Research Award Committee terms of reference

Image Description

Membership

In order to ensure transparency and to allow for wider involvement of the Fellowship, Committee membership for all awards will be for three years only, with approximately one third of the members retiring each year (on 31 December). In the case of newly formed committees, such retirements will begin at the end of the second year.

A Chair will normally have already served on the Award Committee as a member for at least one year and their maximum term as Chair will be for two years - so that their membership term does not extend beyond five years. For biennial awards, years of membership are up to three award rounds (six years) for members – with the maximum years for a Chair’s term being two award rounds (up to four years). There will be a minimum break of two award rounds before a member can re-join a committee.

To safeguard the Academy’s real and perceived independence in decision making, donors or those with a close personal connection to an award (such as an award’s namesake or their family members), may not be members of the relevant award’s committee. Such individuals are also asked to refrain from acting as a referee for candidates for that award.

Award Committee members are unable to apply for an award, or act as a referee for a candidate, for consideration by the committee that they are sitting on. Council members are not eligible to apply for Academy awards during their term and for two years after they leave Council.

Award timeframes

Research award applications are due on 1 June each year.  Award Committee deliberations are to be finalised and written recommendations and reports sent to the Secretariat by 5 September. Recommendations will then be submitted to Council in October for approval.

Committee deliberations

All members are expected to undertake unconscious bias training. Council and The Secretaries will determine the nature of this training each year.

The Academy is committed to promoting diversity of, for example, gender, ethnicity, age, geographical distribution and scientific disciplines, and to the principles of inclusion, equal opportunity, fairness and transparency in its policies and procedures.

Unconscious bias often manifests as prejudice or unsupported judgments. It is considered to be universally present, and often escapes detection because it is not applied consciously.

The purpose of unconscious bias training is to help Committee members recognise its existence and forms, and the influence it can have on decision-making processes, with a view to mitigating its effects on selection processes.  

Current training is provided though the Academy’s unconscious bias training video, which Committee members are requested to view prior to stating their nomination assessments (45 minutes).

Members of each Award Committee are also encouraged to watch the Royal Society video on avoiding group think.

Applicants can only receive funding from the same research or travelling fellowship award once in a three calendar year period. Applicants may apply for more than one award but can only receive one Academy travelling or research award per calendar year. 

If a candidate applies for two or more research or travelling fellowship awards, the chairs of these committees will be alerted to the fact and will be charged to communicate with each other to ensure that the awardee only receives the one award. Their assessment will be based on their determination of the quality of the other applicants in that round.  If an applicant for two awards is the top ranked candidate for both awards, the chairs will recommend a single award that best benefits the research/career of that candidate. 

Committee members will ensure that they are satisfied that proposals comply with the Australian Code for the Responsible Conduct of Research. Research involving Indigenous Australians must comply with the guidelines for Ethical Research in Australian Indigenous Studies.  Any concerns must be reported to the Academy for further clarification or resolution either at the application or pre-award stage.

Conflict of interest

The first task of the Committee before any assessment or ranking takes place is for committee Chairs to ask for and collect declarations of conflicts of interest from all committee members and forward this information to the Secretariat. When identifying conflicts of interest, committee members should use the following as a guide to direct and indirect conflicts. The Secretariat will provide Chairs with a spreadsheet for members to complete and will keep a record of declarations.

To reduce the risk of conflicts of interest, award committee members are asked to refrain from acting as a referee for candidates for awards that fall under their committee’s remit. All conflicts, real or perceived, must be declared in the member’s conflict-of-interest report sent to the Chair and Secretariat.

Members with direct conflicts of interest must abstain from assessing (i.e. discussing and scoring) candidates, but may respond to queries about the candidates’ science, if asked.

Indirect conflicts will be assessed by the committee Chair to determine if an indirect or potential conflict is significant enough to warrant a member absenting from assessing a candidate in part (e.g. scoring but not discussing) or in full.

Committees with Chairs that have declared any direct or indirect conflicts of interest are requested to copy the relevant Side-Secretary into all committee deliberations.

At the relevant Side-Secretary’s discretion an independent third-party assessor may be brought in to assist such committees at any point of the deliberations. They would join as either an additional member of the committee with full voting rights and normal tenure, or as a non-voting observer for one year.

A direct conflict of interest is defined as a close personal or professional relationship with the candidate. An indirect conflict of interest is defined as relationships that could create bias. Refer to the Fellowship nominations conflicts of interest guidelines for examples. 

Perceived conflicts of interest are important to the reputation of the Academy and in some jurisdictions have the same standing as actual conflicts of interest. As such, the number of exceptions to these guidelines approved by the Side-Secretaries will be minimised.

Confidentiality

All material relating to candidates is strictly confidential and must not be shared with anyone. Following the deliberations, all electronic material must be deleted from personal devices and printed material and notes securely destroyed or returned to the Awards office. The deliberations remain confidential, even after the awarding of candidates.

Consideration of candidates

Committee members will ensure that gender and diversity issues are taken into consideration when considering candidates for awards. In formulating their views, award committee members may seek opinions regarding the candidates from other scientists and experts, whether in Australia or overseas.

The Secretariat will organise a web conference for the committee to discuss the award applications. Aside from this Secretariat-organised meeting, chairs will determine how their committee will conduct its deliberations.

Committees are requested to ensure that candidate achievements are judged relative to opportunity. The approach aims to give more weight to the overall quality and impact of achievements rather than the quantity, rate or breadth of particular achievements, which in many instances is directly related to time and resources available rather than talent, merit or excellence. An assessment of a candidate’s opportunity to demonstrate scientific excellence will take into account the factors below, based on the Research Opportunity and Performance Evidence (ROPE) guidelines of the Australian Research Council (ARC).

  • Research training; employment in research positions, either within the research sector or outside academia, including the research component and/or full-time-equivalence of positions; research and development activities; industry engagement; research environment, including supervision, mentoring and leadership; professional development; research management experience, and access to research and support facilities.
  • Career interruptions- including those due to employment outside academia; unemployment, part-time employment; childbirth; parental leave; carers’ responsibilities; misadventure; limited or no access to facilities and resources—such as through workplace interruptions; disaster management and recovery; misadventure; medical conditions; disability; caring and parental responsibilities, community obligations, including Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander cultural practices and protocols or illness.

In general, Award Committees should attempt to achieve a consensus with respect to the awardee/s to be recommended to Council. Where this is not possible, the matter should be resolved by a formal vote. In the event of the number of votes for any two candidates being equal, the Chair would exercise a casting vote. When a vote is used to decide the outcome of the Committee’s deliberations, the actual distribution of the votes should be recorded in the Chair’s report to Council.

Committees can recommend that there be no award made in that round if there is consensus that there isn’t a sufficiently strong candidate.

Chair's report to council

The Secretariat will provide a report template for chairs to complete. Chairs will provide the Awards Officer with a brief summary (one page) of the deliberations of the Committee, how many applications were received, the final decision and why the candidate is being proposed to Council for the award, by 5 September. The report should also include the completed register of conflicts of interest (and how conflicts were dealt with) and any recommended changes to the award or to the selection process.

New members

As part of its recommendations to Council, the Award Committee should advise on optimum disciplinary makeup of the committee for replacement committee members.

The Secretaries Physical and Biological Sciences will review the interest received from individual Fellows to sit on award committees and the Committee recommendations regarding disciplinary makeup and select new members and Chairs as guided by the following selection principles, presenting these to Council Annually out of session for record and oversight:

  • Annually the Fellowship will be consulted on their availability for Award and Sectional committees.
  • The member expertise across each Awards Committee will endeavour to cover the fields of the candidates relevant to that committee
  • When nominations close, new members will be added to any Awards Committee if the Secretaries consider that expertise is lacking or that conflicts would inhibit the committee in ranking particular candidates
  • The membership of each Awards Committee, within the conditions of that Award, and where possible will reflect appropriate geographical spread, gender and ethnic diversity as guided by and in accordance with the principles provided by the Diversity and Inclusion Advisory Committee  (DIACOM).
  • The Secretaries will also consider members outside of the award discipline for Award committees, including corresponding members of the Academy and Fellows of the Royal Society Te Apārangi.
  • The Secretaries will aim to have a minimum of 5 members appointed on each Award Committee.
  • The DIACOM representative on Council will be tasked to record and feedback to the Secretaries any equity and diversity matters observed in relation to the awards and where shown in the annual award committee reports presented to Council.
  • When appropriate Early and Mid-Career Researchers and previous awardees of an Award will be considered for award committee membership, as well as Fellows of other National Academies and non-Fellows with particular expertise.

Honorific Award Committee terms of reference

The honorific awards were established to recognise outstanding contributions to the advancement of science at the early, mid and career level.

Image Description

The honorific awards were established to recognise outstanding contributions to the advancement of science at the early, mid and career level. Career awards recognise life-long achievement. Receipt of early- and/or mid-career honorific awards may assist to advance the recipients’ careers.

The primary criterion for all awards is scientific achievement.

The list of all early-career, mid-career, career and premier honorific awards can be found here.

MEMBERSHIP

To ensure transparency and enable wider involvement of the Fellowship in the selection process, committee membership for all awards will be for three years only and approximately one third of the members will retire each year (on 31 December). In the case of newly formed committees, such retirements will begin at the end of the second year.

A Chair will normally have already served on the awards committee as a member for at least one year and where possible, also be a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science. The maximum term for a Chair will normally be for two award rounds - so the membership term does not extend beyond five award rounds. For biennial awards, the years of membership are up to three award rounds (six years) for members – with the maximum years for a Chair’s term normally being two award rounds (up to four years). There will be a minimum break of two award rounds before a member can re-join a committee. Committee members may not be nominated for that award for two award rounds after they leave the committee.

To safeguard the Academy’s real and perceived independence in decision making, donors or those with a close personal connection to an award (such as an award’s namesake or their family members), may not be members of the relevant award’s committee. Such individuals are also asked to refrain from nominating or acting as a referee for candidates for that award.

Serving members of the Council of the Australian Academy of Science may not be members of honorific award committees, except if specifically required by the award guidelines. Council members are not eligible to be nominated for Academy awards for two years after they leave Council. Council members may not nominate candidates for honorific awards.

AWARD NOMINATION

Copies of each candidate’s nomination documents (including the nomination form, brief citation, non-technical description of the work, CV and list of publications) will be sent by the Secretariat to the award committee in June of each year.

No candidate can receive more than one award in the same year. When a candidate is nominated for more than one award, and becomes a front-runner for more than one award, the Chairs of the relevant committees need to confer. A joint meeting of the relevant award committees can also be arranged by the Secretariat, if needed. 

Award committees will receive a summary of relevant awardee eligibility details to inform their shortlist decision.

COMMITTEE DELIBERATIONS

All members are expected to undertake unconscious bias training. Council and The Secretaries will determine the nature of this training each year.

The Academy is committed to promoting diversity of, for example, gender, ethnicity, age, geographical distribution and scientific disciplines, and to the principles of inclusion, equal opportunity, fairness and transparency in its policies and procedures.

Unconscious bias often manifests as prejudice or unsupported judgments. It is considered to be universally present, and often escapes detection because it is not applied consciously. 

The purpose of unconscious bias training is to help Committee members recognise its existence and forms, and the influence it can have on decision-making processes, with a view to mitigating its effects on selection processes.  

Current training is provided though the Academy’s unconscious bias training video, which Committee members are requested to view prior to starting their nomination assessments (45 minutes).

Members of each award committee are also encouraged to watch the Royal Society video on avoiding group think.

The Secretariat will organise a web conference for the committee to discuss the award nominations. Aside from this Secretariat-organised meeting, Chairs will determine how their committee will conduct its deliberations.

CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

The first task of the Committee before any assessment or ranking takes place is for committee Chairs to ask for and collect declarations of conflicts of interest from all committee members and forward this information to the Secretariat. When identifying conflicts of interest, committee members should use the following as a guide to direct and indirect conflicts. The Secretariat will provide Chairs with a spreadsheet for members to complete and will keep a record of declarations.

To reduce the risk of conflicts of interest, award committee members are asked to refrain from nominating, or acting as a referee for, new nominees for awards that fall under their committee’s remit. It is appreciated that there may be residual conflicts from existing nominations. These should be dealt with in consultation with the Secretaries.

All conflicts, real or perceived, must be declared in the member’s conflict-of-interest report sent to the Chair and Secretariat.

Members with direct conflicts of interest must abstain from assessing (i.e. discussing and scoring) candidates, but may respond to queries about the candidates’ science, if asked.

Indirect conflicts will be assessed by the committee Chair to determine if an indirect or potential conflict is significant enough to warrant a member absenting from assessing a candidate in part (e.g. scoring but not discussing) or in full.

Committees with Chairs that have declared any direct or indirect conflicts of interest are requested to copy the relevant Side-Secretary into all committee deliberations.

At the relevant Side-Secretary’s discretion an independent third-party assessor may be brought in to assist such committees at any point of the deliberations. They would join as either an additional member of the committee with full voting rights and normal tenure, or as a non-voting observer for one year.

A direct conflict of interest is defined as a close personal or professional relationship with the candidate. An indirect conflict of interest is defined as relationships that could create bias. Refer to the Fellowship nominations conflicts of interest guidelines for examples. 

Perceived conflicts of interest are important to the reputation of the Academy and in some jurisdictions have the same standing as actual conflicts of interest. As such, the number of exceptions to these guidelines approved by the Side-Secretaries will be minimised.

CONFIDENTIALITY

All material relating to candidates is strictly confidential and must not be shared with anyone. Following the deliberations, all electronic material must be deleted from personal devices and printed material and notes securely destroyed or returned to the Awards office. The deliberations remain confidential, even after the awarding of candidates.

CONSIDERATION OF CANDIDATES

If a proposed candidate is already the recipient of an Academy early-career honorific award, they will not be eligible for nomination for another early-career award or a mid-career honorific award. In accordance with the objectives of the honorific awards, a mid-career honorific award recipient will also not be eligible for nomination for another mid-career award and Fellows of the Academy are ineligible to be nominated for early or mid-career honorific awards. Premier awardees can be awarded a second premier award but not in the same award year.

Where a candidate has been put forward for an award but is clearly better suited or equally eligible for other awards in that round, the Secretaries have the discretion to consider having the nomination moved or jointly considered for the other award (with prior approval of the nominator).

Each committee should ensure that they have examined each case appropriately, exercising judgement and limiting the use of metrics (e.g. H-indexes, number of international presentations) or other constructs that can discriminate against those who have had fewer years full-time in research. Metrics should only be used in a qualitative way and not as a decisive criterion in recommending a candidate for an award. Any use of metrics should take into account the size and the practices in different fields.

In formulating their views, award committee members may seek opinions regarding the candidates from other scientists and experts, whether in Australia or overseas.

Committees are requested to ensure that candidate achievements are judged relative to opportunity. The approach aims to give more weight to the overall quality and impact of achievements rather than the quantity, rate or breadth of particular achievements, which in many instances is directly related to time and resources available rather than talent, merit or excellence. An assessment of a candidate’s opportunity to demonstrate scientific excellence will take into account the factors below, based on the Research Opportunity and Performance Evidence (ROPE) guidelines of the Australian Research Council (ARC).

  • Research training; employment in research positions, either within the research sector or outside academia, including the research component and/or full-time-equivalence of positions; research and development activities; industry engagement; research environment, including supervision, mentoring and leadership; professional development; research management experience, and access to research and support facilities.
  • Career interruptions- including those due to employment outside academia; unemployment, part-time employment; childbirth; parental leave; carers’ responsibilities; misadventure; limited or no access to facilities and resources—such as through workplace interruptions; disaster management and recovery; misadventure; medical conditions; disability; caring and parental responsibilities, community obligations, including Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander cultural practices and protocols or illness.

Taking the above considerations into account, the key question should ALWAYS be: has the candidate made significant research contributions worthy of the award?

Committee members are asked to assign scores for each candidate out of a total of 100, based on a scoring matrix provided by the Academy that allocates a score of up to 100% to scientific achievement. Other factors such as mentorship and international profile can be used as a tie breaker, but not as primary scoring criteria. This is subject to any additional specific criteria of an award.

Recognising that it is not necessary to assign 100 to any particular candidate, total scores of 80 and above indicate an assessor’s support for shortlisting and/or awarding the candidate.

When members score shortlisted nominations, they are asked to keep to a scoring range of 80-100, noting that a score of 100 means that the candidate is outstanding in every way. This is in contrast to an 80, which might mean that the candidate is very strong, but the case is not as compelling as some others under consideration. Members must avoid tied scores. 

In general, Award Committees should attempt to achieve a consensus with respect to the candidate to be recommended to Council. Where this is not possible, the matter should be resolved by a formal vote and recorded in the committee’s report to Council. If the number of votes for any two candidates are equal, the Chair should exercise a casting vote, except for when a Chair’s vote will have an impact on the awarding of a candidate they are conflicted with. In such a case, The Secretaries will be notified to adjudicate.

Committees can recommend that there be no award made in a round if there is a consensus that there is not a sufficiently strong candidate.

Committees can recommend that the award be jointly awarded to more than one candidate and are encouraged to consider doing this if the top two candidates are very close and the second candidate can be shown to represent dimensions of diversity, as defined in the Fellowship nominations diversity dimensions guidelines. However, where there are two candidates in close contention for the award who do not meet this criterion, only one can be recommended to Council. If a second awardee is proposed, the reasoning must be included in the committee’s report to Council. 

Committees will also be requested to provide (when possible) a shortlist of high quality unsuccessful candidates who will be invited to update their documentation for consideration (if eligible) for up to two subsequent awarding rounds. Up to three unsuccessful candidates may be shortlisted if dimensions of diversity are represented. Otherwise, only two unsuccessful candidates may be shortlisted.

Committees will be requested to also provide the names of the runner-up for each award in case there were concerns by Council about the appropriateness of the recommended awardee. 

CHAIR’S REPORT TO COUNCIL

The Secretariat will provide a report template for Chairs to complete. Chairs will provide the Awards Officer with a brief summary (one page) of the deliberations of the committee, how many nominations were received, the shortlist of up to four candidates (including the awardee), the final decision and why the candidate(s) is being proposed to Council for the award, by 5 September. The report should also include the completed register of conflicts of interest (and how conflicts were dealt with) and any recommended changes to the award or to the selection process.

NEW MEMBERS

As part of its recommendations to Council, the award committee should advise on optimum disciplinary makeup of the committee for replacement committee members. 

The Secretaries Physical and Biological Sciences will review the interest received from individual Fellows to sit on award committees and the committee recommendations regarding disciplinary makeup. They will select new members and Chairs as guided by the following selection principles, presenting these to Council annually out of session, for record and oversight:

  • Annually the Fellowship will be consulted on their availability for award and sectional committees.
  • The member expertise across each awards committee will endeavour to cover the fields of the candidates relevant to that committee.
  • When nominations close, new members will be added to any awards committee if the Secretaries consider that expertise is lacking or that conflicts would inhibit the committee in ranking particular candidates.
  • The membership of each awards committee, within the conditions of that award and where possible, will reflect appropriate geographical spread, gender and ethnic diversity as guided by, and in accordance with, the principles provided by the Diversity and Inclusion Advisory Committee  (DIACOM).
  • The Secretaries will also consider members outside of the award discipline for award committees, including corresponding members of the Academy and Fellows of the Royal Society Te Apārangi.
  • The Secretaries will aim to have a minimum of 5 members appointed on each award committee.
  • The DIACOM representative on Council will be tasked to record and feedback to the Secretaries any equity and diversity matters observed in relation to the awards and where shown in the annual award committee reports presented to Council.
  • When appropriate, early- and mid-career researchers and previous recipients of an award will be considered for award committee membership. Fellows of other National Academies and non-Fellows with particular expertise with also be considered.

Noel Sydney Hush 1924–2019

Noel Hush researched electron transfer in electrochemical changes, between metal ions, in covalent bond frameworks, in surface chemistry of gold, and in complex organic and bio-organic molecules.

Image Description

Noel Hush left Sydney with his MSc in 1949 to work in Manchester, and then Bristol, before returning to the University of Sydney in 1971 as the inaugural professor of theoretical chemistry, the first such chair in Australia. His students and collaborators occupy senior positions in Australian and international universities. 

With theoreticians and experimentalists he researched electron transfer in electrochemical changes, between metal ions, in covalent bond frameworks, in surface chemistry of gold, and in complex organic and bio-organic molecules. 

He was a leader among Australian academics, protesting the restrictions placed on Russian Jewish scientists who wished to leave their homeland. 

He was elected to fellowship of the Australian Academy of Science and the Royal Society of London, and he continued research long after the formal retirement age.

Download the memoir

 

Supplementary material

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 36, 2025. It was written by Ian D. Rae and Jeffrey R. Reimers.

John William White 1937–2023

John William White was a pioneer in the application of neutron scattering to chemistry and one of the most influential advocates for neutron facilities globally, particularly in Australia.

Image Description

John William White FRACI FAIP FRS FAA CMG AO (1937–2023) was a pioneer in the application of neutron scattering to chemistry, one of the most influential advocates for neutron facilities globally, particularly in Australia, and was a friend and mentor to a great many neutron-scattering scientists working worldwide. 

This biographical memoir will demonstrate the enormous legacy that he leaves through his service to science by following his career from the University of Sydney to Oxford University – initially as a DPhil student, but subsequently as a fellow at St John’s College – through to Director of the Institut Laue Langevin (ILL) neutron facility in Grenoble, France, before returning to Australia as Professor at the Australian National University in Canberra.

Download the memoir

 

Supplementary material

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 36, 2025. It was written by Elliot Paul Gilbert and Julia Stretton Higgins.

John Oswald Newton 1924–2016

John Oswald Newton was internationally distinguished for his work in nuclear structure and heavy-ion reactions, and played an instrumental role in enhancing Australia’s nuclear science capability.

Image Description

John Oswald Newton (1924–2016) was internationally distinguished for his work in nuclear structure and heavy-ion reactions, and played an instrumental role in enhancing Australia’s nuclear science capability. 

Throughout his work in England, the United States, and Australia, Newton drove pivotal advancements in the study of Coulomb excitation, angular correlation methods, and the alpha decay of odd nuclei, and was a pioneer in the study of high spin states using heavy-ion reactions. 

Major achievements at the Australian National University under his leadership were the installation of a new tandem accelerator, the introduction of a collaborative research ethos to the Department of Nuclear Physics, and a new research initiative into nuclear fusion and fission in heavy-ion collisions. 

Newton’s prior experience at top international laboratories inspired his vision to transform the Department into a world-recognised facility for nuclear physics research.

Download the memoir

 

Supplementary material

 

About this memoir

This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol. 36, 2025. It was written by Katja Curtin, Mahananda Dasgupta and David Hinde.

Statement—Academy endorsement of statement on Improving the reproducibility of biomedical research by IAP for Health

In September 2016, the Australian Academy of Science endorsed the InterAcademy Partnership for Health (IAP for Health) statement on improving the reproducibility of biomedical research.

Image Description

In September 2016, the Australian Academy of Science endorsed the InterAcademy Partnership for Health (IAP for Health) statement on improving the reproducibility of biomedical research.

There is growing discussion within the biomedical research community about the need to improve the reproducibility of research studies so as to drive scientific progress, accelerate translation into clinical applications, and maximise returns on funding. Many improvements in national and global health are rooted in the findings of biomedical research and it is crucial that research practices are as effective as possible.

The Australian Academy of Science has joined with academies of forty five countries around the world to endorse a statement issued by the IAP for Health on improving the reproducibility of biomedical research.

In signing this statement, IAP for Health member academies recognise that:

  • It is critically important for the progress of science that the reproducibility of research is optimal. Where policies to improve national and global health are concerned, they must be based on the best available evidence – the value of research and the efficient use of resources can only be maximised through the most robust science.
  • There is no single cause of irreproducibility and a number of measures are required to address it. These measures will rely on multiple actions from many stakeholders.

The full text of the IAP for Health statement on improving the reproducibility of biomedical research, along with the names of national science academies that have endorsed it, is available on the IAP for Health website.

It should be noted that Professor David Vaux FAA, from the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research, Melbourne, was a member of the working group who put together this statement.

Notes for news editors

The InterAcademy Partnership for Health is a component network of the InterAcademy Partnership. Its membership comprises 78 academies of medicine or academies of science and engineering with medical sections. IAP for Health is committed to improving health world-wide, including through the release of consensus statements on matters of importance to global health. IAP for Health Statements such as this one are prepared by a working group comprising experts nominated by member academies, and are released once they have been endorsed by more than half the member academies of the network.

Statement—Conviction of Italian earthquake scientists

October 2012

Image Description

October 2012

The Australian Academy of Science, a fellowship of Australia’s most eminent scientists, wishes to express its concern about the liability apportioned in the case involving six scientists who gave advice prior to the earthquake in L’Aquila, Italy, in 2009.

Dealing with scientific uncertainty and risk communication is a difficult task. In the case of earthquake prediction, understanding has grown considerably in recent years. Seismologists can forecast regions that are more susceptible to large earthquakes based on broad patterns, but cannot predict the time and precise location of events. The inherent unpredictability of earthquakes makes assessment of short-term risk very difficult and nuances of language in conveying risk can lead to differing interpretations.

The Academy does not have access to information about the Italian case. While the written report of the Court is not expected for some time, it appears clear that it was not the science of earthquake prediction that was on trial. Rather, it was the care taken in delivering the advice that was provided.

The outcome of the trial must be considered in the context of Italian law, and the Academy understands that this outcome is subject to appeal, and that the defendants are free until the appeals process is completed.

The Academy considers the case to be a reminder that while formulating advice based on the best available evidence, scientists must apply due diligence and ensure proper procedures are followed. It also highlights the importance of effective processes to translate scientific evidence and knowledge into public policy and advice.

Endorsement—Biosecurity

November 2005

Image Description

November 2005

The Academy has endorsed the 2005 Inter Academy Panel (IAP) statement on biosecurity. The statement recognises that scientists have an obligation to do no harm, and to take into consideration the reasonably foreseeable consequences of their own activities. As part of the statement, the IAP has developed a set of fundamental principles that scientists can use to formulate new codes of conduct to help avoid the potential misuse of science and technology. The principles address five fundamental issues facing scientists working in the biosciences: awareness, safety and security, education and information, accountability, and oversight.

A full copy of the statement is available from the IAP website.

Ruth Stephens Gani 1927-1997

Ruth Gani (nee Stephens) was born in York, England on 22 February 1927, the only child of Henry and Maggie (Harry and Mimi) Stephens. After attending the Altrincham County High School for Girls, she passed her School Certificate in 1943.

Image Description

Written by J.M. Gani.

Ruth Gani (nee Stephens) was born in York, England on 22 February 1927, the only child of Henry and Maggie (Harry and Mimi) Stephens. After attending the Altrincham County High School for Girls, she passed her School Certificate in 1943.  She began her working career as a Laboratory Assistant at the Imperial Chemical (Pharmaceuticals) Veterinary Research Laboratories in Wilmslow, while continuing her studies at the Salford Technical College Evening School, where she obtained her Higher School Certificate in 1946.

At this stage, she faced a difficult choice between two scholarships, one at the Royal Academy of Music in London to study piano, and the other at the University of Liverpool to study Botany.  She chose the latter and graduated with a Bachelor of Science (Hons) degree in Botany in 1949. She continued to play the piano throughout her life, and was particularly fond of the Mozart sonatas.

She was now appointed a Research Assistant in the Bracken Research Unit of the West of Scotland Agricultural College, Glasgow (1949-52), and was also a part time Demonstrator in Botany at the University of Glasgow.  In 1953, she was promoted to Assistant Lecturer, and attended a course in Plant Cytogenetics at the John Innes Horticultural Institute, Hertford, in 1954.

At the end of that year, she emigrated to Australia to become Research Assistant to Sir Otto Frankel  in the Cytogenetics Section of the CSIRO Division of Plant Industry, where she helped to investigate the genetics of wheat.  Early in 1955, she met Joseph Gani, a Commonwealth Postgraduate Scholar in Statistics at the Australian National University (ANU).They were married on 3 September 1955, and had four children: Jonathan in Perth, W.A. in1957, Miriam in New York in 1959, Matthew in Canberra in 1962, and Sarah in East Lansing, Michigan in 1964.

After the award of his PhD in 1955, Joseph took up various positions in Perth, New York, Canberra (ANU), Michigan, Sheffield, Canberra (CSIRO), Kentucky and California, finally retiring in Canberra in 1994. Ruth always joined him with the children, and managed to make a comfortable home for the family in each new environment. 

While in Perth, Ruth worked as a part time Demonstrator in the Botany Department of the University of WA in 1957-58 and 1960, and was also a Lecturer for an evening course on Genetics at the WEA.  In New York in 1959, she took a course in Developmental Genetics at Columbia University.

On the family's return to Canberra in the early 1960s, she worked as a part time Research Assistant in the Genetics Section of the CSIRO Division of Plant Industry.  In 1965, when the family moved to Sheffield, England, Ruth worked part time in the Centre for Human Genetics of the United Sheffield Hospitals from 1969 to 1974.

On returning to Australia with the family, she worked in 1977 as an Honorary Research Associate in the ANU Department of Population Biology, Research School of Biological Sciences. Between 1978 and 1981, she was the Officer in Charge of the Cytogenetics Section in the Cytology Department of the Woden Valley Hospital (now the Canberra Hospital).

Later. in 1988, she established the Cytogenetics Section of the Haematology Department at this Hospital. While in Lexington, Kentucky in the early 1980s, she enrolled for a Master's degree in Cell Biology at the University of Kentucky, and was awarded her MSc in 1987. Her last job from1994 until 1996 was with the ANU's Human Genetics Department, in the John Curtin School of Medical Research under Professor Sue Serjeantson.

In 1992, Ruth was diagnosed with breast cancer, and underwent a mastectomy.  She appeared to be in remission but by 1995, the cancer had spread and she underwent chemotherapy.  She faced the decline of her health with stoicism and was able to celebrate Christmas 1996 with her family.  In 1997, she was moved to the Hospice on the Acton Peninsula and died there on 28 January 1997.  Her ashes are buried at the Norwood Park Cemetery, Canberra.

Ruth managed to combine her personal life as a wife and mother with an intense dedication to Genetics.  She was a foundation member of the Human Genetics Society of Australasia, and a member of the American Society of Human Genetics.  She was the author of several papers including:

  • "The nucleoli of cultured human lymphocytes I.  Nucleolar morphology in relation to transformation and the DNA cycle".  Exp.Cell Res. 50 (1976) 249-258.
  • "Nucleoli of cultured human lymphocytes II.  Nucleolar fusion and its relation to acrocentric association".  Hum.Genet. 42 (1978) 271-282.
  • Her scientific achievements are commemorated by the Australian Academy of Science's annual Ruth Stephens Gani Medal for Human Genetics, first awarded in 2008.

Her scientific achievements are commemorated by the Australian Academy of Science's annual Ruth Stephens Gani Medal for Human Genetics, first awarded in 2008.

Fenner conferences on the environment

This fund supported a series of environmental conferences on the environment and conservation issues in Australia and its environs.
Historical awards Submission deadline:
Fenner conference icon
Image Description

Award highlights

  • With the generous support of the late Professor Frank Fenner FAA FRS and the late Mrs Bobbie Fenner, the Academy established a series of environmental conferences on the environment and conservation issues in Australia and its environs.
  • The purpose of these conferences was to bring together those with relevant scientific, administrative and policy expertise to consider current environmental and conservation problems in Australia, thereby contributing to the formation of policies that can alleviate some of these problems.

This award will not take applications after 2025. Please see the Workshop Series for the Academy's new program to support scientific workshops.

Fenner conferences on the environment are conferences on the environment and conservation issues in Australia and its environs. Their aim is to bring together those with relevant scientific, administrative and policy expertise to consider current environmental and conservation problems in Australia, thereby contributing to the formation of policies that can alleviate some of these problems. If you are interested in holding a conference, please see the Workshop Series for the Academy's new program to support scientific workshops.  

Past conferences

  • 2026/27: Transdisciplinary strategies to improve accountability for biodiversity conservation in cities
  • 2025/26: Preparing nature and society for a hotter world
  • 2024/25: Characteristics, causes, and prospects of Australian drought under a changing climate
  • 2022/23: Compound events in Australia – strategic planning for multivariate risk
  • 2021/22: Exceptional times, exceptional plants: Alternative ex situ conservation strategies for Australian plants
  • 2020/21: Making Australian agriculture sustainable.
  • 2019/20: Managing wild and weedy Australia across boundaries and disciplines
  • 2018/19: The use of gene drive technology in conservation
  • 2017/18: Urban Sustainability and Conservation
  • 2016/17: International Forward Osmosis Summit (IFOS) 2016
  • 2015/16: Maximising the capacity of citizen science for science and society: A Fenner Conference on the Environment, Shine Dome, Canberra
  • 2014/15: Addicted to Growth?: How to move to a Steady State Economy in Australia, Shine Dome, Canberra
  • 2013/14: Coral Reefs on the edge - new challenges for high latitude coral reef communities, Houtman Abrolhos Island Research Station (PDF, 83 KB)
  • 2012/13: Population, Resources and Climate Change - Implications for Australia's near future, Shine Dome, Canberra
  • 2009/10: Healthy climate, planet and people: co-benefits for health of action on climate change, Shine Dome, Canberra (PDF, 210 KB)
  • 2008/9: The art and science of good environmental decision making. Shine Dome, Canberra (PDF, 210 KB)
  • Wildlife Population Dynamics and Management, Fenner Conference on the Environment, The Shine Dome, Canberra, 2–5 December 2007
  • Water, population and Australia's urban future, 2007 Fenner Conference on the Environment, The Shine Dome, Canberra, 15–16 March 2007
  • Integrating agricultural and environmental imperatives for a profitable and sustainable future, Fenner Conference on the Environment, The Shine Dome, Canberra, 8–9 November 2006
  • Urbanism, environment and health, Fenner Conference on the Environment, The Shine Dome, Canberra, 25–26 May 2006
  • Understanding the population–environment debate: Bridging disciplinary divides, 2004 Fenner Conference on the Environment, 24–25 May 2004
  • Redesigning agriculture for the Australian environment, 2002
  • Biodiversity conservation in freshwaters, 2001
  • Nature tourism and the Australian environment, 2000
  • Future Australian landscapes - visions of harmonious environment, 1998/1999
  • Ethics of manipulative research and management in world heritage areas, 1997
  • Tracking progress: linking environment and economy through indicators and accounting Systems, Fenner Conference on the environment, The University of New South Wales, Sydney, 30 September to 3 October 1996
  • Developing strategies for sustainable habitation of Australia’s rangelands, 1996
  • Environmentally responsible defence, 1995
  • Risk and uncertainty in environmental management, 1995
  • Environmental principles to practice, 1994
  • International trade and the environment, 1993
  • Biological diversity – its future conservation in Australia, 1992
  • Protection of marine and estuarine areas, 1991
  • Ultraviolet B radiation impacts, 1990
  • The Constitution and the environment, 1990
  • Chemicals in agriculture, 1989
  • Conservation in management of the River Murray System-making conservation count, 1989
  • Australian Alps National Parks-World Heritage Area?, 1988

     

One conference is funded annually. Conferences are usually of about two days duration with a membership of 20-30. A sum of up to $10,000 is provided. The supplementation of this sum is encouraged.

Organisers are asked to make an undertaking on acceptance of an offer of funding from the Academy to call their conference a Fenner Conference on the Environment and to advertise it as such.

Research conference applications are in two stages.

Organisers are invited to submit an online Expression of intent (EOI), which should include:

  • proposal (1 page)
    • the aims, value and timelines of the conference, including an indication of support from the local scientific community and the importance for Australian science
    • a tentative program, including expected number of attendee and any known or invited speakers
    • a brief outline of anticipated budget
  • provisional dates and venue
  • names of the organisers
  • how the diversity and inclusion of speakers and attendees will be actively considered and where possible, achieved.

Note that conferences that are one of a continuing series are less likely to gain support unless they specifically address a newly emerging theme or topic within the broader area of the series.

Expressions of Intent are short-listed by the awards committee Chairs in June, and the organisers of short-listed proposals are asked to provide a detailed application by 1 August. Full applications should include:

  • expanded explanation of the aims and value of the conference (up to 1,000 words)
  • a list of projected active participants
  • a detailed program budget, including other sources of income
  • at least one letter of support from the supporting organisation/society.

The final decision is announced in early November.

Venue hire of the Shine Dome is complimentary for up to two days where requested. Please note that AV equipment and technician, catering and caretaking are not included in the complimentary Shine Dome venue hire. Shortlisted applicants are requested to contact the Shine Dome Venue Coordinator for a quote as part of their application budgeting.  At this stage, applicants should also check availability of proposed dates, and a tentative hold will be placed on these dates. Please note that this is not secured until the award is granted, but will increase the likelihood that the dates will still be available if/when awarded.