know and help his young men (the Oxford colleges at that time were still gender-segregated). He and Elizabeth therefore decided to have an evening encounter with every student at least once a year by inviting a batch of ten to twelve to the President's lodging on one day of each week during term. Unfortunately, dinners in the lodgings for so many were too difficult for the college kitchens. Typically, Elizabeth solved the problem by inviting the young men to dessert, accompanied by rather unusual dessert wines (Madeira or Barsac), served with elegant fruit knives on a beautiful service of college plates. An hour of talk around the dining table followed by coffee in the drawing room must have left memorable impressions on those who chose to attend. All who could not attend, except those who neither came nor responded, were re-invited again during the same year. Married graduates and their wives were invited to small dinner parties instead.
The daily business of the college occupied Sandy's weekdays in the study of the President's lodgings from 9.15 to 11.00 a.m., or later as needed. His 'spare time' between 11.00 a.m. and around 6.00 p.m. was spent mainly at the Department of Biochemistry. (He still had one last doctorate pupil, J. D. Wells, who had moved to Oxford from Canberra to complete his thesis research.) Most evenings were spent socially, entertaining or being entertained. No wonder that Sandy described this period as being 'a strenuous life for both of us'.
A college decision made during this period, although quite uncrucial, reveals the sense of continuity that characterizes the old universities. The stucco and stonework on the east end of the chapel, and on some outer walls of the Garden Quad, needed refacing, either by stone or by concrete blocks and stucco. The latter would save £30,000 but would have a life expectancy of one hundred years rather than the four hundred years of stone. Sandy's remark, that the difference spread over three hundred years was cheap at the price, convinced the governing body. 'How good it was to belong to an institution that could look forward with confidence to the next four hundred years'.
Sandy retired from the presidency in 1978, without regrets, following a change in the College Statutes making retirement mandatory at 67. A Victorian mansion in Rawlinson Road, remodelled as a college residence towards the end of Sandy's tenure, was fittingly named Ogston House. He was pleased.
Retirement years, 1978–96
Sandy's service to others did not cease with his retirement from Oxford. After a year of travelling to Canada, the USA, Australia, Israel and Greece, which still included the giving of seminars and some collaborative theoretical work, the Ogstons chose York as a retirement city, and bought a house on Dewsbury Terrace. It proved to be a happy choice. Collaborations in science continued until Ogston was 75. Nor did Sandy's efforts to help others cease with his departure from Oxford. He had accepted an invitation in 1976 to serve first as Vice-Chairman and in 1981 as Chairman of the Council of Selly Oak Colleges, Birmingham, and he continued this task until 1986, well into his retirement. It was an important part of his life at that time, although unfortunately the duties of chairman did not encourage the close connections with the lives of students and staff members that he so much enjoyed.
A well-balanced life
Ogston's contributions to academic matters, through original science and through his service on behalf of succeeding generations of scholars, show a breadth that few distinguished scientists can match. Surely this was no accident, for his decision to live a balanced life was made consciously and early. Three leisure activities weave in and out of Sandy's long life: boating, hiking and music. The first began seriously when at the age of 13 during one of the family's annual Deeside holidays he learned to sail a lug-sailed twelve-foot dingy. Holidays in Norfolk when he was 16 and 17 taught him how to progress upwind in narrow waters. At 19, as a young Oxford undergraduate he bought a Norfolk punt, 'Jenny Spinner', which he sailed later on the Thames with his young wife. Racing or organizing races was an occasional enterprise. His first experience in the organizational category was at Eton when as 'ninth man' he had the task of marshalling the annual boat races of the school, hitherto always disorganized and behind schedule. By obtaining from earlier records the slowest time for each type of race and by having late-comers disqualified, he succeeded in transforming the event to order and punctuality: a transformation that continued when he left for Oxford. He rowed briefly as an undergraduate and was stroke of the second college eight. Canoeing was another Ogston signature. During his early days in Oxford, Sandy had purchased for £10 a used but beautiful wooden canoe from Timm's Boathouse. The boathouse had ceased renting it because it was too tippy and their customers always returned wet from excursions. When he was President of Trinity, he and Elizabeth on several occasions watched the Oxford Eights college boat races from this narrow, perfectly varnished but now fifty-year-old canoe after having followed the Eights down the Thames to the start, paddling 'a bit show-off-ish[ly]' in unison from the kneeling position.
Hiking also began in childhood in Scotland and continued to be actively pursued as long as limbs allowed. Active is indeed the word. In Canberra the Australian bush can be dense scrub vegetation with fallen trees beneath a virgin eucalyptus forest. On one occasion Sandy and Elizabeth took 7 hours to travel 4 miles! Navigation by pocket altimeter to keep on a contour and by prismatic compass to maintain a sense of direction was at times the only means of knowing one's whereabouts. The Ogstons, with their constant attention to students, involved others in these activities. Graduate students and fellows from University House frequently joined them in hiking, picnicking and swimming expeditions.
Making music began to play a part in Sandy's life when he returned to Oxford after the war. Encouragement by and participation with his doctoral student Jean Stanier, when both were learning to play the recorder in 1946, helped to overcome his diffidence regarding his musical ability, at least sufficiently to enjoy playing if not performing. A term's sabbatical leave in 1951 was spent learning to play a keyboard instrument, and he bought a small Goble harpsichord, which on going to Australia he gave to his daughter Liddy. On his return from Australia he built his own from a kit, being at a loss without one. He never thought his playing good enough for others to hear, but he played regularly for himself.
Religious matters were of great importance to both Sandy and Elizabeth Ogston. During the war, Elizabeth had begun to attend the University Church (St. Mary's) in Oxford, and sometimes took the older girls to Sunday School. Sandy began to accompany her to Evensong conducted by the Vicar, Roy Lee. Roy's undogmatic teaching and a gentle encouragement from Elizabeth led to their both being confirmed in 1954. Sandy treasured the rich and varied religious diet provided by St. Mary's 'in beautiful buildings, soaked in history'. The Ogstons missed this at ANU, and so varied their continued Anglican connection with attendance at the Meeting House of the Quakers, whose approach to religion they both found very acceptable.
Leadership, not usually sought, was often thrust on Ogston. On being asked to attend the ecclesiastical council meeting (the Diocesan Synod) as a lay member, he agreed on condition that his first action would be to support a motion that women should be eligible for membership in the Synod. The motion carried without any dissent following Sandy's enraged remarks after titters were evoked by the proposer: 'At the beginning of this Synod we heard an inspired address about not regarding the people of Papua New Guinea as second class citizens...Are we to regard half of our [own] people as second class citizens?'.
The Ogstons attended all of the annual conferences of the Australian Student Christian Movement (ASCM) held while they were at ANU. Sandy tried, with only partial success, to have the 1968 ASCM meeting (which he was co-opted into organizing in Canberra) to be joint with the annual meeting of the Catholic Students Union. His constant wish to do something for undergraduate students, otherwise missing during his tenure at ANU, was fulfilled somewhat by participation in and organizing these meetings.
Family
I have left until last a mention of Sandy's family – in the literal and figurative senses – because of its absolutely essential role in all of his life. He was courting Elizabeth (nÈe Wickstead) during his early days in Oxford and married her in 1934. They had been married over sixty years when he died. They had three daughters and a son. As 'Barry' Blumberg, Nobel Laureate in Physiology and Medicine (1976), Sandy's most illustrious student, said during his 1996 memorial ovation, 'Sandy and Elizabeth were loving and extraordinarily compatible. In our later years I hardly ever remember seeing one without the other'.
I was fortunate, in part because of the vagaries of accommodation in wartime Balliol, to be invited to share with Richard Tucker a bedsitting room in the Ogston family home at 5 Mansfield Road. To be a member of Sandy's scientific family is a privilege that many have shared. But to be a member – even if to some degree adopted – of his home family was more than a privilege: it was a joy. The home that Sandy and Liza (I almost never heard him address his wife other than as Liza) gave to their children and to us two wartime adoptees was full of life and humour. We were made welcome despite episodes of sinks stained with potassium permanganate and desperate attempts to bleach the results with other chemicals.
When Sandy died, I wrote to Liza and mentioned what I felt constituted the successful formula for her relationship with him, 'a great deal of affection but at the same time a complete understanding of the weaknesses as well as the strengths of one's spouse, and the courage and sense of security to indicate which is relevant at any particular time'. Her later reply included a quiet statement of the love and affection that Sandy and Liza shared. She wrote that she was 'glad that I have stayed alive longer than he did'. Then, in writing of the early post-war days in Oxford and of having had 'a letter from Jean [Stanier] this morning' she continued: 'Now that was the best part of Sandy's life. That gang of you all in the lab, and the undergraduates in Balliol. It was good wasn't it? He was lucky, wasn't he?...with the people he knew? And all of us were lucky to know him'.
E. M. Southern (Whitley Professor of Biochemistry, Oxford), at about the same time, wrote to me: 'I think that many a young scientist reading [about Sandy] will feel that that is the kind of scientist they would like to be. It is becoming more and more difficult to be like Sandy. We must strive to keep it possible'.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol.12, no.4, 1999. A shorter version of this memoir is also published in Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society of London, 1999. The memoir was written by O Smithies, School of Medicine, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, USA.
Numbers in brackets refer to the bibliography.
Acknowledgement
The frontispiece photograph was taken in 1970 by R. Westen and is reproduced courtesy of the John Curtin School of Medical Research, Australian National University.
References
- Krebs, H.A. 1949 The Tricarboxylic Acid Cycle. In The Harvey Lectures 1948-1949, series 44, pp. 165-199. Springfield, Illinois: Charles C. Thomas.
- Krebs, H.A., & Johnson, W.A. 1937 The role of citric acid in intermediate metabolism in animal tissues. Enzymologia 4, 148-156.
- McFarlane, A.S. 1935 Biochem. J. 29, 407.
- Shemin, D. 1946 The Biological Conversion of l-Serine to Glycine. J. Biol. Chem. 162, 297-307.
- Wood, H.G., Werkman, C.H., Hemingway, A., & Nier, A.O. 1941 Mechanism of fixation of carbon dioxide in the krebs cycle. J. Biol. Chem. 139, 483-484.
Bibliography
- 1935 (With J.F. Brown) The potent-iometric titration of non-aqueous solutions applied to amino acids. Trans. Faraday Soc. 31. 574-585.
- (With R.C.G. Moggridge) The potentiometric titration of solutions of vitamin B1. Biochem. J. 29. 866-870.
- Constitution of the purine nucleosides. Part III Potentiometric determination of the dissociation constants of methylated xanthines. J. Chem. Soc. 1376-1379.
- 1936 (With B. A. Potus) Potentiometric titrations of vitamin B1 and of thiochrome. Biochem. J. 30. 736.
- Micro-potentiometric filtrations of normal horse serum globulins. Biochem. J. 30. 1845.
- Some dissociation constants. J. Chem. Soc. 1713.
- Temperature coefficients of electrical conductivity of electrolytes in methyl and ethyl alcohols. Trans. Faraday Soc. 32. 1679.
- Ionisation of amines in alcohol: a possible slow reaction. J. Chem. Soc. 1023.
- 1937 Some observations on mixtures of serum albumin and globulin. Biochem. J. 31. 1952.
- 1938 (With E. R. Holiday) Ultraviolet absorption and potentiometric titration curves of human serum proteins and some others. Biochem. J. 32. 1166.
- (With C. Wilson) Treatment of peripheral vascular disease by intermittent venous occlusion: a new, simple and inexpensive method. The Lancet. 606.
- Enzymatic removal of bound carbohydrate from normal horse serum pseudoglobulin. Nature. 141. 1056.
- 1939 (With J.St.L. Philpot and S. Zucherman) Observations related to the swelling of sexual skin in Rhesus monkeys. J. Endocrinol. 1. 231.
- 1942 Addendum: Examination in the ultracentrifuge (of Tobacco Necrosis virus). Brit. J. Path. 23. 328.
- 1943 Addendum: Examination of Bushy Stunt Virus in the ultracentrifuge. Biochem. J. 37. 78.
- Addendum: Examination in the ultra-centrifuge (of antigen of Salmonella typhivenrium). Biochem. J. 37. 612.
- On the theory of the periodic structure of proteins. Trans. Faraday Soc. 39. 151.
- 1945 (With J.P. Johnston and H.C. Longuet-Higgins) On the distribution of the molecular weights of proteins. Trans. Faraday Soc. 41. 588.
- (With H. Gutfreund) Physical properties of bovine serum after heating with formaldehyde. Biochem. J. 39. 186.
- (With J.P. Johnston) Ultracentrifugal examination of fractions of Tobacco Mosaic virus. Brit. J. exp. Path. 20. 313.
- On the numerical consequences of certain hypotheses of protein structure. Trans. Faraday Soc. 41. 670.
- Ultracentrifugal examination of a virus causing tobacco necrosis. Brit. J. exp. Path. 26. 286.
- 1946 Spreading of boundaries in electrophoresis. Nature. 157. 195.
- (With H. Gutfreund) The sedimentation constant of insulin. Biochem. J. 40. 432.
- Addendum. Examination in the ultra-centrifuge (of a milk protein). J. Dairy Res. 14. 328.
- (With G.S. Adair and J.P. Johnston) Osmotic pressures and sedimentation velocity of Gastrophilus methaemoglobin. Biochem. J. 40. 867.
- (With J.P. Johnston) A boundary anomaly found in the ultracentrifugal sedimentation of mixtures. Trans. Faraday Soc. 42. 789-799.
- 1947 The definition and meaning of pH. Physiol. Rev. 27. 228.
- 1948 (With C.A. Coulson, J.T. Cox and J.St.L. Philpot) A rapid method for determining diffusion constants in solution. Proc. Roy. Soc. A. 192. 382-402.
- (With E.R. Holiday, J.St.L. Philpot and L.A. Stocken) Replacement reactions of b-b'-dichlorodiethyl sulphide and of some analogues in aqueous solution: isolation of b-chloro-b'-hydroxydiethyl sulphide. Trans. Faraday Soc. 44. 45.
- Chemical reactions of mustard gas in aqueous solution. Biochem. Soc. Symp. No. 2. 2.
- (With R. Cecil) Addendum: Sedimentation and diffusion of glucose oxidase (Notation). Biochem. J. 42. 229.
- (With K. Bailey and H. Gutfreund) Molecular weight of tropomyosin from rabbit muscle. Biochem. J. 43. 279.
- (With D.J. Bell, H. Gutfreund and R. Cecil) Physicochemical observations on some glycogens. Biochem. J. 42. 405.
- (With O. Smithies) Some thermo-dynamic and kinetic aspects of metabolic phosphorylation. Physiol. Rev. 28. 283-303.
- (With R. Cecil) Sedimentation of thymus nucleic acid in the ultracentrifuge. J. Chem. Soc. 1382.
- Interpretation of experiments on metabolic processes, using isotopic tracer elements. Nature. 162. 963.
- (With R. Cecil) Accuracy of the Svedberg oil-turbine ultracentrifuge. Biochem. J. 43, 592-598.
- 1949 (With R. Cecil) Sedimentation constant, diffusion constant and molecular weight of lactoglobulin. Biochem. J. 44. 33.
- The Gouy diffusiometer; further calibration. Proc. Roy. Soc. A. 196. 272-285.
- (With R. Cecil and J.P. Johnston) Influence of solvent movement on sedimentation. Nature. 163. 919.
- (With H. Gutfreund) A method for determining the sedimentation constant of material of low molecular weight: studies on oxidation products of insulin. Biochem. J. 44. 163.
- The sedimentation and diffusion of poly-saccharrides from Penecillium luteus; interpretation of the results obtained from polydisperse material in the Gouy diffusiometer. Biochem. J. 45. 189.
- 1950 (With R.E. Davies) On the mechanisms of secretion of ions by gastric mucosa and by other tissues. Biochem. J. 46. 324.
- (With J.E. Stanier) On the state of hyal-uronic acid in synovial fluid. Biochem. J. 46. 364.
- (With J.E. Stanier, B.A. Tomes and D.J. Strawbridge) Elastic properties of ox synovial fluid. Nature. 165. 571.
- Sedimentation and diffusion of desoxy-ribose nucleic acid. Trans. Faraday Soc. 46.
- (With R. Cecil) A simple double-prism refractometer. J. Sci. Instruments. 28. 253-254.
- 1951 (With J.P. Johnston and J.E. Stanier) A modification of the Elson and Morgan method for the estimation of gluco-samine. Analyst. 76. 88.
- (With J.E. Stanier) The dimensions of the particle of the hyaluronic acid complex in synovial fluid. Biochem. J. 49. 585.
- (With J.E. Stanier) A micro-method for the estimation of uronic acids. Biochem. J. 49. 591.
- (With J.H. Fessler) Studies of the sedimentation, diffusion and viscosity of some sarcosine polymers in aqueous solution. Trans. Faraday Soc. 47. 667.
- Specificity of the enzyme aconitase. Nature. 167. 693.
- 1952 (With J.E. Stanier) Further observations on the preparation and composition of the hyaluronic acid complex of ox synovial fluid. Biochem. J. 52. 149.
- Addendum: sedimentation and diffusion of Licheniformius A, B and C. Biochem. J. 51. 558.
- (With R. Cecil) Addendum: Sedimentation and diffusion of fumarase. Biochem. J. 51. 494.
- (With E.F. Woods) Molecular configuration of dextrans in aqueous solution. Nature. 171. 221.
- 1953 (With J.E. Stanier) A Couette viscosimeter. Biochem. J. 53. 4-7.
- (With J.E. Stanier) Composition and properties of hyaluronic acid complex of ox synovial fluid. Faraday Soc. Disc. No. 13.
- (With J.E. Stanier) The physiological function of hyaluronic acid in synovial fluid: viscous, elastic and lubricant properties. J. Physiol. 119. 244.
- (With J.E. Stanier) Some effects of hyaluronidase on the hyaluronic acid of ox synovial fluid, and their bearing on the investigation of pathological fluids. J. Physiol. 119. 253.
- Dimensions on solute particles from dynamic properties of their solutions. Trans. Faraday Soc. 49. 1481.
- 1954 (With E.F. Woods) The sedimentation of some fractious of degraded dextran. Trans. Faraday Soc. 50. 635.
- (With R.L. Baldwin) The diffusion and sedimentation coefficients of a liquid two-component in terms of macroscopic properties of the system. Trans. Faraday Soc. 50. 749.
- Methods of describing unidimensional diffusion in binary liquid systems. Trans. Faraday Soc. 50. 1303.
- Sedimentation and solvation in multi-component systems. Trans. Faraday Soc. 50. 1363.
- (With J.H. Fessler and J.E. Stanier) Some properties of human and other synovial fluids. Biochem. J. 58. 656-660.
- 1955 (With J.M. Tilley) Studies on the heterogeneity of crystallized b-lactoglobulin. Biochem. J. 59(4). 644-653.
- Removal of acetylcholine from a limited volume by diffusion. J. Physiol. 128(1). 222-223.
- Chemistry of proteins, peptides, and amino acids. Annual Rev. Biochem. 24. 181-206.
- (With E.O. Field) Boundary spreading in the migration of a solute in rapid dissociation equilibrium; theory and its application to the case of human haemoglobin. Biochem. J. 60(4).
- Examination in the ultracentrifuge. Biochem. J. 61(4). 696-697.
- 1956 (With J.R. Hall) Sedimentation and diffusion of samples of penicillinase. 62(3). 401-403.
- (With B.S. Blumberg) The selective solvation of the hyaluronic acid complex of ox synovial fluid. Biochem. J. 63(4). 715-717.
- 1957 (With B.S. Blumberg) The effects of pro-teolytic enzymes on the hyaluronic acid complex of synovial fluid. Biochem. J. 66(2). 342-346.
- (With M.P. Tombs) The heterogeneity of bovine b-lactoglobulin. Biochem. J. 66(3). 399-403.
- 1958 The spaces in a uniform random suspension of fibres. Trans. Faraday Soc. 54. 1754-1757.
- (With T.F. Sherman) Electrophoretic removal of protein from hyaluronic acid. Nature. 181. 482-483.
- (With B.S. Blumberg) Further evidence on the protein complexes of some hyaluronic acids. Biochem. J. 68(1).
- Conditions for differential reaction of identical chemical groups. Nature. 181(4621).
- (With B.S. Blumberg, D.A. Lowther and H.J. Rogers) Physicochemical properties of hyaluronic acid formed by Streptococcus haemolyticus. Biochem. J. 70(1). 1-4.
- Sedimentation in the ultracentrifuge. Biochem. J. 70(4). 598-599.
- 1959 (With T.F. Sherman) Degradation of the hyaluronic acid complex of synovial fluid by proteolytic enzymes and by ethylenediaminetetra-acetic acid. Biochem. J. 72(2). 301-305.
- 1960 Biochemical investigation of a case of glycogen-storage disease (von Gierke's disease). Addendum-examination in the ultracentrifuge. Biochem. J. 74. 229-230.
- Some tests of the effect of stirring on the rate of dialysis: the indeculator. Arch. Biochem. 89. 181-183.
- (With C.F. Phelps) Exclusion of inulin from solutions of hyaluronic acid. Nature. 187. 1024.
- 1961 (With T.F. Sherman) Effects of hyalu-ronic acid upon duffision of solutes and flow of solvent. J. Physiol. 156. 67-74.
- (With C.F. Phelps) The partitions of solutes between buffer solutions and solutions containing hyaluronic acid. Biochem. J. 78. 827-833.
- (With J.F. Morrison and W.J. O'Sullivan) Kinetic studies of the activation of creatine-phosphoryl-transferase by magnesium. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 52. 82-96.
- 1962 Molecular weights of enzymes. Nature. 196. 171-172.
- Some thermodynamic relationships in ternary systems, with special reference to the properties of systems containing hyaluronic acid and protein. Arch. Biochem. Suppl. 1. 39-51.
- 1963 On uncertainties inherent in the determination of the efficiency of collison between virus particles and cells. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 66. 279-281.
- (With M. Davies and L.W. Nichol) Frictional effects in the migration of mixtures of hyaluronic acid and serum albumin. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 75. 436-438.
- (With T.C. Laurent) The interaction between polysaccharides and other macromolecules. Biochem. J. 89. 249-253.
- 1964 On the estimations of glucosamine in hyaluronic acid. Anal. Biochem. 8. 337-343.
- 1965 (With B.N. Preston and M. Davies) The composition and physicochemical properties of hyaluronic acids prepared from ox synovial fluid and from a case of mesothelioma. Biochem. J. 96. 449-474.
- (With B.N. Preston) Use of light-scattering to measure the selective interaction of a macromolecular solute with the components of a binary solvent. Nature. 207. 80-81.
- (With M.A. Denborough) Failure of phenol to remove residual protein from hyaluronic acid. Nature. 207. 1389.
- 1966 (With B.N. Preston) The exclusion of protein by hyaluronic acid. Measurement by light scattering. J. Biol. Chem. 241. 17-19.
- Discussion: protein-polysaccharide interaction. Federation Proc. 25. 1039.
- When is pressure osmotic? Federation Proc. 25. 1112-1114.
- Measurement of osmotic properties of hyaluronic acid by equilibrium sedimentation. Federation Proc. 25. 1118-1119.
- Measurement by light scattering of the exclusion of protein by hyaluronic acid. Federation Proc. 25. 1122-1123.
- On water binding. Federation Proc. 25. 986-989.
- Macromolecular hydration in solution. Federation Proc. 25. 993.
- On the physical chemistry of porous systems [Review]. British Med. Bulletin. 22. 105-108.
- 1967 (With L.W. Nichol and B.N. Preston) The equilibrium sedimentation of hyaluronic acid and of two synthetic polymers. Biochem. J. 102. 407-416.
- (With P. Silpananta and J.R. Dunstone) Fractionation of a hyaluronic acid preparation in a density gradient. The isolation and identification of a chondroitin sulphate. Biochem. J. 104. 404-409.
- (With L.W. Nichol and D.J. Winzor) Evaluation of gel filtration data on systems interacting chemically and physically. Archives of Biochem. & Biophys. 121. 517-521.
- 1968 (With R. Cecil) Addendum: Sedimentation of human catalase. Biochem. J. 43. 209.
- (With P. Silpananta and J.R. Dunstone) Fractionation of ahyaluronic acid preparation in a density gradient. Some properties of the hyaluronic acid. Biochem. J. 109. 43-50.
- (With E. Edmond) An approach to the study of phase separation in ternary aqueous systems. Biochem. J. 109. 569-576.
- (With E. Edmond, S. Farquhar and J.R. Dunstone) The osmotic behaviour of Sephadex and its effects on chromatography. Biochem. J. 108. 755-763.
- 1969 (With L.W. Nichol and G.D. Smith) The effects of isomerization and polymerization on the binding of ligands to acceptor molecules: implications in metabolic control. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 184.
- 1–10.
- (With P. Silpananta and J.R. Dunstone) Protein associated with hyaluronic acid in ox synovial fluid. Australian J. Biol. Sci. 22. 1031-1037.
- 1970 (With E. Edmond) Phase separation in an aqueous quaternary system. Biochem. J. 117. 85-89.
- (With J.D. Wells) Osmometry with single sephadex beads. Biochem. J. 119. 67-73.
- (With P. Silpananta) the thermo-dynamics of interaction between Sephadex and penetrating solutes. Biochem. J. 116. 171-175.
- (With G.E. Hibberd and D.J. Winzor) An experimental and theoretical investigation of boundary spreading in gel chromatography. J. Chromatography. 48. 393-399.
- An open-ended tale. Search 1 (2), 60-63.
- 1972 (With J.D. Wells) The osmotic properties of sulphoethyl-sephadex. A model for cartilage. Biochem. J. 128. 685-690.
- (With B.N. Preston and J.D. Wells) Micro methods of osmometry based on the equilibrium swelling of gels. Biochem. J. 130. 16P-17P.
- 1973 (With B.N. Preston) A sensitive and accurate gel osmometer. Biochem. J. 131. 843-850.
- 1975 (With P.A. Baghurst, L.W. Nichol and D.J. Winzor) Quantitative interpretation of concentration-dependent migration in gel chromatography of reversibly polymerizing solutes. Biochem. J. 147. 575-583.
- 1978 (With C.C. Michel) General descriptions of passive transport of neutral solute and solvent through membranes [Review]. Prog. Biophys. & Molec. Biol. 34. 197-217.
- 1979 (With B.N. Preston) The molecular compression of dextran. Biochem. J. 183. 1-9.
- 1981 (With L.W. Nichol and P.R. Wills) Effect of inert polymers on protein self-association. FEBS Letters. 126. 18-20.
- 1982 A new relationship between kinetic and equilibrium parameters of reversible enzyme reactions. Biochim. et Biophys. Acta. 707. 289-290.
Alexander Boden 1913-1993
Alex Boden was a manufacturing chemist who succeeded in that most difficult of industries; through his texts, he was an exceptionally successful educational author; and he was a publisher who relished editing, a man of some privacy and reticence who made deep and continuing friendships across the world, a singularly devoted husband, parent and grandparent, and a philanthropist in an age when philanthropy had almost dropped out of sight. His life was one of remarkable richness, variety, originality and generosity. It is unlikely that there has been another Australian of his kind.
Written by I.G. Ross
- Early years
- The student
- The manufacturing chemist
- The end of DDT
- Hardman at Seven Hills
- Science press
- The author
- The farmer
- Bioclone Australia Pty Ltd
- Planner and manager
- Business philosophy: The Newcastle address
- The public persona
- Family man
- Travelling and the cultivation of friendships
- The philanthropist
- The Boden chair of human nutrition
- The Boden Conferences
- Recognition
- Envoi
- About this memoir
Alex Boden was a manufacturing chemist who succeeded in that most difficult of industries; through his texts, he was an exceptionally successful educational author; and he was a publisher who relished editing, a man of some privacy and reticence who made deep and continuing friendships across the world, a singularly devoted husband, parent and grandparent, and a philanthropist in an age when philanthropy had almost dropped out of sight. His life was one of remarkable richness, variety, originality and generosity. It is unlikely that there has been another Australian of his kind.
His election to the Australian Academy of Science was on the nomination of Professor John Swan, who has recalled:
Alex Boden was a man of remarkable talents, pconcealed by a modest, even humble, exterior. I never saw him angry. He was greatly admired as a man who had achieved much in life but whose ambition was to contribute to family, social and community welfare, to give rather than take, to be supportive of others, and above all to foster the advancement of science.
One can wonder of how many, not professionally engaged in scientific research, it could be said that the voluntary side of their life was 'Above all, to foster the advancement of science'. Or that, as was the case, that they enjoyed no social contacts more than the company of scientists.
In writing this memoir I have depended on much help from Alex's family and former business associates, but I have also relied at times on my own recollections. We first met in 1942 in a manner so typical of Alex's style that it should strike a suitable note for appreciation of the longer narrative.
I was in Dymock's bookshop in Sydney looking at an enticing shelf of chemistry texts. There was a young, suited man beside me, and he asked me - I was in school uniform - what books I used at school. Idrew down two favourite English texts. He said: 'What about this one?' and he picked out Boden's Handbook of Chemistry. 'Oh', I said, 'it's our set text but it's no good'. 'Oh, I'm sorry,' he said. 'I wrote it'. The next day I sent him a letter detailing my reasons for that embarrassing verdict. They were actually only nitpicking ones. In response Alex bravely offered me my first job, at £2 a week, to work through the vacation at the Hardman Research Laboratory on revisions of the Handbook for the next edition. I accepted.
Early years
Alexander Boden was born on 28 May 1913, shortly after William and Helena Boden arrived in Australia from Northern Ireland. They established a drapery business in the main shopping centre of the Sydney suburb of Chatswood. He was the only son; there were two sisters.
His father, William Boden, was born in Ballinasloe on the border of counties Galway and Roscommon, but went in his youth to join his uncle in the latter's evidently prosperous drapery story in Magherafelt, Co. Derry. A surviving photograph of the staff of the store is impressive: some fifty men and women in starched collars and prim blouses stand in well-ordered ranks. The move to Australia in 1913 followed the emigration of two brothers and a sister. His mother, formerly Helena Isabella Hutchinson, a schoolteacher, came from Knockboy, near Broughshane, Co. Antrim, of a family of schoolteachers and clerics.
Alex Boden's education was at Willoughby Public School and North Sydney Boys High School. His father's premises were owned by the pharmacists Washington H. Soul, Pattinson and Co. and one day, while the young Alex was still at school, his father asked his landlord what was the best career for a boy. 'Buyin' and sellin'' was DrPattinson's counsel. In a greatly expanded sense it could be said that Alex Boden followed this advice.
The student
In 1929 Alex passed the Leaving Certificate with honours in Mathematics and Chemistry. An exhibition took him to the University of Sydney, where he enrolled in science to which he, like many before and after him, had been drawn by school chemical experiments:
I can trace my interest in chemistry to my first chemical experiment in school, changing the colour of litmus paper. I took some paper home and spent an exciting afternoon changing it from pink to blue with vinegar and washing soda. This was something I could do without instruction or interference from others. [1]
The last sentence is revealing: self-reliance was to be the hallmark of his life.
He made ample time for extracurricular activity, and set a possible record in ecumenism through his simultaneous membership of the Student Christian Movement (he had been a Sunday school teacher at Willoughby Presbyterian church), of Professor John Anderson's notoriously subversive Freethought Society, and the Sydney University Regiment (Corporal 1931). He became a highly-qualified Boy Scout leader. He spoke at the Sydney University Union's parliamentary-style Union Night debates, and engaged in hockey and wrestling.
Notable survivals of that time are notebooks in which Alex recorded in carefully marshalled tables the books he had read and his opinions of them. Thus in his first university year he records reading, wholly or in part, about a hundred books. Representative entries from that year include Better Ballroom Dancing by Scott (75% read) with a note 'Correction of mistakes etc.'; Goodbye to All That by Robert Graves (all read) 'Good realistic. No censoring of language'; Handbook of Photography by Sinclair (most read) 'Pretty good but a bit old-fashioned'; Religion and Science, by Draper (all read) 'V. readable'; English Regal Copper Coins, by Bamah (most read); 'Coins 16721860. No pics. may be good for reference'; La Vie des Abeilles by Maeterlinck (2/3 read) 'V.g. Hard French. Interesting and novel'; Communist Manifesto by Marx and Engels (all read) 'Quite fair. Rather old but still interesting'. This remarkable reading programme continued, with unabated assiduity and eclecticism, right through to the end of his fourth year - 400 titles, all similarly noted.
He graduated with honours in the bleak year of 1933. While this account must shortly take up his business career, it will be convenient here to carry on with one of his subsequent extra-professional interests - the theatre. He joined The Playmakers and in 1934 made his debut in Crime Made Legal. Advance publicity noted that 'Alex Boden is a newcomer to the Society and is making his first appearance in the important part of Inspector Burke. His fine speaking voice and confident bearing are sure to find favour.' It must be assumed that they did, for he made at least a dozen subsequent appearances, mostly with Sydney's oldest repertory company, The Sydney Players. His notices were generally flattering, as in A Midsummer Night's Dream: 'As Theseus, Alex Boden was easily the most competent of last night's performers. He alone gave real dignity to his lines.'
After 1936, however, the store of programmes and press clippings stops. Life had acquired other dimensions. He wrote in his notebook:
Aged twenty four and watching now the last grains of 1937 run through our fingers. A book [his Handbook of Chemistry] was born in January. Perhaps it will be worthy of rebirth. Almost a beginning on another. Finances are dull but they have been smoothed sufficiently to give a little takeoff for 1938. Sentiments not entirely controlled and showing no practical advance.
1937 was the year of a blundering young chemist in ignorant virtuous lazy search for better things (what better things?). The need is for better blending of gravitas and j[oie] de v[ivre]. The morning is ripening rapidly.
The manufacturing chemist
Boden's business career took two paths that need to be traced separately. One, his career in science and chemical manufacture, follows naturally at this point. Later, there will be an account of his parallel career as publisher and author.
His first job (1934) was a nine-month temporary appointment as an assistant biochemist at Royal North Shore Hospital. This was the only time he worked for a salary. While searching for a next job at the depths of the depression, his eyes were clearly on the commercial world. On 28 June 1935 there was registered the Pastoral Products Company for 'the manufacture and sale of chemical products etc.', proprietors Alexander Boden (then just 22) and Douglas J. Bush. Of this venture nothing has been found but a letterhead with a mid-city address describing the company as 'manufacturers and distributors of accessories for the man on the land'.
He did however make another more durable move the same year through an advertisement for a position with a Hardman Research Laboratory, at 1035 Bourke Road, Waterloo. The owner, name unknown, was 'an oldish bachelor' who wanted to build a business for a protégé, Kethel Hardman. Dr Len Atkins, a life-long friend, remembers Hardman as a youngish man, not a technologist, who had set up a business based on contract analytical work supplemented by the recycling of 35 mm movie film, recovering nitrocellulose and silver. The business lacked a chemical director. Alex wrote: 'I knew so little that I thought I knew everything and fitted in immediately'. The Waterloo premises included a modest laboratory. Alex expanded the recycling business to the reprocessing of X-ray plates, the recovery of silver from spent fixing fluids from photographic processors, and of lead from toothpaste tubes.
The arrangement with Hardman was presumably, since it was not salaried, of a commission or profit-sharing kind. In any event, it was unharmonious and short-lived and Hardman left. There was then a fire in the celluloid film plant which the owner had insured well. He told Alex that once he had the insurance money, Alex could have the business. Thus Alex, by then a Registered Analyst, acquired the Hardman business and chose to retain the name. He moved to a laboratory situated above a furrier's overlooking Hyde Park. The analytical services were transferred to premises in Crown Street, Surry Hills, under the name of Sydney Testing Laboratories Pty Ltd. Alex began to buy, repackage and sell chemicals. His products included 'Lotus Bloom' face powder, price 6d, advertised, with a portrait, by Woolworths in the Sydney Sun, 25 May 1939:
Chemist triumphs. For months and months Mr A. Boden B.Sc., skilled analyst, has been testing and comparing expensive world famous powders ... Read these amazing facts: 27 Actual tests were necessary before Lotus Bloom was perfected ...
Shortly after graduation Alex had been in friendly association with another chemist, who had found employment with a shoe factory and was formulating shoe finishes: dyes, waxes, latexes, adhesives. Having thus learnt about these arcane matters, Alex in 1939 suggested to a hockey team-mate, Max Carson, that they go into business to supply such products to the trade. The operation was conducted, as Shirley Finishes Pty Ltd, from a garage in Crown Street, later in Chippendale. In due course the adhesives side of the business, initially based on formulations of natural rubber but later moving to synthetics, became the dominant one. In the mid-1950s, Carson acquired Alex's interests.
In parallel (1940) with another partner, Ray Russell, Alex embarked on actual chemical manufacture in Enmore, an inner suburb. A new company, Alex Minter & Co., was formed: the name was invented. A meat chemist, George Levack, suggested the first product: glyceryl monostearate, an emulsifier used, for example, in hair creams, and made by heating hydrogenated stearine with glycerol. Other trademarked products were copper oleate as a waterproofing agent, and products for hardening paints and metal welding fluxes. Alex Minter & Co. later moved to a seven-acre site in Northmead, manufacturing products for water treatment, preservation of textiles and various agricultural applications: aluminium sulphate and aluminium hydroxide gel, copper 'naphthanate' (hexahydrobenzoate), and metal stearates. Alex Minter was sold in 1961 to Chemical Materials Ltd.
Meanwhile in 1948 Alex founded Hardman Chemicals Pty Ltd and in 1953 he moved this operation to the site of a former army warehouse in Marrickville, on a residuum of which Boden Books (owner of Science Press) and a later company, Bioclone Australia, now operate. He embarked on a new venture based on reacting chlorine gas with ethanol and with benzene, a development that came about indirectly through one of his clients, a carpet manufacturing company. The technical director, Dr Egon Grauaug, was interested in making certain wetting agents used in wool scouring and hence in carpet manufacture. They were based on epichlorhydrin which can be made from glycerol and hydrogen chloride, and hydrogen chloride is readily made as a byproduct of organic chlorination reactions.
A product requiring chlorination chemistry is DDT (p,p'-dichloro-diphenyl-trichloroethane), the demand for which was just developing. The original intent was thus to use the manufacture of DDT as a source of hydrogen chloride for the manufacture of epichlorhydrin. In fact that objective was abandoned quite early in favour of the manufacture of DDT in quantity much greater than the demand for a speciality wetting agent would justify. Alex carried out the initial experiments at home, where a pilot chlorination plant was built, supervised during the day by his wife. Primary products of the chlorination of alcohol and benzene are trichloracetaldehyde ('chloral', an hypnotic) and chlorobenzene (plus higher chlorinated benzenes: markets were established for p-dichlorobenzene as an insecticide and as a counter-odorant, and for o-dichlorobenzene as a solvent and cleanser). Condensed together in the presence of cold fuming sulphuric acid, chloral and chlorobenzene produce DDT which separates as a waxy solid.
The accompanying rather dingy picture of the plant is reproduced from Boden's An Introduction to Physics and Chemistry (1959). The chlorination of ethanol was a continuous process. Alex recalled (in speaking notes for a lecture, post-1978) that in the early days he spent nights checking the process, sleeping near the coal-fired boiler to keep warm:
We could not afford to buy good chemical engineering equipment, so we made a lot of it ourselves. Teflon was relatively new then, and we pressed it and made it into gaskets and valves and pumps which worked well. No other plastic construction material was available to resist a mixture of hot solvent, chlorine, and hydrogen chloride.
Elsewhere he wrote:
The condensation of chloral and chlorobenzene is a right messy operation. Handling highly flammable poisonous solvents, corrosive hydrochloric acid and 103% sulphuric acid can hardly be taken as a chemical picnic. We had a keen team of fitters who built new plant as the old fell to pieces. [1]
The copious byproduct hydrogen chloride had to be disposed of. The economic viability of the enterprise was secured through a contract to supply the battery company Eveready, in nearby Rosebery, with drums of zinc chloride solution, made from Hardman's hydrochloric acid and scrap zinc obtained from galvanizing plants. In a reminiscence in 1986, he said:
We made DDT in those days, and when I say we, that meant everybody. We made zinc chloride and packed it into drums, and everybody had to help roll the drums up on to the truck which took them to Rosebery.
The manufacture of zinc chloride extended, using imported ammonium chloride, to zinc ammonium chloride for sale principally to the galvanized pipe division of Stewart and Lloyd, in Newcastle. There followed in the 1960s the establishment of a merchandising department selling eventually sodium fluoride, textile dyes and reflective sheeting. Cash flow was further bolstered by manufacturing, under license, a product for phosphatising steel prior to painting.
The company entered the 1960s with justifiable confidence, but Alex later said
I was fortunate to be involved in the chemical industry in the 1950s when shortages of chemicals meant that one could make a chemical with some hope of selling it. Now competition from overseas supplies and the high cost of labour make a new chemical enterprise expensive and hazardous. [2]
In fact, the 1960s were not easy. The company was short of capital and suffered from liquidity problems. There was a fire in the chlorobenzene plant. Against all Alex's instincts he was at times forced to retrench staff and at other times to ask staff to accept pay cuts.
His turnaround came in the late 1960s through George Levack who had moved to the central coast of New South Wales and had met Owen Chapman, an engineer involved in rutile mining there. Alex joined Chapman in a mining venture, Wyong Rutile Pty Ltd (later Wyong Minerals). For three years, as Coastal Chemicals Pty Ltd based at Wyong, he also manufactured rutile mining equipment in fibreglass. Wyong Minerals was later transformed into a sizeable holding in the then substantial Victorian Antimony Mining (VAM) group. The later timely sale of his interest in VAM was critical to his tenacious preservation of Hardman over the period that it was relocating to Seven Hills and recasting its product lines.
With the capital gained from the VAM transaction Alex further developed the Marrickville site and also built a portfolio of investments in public companies and commercial property developments. He had for many years been a ready and generous donor to causes scientific and individual. The income from these investments led him to think later about the possibility of larger philanthropies, and eventually made them possible.
The end of DDT
When Alex began manufacture in the 1950s, DDT was seen as a magical pesticide. It had saved possibly more lives than any previous man-made product. A change came with the raising of environmental alarms, for which DDT became the scapegoat and icon. Also, concern spread to human health. Alex, who had advanced ideas in regard to health checks for his staff, recalled:
During the years that our company made DDT I had, at various times, fears for my staff who, like myself, were reasonably saturated with the sticky stuff. I visited DDT plants in other parts of the world, and gradually became satisfied that DDT is harmless to man, and that DDT workers were as healthy as the general population. In the DDT plant in Los Angeles, the largest in the world, the workers were found to be average in all health respects except cancer cases which were, surprisingly, nil.
This led to a study of DDT as a cancer inhibitor. DDT was fed, along with a known carcinogen, to female rats. The results indicated that DDT-treated rats had a significantly lower incidence of mammary cancer, and a lower number of tumour sites than the control group. The work was not pursued because of the impossibility of experiments on humans, but it might have shown that the residues of DDT, for which DDT was banned on general aesthetic grounds, and because of its persistence in the environment, could have been beneficial after all. [2]
Also making DDT were ICIANZ and Union Carbide. Each eventually found its manufacture to be uneconomic. Hardman Chemicals continued making DDT through the 1960s, but environmental concerns led to its declining use and the problems of by-product waste disposal increased. Black liquid residues consisting mostly of sulphuric acid mixed with sulphonated chlorobenzenes were no longer welcome at the old brickpit tip at nearby St Peters. Alex could now buy hydrochloric acid more cheaply than he could make it. He told me too that whatever the case for continued approved uses, as a publisher of school texts that treated social issues in science, he could hardly continue to make such a controversial product. The resourceful integrated programme of manufactures based on chlorination chemistry, that had begun in the 1950s, closed in the early 1970s.
Hardman at Seven Hills
By then, most of the functions of Hardman had been moved to a 20-acre site at Seven Hills, in western Sydney. The land, a dairy farm, had been acquired in 1961. Production shifted from organics to inorganics, particularly aluminium chloride and chlorhydrate, zinc chloride and zinc ammonium chloride, which became the heart of the Hardman operation. With knowledge that his largest customer was planning to phase out its demand for zinc chloride, Alex sought an alternative product. For some years (commencing in Marrickville) he was able to secure a valuable raw material in the form of stockpiled baghouse fume from the copper smelter (Electrolytic Refining and Smelting, later Southern Copper) at Port Kembla. The fume was a complex mixture of 33% zinc, 25% lead and in amounts from 2% down to 0.5% copper, cadmium, arsenic, tin, bismuth and antimony, with other elements in still smaller quantities. Their recovery presented novel problems in extractive metallurgy. Eventually, zinc alone was recovered (as sulphate) at Hardman and the balance, in the form of lead sulphate with admixtures, was shipped profitably to an English smelter. By 1970 the company had built up a large export business, mainly of zinc sulphate (monohydrate and heptahydrate) to the USA. This achievement was recognised via a government E for Export Award.
Markets move: the demand for zinc chloride products fell, and further diversification was needed. To enlarge the company's customer base (up to that point, only about fifteen companies), manufacture commenced, under license, of a range of novel water-soluble epoxy resins for surface coatings and modification of concrete. Some non-chemical manufacturing was attempted, but faltered at the task of retail marketing.
In 1987 the company's name changed to Hardman Australia, primarily to identify more clearly its Australian origin and ownership, but also to distance itself from exclusive dependence on chemicals. The policy Alex set for it (recalled in later Board minutes) was simply that Hardman should be a conservative, ethical company to be operated with the aim of increasing its net worth. At the time of his death Hardman Australia had fifty staff and an annual turnover of the order of $15 million. Products manufactured included aluminium hydroxychloride and aluminium and magnesium hydroxide gel and polyaluminium chloride for adhesives, antiperspirants, liquid stomach antacids, and water treatment; zinc sulphate as a micronutrient for cereals and other crops and, specially formulated, as a treatment for footrot; zinc chloride and zinc ammonium chloride; magnesium chloride for textile processing and adhesives; magnesium hydroxide gel for pharmaceuticals; water-soluble epoxies; and certain moulded road-safety products such as reflective road markers and flexible reflective roadside posts. These manufactures were complemented by an extensive range of indented product lines, while a 49% owned company, Hardman Chemical Industries Pte [SIC] Ltd in Singapore, produced inorganic chemicals for the South-East Asian market.
Science press
There was a certain inevitability about Alex Boden becoming a publisher. As an undergraduate he had produced mimeographed lecture notes that were sold through the Sydney University Union. He is remembered as watching nearby to see how they were selling. He became production editor of the student newspaper Honi Soit and he sold advertising for the Science Association's Science Journal - no mean task in the depths of the depression. His reward was to meet Dr Ernest Harden, the Hungarian proprietor of the Shakespeare Head Press, whose advertisement appeared in the 1933 Journal.
A chance meeting after Alex's graduation led Harden to invite him to prepare a textbook for secondary school chemistry, suited to the New South Wales curriculum. From his own methodical high school notes, reworked to reflect his later studies and his developing interest in the economic significance of chemistry, he delivered in 1936 the manuscript of A Handbook of Chemistry. Notwithstanding that both professors of chemistry rang Harden to say that Alex didn't know enough chemistry to write a textbook, Harden went ahead and the book appeared in 1937 under the Shakespeare Head imprint. There was a revised edition in 1941, and then the publisher was taken over by Consolidated Press.
The Handbook of Chemistry was thus committed to the Consolidated (Shakespeare Head) Press, to that press's considerable profit. Harden described the book in his catalogue as one of the major successes of Australian publishing. Alex later compiled a more elementary Introduction to Modern Chemistry, which he thought should be sold at a low price. Harden said he could not sell it at the price proposed but encouraged Alex to publish it himself. He established Science Press in 1943, and its first productions in 1946 were the Introduction and a booklet of physics problems.
The notion, that the books produced by Science Press should be made available to students as cheaply as possible, was to be a hallmark of his press's operations. The result was, however, that the Press was in most years a drain on the group's finances, even though Alex never took out a salary for his role in it or charged rent. In short, the Press would not have survived without the backing of chemical manufacture.
Around this time Keith Bullen FAA FRS arrived in Sydney to the chair of applied mathematics. Alex agreed to publish his Introduction to the Theory of Dynamics (1948), subsequently enlarged to cover statics. The resulting Introduction to the Theory of Mechanics (1949), pitched at undergraduates or senior secondary pupils in the British system, received respectful reviews. Publication in Australia of a mathematical text to Bullen's excruciatingly meticulous standards presented problems. Having resourcefully resolved them, the effort brought its rewards: Bullen's Dynamics ran through eight editions over the next 22 years.
While the Press was active with reprints, further titles were added only slowly: another of Alex's own elementary books in 1959, then two mathematical texts by commissioned authors, and in 1962 his Senior Chemistry. Exclusive preoccupation with science ended in 1962/3, when the Press branched into high school texts in French and in literature. A six-part series on French was destined to be a conspicuous success, passing the landmark of a million volumes sold around 1990.
In the 1970s, Science Press's publication programme expanded, with an increasingly wide range of titles. Of the 140 titles published by Science Press up to the time of Alex's death, many would not have been of his direct concern. But surprisingly many would have been, to some degree. Alex loved editing and, to adopt the word he used for his role in Chemical Science (1976), producing books. The early textbooks on French were worked over intensively by him, providing exemplars of the way he thought Science Press should publish for Australian schools. To the end of his life he would use spare time on aeroplanes, in the early morning, or where else occurring, perfecting text: his own or his authors'.
An example will illustrate the ubiquity and detailed nature of his involvement. In 1975 the Press issued a kit text by T.Hackett et al. Communicate! An Introduction to the Language and Culture of Germany, Japan, France and Indonesia. With another edition on the way, he wrote in 1979 to Mrs Michiko Furosho, the opera singer daughter of a business associate in Tokyo, in the following terms:
Dear Michiko: I have a book on languages for Australian students. To go with each language we have a tape. On one side is text material, on the other we want to give songs of the country. These songs should be ones that the students can sing themselves and so learn to use the language ... I remember the beautiful songs that you sent to the ABC through me and your sweet voice would be ideal for the songs needed. What songs do you sing to Mikihito [her son]? I would like to ask if you could organise such a tape for me. Some variations would be welcome such as a male voice or a group of voices. Some of the children's choirs that I heard on Japanese TV were wonderful ...
A listing of the complete output of Science Press, up to the time of its founder's death, has been lodged with the Australian Academy of Science. This list of some 170 titles, seemingly so diverse, nevertheless reflects a consistent philosophy. One can discern in it the pedagogue manqué, the desire to deal with issues as well as with curricula and, even when the detailed decisions were not his, the hand upon the tiller. Music, art, communication, societies feature, far cries from chemistry; and new media such as audio and video cassettes appear.
The author
The chemistry texts used in Australian schools in the 1930s were invariably of British provenance and style. Alex Boden's first book, the Handbook of Chemistry, set a new pattern from the outset. Its frontispiece was a map of Australia with mineral occurrences marked. Its text was plain and clear with numerous Australian references and industrial and social allusions were prominent.
He was keen on the production of petrol from coal. The caption to Fig. 16 is pure, proselytising Boden (aged 23):
View of part of the works at Billingham, where petrol from coal is stored. Eventually coal may replace petroleum as a source of volatile fuel. New sources of energy will be one of the major problems of industry in the future.
Successive editions went through numerous changes. The second, in 1941, was 50% longer, and the seventh (1948) was further expanded. By then the book had been considerably transformed, especially in its much more numerous illustrations. The book remained in print, essentially unaltered, till the tenth edition (1957).
In 1945, to meet the requirements of the chemistry part of a combined Chemistry and Physics course in New South Wales, Alex compiled and, as had become his practice during successive revisions of the Handbook, trialled with the assistance of numerous school teachers, a shorter Introduction to Modern Chemistry (1946). The text was concise with generous illustrations and descriptions of applications of chemistry in industry and agriculture - and in a tentative way in biology.
Following the publication, collaboratively, of two small books of problems in elementary chemistry and physics, Alex next produced, in 1959, An Introduction to Physics and Chemistry. His diligence in locating appropriate and interesting illustrations is exemplified by a picture of tungsten atoms obtained by the then very new technique of field ion microscopy, the photograph having been obtained directly from the inventor of the method, Erwin Müller.
By 1960, the durable Handbook was out of date, and Alex set about preparing an entirely new Senior Chemistry (1962). In what became his characteristic mode, he was not just an author of the book but also its organizer, using his now numerous contacts in industry, CSIRO, and universities in Australia and abroad as sources of particular pieces of text and of illustrations. The book was copiously illustrated, often with pictures of recent research, especially in CSIRO: his objective was to have at least one half-tone or line block per page. Long before the rise of the feminist movement, he made a particular effort to include pictures of women and references to them. I was closely involved in this book and so witnessed his constant reworking of successive drafts, seeking clarity, conciseness and an effective page layout. I learnt a good deal from seeing my own contributions edited in this way. Frequently, revisions were made so that a page could end with a completed paragraph: a hard objective but one achieved with half of the recto pages of the book. Exquisite pains were taken with diagrams. Again the book was trialled extensively, in ten schools.
There followed an ambitious new venture: two multi-authored texts in general science, once again conceived, produced, copiously illustrated and ruthlessly edited by Boden. Introduction to Science (1964) is a notable achievement. Written for high school students in their first three years, it tackled the problem of teaching over the whole of science. It was successful and sold over 300,000 copies.
I see the production of this book, before its time in terms of international offerings, as a tour de force. This was to be a book for beginning science students: years seven-to-nine. The plan that Alex adopted for his Introduction to Science defined twelve chapters and within each about four defined sections, of which the fourth (given that the first chapters were to deal with the physical end of the sciences) deftly and progressively brought in treatments of biology, ecology, and issues of social consequence. The last of the twelve chapters, on Man and Food, presaged the concerns that were to lead him later to endow the Boden Chair of Human Nutrition.
The book, in six editions, had a successful market for the better part of twenty years. A self-contained sequel, with even more authors and more acknowledgements, was published in 1966 as Advancing with Science. Notable in this book is the explicit treatment of the biology of human reproduction.
Towards the end of the 1970s, Alex's Senior Chemistry became dated, socially as much as scientifically. At a colloquium on senior school chemistry in 1976 he said:
Chemistry is losing popularity among students because many of them consider it to be too hard; I suggest that the word 'irrelevant' be substituted for 'too hard'. Young people in general show a great aptitude for knowledge which they consider to be interesting or useful. Certainly the pressures of affluence affect the time available, and must be taken into account when we determine the rate at which knowledge can be fed to the students. They do not have as much time as they previously had to come to mental equilibrium with the great flow of new knowledge.
Having seen the need for an updated chemistry text, this time he enlisted help. The authorship of Chemical Science (1981) is attributed to Hunter, Simpson and Stranks, with a separate laboratory manual compiled by Carswell, the whole 'produced' by Boden. Eventual sales attained 100,000.
For some years, in the 1960s, when many publishers were commissioning their printing overseas, Alex considered he had a responsibility to support Australian printing houses. By the 1970s, however, the economics of offshore publishing were inexorable, and Chemical Science was printed, in multicolour, in Singapore.
With the production of Chemical Science one might have expected Alex to hang up his boots as a sole author of chemistry texts. Nevertheless, just five years later (he was then 73), there appeared his 512-page Chemtext (1986), just short of fifty years after his first book, the Handbook. Chemtext was a wholly new book as modern in its style as its snappy title, with an enthusiastic foreword by Barry O. Jones FAA, then Minister for Science. The next year, collaboratively, Alex published an accompanying Teachers' Manual.
For anyone who has taught chemistry - indeed science - over many decades, and perhaps was weaned on Boden's original Handbook, the shift that is shown in Chemtext is astonishing in its dimension, yet wonderful in its youthful spirit. Barry Jones launched the book and declared that Chemtext ought to be required reading for every member of the Federal Cabinet.
John Emsley, New Scientist's chemistry correspondent, in reviewing new offerings in the chemistry textbook market, also enthused:
Although people assume that the US is the only market capable of supporting full-colour general texts, Chemtext, by Alexander Boden from Australia, shows it can be done elsewhere. And done better. Here is a book imbued with the joy of chemistry. Items of human interest dot its pages, and Boden takes every opportunity to show the relevance of the subject to the everyday world ... Such is my admiration for this book that I can even forgive such words as 'weedicide' and the use of mL. [3]
For some decades the Australian Academy of Science lived, to a degree, on the proceeds of textbooks aimed at the same markets as those for which Alex Boden wrote and produced. Apart from the Academy's flagship biology text The Web of Life, Alex's books were as successful and influential as any.
The farmer
While searching for land on which to relocate Hardman, Alex was shown and later bought a dairy property near Windsor, from which in due course he delivered daily 150 gallons of Friesian milk to the Sydney market. The farm became his principal hobby and weekend retreat. It was also, from 1980, the site of an endeavour in the hydroponic production of vegetables, then more advanced in New Zealand than in Australia. With his son-in-law Hugh Thomas, he developed a 60m long pilot facility with automated analysis and supply of nutrients. Imported chemicals from New Zealand were replaced by Hardman, but there were continuing difficulties in maintaining chelated iron in solution. There were always difficulties in producing tomatoes and lettuce at premium price peaks. A flood terminated the venture. Dairying continues.
Bioclone Australia Pty Ltd
Alex had long deplored the loss to Australia when, as continues to occur, Australian innovations are exploited in other countries. An opportunity to take a personal hand in redressing the outflow came in 1979 through his chairmanship of the New South Wales State Committee of CSIRO. Here he became aware of the emergent outcomes of a collaboration that had been set up between CSIRO's Unit of Molecular and Cellular Biology (Dr Geoff Grigg) and the Garvan Institute of Medical Research (Dr Les Lazarus).
The objective of the collaboration was to develop a series of improved immunoassay systems for assaying human hormones, based on then new monoclonal antibodies. CSIRO and Garvan Institute scientists had isolated families of monoclonal antibodies specific to each of a series of pituitary hormones and began to integrate them into usable assay kits. At this point it was perceived that the development of practical kits for clinical use would be assisted by a commercial collaboration. In the market place these kits would be in competition with products dependent on an inferior technology using polyclonal antibodies. Grigg proposed to a business member of the CSIRO State Committee that a commercial venture be established to develop and market the new technology; the member, in turn, proposed that he and Alex form a partnership. The proposal fell on receptive ears, and Alex agreed.
This speculative enterprise engendered no enthusiasm at all among Alex's senior staff at Hardman, but after listening to the objections, he characteristically made his own decision. He explained that he had seen too much good research lost to the country, and that he considered that biological manufacturing had a promising future.
The decision he made was to set up a company, Bioclone, and provide its start-up finance. 'It happened that I had some shares which had been so much wallpaper for many years but had at last come good'. Management was through his senior Hardman staff. Dr John Smeaton, an expatriate who was running his own diagnostics supply company in the USA, was employed to run the new company and Bioclone was set up in Marrickville in mid 1981. Almost immediately Alex's intended business partner withdrew from the enterprise along with promised funds. Nonetheless, with resourceful improvization Bioclone eventually reached the market place, initially with a pregnancy test. When Smeaton left in 1985, turnover was approaching $1 million per annum, the on-site staff numbered six, and many more, funded by Bioclone, worked at the Garvan Institute and CSIRO.
Nevertheless, from the outset Bioclone seems to have experienced all the varieties of the culture shocks that are to be expected when academic and government scientists and commercial manufacturers meet under the same institutional roof. CSIRO and Garvan staff were critical of the resources Bioclone was prepared to provide or raise, while Hardman managers felt that the research staff saw Bioclone funds in the light of research grants: open ended, without fixed goals or milestones. There were different opinions about commercial strategies. In 1982 Alex made unsuccessful overtures for further capital but later, when urged to float the company - the funds, he was assured, would be easy to raise - he declined to do so. By then he had resolved to build the company through sales, as he had successfully done with Hardman. Another commercially sound objective, apparently favoured by some and certainly prevalent in the biotechnology world, would have been to get the company up to speed - or the prospect of it - and sell it quickly at a profit. This did not happen either: it would have negated Alex's basic reason for committing himself to Bioclone, and his instincts always were to invest for the long haul.
The venture did not enjoy a comfortable life. At its peak of sales performance Bioclone achieved annual sales approaching $3 million. For most of its time it was not profitable and Hardman Chemicals felt that it was haemorrhaging to support it. In the late 1980s, when cash requirements sought from Hardman magnified, there were fears that Hardman might be brought down. At that time Alex would gladly have floated Bioclone and sought to do so, but after the stockmarket crash of 1987 underwriters were unwilling. Crucial assistance was however negotiated through private equity investments, and the company's position improved to the point that it was holding its own and exporting some 25 diagnostic kits, mainly in the endocrine range. It was not, however, able to fund further development from its revenue. Following Alex's death, Bioclone was sold to Hitachi Australia and continues to operate at Marrickville. Thus, to some degree, Alex's primary motive in starting Bioclone was realised, even if not as spectacularly as might have been hoped for in the heady early days of biotechnology.
Ten years after Alex started Bioclone (1980), the Hawke Government initiated its Cooperative Research Centres (CRC) Program. The objectives of this programme are similar to those which Alex had for Bioclone. The social engineering which he sought to effect, in bringing public-sector research workers into effective collaboration with a market-driven private sector, for the benefit of everyone, has proved instructively testing in the six years of the CRC programme. In the execution of any cooperative contract there will be issues of governance, performance, intellectual property rights and strategy, foreign to managers accustomed to directing their own affairs. The university and other public-sector technology marketing companies that have sprung up since the mid-1980s all have hard-won experience of the problems. Alex was a decade ahead of the field.
Planner and manager
Alex Boden's forte was in vision and planning. Of necessity he coped with the mundane routine of general management but he did not enjoy it. Still less did he enjoy the personally distressing tasks that befall all managers at times. It is believed, for example, that he never personally sacked an employee.
Once Hardman Chemicals was on its feet, however, he was able to attract to the company a succession of capable managers. With his trusted managers in place, his style was to encourage, to give trust, to commend improvements and seldom to comment on what had gone wrong. He was also tenacious in holding to commitments he had made. Such tenacity, not always worn easily by his senior staff, was nevertheless characteristic of the way he stuck to and followed up all his decisions. Especially was this true of his philanthropy.
Behind Alex's success in building his company lay relentless enquiry, in the literature (he accumulated what was surely, in Australia, the only privately owned complete set of Chemical Abstracts - eventually given to Bond University), of consultants in the USA in relation to products, processes and markets, and of his exceptionally wide network of commercial, public sector and academic contacts.
His success was founded too on acute observation, of the world, of opportunities, and of the most trivial of passing events. Who else would have recorded in his daily diary that when he was driven from London to Slough at 7.30 am by Celltech's Chief Executive it was in a red Ford Granada? In his notes of business discussions he seems to have been as interested in his discussion partners as in the business matters. In 1967, some 30 tons of French DDT were brought in by a Perth company producing herbicides. Alex recorded a discussion with its principal. After noting that the latter had three children plus an adopted aboriginal boy, that his wife was keen on cooking and learning Russian, and that he had a large boat and 'doesn't worry about business', and yet more domestic details, he went on with:
At university [he] wrote anti-religious contributions to journals. He quoted Voltaire's 'the world will be happy when the last king is choked by the entrails of the last priest'. He talked of knowledge at various levels and [claimed that] with basic enough knowledge of tree and insect behaviour, infestations and even weather cycles can be predicted. I failed to see the connection and asked him to write it down for me.
I also said that business did worry me and instanced stray imports of DDT spoiling an overall arrangement with Australian manufacturers not to import. He said he had not acted with any intent ...
Alex was uninhibited and exceptionally diligent in pursuit of answers. It was entirely natural for him, when planning a visit to Cuba, to write first of all to Fidel Castro for permission to visit a factory (the request was granted). From time to time he would commission research (for example, in CSIRO on the purification of rutile and ilmenite) of a kind beyond the capacity of the company's laboratory. For Bioclone, he established a collaboration in Moscow.
Behind these enquiries lay relentless methodical note-making, a practice demonstrably entrenched in his undergraduate days. In thick carbon-copy volumes, entries were made every three weeks or so, summarizing technical data, market estimates and costs of potential products. Thus in 1955 a suite of successive entries were headed: Weed killers, DDT users, Potassium thiocyanate, Chloride factory, Copper cyanide, Ferrous oxalate, Phosphoric acid, Ammonium chloride, Zinc cyanide, Molybdenum salts. And later: Growing citrus.
Business philosophy: The Newcastle address
On 20 October 1987, Alex (then 74), was invited by the Newcastle Branch of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute to address it, before a dinner. He began: 'If you wish to doze off before dinner, please feel free'.
The unpublished text [1] that he prepared for this occasion traverses in serio-whimsical style his business life. 'My subject' he said, 'is the chemist as a businessman', and then he went on to say:
There is plenty of interest but little amusement in chemistry. Chemists generally are a serious bunch. They are taught to think before speaking and that is a serious handicap in a fast-moving world, especially if you are married.
Chemists are fenced off from the common herd by thoughts of accuracy and limits of error. A science student discussing his activities told his girl friend 'Today we measured thousandths of centimetres'. Gee', she said, 'How many thousandths are there in a centimetre?'. 'Bloody millions' he told her.
Then after discussing the conditions of employment of chemists, hinting at industrial relations, talking about risk taking and market appraisal comes, from the heart:
Some businesses begin as partnerships as prosperity starts to emerge, trouble sets in. Human beings have a great sense of self-esteem. It is rare that one partner credits the other for their prosperity. Sometimes, one becomes less satisfied with only half the cake, and the partnership can be in danger. The seeds of disagreement can be very small. The magnificent partnership of Gilbert and Sullivan broke up over the colour of a new carpet for a theatre. A successful partnership, like a good marriage, can be very satisfying, but it needs wary planning.
On the choice of a business:
What to make in a new business? Something that people want? Nowadays, people are [so] saturated with offers of many goods and services that they do not seem to want anything. Rather the question must be 'What can you sell?' A chemist is likely to think of starting up a business by making chemicals. This is an unlikely way to go
The majority of successful businesses do not involve chemicals. All involve service of some kind which people want to buy.
A business rarely starts with a new invention. That is too chancy. Find something to sell, and start selling it. Then look around for ideas to improve profit by your effort so that you can pay the rent and the wages. Use your friends to help you and your enemies to goad you on. You can spend a lifetime working out a better mouse container. Or you can buy traps from someone who already makes them, and then go out and sell them. A business is there to make money, not to make mouse traps, or chemicals, or magic pills.
As a general rule I suggest that a business is better based on consumable items than on items for which you need a stream of customers beating a path to your door. If you can find a customer for an item which can be sold to the same customers time after time it can be better than having to find a new buyer for each sale.
Further material of an autobiographical nature from this notable address has been incorporated elsewhere in this memoir.
The public persona
Alex was a private man. He did however belong to Sydney's best endowed club, the Australian, and, when not entertaining on his own territory, enjoyed using the club to consolidate friendships. He was a lifelong Freemason.
From the late 1960s onwards he accepted various honorary appointments, among them Vice-President (1968) of the Australian Chemical Industries Council (on which body he was the most substantial sole proprietor), Chairman of CSIRO's New South Wales State (advisory) Committee (1979), and by election a member of the Senate of the University of Sydney (197982). I think it could be said, however, that committees were not his milieu (unless he were in the chair).
Family man
On 20 November 1943, Elizabeth Constance McVicar was married to Alexander Boden at St Stephen's Presbyterian
Church in central Sydney. Beth McVicar was a science graduate who had met Alex some years before when, while an undergraduate, she sought vacation employment. They honeymooned at the Naval Lodge, Jervis Bay. The surviving receipt, a reminder of the times, says: please bring tea, butter and sugar coupons.
There were five children, all Sydney University graduates: Alexandra (medicine), Diana (a PhD in biochemistry), Elissa (agriculture and law), William (science) and Helena (science and psychology). All are married, between them they have eighteen children and grandchildren, every one treasured by Alex whose attention to them all was extraordinary, given the demands of his business life. The headmistress of his daughters' school used to say that he was the only father she could count on to turn up for the school's sports and open days.
The public side of Alex's life was business and its attendant risk-taking; his family was his haven and delight, and Beth was his complement. A colleague has commented that he lived very comfortably among females: four out of five children and nearby a vigorous artistic mother-in-law. Alex, for all his network of professional contacts, was inherently a reserved man. Beth, the most generous of hostesses, was his perfect foil. Between them, they projected, and delivered, a special kind of expansive hospitality.
There was a choice of venues for their hospitality, and all were much used by children, grandchildren and guests: their principal house in Roseville, a rangy holiday house at Palm Beach, another house at Blackheath in the Blue Mountains, and the farm.
Travelling and the cultivation of friendships
In a letter written in 1987 Alex supplied a short curriculum vitae concluding with:'Hobbies: Trying to avoid being drowned in paper. Travelling. Collecting personal relationships.' The last two of these 'hobbies' interlocked. While his travels were often for business purposes, the end result was as much the cultivation of friendships, new and renewed, as the achievement of any commercial objectives.
His first foray beyond Australia was in 1951, by air, when intercontinental air travel was novel, airport departures were as enthusiastic and social as the streamered farewells accorded to departing passengers on ocean liners, and the BCPA DC6 aircraft offered sleeping accommodation. Beth accompanied him. They went to the USA and attended the Diamond Jubilee Banquet of the American Chemical Society where he first met Linus Pauling, who many years later was to suggest the title for the endowed Boden Chair of Human Nutrition. Back in Australia, Alex sought out visitors to the country whom he might be able to entertain and assist. In 1956 he received the following letter from Missouri:
Your kind invitation was highly appreciated. I wish I could accept, but conditions have arisen, unfortunately, which will prevent my visiting Australia as planned. I regret it very much. Harry Truman.
Dr Geoff Grigg has recalled his style:
Alex liked making the opportunity to meet old scientific friends and to hear what they were doing with their science or their families. He was a kind man and always generous with his time and with his hospitality. On learning that an old friend was flying off somewhere or returning from overseas and arriving at the crack of dawn he would be down to farewell him or her or to pick them up and drive them home. Perhaps it was not such a sacrifice for Alex to get up early to go to the airport as it would be for most, since he made a practice of starting work very early, at 4.30 am anyway.
In 1976 agreements were concluded with the Mafatlal Group in Bombay to promote their dyestuffs and textile chemicals. Before long personal contacts including attendance at four magnificent Mafatlal family weddings in Bombay - became far more important to Alex than mere business.
In the mid-1960s Sergei Kapitza, son of the Nobel Laureate Peter Kapitza, spent some months in the Physics Department at the University of Sydney. He was admirably sociable and it was inevitable that the Bodens would draw him and his wife into their hospitality. The Kapitzas became family friends. Again, in 1979 Alex met Professor Yuri Obchinnikov who represented the USSR Academy of Science at the Australian Academy's 25th anniversary celebration. Professional contacts ensued. These connections became close, evidenced by five visits to Moscow, photographs of three generations of Kapitzas, and in travel diaries admiring descriptions of Obchinnikov's offices and his ways of dealing with the Soviet bureaucracy.
Some years later Obchinnikov, his wife and two colleagues came at Alex's invitation to attend a Boden conference on 'Membranes: Fundamentals and Applications'. It was then learned that Obchinnikov had a terminal illness; upon his death Alex was invited to contribute a memoir to a commemorative volume Portrait of a Scientist (Through his Friends' Eyes) in which it has presumably been published in Russian.
He had other close friends in Japan, China, Singapore, Europe, America and China. The last included two doctors, married, whom he twice funded for experience in Australian hospitals.
The better to sustain these friendships, Alex in his later years was grappling with Russian and Mandarin.
The philanthropist
It may be that, for those few with great accumulated wealth and a philanthropic inclination, they do not know how to begin. Hence charitable foundations. For Alex, charity began while he was still anxiously watching his bottom line. The University of Sydney was his principal beneficiary over many decades, starting in 1946 (he was then 33 and hardly grandly pecunious), when he met a request for funds to restore the third year chemistry laboratory (the cost was £1230/6/8, which closely approximated the salary of a professor at the time). But beyond the formal record lie many gifts unrecorded. They include help to his many immigrant employees, especially towards the education of their children, and (gleaned from letters poked into filing cabinets) frequent assistance towards travel abroad by scientists. However, no donation from Alex ended with the gift: the donor would take a long-term interest in the outcome and the recipient might well benefit further. The impersonal character of the conventional welfare charities thus held no attraction for him.
His gifts to the University of Sydney escalated when approached by Professor Hans Freeman FAA, in his pre-professorial days. Freeman has recalled his first conversation with Alex at a departmental cocktail party.
I had recently returned from CalTech to take up a Lectureship. My ambition was to explore the function of metals in biological systems by studying the crystal structures of metal complexes with simple biological ligands. At the time this was avant-garde stuff and the prospects for getting support for the research in Sydney were not promising. The world, even after sherry, looked gloomy. Someone introduced me to Alex and to this day I do not know what I said to him. A little while later he turned up with a cheque for £5000, a very large sum in 1959.
That gift funded Alexander Boden Fellowships. Some years later (1970) when Freeman was appointed to the chair of inorganic chemistry he asked Alex for help in maintaining a higher visibility for the subject. Alex sponsored, and found among his business contacts donors for, the Foundation for Inorganic Chemistry. It has a governing board that he chaired till his death. He made the point at the outset that if you are going to have donors you have to thank them, and so it happened that to inaugurate the Foundation, there was a dinner in the University's Great Hall. Freeman proposed that Linus Pauling and his wife be the first visitors sponsored by the Foundation, and that they attend the dinner. Freeman recalls:
Totally charmed by Linus Pauling, Alex appointed himself as his chauffeur for the three weeks of his stay in Sydney. It was on the way from the Sebel Town house to the ABC studios in William Street that Alex asked, as only Alex could: 'Linus, what is the most important research in the world today?'. The answer, as we turned into William Street, was instantaneous. 'Research on human nutrition. Think of how much suffering could be prevented if we knew more about fundamental aspects of human health.'
The Foundation, set up with a capital fund, supports two visiting scientists each year.
There were many other gifts. From back in the 1960s, when it could have been said that Professor Harry Messel and Alex were contenders in the high school publishing field, to the time of his death, Alex was a consistent and generous supporter of Messel's Science Foundation for Physics. To the Chemistry Department, there was a donation for what has now appropriately been renamed the Alexander Boden Library. He was a continuing and substantial supporter of selected causes within medical research institutes, among them the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital's positron emission tomography project, the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute, the Prince Henry Hospital Brain Surgery Unit, and Foundation 41. Of his donations he once remarked:
By good luck I have been able to work without having to obtain capital from others. This is particularly useful when you want to give money away, something no sensible partner would tolerate.
The Boden chair of human nutrition
The interchange with Pauling, reported above, appears to have crystallized an intention that Alex had been tossing around in his mind: to endow a chair, a Boden chair, in the faculty of science of the University of Sydney. The potential for application of benefit to Australia, and especially to humanity, was always a criterion.
Pauling at the time of his 1973 visit brought with him a copy of his latest book, Orthomolecular Medicine. Alex later said (of an intention that almost certainly only firmed up during and because of that visit):
I told him of my intention to fund a chair along the same lines of Medicine linked to good chemistry, but indicated that 'orthomolecular medicine' was not familiar to all. He then suggested that Nutrition would be a more understandable subject and so it was named. The department of Human Nutrition, as distinct from animal nutrition, has prospered in a satisfactory manner since then.
He called on the Vice-Chancellor to tell him of his intention and to enquire what the cost would be. Sir Bruce Williams recalls that Alex was pensive, but not deterred, when informed of a sum of the order of twenty times a professorial salary. Some two years later he told Williams that he believed he could subscribe the funds over a period, but would need to talk first with the members of his company - 'he preferred the term members to employees' - to secure their concurrence to the gift. The drawdown of capital that might otherwise be employed for Hardman's purposes could affect their livelihoods.
The Boden Chair of Human Nutrition was created in 1976 to 'develop teaching and research in human nutrition. Especially in developed countries there is evidence that dietary factors may be involved in the etiology of cardiovascular disease, diabetes, malignant disease and obesity in childhood and adult life.'
In a eulogy given at a meeting of the Faculty of Science in 1994, the first incumbent, Professor Stewart Truswell, said:
After endowing this unique chair, Alex's consistent, non-interfering encouragement and moral support were just as important to the realisation of his dream ... On my first day as Boden professor, the senior administrator in the staff office said they were worried because there had never been an endowed chair with the benefactor living. Perhaps Mr Boden might exert undue academic influence on me! As it turned out I can only recall one occasion when Alex discouraged me in a particular project - and he was right.
Truswell arrived in May 1978, and was duly taken under the Bodens' social wing. He did not, however, have a dowry of money for research. He found himself in some difficulty with other senior people in fields cognate with his about raising money for nutrition. An Australian Nutrition Foundation was to be set up with the aim of educating the public. Truswell wanted it to fund nutrition research as well: this was thought not to be feasible. He has recalled:
On 4 October 1978 in my diary: 'Several talks with Alex Boden. We agree to start our own Sydney University Nutrition Foundation and leave the other Australian Nutrition Foundation be'. So we had two parallel foundations, one for nutrition education of the public across Australia, the other ours with the objective of supporting research in the Human nutrition unit in the University of Sydney.
Alex's support was crucial in getting the foundation going. With his continuing attention, gently expressed, it prospered, and the Human Nutrition Unit appears to be securely entrenched in the University.
The Boden Conferences
The Australian Academy of Science was, to a significant degree, Alex's principal Australian competitor in the world of science publishing for secondary schools. But then he knew personally, through his professional and philanthropic interests, a surprisingly numerous and diverse sample of its Fellows. He had been since 1977 a member of the Academy's Science and Industry Forum.
The Academy's history, The First Forty Years, states that in 1979 the National Committee for Biological Sciences proposed that a series of small, specialist meetings on biological subjects should be established as a continuing activity, and that Alex agreed to fund them. What actually happened was that Dr Jim Peacock FAA in his CSIRO Plant Industry office admired a style of conferences, type-named Gordon Conferences, in the USA and felt that Australian biologists needed a similar opportunity. Peacock recalls:
I asked Alex to join me in my office one day when he was to be in Canberra, to discuss over a sandwich lunch an Academy matter on which I needed his advice. He agreed. I began by describing the Gordon Conference concept and I explained why I thought conferences of that kind could be of great benefit to biological research in Australia. Alex showed gratifying interest. I went on to ask for his suggestions on how the Academy might gather up commercial support to meet the costs of organising such meetings - the principal cost being fares for distinguished invited speakers from outside Australia. Alex then said: 'Oh well. I might as well put up the money myself'.
What he agreed to do was to supply the funds needed for two conferences a year for three years, later extended to five. The conference themes were to be proposed to an Academy committee, which Peacock chaired, through appropriate scientific societies. Commencing in 1981, a pattern was set of sequential conferences held at Thredbo in the Australian Alps each February. Alex and Beth Boden attended them and their participation and enjoyment enhanced and distinguished the meetings.
In 1985 Peacock with the then President of the Academy, Arthur Birch, invited Alex to a private dinner at Sydney's leading hotel. As the meal drew to an end, Alex (who no doubt could sense a baited trap better than most) asked what the purpose of the exercise might be, and that was duly identified: the need for a capital fund to support the Boden conferences in perpetuity. What would that cost? Peacock just happened to have the calculations at hand. Alex gave in graciously. The specific agreement was to provide $200,000 over four years. The future of the Boden conferences was assured.
A list of the topics of all Boden Conferences, to 1994, is in The First Forty Years. In recognition of Alex's benefactions and other contributions to the Academy's work, the enclosed garden at the city side of the Academy's Ian Potter House was named Boden Court.
Recognition
Alex had to wait till he was nearly seventy to receive the accolades he manifestly deserved. Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science by Special Election, in 1982; Officer in the Order of Australia, in 1984; Leighton Medallist (the Leighton Medal is the senior award of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute) in 1986; Honorary Doctorate in Science (Sydney) in 1984. The last gave him especial pleasure.
Envoi
One didn't argue with Alex Boden. That was because he didn't care to argue with you: he once wrote: 'One should not speak unless one can improve on silence'. The rules of the game were respect for each other's position, but let's get on to some matter of mutual interest. He spoke ill of no one: affronts he shrugged off. This technique must have been effective in business, where one senses he offered a delphic front.
In Who's Who in Australia he listed his recreations alliteratively as 'fitness, farming and photography'. Sport was part of his early life; fifty years later he was attending a gymnasium three times a week. Under the influence of Linus Pauling and the Human Nutrition chair, but also of the vegetarian customs to which he was introduced through his connections in India, he was carefully observant of his diet, though not to the point of eschewing good cuisine.
He was tough. In later years he was prone to angina, but refused to take medication even when it was placed in his pocket. But eventually heart surgery became unavoidable. An emergency operation in 1990, while successful, did slow him down. At a crowded fiftieth wedding anniversary celebration late in 1993, attended by a host of friends and children and children's children, he nevertheless gave a spirited speech. Shortly afterwards, aged 80 and never having retired from active work, he died quietly at home in the company of his family.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, Vol.11, No.4, 1996. It was written by I.G. Ross AO FAA, Emeritus Professor of Chemistry, former Deputy Vice-Chancellor, Australian National University (RMB 2039, Queanbeyan NSW 2620).
Acknowledgments
My thanks are due, above all, to Mrs Beth Boden for uncovering from scattered material the key sources for this biography. From the family, Dr Diana Thomas and Bill Boden especially gave help. And besides those named in the text I am indebted to Don Baty (the longest serving Hardman employee, eventually a director), Max Carson, David Castleman, Bill Ferguson, Dr Ken Ferguson and Bruce Fielden.
Notes
[1] Address to the Newcastle Branch of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute, 20 October 1987, unpublished. Some of the material in this text had been used in an earlier address in Adelaide, a short version of which appeared as A. Boden, 'Chemistry for Pleasure and Profit: A Personalised View of the Practice of Chemistry', Chemistry in Australia, April 1986, p. 110.
[2] A. Boden, in F.W.G. White (ed.), Scientific Advances and Community Risk, Science and Industry Forum Report No. 13, pp. 12539 (1980). This article is substantially a recapitulation of A. Boden, 'Industrial and Social Risks Associated with Pesticides', Chemistry in Australia, March 1979, pp. 937.
[3] J. Emsley, New Scientist, 28 April 1988, p. 79.
Unattributed quotations are from family papers, mostly untitled and undated.
Albert Russell ('Bert') Main 1919–2009
Bert Main was one of Australia's leading zoologists and a gifted naturalist whose legacy includes the creation of some of Western Australia's most important national parks and nature reserves.
Bert Main (1919–2009) was recognised both nationally and internationally as one of Australia's leading zoologists and a gifted naturalist.
His research and ecological teaching on a wide variety of animals, including frogs, reptiles, birds, insects and marsupials, laid the foundations for three generations of graduate students who were inspired by his imagination and biological insight.
His foresight and energy as an administrator on government bodies also led to the creation of some of Western Australia's most important National Parks and Nature Reserves that are vital for the preservation of Australia's rich biodiversity and form part of his enduring legacy.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 22(1), 2011. It was written by S. D. Bradshaw, School of Animal Biology M092, The University of Western Australia.
Albert Ernest Alexander 1914–1970
Professor Albert Alexander FAA was a pioneering colloid chemist whose surface science shaped biology and industry. He led applied chemistry education across two universities.
Albert Ernest Alexander was born on 5 January, 1914, at Ringwood, in Hampshire, the last but one of a family of seven children. His father, William Albert Alexander, was a master builder, continuing a business long established in the district. His mother, Beatrice (née Daw), had been a teacher. The death of her husband in 1916 left her with heavy responsibilities which she faced with determination. The three eldest girls had to leave school when they were 14, the two brothers who came next were able to stay until they reached 16; only Albert Ernest, the youngest boy, could be given the full education he desired. From the Brockenhurst County School he proceeded in 1931 to the University of Reading, graduating in 1934 with First Class Honours in Chemistry and an Open Scholarship to King's College, Cambridge.
During his first year at Cambridge he read for Part II of the Natural Science Tripos in Chemistry. Professor R.G.W. Norrish writes: 'I was his supervisor and from the beginning was greatly impressed by his high intellectual ability and depth of understanding; he obtained a First Class in the Tripos Examination, and – as one of the examiners – I can now tell you, after all this time, that he was easily at the top of the list'.
A King's College Senior Scholarship, a DSIR grant for research, and a Ramsay Memorial Fellowship, followed in 1935–36. Alexander joined the Department of Colloid Science to work under Professor E.K. (now Sir Eric) Rideal. Professor S.F. Dainton recalls this Cambridge period:
… when the Langmuir trough was beginning to be exploited for the investigation of the size and shape of large molecules … Alexander soon proved himself to be an extremely neat and clean worker – both attributes being necessary for the trough to be successfully operated; and there can be no doubt that at that time Alexander was one of the best PhD students that Rideal had.
Life at Cambridge made a deep impression on the young graduate from Reading: much of his future attitude to science and research was then determined, Rideal's own philosophy being partly responsible. Rideal recognised (1) the fact:
that many biological problems require the methods and ideas of physical chemistry for their complete solution. This is particularly so with the branches of biology which are relevant to surface chemistry, colloids and macromolecules. In the 1930s it was exceptional to find physical chemists in biological departments or biologists in chemical laboratories. Moreover, the average biologist was not sufficiently trained in chemistry and mathematics to be able to carry out physico-chemical research. Equally the average physical chemist was not usually sufficiently aware of the needs of biology to make useful contributions in this field. Thus one of the ideas of creating a bridging laboratory was to bring physical chemists interested not only in developing the fundamentals of surface and colloid chemistry but also in applying them to biological systems, into contact with biologists who appreciated both the need and the direction which these studies should take. Professor Rideal was an ardent believer in this doctrine and devoted much energy to its propagation.
To Rideal's influence and leadership was added the stimulation provided by a remarkable group of contemporaries assembled in the School of Colloid Science. Most of them were destined to achieve success and recognition for their contributions to physical chemistry. They included H.W. Melville, the Farkas brothers, F.J. Wilkins, Gwyn Williams, J.K. Roberts, H.K. Whalley, R.M. Barter, R.C.L. Bosworth, J.H. Schulman, A.H. Hughes, J.S. Mitchell, G. Gee, F.R. Eirich, D.D. Eley, T. Teorell, and many others, now Knights, Professors, Fellows of The Royal Society, etc. The period was a vintage one. Haydon and Ottewill (2) describe the numerous branches of surface and colloid chemistry studied between 1935 and 1946:
The work on mono-layers at air-liquid interfaces was extended in many directions and was carried out by J.H. Schulman, A.E. Alexander, J. Marsden, D.G. Dervichian, E. Stenhagen and T. Teorell. Built-up multilayers were examined by J.J. Bikerman and protein membranes by O. Gatty. J.S. Mitchell, now Regius Professor of Physics in the University, studied photo-chemical reactions in monolayers. Polymerisation reactions became the special interest of H.W. Melville, G. Gee and R.F. Tuckett, and the sorption of gases by solids by R.M. Barrer. Catalytic problems and gas adsorption continued to be examined by J.K. Roberts and further work was published by J.S. Wang and W.J.C. Orr. During this period work on the electrical properties of colloids was undertaken by I. Kemp, S. Levine, G.P. Dube, R.B. Dean and O. Gatty.
Alexander's first researches (described in two papers, respectively with Schulman and Rideal, in 1937) concerned the differences between reactions at interfaces and those in bulk. The hydrolyses of long-chain esters, spread as films on aqueous alkaline or acid substrates, were followed by observing either surface pressures or surface potentials. Molecular orientations could be changed by compressing the films (i.e. by reducing the areas per molecule); although this altered the absolute reaction velocities only slightly it raised the activation energies above the values found in expanded monolayers or homogeneous solutions. The work had biological undertones since the natural breakdowns and resyntheses of fats most probably involve interfacial reactions.
A third paper, also published in 1937, shows even more clearly a leaning towards biology. It described the examination of a number of porphyrins and closely related compounds, some containing a central co-ordinated metal atom (chlorophyll-a and b, haemin, magnesium naphthalocyanine, iron phthalocyanine, etc.), and some without (protoporphyrin, bilirubin, mesoporphyrin dimethyl ester, etc.), as monolayers on aqueous substrates. Mostly these molecules formed unstable solid-condensed films with the conjugated ring systems vertically oriented and close-packed; their limiting surface areas were consistent with known structural formulae.
In many subsequent investigations Alexander used force-area and potential-area measurements on films spread on water to gain some insight into the orientation and structure of polar head-groups as they actually exist when immersed in the underlying aqueous media. Early examples were the demonstrations in 1939 that, in contact with water, ester groups lost their resonance and triazo-groups became rectilinear.
Two other notable, but different, contributions from this period were studies of the halogenation of long-chain phenols in films, of the deposition of multilayers from monolayers on water on to polished chromium plates, and of a chemical reaction taking place within a solid multilayer so mounted.
Alexander was awarded the PhD degree in 1938 and thereupon went on a holiday – hitch-hiking in Scandinavia – in the company of F.S. Dainton. Dainton, recalling some 34 years acquaintance with Alexander, says: 'We were both research students in Cambridge who had migrated from other universities, and we were therefore drawn together by our common sense of being immigrants. Under the influence of discoveries that we shared many interests, e.g. walking, tennis, squash, and a love of good company and conversation, we soon became friends. It was a friendship which lasted throughout life and had many episodes including … living for some seven years in adjacent roads in Cambridge so that our families were young together, and for years playing an almost regular weekly game of squash'. Dainton continues: 'At that time there was quite a link between Rideal's laboratory and Svedberg's in Uppsala, and after our joint visit to the latter laboratory in August, 1938, Alex decided … to spend as long as he could in Uppsala working jointly with Torsten Teorell'. A Rockefeller Travelling Fellowship helped to make this possible, and during December, 1938, Alexander entered the Institute of Medical Chemistry of the University of Uppsala.
Two papers ('A Study of Films at the Liquid/Liquid Interface, Parts I and II' and 'A Study of Films at the Liquid/Liquid Interface, Part III – A Specific Effect of Calcium Ions on Kephalin Monolayers') record results obtained in Sweden. The objective was to extend knowledge on insoluble films at oil/water interfaces since these would be more related to natural cell-membrane situations than were the often-studied films at air/water interfaces. As a preliminary step the technique for the measurement of oil/water interfacial tensions had to be improved. This done, force-area curves were plotted for gliadin, serum albumin, lecithin, Iysolecithin, and sodium cetyl sulphate at a benzene/water boundary; they were seen to be in conformity with the Langmuir hyperbolic van der Waals' equation of state for expanded films. Finally, with Åborg, the behaviour of salts (NaCl, KCl, MGCl2, and CaCl2) towards kephalin (a phosphatide cell lipoid) when spread as a monolayer at benzene/water interfaces was reported. A stabilising action of calcium ions was noted, more pronounced than had previously been seen with lecithin films. The authors comment:
… that of the various inorganic ions which affect cell and organ functions, calcium seems to play a role of first importance, being necessary, for instance, for the integrity of cell membranes, for normal irritability of the nervous apparatus, and for blood clotting.
The collaboration with Teorell was interrupted in September, 1939, by the outbreak of war. The nine months in Uppsala had, however, given Alexander not only a love of Scandinavia but also a lasting conviction that surface chemistry was likely to be of fundamental importance in biochemistry and physiology.
He returned to Cambridge. A Thesis: 'Molecular Orientation and Reactions in Monolayers' brought him election, in October 1939, as a Fellow of King's College. Research was resumed in the Department of Colloid Science, and continued steadily during the war years. Fourteen publications appeared between 1940 and 1945. They dealt inter alia with films at liquid-liquid interfaces, interfacial tension measurements, surface ageing phenomena, the structures of films and liquid surfaces, the role of hydrogen bonding in condensed monomolecular films, applications of the Gibbs Adsorption Equation to solutions of paraffin-chain salts and to colloidal electrolytes, the effects of soaps and synthetic wetting agents on the biological activities of phenols, the penetrations of molecules through membranes and surfaces, and – in some detail – the properties of protein films.
Work connected with the war was also undertaken. Under the Ministry of Supply a number of "extra-mural" research teams had been established in various of the UK universities to assist with problems arising from the Services, Government Departments, etc. Alexander joined a group, formed around Rideal and Schulman at Cambridge, which investigated smoke screening, incendiary devices – the construction of sticky bombs, the blacking out of large areas of water with surface films of coal dust, and other applications of aerosols and colloids. Such projects were then mostly classified as 'secret'; some of them, although 'applied' in character, had interesting 'fundamental' aspects (e.g. questions concerning the structures and gelling properties of aluminium soaps, or the autoxidation of hydrocarbons on cement particles) which were to occupy Alexander's attention for several post-war years.
He volunteered as a Gas Officer in 1940 but, chemical warfare being inactive, was not called up. He joined the Home Guard and served in this for four years, 1940–43.
In 1944 Alexander became one of the two Assistant Directors of Research in the Colloid Science Department (G.B.B.M. Sutherland, now Master of Emmanuel College, was the other). Work on monolayers at liquid-liquid interfaces, and other aspects of "wet" surface and colloid chemistry, was thereby stimulated. Friendly relations with industry and the chemical professions were encouraged and strengthened. During 1945 a Summer School, largely organised by Alexander in collaboration with the Birmingham and Midland Section of the Royal Institute of Chemistry, was a notable product of this policy. More than 200 people, academic and industrial, of diverse ages and interests, were brought together, amidst the beauty and traditions of Cambridge, for a 'refresher week' of Colloid Science. The 'subjects studied intensively in theory and practice included monolayers and multilayers, foams, emulsions, adsorption, infra-red spectrometry, membrane equilibrium, the ultra-centrifuge, the ultra-microscope, and chromatography. Dr Perutz showed the electron microscope and X-ray diffraction camera, and an outstanding feature was the demonstration by research workers in the Colloid Science Department of their equipment and of the work in progress …'. The course was unanimously declared a noteworthy success (3). Reprints of the lectures, edited by Alexander, were later produced as an 86-page book by the Chemical Publishing Co., N.Y. under the title Colloid Science.
A number of summaries of recent work on surface chemistry were published by Alexander about this time. They dealt with such matters as the structures, spreading, and phase changes of monolayers; reactions within and evaporation through monolayers were usefully reviewed. Applications of monolayer techniques to other branches of science – to organic and physical chemistry, to classical colloidal systems such as emulsions, and to biology – were described and illustrated. Alexander's growing inclination towards biological problems can be seen clearly in the studies he undertook conjointly with Trim, Soltys, Agar, Tomlinson, and others on the anthelmintic and anti-bacterial actions of soap-phenol mixtures. The apparent contradiction that the activities of such mixtures were, in general, accelerated by low, but inhibited by high, concentrations of soap, was explained by identifying soap-phenol complex formations which enhanced bio-activities up to the critical concentrations for micelles; with more soap the competition between soap micelles and biological interfaces caused a progressive reduction of activity.
In 1947 the Chemical Society of London invited Alexander to give the annual Tilden Lecture; this provided an opportunity to survey the results of his Cambridge period. The text of the Lecture reveals much about its author: particularly it shows (as do many others of his papers) his ingenuity in devising apparatus, and his awareness of the wide usefulness of his techniques for the investigations of so many natural and complex systems in which proteins, enzymes, bile acids, soaps, etc. are present at air-water and oil-water interfaces.
During October 1947 the Société de Chimie Physique and the Faraday Society held a joint discussion meeting at Bordeaux on Surface Chemistry. A group photograph of 44 of the participants, including Alexander, appears as a frontispiece to the official volume (4) of 334 pages issued to record the proceedings. Alexander and colleagues were responsible for five papers, the contents of which further illustrate comments made above. One describes robust gear for the measurement of force/area curves at interfaces; simplicity in construction was not 'achieved at the expense of either accuracy or ease of operation; in fact the latter is a distinct improvement over the usual torsion balance methods'. The other four papers deal with the biological activities of colloidal electrolytes, they record especially the effects of soaps and soap-phenol mixtures on bacteria and cultures thereof, and show, by simple experiments, how interactions between colloidal electrolytes carrying opposite charges can markedly inhibit bacterial growth.
In 1948 a travel grant from The Royal Society enabled Alexander to spend three months visiting Universities in the United States and attending a Colloid Symposium of the American Chemical Society.
The following year saw the appearance from the Clarendon Press, Oxford, of Colloid Science, a work of 837 pages, by A.E. Alexander and P. Johnson. Its success was immediate. A reviewer, (5) using italics for emphasis, hailed it as the first book to be written on Colloid Science, and praised it as a broad, modern, and authoritative treatment of the subject of colloid physics and chemistry from the fundamental rather than from the phenomenological viewpoint.
Alexander was by now established as one of Britain's leading physical chemists. His public service commitments were increasing. In 1948 he became an external examiner for the University of St. Andrews; in 1949 he was elected to the Council of the Faraday Society. His research interests were diverse and usually relevant to practice; his relations with chemical industry were cordial. In Cambridge, through the years, Alexander accumulated valuable experience as a teacher and academic administrator. His personal popularity at home and abroad was undeniable; in all ways his career had developed appropriately for the next phase of his life.
Meanwhile, in Australia, the government of New South Wales was planning to expand its technical education system at the tertiary level. Initially the creation of an Institute of Technology had been proposed and, in 1947, a Developmental Council was set up to promote and manage such a project. In August 1948 this Council decided inter alia to advertise Chairs in Applied Chemistry and Chemical Engineering. In due course A.E. Alexander and J.P. Baxter were appointed respectively to these two positions. They arrived during 1949, were officially welcomed at a Lord-Mayoral Town Hall reception, and started work in the Sydney Technical College, Ultimo, where a sensible and adequate chemical building existed thanks to the pre-war foresight and drive of Dr R.K. Murphy, Head of the Chemistry Department throughout the inter-war years, and later the Principal of the College.
The new institution was incorporated by an Act of the State Parliament in April, 1949, as the New South Wales University of Technology. Its objects, in the words of the Act, were: (a) the provision of facilities for higher specialised instruction and advanced training in the various branches of technology and science in their application to industry and commerce; and (b) the aiding by research and other suitable means of the advancement, developments and practical application of science to industry and commerce.
With such aims, and where chemistry was concerned, Alexander was fully in sympathy. He started work to form a School of Applied Chemistry with enthusiasm. The organising de novo of a university teaching department proved to be a heavy task made difficult by a number of factors – the rapidity of numerical increase of colleagues and students being one. A note by Alexander himself, written about 1955, says:
… since taking up my present position the staff of the Chemistry School has grown to such an extent that the administrative load has become extremely time-consuming, despite decentralisation of the School into a number of virtually autonomous units. The present staff establishment in Sydney totals 157, which includes three Professors and 34 Lecturers. As Head of the School I am also responsible for chemistry instruction in the Newcastle, Wollongong, and Broken Hill Colleges, as well as for a Dept. of Biological Sciences with a staff of 33 … The large staff is justified by the fact that the Chemistry School gives instruction to both full-time and part-time students in almost every faculty, the total number of students being approximately 2,000.
Additional responsibilities came with Alexander's Deanship of the Faculty of Science, and Chairmanship of the Research and graduate studies committee of the Professorial Board. Consistently with his convictions regarding professional service, he gave time freely to the Royal Australian Chemical Institute, being a committee member of the NSW Branch from 1952 to 1956 and its President during 1955.
Research activity in the School was high from the beginning. Projects from Cambridge were transferred to Sydney, and new ones introduced. Many of the latter had industrial or technical implications and arose from the friendly liaison Alexander quickly established with such bodies as the CSIRO, the Bread Research Institute, the NSW Department of Agriculture, the Australian Meat Board, and with sundry paint technologists, veterinarians, etc.
Throughout Alexander's seven years with the New South Wales University of Technology he produced, as author or part-author, some 40 papers. Monolayer studies were resumed or extended, often with shifts of emphasis towards systems of practical importance. Thus the use of cetyl alcohol films to conserve water by retarding evaporation from dams in the drier parts of Australia caught Alexander's imagination, and is the reason why work was begun on the diffusion of small gas molecules (e.g. H2S to simulate H2O) through insoluble monolayers. Likewise, experiments on the permeabilities of films to organic compounds adsorbed thereon underlay several years' attention to the cattle tick problem in NSW.
The same period saw the start of a long series of investigations into the unique ability of wool fibres to undergo supercontraction – a spontaneous decrease in fibre length, sometimes reversible and sometimes irreversible according to the treatments given. Wool supercontracts irreversibly in hot concentrated aqueous solutions of lithium halides, probably through breakage of hydrogen bonds. Factors affecting such behaviour were identified.
Structure determinations by surface layer techniques continued. An unsaturated haemolytic fatty acid, isolated from horse brain, was thus identified, preliminary studies were made on the puparial and pupal cuticle waxes from sheep blowfly and other pests, the phenomenology of spreading of fatty alcohols was investigated, and the surface properties of wheat glutens reported.
During 1956 Alexander transferred to the University of Sydney. His motives were not made public until 1961 (6). Concerning the University of Technology he says '… I came to it full of hope. I left completely disillusioned'. In November 1949 there was the prospect of an autonomous university and of a move from Ultimo to new buildings at Kensington by 1951. Both autonomy and new buildings were slow to come. The university had started as part of the Department of Technical Education, strongly influenced by the Public Service Board. Various administrative procedures led to misunderstandings and friction. Hartwell, writing in the Nation of January 14, 1961, says 'Of the seven original professors, two soon resigned, three (Professors A.E. Alexander, D.W. Phillips and myself) began a long and unrewarding battle to improve conditions, and one (Professor J.P. Baxter, now the vice-chancellor) watched and waited. Early agitation culminated in 'a prayer' by Alexander, Phillips and myself to the Council, which roundly condemned the administration, and demanded autonomy and a vice-chancellor'. This prayer, which only three professors would sign, was described by Mr. W. Wurth, the Chancellor, as 'the most shocking document' he had ever received.
Autonomy was eventually achieved. Alexander continues
we asked to have a distinguished academic, with previous experience of University work, appointed as the first Vice-Chancellor. This was doubly necessary in view of the first stormy years and the fact that the autonomous University was in its formative stages. Instead the Chancellor appointed Dr J.P. Baxter, Professor of Chemical Engineering, whose previous experience had been solely in industry …
Difficulties reappeared; they lay
particularly in the powers of the Professorial Board and the professorial heads of departments. We sought no unusual powers or privileges, merely those accorded to our opposite numbers in the University of Sydney. Thus, for example, we sought the same selection procedure as operates there; but instead we obtained the travesty of one …
For Alexander, matters came to a head over alleged political tests and security checks applied to prospective employees of the university. A particular case (7) was before the Professorial Board on 12 June 1956. Alexander says:
The atmosphere was tense as Hartwell described the events up to that time and sought our support on the important matter of principle involved. Although the meeting was overwhelmingly in support of Hartwell, when it came to the point only a small handful – three or four at the most – were prepared to back their principles to the extent of a show-down with the Vice-Chancellor. If a few more had shown a fraction of Hartwell's guts … the outcome would have been different. I shall not forget my feelings as we dispersed.
Alexander departed in November, 1956, with '… my losses, apart from seven years of wasted effort … no more than a somewhat smaller salary and seven years superannuation (perhaps £2,000)'. He records the reason why he did not resign much earlier than he did. 'This was the calibre and spirit of the staff within the Chemistry School. The teaching staff, most of whom had had experience in overseas universities, were solidly behind my efforts to achieve a real University'.
Work was quickly restarted in the University of Sydney, and over the next 13 years some 50 or more papers were to appear from Alexander and his colleagues. Broadly, the pure and applied projects undertaken may be catalogued under four headings: (a) monolayer studies, (b) micellar solutions, (c) the roles of surfactants in heterogeneous polymerisations, and (d) the effects of polyelectrolytes on the crystallisations of sparingly soluble salts. In addition, general questions concerning science education gradually began to engage Alexander's attention with mounting fervour throughout his last decade.
Under (a) were surface balance studies of polymer monolayers, of alcohols containing sterically hindered hydroxyl groups, and of hydrogen bonding in films of nylon-type polyamides. The interactions between proteins and surfactants at air-water interfaces were also investigated by monolayer techniques.
Many important practical problems were examined under (b), perhaps the most significant being concerned with solubilised pesticides and the cattle-tick Boophilus microplus. For 50 years this pest had been controlled by dipping the infested cattle in arsenical solutions; to these, however, the tick was seemingly becoming more resistant. The first DDT suspensions, under cattle-dipping conditions, were unstable, and Alexander's assistance was sought by the Department of Agriculture, NSW, to improve the efficiency of such formulations. The DDT was apparently not as persistent on the hides of living cattle as it was on inanimate surfaces, but experiment revealed that colloidal DDT dispersions flocculated more rapidly than usual in the presence of cattle hair. The cause was traced to the large hydrophobic surface of the hair. Surface coagulations at air-water interfaces had been noted before but this was the first time it had been recognised at a solid/liquid interface. The effects of various salts and clays on the suspensions were measured, and the role of surface active agents in relation to crystal growth of DDT in aqueous media elucidated. The permeabilities of insect cuticles could be increased by the presence of micellar soap – a fact connected with earlier work at Cambridge on surface activity and permeability as factors in drug action.
The effects of pressure on the critical micelle concentration of cationic surfactants were examined, and unexpected maxima in the c.m.c. versus pressure curves at 750 atmospheres attributed – to the increase in the dielectric constant of water in this region.
The adsorption isotherms for several anionic surfactants on wool were measured at different temperatures, both above and below the c.m.c.
The purpose of the work under (c), begun in 1960, was to determine how surface active agents influence the mechanism of polymerisation in heterogeneous systems. Alexander believed that an examination of relatively simple systems would lead naturally to an understanding of the more complex, but industrially important, process of emulsion polymerisation.
At the outset the theory of emulsion polymerisation most widely accepted was that of Smith and Ewart (8) by which soap micelles were supposed to be the primary locus of polymerisation during the nucleation period; however past experience gave grounds for thinking such ideas inadequate.
The aqueous polymerisation of vinyl acetate was first examined. Different types of surfactants (anionic, non-ionic, or cationic) were found to influence the reaction rate, apparently through effects on the colloid stability of the formed latex. Methyl acrylate, an isomer of vinyl acetate, was subsequently shown to behave comparably. Micelles in these systems appeared to play minor roles as monomer reservoirs. Further support for this conclusion came from the true solution polymerisation of acrylamide, which was relatively unaffected by surfactants.
Later it was shown that surfactants exhibited an effect additional to that due simply to a change in colloid stability. The kinetics observed for seeded systems implied that polymerisation begins in the aqueous phase with the formation of oligomeric free radicals which then enter the seed radicals which, in turn, become the primary loci of polymerisation. Entry of charged oligomeric free radicals may be retarded by coulombic repulsion generated by adsorbed ionic surfactants of the same sign; this would result in a marked decrease in reaction rate. Retardation may also be caused by nonionic surfactants providing a viscous layer through which the oligomers must diffuse. The role of surfactants in heterogeneous polymerisation, evidently more complicated than was envisaged by Smith and Ewart, is still a matter for debate.
The investigations under (d) originated with earlier observations that the physical shapes of DDT crystals could affect the biological activity of this compound when dispersed as a cattle dip. In his 1954 Liversidge Lecture Alexander had briefly referred to the long-known fact that during the process of crystallisation a crystal habit could be modified by preferential adsorption of substances such as dyes on particular crystal faces. Three papers record studies of the ways in which low concentrations (e.g. a few ppm) of several polyelectrolytes, both natural or synthetic, were found to retard significantly the rates of crystallization of calcium sulphate or oxalate. Such behaviour could be understood if the adsorbed species prevented further growth by blocking the movement of spiral dislocations.
The work has medical implications since calcium oxalate appears in the majority of kidney or bladder "stones". For a normal urine the ion product of the calcium and oxalate ions present is ca 170 times greater than for a saturated solution of calcium oxalate, and only when some protective mechanism breaks down are "stones" formed. Alexander et al, identified this mechanism as the adsorption of urinary polymers on crystal embryos and on the faces of growing crystals, thus reducing the nucleation and growth rates. A parallel study on the effects of polymeric additives on the crystallization of calcium sulphate dihydrate from aqueous solution forms the subject of Alexander's last research publication, which appeared in print some four months after his death.
Thoughts on the organisation of universities, and of chemistry courses at various levels, increasingly occupied Alexander's mind during his final years. Personal experiences, first in Cambridge, then in the University of NSW, and finally in the University of Sydney, convinced him that the administrative arrangements and machineries of government in the larger Australian universities left much to be desired. His main ideas for their reform were summarised in the A.D. Ross Lecture, delivered in the University of Western Australia in March 1965. The title chosen: 'University Organisation and Government: A Century Out-of-date?' gave the keynote of the central themes. Arguments followed for more democratic systems of control by elected representatives of the academic staff on all bodies involved in basic issues such as planning and policymaking, for more decentralised administrations, and for a scrapping of the traditional Faculty and Departmental divisions. These and other changes were advocated in fresh and vigorous language. Alexander observed '… Australian universities investigate everything except themselves'. He deplored the timid attitudes of many academic persons, and the apathy of the majority of them to all issues other than salaries. His analysis of the remarkable growth and achievements of the CSIRO in the field of scientific research is striking:
This body … has such an international standing that it can recruit overseas purely on its reputation. Many scientists and others in universities were wont to … bemoan the relative affluence of the CSIRO. But the reasons for the relative affluence and success of that body seem not to be appreciated in universities – or if appreciated are certainly not acted upon. Let me state them briefly: refusal to undertake problems without adequate facilities, insistence on quality of research staff, decentralized administrative arrangements, interest in the complex problems of communications within its ranks and with the public, and encouragement of frank criticism through bodies such as Advisory Councils.
Alexander concludes:
Since internal forces seem unlikely at present to bring about any major reform in our university system, we must look to external forces … Only two sources seem possible to me – the Australian Universities Commission and the Federation of Australian University Staff Associations. These two bodies working in concert, if backed by an informed public opinion and particularly by the graduate associations of universities, could work wonders, so vulnerable is the present system. The Universities Commission could, by virtue of its financial powers, ensure that the new universities being set up do not merely reproduce an existing archaic pattern … Furthermore, the most likely hope of reforming existing universities will come from the influence of successful new ones, as is already beginning to happen in Britain.
Alexander's Lecture concluded with a challenge to the University of Western Australia:
to make a gesture unprecedented in Australian university history – to say to the academic staff, 'What sort of organisation do you want, and how could we attain it?' You would be staggered by the impact upon other universities, upon staff morale, and upon recruitment … and … it is the calibre of the academic staff which determines not only the standing but the effectiveness of any university … For its vitality the university depends on persons, not institutions, which are no more than a physical prerequisite. The university is judged by its ability to attract the best people and provide them with the most favourable conditions for research, communication and teaching.
The last of Alexander's public campaigns concerned science teaching in schools. The "Wyndham Scheme", introduced in NSW in 1962, had added a year to secondary education, and had made "junior" science a compulsory subject for all pupils in their first four years. Alexander explains his personal involvement in a 66-page booklet (9), published in May 1969:
… I would have remained largely ignorant of what was going on in the science courses of the Wyndham Scheme until 1968 (when the first intake of 'Wyndham guinea-pigs' entered the universities), but for family reasons. These provided the stimulus, whilst on sabbatical leave in Britain in 1966, for studying the syllabus, text-books and Teachers' Manual put out for the new Higher School Certificate course, which had commenced that year. The syllabus was so impossible and the books so poor that I felt impelled to write to the Press in Sydney (10) making not only some trenchant criticisms but also some concrete suggestions for improvement.
Thus started a cut-and-thrust controversy which was to last three years, in which some 40 letters would be written to newspapers, but from which, after much smoke and fire, signs of improvement are appearing. To Alexander, more than to any other person, must go the credit for bringing these matters to the attention of the public and the Education Department alike. His active interest in the Secondary Schools Science Association was, for example, a catalyst which, in late 1969, led this body to make a valuable survey of teacher opinion without which it would have been far more difficult to devise the better courses for trial in schools in 1971.
An anonymous writer has commented (11) on Alexander's
rare readiness to initiate a public debate on matters of public concern, and to pursue the matters which provoked him with a fearlessness which, for a while, might lose friends but which in the end could only deepen respect and friendship. The latest of these concerned secondary school science education, and no one could complain of pulled punches there. One could disagree with him, and at the pressure he was ready to bring through media as public as the press, but it was impossible to denigrate the principles which moved him – and one mostly agreed with him anyhow.
The obituarist of King's College, Cambridge speaks (12) of Alexander thus:
He took part in many campaigns, firmly, loudly, and fearlessly, yet always with his characteristic good temper … Alex was a cheery, outdoor character with a healthy outlook on life. He thought nothing, in his student days, of cycling from Ringwood to Cambridge, and one of the things he liked about Australia was the long season of glorious bathing from the Sydney beaches. Though not easy to get to know intimately, he was always friendly and smiling. He could be justly indignant, but he never lost his temper. Nor did he ever say or allow an unpleasant word about other people. No wonder he was a valued and popular colleague, firm, patient and gentle in his administration, and had innumerable friends. It was only when he found undesirable activities going on behind the scenes that his equanimity was disturbed; and then he spoke out strongly.
Dr. R.J. Hunter assesses (13) Alexander as:
a remarkable man … a truly gifted individual in whom a fine scientific mind had been united with a generous and outgoing personality. An infectious laugh assured him of the affection of his colleagues whilst his high principles and dedication to his ideals earned him the respect of a wide variety of people both inside and outside his chosen profession...all those who associated with him in any of his many activities will remain influenced by his genuine humanity …
Alexander's publication list shows the large number of students and co-workers who were, through the years, attracted to his laboratories at Cambridge and in the two Sydney Universities. As a research supervisor Alexander had a flair for finding problems in the realities of practice. He 'demanded much of his students, for the problems he set them were never trivial, and he expected them to exercise a considerable degree of independence in tackling them. Nevertheless he was always patient and encouraging when things were not going well and he remained both friend and adviser to his former students long after the formal association was terminated'.
The anonymous Royal Australian Chemistry Institute writer (loc. cit.) summarises the many tributes contained in letters received from Alexander's numerous friends in all parts of the world when he says: 'Those who were privileged to be in his department learnt much from his sympathy, generosity, gregariousness, unaffectedness, patience, strength and transparent honesty. Others, who knew of him only at secondhand, found it hard to believe that his forthrightness did not conceal deviousness, which it did not'.
Despite his many other preoccupations, Alexander always took his full share of administrative responsibilities and worked unselfishly to sustain and strengthen a healthy liaison with industry and applied science generally. For years he was a co-opted member of the Advisory Council of CSIRO, of the Research Advisory Committee of the Bread Research Institute of Australia, and a consultant to two of the largest firms of chemical manufacturers. Within the University of Sydney 'he held many positions of the kind in which the service far exceeds the thanks', and at the time of his last illness he was Dean of the Faculty of Science. His loyalty to the Royal Australian Chemical Institute has already been noted. He was a trustee of ANZAAS.
Alexander's last years were clouded by tragedy. As a research student he had been unofficially engaged to Catherine Robson. They were married in 1940 and had a daughter Naomi and a son Neil. They were a happy family in Australia, with a home in Sydney and a little cottage up-country at Berilee, enjoying fishing and other open air pastimes. Unfortunately Catherine, after a fairly long illness died from cancer on 14 November, 1963. Two years later, on 10 December, 1965 Alexander married Gisela Baker (née Zutavern, of Heidelberg), the widow of a Sydney industrial chemist, who brought him two stepdaughters. In 1966 Alexander was in Bristol as a Leverhulme Visiting Professor when he learned that Naomi (then the wife of an Australian postdoctoral fellow studying overseas) had been killed in a car crash in the US. The blow was hard to endure. Alexander's public reaction was to found the 'Naomi Alexander Memorial Fund', in the Women's College of the University of Sydney, with (14) an initial donation of $1,000 to start a trust fund, the income from which was 'to be used either as a prize to a deserving student or at the discretion of the Principal'.
As the NSW representative of the Chemical Society of London, Alexander was involved in organising the historic first meeting in Sydney of the oldest English Chemical Society under the Chairmanship of its Australian President (the late Sir Ronald Nyholm, FRS) and in the presence of many distinguished visitors assembled for the 1969 IUPAC Congress. Photographs (15) taken on this occasion are the last pictures we have of Alexander.
He became ill a few weeks later. Towards the end of the year a brain tumour was diagnosed, located, and operated upon, but without lasting success. By April, 1970, his strength was rapidly diminishing. Yet optimism persisted … on 9 May he announced a decision to retire at 60, not 65, and to join an anti-pollution research group, this was during my last conversation with him. By 16 May he had ceased to recognise those around him. He died peacefully during the evening of 23 May 1970.
The Pymble Presbyterian Church was packed by friends, colleagues, and students on 26 May for a funeral service during which a moving panegyric was spoken by Professor I.G. Ross.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Records of the Australian Academy of Science, vol. 2(2), 1971. It was written by Raymond James Wood Le Fèvre DSc FRS, Foundation Fellow of the Academy, and Emeritus Professor of Chemistry, University of Sydney. He was a Councillor from 1954–56.
Notes
(1) D.A. Haydon and RH. Ottewill, The Department of Colloid Science, University of Cambridge, Chemistry and Industry, 1962, p.l267.
(2) Chemistry and Industry, loc. cit.
(3) Chemistry and Industry, 1945, pp. 250, 273.
(4) Surface Chemistry, Butterworth's Scientific Publications, London, 1949.
(5) Anon, Trans Faraday Soc., 45, 1949, p. 895.
(6) 'Seven Years in Kensington', Nation, 25 Feb., 1961, pp.9-13.
(7) R.M. Hartwell, Vestes, 3, (1960), 51.
(8) J. Chem. Phys., 1948, 16, 592.
(9) Education and Alchemy – The Story of Wyndham Science, The Secondary Schools Science Association, 1969.
(10) Sydney Morning Herald, 8 Dec. 1966.
(11) Proc. Roy. Austr. Chem. Inst. 37, (1970), p.211
(12) Ann. Rep. King's Coll. Cambridge, 1970, p.17
(13) Search, 1, (1970), p.91.
(14) See Sydney University Calendar, 1970, p.612.
(15) Reproduced in Chemistry in Britain for November, 1969.
Albert Cherbury David Rivett 1885–1961
Sir David Rivett was a physical chemist, science administrator and Foundation Fellow of the Academy.
Sir David Rivett was a physical chemist and science administrator. He spent two decades leading Australia's Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), first as chief executive officer from 1927 and then as Chairman from 1946 to 1949, shaping the organisation that would become the CSIRO. He was a Foundation Fellow of the Academy and served as vice-president 1954–1955.
Download the memoir
Alan Walsh 1916–1998
Sir Alan Walsh was the originator and developer of the atomic absorption method of chemical analysis, which revolutionised quantitative analysis in the 1950s and 1960s.
Written by Peter Hannaford.
Alan Walsh was the originator and developer of the atomic absorption method of chemical analysis, which revolutionised quantitative analysis in the 1950s and 1960s. Atomic absorption provided a quick, easy, accurate and highly sensitive method of determining the concentrations of more than 65 of the elements, rendering traditional wet-chemical methods obsolete. The method has found important application worldwide in areas as diverse as medicine, agriculture, mineral exploration, metallurgy, food analysis, biochemistry and environmental control, and has been described as 'the most significant advance in chemical analysis' in the 20th century.
Family background and early influences
Alan Walsh was born on 19 December 1916 and brought up in Hoddlesden, a small moorland village in the borough of Darwen, in Lancashire, England, about twenty miles north of Manchester. He was the eldest son of Thomas Haworth Walsh, who managed a small family cotton mill in Hoddlesden, and Betsy Alice Walsh (née Robinson). He had an older sister, Evaline, and two younger brothers, Jack and Tom. In 1947 Alan emigrated to Australia and soon afterwards met an English-born nurse, Audrey Dale Hutchinson, whom he married in 1949. They had two sons, Thomas Haworth and David Alan.
The family cotton mill, Vale Rock Mill, Holden Haworth Ltd, was one of two mills that employed most of the people in Hoddlesden and many from the next town. Alan's father, Thomas, was an astute and remarkable man who managed the mill for 52 years, including the period during the late 1920s and 1930s when the cotton industry was badly hit by the depression. Thomas had the interests of his family at heart but laid down the rules and would not allow disobedience of any kind. Alan's mother, Betsy, was a charming, warm-hearted woman. Alan was very like her in some ways but his astuteness and determination came from his father. The village was quiet: just one pub, a school, a church and a village shop, which Alan's grandfather, Benjamin Walsh, ran and which sold everything from meat, vegetables and groceries to clothing. Benjamin was a friend and helper of the vicar, and had a big say in village affairs. Alan's grandmother, Mary (née Haworth), was a strong-minded woman of the old school who insisted on good manners at all times.
Alan's uncle and godfather, Marsden Walsh, described Alan as a delightful and serious boy. He was something of a loner and happy with his own company, qualities his uncle said would stand him in good stead. Even though he had quite a serious side to him, he had a great sense of fun. He had what was known as a lazy eye and for a period had to wear a patch. He made light of this and fooled about so that his friends thought nothing of it because he made them laugh. He had a great sense of humour, but was never unkind at someone else's expense. Whenever he talked about his early life, he would say he was brainwashed – too much religious teaching – and how narrow their life was. Once when asked what he wanted to do with his life he said 'I want to find things out and how they work'. So, when later he became a scientist his uncle was not surprised.
Education
From the age of ten Alan attended the local grammar school in the nearby town of Darwen, where he passed the Northern Universities Matriculation examination in 1933 and the Higher School Certificate examination in 1935. Of his school days, Alan recalls:
I had no idea where I was headed during secondary school. In fact when I was 16 years old I was advised to do French, English and History and drop Science. At the time I was having trouble with eye strain and because I thought French, English and History would involve a lot of reading, I chose rather to study Mathematics, Chemistry and Physics in which I performed quite well…. [1]
At that stage I was very uncertain about my next step. I remember being attracted by a teacher training course, but my headmaster had other ideas. He finally spoke to my father and they persuaded me to apply for the honours course in physics at the University of Manchester. [2]
In October 1935 Alan entered the honours school of physics at the University of Manchester. In his second and third years he was a resident at St Anselm Hall, where the warden, the Reverend T.H. South, described him as 'a quiet, industrious student, with a sense of humour, and a sense of responsibility, who has been popular and respected in Hall. He has been a successful captain of our Association Football XI this season.' In his final year Alan took the joint course in physics and electrotechnics, an option available for honours students in physics.
Of his time at Manchester, Alan recalls: [3]
It was only after I went to university that I experienced the real joys of learning and research. I had been at university only two weeks when I attended a lecture by Professor (later Sir) Lawrence Bragg, who was head of the University Physics Department. In a lecture to the University Physical Society he told, in extremely simple language, the story of the pioneering work he and his father had done in their development of X-ray methods for determining the structure of crystals. The basic simplicity and beauty of their contribution greatly impressed us freshers: the drama was enhanced by the knowledge that their work had been of such outstanding merit that they were awarded the Nobel Prize.
Even after graduating from Manchester University, I still had no definite plans regarding my future employment. The problem was shelved when, much to my surprise, I was awarded a research scholarship to work on the determination of crystal structures by X-ray methods.
In August 1938 Alan undertook postgraduate research in the Physics Department at the Manchester College of Technology, which later became the University of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology. His supervisor was Dr William H. Taylor, Head of the Physics Department at that time and known for his X-ray work on mineral crystals. During this period Alan's research was influenced by Dr Henry Lipson, who proposed that he study the structure of ß-carotene, an important biological molecule that presented a considerable challenge to X-ray structure analysis at that time. He spent one year at the Manchester College of Technology and then continued the theoretical work on the analysis of ß-carotene for a further period after he had moved to the British Non-Ferrous Metals Research Association. He was awarded the degree of MSc (Tech) in 1944 for a thesis entitled An X-ray examination of ß-carotene. In 1960 he was awarded a DSc from the University of Manchester for his contributions to atomic and molecular spectroscopy.
The war years 1939–45
In September 1939 Alan began duties as Investigator in the Physics Section of the British Non-Ferrous Metals Research Association (the 'BNF') in Euston Street, London, under the direction of the leading British spectrographer, D.M. Smith. Alan recalled:3
In the first place I was to work on the development and application of spectroscopic [emission] methods of metallurgical analysis, about which I virtually knew nothing, but with the intention of also, in due course, working on X-ray studies of metals. With the outbreak of war [on the day he was due to start], these plans were abandoned and for the duration I worked only on spectroscopy.
During World War II Alan was unable to join the Services because of his metallurgical occupation, but he undertook part-time service in the Home Guard, where 'he was put in the mobile cavalry (bicycle section), being of the athletic type. He had represented Manchester at tennis'. [4]
At the BNF Alan was given the task of determining which metals were being used in enemy bombers which had been shot down. The information was passed on to the war economists, who could then make deductions about how the German war effort was progressing. During this time Alan devised a number of methods for the rapid and accurate spectrographic analysis of aluminium, copper and zinc based alloys (1-4). These methods also had an important role in the production control of war materials and were widely used in industry. The usual procedure was to make the sample for analysis one electrode of an electric arc or spark and to examine the light emitted by means of a spectrograph. The presence of any element could be detected by noting the wavelengths of the spectral lines while their intensities were a measure of the concentrations.
During the course of this work Alan became aware that when following a method that worked well in one laboratory, difficulties arose when applying it in others. He then devised and built a prototype of the General Purpose Source Unit (8) from existing components and bits and pieces of government surplus. This unit was a highly versatile but simple electrical source unit, capable of generating a variety of electrical discharges, including arc-like and spark-like discharges, for use in spectrographic emission analysis. The 'Walsh Circuit' permitted a high degree of stability and reproducibility of the electrical characteristics of individual discharges. Alan assisted in developing the commercial form of the Source Unit, which was subsequently manufactured by Hilger and Watts Ltd, London as the BNF Spectrographic Source Unit FS 130. It appeared on the market in 1950 and was still being produced in the 1980s.
In January 1944 Alan was seconded to the post of Deputy Chief Chemist at the Metal and Produce Recovery Depot, Ministry of Aircraft Production, in Eaglescliffe, Durham. There he was in charge of the laboratory and technical operations concerning the preparation and inspection of aluminium ingots obtained by melting aircraft scrap.
In January 1945 Smith left the BNF to join Johnson Matthey, and Alan returned to the BNF as Chief Spectroscopist to take charge of the spectrographic research and to give assistance in other applications of physics to metallurgy. Later in 1945 Alan visited Germany as a member of the British Intelligence Objective Sub-Committee Team on Spectrochemical Analysis. Bill Ramsden, who worked at the BNF from 1950 to 1954 and later became a life-long friend of Alan's, writes: [5]
My own impressions are that Alan Walsh was a rather unique person, characterised by an original mind and an unusual ability to penetrate to the heart of a problem. He was also a 'character', possessed of a dazzling wit and a mischievous sense of humour, and one was very fortunate to be in his company…. As far as the BNF was concerned, I have no doubt that he created 'waves' in that establishment.
During the spring of 1945 the BNF was asked to explore the possibilities of developing a spectrographic technique for determining impurities in uranium metal, and Alan duly devised a method for doing this that was released for publication some years later (14). Around this period the BNF was involved in the 'Tube Alloys Project', which was a cover for the development of the British atom bomb. Former staff from the BNF were recently astonished to read in The Times [6] that a secretary at the BNF, Melita Sirnis (later Melita Norwood), had been recruited by the KGB and had been passing on 'highly sensitive' material to the Soviet Union for forty years under the code name of 'Hola'. Melita Sirnis had been personal secretary to the Director of the BNF, Dr G.L. Bailey, during the period 1939-1948 and would have had free access to the Association's work during that period. However, Bill Ramsden recalls that during his time at the BNF, from 1950-54, there was certainly no level of security or screening and doubts that 'highly sensitive' material would have been sent after 1950. [7] He writes 'Certainly, the thought of my early reports on photoelectric emission spectroscopy as well as the details of the Walsh BNF Source Unit being available to the Kremlin before being circulated to BNF members is slightly hilarious.'
Of his research at the BNF Alan wrote (83):
By the end of the war I think there was a general feeling of satisfaction, and perhaps even a state of euphoria, regarding the development of spectrochemistry. I believe few workers shared my strong conviction, which I frequently expressed, that further progress would require a completely new line of attack. I tried desperately hard to conceive totally different approaches but came to a total impasse…
I was particularly conscious of the fact that accurate analysis [by atomic emission] required standards of very similar composition to the sample for analysis. If one wanted to be cynical about this then one could claim that accurate spectrochemical analysis consisted in confirming that the composition of a sample was what it was supposed to be…
It was with a sigh of relief that I left these problems of spectrochemical analysis in 1946…
The early CSIR/CSIRO years 1946–51
*Appointment to the CSIR Division of Industrial Chemistry, Melbourne, Australia
In 1945 Alan applied for an advertised position of Research Officer for Spectroscopic Investigations in the Chemical Physics Section of the Division of Industrial Chemistry, Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), at Fisherman's Bend in Melbourne. The Chief of the Division, Dr I.W. (later Sir Ian) Wark, had proposed the establishment of a new Chemical Physics Section to apply modern physical techniques to the solution of chemical problems. The functions of the Section would include 'spectrographic work of a fundamental nature and general spectro-analysis for the Division'. [8] Dr A.L.G. (Lloyd) Rees, who took up the position of Section Leader of the new Chemical Physics Section in November 1944, convinced Wark to purchase several state-of-the-art spectroscopic instruments, including a large Hilger-Littrow quartz spectrograph, a Hilger-Müller double monochromator, a Beckman DU ultraviolet-visible spectrophotometer, and a Perkin-Elmer Model 12B infrared spectrometer. The Research Officer for Spectroscopic Investigations would be responsible for setting up a laboratory for emission spectrographic analysis and for undertaking research in the newly developing field of infrared spectroscopy.
In July 1945 a report of an interview at the Australian Scientific Liaison Office in London by a junior officer states 'Walsh does not give me the impression of one who could direct research, but I should imagine he would be a careful and painstaking worker'. The position was subsequently offered to a another applicant, who after a considerable period of time could not make up his mind. After Alan had contacted the Liaison Office to enquire about his application, Mr Lewis Lewis, who at that time was the Australian Scientific Liaison Officer in London, wrote to Wark about Walsh 'with whom I was quite well impressed'. In March 1946, in a letter to CSIR Head Office based on a recommendation from Rees, Wark wrote:
Walsh seems to have been in charge of a small team at the BNF and is held in sufficient regard to be sent to Germany… These facts, combined with Lewis' favourable impression, lead us to the conclusion that we have been unduly cautious regarding him. In any case, there is room for a man of his attainments for pure research work, even if we must ultimately seek another leader.
In May 1946 Alan was duly appointed to CSIR, but before leaving England, Wark and Rees arranged for him to spend a period of three to four months in the laboratory of G.B.B.M. (later Sir Gordon) Sutherland in Cambridge, obtaining experience in the new field of infrared molecular spectroscopy. During this period in Cambridge, Alan established life-long associations with two molecular spectroscopists, Donald Ramsay and Norman Sheppard, the latter of whom introduced Alan to the experimental and theoretical aspects of infrared spectroscopy. This work in Sutherland's group led to a paper in Nature on the infrared spectrum and molecular structure of phthiocerane (10). In a letter to Wark, Sutherland wrote 'in my opinion you have got hold of a very good man'.
Alan set sail for Australia via the USA, where he visited a number of companies and laboratories to see the various items of spectroscopic equipment that Rees had ordered for the new spectroscopy laboratory at CSIR. He arrived in Melbourne in April 1947 aboard the 'Dominion Monarch'. Upon arrival in the CSIR Division of Industrial Chemistry at Fisherman's Bend in Melbourne, Alan recounted: [9]
The main building of the laboratories was most impressive, almost posh. Behind was a motley collection of old army huts. But the scientific equipment was first class… The conditions for the 'men at the bench' were utopian. Individual freedom and initiative were not only permitted, they were actively encouraged; a bold failure was more highly regarded than a cautious advance. Red tape and bureaucratic nonsense were totally absent.
The working conditions bore no relationship whatsoever to the popular concept of a government-controlled organisation. The frequent arrival of new staff, many from overseas, and of magnificent new equipment contributed to the general feeling of excitement. It was as lively a place to work in as one could imagine. The high calibre of the leadership at that time is reflected by the subsequent careers of Sir Ian [Wark], his right-hand man Mr Lewis Lewis, and those who were section leaders…
We were a hard working bunch. Most of us worked on Tuesday and Thursday evenings, and there were usually several people in the laboratories on other evenings and at weekends. Even the Minister [in charge of CSIRO] R.G. Casey used to visit the laboratories at weekends. He took an earnest interest in all the research projects…
An amusing facet of life at that time was that many of us were operating instruments and techniques which were unique in Australia. We could therefore claim undisputed leadership within Australia of various areas of chemical research. We rather enjoyed being referred to as a 'pride of prima donnas'.
Whilst life was fun it was also earnest, and there was no escape from Wark's insistence on excellence. As an example, the inimitable R.G. (Dick) Thomas said, 'If you tell Wark in the morning you have discovered how to annihilate gravititational forces, he'll want to know what you're going to do in the afternoon'.
Infrared molecular absorption spectroscopy
Upon commencing at CSIR Alan set about installing the new Perkin-Elmer Model 12B spectrometer, thereby establishing his first interaction with the Perkin-Elmer Corporation. This was the first operating infrared spectrometer in Australia, and there was a steady stream of requests for service and collaborative work from organic chemists both within the Division and outside it. Alan was particularly interested in understanding the mechanics of the technique and studying the structure of small molecules. Together with Arthur Pulford, an MSc student from the University of Sydney, he studied the vibrational spectrum of nitrosyl chloride (NOCl) and calculated its geometry and thermodynamic properties (15).
The Perkin-Elmer Model 12B, like all commercial infrared spectrometers at that time, used a direct current (DC) amplification system. To obtain good spectra with such systems was difficult because small changes in ambient temperature caused pronounced wandering of the baseline. Alan recalled (75):
The best spectra were obtained late at night or in the early hours of the morning. It was therefore a memorable occasion, which substantially improved my quality of life, when our Model 12B was converted to a Model 12C. This incorporated a fast thermocouple, which permitted the use of a modulated light source and a synchronous AC [alternating current] detection system and completely removed the problem of drifting base lines. Recording infrared spectra was transformed from a chore to a pleasure.
Alan soon realised that the resolution of the Perkin-Elmer (prism-based) spectrometer was quite inadequate for resolving the rotational lines of any but the lightest molecules, and even in these cases the full details of the spectrum were not revealed. To improve the resolution he devised a simple and elegant modification of the infrared prism monochromator in which radiation was passed two or more times through the same optical system (17). To do this he placed a pair of right-angle mirrors at the exit slit of the spectrometer to reflect the radiation back through the prism and, to isolate the desired multiple-pass beam from the other beams, he placed a rotating 'chopper' in front of the additional mirrors to modulate only the multiple-pass light and fed the output of the thermocouple detector to an amplifier tuned to the frequency of the chopper. An additional advantage of this modification was that the level of stray light, hitherto a major problem in infrared spectroscopy, was reduced dramatically.
Alan's 'double-pass monochromator' was patented in 1950, with coverage in Australia and eight overseas countries. Perkin-Elmer, the world's major manufacturer of infrared spectrometers, secured an exclusive licence and in 1953 began manufacturing a kit of 'Walsh Mirrors' to allow the conversion of their standard infrared spectrometer to a double-pass monochromator system. This experience with patenting and licensing and the interaction with Perkin-Elmer had significance for future events in that it involved Alan personally with the commercial aspects of scientific investigation.
Atomic emission spectroscopy
Shortly after his arrival at CSIR Alan also initiated a project to investigate the fundamental processes occurring in spectroscopic atomic-emission sources, and in particular to attempt to correlate the emission of radiation from the discharge with the electrical phenomena occurring in circuits containing an arc or a spark gap. He had the instrument workshop construct a source unit to the Walsh BNF design (8), which was capable of producing sparks that were electrically identical. Although such source units were by then well established in laboratories in the UK, the CSIR unit proved rather unreliable and was not sufficiently stable for the research Alan was proposing. John Shelton, who worked with Alan on this project, writes: [10]
It is interesting to speculate whether Walsh would have invented atomic absorption analysis if the source unit had been successful and allowed the planned research on inter-element effects to proceed. The frustration of the planned emission work stimulated him to think more and more about the tremendous number of sample atoms in the ground state, compared with the few, sensitive to minor changes in electrical and other conditions, in excited states.
Atomic absorption spectroscopy 1952–77
Establishment of the principle of the method
In an address to the Silver Anniversary Symposium on Great Moments in Analytical Chemistry at the Pittsburgh Conference in 1974, Alan recounted (68):
My initial interest in atomic absorption spectroscopy was a result of two interacting experiences; one of the spectrochemical analysis of metals over the period 1939-46; the other of molecular spectroscopy over the period from 1946-52. The interaction occurred in early 1952 when I began to wonder why, as in my experience, molecular spectra were usually obtained in absorption and atomic spectra in emission. The result of this musing was quite astonishing: there appeared to be no good reasons for neglecting [atomic] absorption spectra; on the contrary, they appeared to offer many vital advantages over atomic emission spectra as far as spectrochemical analysis was concerned. There was the attraction that absorption is, at least for atomic vapours produced thermally, virtually independent of the temperature of the atomic vapour and of excitation potential. In addition, atomic absorption methods offered the possibility of avoiding excitation interference, which at that time was thought by many to be responsible for some of the inter-element interference experienced in emission spectroscopy when using an electrical discharge as light source.
A number of journalists have written (and it is commonly believed) that Alan conceived the atomic absorption method of chemical analysis in 'a flash of inspiration' in early 1952. [11,13,14] However, a colleague of Alan's at the BNF during the war, Sidney Payne, writes: [15]
I think that he [Alan] envisaged atomic absorption far earlier than indicated by Karen Robinson.14 I clearly remember chatting to him whilst I was using a simple flame [emission] photometer and he commented upon the fact that only a small proportion of the atoms were excited by this technique and that it would be better if some way could be found to measure the much larger quantity of unexcited atoms. My reply was 'Well, why don't you go away and think about it'. History confirms that he did just that.
The following is a reconstruction of the events leading up to Alan's establishment of the principle of the atomic absorption method, based on articles by Alan (68, 82), a colleague John Shelton,10 and Andrew McKay,11 and a recorded interview with Alan: [12]
On a Sunday morning in March 1952 Walsh was working in the vegetable garden of his home in the Melbourne bayside suburb of Brighton when he suddenly had a revealing flash of thought, something that stemmed from his earlier work in related fields. He hurried inside, dirt still on his shoes, and phoned his colleague, John Shelton. 'Look John!' he exulted. 'We've been measuring the wrong bloody thing! We should be measuring absorption, not emission!' John reminded him: 'We've been through that before – you can't work out the concentration of a sample from the absorption because of the emitted light at the same wavelength'. Walsh replied: 'I've thought of that. We'll use a chopper on the source and a tuned amplifier, so the light emitted from the sample won't matter.'
Early next morning Walsh set up a simple experiment, using the element sodium. By morning tea he had a successful result. 'I was very excited and called in my colleague, Dr J.B. Willis, who at that time was working on infrared spectroscopy and later was to make important contributions to the atomic absorption method of chemical analysis. "Look", I shouted, "that's atomic absorption". His reply, which I have never let him forget, was "So what?" This was typical of the general reaction to my early work on atomic absorption'.
It would appear that the 'revealing flash of thought' on the Sunday morning in March 1952 alluded not to Alan's initial conception of the atomic absorption method of chemical analysis but rather to his sudden realisation, after a considerable period of mulling over the subject, that 'atomic absorption spectra appeared to offer many vital advantages over atomic emission spectra' (68) and that 'what we needed to do first was actually to measure absorption'. [16]
In his initial, simple demonstration of the atomic absorption method, Alan used a standard sodium vapour lamp operated from a 50 Hz mains supply and thus had an alternating output, so that it was not necessary to use a 'chopper'. The sodium D lines from this source were isolated, but not resolved from each other, by means of a simple direct-vision spectrometer and their combined intensity was measured by means of a photomultiplier tube, the output from which was recorded on a cathode ray oscillograph. Amplification of the signal was by the AC amplifier in the oscillograph. A simple air-coal gas flame was interposed between the sodium lamp and the entrance slit of the spectrometer. When a water solution containing a few milligrams of sodium chloride was sprayed into the air supply of the flame, the cathode spot on the oscillograph deflected to zero, thus establishing the principle of the atomic absorption method of chemical analysis.
In his chairman's address (71) to the Fifth International Conference on Atomic Spectroscopy in 1975, Alan conjectured why atomic absorption spectra had remained largely unexplored for almost one hundred years since Kirchhoff had first interpreted the Fraunhofer lines in the spectrum of the Sun as atomic absorption lines and used them to identify the elemental constituents of the solar atmosphere, and since Kirchhoff and Bunsen had founded qualititative spectrochemical analysis based on atomic spectra emitted by substances vaporized in a flame. Alan believed that one of the reasons atomic absorption spectra had been neglected for so long was a misunderstanding regarding the implications of Kirchhoff's law, which states that 'for radiation of the same wavelength at the same temperature the ratio of the emissive power to the absorptive power is the same for all bodies'. Alan pointed out that this law was often interpreted as 'good radiators are good absorbers and poor radiators are poor absorbers' (which holds only for radiation of a given wavelength and a given temperature) and that it had generally been assumed that methods based on emission spectra would be equally applicable to the same range of elements as those based on absorption spectra, which were generally much more difficult to measure, especially in a luminous flame. In early 1952 Alan began to realise this may not be the case and as a result of his two interacting experiences he began to wonder why it was that spectroscopists usually measured atomic spectra in emission and molecular spectra in absorption. As a result of considering this problem he concluded that atomic absorption spectra could prove much superior to conventional atomic emission spectra for many spectrochemical analyses.
Development of the atomic absorption method
Although his initial, simple demonstration of the atomic absorption method was performed using a sodium vapour lamp as the light source, Alan envisaged that the source would generally be a 'white-light' continuum source, such as a hydrogen or tungsten lamp, that would be capable of being used for the whole range of metals (68). However, when he attempted to determine copper and zinc using a continuum source and a high-resolution Hilger-Littrow spectrograph, he found the sensitivity to be disappointingly low (68). He realised that the resolution of the spectrograph was insufficient to accurately measure the profile of the extremely narrow absorption lines (about 0.003 nm) and that, even if a spectrograph or monochromator with much higher resolution became available, the energy transmitted over the small spectral bandpass would be much too low to provide adequate signal-to-noise ratios. Alan recounted (75):
I decided to abandon all attempts to produce a high-resolution dispersion system and [instead] to obtain high effective resolution by replacing the continuum light source by atomic spectral lamps which emitted lines which were considerably narrower than the absorption lines they measured. If the emission line is sufficiently narrow, the peak absorbance can be measured, and this can be correlated with atomic concentration. This concept of using a sharp-line source was the vital step in the development of atomic absorption spectrophotometers. It not only obviated the need for a high-resolution monochromator, it also gave atomic absorption methods one of their most attractive features. This is the ease and certainty with which one can isolate the required line, a characteristic that results from the fact that the line to be selected is usually one of the strongest emitted by the lamp, and it is only necessary to isolate this from other lines emitted by the lamp. This contrasts with emission methods, in which it is necessary to isolate the required line from all other lines emitted by the sample, many of which [from other elements] may be much more intense and at neighbouring wavelengths.
A CSIRO colleague, Alec Moodie, recalls that during the (North American) summer of 1952, when he was at Pennsylvania State University, he received an airletter from Alan with a sketch of his proposed atomic absorption scheme and a comment at the end, 'The sharp-line source doesn't yet exist!'
Apparently while reading Tolansky's book High Resolution Spectroscopy, [17] Alan learned that a hollow-cathode discharge can provide a source of very sharp spectral lines and quickly realised 'that could be a very robust and rugged source'. He also considered electrodeless discharge lamps of the type he and a colleague, Norman Ham, subsequently developed for Raman spectroscopy (32), but soon realised that hollow-cathode lamps offered a much wider coverage of elements. In January 1953 Alan, together with John Shelton and the glass instrument makers, George Jones and Frank Williams, set out to construct hollow-cathode lamps which used a closed gas-circulating system, of the type described by Tolansky, in which the rare gas was pumped continuously through traps to remove molecular impurities liberated by the discharge from the cathode and from the walls of the tube. This system involved a rack of elaborate gas handling and pumping gear and was not very convenient. During a visit to the USA in mid-1953, Alan reported back to John Shelton on the work of Dieke and Crosswhite, [18] who were using compact sealed-off hollow-cathode lamps in which the gaseous impurities were removed by a 'getter' of activated uranium. Alan and John Shelton then abandoned the gas circulating system and during August-September 1953 began the development of sealed-off hollow-cathode lamps for all the elements that could be determined by atomic absorption, using zirconium getters as suggested by Alan's section leader, Lloyd Rees. This was a daunting, exhaustive task, which took several years to accomplish. The first satisfactory sealed-off hollow-cathode lamps were constructed and tested during the period December 1953 to January 1954.
At this stage Alan had arrived at a satisfactory method for making the atomic absorption measurements, which was to become the generally accepted method, and at an experimental arrangement that had all the essential components of a modern commercial atomic absorption spectrophotometer: a sealed-off hollow-cathode lamp as source, a flame atomizer as absorber, and a 'chopper' and synchronously tuned amplifier. A critical factor in Alan's successful development of the atomic absorption method was his appreciation of the necessity for a modulated light source and a synchronously tuned amplifier system to discriminate between the emission of the source and that of the luminous flame absorber.
A provisional patent application was lodged on 17 November 1953. As soon as the final patent specification was filed, on 21 October 1954, [19] Alan submitted his landmark paper 'The application of atomic absorption spectra to chemical analysis' to Spectrochimica Acta (29). This was published in early 1955, virtually at the same time ** as a paper by C.T.J. Alkemade and J.M.W. Milatz, [20] who had arrived independently at the concept of analytical atomic absorption spectroscopy. The latter authors did not pursue their work further, possibly because they regarded the method merely as one for determining 'all metals that are usually to be determined in flame photometry'.
Alan's original paper on atomic absorption (29) is quite remarkable. In addition to proposing the atomic absorption method and discussing the various factors governing the relationship between atomic absorption and atomic concentration, he also proposed the details of the atomic absorption instrumentation that are essentially those in use today and he proposed or suggested several applications and developments of the atomic absorption method that were to keep teams of scientists, both at CSIRO and in other laboratories, occupied for the next twenty to thirty years. These included applications of atomic absorption to absolute chemical analysis, that is, analysis without the requirement of calibrating standards of known composition; applications to the determination of relative oscillator strengths of atomic resonance lines; applications to isotopic analysis; and the use of a furnace for vaporizing samples in atomic absorption spectroscopy.
Early exploitation of the atomic absorption method
During May to July 1953 Alan visited laboratories in England and the USA and discussed the possible commercial exploitation of atomic absorption with a number of instrument manufacturers. The only person to show any enthusiasm was Dr Alexander Menzies, a physicist and Director of Research for the leading British instrument manufacturer, Hilger and Watts Ltd, with whom Alan had previously had dealings through the manufacture of the BNF Spectrographic Source Unit. CSIRO arrived at a tentative exclusive licence agreement with Hilger and Watts, based on the provisional patent application.
The first public demonstration of a working atomic absorption instrument was in March 1954 at an exhibition of scientific instruments held by the Victorian Division of the (then British) Institute of Physics at the University of Melbourne. The exhibited instrument had all the essential components of a modern commercial atomic absorption instrument, including a sealed-off (copper) hollow-cathode lamp as source, a flame atomizer as absorber, and a 'chopper' and synchronously tuned amplifier to discriminate between the emission of the source and that of the luminous flame. There was also provision for a sodium vapour lamp and viewers were invited to 'dip their (salty) finger' into a beaker of water and this would register a deflection on the strip chart recorder. A photograph of the 'first atomic absorption spectrophotometer' is shown in Figure 2. Alan wrote (68):
The apparent complexity of the instrument was due largely to its being of the double-beam type, which in our early experiments, we regarded as essential because of the poor stability of many of our hollow-cathode lamps. The viewer was possibly further confused by the optical path being in opposite directions on the instrument and on the explanatory diagram. Whatever the reason, the instrument aroused no interest whatsoever during the three days it was on exhibition.
However, when Dr Menzies visited Melbourne shortly afterward to assess its performance, he was sufficiently impressed for his firm to decide to produce, under licence to CSIRO, the first commercial atomic absorption spectrophotometer.
In July 1954 CSIRO entered into an exclusive licence agreement with Hilger and Watts on terms which provided for a 5% royalty on each instrument sold. The exception to this exclusivity was for the case of a potential Australian manufacturer or if Hilger and Watts failed to produce satisfactory instrumentation, in which case the licence would be withdrawn.
In July 1954 Alan's colleague, John Shelton, left on a three-year secondment to the Australian Scientific Liaison Office in London, where it was agreed he would spend one-third of his time spreading the word about atomic absorption, visiting laboratories in England, and keeping in touch with the production of the atomic absorption equipment by Hilger and Watts. Barbara Russell was employed on a fixed-term appointment to replace John, who had expected to see a steady stream of papers from Alan and Barbara, showing the effectiveness of the atomic absorption method in hitherto difficult analyses. However, this did not happen. John writes:10 'Dr Wark had commented to Walsh that as the principle of the method had been established and was to be published, he should leave the "hack work" to others and get back to research'. Although Alan certainly did not regard the practical analytical work as 'hack work', he returned to his fundamental research on the assessment of the possibilities of absolute chemical analysis by atomic absorption and on the testing of the peak atomic absorption method, by comparing measurements on aqueous solutions with the known oscillator strengths of elements over a wide range of oscillator strength values and excitation wavelengths.
In early 1956 Alan sent John Shelton a draft of a paper that included the latest results to test the peak atomic absorption method. Dr Menzies, from Hilger and Watts, arranged for John to lecture on this work at a meeting of the Spectroscopy Group of the Institute of Physics in London in March 1956. The results aroused some interest and led to requests for the lecture to be repeated at the Chemical Inspectorate and Atomic Energy Laboratories at Woolwich and at the research laboratories of the British Aluminium Company. In a letter to Alan in March 1956, John reported: [21]
Apparently some people got the idea from your paper in Spectrochimica Acta that the method was a scientific curiosity rather than a practical analytical method. Several people have mentioned to me that they had not thought seriously about using atomic absorption until they had heard the lecture, so I feel pleased that some tangible result has come from the lecture.
John later wrote10 that he liked to think that this letter might have had some influence on the change in direction of the atomic absorption project that was soon to take place at CSIRO.
The Hilger and Watts experience
During the period Hilger and Watts held an exclusive license (1953-57), their interaction with Alan and CSIRO was sparse and progress was slowed by technical difficulties, including the development of satisfactory hollow-cathode lamps. A Hilger and Watts progress report for July 1956 stated that enquiries from potential users had 'not so far revealed any demand for a comprehensive instrument capable of dealing with many elements'. [22] It had therefore been decided to manufacture the atomic absorption equipment as an attachment to the existing Hilger and Watts Uvispek spectrophotometer. [23] However, there was no provision in the attachment for modulating the light from the source, probably because this would have necessitated major alterations to the Uvispek itself, which had a DC amplifier/detection system, whereas Alan's work had shown that a modulated light source and synchronously tuned amplifier were essential for discriminating between the emission of the source and that of the luminous flame absorber.
In early 1956 John Shelton learned that Dr Menzies was planning to present a paper on the Hilger and Watts unmodulated DC atomic absorption system to the Fifteenth Congress of the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry in Lisbon later that year. This triggered an immediate reaction from Lloyd Rees and Alan. John was sent to the Lisbon conference with the intention of making it clear that the Hilger and Watts system was not a genuine atomic absorption instrument and that the full benefits of atomic absorption necessitated a modulated source and synchronously tuned amplifier/detector. The CSIRO paper included some results of the first tests of the peak atomic absorption method by comparing measurements on aqueous solutions with the known oscillator strengths of elements over a wide range of oscillator strength values and excitation wavelengths and also some results on limits of detection. However, the paper did not contain any real analytical results, and John Shelton recalls that it 'deservedly went down like a lead balloon'. In a letter to Alan in September 1956, reporting on the Congress, John wrote: [24]
Menzies followed immediately afterwards and is now really plugging atomic absorption. His results on brass have given him a really improved outlook…. He took a Uvispek with atomic absorption attachment to Lisbon (some of it by air which no doubt hurt his Scots soul) and gave demonstrations. As a toy it goes quite well, and it's to be hoped that more people will get into doing the actual analytical tests – i.e. on real problems – that, it seems to me, are needed most now. Hack work it may be, but until somebody does some appreciable amount of first class analytical work with the method then the analyst will be shy of it. And they won't be convinced with synthetic samples. They'll want actual samples and a statistical analysis of results.
The Lisbon paper appeared in the congress proceedings (30) and a full version was published in 1957 (31). Neither paper attracted any interest. Alan told how 'the most interest shown at that stage in the technique had been by school children at a working display of the instrument at a Chemex exhibition in Melbourne in May 1956'. [25]
In mid-1957 Alan was planning an extended visit to Europe and he arranged to visit Hilger and Watts in London with the specific intention of pointing out the deficiencies in their atomic absorption equipment and having them rectified. Alec Moodie recalls that Alan decided to concentrate on just two objectives: to convince Hilger and Watts that they should incorporate a modulated light source with synchronous detection and that they should use a stainless steel, rather than a brass, burner for the flame to avoid obtaining spurious zinc atomic absorption signals. When Alan visited Hilger and Watts, he discovered that the company was experiencing economic difficulties and that two of its leading optical designers, F. Twyman and A. Green, had both left the company. The meeting, comprising a board of executives, went on well into the evening, and Alan still had made no progress, later confessing he had 'failed on both objectives'. After the meeting, when leaving the building, it was dark and raining quite heavily, and the executives drove off, leaving Alan standing in the rain, despondent and looking for the nearest public transport. After a while a limousine pulled up, with Alan dripping with water and expecting to be offered a lift to a station. One of the executives in the back of the limousine wound down the window, called 'Hey Walsh, do you realise there is a tube station down the road?', wound up the window, and drove off. At a gathering soon after, Alan was apparently asked whether it was true that the Hilger and Watts atomic absorption instrument was useless. 'No', he said, 'It is not useless, it would make a great pie warmer'.
In June 1957, Lewis Lewis, who was now at CSIRO Head Office in Melbourne, visited Hilger and Watts at the request of the (then) Deputy Chairman of CSIRO, Sir Frederick White, to put it to them that their efforts so far had not done justice to the potential of the technology. Hilger and Watts agreed to their exclusive licence being revoked and replaced with a non-exclusive licence, provided no other licences were granted on more favourable terms.
Although Hilger and Watts recognised the limitations of the Uvispek attachment, they were obliged to accept that it would take several years to bring out an improved version. Under the circumstances it was decided to continue with the manufacture of the simple attachment until such time as they could offer a sophisticated integrated instrument. In February 1958, Hilger and Watts sold their first atomic absorption instrument, the Model H 909, and from 1961 sales continued at about 30 to 60 instruments a year for several years. [22]
The Techtron experience
In 1958, Eric Allan of the Ruakura Soil Research Station at Hamilton, New Zealand, who had assembled his own atomic absorption equipment following discussions with Alan, published the first analytical atomic absorption results, on the determination of trace amounts of magnesium in various agricultural materials. [26] Shortly afterwards, John David, of the CSIRO Division of Plant Industry in Canberra, using improvized equipment made with Alan's assistance, reported the determination of zinc and other elements in plant-digest solutions. [27] This was followed by analytical applications in clinical chemistry, by John Willis of the CSIRO Division of Chemical Physics, [28] and in the mineral processing industry, by Max Amos and co-workers from Conzinc Rio Tinto Australia. [29] These initial analytical results on the applications of atomic absorption stimulated a steady flow of requests to Alan, mostly from industry, for help in getting atomic absorption into wider use in Australia.
By 1958 there was still no sign of any instrument manufacturer prepared to produce the type of instrument Alan considered necessary. He then decided to embark on 'Operation Backyard' – the construction of equipment in Australia to apply the atomic absorption method – and gave instructions on how to put together a 'do-it-yourself' kit. [30] Fred Box of CSIRO designed and built the electronics, which included a broadband AC amplifier (commonly called the 'Working Man's Amplifier' or 'WMA') and a power supply to run the hollow-cathode lamps (34). George Jones and later John Sullivan developed and provided the expertise and 'hands-on' skills for producing the hollow-cathode lamps (36), while John Willis worked on the analytical methods for specific analyses. A simple commercially available monochromator, such as a small Zeiss quartz-prism monochromator, was recommended for isolating the atomic resonance lines.
Alan then had to find businesses that were prepared to co-operate in manufacturing components that were not available commercially. He recalled: [31]
The electronic part of our equipment was perfectly conventional electronics, nothing fancy, so we put out a tender for manufacturing six of our amplifiers and power packs, and a little firm called Techtron put in the lowest bid, so they got the business. They had a staff of five. Then I toured the backyards of Melbourne to find a little machine shop [Stuart R. Skinner] with a staff of eight. Then we tried various glass-blowing people for the lamps, and we found a little firm [Ransley Glass Instruments, later to become Atomic Spectral Lamps] that was willing to try. This was a pure glass-blowing firm, who knew nothing about vacuum technique or electrical discharge in gases, and they had no technical people on their staff at all.
By mid-1962, it was estimated that in excess of thirty of these 'do-it-yourself' kits had been supplied to Australian laboratories and about ten to other parts of the world, including New Zealand and South Africa. Alan recalled:25 'It was certainly enough for Karl Zeiss in Germany to wonder why so many of their monochromators were being sold in Australia'.
In July 1962 Alan and Lloyd Rees arranged a symposium on atomic absorption spectroscopy through the Victorian State Committee of CSIRO, of which John Shelton was secretary. Alan and colleagues John Willis, John Sullivan and John McNeill, and several users of atomic absorption equipment, made presentations. The meeting was attended by about eighty users, potential users and CSIRO staff, including the Chairman of CSIRO, Sir Frederick White, and Lewis Lewis. At the end of the symposium, Geoffrey Frew, Chairman of Techtron Appliances Pty Ltd, declared his intention to manufacture a 'complete' atomic absorption spectrophotometer. Alan recalled how all the main players were present at the same place at the same time and the whole deal was virtually signed and sealed that evening. This announcement by Frew was 'tantamount to announcing the impending birth of an Australian spectroscopic instrument industry' (82).
In early 1964, Techtron produced the first all-Australian atomic absorption instrument, the Model AA-3, which incorporated a 'Sirospec' grating monochromator designed by John McNeill [32] at CSIRO, diffraction gratings ruled on a ruling engine designed and constructed by Dai Davies and Geoffrey Stiff at CSIRO, and a 'WMA' AC amplifier unit. The AA-3 was exhibited publicly for the first time at the Pittsburgh Conference on Analytical Chemistry in March 1964. A detailed account of the Techtron atomic absorption story has recently been written by Max Amos. [33]
At this stage Alan and his colleagues at CSIRO had established atomic absorption as a widely used analytical method in Australia, with a small flow-over into New Zealand and South Africa. Alan wrote (68):
While knowledge of the technique spread rapidly throughout Australian industry, there was one memorable exception. I recall the technical director of one of our biggest mining companies phoning CSIRO Head Office in the early 1960s and stating that he had just returned from South Africa where they were using a brand new instrument called the atomic absorption spectrophotometer. He wanted to know whether there was anyone in CSIRO who knew anything about it. Our man in Head Office said he didn't know but he would make enquiries.
In 1965 Max Amos from Sulphide Corporation and John Willis from CSIRO published a joint paper on the use of the high-temperature nitrous oxide-acetylene flame, [34] which extended the applicability of the atomic absorption method to more than sixty-five elements, including previously recalcitrant refractory elements such as aluminium, vanadium, zirconium and beryllium. From that stage onwards there was a dramatic increase in interest in the atomic absorption method and it rapidly gained wide acceptance. Alan recalled:30
The real winner in Australia, of course, was the mining boom and its timing was a real fluke. At the very time when we suddenly wanted tens of millions of analyses there was a technique waiting to do it. It's incredible that it happened like that. I don't think you could name a single mining company that didn't come here [to our laboratory].
In August 1965, Techtron Appliances Pty Ltd merged with Atomic Spectral Lamps Pty Ltd to form Techtron Pty Ltd, which manufactured the Model AA-4 with a synchronously tuned amplifier and a nitrous oxide-acelylene burner. This was followed by a period of rapid growth, with staff increasing to around 200 in 1966. Geoffrey Frew was obliged to move premises and decided to build a new factory. He tells25 how Alan accompanied him to the Oakleigh branch of the Commonwealth Trading Bank 'to give weight to our plans to build a modern factory for the manufacture of scientific instruments for export'. Frew was granted the loan and in March 1967 the company moved into the new factory, in Mulgrave on the outskirts of Melbourne. In October 1967, Techtron Pty Ltd was approached by Varian Associates, a successful instrument manufacturing company in Palo Alto, California, with an offer of acquisition, first a 50.5% holding and progressing to 100% over five years.33 The merger, to form Varian Techtron Pty Ltd, brought 'great strengths to the company in the way of manufacturing techniques, financial support, and perhaps most importantly, a world-wide distribution network for its products'. [35] This was followed by further rapid growth, with sales increasing at an average of 30% a year for the next six years and staff growing to 630 by 1972. The company continues today as Varian Australia Pty Ltd, and is the second largest manufacturer of atomic absorption equipment, exporting more than two-thirds of its output.
In 1970, Geoffrey Frew donated a substantial sum to the Australian Academy of Science 'in recognition of the successful commercial development of atomic absorption spectrochemical analysis, which had been originated by Dr A. Walsh of the CSIRO Division of Chemical Physics in 1954'. The Geoffrey Frew Fellowships enable distinguished scientists from abroad to travel to Australia to participate in the Australian Spectroscopy Conferences and to visit scientific centres around the country. Recipients have included Nobel Laureates A.L. Schawlow, G. Porter, G. Herzberg, C. Cohen-Tannoudji and J. Polanyi.
The Perkin-Elmer experience
From 1958 Alan made regular visits to the USA, conducting lecture tours and reporting recent atomic absorption results from Australia and New Zealand. The analytical spectroscopists and major American instrument manufacturers remained sceptical of the value of the method. After papers he had presented at the Louisiana State University Symposium on Analytical Chemistry in January 1958, Alan reported that one spectroscopist, Jim Robinson from Esso Research, Baton Rouge, was enthusiastic about the potential of the atomic absorption method. In mid-1958 Robinson obtained approval to start some atomic absorption work, using equipment based on a Perkin-Elmer Model 13 infrared-ultraviolet spectrometer. [36] During his 1958 visit, Alan also visited the Perkin-Elmer Corporation, with whom he had previously had dealings in regard to the double-pass monochromator. A Perkin-Elmer representative indicated to him that the company would be 'seriously interested in becoming a licensed manufacturer of atomic absorption equipment if it could be shown capable of determining calcium in blood serum' (82). Alan's colleague, Alec Moodie, recalls how Alan's laboratory 'soon became littered with hospital samples that were laden with pathogens and which had to be treated rather cautiously'.
Alan realised he needed the support of an experienced chemist and asked a colleague, John Willis, who had been working on infrared spectroscopy, if he could look into the calcium problem. The determination of calcium in blood serum turned out to be one of the most difficult first problems John could have tackled. After a while he decided to tackle magnesium in blood instead, which turned out to be relatively straight-forward at a time when the available (wet) methods were so difficult and laborious that such a determination was scarcely attempted. Shortly afterwards, John was able to extend the atomic absorption method to the rapid determination of sodium, potassium and calcium in body fluids. [37]
In March 1959 John Willis submitted an interim report of his work on calcium and magnesium in blood serum to Perkin-Elmer. Meanwhile, Perkin-Elmer had assembled a flame photometer-like atomic absorption instrument and had started some atomic absorption work of their own. [38] In November 1959 the company was granted a licence from CSIRO to manufacture atomic absorption equipment. In 1960, after extensive internal discussions, Perkin-Elmer established a group, headed by Walter Slavin, to develop an atomic absorption instrument. In 1961 the company began shipments of an improvized atomic absorption instrument, the Model 214, using components that had been developed earlier for the Model 13 infrared-ultraviolet spectrometer.
In May 1961 Walter Slavin and a colleague, Herbert Kahn, submitted a detailed report [39] to Perkin-Elmer management that included the design of a completely new atomic absorption instrument, the Model 303. The report met with 'massive management resistance', especially in the marketing department.38 In early 1962 it was clear that management would block, or at least continue to delay, the start of the Model 303. So Walter Slavin phoned Alan, who agreed to go to Perkin-Elmer in Norwalk, Connecticut to meet with senior management. Alan recounted:3
After I had described the widespread use of atomic absorption methods in Australia the chairman of the meeting, Chester Nimitz Jr *** (a former submarine commander and son of Chester Nimitz, who commanded the US Pacific Fleet in World War 2) asked rather tersely: 'If this goddamn technique is as good as you say it is, why isn't it being used right here in United States of America?' My reply, which my friends at Perkin-Elmer love to recall, was 'You'll have to face up to it, Chester, the United States is just an underdeveloped country'.
Alan tells how each Christmas thereafter he and his wife Audrey received a card from Chester Nimitz, which invariably included the message: 'Glad to report we are developing nicely!'
In March 1962 Perkin-Elmer began building the Model 303. It was released on the market in April 1963, about the same time as the Techtron AA-2, which used an imported monochromator. By 1965 the Model 303 had already overtaken infrared spectroscopy as Perkin-Elmer's largest product line and had captured the bulk of the atomic absorption market. This prompted Alan to remark (71):
Indeed, whereas previously it [atomic absorption] had been regarded by some reactionaries as the greatest confidence trick since a Sydney taxi-driver sold the Harbour Bridge to an American millionaire, it was now being hailed as the greatest invention since the bed! I presume the truth lies somewhere between these two extremes.
In 1966 Alan's Chief, Lloyd Rees, felt that as result of Perkin-Elmer's highly successful atomic absorption operations the company ought to consider making a serious investment in the Australian scientific instrument business. Walter Slavin and Alan arranged for Lloyd Rees to meet the head of the Perkin-Elmer instrument business in Norwalk. Walter Slavin tells how Alan and he waited outside the office for the whole afternoon for the deal to be negotiated and were then advised that it was felt that it would be monopolistic for Perkin-Elmer to buy Techtron. The decision was that Perkin-Elmer would provide commercial support to Australian science by setting up a factory to manufacture a helium quadrupole mass-spectrometer leak detector developed by Don Swingler at the CSIRO Division of Chemical Physics. Alan and Walter had been seeking support for the commercialization of some of the atomic absorption research originating in Alan's laboratory, such as the resonance detector (46), but this had been rejected because it would have meant Perkin-Elmer going into competition with Techtron 'on their own turf'.
In 1967 Perkin-Elmer purchased land immediately adjacent to the site of the new Techtron factory in Mulgrave, Melbourne, to build a factory to manufacture the helium leak detector. Geoffrey Frew, the Chairman of Techtron, recalled:25 'Although we knew they had no licence to manufacture atomic absorption instruments in Australia, I was very annoyed by the speculations that followed the announcement of their land purchase and setting up business next door'. At the opening of the Perkin-Elmer factory in October 1967, Perkin-Elmer's founder and President, Richard Perkin, was 'very optimistic and predicted that his company would expand steadily in Australia and, as well as making the helium leak detector, would tender for government contracts'.25
Coincidentally, in October 1967 Techtron was approached with the offer of acquisition by Varian Associates. After just six weeks of operation Perkin-Elmer surprisingly closed its plant in Melbourne and in May 1968 the building was purchased by Varian Techtron Pty Ltd as part of a massive expansion of its operations.
Further atomic absorption and related work
During the 1960s and 1970s Alan's research was directed toward the development of novel instruments and techniques to simplify and improve atomic absorption equipment. He was especially keen to develop instruments of the simplest possible design for use in industrial environments where the samples were actually being taken.
In particular, Alan felt it should be possible to replace the monochromator, which was rather fragile, bulky and expensive, with a simpler and more rugged 'non-dispersive' device. In 1965 he and John Sullivan developed the resonance detector (46, 49, 52, 56), which consisted of a vapour cell of the appropriate element to selectively absorb the resonance lines from the source and a photomultiplier to detect the atomic fluorescence emitted by the vapour cell. Alan was known to remark 'Even a chemist can't put it out of alignment'. Such resonance detectors were subsequently tested in an industrial environment for the determination of calcium and magnesium in brown coal by the State Electricity Commission of Victoria and for the determination of nickel and zinc in ore samples. [40] Later, Alan and a colleague, Peter Larkins, developed the separated (nitrogen-sheathed) flame as a versatile resonance detector for the isolation of atomic resonance lines (70, 72).
The resonance detector was followed by the development of the ingenious technique of 'selective modulation' for isolating atomic resonance lines (48, 56, 59). Radiation from a sharp-line source is passed through a pulsating vapour of absorbing atoms and the resonance lines are detected using a synchronous amplifier tuned to the frequency of modulation of the atomic vapour. Alan predicted that the selective modulation technique should also lead to appreciable sharpening of the profile of the atomic resonance line, giving rise to 'sub-Doppler' linewidths. This was subsequently demonstrated experimentally, [41] culminating in Alan proudly claiming a bottle of red wine as a result of a long-standing wager with me.
Alan realised that light intensities higher than those available from standard hollow-cathode lamps would be required in applications involving resonance detectors or atomic fluorescence detection. In 1965 he and John Sullivan developed the 'high-intensity' hollow-cathode lamp (45), which employs two discharges, a hollow-cathode discharge to generate an atomic vapour by cathodic sputtering and a high electron-current discharge, isolated from the first, to excite the atoms. The 'Sullivan-Walsh' high-intensity lamp allows the intensity of the resonance lines to be increased up to a hundred-fold without any increase in atom density and hence linewidth. It also has the advantage that most of the light output is usually concentrated in the strongest resonance line. Such lamps are manufactured by Varian Australia Pty Ltd and by the Perkin-Elmer Corporation. A modified version, based on that developed in Alan's laboratory by Martin Lowe, [42] is manufactured by Photron Pty Ltd in Melbourne.
Alan's original paper (29) also envisaged the possibility of using atomic absorption as a simple method of isotopic analysis. By employing a sharp-line source containing only one isotope of an element, analyses can be performed for that isotope if the 'isotope shift' of the resonance line is larger than or comparable with the width of the line. Successful isotopic analyses have since been realised for elements having relatively large isotope shifts, such as lithium, boron (which was investigated in Alan's laboratory by Hannaford and Lowe [43]), lead, mercury and uranium.
In his landmark paper (29) Alan proposed that the atomic absorption method should offer the possibility of absolute chemical analysis, that is, analysis without the need for standard samples of known composition. His next two papers (30, 31) went some of the way towards demonstrating absolute analysis, but Alan realised the inadequacy of the flame absorber, in which the atomization was usually far from complete. Professor Boris L'vov in Leningrad accepted the challenge and later established graphite-furnace atomic absorption spectroscopy, involving the complete vaporization of samples. L'vov, in collaboration with Walter Slavin and colleagues at Perkin-Elmer, has now successfully realised absolute atomic absorption analysis for a wide range of elements. [44] In addition, use of the graphite furnace as an atomizer has increased the sensitivity of atomic absorption analysis by one to two orders of magnitude.
From the time of his original atomic absorption paper (29), Alan was conscious of the limitations of flame methods of atomization, sometimes referring to the flame as 'a hotbed of chemical reactions'. The limitations include incomplete atomization of most elements from their compounds, causing low sensitivity and possible chemical interferences; the necessity of an oxidant, rendering the vacuum ultraviolet (and hence elements like carbon, sulphur and phosphorus) inaccessible; and the need for prior dissolution of the sample. In addition, the presence of various molecular species can introduce background absorption signals, and the need for an explosive gas such as acetylene is undesirable in certain locations such as hospitals.
In a paper published in 1959, Alan and Barbara Russell reported (33) that a hollow-cathode discharge can provide a simple and convenient means of generating an atomic vapour of essentially any solid element. Energetic rare-gas ions formed in the hollow-cathode discharge bombard the surface of the cathode and eject atoms to produce an atomic vapour. Thus this process of cathodic sputtering provides a method in which metals and alloys can be atomized directly without prior dissolution. Furthermore, the method should, in principle, not be subject to any of the above limitations of the flame. In June 1967 Alan employed me to look further into the cathodic sputtering method of atomization. In 1973, together with David Gough, we reported the first results, on the determination of a range of elements in solid samples of iron-base alloys (63, 64). Alan wrote (68):
I would not expect the scientific instrument manufacturers to be greatly interested in the simple sputtering cell… I would, however, like to think that some of them are musing on possible ways of embellishment to ensure that any commercial version will have an impressive price tag.
Indeed, it took more than another decade before an atomic absorption sputtering system was manufactured, by Analyte Corporation, USA, in 1988.
In his final Keynote Address, [45] to the Pittsburgh Conference in 1990, Alan stated that his own work on atomic absorption 'originated in a laboratory devoted primarily to basic, curiosity-oriented research and finished in applied research of tremendous economic value'. He went on to say that one of his colleagues had 'taken the return journey'. I had worked with Alan on attempts to develop methods of atomization based on cathodic sputtering that were largely unsuccessful for routine analysis. However, my colleagues and I then showed that the atomic vapours produced by cathodic sputtering can provide a surprisingly good environment for conducting a variety of fundamental laser spectroscopic experiments. These included time-resolved fluorescence measurements of atomic lifetimes and their application to the determination of solar elemental abundances from the Fraunhofer absorption lines; coherence spectroscopy including quantum beats in excited or ground atomic states; and high-resolution Doppler-free laser saturation spectroscopy. Thus cathodic sputtering has permitted high-resolution and time-resolved laser spectroscopic techniques to be readily extended to a very wide range of atomic systems (81). Alan seemed particularly excited by this work, not only because of its potential as a universal method for determining atomic lifetimes, and hence absolute oscillator strengths, for atomic absorption spectroscopy, but also because the Fraunhofer absorption lines are 'just atomic absorption'. Alan concluded his Pittsburgh address with 'my experiences over forty years with CSIRO have convinced me that the doors between fundamental and applied research should remain open'.
Significance and benefits of atomic absorption
Atomic absorption has provided a quick, easy, accurate and highly sensitive means of determining the concentrations of over sixty-five of the elements. The method has found important application world-wide in areas as diverse as medicine, agriculture, mineral exploration, metallurgy, food analysis, biochemistry and environmental monitoring. It has been described as 'the most significant advance in chemical analysis' in the twentieth century. [46]
By the time the original patents of atomic absorption had expired around 1969, twenty licences had been issued, and there were also several manufacturers in countries such as Japan in which patents had not been sought. During 1963-67 sales of atomic absorption instruments experienced exponential-like growth. By 1969 there were more than 10,000 atomic absorption spectrophotometers in use in hospitals, factories and laboratories around the world, and by 1977 this number had grown to around 40,000. Alan tells how a slight decrease in the rate of world sales around 1968 came as a relief to his colleague, John Willis, who 'feared that if sales continued to increase at the same rate as 1963-68, then by the turn of the century the whole surface of the Earth would be covered by atomic absorption spectrophotometers'. [47] This did not come about!
The current world market for atomic absorption instruments is around $A300 million a year. Varian Australia Pty Ltd in Melbourne, with a staff of around 400 and a similar number outside the company engaged in contract work, has the second largest share of the market, after the Perkin-Elmer Corporation, while GBC Scientific Equipment Pty Ltd in Melbourne, with a staff of around 180, is the third largest. In addition, Photron Pty Ltd in Melbourne manufactures hollow-cathode lamps and high-intensity hollow-cathode lamps for atomic absorption. The commercialization of the atomic absorption spectrophotometer essentially led to the birth of the scientific instrument industry in Australia.
In 1968, A.W. Brown, a scientist with postgraduate qualifications in business administration, was recruited by John Shelton at CSIRO Head Office to conduct a detailed cost-benefit analysis of the atomic absorption project. This study [48] conservatively assessed the value of the net benefits to the Australian economy at around $22 million (in 1968 Australian dollars), compared with $1.3 million originally spent on the research. (Later estimates gave the accumulated benefit to Australia by the year 1977 as in excess of $200 million, including overseas royalties, the setting up of new industry, and the productivity increases in a wide range of enterprises.) Much to the surprise of many, Brown found that the major benefits to the economy were not through the manufacture of atomic absorption equipment in Australia but rather through benefits to the user, that is, benefits associated with productivity gains, especially the ability to perform large numbers of assays very rapidly and with a high order of accuracy. This component far outweighed the benefits of manufacture. Royalty income was miniscule by comparison.
Mr Barry Jones, a former Minister for Science in the Australian Government, recently remarked: [50] 'I don't know there is a single significant laboratory anywhere in the world that doesn't have an atomic absorption spectrophotometer. The tragedy is, of course, as with so many other of our ideas with something that really began here, licensing rights were sold off to other countries and the result is that only a small proportion of the actual machines were manufactured in Australia after a while.' This is a popularly held view among journalists, politicians and academics. During the period 1954 to 1962, Australia did not have the scientific instrument manufacturing capability to handle the massive expansion that resulted first from the Australian mineral boom of the 1960s and later from the 'environmental boom' and the enormous demand from around the world. There was no company in Australia geared up to cope with such a demand. Moreover, the cost-benefit analysis of Brown showed that the major benefits to Australia's economy lay not in royalties or in manufacture of the instrument but through benefits to the user.
Alan regarded the benefits of atomic absorption to humanity – for example, through its use in hospitals throughout the world – as having 'given him more satisfaction than all the dollars it has earned'. One of his favourite stories [11], [49] concerned a five-year-old boy, who in 1968 had suffered extensive burns while playing with a can of petrol and was undergoing treatment at the Children's Medical Research Foundation in Sydney. For weeks doctors fought to save his life, and finally violent convulsions started for no apparent reason and death appeared imminent. Tests with an atomic absorption spectrophotometer established that the boy had suffered a severe loss of magnesium as a result of the burns. Doctors replaced the lost magnesium, the convulsions ceased, and the boy eventually recovered. A photograph of the boy had a prominent place in Alan's office for the remainder of his time at CSIRO.
When asked about the appropriateness of the development of atomic absorption in Australia, Alan replied: [16]
Well, of course it was fortunate. We say it was good planning! I think it's a good example of how uncommitted research can finally be more significant than directly applied work. If somebody had said in 1950 that there was going to be a mineral boom in ten years' time which would need new methods of analysis, I'm sure we would have tried to elaborate existing methods, rather than follow a completely new line.
In his final scientific paper (83), written in 1991, Alan concluded:
There are two important lessons to be learned from this account of the development of atomic absorption methods and the difficulties encountered in convincing analysts and scientific instrument manufacturers of their potential.
First, it should be noted that this work originated in a laboratory where scientists were encouraged to study a subject at a basic level and were not expected to have a specific goal for every set of investigations. I think this is a tremendously important point. Increasingly we find young scientists being channelled into increasingly narrow areas of activities aimed only at targets with good prospects of success. They are being given less and less room to manoeuvre. Their work is being largely confined to answering questions, ignoring the many lessons that have shown that much successful research has its origin in asking the right question.
The second lesson is that it is a mistake for the scientist or the inventor to try to sell an invention by scientific and technical arguments rather than by a demonstration of how well it can fulfill the functions it claims to fulfill. The licensee is not interested in how clever the invention is; he or she merely wants to know what benefits the invention affords the designer, manufacturer, and user of the equipment in which it is incorporated.
Retirement 1977–98
Retirement from CSIRO
In November 1976 Alan gave notice of his intention to retire from CSIRO on 5 January 1977, just after his sixtieth birthday and after thirty years of service and fifteen years as Assistant Chief of the Division of Chemical Physics. He had for many years said 'I will have run out of new ideas by the age of sixty and I should make way for a younger person'.
Two weeks after giving notice, Alan received a telex:
I have pleasure in informing you that Her Majesty The Queen has been graciously pleased to approve the recommendation that you be awarded a Royal Medal in recognition of your distinguished contributions to emission and infrared spectroscopy and your origination of the atomic absorption method of quantitative analysis.
Alan had the distinction of being only the fourth Australian scientist to have been awarded a Royal Medal, after Ferdinand von Mueller in 1888 and Nobel Laureates Sir Macfarlane Burnet and Sir John Eccles. In the Silver Jubilee Queen's Birthday Honours List in June 1977, Alan was created a Knight Bachelor for 'his distinguished service to science'. Alan's many other honours included election to Fellowship of the Royal Society of London in 1969 and Foreign Member of the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences in 1969, being only the second Australian scientist (after Burnet) on whom the latter honour had been bestowed.
On the occasion of Alan's retirement, his Chief of Division, Dr Lloyd Rees, paid the following tribute:51
Alan Walsh did not only invent an analytical instrument called the atomic absorption spectrophotometer – he created a field of scientific work in atomic absorption spectroscopy and initiated and cultivated its application to elemental chemical analysis in areas as disparate as agriculture and chemical industry, and medicine and the mining and metallurgical industries. His contribution to science, industry and human welfare has been enormous. In spite of his great distinction Alan Walsh is a human being – he enjoys life and has never found it necessary to develop eccentricities or affectations.
Alan seemed overwhelmed by all the fuss being made of his retirement, and at a CSIRO dinner in his honour remarked 'I've been to so many farewell dinners recently that I'm beginning to acquire a taste for wine'.
Alan was intending to become a private consultant to industry and sadly had to vacate his office and laboratory at the CSIRO Division of Chemical Physics. He had also accepted an honorary fellowship at Monash University, adjacent to CSIRO, which had awarded him an honorary doctorate in 1970. But first he was going to take a long holiday 'to recharge my batteries and to have some time to renovate the house, do some gardening, swim a little, and improve my golf swing'. After a weekend's golf Alan was known to comment 'golf defies all theory' and 'it is a relief to get back to research where the problems were more amenable to rational analysis'.
Six years later, in June 1982, Alan was elated to learn that he had been invited back to CSIRO as a Senior Research Fellow. In December 1994 the Spectroscopy Wing at the CSIRO Division of Chemical Physics was named the 'Alan Walsh Spectroscopy Laboratory'.
The Perkin-Elmer consultancy
After his visit in 1962, Alan began to visit Perkin-Elmer in Norwalk on a regular basis and participated in some major commercial decisions. These included the decisions for Perkin-Elmer to construct their own hollow-cathode lamps, to manufacture a Zeeman attachment to their atomic absorption equipment to correct for background absorption, and to manufacture the inductively coupled plasma source. [38]
About a year after his retirement from CSIRO, Alan became a formal consultant to Perkin-Elmer. During 1978-1982 he and his wife, Audrey, spent several Australian winters beside the Bodensee near Überlingen, Germany, where Alan made frequent visits to the Perkin-Elmer plant, the 'Bodensee-werk'. At that time the chief research interest there was the hydride generation technique for atomic absorption, and Alan suggested that it might be very interesting to combine the hydride work with a 'solar-blind' photomultiplier to provide a simple non-dispersive atomic fluorescence spectrometer for the determination of arsenic and selenium. Alan and Walter Slavin convinced the Bodenseewerk engineers to build a prototype and it worked nicely (79). However, Perkin-Elmer marketing decided the market was too small. Some years later the Chinese built a highly successful hydride instrument for a large market. [38]
In the early 1980s Alan initiated a project to investigate coherent forward scattering as a possible method of spectrochemical analysis (80). Coherent forward scattering had been pioneered in Oxford as a spectroscopic technique in the mid-1960s by George Series, [52] of whom Alan had long been an admirer. The technique relies on the fact that the light emitted from atoms in the forward direction is phase-coherent and so the intensity is proportional to the square of the number of atoms, thus offering the possibility of higher sensitivity than atomic absorption. The method has the additional advantage that any background radiation scattered from 'particles' in the atomic vapour is not detected. With Alan's help, Perkin-Elmer conducted an extensive development programme on coherent forward scattering and built a system derived from their Zeeman background correction instrument. The project was abandoned when it could not be proved to be commercially attractive.
The scientist and the man
It is instructive to consider some of the characteristics that may have contributed to Alan's success as a scientist and to his successful development and commercialization of the atomic absorption method of chemical analysis.
First and foremost, his work was characterized by a remarkable simplicity and elegance, a hallmark of many great scientists. Alan himself wrote (83):
My general attitude to research was greatly influenced by the fact that I studied physics at Manchester University. The Physics Department had an illustrious record of major achievements, including Rutherford's development of the nuclear theory of the atom, Bohr's first theory of the origin of atomic spectra, Moseley's law of X-ray spectra, and [Lawrence] Bragg's work on the determination of crystal structures by X-ray crystallography. A feature of all these advances was [that] whilst they were profound they were all very simple. I think by the time I had finished my course at Manchester I took it for granted that the very essence of a significant contribution to physics was a fundamental simplicity.
Sometimes Alan's ideas and schemes were so deceptively simple that they were not always appreciated at first, but as the years went by, they frequently had a habit of becoming important.
Alan was blessed with an extraordinarily creative and fertile mind, forever generating new ideas. One of his colleagues, Peter Larkins, tells [53] how on one occasion a colleague was attempting to improve the performance of a sputtering system as an atomizer for atomic absorption. Alan made a suggestion which it was estimated would improve the absorption sensitivity by a factor of about two. He came back a while later with another suggestion to give another factor of two. By lunchtime it was estimated he had been back fifteen times! He also displayed great zest and enthusiasm in whatever he tackled, and this seemed to infect those around him. He was a great inspiration to work with. John Willis tells [54] how in the early days he had been working on the Littrow spectrograph with a modification which Alan and he had hoped would vastly improve its performance. Alan came into the laboratory and asked John how he was getting on. John replied with an air of disappointment that he couldn't do much better than a factor of two. 'Don't despise a factor two, John', he said. 'Three factors of two make a factor of ten!'
Alan had a rare combination of vivid imagination and experimental practicality. He was a wonderfully intuitive scientist, with an enormous grasp of the numerical, carrying numbers and orders of magnitude in his head. He was known to say [55] 'Kelvin could take no pleasure in an equation unless he could feel its weight'. He could make things work so well that some people felt he could 'work magic'. He never pretended to have any unreal powers; he always had his feet firmly on the ground. On one occasion his Chief, Lloyd Rees, wanted to construct a reflecting infrared microscope, which was to be used by John Willis to study the infrared spectra of small protein samples. It was clear to Alan that the numerical aperture of the infrared spectrometer was ill-matched to the microscope. The instrument workshop launched into building the microscope, and the carpenters made a magnificent timber box lined with felt. No detectable signal came through. Alan was heard to say [54] 'Lloyd seems to hold me personally responsible for the laws of optics being what they are'.
Alan grew up in a small family business where he acquired an acute business sense. He once remarked: [51] 'My family was steeped in the traditions of the Lancashire textile industry. I was brought up in the real world – where one went out to make a quid'. Unlike many scientists of his generation, he enjoyed mixing with the captains of industry and spoke their language. It was fascinating to observe him in action at a meeting or in some business negotiation. He would rarely take the lead, preferring to listen politely and assimilate what others had to say. At the end of the meeting he would invariably be asked his opinion, and then would eloquently deliver a definitive statement, which would often end the discussion. He had little time for 'virtuoso performances'. He also had the tenacity and perseverance to see a long and difficult project or business negotiation through to completion. A colleague once said of him:13 'If he had a problem he would gnaw away at the damn thing until it surrendered'.
Many people expected a distinguished scientist like Alan to be a stereotype academic, totally devoted and consumed in his research and with little time for the ‘ordinary' things in life. His Chief, Lloyd Rees, once wrote: [56]
Throughout his life he [Alan] has been interested in sport, football, cricket, squash and latterly golf. His other sport was drinking red wine. At one stage of his career he indulged in all-year-round early morning swimming in Port Phillip Bay, which, during the winter months, can be sustained by the hardiest individuals only. He has, however, recovered from this aberration and now spends much of his spare time cultivating camellias.
Alan was an avid follower of cricket, especially English cricket, and a great admirer of the inimitable English cricket commentator John Arlott. Alec Moodie recalls how on one occasion Alan proudly showed him a newspaper clipping about his younger brother, Tom, who had opened the batting for the village cricket team in Hoddlesden and on this occasion 'carried his bat' through the innings but failed to 'open his account'. Alan described his brother as 'always cautious, typical of a Lancashire batsman'.
Alan had a remarkable ability to mix with people from all walks of life. His colleague, John Willis, states: 'I have never met anyone who was so immediately at home with people, whether it was politicians, businessmen, distinguished scientists, the younger members of the Division, the tradesmen, or the canteen ladies'. I myself can hardly recall an instance when Alan tried to put another person down or any scientific paper or lecture where he criticized the work of others. It was as though life were too short not to spend it being constructive at all times. He was a wonderful mentor and role model for any young scientist to emulate, forever striving for excellence and providing encouragement and words of wisdom.
Finally, Alan had a wonderful English North Country humour, which was legendary world-wide. During discussions or during gloomier moments in the laboratory he could defuse a situation by coming out with a characteristic 'one-liner' followed by loud, raucous laughter that echoed the length of the passage. Some of his sayings and traditions still live on in the Alan Walsh Spectroscopy Laboratory.
Alan Trumble, a close friend and neighbour of Audrey and Alan, commented, in a eulogy to Alan:57
Alan loved life and people, always showing a very genuine interest in others' activities and concerns for their problems. He was a devoted family man and extremely proud of his boys, Tom and David, absolutely delighted with his daughters-in-law, a doting grandfather to Chevaun, Miriam, Emily and Jack. You could not be close to the Walsh family without appreciating the wonderful affection of a husband for a wife.
Epilogue
In Alan's final years his memory sadly began to fade but he still retained his mischievous sense of humour and good nature to the end. In this memoir we have attempted to capture some of that humour for posterity.
Alan died in Melbourne on 3 August 1998, aged 81, survived by his widow, Audrey, and sons, Tom and David, and their families.
Honours and distinctions
Medals and awards
- 1966: Britannica Australia Award
- 1969: Talanta Gold Medal
- 1969: Royal Society of Victoria Research Medal
- 1972: Maurice Hasler Award in Spectroscopy, US Society of Applied Spectroscopy
- 1975: Kronland Medal, Czechoslavak Spectroscopic Society
- 1975: James Cook Medal, Royal Society of New South Wales
- 1976: Torbern Bergman Medal, Swedish Chemical Society
- 1976: Royal Medal, Royal Society of London
- 1977: Knight Bachelor
- 1978: John Scott Award, City of Philadelphia, USA
- 1980: Matthew Flinders Lecture and Medal, Australian Academy of Science
- 1982: Robert Boyle Medal, Royal Society of Chemistry (Inaugural Award);
- 1982: K.L. Sutherland Memorial Medal, Australian Academy of Technological Sciences (Inaugural Award)
- 1991: Colloquium Spectroscopicum Internationale Award for Major Scientific Contributions to Analytical Spectroscopy (Inaugural Award)
Academic affiliations
- 1958: Fellow, Australian Academy of Science
- 1969: Foreign Member, Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences
- 1969: Fellow, Royal Society of London
- 1969: Honorary Member, Society of Analytical Chemistry, Great Britain
- 1972: Honorary Fellow, Chemical Society, Great Britain
- 1975: Honorary Fellow, Royal Society of New Zealand
- 1979: Honorary Fellow, Australian Institute of Physics
- 1980: Honorary Fellow, Royal Society of Chemistry, Great Britain
- 1981: Honorary Member, Japan Society for Analytical Chemistry
- 1982: Fellow, Australian Academy of Technological Sciences
Honorary degrees
- 1970: Doctor of Science, Monash University, Australia
- 1986: Doctor of Science, University of Manchester, UK
Special journal issues, Spectrochimica Acta
- 1980: Commemoration of 25th anniversary of Alan Walsh's landmark paper on atomic absorption [58]
- 1999: Alan Walsh Memorial Issue [59]
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 13(2), 2000. It was also published in Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society of London, 2000. It was written by Peter Hannaford, Alan Walsh Spectroscopy Laboratory, CSIRO Manufacturing Science and Technology, Clayton, Victoria 3169.
Acknowledgements
I express my deep gratitude to Sir Alan Walsh for his inspiration, encouragement and friendship over a period extending more than thirty years. I am especially indebted to Lady Walsh for providing background material and numerous anecdotes about Alan; to Alan's cousin, Mrs Kathleen Hoyle, for generously providing the material on Alan's early life in Hoddlesden; to Professor Alec Moodie for providing many of the stories and anecdotes concerning Alan's life at CSIRO; to Mr John Shelton for providing background material on Alan's development of the atomic absorption method; to Mr Walter Slavin for providing material about Alan's association with Perkin-Elmer; and to Dr John Willis for providing numerous sources of information, including the background on Alan's work in molecular spectroscopy, and for preparing the bibliography.
I am especially grateful to Professor Sandy Mathieson, John Shelton, Walter Slavin and John Willis for constructive comments on the manuscript. I also gratefully acknowledge contributions from Mr Max Amos, Mr Peter Beale, Mr David Gough, Dr Norman Ham, Mr Bill Ramsden, Professor Norman Sheppard, Mr John Sullivan, Mr Rodney Teakle and Dr Harold Whitfield. Finally, I wish to thank my colleagues from the Alan Walsh Spectroscopy Laboratory at CSIRO and my wife Kay for permitting me three months of pleasure to indulge in writing this biographical memoir.
The photograph of Alan Walsh was taken in June 1979 by the CSIRO Division of Chemical Physics.
References
- 'Alan Walsh. The making of a scientific breakthrough', Double Helix News (CSIRO), 11 (1988), 10.
- A. Walsh, 'Why did you become a scientist?', written in 1993 for The Quantum Book of How and Why, later published as Why? Scientists Answer Children's Questions (Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 1998) eds P. Long and J. Phemister. Walsh's article never appeared in the final version of the book (A. Walsh, personal papers). Walsh's personal papers, of which I was able to make extensive use, will be deposited in the Basser Library, Australian Academy of Science, Canberra.
- L. Parker, 'Scientist viewpoint', Science Teachers Journal, 34(3) (1988), 81-86.
- P.T. Beale, letter to J.B. Willis, 28 November 1998 (A. Walsh, personal papers).
- W. Ramsden, letter to J.B. Willis, 24 November 1998 (A. Walsh, personal papers).
- 'Don't judge spook by her cover', The Times; reprinted in The Australian, 13 September 1999.
- W. Ramsden, personal communication, January 2000.
- J.B. Willis, 'Spectroscopic research in the CSIRO Division of Chemical Physics 1944-1986', Hist. Rec. Aust. Sci., 8 (1991), 151-182.
- I.W. Wark, 'The CSIRO Division of Industrial Chemistry 1940-1952', Rec. Aust. Acad. Sci., 4 (1979), 7-41.
- J.P. Shelton, 'Atomic absorption spectroscopy – a personal recollection, 1947-1958', Spectrochim. Acta B, 54 (1999), 1961-1966.
- A. McKay, 'The absorbing atom', in Surprise and Enterprise: Fifty Years of Science for Australia (CSIRO, 1976), pp. 6-7. Based on an earlier article by J.R. Price, Australia Now, 1 (1971), 12-13.
- 'Alan Walsh and the atomic absorption spectrophotometer', CSIRO Scifile, 34 (1988), 4.
- B. Beale, 'Eureka! they cry', Sydney Morning Herald, 5 April 1986.
- K. Robinson, 'Sir Alan Walsh 1916-98', Chemistry in Britain, 35(1) (1999), 59; Coresearch, No. 376 (1998), p. 4.
- S.J. Payne, 'Remembering Alan Walsh', Chemistry in Britain, 35(3) (1999), 23.
- H.A. Willis, 'Sir Alan Walsh, the inventor of atomic absorption spectrometry', ESN Interviews, European Spectroscopy News, 24 (1979), 18-23.
- S. Tolansky, High Resolution Spectroscopy, Methuen, London, 1947.
- G. Dieke and H.M. Crosswhite, 'Purification of rare gases using activated uranium', J. Opt. Soc. Am., 42 (1952), 433.
- Apparatus for spectrochemical analysis, Australian Patent Application 23,041/53 (Nov. 17, 1953); Australian Patent Specification 163,586 (Oct. 21, 1954).
- C.T.J. Alkemade and J.M.W. Milatz, 'A double-beam method of spectral selection with flames', Appl. Phys. Res., B4 (1955), 289-299; 'Double-beam method of spectral selection with flames', J. Opt. Soc. Am., 45 (1955), 583-584.
- J.P. Shelton, letter to A. Walsh, 5 March 1956 (A. Walsh, personal papers).
- A.C. Nicholas, 'A case study of an innovation: the development of atomic absorption spectroscopy', January 1965 (A. Walsh, personal papers).
- A.C. Menzies, 'A study of atomic absorption spectroscopy', Anal. Chem., 32 (1960), 898-904.
- J.P. Shelton, letter to A. Walsh, 21 September 1956 (A. Walsh, personal papers).
- M.L. Carseldine, The development of atomic absorption spectroscopy and subsequent instrument manufacturing industry that has arisen in Australia. MSc thesis, Griffith University, Brisbane (1984).
- J.E. Allan, 'Atomic absorption spectrophoto-metry with particular reference to the determination of magnesium', Analyst, 83 (1958), 466-471.
- D.J. David, 'The determination of zinc and other elements in plants by atomic absorption spectroscopy', Analyst, 83 (1958), 655-661.
- J.B. Willis, 'Determination of magnesium in blood serum by atomic absorption spectroscopy', Nature, 184 (1959), 186-187.
- B.S. Rawling, M.D. Amos and M.C. Greaves, 'The determination of silver in lead concentrates by atomic absorption spectroscopy', Nature, 188 (1960), 137-138.
- P. Kelly, 'A good idea is so hard to sell', The Australian, 31 May 1976.
- S. Encel, 'Science, discoveries and innovation: an Australian case history', Int. Soc. Sci. J., 22 (1970), 42-53.
- J.J. McNeill, 'Diffraction grating ruling in Australia', Rec. Aust. Acad. Sci., 2 (1972), 18-39.
- M.D. Amos, 'The development of the atomic absorption spectrometer manufacture in Australia’, Spectrochim. Acta B, 54 (1999), 2023-2030.
- M.D. Amos and J.B. Willis, 'The use of high-temperature pre-mixed flames in atomic absorption spectroscopy', Spectrochim. Acta, 22 (1966), 1325-1343; errata ibid, p. 2228.
- M. Spiller, 'Varian-Techtron Pty Ltd: company and product history', Doc: 1241P, Edition No. 1, May 1985.
- J.W. Robinson, 'A tribute to Sir Alan Walsh – development of atomic absorption in the United States – "a personal view''', Spectrochim. Acta B, 54 (1999), 1993-1998.
- J.B. Willis, 'The early days of atomic absorption spectrometry in clinical chemistry', Spectrochim. Acta B, 54 (1999), 1971-1975.
- W. Slavin, personal communication, January 2000.
- W. Slavin and H. Kahn, Perkin-Elmer Engineering Report 594, May (1961).
- R.M. Lowe and J.V. Sullivan, 'Developments in light sources and detectors for atomic absorption spectroscopy', Spectrochim. Acta B, 54 (1999), 2031-2039.
- D.S. Gough and P. Hannaford, 'Sharpening of atomic resonance lines by selective modulation', Spectrochim. Acta B, 35 (1980), 677-85.
- R.M. Lowe, 'A high-intensity hollow-cathode lamp for atomic fluorescence', Spectrochim. Acta B, 26 (1970), 201-205.
- P. Hannaford and R.M. Lowe, 'Determination of boron isotope ratios by atomic absorption spectroscopy', Anal. Chem., 49 (1977), 1852-1857.
- B.V. L'vov, 'Recent advances in absolute analysis by graphite furnace atomic absorption spectroscopy', Spectrochim. Acta B, 45 (1990), 633-655.
- A. Walsh, 'The development of atomic absorption methods of elemental analysis', Keynote Lecture, Pittsburgh Conference on Analytical Chemistry, 1990 (A. Walsh, personal papers).
- I.W. Wark, Why Research? A Research Scientist Writes of his Work, Educational Employers Ltd, Reading, UK, 1968.
- J.B. Willis, 'Analysis of biological materials by atomic spectroscopic techniques – a review of progress in the last decade', Revue de GAMS, 1971, No. 3, pp 83-91.
- A.W. Brown, 'The economic benefits to Australia from atomic absorption spectroscopy', Econ. Record, (1969), 158-180.
- 'Answer to the puzzle of a burnt boy', Sydney Morning Herald, 14 September 1968.
- B.O. Jones, P. Hannaford and G. Nossal, Interview with Robyn Williams and Martin Hewetson, The Science Show, Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 5 September 1998.
- 'Dr Alan Walsh to become industry consultant', Coresearch, No. 212 (1977), p. 1; A.L.G. Rees, telex to M. Dack, 31 December 1976 (A. Walsh, personal papers).
- A. Corney, B.P. Kibble and G.W. Series, 'The forward scattering of resonance radiation with special reference to double resonance and level-crossing experiments', Proc. Roy. Soc. London, A 293 (1966), 70-93.
- P.L. Larkins, 'Sir Alan Walsh – the scientist and the man', Analyst, 117 (1992), 231-233.
- J.B. Willis, personal communication, March 2000.
- A.F. Moodie, personal communication, December 1999.
- A.L.G. Rees, communication to CSIRO Head Office, 22 August 1972 (A. Walsh, personal papers).
- A. Trumble, Eulogy, Thanksgiving Service for Alan Walsh, 7 August 1998.
- 'Atomic absorption spectroscopy: past, present and future – to commemorate the 25th anniversary of Alan Walsh's landmark paper in Spectrochimica Acta', Spectrochim. Acta B, 35 (1980), 637-993.
- Alan Walsh Memorial Issue, Spectrochim. Acta B, 54 (1999), 2031-2039.
Bibliography
Contributions to books
- A. Walsh, The spectrographic analysis of aluminium alloys by the direct comparison method, in Collected Papers on Metallurgical Analysis by the Spectrograph, ed. D.M. Smith, Brit. Non-Ferrous Metals Research Assoc., London, 1945, pp. 65-81.
- A. Walsh, D.M. Smith, The spectrographic analysis of zinc base alloys, ibid., pp. 116-129.
- D.M. Smith, A. Walsh, Note on the spectro-graphic determination of aluminium in aluminium brass (76/22/2), ibid., pp. 130-134.
- A. Walsh, Light sources for spectrochemical analysis, in Metal Spectroscopy, ed. F. Twyman, Griffin, London, 1950, pp. 170-228.
- N.S. Ham, A. Walsh, Raman bands in liquids, in Encyclopaedic Dictionary of Physics, Vol. 6, Pergamon, Oxford, 1962, p. 177.
- A. Walsh, J.B. Willis, Atomic absorption spectrometry, in Standard Methods of Chemical Analysis, Vol. 3, Part A. Instrumental Methods, ed. F.J. Welcher, Van Nostrand, Princeton, NJ, 1966, pp. 105-117.
Journal articles
- D.M. Smith, A. Walsh, The electrical screening of sparking apparatus for use in spectrographic analysis, J. Sci. Inst., 20 (1943), 63-64.
- A. Walsh, A general-purpose source unit for the spectrographic analysis of metals and alloys, Bull. Brit. Non-Ferrous Metals Research Assoc., No. 201 (1946), 60-80; Metal Industry, 68 (1946), 243, 263, 293.
- A. Walsh, The suppression of radio interference from spark generators used in spectrographic analysis, Brit. Non-Ferrous Metals Research Assoc., Paper No. S35/125 (1946).
- S. Stallberg-Stenhagen, E. Stenhagen, N. Sheppard, G.B.B.M. Sutherland, A. Walsh, Infra-red spectrum and molecular structure of phthiocerane, Nature, 160 (1947), 580-582.
- A. Walsh, The spectroscopic determination of thermodynamic data, J. Proc. Aust. Chem. Inst., 16 (1949), 371-386.
- A. Walsh, J.B. Willis, Infra-red absorption spectra at low temperatures, J. Chem. Phys., 17 (1949), 838.
- A. Walsh, J.B. Willis, Infra-red absorption spectra at low temperatures, J. Chem. Phys., 18 (1950), 552-556.
- A. Walsh, Spectrographic analysis of uranium, Spectrochim. Acta, 4 (1950), 47-56.
- A.G. Pulford, A. Walsh, The infra-red spectrum and thermodynamic constants of nitrosyl chloride, Trans. Faraday Soc., 47 (1951), 347-353.
- J.C. Earl, R.J.W. Le Fèvre, A.G. Pulford, A. Walsh, The infra-red spectra of three sydnones, J. Chem. Soc., 481 (1951), 2207-2208.
- A. Walsh, Design of multiple monochromators, Nature, 167 (1951), 810-811.
- N.S. Ham, A.L.G. Rees, A. Walsh, Infra-red studies of solvent effects, Nature, 169 (1952), 110-111.
- N.S. Ham, A.L.G. Rees, A. Walsh, The infra-red spectra of solutions of iodine in mesitylene, J. Chem. Phys., 20 (1952), 1336-1337.
- N.S. Ham, A. Walsh, J.B. Willis, A quadruple monochromator, Nature, 169 (1952), 977.
- A. Walsh, Multiple monochromators. I. Design of multiple monochromators, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 42 (1952), 94-95.
- A. Walsh, Multiple Monochromators. II. Applications of a double monochromator to infra-red spectroscopy, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 42 (1952), 96-100.
- N.S. Ham, A. Walsh, J.B. Willis, Multiple monochromators. III. A quadruple monochromator and its application to infra-red spectroscopy, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 42 (1952), 496-500.
- A. Walsh, Multiple monochromators, Nature, 169 (1952), 976.
- A. Walsh, Echelette zone plates for use in far infra-red spectroscopy, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 42 (1952), 213.
- A. Walsh, Reduction of scattered light in a Littrow-type monochromator, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 43 (1953), 58.
- A. Walsh, Design of double-beam multiple monochromators, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 43 (1953), 215.
- A. Walsh, J.B. Willis, Multiple monochromators. IV. A triple monochromator and its application to near infra-red, visible and ultra-violet spectroscopy, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 43 (1953), 989-992.
- A. Walsh, The application of atomic absorption spectra to chemical analysis, Spectrochim. Acta, 7 (1955), 108-117; erratum, ibid., p. 252.
- J.P. Shelton, A. Walsh, The application of atomic absorption spectra to chemical analysis, Proc. XV Congr. Pure Appl. Chem. (Lisbon 1956), IV-50 (1958), 403-409.
- B.J. Russell, J.P. Shelton, A. Walsh, An atomic absorption spectrophotometer and its application to the analysis of solutions, Spectrochim. Acta, 8 (1957), 317-328.
- N.S. Ham, A. Walsh, Microwave-powered Raman sources, Spectrochim. Acta, 12 (1958), 88-93.
- B.J. Russell, A. Walsh, Resonance radiation from a hollow cathode, Spectrochim. Acta, 15 (1959), 883-885.
- G.F. Box, A. Walsh, A simple atomic absorption spectrophotometer, Spectrochim. Acta, 16 (1960), 255-258.
- B.M.Gatehouse, A. Walsh, Analysis of metal samples by atomic absorption spectroscopy, Spectrochim. Acta, 16 (1960), 602-604.
- W.G. Jones, A. Walsh, Hollow-cathode discharges: the construction and characteristics of sealed-off tubes for use as spectroscopic light sources, Spectrochim. Acta, 16 (1960), 249-254.
- A. Walsh, The application of atomic absorption spectra to chemical analysis, Adv. Spectrosc., 2 (1961), 1-22.
- N.S. Ham, A. Walsh, Potassium and rubidium Raman lamps, J. Chem. Phys., 36 (1962), 1096-1097.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption spectroscopy, Proc. Int. Conf. Spectrosc., 10 (1962), 127-142.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption spectroscopy, Rep. Conf. Hydrocarbon Res. Group Inst. Petrol., London (1962), pp. 13-28 (Inst. Petrol., London, 1962).
- C.K. Coogan, J.D. Morrison, A. Walsh, J.K. Wilmshurst, Fourth Australian Spectroscopy Conference, Aust. J. Sci., 26 (1963), 141-145.
- C.K. Coogan, J.D. Morrison, A. Walsh, J.K. Wilmshurst, Spectroscopy in Australia, Nature, 200 (1963), 319-322.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption spectroscopy in Australia, Feigl Anniversary Symposium on Analytical Chemistry, Birmingham, 1962 (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1963) pp. 281-287.
- A. Walsh, Fourth Australian Spectroscopy Conference, Canberra, 1963, Appl. Optics, 3 (1964), 322.
- J.V. Sullivan, A. Walsh, High intensity hollow-cathode lamps, Spectrochim. Acta, 21 (1965), 721-726.
- J.V. Sullivan, A. Walsh, Resonance radiation from atomic vapours, Spectrochim. Acta, 21 (1965), 727-730.
- A. Walsh, Some recent advances in atomic absorption spectroscopy, Proc. 12th Int. Conf. Spectrosc., (1965), pp. 43-65.
- J.A. Bowman, J.V. Sullivan, A. Walsh, Isolation of atomic resonance lines by selective modulation, Spectrochim. Acta, 22 (1966), 205-210.
- J.V. Sullivan, A. Walsh, The application of resonance lamps as monochromators in atomic absorption spectroscopy, Spectrochim. Acta, 22 (1966), 1843-1852.
- A. Walsh, Some recent advances in atomic absorption spectroscopy, Jl. N. Z. Inst. Chem., 30 (1966), 7-21.
- A. Walsh, Some recent advances in atomic absorption spectroscopy, Zh. Prikl. Spektrosk., 4 (1966), 471-480. (In Russian – translation of preceding reference.)
- J.V. Sullivan, A. Walsh, Resonance monochromators for absorption measure-ments in the visible and ultraviolet, Spectrochim. Acta B, 23 (1967), 131-132.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption spectroscopy (Einstein Memorial Lecture, 1967), Aust. Physicist, 4 (1967), 185-189.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption spectroscopy: a foreword, Appl. Opt., 7 (1968), 1259-1260.
- A. Walsh, Simultaneous multi-element analysis by atomic absorption spectroscopy, XIII Colloquium Spectroscopicum Internationale, Ottawa, 1967, pp. 257-268 (1968).
- J.V. Sullivan, A. Walsh, The isolation and detection of atomic resonance lines, Appl. Opt., 7 (1968), 1271-1280.
- P.L. Larkins, R.M. Lowe, J.V. Sullivan, A. Walsh, The use of solar-blind photomultipliers in flame spectroscopy, Spectrochim. Acta B, 24 (1969), 187-190.
- A. Walsh, Physical aspects of atomic absorption, ASTM Spec. Tech. Pub., No. 443 (1969) 3-18.
- P.A. Bennett, J.V. Sullivan, A. Walsh, A simple protein meter, Anal. Biochem., 36 (1970), 123-126.
- A. Walsh, The application of new techniques to simultaneous multi-element analysis, Pure Appl. Chem., 23 (1970), 1-10.
- A. Walsh, Preface to B.V. L'vov, Atomic Absorption Spectrochemical Analysis, (Adam Hilger, London, 1970).
- A. Walsh, Eighth Australian Spectroscopy Conference, Monash University, 16-20 August 1971, Appl. Opt., 11 (1972), 708.
- D.S. Gough, P. Hannaford, A. Walsh, The application of cathodic sputtering to the production of atomic vapours in atomic fluorescence spectroscopy, Spectrochim. Acta B, 28 (1973), 197-210.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption methods for the direct analysis of metals and alloys, (Hasler Award Address, 1972), Appl. Spectrosc., 27 (1973), 335-341.
- A. Walsh, Invention and innovation, Search, 4 (1973), 69-74.
- A. Walsh, Non-dispersive systems in atomic spectroscopy, Pure Appl. Chem., 34 (1973), 145-161.
- A. Walsh, Obituary to Mr J.E. Allan, Search, 4 (1973), 126.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption spectroscopy – stagnant or pregnant?, Anal. Chem., 46 (1974), 689A-708A.
- A. Walsh, Ninth Australian Spectroscopy Conference, Australian National University, 13-17 August 1973, Appl. Optics, 13 (1974), 703.
- A. Walsh, The separated flame as a resonance detector, Analyst, 100 (1975), 764.
- A. Walsh, Spectrochemistry since Kirchhoff and Bunsen. Proc. Roy. Aust. Chem. Inst., 42 (1975), 297-303.
- P.L. Larkins, A. Walsh, Flame-type resonance spectrometers – a new direction in atomic spectroscopy, Proc. Int. Conf. on Heavy Metals in the Environment, Toronto, 27-31 October 1975, 249-259.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption spectroscopy and its applications – old and new, Pure Appl. Chem., 49 (1977), 1621-1628.
- A. Walsh, Atomic spectroscopy – what next?, Atom. Abs. Newsletter, 17 (1978), 97-99.
- A. Walsh, The birth of modern atomic absorption spectroscopy, Chimia, 34 (1980), 427-429.
- A. Walsh, The application of atomic absorption spectrometry to chemical analysis, Matthews Flinders Lecture of the Australian Academy of Science, Hist. Rec. Aust. Sci., 5 (1980), 129-162.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption spectroscopy – some personal recollections and speculations, Spectrochim. Acta B, 35 (1980), 639-642.
- A. Walsh, Atomic absorption and atomic fluorescence methods of elemental analysis: their merits and limitations, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London, A305 (1982), 485-498.
- K. Braun, W. Slavin, A. Walsh, Non-dispersive atomic fluorimeter for metals that form volatile hydrides, Spectrochim. Acta B, 37 (1982), 721-726.
- A. Walsh, Coherent forward scattering and its application to elemental analysis, Anal. Proc., 21 (1984), 54-55.
- P. Hannaford, A. Walsh, Sputtered atoms in absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy, Spectrochim. Acta B, 43 (1988), 1053-1068.
- A. Walsh, The development of atomic absorption methods of elemental analysis 1952-1962, Anal. Chem., 63 (1991), 933A-941A.
- A. Walsh, The development of the atomic absorption spectrophotometer, Spectrochim. Acta B, 54 (1999), 1943-1952; reproduced from a draft of a manuscript written in June 1976.
Notes
Numbers in brackets refer to the bibliography.
Numbers in square brackets refer to the references.
* In 1949 the (Australian) Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) became the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO). In October 1958 the Chemical Physics Section of the CSIRO Division of Industrial Chemistry became the Division of Chemical Physics, with Dr A.L.G. Rees as its foundation chief.
** The receipt date of Walsh's paper (29) is stated as 18 January 1955, which was subsequently amended to 19 November 1954 in an erratum (29). The receipt date of the paper by Alkemande and Milatz was 29 December 1954, and 27 December 1954 for a short Letter to the Editor.
*** Chester Nimitz Jr was Vice-President of the Instrument Division of the Perkin-Elmer Corporation and soon became President and later Chairman of the Board of Perkin-Elmer.
Alan McLeod Sargeson 1930–2008
Professor Alan Sargeson FAA FRS was an inorganic chemist internationally renowned for his contributions to coordination chemistry.
Alan Sargeson was an extraordinarily gifted inorganic chemist who consistently made important and lasting contributions to his discipline. His lifelong interests were in the area of coordination chemistry, especially in the stereochemistry and reactivity of complexes involving the transition element cobalt. Notable discoveries included the elucidation of the mechanisms of substitution reactions of cobalt complexes, and the demonstration that amino acid amides and their esters and phosphate esters incorporated in properly designed metal complexes could achieve the high rates of hydrolysis displayed by enzyme reactions. Perhaps most notable was the discovery of the ready formation of cage complexes where the metal is fully encapsulated. His impact on his field was far-reaching, his achievements were at the highest level and for over thirty years he was among the few who dominated the field.
Download the memoir
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 22(2), 2011. It was written by B. Bosnich.
Alan Kenneth Head 1925–2010
Dr Alan Head AO FAA FRS made wide-ranging contributions to research, including developing the fatigue theory that made safe commercial jet travel possible, designing the dual-mirror concept behind the Parkes telescope, and pioneering computer-simulated dislocation imaging.
Introduction
Alan Head had many scientific interests. He was a mathematical physicist but was so widely read that he could turn his hand to almost anything that had a scientific basis. His contributions ranged from a design for a giant radio telescope to writing a computer program to simulate the diffraction of electrons as they pass through a crystalline specimen containing defects on an atomic scale and to calculate the images produced by these defects; from the elastic properties of engineering materials to the aberrations in aplanatic, non-spherical lens systems; from the causes of fracture in solid state materials to the patented design for a refrigerator that obtains its cooling power by selectively radiating electromagnetic radiation through a ‘window’ in the earth’s atmosphere to outer space; from Galois theory to quantum computers. Perhaps his greatest success was the theory of fatigue in aluminium alloys used in the construction of jet aeroplanes. Not only was he able to establish the micro-mechanisms involved, his analysis was such that the time that the processes would take to produce a complete failure could be estimated. Without this analysis, commercial aviation as we know it today would have been totally unsafe, whereas knowing the effective lifetime of components and replacing them before the end of their lifetime meant that, provided the relevant maintenance was carried out diligently, travel by air could be safe. The project that gave Alan most pleasure was his understanding of Galois theory and his being the first person to apply it to a practical case concerning the elastic anisotropy of crystalline materials. These two examples epitomise the value Alan put on ‘theory’. Theory was only good if it led to a practical, useful result. Alan Head had a brilliant career but his feet were always firmly on the ground. He was modest, quietly spoken and very approachable. He was a friend and mentor to many. There are more than 10 scientific topics (including those mentioned above) described in this memoir and he made significant contributions to all of them.
Narrative
Alan Kenneth Head was the first child of Elsie May (née Burrell) and Rowland Henry Jack Head. Elsie and Jack had grown up together in Surrey Hills (an eastern suburb of Melbourne). After their marriage, they moved to Bairnsdale in Victoria to run the newsagency there. Within a few years they moved back to Melbourne to take over the Toorak newsagency. Alan was born on 10 August 1925. The family lived in residential accommodation above the shop. Two more children, Margaret and Keith were born but then, when Alan was about seven, his father died suddenly. His mother was left to look after three young children (with another, Sybil, on the way) and to carry on running the newsagency. This was the early 1930s and there was a deep depression in Australia as in most parts of the world. To make matters worse, the newspaper companies were reluctant to accept that a woman could run the business. Moreover, the usual protocol for running a newsagency was that next week’s papers had to be paid for in advance. More than once Elsie had to rely on the generosity of friends to help her meet her obligations.
However, they all survived and, indeed, there were some perks and advantages for the children of a newsagency proprietor. For instance, they were allowed two comics a week. Rather than comics, Alan chose Scientific American and Practical Mechanics; possibly a sign of things to come! Also, newsagencies carried a range of other goods for sale and on special occasions, such as birthdays and Christmas, the children could choose toys from the stock in the shop. Alan and Keith each had a collection of Dinky toys acquired in this way. Keith played with his, but Alan kept his in their original boxes and put them on display on a side table. Keith also recalls that Alan was irritatingly unbeatable at Monopoly and other board games: ‘Our excuse was that he was older than we three, but, in truth, we knew that he was simply thinking at a different level to us’.
Keith was about three or four when his father died, but later, probably when Alan had started school, he remembers Alan helping to run the newsagency, doing the ordering and banking and keeping the books. It seems likely that Alan earned money from his mother for doing this because when his youngest sister, Sybil, fell in love with a brown coat that mother could not afford, Alan bought it for her.
Alan’s school education was mainly in church schools, but at first he was sent to the Toorak State School. That was very short-term because he ‘came home with swear words’ and was removed immediately. He then went to Christ Church School in South Yarra. When Alan was about 10 or 11 it was decided to send him to Ballarat Grammar School on the strength of a recommendation that there was a particularly fine housemaster there. Alan won a boarding scholarship, which no doubt eased the financial burden on the family. Keith said ‘So that we didn’t lose touch with Alan, some weekends mother would pack a picnic lunch, bundle us three into the car and go and visit Alan’.
The housemaster was indeed ‘fine’ and liked to play bridge on Saturday afternoons. Alan discovered that pupils who were invited to make up a four also received afternoon tea and scones with jam and cream. So Alan went to the library and learned how to play contract bridge from books. In fact, all through his life, libraries, self-education and books played a major role. Alan was Dux of Ballarat Grammar School in 1940.
Because the education at Ballarat Grammar School only went to ‘Leaving’ level (year 11), Alan had to change schools to do his two ‘honours’ years, which would qualify him to go on to higher education. He won a boarding scholarship to Scotch College in Melbourne and was Dux of Scotch in 1942.
There is a coincidental connection here. The Head family’s great-great-grandparents arrived in Sydney in 1838, fifty years after the First Fleet. They decided to move to the Melbourne area, which had just been settled (illegally) by John Batman and others arriving from Van Diemen’s Land (Tasmania) in 1835. The Heads arrived in the Melbourne region in 1839 and decided to settle on the land on which Scotch College stands today. In 1939 the collective Head family decided to celebrate their centenary by having a large gathering, a party and a big raffle. The prize for the big raffle was a tailored suit. Alan won the raffle, but since it was obvious that at the age of 13 he had no real use for a suit, it was decided that he should be given the very best Malvern Star bicycle instead. Sixty years later, when the Head family held another reunion, Alan donated the money for the raffle.
On the basis of his academic results at Scotch, Alan was awarded a scholarship to Ormond College to study at the University of Melbourne. In his final year at school Alan’s subjects were Mathematics 1, Mathematics 2, Mathematics 3, Mathematics 4, Physics and Chemistry. At university, he embarked on a double course of mathematics and physics. Towards the end of his time at Ormond, Alan met his future wife, Gwen, at dancing classes held at the College. Reports have it that Alan was quite a good dancer and during their ensuing five-year courtship, dancing seems to have been their main social pastime. After the dance, usually on Saturday night, Alan took Gwen home, as a good escort should. But apparently Gwen never knew where he lived. She explained this to me as ‘Alan didn’t talk much’!
Alan obtained his BA in Mathematics in 1945 and his BSc in Physics in 1946. He spent most of 1947 tutoring in mathematics at Trinity, another College of the University of Melbourne. In late 1947 or early 1948 he obtained a position as Research Officer at the CSIR Division of Aeronautics (the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research [CSIR] being the forerunner of CSIRO – the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation).
The Division of Aeronautics had established a large experimental programme on the fatigue of metals and they were gathering data on full-size specimens such as the wings of Mustangs. These were single-seat, long-range fighter aircraft built in large numbers during the Second World War. Alan was recruited to try to assess the data and extract useful information from it. Alan did this in a seminal paper entitled ‘The Growth of Fatigue Cracks’ published in the Philosophical Magazine in 1953 (6). This paper was the first in a book entitled Top Ten Papers 1907–2007 published by the Defence Science and Technology Organisation. Interestingly, the second paper in this book is by D. R. Warren concerning his invention of the flight recorder (black box), first published in 1954. The invention was a success, but the development was not taken up by Australia.
Soon after Alan joined the Division of Aeronautics it was decided that the Division should come under the umbrella of the Commonwealth Department of Supply and it was renamed the Aeronautical Research Laboratories. In the early 1950s the Department of Supply was keen to bring their staff up to date with work going on in other parts of the world. To this end, they were awarding studentships for scientists to go overseas for up to two years. Alan obtained one of these in 1951. On 8 March 1951 he married Gwenneth Nancy Barlow (Gwen) and a month later they left Melbourne for England.
Alan and Gwen spent some time in London while Alan visited UK Government laboratories, some of which offered him a job. But Alan politely declined all offers. Although the studentships were not supposed to be used to further the recipient’s formal education, Alan was keen to be part of the Physics Department at the University of Bristol. This was the place to be in Solid State Defect Physics, because it was at the forefront of the new science concerning dislocations in crystals.
A dislocation is a line defect in a crystal where a plane of atoms in the lattice is incomplete. Dislocations can be moved about inside the crystal by external stresses, and they are necessary for the permanent (plastic) deformation of all crystalline materials. They can multiply if stresses greater than the yield stress are applied and they can tangle, whereupon they become difficult to move and produce the phenomenon known as work hardening. Work hardening can increase the load that the material can support, but it can also produce a higher degree of brittleness, which can lead to failure. It seems that Alan had assimilated this knowledge and recognised that it was crucial to the problem of fatigue.
In 1951 Alan got his wish and enrolled as a PhD student at the H. H. Wills Physics Laboratory at the University of Bristol.
It is interesting that the paper referred to earlier concerning the growth of fatigue cracks (6) contains no reference at all to dislocations. It is a paper based on ordinary elasticity/plasticity theory applied to a material which is elastically and plastically inhomogeneous. The inhomogeneous regions are, of course, the result of varying numbers, different types of dislocation arrays and varying densities of dislocations. As mentioned in the abstract, not only did the paper explain the processes in detail, but it was also capable of predicting the life span of a part or component, so that it could be taken out of service before a catastrophic failure occurred.
The paper was received by Philosophical Magazine on 20 May 1953. This was just 18 days after the first fatal crash of the De Havilland Comet aircraft. Unfortunately two more fatal Comet crashes occurred in 1954. Wreckage of Comet G-ALYY was recovered and examined and it was concluded that the crash was due to metal fatigue initiated at the corners of the rectangular shape of the cabin hatches and windows acting as local stress raisers. Other contributing factors were the punching, rather than the drilling of smooth holes for rivets and the omission of Redux glue (to spread the load between rivets, and therefore reduce the stress-raising effect) in the construction of the fuselage. The Comet was one of the first airliners to use jet engines. Jet engines were more fuel efficient at high altitudes and enabled aeroplanes to fly above most of the weather. But at high altitudes it was necessary to pressurise the cabins for the well-being of the passengers. This pressurisation and depressurisation provided the cyclical stress conditions under which fatigue occurred. It is no exaggeration to say that without Alan’s pioneering work, a safe commercial aviation industry could not have been developed.
One of the main influences of this period on his life in the Physics Department of the University of Bristol were the sessions at morning and afternoon tea when senior scientists discussed and explored their topic freely with each other. Alan adopted this practice with enthusiasm and introduced similar informal discussions in all the places in which he subsequently worked. For instance, Steven Celotto, a PhD student from the University of Queensland who came to our Division to do his research, remembers that the best time was going to morning and afternoon tea with the rest of the group: ‘It was fun and I learned so much. Alan was the best to learn from; he never talked down to me, but he never spoon fed me. He tried to get me to work it out and if I got stuck he would get me moving again. He tailored his explanations to the person. I learned my physics and chemistry not at the University of Queensland, but at the CSIRO coffee table’.
Alan took less than two years to finish his PhD work. His thesis was on two topics, ‘The Interaction of Dislocations and Boundaries’ and ‘The Growth of Fatigue Cracks’. He was back in Australia when he was awarded a PhD in absentia at a ceremony on 7 July 1954.
In 1955 the CSIRO Division of Radio-physics was giving a lot of consideration to the construction of a large radio telescope, of the order of 300 feet in diameter, to be installed somewhere in Australia to view the southern skies. The large dish at Jodrell Bank near Manchester was under construction at the time and it was considered that these telescopes would complement each other. In the early months of 1956, the Chief of Radiophysics, E. G. Bowen, and the assistant chief, J. L. Pawsey, got in touch with Alan to enquire if the ‘new’ stronger aluminium alloys used in aeroplanes would be suitable to construct a large, rigid, steer-able dish. The main problem was that it was likely that the dish would sag under its own weight and thus change shape as it was pointed in different directions and elevations. They wanted a dish that was able to pick up the 21-centimetre hydrogen line and any distortions in the shape of the dish of the order of a centimetre or so would compromise its performance. Alan’s reaction was that it would be better to have a two-component ‘mirror-arrangement’ in which the large dish is set rigidly into the ground and points vertically upwards and a second, much smaller, mirror of a barrel-type shape is sited near the focus of the large dish to collect the reflected radiation. Different areas of the sky could be examined by steering the smaller mirror to point at different regions of the dish. There followed a year or so of meetings and discussions on the pros and cons and several detailed technical reports on the suitability of a steerable dish versus a stationary one. Among Alan’s personal papers there was a very thick file containing correspondence and calculations of likely performance parameters for each of the telescopes. However, in late 1956 it was decided to construct the radio telescope with a steer-able dish and locate it at Parkes in New South Wales. Alan wrote up his novel design and it was published in Nature in 1957 (16). Several telescopes have been constructed to Alan’s design in the former USSR and the USA. Perhaps the best-known radio telescope that is based on Alan’s design is the 305-metre dish at Arecibo in Puerto Rico operated by Cornell University. Alan’s work on the geometrical optics of a two-mirror system for the telescope led to a series of five papers on aplanatic mirror and lens systems (17), (19), (21), (22) and (66).
After Alan’s success in producing a theory of fatigue that was able to predict the safe life of a structure and a busy but largely fruitless year spent detailing his new design for a giant radio telescope, it seems that he considered moving on from the Aeronautical Research Laboratories. Word got around and in early 1957 Walter Boas, Chief of the CSIRO Division of Tribophysics (‘Tribo’) invited him to the Division for a talk. Walter was a researcher of the old school and agreed with the maxim of Sir Ian Clunies Ross, Chairman of CSIRO, that the way to run a research organisation was to appoint top-quality scientists in the relevant field and let them decide the topics to study. The job of the Chief was to ensure that they had sufficient resources to carry out their studies. Alan was pleased to be asked to join Tribo, but not even he knew what path his career might take. He called his appointment ‘an experiment’. On a later occasion, in 1980, when Alan was moving from the Division of Materials Science (the old Tribophysics re-named) he wrote in reply to an invitation from Lew Chadderton, Chief of Chemical Physics to join his Division: ‘What would I be doing? The same sort of things I have been doing, whatever that means. I always have been a bit difficult to fit into grand organisational charts, programs and subprograms etc. I suppose because I tend to “redeploy” myself at unpredictable times and in unexpected directions. For the last few years I have been classed as an “overhead”, which at least provided some general mirth’.
Alan commenced duty at Tribophysics on 8 July 1957. His period at the University of Bristol had equipped him with a knowledge of dislocations to last him for the rest of his career. With a few exceptions, the science of single dislocations and simple interactions of two or three dislocations was either known or calculable. But in the case of ductile metals it was obvious from experiment that extremely large numbers of dislocations are generated and moved by the external applied stresses, and interact not only with each other in huge crowds and entanglements but also with the internal crystal boundaries. So further work on dislocations consisted of examining the stability of arrays and their mobility as a group under applied stresses. Eventually this led to what could be termed continuum theories of dislocations. For instance, from 1972 to 1973 Alan produced six papers (55), (56), (57), (58), (59) and (60) on ‘Dislocation Group Dynamics’. (Two of these (58) and (59) were co-authored by W. W. Wood.) Towards the end of his career he, with colleagues from the Mathematical Institute at the University of Oxford, produced another series of papers, this time on continuum modelling of dislocations and associated plasticity, (79), (82), (83) and (85).
However, his next ‘off-track’ activity occurred in 1959, after Alan and Gwen had taken a holiday in Queensland. They were travelling by car on a hot day in the region of the Glasshouse Mountains. They had some tomatoes in the boot that were getting hotter and riper by the minute. Thoughts turned to how to keep them cool. Here the story becomes unclear, but what is certain is that Alan took the problem of how to keep things cool in the Outback seriously. He came up with a design for a refrigerator that required no power. Described like that, it sounds as if he had invented a device for perpetual motion (or at least perpetual cooling) and this led to difficulties when he lodged the patent (28). The device consists of a sheet of a good thermal conductor (for example, aluminium) coated with a substance that selectively radiates and absorbs electromagnetic radiation at a wavelength of about 10 microns. It so happens that, providing there are no clouds in the sky, there is a ‘window’ in the atmosphere between the absorption band for carbon dioxide on one side and an absorption band for water vapour on the other. This window lies between 8 and 13 microns, so that if a radiator emits radiation at 10 microns it escapes to outer space, the radiator loses heat and cools down. Thus the design of the refrigerator consists of a lid made of a good thermal conductor coated with a selective emitter. This is fitted to an insulated box containing, for example, the tomatoes. The device is placed so that it can see clear sky, but it has to be shaded from direct sunlight. This is because the power of sunlight falling on the surface of the earth when there is a cloudless sky is approximately 1,000 watts/m2 compared to the power of the refrigerator which is about 100 watts/m2. Thus the heating power is 10 times greater than the cooling power. This is a difficult hurdle to overcome without high-quality insulation. The lack of cooling power may be one reason why this invention has not been taken up commercially. Another way of enhancing the cooling performance could be to find a selective coating material for the conductor that has a much narrower band of radiation, so that it fits through the window at 8 to 13 microns without any being absorbed at the edges. The refrigerator works day and night as long as the skies are clear.
In Australia, peak loads for electricity occur in the summer because of the widespread use of air conditioning. If such a device were perfected and fitted to every house and building in Australia it would make an enormous difference to the amount of fuel used to produce electricity and would reduce the production of carbon dioxide dramatically.
In 1962 Alan received the degree of Doctor of Science from the University of Melbourne for a thesis on three topics – Fatigue of Metals; Dislocation Theory; and Geometrical Optics of Aspherical Systems.
Also in that year Alan accepted an invitation to Brown University in Rhode Island to work with John Gilman and his group for a year. At the time of Gwen and Alan’s visit to Rhode Island, the Americas Cup Challenge yacht races between Weatherly (USA) and Gretel (Australia) were being staged. By a circuitous route, involving a cocktail party given by the Australian Ambassador and an American friend with connections with the US Navy, Gwen and Alan were invited to watch one of the races at close range from a US destroyer. This happened to be the second race of the series, in which Gretel beat Weatherly. Unfortunately from an Australian point of view, Weatherly won the series by four races to one.
On his return from Rhode Island, Alan became interested in anisotropic elasticity. It is a difficult concept to explain, but dislocations, which are the individual elements of plasticity (that is, permanent deformation), are described mathematically by linear elasticity (Hooke’s Law; stress is proportional to strain), implying that if a stress is applied and then removed the strain returns to zero. Usually the type of elasticity used to make these calculations was isotropic; that is, the material has the same elastic properties in all directions. But crystals are generally anisotropic elastically and Alan began to apply the theory of anisotropic elasticity to dislocations and dislocation groups.
Because a dislocation is a defect in the lattice of a crystal, the crystal is not in its state of minimum energy as there is an amount of energy per unit length associated with the dislocation. In order to minimise this as much as possible, dislocations usually run straight from surface to surface or from pinning point to pinning point. Alan found that using anisotropic elasticity, the energy per unit length could be very different – so much so that it would be quite possible for a segment of the dislocation pinned at each end to assume an angular elbow shape so that, although it had increased its length, the two new directions it was lying in were low energy directions and the overall energy of the dislocation was decreased. Alan asked a colleague, Mike Loretto, to use the transmission electron microscope to look for dislocations in a piece of lightly deformed beta brass. Beta brass is quite anisotropic elastically and Alan had calculated the angles of the bends for different types of dislocations lying on different slip planes and different Burgers vectors (37). Mike found the bent dislocations but was unable to determine their Burgers vector using the usual invisibility criteria. In fact, these criteria rely on isotropic elasticity and arise from the physical condition that, for pure screw and pure edge dislocations, some diffracting planes remain flat and in these cases, therefore, the diffraction of the electrons is as if from a perfect crystal and there is no image. For elastically anisotropic crystals, in general (except for some special cases of symmetry) no plane remains flat and one obtains an image of the dislocation for all diffracting conditions. This was the phenomenon that Mike had been observing.
(Biographer’s note: Dislocations are line defects in a crystal that can be present because of ‘mistakes’ in the packing of atoms as the crystal grows or can be formed when the crystal is deformed plastically. The Burgers vector of a dislocation is determined by comparing a clockwise circuit taken around the dislocation line in the imperfect crystal with a similar circuit in a perfect crystal. The lack of closure of the circuit in the good crystal (measured from finish to start) is the Burgers vector. The magnitude of the Burgers vector, its direction in the crystal and the direction of the dislocation line in the crystal determine the detailed displacements of the atoms in the vicinity of the dislocation. These displacements can be detected and imaged in the transmission electron microscope by electrons diffracting through the crystal and forming an image on the microscope screen (or on film).)
Alan decided that the thing to do was to simulate the two-beam operation of the electron microscope in a computer and to calculate the images of the dislocations corresponding to the different diffraction conditions used experimentally. Computation of images was not new. Peter Hirsch’s group at the University of Cambridge had been doing it for several years. They produced graphs of intensity of the image across the dislocation line. But Alan realised that because the differential equations to be integrated were a pair of first-order linear differential equations, the numerical integration of these could be speeded up considerably. At first this produced some consternation because so much information was produced that it became difficult to assimilate. So it was decided to transform each calculated intensity into a pixel and form a half-tone image that could be directly compared with the actual electron micrograph image. Using this comparison, Burgers vectors were determined and it was found that the dislocation angles were as predicted by Alan’s theory. The immediate result of this work was the production of four papers (37), (40), (41) and (42). The long-term consequence was the production of a monograph that explained the technique of image matching in detail and provided the computer program (61).
In the space of about eight months, starting with an odd prediction based on anisotropic elasticity, Alan had created a new field of defect identification using image matching. In the next few years it was taken up by other groups around the world as a standard method of defect identification.
In 1966 Australia changed to decimal currency and by 1968 the Reserve Bank was becoming increasingly aware of large-scale counterfeiting of $10 notes. The Governor of the Reserve Bank, Dr H. C. ‘Nugget’ Coombs, convened a meeting on 9 April 1968 to which seven wise men of science were invited. Alan was one of them. There were several follow-up meetings, but after that only one of the group, Sefton Hamann, Chief of the CSIRO Division of Applied Chemistry, stayed with the project to the end. The result was the introduction of plastic ‘paper’ to print the notes on (suggested by polymer scientist David Solomon), the inclusion of a clear window and an upgrading of the apparently chaotic line markings on the notes.
Also in 1968 Alan developed an interest in earthquakes. Many earthquakes demonstrate a pattern of behaviour reminiscent of dislocation movement, in which many small movements occur along the slip line, building up the stress so that eventually this is relieved by the fracture of the rock, producing a very large relative movement on opposite sides of the fault line. Alan chose to study the San Andreas Fault in California because this had by far the largest amount of instrumentation on it and the records were detailed and covered a long period of time. He found it was possible in some cases and at some times to describe the movements as analogous to dislocations. But there were other times when the behaviour seemed to be random and chaotic. I believe that Alan had hoped that he could analyse the data in the same way as he had done for fatigue of metals and be able to predict when failure would occur. Bearing in mind that any prediction had to be given in time to evacuate the population, yet could not be too far into the future so that the people would be away from home for weeks or months, this seems to have been a very ambitious aim. After a year or two, he shelved the idea and went on to other things.
Throughout his career, Alan liked to promote the myth that all he needed to do his work was a pile of paper and some 2B pencils. In fact he embraced computers from their first inception. During 1956 when the Giant Telescope design and its performance parameters were being determined, Australia’s first – and the world’s fourth – stored-memory electronic computer CSIRAC (Council for Scientific and Industrial Research Automatic Computer), was commissioned. It was about 1,000 times faster than the best mechanical calculators. It was built at the CSIRO Division of Radiophysics by a team led by Maston Beard and Trevor Pearcey. Trevor Pearcey had improved the analysis of the performance parameters for the design of Alan’s telescope by extending Alan’s geometric optical calculations to take into account diffraction effects as well. Initially CSIRAC was located in Sydney, but in the late 1950s it was moved to the University of Melbourne and Alan started using it for his work on anisotropy elasticity.
In the early 1960s, CSIRO set up a computing network with one large machine based in Canberra and smaller satellite machines in Adelaide, Melbourne and Sydney. This phase lasted for about 10 years until ‘supercomputers’ began to appear and the rest of us had our very own, very powerful personal computers. Alan now became interested, not so much in number crunching, but in using symbolic languages (such as MuMATH and LISP) to do algebra, to solve equations and even to delve into fairly exotic manipulations using Lie Groups, Lie Algebras and Galois Theory. Both Lie and Galois are classified as abstract algebras. Lie Groups were initially introduced as a tool to solve or simplify ordinary differential equations or partial differential equations or combinations of the two. The model for this seems to have been Galois Theory. Originally, Galois used permutation groups to describe how the various roots of a given polynomial equation are related to each other. Galois theory was originally motivated by the question, ‘Why is there no formula for the roots of a fifth (or higher) degree polynomial equation in terms of the coefficients of the polynomial, using only the usual algebraic operators (addition, subtraction, multiplication and division) and application of radicals (square roots, cube roots etc.)?’ Apparently, Galois Theory not only provides a beautiful answer to this question, it also explains in detail why, on the other hand, it is possible to solve equations of degree four or lower in the above manner. ‘Beautiful’ it may be, but it has also been described as ‘refined and inaccessible’ by Professor J. R. Ockendon.
Nevertheless, Alan needed it to see if the sextic equation that is central to the theory of anisotropic elasticity has any rational roots, either in general or for specific orientations in the crystal. In pursuing this goal, he found that 2B pencils let him down. The process was just too long and intricate. So he wrote computer programs suitable for personal computers for the manipulation of both Lie and Galois algebras so that he could obtain answers in a shorter time (67), (69), (77), (78), (81), (84) and (86).
Among Alan’s files, I found some correspondence, dated August 1985, between Professor H. M. Edwards and Alan concerning a book that Edwards had recently published. The first exchange of letters goes thus:
Alan to Professor Edwards:
Congratulations! I have just come across your book on Galois Theory. It is beautiful and my regret is that you did not write it ten years ago. At that stage I was silly enough to actually want to apply Galois theory to a real physical problem, not knowing anything about it except that it existed. It took me several years of perplexity before I realised that no one actually applied it but only admired its beauty. Books on the subject seem to be written with someone else other than me in mind and it wasn’t until I got back to the original Galois that I started to see the light …
Reply form Professor Edwards to Alan:
Thank you for your kind letter and for the reprints. It looks to me like you didn’t need me at all. You seem to have mastered Galois theory by reading Galois on your own. A great achievement.
But perhaps I need you. There is one point in Galois’s memoir that I have not succeeded in understanding. It is at the bottom of p. 112 in the translation in my book where it describes ‘the method one must use in practice’ to determine whether a given equation is solvable by radicals …
(Biographer’s note: It seems that not only was Alan working from the original French, but also he was probably the first person to use Galois Theory to solve a practical problem. As far as I could understand the correspondence, the two never did quite agree on the ‘point on p. 112’.)
Alan developed a strong interest in the emerging, but extremely popular, concept of quantum computers. With conventional silicon chips, the memory elements are becoming smaller and smaller and are being packed closer and closer together until ultimately they will be limited by the size of the atoms themselves. Quantum computers may present a potential solution for this problem. They do involve atoms, but the concept is more to do with the quantum states of the atom (or ion) and the zeros and ones of today’s technology (bits) would be replaced by different quantum states of the atom (qubits) and mixtures of these quantum states. It would be a requirement that the atoms stay in their given state or mixture of states for a period of time and are not affected by outside disturbances. Work by Peter Hannaford and Tim Bastow was going on in our laboratory that was relevant to the possible development of a quantum computer. Peter Hannaford attended a conference in June 1995 at which there was a talk about quantum computing and on his return to the laboratory he asked Alan to give a talk on the subject. The talk was well attended – standing room only. Alan was invited to repeat the talk at La Trobe University and at the University of Melbourne. Alan encouraged Peter Hannaford to approach the Defence Science and Technology Organisation (DSTO) at Salisbury near Adelaide about funding a joint project to develop quantum computing. Nothing came of this; again, Alan was too far ahead of his time.
Throughout his career, Alan’s emphasis was always on research. On many occasions this was achieved alone but he was also keen to collaborate. No matter how esoteric his research may have appeared to others, for him it always had to have a useful result. He spent periods abroad collaborating with people who had (at that specific time) similar interests to his own. He spent a year at Brown University working with John Gilman; six months in 1971 at the University of Florida with John Hren’s group; a year at the Department of Materials Science at Oxford University in 1968 with Peter Hirsch’s group. Later he had several, almost yearly visits to the Mathematical Institute at Oxford University to collaborate with John Ockendon and his colleagues.
It was during one of his visits to the Mathematical Institute that Alan observed in action a scheme whereby people from industry could bring problems along to be considered, and hopefully have them taken on and solved, by a panel of mathematicians. The scheme was MISG, which stands for Mathematics in Industry Study Group. Alan was so impressed that he imported the idea to Australia and pulled a few strings to get it going. Initially it was organised by CSIRO’s Division of Mathematics and Statistics. It is still going, now under the wing of the Australia and New Zealand Institute of Applied Mathematics, and recently had its 26th birthday. Noel Barton, who was heavily involved with MISG in Australia, including being the director for seven years, recalls that ‘Alan was an influential participant. He had deep knowledge in areas where many of the mathematical participants were weak, especially in chemistry and physics and was therefore useful on topics with origins in chemical engineering. These included development of new mathematical models for phenomena involving chemistry coupled with aspects such as coating, droplets, bubbles and phase change. Alan had a dry and easy-going style. Allied with his obvious intelligence and special knowledge, his style enabled him to work well in the group dynamics required in the MISG. He was a valuable contributor on numerous occasions and we were always pleased to have him as a delegate’.
Alan was offered Chairs at overseas universities but always turned them down. The administration involved would interfere with his research and working in Australia was far enough away not to be interrupted by too many visitors. But there were several instances when he did take on an administrative role. When Walter Boas retired, Alan was appointed Acting Chief of Tribophysics until a new Chief was found. He was also appointed interim Chief when the Division of Materials Science joined the Division of Chemical Physics and was renamed the Division of Materials Science and Technology. He was invited to become the founding Director of the Institute of Physical Sciences when CSIRO was grouping divisions into an Institute structure. He declined the offer. He sat on review boards for the Division of Radiophysics and for the Division of Mathematics and Statistics. He served for many years on the Australian Aeronautical Research Committee. In 1968 Alan was one of the founding members of the International Congress on Fracture. In the same year he became one of the editors of the International Journal of Fracture and he only resigned when he retired in 1990. He was one of the organizers of a meeting held on 8–9 October 1996 under the auspices of the Royal Society of London on ‘Vortices, Dislocations and Line Singularities in Partial Differential Equations’. The meeting is recorded in Phil. Trans. of the Roy. Soc. Lond., 355, 1945–2072 (Number 1731).
Alan was awarded several honours during his career. He was awarded the Syme Medal by the University of Melbourne in 1969 for the best original research in physics produced in Australia in the previous two years. He was elected to the Australian Academy of Science in 1971 and to the Royal Society of London in 1988. He was appointed an Officer of the Order of Australia in 1991 and was awarded the John Shearer Medal in 1976 for a paper entitled ‘Earthquakes and Dislocations’ as the best paper for that year presented to the Australian Mineral Foundation. He received a Centenary Medal in 2003 (instigated in 2001 to mark the centenary of Federation in Australia) from the Australian Government for his service to research and science.
Alan retired in 1990 from CSIRO at the mandatory age of 65, but was given an Honorary Research Fellowship so that he could stay in the laboratory and do what he did best: encourage, mentor, advise and interact generally with the other researchers. In March 2001 he was made an Adjunct Professor at Swinburne University of Technology for three years.
Alan was a quiet man, generally of few words. He was an avid reader. His evening routine was to go home, have dinner, put on some favourite classical music and read a book; usually he read one book a night. All his books were borrowed from libraries and when he ran out of books of interest at one library he went to another library in another suburb. I believe he changed libraries four times. As Gwen told me several times, ‘He didn’t talk much’.
Despite all this success he kept his feet on the ground. He was a quietly spoken, unassuming, approachable man. I never saw him get angry. When he was annoyed, he simply opted out of the conversation. There was one occasion, however, when he did lose his temper. In 2005 the laboratory was being extensively rebuilt and refurbished. As a result of this, Alan lost his office of which he had been the sole occupant since 1980 and in which he had done all his thinking. He was offered a desk in a communal office for about eight people as a replacement. He reportedly became very angry, left the building immediately and never went back. The circumstances surrounding the office change are not clear, but I think that Alan believed he would be unable to work in such surroundings. He may also have considered that he was being hounded out and was considered by the management to be of no further use. He became very with-drawn. Apart from his work, his interactions with others in the laboratory and his reading, he had few other interests so he stayed at home. Occasionally he did have some ex-colleagues call at his home to discuss their work and obtain advice.
Alan died in a nursing home in Melbourne on 9 January 2010 from cardiopulmonary degeneration. Since his passing, messages of appreciation have been arriving from all over the scientific world. Needless to say, all these messages were glowing in their assessment of Alan, both as a scientist of extraordinary ability and as a friend and colleague who was always willing to talk to and help others without any sign of pomposity or pretentiousness.
Alan is survived by his wife, Gwen, and his siblings, Margaret Boston, Keith Head and Sybil Kent. Alan and Gwen had no children.
About this memoir
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 21(2), 2010. It was written by Peter Humble.
Acknowledgements
It has been an honour, a privilege and a very pleasing experience to write about the life and career of Alan Head, my friend and colleague of some forty years.
During the process I drew on many sources and received help from many people. I should like to thank the following for their time and effort: Tim Bastow, Rob Birtles, Steve Celotto, Leo Clarebrough, Richard Donelson, Chris Forwood, Peter Hannaford, Gwen Head, Keith Head, Anita Hill, Cassandra Humble, Tien Kieu, Dimitria Kyriacopoulos, Julie McInerny, Allan Morton, Hilary Ockendon, John Ockendon, Ian Polmear, Rosanne Walker and Geoff West.
Bibliography
- Head, A. K., ‘Statistical Properties of Fatigue Data on 24ST’, A. S. T. M. Bull., 169 (1950),51.
- Wood, W. A. and Head, A. K., ‘Some New Observations on the Mechanism of Fatigue in Metals’, J. Inst. Metals, 79 (1951), 89–102.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Interaction of Dislocations and Boundaries’, Phil. Mag., 44 (1953),92–94.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Mechanism of Fatigue in Metals’, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 1 (1953), 134–141.
- Bullen, F. P., Head, A. K. and Wood, W. A., ‘Structural Changes during the Fatigue of Metals’, Proc. Roy. Soc., A, 216 (1953), 332–343.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Growth of Fatigue Cracks’, Phil. Mag., 44 (1953), 925–938.
- Head, A. K., ‘Edge Dislocations in Inhomogeneous Media’, Proc. Phys. Soc., B, 66 (1953),793–801.
- Head, A. K. and Louat, N. P., ‘The Distribution of Dislocations in Linear Arrays’, Aust. J. Phys., 8 (1954), 1–7.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Growth of Fatigue Cracks’, A. R. L. Metals Report, 5 (1954).
- Clarebrough, L. M., Hargreaves, M. E., Head, A. K. and West, G.W., ‘Energy Stored During the Fatigue of Copper’, J. Metals, 7 (1955),99–100.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Effect of Frequency on the Fatigue of Metals’, J. Phys. Soc Jap., 11 (1956),468–469.
- Head, A. K. and Hooke, F. H., ‘Fatigue of Metals under Random Loads’, Nature, 177 (1956),1176–1177.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Propagation of Fatigue Cracks’, J. Appl. Mech., 23 (1956), 407–410.
- Head, A. K. and Hooke, F. H., ‘Random Noise Fatigue Testing’, Int. Cong. Fatigue of Metals(1956), Session 3, Paper 9, 3–5.
- Head, A. K., ‘Fatigue’, J. Aust. Inst. Metals, 1(1956), 148–154.
- Head, A. K., ‘A New Form for a Giant Radio Telescope’, Nature, 179 (1957), 692–693.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Two Mirror Aplanat’, Proc. Phys. Soc. B, 70 (1957), 945–949.
- Clarebrough, L. M., Hargreaves, M. E., West, G. W. and Head, A. K., ‘The Energy Stored in Fatigued Materials’, Proc. Roy. Soc. A, 242(1957), 160–166.
- Head, A. K., ‘A Class of Aplanatic Optical Systems’, Proc. Phys. Soc., 71 (1958),546–551.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Position of Dislocations in Arrays’, Phil. Mag., 4 (1959), 295–302.
- Head, A. K., ‘Aplanatic Lenses’, Proc. Phys. Soc., 74 (1959), 731–736.
- Head, A. K., ‘Aplanatic Lenses of High Refractive Index’, J. Op. Soc. Am., 50 (1960), 922.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Interaction of Dislocations with Boundaries and Surface Films’, Aust. J. Phys. 13 (1960), 278–283.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Stress Fields Around Some Dislocation Arrays’, Aust. J. Phys., 13 (1960),613–615.
- Mitchell, L. H. and Head, A. K., ‘The Buckling of a Dislocated Plate’, J. Mech. Phys. Solids, 9(1961), 131–139.
- Clarebrough, L. M., Hargreaves, M. E., Head, A. K. and Loretto, M. H., ‘Stored Energy and Flow Stress in Deformed Metals’, Phil. Mag., 6 (1961), 819–822.
- Head, A. K. and Thomson, P. F., ‘On the Method of Eshelby, Frank, and Nabarro for Calculating the Equilibrium Positions of Dislocations’, Phil. Mag., 7 (1962), 439–449.
- Head, A. K., ‘Method and Means for Producing Refrigeration by Selective Radiation’, lodged9/2/1959; issued 1962. U.S. Patent 3,043,112, Australian Patent 239364 issued 1962.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Energy of a Screw Dislocation in a Cubic Crystal’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 5 (1964), 51–54.
- Head, A. K., ‘The [111] Dislocation in a Cubic Crystal’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 6 (1964), 461–465.
- Chen, H. S., Gilman, J. J. and Head, A. K., ‘Equilibrium of Extended Dislocations within Edge Dislocation Dipoles’, Phil. Mag., 10 (1964), 35–42.
- Chen, H. S., Gilman, J. J. and Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Multipoles and their role in Strain Hardening’, J. Appl. Phys., 35 (1964), 2502–2514.
- Armstrong, R. W. and Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Queuing and Fracture in an Elastically Anisotropic Medium’, Acta Met., 13 (1965), 759–764.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Dislocation Image Force in Cubic Polycrystals’, Phys. Stat. Sol. (1964), 481–484.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Equilibrium and Stability of Dislocations in a Non-Uniform Stress Field’, International Conference on Electron Diffraction and the Nature of Defects in Crystals, Melbourne, 1965.Vol. 2: The Nature of Defects in Crystals (Canberra: Australian Academy of Science, 1965).
- Atkinson, C. and Head, A. K., ‘The Influence of Elastic Anisotropy on the Propagation of Fracture’, Int. J. Frac. Mech., 2 (1966), 489–505.
- Head, A. K., ‘Unstable Dislocations in Anisotropic Crystals’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 19(1967), 185–192.
- Humble, P., Segall, R. L. and Head, A. K., With an Appendix by Gottlieb, H. P.W., ‘The Energy of Dissociated Triangular Frank Loops in F. C.C. Metals’, Phil. Mag., 15 (1967), 281–296.
- Head, A. K., ‘Abnormal Damping by Unstable Dislocations in Anisotropic Crystals’, Phys. Rev. Lets., 18 (1967), 484–485.
- Head, A. K., Loretto, M. H. and Humble, P., ‘The Influence of Large Elastic Anisotropy on the Determination of Burgers Vectors of Dislocations in Beta-Brass’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 20 (1967), 505–519.
- Head, A. K., Loretto, M. H. and Humble, P., ‘The Identification of Burgers Vectors and Unstable Directions of Dislocations in Beta-Brass’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 20 (1967), 521–536.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Computer Generation of Electron Microscope Pictures of Dislocations’, Aust. J. Phys., 20 (1967), 557–566.
- Head, A. K., ‘HALFTONE’, Technical Note 21, CSIRO Computing Section (1967).
- Baker, B. G. and Head, A. K., ‘Computed Adsorption on Heterogeneous Surfaces’, Trans. Farad. Soc., 64 (1968), 485.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Reconstruction of Displacement Fields of Defects in Crystals from Electron Micrographs, I: Analytic Fields’, Aust. J. Phys., 22 (1969), 43–50.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Reconstruction of Displacement Fields of Defects in Crystals from Electron Micrographs, II: Discontinuous Fields and Many Beams’, Aust. J. Phys., 22 (1969),345–350.
- Clarebrough, L. M. and Head. A. K., ‘Unstable Directions of Shockley Partial Dislocations’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 33 (1969), 431–434.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Outer Fringe of a Stacking Fault’, Aust. J. Phys., 22 (1969), 569–571.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Invisibility of Dislocations’, in Physics and Strength and Plasticity, Ed. A. S. Argon (Cambridge, Mass.: M.I.T. Press,1969), 65–73.
- Morton, A. J. and Head, A. K., ‘The Elastic Anisotropy of CuZn as Determined by an Electron Microscopy Study of Unstable Dislocations’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 37 (1970), 317–324.
- Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Energies in Cubic Solids with C12=−C44’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 38 (1970), K119–K122.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Recursive Evaluation of Functions’, Decuscope, 9, No. 3 (1970), 4.
- Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Theories of the Plastic Properties of Metals and the Transition to Continuum Mechanics’, in Inelastic Behaviour of Solids, Eds M. F. Kanninen, W. F. Adler, A. R. Rosenfield and R. I. Joffe (New York: McGraw Hill, 1970), 45.
- Head, A. K., ‘Discrete Dislocations in Continuum Elasticity’, in Fundamental Aspects of Dislocation Theory, Eds J. A. Simmonds, R. DeWit and R. Bullough (Washington: National Bureau of Standards, 1970)(National Bureau of Standards Publication,317), Vol. 1, 5.
- Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Group Dynamics, I:Similarity Solutions of the n-body Problem’, Phil. Mag., 26 (1972), 43–53.
- Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Group Dynamics, II: General Solutions of the n-body Problem’, Phil. Mag., 26 (1972), 55–63.
- Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Group Dynamics III: Similarity Solutions of the Continuum Approximation’, Phil. Mag., 26 (1972), 65–72.
- Head, A. K. and Wood, W. W., ‘Dislocation Group Dynamics, IV: General Solutions of the Continuum Approximation’, Phil. Mag., 27(1973) 505.
- Head, A. K. and Wood, W. W., ‘Dislocation Group Dynamics, V: Equilibrium Revisited’, Phil. Mag., 27 (1973), 519–530.
- Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Group Dynamics, VI: The Release of a Pile-up’, Phil. Mag., 27(1973), 531–539.
- Head, A. K., Humble, P., Clarebrough, L. M., Morton, A. J. and Forwood, C. T., Computed Electron Micrographs and Defect Identification (Amsterdam: North–Holland Publishing, 1973), pp. 400.
- Wood, W.W. and Head, A. K., ‘The Motion of Dislocations’, Proc. Roy. Soc., 336A (1974),191–209.
- Head, A. K. and Sanders, J. W., ‘The Uniqueness of Electron Micrographs of Crystal Defects’, in Eighth International Congress on Electron Microscopy, Canberra, 1974, vol. 1 (Australian Academy of Science, 1974), p. 302.
- Clarebrough, L. M. and Head, A. K., ‘On the Width of Stacking Faults’, Phil. Mag., 33 (1976), 557.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Identification of Crystal Defects by Computer Simulated Electron Micrographs’, in Proceedings of the 1976International Conference on Computer Simulation for Materials Applications, Eds R. J. Arsenault, J. R. Beeler and J. A. Simmonds, Nuclear Metallurgy, 20 (1976), 1179–1183.
- Head, A. K., ‘Aplanatic Mirror Pairs’, Applied Optics, 15 (1976), 2621.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Galois Insolvability of the Sextic Equation in Anisotropic Elasticity’, J. Elasticity, 9 (1979), 9–20.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Elastic Anisotropy of Metals’, in Physics of Materials: a Festschrift for Dr Walter Boas on the Occasion of his 75thBirthday, 10 February 1979, Eds D. W. Borland, L. M. Clarebrough and A. J. W. Moore (Melbourne: CSIRO, 1979), pp. 105–110.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Monodromic Galois Groups of the Sextic Equation of Anisotropic Elasticity’, J. Elasticity, 9 (1979), 321–324.
- Head, A. K., ‘Multiplication modulo n’, BIT, 20 (1980), 115–116.
- Head, A. K., ‘Table Errata 568’, Mathematics of Computation, 34 (1980), 331.
- Head, A. K., ‘Why Materials Behave as they do’, in Materials for the Future, Ed. P. M. Kelly (Canberra: Aust. Acad. Science, 1981), pp. 1–8.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Explicit Solution of the Howie – Whelan Differential Equations of Electron Microscopy’, Phil. Mag. 44 (1981), 827–833.
- Head, A. K., ‘Partial Fractions and other Goodies’, The Softwarehouse Newsletter, 9 (1983), 7–10.
- Wood, W. W. and Head, A. K., ‘Dislocation Pile-ups and Stress Intensity Factors’, Q. J. Mech. Appl. Math., 37 (1984), 161–178.
- Head, A. K., ‘Polynomial Addition Speedup’, The Softwarehouse Newsletter, 13 (1985), 6–8.
- Head, A. K., ‘The Sextic Polynomial of Crystal Elasticity’, Phys. Stat. Sol., 132 (1985),117–123.
- Hurley, A. C. and Head, A. K., ‘Explicit Galois Resolvents for Sextic Equations’, Int. J. Quantum Chem., 31 (1987), 345–359.
- Head, A. K., Howison, S. D., Ockendon, J. R., Titchner, J. B. and Wilmott, P., ‘Continuum Model for Two-Dimensional Dislocation Distributions’, Phil. Mag., 55 (1987), 617–629.
- Clarebrough, L. M. and Head, A. K., ‘Walter Boas, 1904–1982’, Historical Records of Australian Science, 6 (1987), 507–517.
- Head, A. K., ‘Explicit Galoisian Solutions in Anisotropic Elasticity’, Euro. J. Appl. Math., 2(1991), 191–197.
- Head, A. K., Howison, S. D., Ockendon, J. R., and Tighe, S. P., ‘Mathematical Modelling of Dislocation Plasticity’, Festschrift in Honour of Jens Lothe on his Sixtieth Birthday, 25th November 1991, pp. 317–321.
- Head, A. K., Howison, S. D., Ockendon, J. R. and Tighe, S. P., ‘Mathematical Modelling of Dislocation Plasticity’, Physica Scripta, T44 (1992), 135–136.
- Head, A. K., ‘LIE, a PC Program for Lie Analysis of Differential Equations’, Computer Physics Communications, 77 (1993), 241–248.
- Head, A. K., Howison, S. D., Ockendon, J. R. and Tighe, S. P., ‘An Equilibrium Theory of Dislocation Continua’, S. I. A. M. Review, 35 (1993), 580–609.
- Head, A. K., ‘LIE, a PC Program for Lie Analysis of Differential Equations’, Computer Physics Communications, 96 (1996), 311–313.
- Sherring, J., Head, A. K. and Prince, G. E., ‘Dimsym, and LIE; Symmetry Determination Packages’, Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 25 (1997), 153–164.
- Chapman, S. J., Elliott, C. M., Head, A. K., Howison, S. D., Leslie, F. M. and Ockendon, J. R., ‘Vortices, Dislocations and Line Singularities in Partial Differential Equations’, Discussion Held 8th and 9th October 1996, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc., A355 (1997), 1947.
- Head, A. K., ‘Some Echoes of CSIRAC: Using CSIRAC for Scientific Computing’, in The Last of the First: CSIRAC, Australia’s First Computer, Eds D. McCann and P. Thorne (Melbourne: U. Melbourne, 2000), p. 176.