2007 awardees
Career awards
Matthew Flinders Medal and Lecture
Professor Peter Hall
Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Melbourne
Peter Hall is a leading international researcher in theoretical and applied statistics and probability theory. He has made substantial contributions to nonparametric statistics over a 25-year period. Peter has had a massive influence on the development and assessment of the bootstrap method. He has made very important contributions to smoothing methods in statistics, and has introduced practical smoothing parameter-selection methods in a variety of settings. He also developed novel theoretical arguments to explain why some approaches are more variable, or more biased, than others. Peter’s research on fractal-based statistical methods for quantifying surface roughness has also been groundbreaking.
Craig Medal
Professor Hans Freeman
Professor Emeritus, School of Molecular and Microbial Biosciences and School of Chemistry, University of Sydney
Hans Freeman has made distinguished contributions to science through the study of the crystal structures of biological coordination compounds including metal-peptide complexes and metalloproteins. He introduced the use of computers for crystallographic calculations to Australia, and his laboratory was the first in the southern hemisphere to determine the crystal structure of a protein, plastocyanin. He has been a selfless advocate for macromolecular crystallography; a recent example is his membership of the Policy and Review Board of the Australian Synchrotron Research Program. He was the Foundation President of the Society of Crystallographers in Australia.
Hannan Medal in Statistical Science
Emeritus Professor Eugene Seneta
Professor Emeritus, School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Sydney
Eugene Seneta has done much seminal work in probability and statistics in connection with branching processes, the history of probability and statistics, and in such diverse areas as slowly varying functions, Bonferroni type bounds on probabilities of unions of sets, on modelling of the price of a risky asset, and in the scaling of Higher School Certificate marks. The implications of some of his research are considerable. The algorithm which Eugene produced for scaling Higher School Certificate marks in the early 1980 was later used to determine the New South Wales Tertiary Entrance Rank.
Jaeger Medal
Professor Ian McDougall
Professor Emeritus, Research School of Earth Sciences, Australian National University
Ian McDougall has an extraordinary record of scientific achievement in the fields of plate tectonics, geochronology, planetary noble gas evolution, and the origin and evolution of humans. In addition to making fundamental contributions to plate tectonics by precise dating of the large-scale movement of oceanic plates, his work provides the benchmark for our understanding of hominid evolution in East Africa. This is exemplified by his recent dating of the new species Australopithecus anamensis, a finding that provides new insights into our understanding of the genesis of our own species.
Lyle Medal
Professor Yuri Kivshar
Head, Nonlinear Physics Centre, Research School of Physical Sciences and Engineering, Australian National University
Yuri Kivshar is a world leader in nonlinear physics and optics, widely recognised for his contributions to our understanding of self-trapping and energy localisation, pioneering results in the theory of optical solitons and vortices, and the world-first predictions of many important effects in nonlinear physics of periodic photonic structures. Most of his theoretical predictions have been verified and demonstrated experimentally. Yuri is a leading figure in the interchange of ideas between nonlinear optics and atom optics. His research is multidisciplinary in background and focus.
Early-career researchers award recipients
Dorothy Hill Award
Dr Léanne Armand
Marseille Oceanography Centre, Laboratory of Oceanography and Marine Biogeochemistry, Marseille
Léanne Armand is the recipient of the 2005–07 European Union Marie Curie Fellowship for her comprehensive taxonomic treatment of Southern Ocean diatoms. She has added rigour to the study of diatoms by applying statistical analysis, increasing the degree of confidence in the reconstruction of sea water temperatures of the past. This has particularly enhanced the value in reconstructing environments during the late Quaternary. The relevance of this type of work is increasing as questions of evolution of our modern environment become more important.
Fenner Medal
Dr Peter Dodds
CSIRO Plant Industry, Canberra
Peter Dodds is an exceptional and highly creative young researcher in the area of the molecular biology of host-pathogen interactions, specifically the interaction between the flax plant and its flax rust pathogen. He has isolated several genes from flax related to resistance to rust, providing insights into the evolution of these genes and the molecular basis for the specificity of plant-pathogen interaction. He has also isolated the first rust pathogen avirulence genes and developed a general method for isolating and recognising these genes. These discoveries have provided a route towards engineering new rust resistance genes for use in agriculture.
Gottschalk Medal
Professor Jamie Rossjohn
Australian Research Council Federation Fellow, The Department of Biochemistry & Molecular Biology, School of Biomedical Sciences, Monash University, Melbourne
Jamie Rossjohn’s primary contribution is to provide a structural basis for events central to infection and cellular immunity. He has provided insight into the mechanism of action of the cholesterol-dependent pore-forming toxins and a toxin that inactivates an essential chaperone protein. Jamie has provided an understanding of receptor-recognition events at the immunological synapse. This includes providing insights into the basis of MHCrestricted antigen recognition, T-cell immunodominance, allorecognition and signalling, and also MHC polymorphism in the context of antigen presentation and viral evasion.
Le Fèvre Memorial Prize
Professor Thomas Maschmeyer
Federation Fellow and Professor of Chemistry, University of Sydney
Thomas Maschmeyer is renowned for his ground-breaking research in materials and catalysis which led to his meteoric rise in stature within the international chemical community. His guiding principle of ‘selectivity tuning by active site design’ underlies his discoveries from pharmaceutical synthesis to process intensification and biofuels. Thomas’ leading role in the establishment of the combinatorial catalysis company Avantium was instrumental in the listing of the Australian Biodiesel Group on the Australian Stock Exchange.
Moran Medal
Professor Robin Hyndman
Professor of Statistics, Department of Econometrics and Business Statistics, Monash University, Melbourne
Rob Hyndman has made major contributions to a wide range of fields, especially to forecasting, time-series, graphical methods and computational statistics. His research in forecasting challenged the appropriateness of the most fundamental of Bayesian forecasting models for exponential-family time series and on state-space models for exponential smoothing. Rob has recently proposed a new methodology for forecasting age-specific mortality curves and all official Australian cancer forecasts now use this method. His research on graphical methods has produced an ingenious method for visualising conditional probability densities, and a remarkably useful tool for data analysis – the ‘highest density region’ box plot.
Pawsey Medal
Professor Ben Eggleton
Professor of Physics, ARC Federation Fellow, Research Director, CUDOS – ARC Centre of Excellence, School of Physics, University of Sydney
Ben Eggleton has pioneered research in optical device physics and photonics that underpin the development of the next generation of communication technologies and has made seminal contributions leading to the development of the photonic chip. His research achievements include the first experimental observation of nonlinear pulse propagation in photonic crystals, ground-breaking work on geometries for photonic crystal fibres, and the demonstration of highly original and significant nonlinear waveguide.
2006 awardees
Career awards
Macfarlane Burnet Medal
Professor Jenny Marshall Graves
Professorial Fellow, Research School of Biological Sciences, Australian National University, Canberra.
Jenny Graves has a highly acclaimed international reputation for her work in mammalian genetics and comparative genomics on Australian marsupials and monotremes. Her research has raised profound questions about human biology and mammalian evolution. She has made extensive ground-breaking discoveries relating to the cell cycle, control of DNA replication, evolution of the mammalian genome and the function and evolution of sex chromosomes. She graduated from Adelaide University and received a Fulbright award to undertake a PhD in Molecular Biology at the University of California, Berkeley, USA. Jenny was selected as the 2006 laureate for the Asia-Pacific region L’Oréal-UNESCO Awards for women in science. She is a Research Director at the Australian Research Council Centre for Kangaroo Genomics.
Craig Medal
Professor Barry Ninham
Visiting Fellow, Applied Mathematics Department, Research School of Physical Sciences and Engineering, Australian National University, Canberra.
Barry Ninham is a talented theoretical physical chemist and one of the world’s leading theoreticians in colloid science. He has specific expertise in molecular self-assembly and non-electrostatic interactions between atoms and molecules. He has pioneered the measurement of surface forces and introduced the ground-breaking concept of well-defined microstructures in substances such as emulsions. He completed his undergraduate and Masters at the University of Western Australia and a PhD at the University of Maryland. He is Founder and Head of the Applied Mathematics Department.
Ian Wark Medal
Professor Graeme Clark AC
Director, The Bionic Ear Institute and Laureate Professorial Fellow, The University of Melbourne.
Graeme Clark is internationally recognised for inventing the Bionic Ear, the first multiple channel cochlear Implant. His pioneering research on electrical stimulation of the auditory pathways led to the development of the prototype multiple-channel cochlear implant which was implanted in a research volunteer in 1978. Since then, the implant has brought hearing to more than 50,000 deaf people, including 20,000 children, in over 120 countries. He founded The Bionic Ear Institute in 1983 and continues to refine the implant so that patients now understand significantly more speech, and severely and profoundly deaf children can develop near-normal speech.
Mawson Medal
Professor Kenneth McNamara
Senior Curator of Invertebrate Palaeontology, Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Western Australian Museum. Adjunct Professor Palaeontology, Department of Applied Geology, Curtin University of Technology, Perth.
Kenneth McNamara is internationally renowned for outstanding academic contributions in palaeontology and biology relating to studies of developmental change, rates of growth and phylogeny. He is a well-recognised expert on trilobites and their evolutionary patterns. He graduated from the University of Aberdeen, and obtained his PhD from the University of Cambridge. His taxonomic research has resulted in the description of at least 69 new species and 13 new genera of invertebrates.
Early- and mid-career awards
Dorothy Hill Award
Dr Adriana Dutkiewicz
QEII Research Fellow (Australian Research Council), School of Geosciences, University of Sydney, Sydney.
Adriana Dutkiewicz has made exceptional contributions in the field of early Precambrian petroleum geology. She was the first to discover oil inclusions preserved in Archaean and early Precambrian rocks and to demonstrate that primordial biomass was sufficiently abundant to generate hydrocarbons. She has shown that eukaryotes survived extreme climatic events including higher temperatures than previously accepted. Adriana has contributed valuable insights relating to the early evolution of life and petroleum exploration.
Fenner Medal
Dr Barry Brook
Senior Research Fellow, School for Environmental Research, Charles Darwin University, Darwin.
Barry Brook is internationally recognised for excellence and innovation in conservation biology. His work has raised awareness of the relevance of past extinctions for present biodiversity loss. His research using analytical and computer simulation modelling has contributed to the modern understanding of species extinction dynamics. He gained his PhD from Macquarie University, Sydney on the subject of population viability analysis.
Frederick White Prize
Dr James Tickner
Research Scientist, CSIRO Minerals, Lucas Heights Science and Technology Centre, Lucas Heights.
James Tickner has made impressive scientific contributions in innovation and has secured six patents. He developed nuclear instrumentation for the mineral industry and invented a new type of camera for finding buried landmines. He co-invented the concept of fast-neutron/gamma ray radiography for rapidly screening bulk cargo. He has made important advances in the fields of nuclear simulation and solving challenging measurement or imaging problems.
Gottschalk Medal
Dr Joel Mackay
Senior Research Fellow (National Health and Medical Research Council), School of Molecular and Microbial Biosciences, University of Sydney, Sydney.
Joel Mackay has a distinguished career in human physiology and health research that is focused at the molecular level. He discovered the mechanisms behind the vancomycin group of antibiotics, leading to improved derivatives. He has made valuable contributions to understanding the transcriptional regulation involved with forming red blood cells, tracing point mutations, and protein structures, advancing knowledge of inherited blood disorders such as thalassemia.
Le Fèvre Memorial Prize
Associate Professor Michael Sherburn
Senior Fellow and Group Leader, Research School of Chemistry, Australian National University
Michael Sherburn is a talented synthetic chemist, developing powerful new methods to achieve efficient chemical synthesis. These new methods have been applied to the synthesis of natural products and designed structures, that are potentially important in medical treatments. His research group has created superbowl container molecules to capture and release drugs and chemicals. These molecules have potential in drug delivery, for removing environmental toxins, catalysing chemical reactions and allowing new chemical purification. His group has developed ingenious methods to synthesise polycyclic natural products, including the anti-cancer agent, podophyllotoxin.
Pawsey Medal
Dr Mahananda Dasgupta
Senior Fellow, Department of Nuclear Physics, Research School of Physical Sciences
and Engineering, Australian National University, Canberra.
Mahananda Dasgupta is a leading international researcher in the field of nuclear fusion physics. Her cutting-edge contributions include precision measurements of unprecedented accuracy. She has developed theoretical models to describe quantum tunnelling of composite objects and designed efficient experimental particle detection equipment. Mahananda completed her PhD at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research in Bombay.
Athlete data in professional sport – Expert working group
'Getting ahead of the game: Athlete data in professional sport' calls for improved governance of data collection in professional sport.
The report Getting ahead of the game: Athlete data in professional sport was prepared, written and overseen by an expert working group established collaboratively by the Chairs, the Australian Academy of Science, and The University of Western Australia’s Minderoo Tech & Policy Lab.
The expert working group includes domain experts in sports science and sports medicine, artificial intelligence, law, policy, social science and governance. It also includes sports practitioners and former representative athletes in professional and high performance/Olympic sport, as well as experts in athlete rights and representation.
Payment error
Unfortunately there has been error with the payment; you have not been charged. Please return to the previous page and try again, otherwise, please contact us. We have listed some common reasons for payment errors below.
Payment information was input incorrectly.
It’s possible that the credit card information was entered incorrectly. Please double-check that the name, expiration date, and CVV number entered in our system match what’s on your card.
Card was declined by financial institution (bank or credit card company).
Some financial institutions may impose spending limits, or caps on the number of transactions that can take place during a certain period of time. You may wish to try again later, or contact your financial institution to authorise the payment.
Committee—Hannan Medal
Purpose: To advise Council on the award of the Medal, in accordance with Standing Order XXII.
Purpose: To advise Council on the award of the Medal, in accordance with Standing Order XXII.
- Professor Alan Welsh FAA - Chair
- Professor Matt Wand FAA - Member
- Dr Frank De Hoog - Member
- Professor Richard Hartley FAA FRS - Member
- Professor Michael Cowling FAA - Member
- Professor Jean Yang - Member
Committee—Ian Wark Medal and Lecture
Purpose: To advise Council on the award of the Medal, in accordance with Standing Order XXII.
Purpose: To advise Council on the award of the Medal, in accordance with Standing Order XXII.
- Professor Erich Weigold AM FAA FTSE - Chair
- Professor Willy Zwaenepoel FAA FTSE - Member
- Professor Andrew Blakers AO FAA FTSE - Member
- Professor Calum Drummond AO FAA FTSE - Member
- Professor Elaine Wong - Member
Committee—Nancy Millis Medal For Women in Science
Purpose: To advise Council on the award of the Medal, in accordance with Standing Order XXII.
Purpose: To advise Council on the award of the Medal, in accordance with Standing Order XXII.
- Professor Dorrit Jacob FAA - Chair
- Professor James McCluskey AO FAA FAHMS - Member - Melbourne University Representative
- Professor Laura Parry - Member
- Professor Ute Roessner AM FAA - Member
- Professor Tim Ralph FAA - Member
Committee—Pawsey Medal
Purpose: To advise Council on the award of the Medal, in accordance with Standing Order XXII.
Purpose: To advise Council on the award of the Medal, in accordance with Standing Order XXII.
- Professor Xiaojing Hao FAA FTSE - Chair
- Professor Mathai Varghese FAA - Member
- Professor Nicole Bell - Member
- Professor Halina Rubinsztein-Dunlop AO FAA - Member
- Professor Catherine Stampfl FAA - Member
Sir Thomas Ranken Lyle 1860-1944
Thomas Ranken Lyle was born in Londonderry, Northern Ireland on 26 August 1860. He graduated from Trinity College, Dublin in 1883 with the highest honours the college could award: gold medals in mathematics and experimental science and a university studentship in mathematics. He gained his MA in 1887 and continued his studies in advanced mathematics and physics.
Thomas Ranken Lyle was born in Londonderry, Northern Ireland on 26 August 1860. He graduated from Trinity College, Dublin in 1883 with the highest honours the college could award: gold medals in mathematics and experimental science and a university studentship in mathematics. He gained his MA in 1887 and continued his studies in advanced mathematics and physics.
Lyle took up the chair of natural philosophy at the University of Melbourne in 1889. With the introduction of the Master of Science degree in 1891, he embarked on a small research program. Much of the apparatus he needed had to be made in the university, and Lyle was fortunate in that he was an expert glass-blower. He was also a skilled photographer. When, in mid-February 1896, he read newspaper reports of Röntgen's discovery of a mysterious new form of radiation he put this combination of skills to good use and successfully evacuated a Crookes tube to produce practical X-rays. He is credited with taking both the first X-ray and the first published X-ray in Australia, in March 1896. In June of that year he was invited to take a photograph of a patient who had a needle embedded in his wrist. The 'shadow photograph', clearly showing the needle's exact location, allowed the surgeon to make an incision at the correct point and extract the needle.
Despite this ground-breaking medical work, Lyle's more active interest was in electrical power technology, in particular alternating currents and their associated magnetic effects. His most significant paper was a theoretical analysis of the alternating current generator.
Lyle was a member of numerous government bodies and inquiries. He held several directorships, including that of the Metropolitan Gas Company. Among other senior appointments he was one of the first three (part-time) commissioners of Victoria's State Electricity Commission and its first chairman. In 1919 he was a foundation member of the Australian National Research Council (ANRC), the forerunner to the Australian Academy of Science, and its president from 1929-32. The ANRC recognised his outstanding contribution to scientific life in Australia in 1931 when it created the Thomas Ranken Lyle medal for distinguished Australian research in mathematics and physics.
Lyle was also an excellent sportsman. In 1885-87 he played rugby for Ireland five times before suffering knee injuries that caused him to be lame in later life and eventually forced his resignation from the University of Melbourne in early 1915. His health deteriorated after a cerebral haemorrhage in 1940 left him a semi-invalid, and he died on 31 March 1944.
Lyle received an ScD degree from Trinity College, Dublin in 1905, a fellowship of the Royal Society in 1912 and a knighthood in 1922
Bibliography
- Home, R.W. 1986, Lyle, Sir Thomas Ranken (1860-1944), mathematical physicist, Australian Dictionary of Biography, editors Bede Nairn and Geoffrey Serle, Melbourne University Press, pp.172-174
- Macdonald, Colin F. 1965, Röntgen's discovery of the X-rays and the pioneer Melbourne radiologists, Victorian Historical Magazine, vol.36, no.4, November, pp.136-153
- Russel, K.F. 1975, William Stone: a pioneer in Australian radiology, Australasian Radiology, vol.19, no.3, September, pp.216-222
- Ryan, J., Sutton, K. and Baigent, M. 1996, Australasian Radiology – A History, pp.24-26
- Trainor, J.P. 1946, Salute to the X-Ray Pioneers of Australia, W. Watson & Sons, (Sydney) pp.26-27
Travelling Fellowship Award Committee terms of reference
Membership
In order to ensure transparency and to allow for wider involvement of the Fellowship, Committee membership for all awards will be for three years only, with approximately one third of the members retiring each year (on 31 December). In the case of newly formed committees, such retirements will begin at the end of the second year.
A Chair will normally have already served on the Award Committee as a member for at least one year and their maximum term as Chair will be for two years - so that their membership term does not extend beyond five years. For biennial awards, years of membership are up to three award rounds (six years) for members – with the maximum years for a Chair’s term being two award rounds (up to four years). There will be a minimum break of two award rounds before a member can re-join a committee.
To safeguard the Academy’s real and perceived independence in decision making, donors or those with a close personal connection to an award (such as an award’s namesake or their family members), may not be members of the relevant award’s committee. Such individuals are also asked to refrain from acting as a referee for candidates for that award.
Award Committee members are unable to nominate or apply for an award or act as a referee for a candidate, for consideration by the committee that they are sitting on. Council members are not eligible to nominate or apply for Academy awards during their term and for two years after they leave Council.
Award timeframes
Travelling Fellowship award nominations and applications are due by 1 June each year. Award Committee deliberations are to be finalised and written recommendations and reports sent to the Secretariat by 1 August. Recommendations will then be submitted to EXCOM in August for approval.
Committee deliberations
All members are expected to undertake unconscious bias training. Council and The Secretaries will determine the nature of this training each year.
The Academy is committed to promoting diversity of, for example, gender, ethnicity, age, geographical distribution and scientific disciplines, and to the principles of inclusion, equal opportunity, fairness and transparency in its policies and procedures.
Unconscious bias often manifests as prejudice or unsupported judgments. It is considered to be universally present, and often escapes detection because it is not applied consciously.
The purpose of unconscious bias training is to help Committee members recognize its existence and forms, and the influence it can have on decision-making processes, with a view to mitigating its effects on selection processes.
Current training is provided though the Academy’s unconscious bias training video, which Committee members are requested to view prior to stating their nomination assessments (45 minutes).
Members of each Award Committee are also encouraged to watch the Royal Society video on avoiding group think.
Applicants can only receive funding from the same research or travelling fellowship award once in a three calendar year period. Applicants may apply for more than one award but can only receive one Academy travelling or research award per calendar year.
If a candidate applies for two or more research or travelling fellowship awards, the chairs of these committees will be alerted to the fact and will be charged to communicate with each other to ensure that the awardee only receives the one award. Their assessment will be based on their determination of the quality of the other applicants in that round. If an applicant for two awards is the top ranked candidate for both awards, the chairs will recommend a single award that best benefits the research/career of that candidate.
Committee members will ensure that they are satisfied that proposals comply with the Australian Code for the Responsible Conduct of Research. Research involving Indigenous Australians must comply with the guidelines for Ethical Research in Australian Indigenous Studies. Any concerns must be reported to the Academy for further clarification or resolution either at the application or pre-award stage.
Conflict of interest
The first task of the Committee before any assessment or ranking takes place is for committee Chairs to ask for and collect declarations of conflicts of interest from all committee members and forward this information to the Secretariat. When identifying conflicts of interest, committee members should use the following as a guide to direct and indirect conflicts. The Secretariat will provide Chairs with a spreadsheet for members to complete and will keep a record of declarations.
To reduce the risk of conflicts of interest, award committee members are asked to refrain from nominating, or acting as a referee, for candidates for awards that fall under their committee’s remit. All conflicts, real or perceived, must be declared in the member’s conflict-of-interest report sent to the Chair and Secretariat.
Members with direct conflicts of interest must abstain from assessing (i.e. discussing and scoring) candidates, but may respond to queries about the candidates’ science, if asked.
Indirect conflicts will be assessed by the committee Chair to determine if an indirect or potential conflict is significant enough to warrant a member absenting from assessing a candidate in part (e.g. scoring but not discussing) or in full.
Committees with Chairs that have declared any direct or indirect conflicts of interest are requested to copy the relevant Side-Secretary into all committee deliberations.
At the relevant Side-Secretary’s discretion an independent third-party assessor may be brought in to assist such committees at any point of the deliberations. They would join as either an additional member of the committee with full voting rights and normal tenure, or as a non-voting observer for one year.
A direct conflict of interest is defined as a close personal or professional relationship with the candidate. An indirect conflict of interest is defined as relationships that could create bias. Refer to the Fellowship nominations conflicts of interest guidelines for examples.
Perceived conflicts of interest are important to the reputation of the Academy and in some jurisdictions have the same standing as actual conflicts of interest. As such, the number of exceptions to these guidelines approved by the Side-Secretaries will be minimised.
Confidentiality
All material relating to candidates is strictly confidential and must not be shared with anyone. Following the deliberations, all electronic material must be deleted from personal devices and printed material and notes securely destroyed or returned to the Awards office. The deliberations remain confidential, even after the awarding of candidates.
Consideration of candidates
Committee members will ensure that gender and diversity issues are taken into consideration when considering candidates for awards. In formulating their views, award committee members may seek opinions regarding the candidates from other scientists and experts, whether in Australia or overseas.
The Secretariat will organise a web conference for the committee to discuss the award applications. Aside from this Secretariat-organised meeting, chairs will determine how their committee will conduct its deliberations, for example via electronic means.
Committees are requested to ensure that candidate achievements are judged relative to opportunity. The approach aims to give more weight to the overall quality and impact of achievements rather than the quantity, rate or breadth of particular achievements, which in many instances is directly related to time and resources available rather than talent, merit or excellence. An assessment of a candidate’s opportunity to demonstrate scientific excellence will take into account the factors below, based on the Research Opportunity and Performance Evidence (ROPE) guidelines of the Australian Research Council (ARC).
- Research training; employment in research positions, either within the research sector or outside academia, including the research component and/or full-time-equivalence of positions; research and development activities; industry engagement; research environment, including supervision, mentoring and leadership; professional development; research management experience, and access to research and support facilities.
Career interruptions- including those due to employment outside academia; unemployment, part-time employment; childbirth; parental leave; carers’ responsibilities; misadventure; limited or no access to facilities and resources—such as through workplace interruptions; disaster management and recovery; misadventure; medical conditions; disability; caring and parental responsibilities, community obligations, including Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander cultural practices and protocols or illness.
In general, Award Committees should attempt to achieve a consensus with respect to the awardee to be recommended to Council. Where this is not possible, the matter should be resolved by a formal vote. In the event of the number of votes for any two candidates being equal, the Chair would exercise a casting vote. When a vote is used to decide the outcome of the Committee’s deliberations, the actual distribution of the votes should be recorded in the Chair’s report to Council.
Committees can recommend that there be no award made in that round if there is consensus that there isn’t a sufficiently strong candidate.
Chair's report to council
The Secretariat will provide a report template for chairs to complete. Chairs will provide the Awards Officer with a brief summary (one page) of the deliberations of the Committee, how many applications were received, the final decision and why the candidate is being proposed to Council for the award, by 5 September. The report should also include the completed register of conflicts of interest (and how conflicts were dealt with) and any recommended changes to the award or to the selection process.
New members
As part of its recommendations to Council, the Award Committee should advise on optimum disciplinary makeup of the committee for replacement committee members.
The Secretaries Physical and Biological Sciences will review the interest received from individual Fellows to sit on award committees and the Committee recommendations regarding disciplinary makeup and select new members and Chairs as guided by the following selection principles, presenting these to Council Annually out of session for record and oversight:
- Annually the Fellowship will be consulted on their availability for Award and Sectional committees.
- The member expertise across each Awards Committee will endeavour to cover the fields of the candidates relevant to that committee
- When nominations close, new members will be added to any Awards Committee if the Secretaries consider that expertise is lacking or that conflicts would inhibit the committee in ranking particular candidates
- The membership of each Awards Committee, within the conditions of that Award, and where possible will reflect appropriate geographical spread, gender and ethnic diversity as guided by and in accordance with the principles provided by the Diversity and Inclusion Advisory Committee (DIACOM).
- The Secretaries will also consider members outside of the award discipline for Award committees, including corresponding members of the Academy and Fellows of the Royal Society Te Apārangi.
- The Secretaries will aim to have a minimum of 5 members appointed on each Award Committee.
- The DIACOM representative on Council will be tasked to record and feedback to the Secretaries any equity and diversity matters observed in relation to the awards and where shown in the annual award committee reports presented to Council.
- When appropriate Early and Mid-Career Researchers and previous awardees of an Award will be considered for award committee membership, as well as Fellows of other National Academies and non-Fellows with particular expertise.