Dr Kristen Bremmell, chemical engineer
Dr Kristen Bremmell interviewed by Ms Marian Heard in 2001. Dr Kristen Bremmell received a PhD from the University of Newcastle in chemical engineering. Her doctoral studies investigated the fundamental nature of chemicals used in treating industrial wastewater.
Dr Kristen Bremmell received a PhD from the University of Newcastle in chemical engineering. Her doctoral studies investigated the fundamental nature of chemicals used in treating industrial wastewater.
After finishing her PhD, she was a research fellow at the University of Melbourne in the Particulate Fluid Processing Centre, where she worked on a project involving alumina industry tailings.
As a research fellow at the Ian Wark Research Institute at the University of South Australia, her research area is in colloid and interface science. She investigates particle interactions and the effect of different molecules in suspensions of particles. This work is important to the minerals industry in the processing of ores and tailings treatment. A second area of application of her research is the biological and pharmaceutical area where she is working to measure the deformability of red blood cells and looking at titanium bone implants.
Interviewed by Ms Marian Heard in 2001.
Contents
- Early experiences in practical science
- Excitement and independence in hands-on chemistry
- Honours projects in waste treatment
- PhD work: the chemical treatment of waste water
- Amazing experiences in a sugar refinery and beyond
- Projects in mineral processing
- Biological applications
- Fundamental science, funding and commercialisation
- Wide-spread interests and opportunities
- Getting the message out that science is an exciting place to be
Early experiences in practical science
Kristen, would you tell us about your early life and how your interest in science began?
I was born in Newcastle, in New South Wales, in 1970. I had one brother, and we shared a lot of time playing in the garden and around the house, and going on holidays together.
As I was growing up I was always interested in looking at nature – at bugs and plants and how they lived and were made up – and at how things around me worked. My grandfather bought me a chemistry set and was very interested in teaching me things, helping me learn about life and where things came from.
You were good at science at high school, weren’t you?
Yes, I enjoyed science, particularly the practical aspects of it. My physics teacher, Mr Donald, inspired us a lot and we used to enjoy doing the experiments, going outside to look at light refracting, and making little solar instruments that would work in the sun. It was a lot of fun.
While I was at school, thinking I might like to be a vet, I did some work experience at an animal house at the University of Newcastle. That involved me doing all the menial tasks, though – every day, for example, I had to clean out the messy cages for the rats and the three dogs, and feed the sheep. But I had an interesting experience when a kookaburra came in with a broken wing and the vet decided to operate to fix it. I was helping out, but because kookaburras have hollow bones, the gas that was used to anaesthetise the bird came out of its wing and I couldn’t stop yawning!
Excitement and independence in hands‑on chemistry
What subjects did you study for your science degree at the University of Newcastle?
I started out in first year studying chemistry, psychology, computer science and maths. Later on I did a little bit of geology, and majored in chemistry. I ended up doing all the chemistry subjects that I could do.
Did you, like most students, have a part-time job during that time?
Yes, I did – actually, two part-time jobs. I worked in a shoe shop and also in a coal lab, Carbon Consulting, where we analysed coal for moisture and for ash content. We did a lot of ultimate analysis as well, like fluorine and carbon dioxide.
That led to another interesting experience, when one day I was pressuring a vessel with carbon dioxide. Suddenly, as I was filling this vessel, I felt the floor rumble underneath me and there was a big bang – ‘Oh, what have I done?’ I thought. But it turned out to be an earthquake, and we all went outside and watched BHP burning. It was an exciting time.
Did BHP’s large presence in Newcastle influence your decision to go into chemistry?
It had a big influence, I think. I’d grown up with BHP always around, and it was always talked about in school. Many people were encouraged to do science, and engineering in particular, because of BHP. The company provided a lot of scholarships and part-time jobs.
In fact, at the end of third year I was lucky enough to get a job at BHP Research. They gave me the independence to take on projects myself, even as an undergraduate student, and investigate a variety of different things. I looked at the copper sediments from Ok Tedi mines, and at gold leaching; I looked at water treatment and we also did a bit of work on site remediation.
Honours projects in waste treatment
After that you obtained a BHP scholarship to do your Honours in chemistry at Sydney University. What work did you do for that?
I did a waste water treatment project that BHP were interested in. In their rolling mills, in particular, they use an emulsion – a fine dispersion of oil in water – to lubricate the steel as it is rolled. But the emulsion gets quite dirty after a while, so we were trying to break the emulsion, separating the oil from the water, for the water to be reused and the oil disposed of.
Also I did a lot of flotation experiments, supplying air bubbles through a solution. The waste products stick to the air bubbles because they are hydrophobic, and they rise to the surface. You can then remove them and concentrate them up.
PhD work: the chemical treatment of waste water
To do your PhD you returned to the University of Newcastle. What did that involve?
I’d never planned to keep going and do a PhD; I always thought that I would get out and get a job. But I really enjoyed the independence of staying at uni. I think doing a PhD is very independent work.
I was working with a waste-water treatment business, treating industrial waste. There are two different chemicals that they use: a polymer, or a flocculant, and a surfactant, which is a detergent, something that you might use to wash up your dishes. I was looking at the interaction between these two molecules and also how they interact on the surface of a particle. It is important to know how this works so that you can best utilise the chemicals that you are adding to separate the solid waste product from the water. (You don’t want to add too many chemicals, both from an economical perspective and also with respect to the environment.)
We were hoping to understand something about how these chemicals work and how to select the correct chemicals, and then the correct amounts and order of addition, to get the most efficient separation of the waste from the water.
Your PhD graduation was unusual in one respect, wasn’t it?
Yes. It was in the middle of the year, when there is a smaller graduation. Only four chemical engineers graduated, and they were all females, which was quite unusual.
Amazing experiences in a sugar refinery and beyond
For your PhD work you travelled across to Western Australia. Tell us about your experiences there.
I was working as a consultant. We used to do a lot of pilot plant trials, and this particular one was commissioning a plant in a sugar refinery at Kununurra – installing the plant and keeping it working for a little while.
It was a very exciting and interesting time. I worked in the sugar mill, which was an experimental-type mill. They were experimenting with a lot of different technologies, and one reason we were there was to look at inserting some new technology to separate the sugar liquor from the crushed sugarcane.
While I was there I not only got to work on my little bit of the plant, but also found out a lot about how the plant worked and the different processes happening in the plant, right from the crushing through the separation of the sugar juice from the cane, the crystallisation and the drying process, to using the gas to generate electricity for the plant and for the town as well. And I had the incredible experience of going into the control room, where the computer controlled the plant. They actually taught us how to control the whole plant from this room, even changing the chemicals and changing the speed and things that happened. It was a continuous plant, and if you had problems with the sugarcane and you weren’t getting enough feed, you had to slow down the rest of the process so that you didn’t actually ever have to stop.
The town and surrounding area is an amazing place as well, and I went on a few day trips. We went to the Ord River, which was dammed to provide water for agriculture and so on. They grow a lot of different produce around there and also have lots of wonderful fishing. It’s a popular place to go. And during a flight over the beautiful Bungle Bungles we went over the Kimberley diamond mine, another very interesting thing to see. On one trip we went in our four‑wheel drive to El Questro station, where we had a swim in the swimming-hole. The station is a tourist-type place but again is very beautiful, as were the Aboriginal rock paintings that we saw, to our great surprise, on our way to it. So going there was a fabulous experience.
Projects in mineral processing
What did you do after your PhD?
I got a research position at the University of Melbourne, working on an industrial project in the alumina industry. Like a lot of other mineral processing-type industries, they put their waste products into a tailings dam – eventually the water will evaporate off and they can reclaim the land. We were looking at how you could better separate the solids from the liquids, using various mechanical techniques, and also at the various chemicals that are added to do this. If we could end up with a drier product, the land could be reclaimed a lot faster.
And in your current work, at the Ian Wark Research Institute, in Adelaide, two of your projects relate to mineral processing, don’t they?
Yes. One project is on optimising dewatering in mineral processing. That is a little bit similar to the work I did at Melbourne Uni but it involves looking at the whole process, right from the ore extraction through to the tailings dams, and again the different chemicals and mechanical techniques that you can add to optimise the mineral processing.
Another project is looking at polymers in mineral processing. A polymer has a long-chain carbon backbone. We are studying how these molecules adsorb onto particles and flocculate them, or how they might form a steric barrier to allow the particles to slide over each other in a more efficient way for pumping. We do a lot of fundamental work, from looking on a small scale at how the chemicals interact with a surface, right up to looking on a larger scale at the rheology, or flow, of these systems with chemicals present. So we go from the nanometer scale right up to the plant scale, where we do a lot of plant visits and testing of the actual product.
Biological applications
Isn’t there also an interesting biological aspect of your work?
There is. Since I started at the Ian Wark Institute I have been interested in coming into the biological area, and one of the projects I’m involved in is looking at how red blood cells deform to fit through your small capillaries. We plan to use an atomic force microscope, which comes into contact with the red blood cells and measures the force as a sphere approaches a red blood cell, to measure how that red blood cell deforms and also its elasticity. We hope to then be able to apply that to red blood cells from people with different diseases – to look at how these diseases (and different pharmaceuticals) might affect the red blood cells. Then we can apply this to other types of cells as well.
The other project I’m involved in, with a PhD student, is looking at titanium bone implants. When you implant something into your body, you want it to be accepted by your body and then you also want it to adhere quite quickly and become part of your bone structure. We’re looking at the different proteins, which are what adsorbs first onto your bones: how they adsorb, and how quickly and how strongly they adsorb. Once the proteins have adsorbed, then the bone cells are able to come and grow on your implants.
Fundamental science, funding and commercialisation
How is the research at the Ian Wark Institute funded?
The director began the institute on industry money and I’m currently funded that way as well, from the different industry projects that I’m involved with. Other people within the institute are actually funded as part of a Special Research Centre for which the Australian Research Council gives money each year.
Having worked closely with commercial companies in your research, what do you think about the commercialisation of science?
I enjoy the practical, applied aspect of science, so I’m very happy that science is becoming more commercial. Also, the industry provides quite a lot of funding for science which would otherwise be quite difficult to come by. I can see a possible conflict of interest, in that you might be forced to do certain work that a company requires, and in that respect it is important to have very fundamental science as well – which I guess comes from government funding. But I’ve been very happy to work with companies. As long as you supply them with the answers that they want, you can also manage to study fundamental things along the way.
Wide-spread interests and opportunities
Kristen, as well as your research you have a range of other interests, some of which I think began during your school years.
Yes. I like to keep fit. I go to the gym, I do a lot of walking and riding my bike, and I enjoy hiking. When I was young I started dancing in what was called Physical Culture, and I did that until I was in my teens; now I enjoy Latin dancing. I also learnt the piano and I still like to play (but occasionally, when I find a piano). And travel is a big passion of mine. I used to travel a lot with my family around Australia. We had a caravan and we used to go to different places and look around, going caving and walking in the bush, going to zoos and swimming a lot.
Being in science, I’ve been lucky enough to travel overseas quite a few times, sometimes to quite exotic places. On one special occasion I went to a Colloid and Interface Science Conference in Sophia, Bulgaria. A few Australians that I knew were there and also I met a lot of international people, from Europe, the UK and the US. And before coming home I went for a holiday through Croatia and Boznia-Herzegovina, spending a few days in Sarajevo to visit my friend who works for the United Nations. The war there had just finished, and I had the opportunity to experience an amazing combination of different cultures, plus a lot of peacekeepers and UN workers, all in one city. It was like a big party – although it was very sad to see so much destruction. The people have an incredible ability to laugh and enjoy life, simply to get on with life even amidst such destruction and sorrow. It made me feel very lucky.
Three years later I went to a similar conference in Bristol and visited my French friend Sophie, who had gone back to live in France after we did our PhDs together. She was now working with Exxon. We travelled around France, around Normandy, we went to Monet’s garden in springtime. And after the conference, I travelled around Ireland for about 10 days. So that was another amazing trip.
Getting the message out that science is an exciting place to be
What would you tell a young person were the most rewarding or exciting aspects of a career in science?
There are a lot more opportunities available for someone in science than I realised when I started. One, of course, is travel: you can travel overseas with your job (going to a lot of overseas conferences, as I do, gives you the chance to see a wide variety of life and to travel a little bit while you’re there) and also you can get work overseas quite easily, either as a postdoc or in a longer-term job. It’s very much up to you.
I enjoy the wide variety of work you can do, wherever your job may be. You can work in the lab, work with students, work with companies, go on site visits, prepare reports and grant proposals. It’s just an exciting place to be.
What skills do you think are important in science today?
You need a wide variety of skills, not just in your particular area of science or technology. Good communication skills are very important to attract funding and also to talk about your results and excite people about them. You need very good people skills, to interact with a wide variety of people – international people, government people, funding people, students, business people. Yes, you need very good communication skills.
Where do you see yourself in 10 years’ time?
Actually, I’m interested in a variety of things, including science management and policy development, and the communication of science, promoting science awareness. I hope to work on the skills that those things involve, and to just look for opportunities and take them as they come up.
Professor David Craig (1919-2015), theoretical chemist
President of the Australian Academy of Science 1990-94.
President of the Australian Academy of Science 1990-94.
Professor David Craig was born in 1919 in Sydney. He completed a BSc(Hons) at the University of Sydney in 1940 and an MSc in 1941. From 1942 to 1944, his scientific career was interrupted by war service and in 1944 he returned to the University of Sydney as a lecturer in physical chemistry. In 1946 Craig moved to University College, London, where he was a Turner and Newall Research Fellow. On completion of his PhD in 1949 he was appointed lecturer at University College until 1952. In 1952 Craig returned to the University of Sydney to be the first Professor of Physical Chemistry. In 1956 he went back to University College, London as Professor of Theoretical Chemistry. In 1967 Craig came back to Australia when he was appointed Foundation Professor of Physical and Theoretical Chemistry at the Research School of Chemistry, Australian National University (ANU), a position he held until his retirement in 1984. At the ANU he served as Dean of the Research School of Chemistry from 1970 to 1973 and was an Emeritus Professor there since 1984. Professor Craig passed away in July 2015.
Interviewed by Professor Bob Crompton in1998.
Contents
- The early road towards science
- Studying covalent bonds
- War service, firstly in Australia
- To New Guinea and back to Sydney
- At University College, London, for the first time
- Applying molecular orbital theory
- Some stimulating interactions with fellow scientists
- Moving on with spectroscopy
- Marriage and family
- A new Chair in Sydney, and again to London
- In the thick of crystals
- International journeys
- Computers
- Bringing Australians home to the ANU
- Recognition, projects and influential roles
- Honours, a citation classic and a scientific retirement
The early road towards science
David, perhaps you could tell us something about your parents and where you were born.
I had a middle-of-the-road upbringing. My father was a Manchester man who had a very difficult early life. His father died when he was 18 months old, but the father had taken out an insurance policy under which the four children, of which he was the youngest, would all be educated at Cheadle Hulme Grammar School. That is a boarding school close to Manchester, in much the same class as Manchester Grammar. So the children got a good education, and they did very well there.
My father took articles and learned to be an accountant with a Manchester firm. But in 1911, at age 24, he emigrated to Australia for a warmer climate because of his antrum and sinus trouble. Bit by bit he drew the rest of his family out after him, and then in 1915 my mother came out in a boat called the Suevic – safely, despite a trip round the Cape of Good Hope with threats of submarines. My parents were married in Hobart in 1915.
My father teamed up in a firm of accountants called Craig and Fraser, in Sydney, and then went into business in a middle-sized firm called James Sandy and Co., of which he became managing director. The firm manufactured paint and shop-fitting requirements at Redfern and retailed them from a show-room in George Street, Sydney, close to where Wynyard Station is now.
I was born in 1919, at Roseville. My primary education was at Knox Grammar School, at Warrawee on the North Shore line of Sydney, and the secondary part of my education was at Shore – Sydney Church of England Grammar School – in North Sydney. We had a good teaching staff. The headmaster, Mr Robson, was the mathematics master – a Brigade Major in the First World War, very stern but also a very good mathematician. The physics teacher was Mr Fisher, and in chemistry we had E J Clinch, who was really a very good teacher. Unusually, he already knew about resonance and the then modern theory of the valence-bond.
Your own work later has been at the intersection of physics and chemistry, hasn’t it? We never know whether to call it chemical physics or physical chemistry.
I’ve always tried to bridge those two. That’s where my interests have been, throughout.
Studying covalent bonds
When did you go to Sydney University?
I began in 1937 and had the standard four years plus honours course. It didn’t cost my family anything much because like quite a few people I had an Exhibition, which was a publicly funded form of support, and I lived at home. After three years as an undergraduate I was taken on as a student by D P Mellor, who had just come back from Caltech (California Institute of Technology) with the wonderful ‘message as given by St Pauling’ and was full of fire. Linus Pauling had just a few years before that published his famous work on the nature of chemical bonding, particularly covalent binding. By the time that Mellor joined him, he’d got interested in the study of bond type, through magneto-chemistry. You take a standard tube and you pack it with the material of interest, hang it in front of an electromagnet and find what apparent change of mass there is when you switch the magnet on. You can interpret these measurements of susceptibility in terms of the nature of the binding in transition metal coordination complexes. If you’ve got nickel surrounded by four atoms, you can in some cases decide whether they’re square or tetrahedral.
Pauling rationalised the relationship between magneto-chemistry, magnetic susceptibility and bond type in terms of the orbitals that were being occupied in the two sorts of binding. Depending on that occupancy you get a different magnetic property – unpaired electrons in the one case and no unpaired electrons in the other, if we’re talking about nickel. So just by a simple measurement of whether it is paramagnetic or not you can, in favourable cases, discover what the bonds are doing. Mellor and I did that in cobalt, in which a somewhat similar situation applies, with some minor differences.
Pauling was a very interesting man. I saw quite a bit of him later in my career because I got to know his son, Peter Pauling, when Peter worked on the staff at University College, London as a crystallographer. He was one of the first to use computers in X-ray crystal analysis. The father would visit to see him and also to see Christopher Ingold, whom we’ll talk about a bit later on. I have a photograph of Pauling taken in 1973 when he visited the Research School of Chemistry in the ANU.
Later in this initial time at Sydney University, you had your introduction to quantum mechanics, didn’t you?
Yes. It had been discovered in ’26 but in Sydney the message was just filtering through and it was a great novelty. In physics they had Dick Makinson, who was a very able physicist and had grasped quantum mechanics better than others, and in chemistry, Allan Maccoll – who was a great buddy of mine – had spent a vacation working through Dirac’s first book, which is formidable, terribly difficult, and had read other books as well. He gave us a course of lectures in my last year, and got me interested too. Together we worked through a couple of books, doing the best we could with them, trying to get the message.
He was only a few years older than you, wasn’t he, and doing an MSc at the time you were doing honours?
Yes. He’d done a double degree, in maths and chemistry. He later got involved in chemical kinetics rather than theory, but kept both alive. He was the first of us to go to University College, in 1945.
War service, firstly in Australia
Those early days of yours resulted in four or five papers, I think, and several prizes on the way. Your honours year ended after war had begun. Did you join up then?
I finished my honours in about November 1940, and I worked on an MSc over the long vacation and into the early part of ’41. Then the Sydney University Regiment, of which I had been a member for some time, went into camp for about three months and while I was there the rules were varied so that people in reserved occupations – as most of us were – were allowed to enlist in the AIF, at first for service in Australia only but later overseas as well.
After that happened, the Regiment was to be disbanded and the commanding officer, Colonel Stacy, had to decide what to do with his officers. Some went off to anti-aircraft batteries because of the threat already of Japanese bombing. I thought that the thing to do was to try and serve in something in which my scientific training would be useful, and so I went along to talk to Commander Quince, of the Anti-Submarine Unit, who had been a master at Knox when I was there. The Unit was dealing with ASDIC, the use of sound waves to locate submarines, so he tested me in detecting changes of pitch between the reflected and the outgoing sonar beams, which I found very easy. But just as I was leaving he said, ‘Oh well, you’d better do the Ishihara test.’ Being colour-blind I failed the test disastrously, so that was the end of my aspirations to get into the Navy.
I would have thought that a hearing test was far more important!
However, Colonel Stacy, of the University Regiment, had been commander of the 1st Australian Battalion and was an old friend of General Sir Iven Mackay, formerly CO of the 4th Australian Battalion. They had been together on Gallipoli, in the First World War. And just at this time Mackay came back from the Middle East and wrote to Stacy that he was looking for an ADC. Stacy packed me off to Melbourne to try my luck, Mackay took me on and I worked with him for quite a bit.
After the bombing of Darwin we had to go up to see just what had happened. We took off from Mallala airport, north of Adelaide, in an RAAF Avro Anson – a rather ancient pre-war bomber with two engines and only a slight range so that we kept constantly coming down. We were refuelled at funny little airstrips, often by Aboriginals who were very good and quick at it. On we went, step by step, until towards the end of the first day, when darkness was coming down and we were still nowhere near Darwin, the pilot lost his way. There were no radio direction-finding aids available to him and he literally couldn’t find Tennant Creek. We were weaving about, looking for the line of the north-south road, when suddenly he spotted a little group of dwellings and made a landing on a dirt road at right-angles to the north-south road. The plane ran into a ditch but nobody was hurt, so we got out and wondered what to do. Well, in about 20 minutes there was a dust cloud in the distance. In the dusk we watched this thing grow and it turned out to be a Dodge open car of about 1925 vintage, in which there were six very stalwart gents with shotguns. It turned out that the postmistress at old Tennant Creek had sent a message to new Tennant Creek saying the Japanese had landed!
We were taken on from there in a Hudson bomber, through Daly Waters to Darwin, three or four days after the worst of the bombing. We could see all the ships sunk and there were fires still burning in some places.
To New Guinea and back to Sydney
You have a photograph there showing you in New Guinea. What was that about?
Well, later that year we went to New Guinea, this time flying from Townsville to Port Moresby in a Sunderland flying-boat, a very slow aircraft of about 90 knots so that the journey took about four and a half hours. One very interesting trip we made was to Wau, early in 1943 after the action there by the 17th Brigade to repel the Japanese from Crystal Creek. The New Guineans who helped in that had been organised in units, and the photograph shows them with their commander, lined up to have medals presented to them by General Sir Iven Mackay, accompanied by Brigadier Moten, the commander of the 17th Brigade, the Brigade Major of the 17th Brigade and the commander of the local group of ANGAU, the Australian New Guinea Army Unit. I am on the extreme right.
Then your war effort shifted to Sydney, did it?
Technically I was still in reserved occupations, so the Manpower Service arranged for me to return to the University of Sydney, where Professor Fawsitt, the Professor of Chemistry, was looking for new staff. I was mainly lecturing but I did do some work there towards the scientific war effort with Adrien Albert, on the amino-acridines. These bacteriostatic agents inhibit the growth and reproduction of bacteria. Acridine orange was the most famous of them. Albert was developing new ones which were more powerful and which didn’t stain – the acridine orange was a shocker for staining clothes and so on – and he needed someone to work on their ionisation properties and their spectroscopy. So I was lined up to do that with him.
We were very under-equipped. There was no spectrophotometer at all in the University and I had to go and use one at the Royal North Shore Hospital, where Dr Rudi Lemberg, working on the blood pigments – verdohaemochromogen and so on – was good enough to let us use his instrument, on the strict condition I cleaned it up carefully at the end. So we worked on that, and I published a paper on it. But that was my sole contribution to the scientific war effort.
I was back in Sydney in time for the academic session which started in March ’44, when help was needed to teach the large classes that were being formed because quite a few returned soldiers were enrolling by then.
That would have been an interesting mix: raw 17- and 18-year-olds with these people who’d had a lot of experience and had a real drive to get on.
Yes, and very riotous and rowdy the classes were, too. One night, at a meeting of the Chemical Society, a fellow got loose with a fire extinguisher, the old foam type, and was squirting it round everywhere.
At University College, London, for the first time
That stint on staff at the University of Sydney didn’t last long, did it?
No. In the next year, 1945, the first of the Turner and Newall Research Fellowships were advertised for the UK. Allan Maccoll got one and went to work at University College, London with Ingold. The next year, when I applied, the ones on offer were at University College and Liverpool. I had the offer from Liverpool but in the end had another offer from London, which I accepted because for me there was just nothing that could equal the chance to work with Ingold in his department.
During the war the department had been moved from London to Aberystwyth, in Wales. After the worst of the bombing was over, in ’43, it had come back and now Ingold was building it up again. Already there were at least 60 or 70 postgrads there, and that grew very quickly to about 100. He had a great reputation.
Was he a knight already, David?
No, he was knighted after being President of the Chemical Society, which was a few years after that.
And you were one of many Australians seeking that opportunity just after the war?
Yes, absolutely. In 1945 there had been the first departure of people who had had their overseas training delayed by the war, and ’46 was the second major departure. We went on a boat called the Waiwera, which was a cargo steamer really, but with quite a few berths for passengers on board. It was packed with postdocs or postgraduate student hopefuls, of whom you will know Gordon Ada, Douglas Waterhouse and also Edwin Salpeter, who went first to work with Peierls in Birmingham, on infinities in quantum electrodynamics, and then to the US to work with Hans Bethe at Cornell, where he has stayed the whole of his working life. He was made an Honorary Fellow of this Academy.
How did you find London and University College, so soon after the end of the war?
London itself was cleared of a lot of the rubble but very little building had been done, and you could see the nature of the damage – houses were split in two and you could see torn wallpaper inside the rooms, and the baths and so on. An extraordinary sight. The streets had weeds growing in them – it was a scene of desolation. And the College itself had been badly bombed in two big raids in ’40 and ’41, probably because it was close to Euston Station, close to Kings Cross. There was huge destruction in the library – many of their most valuable manuscripts had been sent off to Wales and were safe, but the ordinary, run-of-the-mill science serials had largely gone and had to be replaced, at great expense. Although the rubble had been cleared, it hadn’t been replaced by anything and part of the library was just a blank space.
Chemical Engineering had been flattened and a lot of the other buildings had been damaged, though Physics and Chemistry had escaped, fortunately. But it was really a pretty pathetic sight and the buildings hadn’t been properly maintained inside. The chemistry laboratories were really primitive and dirty, but there was a great spirit.
What about equipment?
Oh, that was quite good. It had gone the double journey to Wales and back. But in addition to that, big firms like ICI had been very generous in building the College up and during my time we got lots more equipment, usually from industry. So it was really in good shape.
But the main thing was the extraordinary vitality and the total research orientation of the place, which was something that I hadn’t really experienced with intensity before. Everybody really had their heads down. And the teaching loads on staff were very light. In my time I think I gave 30 lectures a year, which was an average load and yet was nothing compared with today’s load.
Who were some of the people you met at University College?
On arriving I was astonished to see people like J B S Haldane in the common room, holding court with his acolytes – a very interesting man – and J Z Young, about whom I remember an allegedly true story. J Z Young worked on the nervous system of octopuses and the way they responded to sounds. So, in pursuit of his research, he applied to the Science Research Council for a ‘digital tone generator’. When, in due course, this request was approved, he bought himself a piano! Well, that was one way of generating tones. Andrade was also there, and D R Bates and Harrie Massey.
You have told me that your PhD took two and a bit years. It’s enormously to your credit that, immediately on conclusion of your PhD, you were appointed to the staff of University College.
Well, I think they were pretty hard up for staff. I don’t feel all that flattered. Anyway, I liked being appointed to the staff: it was security. My fellowship paid six hundred a year, which wasn’t all that bad, but I was getting married at about that time and the little extra came in handy.
Applying molecular orbital theory
What was your main scientific interest during that spell in University College?
When I was doing my doctorate, knowing the interest in the department in benzene I worked on the theory of the excited states of benzene – although they had been experimentally characterised to a degree, theoretically there was no proper account of them. First I enlarged the existing method of valence-bonds, and added a different kind of structure in which there were separated plus and minus charges as well as ordinary covalent bonds. I got from that a reasonable picture of the excited levels of benzene, of which two by that time had been roughly characterised so I had a kind of test.
But then I got interested in the serious discrepancy between that theoretical picture of benzene and the molecular orbital picture which had been developed beforehand by Mulliken, amongst others. Working through some work that had been done in 1938 on the molecular orbital theory in which the parameters were all calculated instead of being empirically fitted to experiment, as was the pattern of the time, I was struck that there was something very odd about the results. The separations between the states were sometimes smaller than the coupling integrals between them, so that it really made no sense to claim that those states were physically real. What you had to do was to work it out again, including all that interaction between configurations, and that’s what started me off on the business of configuration interaction. Once that was done, it all began to fit into place – not with great numerical precision, but with agreement in the ordering of the states, which was the first thing you had to look for.
Next I had an interesting, enjoyable period of working with Ian Ross, who was one of my first PhD students and also had worked with me a bit in Sydney so we were very comfortable working together. We wanted to improve the integrals that went into these computations – technically it’s the change from two carbon centres to three and four carbon centres that you’ve got to accommodate. Then I had a letter from Robert Parr, an American who was working with Mulliken in Chicago, saying that they were working with these integrals and he’d got a few himself, and would we like to team up and do a joint trans-Atlantic effort, in which we’d recalculate the whole business, using Parr’s integrals and ours? We agreed to do that. I’d never met him, didn’t meet him for 10 years, but we had a good correspondence and published a joint paper which really for the first time got sensible agreement between theory and experiment.
To extract the roots of a six by six determinant for this work, as we had to do, was a formidable task using the mechanical calculators of the time and was really a full day’s work. And to allow for mistakes it all had to be done twice – we did it once in London, and Parr repeated everything in the US before we could accept that it was right. Now, of course, we can do it in microseconds.
Some stimulating interactions with fellow scientists
We’ll come back later to what computers have done for your field. But first would you like to tell us about your interaction with Teller? It began while you were at University College and continued on and off for some time, I believe.
Yes, that’s right. Edward Teller had been a refugee from Europe in about 1933. Donnan and Ingold, at University College, had given him facilities and accommodation, and Teller in that time had done his famous work with Jahn, the two papers on the Jahn-Teller effect. Because he’d published a paper with Herzberg in ’33 about the interaction of vibrations and electronic motion and that was involved in what Ingold was doing with benzene, there was a natural affinity there and Teller was a theoretical adviser to Ingold and influenced a lot of what went into those famous benzene papers. There was a continuing connection after Teller left and for a long time he was a frequent visitor to the department. I met him on one of those visits.
I’d been working – I suppose really because of Ingold’s interest – on this very problem of vibrational electronic interaction in benzene, as an element in the structure or the spectrum you observe. The problem was not the identification of it but the magnitude, and I had a little model that gave me a magnitude and made a certain amount of sense. When I talked to Teller about it, he was much interested and suggested that I go to work with him in Chicago, as I guess it was at that time, saying that I could work with Mulliken too. I thought it was a bit rich but I’d better try, but to get there I had to apply for a Harkness Fellowship. I didn’t get one, so the whole thing ran into the sand, but I have had many contacts with Teller over the years.
Teller was a wonderful man for discussing a problem with, even though it wasn’t at the top of his mind. We were working on naphthalene at one stage at UC but couldn’t make head nor tail of the problem we encountered. When Teller turned up I told him about it, and he said, ‘Oh, what’s naphthalene again?’ I drew him a picture on the blackboard and said what we thought the orbitals were like, and the electron eigenfunctions and so on. I said we couldn’t really determine which way the first transition would run, along the big axis or the small. He waggled his leg, as he always did sitting on the edge of the table, thinking about it, and in the end he produced an answer which actually was not right but it was brilliant to see the man’s mind ticking over in something that was foreign to him. I don’t suppose he’d thought about that for donkey’s years.
He was quite a forceful character, wasn’t he?
Oh yes. He and Ingold had wonderful discussions and occasionally the junior people like me would be invited along to dinner with the two of them. Of course, we didn’t get a word in while they were batting ideas about. It was the same with Pauling. He and Ingold used to dine together and take us along – wonderful experience. They’d be talking about things that I’d never heard of at the time, such as the Hall effect. Well, I didn’t think Ingold would know what it was. Pauling I’m sure would have, but there they were batting it back and forth.
You said that Teller worked with Herzberg quite a bit. Did you ever meet Herzberg?
Oh yes. Herzberg was a frequent visitor at the College also. He was a supremely good experimental spectroscopist and he was much helped by Teller in the theory. I think Teller was a constant consultant for him throughout many years before Teller got into the nuclear field so deeply.
This was about the time of your second interaction with Maccoll, too, wasn’t it? Was he already on staff at University College then?
Not quite. He had just about finished his PhD on gas kinetics, but he was on the staff before I was and so we were able to get together and work on some of these problems that we’d worked on in Sydney, particularly on what were called the nonbenzenoid aromatic molecules.
This is a class of aromatics, of which benzene is the father and naphthalene and anthracene are the next in line. What distinguishes them is that you’ve got alternating double and single bonds round the rings. There are other systems with that property which are not aromatic, for some reason. For example, there’s the molecule that has two five-membered rings, called pentalene, with alternating double and single bonds, but at that time it had not been made. People had tried very hard to make it. Another one, called heptalene, has two seven-membered rings, same property. So we got together to work on this problem and we found ways of making distinctions between it and the regular aromatics in terms of symmetry properties.
Purely theoretical?
Purely theoretical, yes. We discovered that whereas the ground state of the normal aromatics was totally symmetrical in the symmetry group, the other ones were not. So if you could find a rule for saying which would go this way and which would go that, you would enable people to say straight off, without trying, ‘Well, this is a pseudo-aromatic. It won’t be easy to make.’ We did put out some rules which worked quite well for a few years, but then an exception was found and that was that. We had the pleasant experience later on of people successfully making these molecules and finding they really were very unstable – decomposing very quickly.
I have here a picture of Allan Maccoll and me that was taken probably in Bologna, with Christopher Ingold and Angelo Mangini, one of the great fathers of post-war Italian chemistry. There was a very interesting connection between Mangini and Ingold. Italian chemistry had suffered dreadfully during the war. The bombing in Bologna was formidable – the railway yards were blown to smithereens – so after the war they had almost nothing. But under the Marshall Plan, by which Europe could be, to a degree, built up again with American funds, with Ingold’s support Mangini had succeeded in getting a very good swag of equipment. There was a strong friendship between them. When I first got to Bologna, the first thing that I saw was great piles of equipment in boxes, under the Marshall Plan, not yet unpacked.
Ingold and I went together on that occasion. We flew to Milan, and Mangini had sent his driver and his large, grand Fiat car to meet us. We set off back to Bologna, through villages, up and down – they didn’t have the Autostrada in those days. Our driver had driven in the Mille Miglia, the great motor race of those days, and he was mad, wild. Up and down these hills, with the local inhabitants scattering to right and left. When we finally arrived in Bologna he said, ‘Oh gee, I said to the boss I’d be here five minutes ago, and we’ve only just made it now.’
Moving on with spectroscopy
After a while your students at University College were doing experiments that were all spectroscopy, weren’t they?
Yes, and at that stage I was doing a bit of experimental spectroscopy myself, sharing the work. We got into the business of identifying spectroscopic transitions between two triplet states. In benzene, for example, normally the only states you can see are singlet states – that gives you the ordinary spectrum. But if you get it at low temperatures and you irradiate hard with ultraviolet, some of the molecules will slip into a triplet state. While they are in that state you can measure the spectrum again, and that’s what Ian Ross and I began doing at that stage. We had interesting contacts at that time with Michael Kasha, who was a student of G N Lewis in Caltech – again a US connection in our work.
Our early work with crystals has its own bit of interest. To get decent crystal spectra you had to have very cold conditions. Liquid nitrogen was available to us but not cold enough; you could still see too much vibrational excitation. So we decided the only thing to do was to go for liquid hydrogen – liquid helium was not available – and we had a special Dewar flask constructed for it in the workshops at UCL. There were two Dewars, one for use in the spectra, to cool the crystal down, and the other just to carry the stuff round. We discovered that F E Simon at Oxford was making liquid hydrogen in their laboratories and was willing to supply it, so Peter Hobbins, who was my student working on this, took a Dewar flask up on the train and brought it back, several times. But then, to our dismay, there was a huge explosion in the Oxford hydrogen generator – caused by condensation of oxygen from the atmosphere on the surface of the hydrogen, after which the obvious happened. But we’d been carrying this stuff up and down on the public trains for months!
It’s remarkable, then, that we’re having this interview.
Yes. What is most surprising is that Peter Hobbins survived all the hard work of getting it there and back. And it worked to a degree. Before this terrible explosion we’d got quite a few results, but that was the end because hydrogen was recognised to be just too dangerous. So no more really low temperatures until helium came along.
Marriage and family
You mentioned that you were getting married at about the time you were appointed to the staff of University College. This is probably the time to say something about your marriage and family. Was your wife-to-be an Australian?
Yes. I’d met her in about 1944, on a train between Sydney and Nowra. We’d been on a hike to the Shoalhaven. Meeting her was the best thing that ever happened to me. Then she came and joined me in England in ’48, and we were married in Reading, in Caversham. On making our decision we went to see the parson, and I had to explain to him that although I’d been brought up in a Church of England school and during the war on my ‘meat-ticket’ I’d had ‘C of E’ written – in case the worst happened – I really was not a religious type of person. When he said that was all right, I went on, ‘But I think we’d like to see the church some time.’ He said, ‘Oh, that should be possible. What about 11 o’clock on Sunday morning for morning service?'
We have four children, of whom Andrew is the eldest, born in August 1949. He was at school in England and later did engineering at the University of Sydney and also environmental science at Murdoch. He now combines those, as an environmental engineer managing a fire control program in the extreme north of Western Australia, with a view to encouraging desirable species and discouraging weeds.
Our second, Hugh, is an academic in the Department of English at the University of Newcastle. He works in part on the computer recognition of authorship, taking a piece of writing and analysing the use and frequency of words in it, in order to compare it with authentic samples writing by a known author such as, say, Jonson or Shakespeare and say that it certainly – or probably – is or is not by them.
Number three is our daughter, who is a doctor in Sydney, married to a solicitor. She practises medicine as much as she can with three children. And our fourth is a senior lecturer in the Department of History in the ANU, so we have two out of four academics. We’re up to seven grandchildren now.
A new Chair in Sydney, and again to London
I think you were only at University College for another couple of years before you got a call back to Sydney.
Yes. In Sydney the Council had decided to change the structure of the Department of Chemistry – which had hitherto had two Chairs, Organic and Inorganic – by calling it a School and adding a Chair in Physical Chemistry. I came out to be their first Professor of Physical Chemistry in ’52, I suppose that was. It was a very different department, with quite a bit of equipment – nothing like what I’d been used to in London but it was a good deal better place to work in by then – and very good people on the staff, with a strong research orientation. That’s been a feature of Sydney.
You got your Chair in Sydney when you were still a very young man, about 32. Arthur Birch also took up a corresponding Chair. Was that your first encounter?
Yes, because he’d left Sydney for England well before the war, probably in 1937. We got on famously together in Sydney and we were quite a useful combination, with a few battles to fight. Equipment money was ludicrously short – you had to beg for a few hundred pounds. We begged together and we got a bit of money, but not enough really. It was an interesting school, with Le Fèvre as head and Professor of Inorganic. Arthur was Organic and I was Physical.
I suppose you were dealing mainly with theory by now.
Well yes. I was not doing experiments but I was still running them. One very interesting project was again on naphthalene because we were still concerned to identify experimentally what the excited states were. We got the idea that if we could make a vapour absorption spectrum we could perhaps detect from the nature of the contours of the bands what the directional properties were. It had been done for diatomics, where it was a well-known method. I had a very able and interesting student called Max Redies, who had been in Sydney working with Thomas Iredale, and he was a rather chubby, tubby man. We found that the only way we could get enough vapour pressure of naphthalene in the spectrometer, because we didn’t have a heated tube, was to warm the whole room. So we warmed the entire room to 35 degrees Celsius or more and poor old Max Redies was in a terrible state – he was almost liquid!
We were fortunate to have a Hilger large-quartz spectrograph, which I think Iredale had got years before. Its resolution was just enough to detect a difference in the contours of two of the sets of bands. Armed with those few spectra I went back later to London, where we got a proper spectrometer onto it and that then resolved them comfortably.
This stay in Sydney was fairly short, wasn’t it?
Yes. I heard from Ingold that he would like to get me back in his department, having already got Nyholm back from Sydney Technical College. They had everything that opened and shut in equipment, and an excellent supply of research students and postdocs – it was irresistible. So I went back in ’56. By then London had been greatly rebuilt – despite great blanks in South London – and the College was largely restored. It was a different world to work in. The library was still a bit deficient, but much had been done to restore it and we had libraries close by, such as at the University of London.
In the thick of crystals
What was the focus of your work by that time?
By then I was in the thick of crystals. Liquid helium was easily available and had transformed the whole crystal spectroscopy scene. You could get fine structure that was invisible otherwise. I got some theory going, because in crystals you find that spectral transitions that are single in the molecule get split into two or four separate components, and the magnitude of that splitting can tell you what the characteristic of the transition was, its transition moment. It’s a very important number. This Davydov splitting was named for a Russian who had done the first work on it, showing that it would exist, but we couldn’t get the magnitudes of the intensities right. We got the idea that you had to allow not only for the splitting but for the effect of the crystal field on the mixing of what in the free molecule were separate transitions. They got melded and merged in the crystal. Once you do that, in a certain class of transition the intensities come right. For very weak transitions we had to use a different trick theoretically, but we got to the bottom of all of that.
What was your collaboration with E A Power?
Well, when you work out the interaction between the transition dipoles in the crystal, which underlies the splitting, you’ve got to find out the dipole-dipole interaction sums. But that raises a very tricky problem because, as is well known in static dipoles in three-dimensional arrays, the value of the sum depends on the surface shape: it’s different for a sphere, an ellipsoid and so on. Edwin Power, who was an applied mathematician at University College, already knew that if you used retardation in the potentials – that is, allowing for the speed of propagation of the signal from one dipole to another – then convergence looked possible. The sum wouldn’t be shape-dependent. So Power and I worked on that problem and elaborations of it, beyond just dipole sums into the interaction of optically active molecules, which was the main focus of our work, and also on the theory of the dispersion interaction at long range. That two-way collaboration worked out very well and our association has continued, but the irony was that the problem that I’d first discussed with him turned out to have nothing whatever to do with retardation.
Another colleague, the Sri Lankan Thirunamachandran, began with you round about that time too.
Yes. (He accepts just Thiru as a name.) He was a member of staff in the University of Ceylon, as it was then called, and came to do a PhD with me. In those days, because you couldn’t get a PhD in Ceylon you could be put on the staff without a PhD, so he’d had some research experience. We worked then on crystals, not on dipole sums but on ones like quadrupoles, which do converge. After his PhD he went back to their staff, and a few years later I got him back to a vacancy on our staff in London, where he stayed and is now a Reader. We’ve collaborated, off and on, ever since – and very often Edwin Power has been in the group as well.
Another very famous Australian at University College around that time was H S W Massey, whom you mentioned earlier. He was a Fellow of this Academy till he died.
I knew him quite well. He became Quain Professor of Physics, but when I first knew him he was Professor of Mathematics, running courses on scattering theory as he prepared to write either the second edition of his first book, or his second book. A number of us from Chemistry went over to hear his excellent lectures but as a kind of price for attending these lectures he inveigled us into working through the examples in his book, which were really quite hard going. He was quite a good cricketer. We used to have Physics vs Chemistry matches out at the College grounds, and he would turn out for Physics. Massey and Ingold formed a pretty formidable pair, and working together they could get finance and most of the things they wanted out of the College committee.
International journeys
At about this time you established a number of international links. Travelling here, there and everywhere wasn’t all that easy in those early days, was it?
It was difficult. I had been to Europe, but the very first trip I made to the US, in the ’50s, was under the aegis of the Office of Naval Research. In those days it was easy to have contracts to do such things, and one of the perks was that you could get a free ride to the US on a military-type aircraft. John Pople, Stuart Walmsley, various others and I were going to the first meeting of the International Molecular Crystal Symposium, in Durham, North Carolina, and we were offered rides on the Military Air Transport Service of the US Army.
The first thing you had to do was to be made a member of the military, so we were all made Majors overnight: Major Pople and Major Craig and Major Somebody Else. We all went up to Mildenhall to get on board a converted Second World War bomber – very uncomfortable, with metal seats, and very noisy. As we were getting towards Newfoundland, there was word from the captain that he was having carburettor icing problems and would have to land at Harmon Field, which is a military air force base in either Iceland or Newfoundland. So we had to spend a very uncomfortable night in the other ranks' quarters there while the problem of the carburettors was being looked into. We got off next day but when we arrived at Newark, New Jersey, at night, there was nobody in attendance. (It was the military airfield, not the civilian one.) ‘Major John Pople’ got on the blower and made a fuss, and finally somebody came out, took us on board and helped us with the rest of the journey – but too late for the opening of the conference.
On these international journeys, such as that one to the United States, were you going to conferences or to visit specific people?
That was a specific conference, but we did other things as well. Pople, Walmsley and I hired a car and did a lot of visiting, in Canada as well as the US, and a number of collaborations grew out of such visits. For example, I worked with Bob Gordon, of Kingston, Ontario, on the spectra of highly dilute vapours, with some nice outcomes. A number of other students I met there or later but I can’t think of any particular research projects that came out of that. The contacts were always useful, of course.
Unfortunately, in the course of the crystals meeting I got mumps, one of the early signs of which is a very bad breath, halitosis. The first I knew of it was that I’d be sitting on a bench with people, talking science, and I would see them edging away a bit! By the time I got to Hamilton, Ontario, it was full-blown mumps, but fortunately an old University College pal, Ron Gillespie, who was there as Professor, and his wife took me in. It was something for them to do that, and otherwise I would’ve been in a bad way. Afterwards I made a few more trips in Canada and then came back.
You said you had been to Europe as well.
Yes. Some of the most interesting trips were to Eastern Europe. In 1958, when I was still at University College, the British Council sent me to Czechoslovakia and then to Russia for a month each – very instructive. In Russia it was bureaucratic madness in those years. To make even the slightest variation to arrangements that had been agreed beforehand was almost impossible. I wanted to change from train travel to air travel between Moscow and St Petersburg, or Leningrad as it then was. I started quite early: I spoke to my guide and I spoke to the guide’s boss, and then I spoke to the head of the department. I kept on speaking. Their standard response was always, ‘We will see what can be done.’ But the day came and went before any action. In the end nothing was done and I travelled by train, the Red Arrow, from Moscow to Leningrad. Czechoslovakia was much freer. You didn’t feel the same weight round you. I’m sure it’s changed in Russia now, but it was really a formidable undertaking in those days. It was a tremendous relief to me to get out to Finland. I felt, ‘Well, now I can breathe again.’
Did you meet Davydov during your Russian trip?
Yes, at the University of Moscow – and also in London. We had many contacts.
I believe you had an arduous journey by sea which had some amusing aspects to it.
This happened when my family and I were returning to London in 1956. Again we travelled by cargo steamer, this time the Imperial Star, of the Star Line. We left from Brisbane, travelling around the north of Australia through Torres Strait and across towards Aden. But when we were a day’s steaming from Aden the message came through that the Israeli war had broken out, so we did a 90 degree turn to port and went down to Cape Town. It had been a full month from one sight of land to the next, and the crew was pretty restive. There was some trouble in Cape Town and they came on board loaded with the local grog, there was a bit of a fight and one of them was knifed in the chest.
There were eight passengers on board, of whom my family accounted for five, with the ship’s doctor and his wife and a Lady Monckton. The ship’s doctor was fresh out of medical school and he hadn’t really much experience. When the captain said, ‘I’m sorry, doctor, but we’ve got a knifing, in the chest,’ he said, ‘I haven’t any idea about chests!’ The captain told him, ‘Well, you’re it. Get on with it.’ He did his best, the man duly recovered, and on we went. It was about eight weeks from Brisbane to our landing in Hull, and all that intervened.
Computers
You have brought with you a primitive means of calculating. What is it?
It is called a Curta hand calculator, and it enables you to do simple arithmetic – you can multiply and divide. Supposing you want to multiply a number by another one, you put the first number down here in these little channels and it shows up like this. If you want to multiply that by 25, let’s say, you do two rounds, move it one position, and then five more. Then you read the result off and it’s never wrong.
I began, as probably others did, with the Fuller calculator, which was a form of slide rule wound on a cylinder so that you had about five feet of effective slide rule length to work on. They were quite good for their time.
I take it that neither of those was the sort of thing you were doing your large computations on at University College.
No, they were not any good for diagonalising matrices. The electromechanical ones we had in London were noisy and slow but were a good deal better than anything we’d had before. We had Brunsvigas but then we had the Marchant electromechanical calculator and extracting the roots of a six by six determinant was really a full day’s work. Ian Ross was very good at it, and I don’t think you could’ve beaten his record of about a day. Now, of course, we can do that in microseconds.
People had immense patience, didn’t they?
Oh yes. Anything beyond six by six I think I would have baulked at, though people tell me they’d done eight by eights. That must have been about a week’s work. And with those machines you get a partial result which you have to write down and re-enter, so if you’re doing it by hand there are mistakes.
You had to be very precise, too, in aligning the figures on slide rules accurately to get three or four figures off them. Your field must have profited enormously from the revolution in high-speed computing power since the days of a five-figure log book or a slide rule or other gadget. In your later days you even worked on supercomputers, didn’t you?
Yes. The factor of improvement in computing speed that I’ve seen in my working life is about 1012, so that it’s just a different world now. When I say this to experimenters, they say, ‘Well, it’s a funny thing, but that’s the same order of improvement that we have seen in the period of the minimum flash that we can use in photochemistry. It used to be, in the old days, about a hundredth of a second, and now it’s around a femtosecond.’ You just wouldn’t contemplate undertaking these structure calculations back then, and the world of ab initio calculations of small molecules was simply not within sight 20 years ago. Now people can get very precise results on sizeable molecules, just because computers are so powerful.
Bringing Australians home to the ANU
You have made many oscillations between Australia and Britain and elsewhere, but in 1967 it was back to Australia, to the ANU. What was the background to that?
The first indication was a visit to London by Hugh Ennor (later Sir Hugh Ennor, Secretary to the Department of Science). He was then working in the ANU, and came to talk to Birch and to me and to Ron Nyholm in our various haunts in England. It wouldn’t have done for the College to have any inkling of what was going on at that stage, so we met outside the College, in an Express Dairy Cafe on Euston Road – one of those places where the early morning clerical assistants nip in for a quick cup. So we looked at one another across a pool of coffee left by other drinkers and he explained to me what the ANU had in mind, which was essentially that they wanted to create a centre of chemical research which was so good that it would attract back some of the cohort of young, able scientists from Australia who’d gone to the US or Britain. The ANU wanted somewhere excellent that these people could return to, somewhere very well equipped and all the rest of it. That caused my first spark of interest, and I think Nyholm and Birch reacted with similar interest. We made about three trips out to talk to Council and to Huxley, the Vice-Chancellor.
When the project began to take shape we got serious and we agreed to participate, and then the University agreed to plan the building. They sent an architect and an architect’s draughtsman to London, who set themselves up in a room the University had hired in Brown’s Hotel, Half Moon Street. It was all frightfully secret as we three ‘advisers’ to the project would troop down there, separately or together, to tell them what we thought was required for the various floors of Inorganic, Organic or Physical. They would build them into working drawings; we’d go again and confirm; and this went on. After a month or six weeks we had agreed working drawings.
But at the very last moment there was a hitch: a telephone call from Tom Owen, who was the building works supervisor, to say that funds had unfortunately run down a little bit and we’d have to change the module from 12 feet to 10. The module is the unit of building, the scale, so this was a shocking blow. But the architects took it nobly and we had no alternative but to say okay, we were still interested. And so the building was revamped at quite a late stage to accommodate that change of size.
But it’s a very fine building, isn’t it? Arthur Birch was very proud of how well it was done and how well it looks. It’s a relatively cheap form of construction, I believe.
Yes, the external building was very cheap, and in appearance it does show a good, strong vertical treatment. The secret of its success is that there are no internal walls. There are pillars, of course, but the internal accommodation can be juggled with great freedom, so a laboratory can be made bigger or smaller just by shifting partitions. We insisted on excellent servicing, with everything laid on – nitrogen gas and all the rest of it – and we were well looked after with equipment.
Did you not come out till it was complete?
No, although we were out at least once, maybe twice, in the course of construction. We had the great good fortune to have on site the man who became the lab manager, John Harper, who supervised construction or looked after it from the user’s point of view, and Rod Rickards, who looked after it from the scientist’s point of view. Rod had been recruited from Manchester, where he had been with Arthur Birch. The building is very well adapted to its purpose. We have no great revisions that with hindsight we’d like to have made – and of course the secret is to have no internal walls.
Recognition, projects and influential roles
I want to turn now to your role in the Academy, David. Just after you’d returned to Australia to take up the appointment at the ANU, you were elected to the Royal Society. I wonder whether they were trying to entice you back to Britain once more.
I don’t think they would have thought of me as important as all that, Bob. No, I don’t think there would be any coupling between those possible events.
You were elected to this Academy one year later, and became Treasurer in 1985, for four years – that’s quite an onerous job – and then President from 1990 to 1994. The Academy was doing a number of things while you held each of those positions. What do you think are the highlights of that time?
Well, certainly my recollection of the Treasurer’s appointment was of dealing with the Becker Bequest, which was a major thing from the Academy’s point of view. Becker was a huge benefactor of the Academy and had already donated the Dome, and we knew that we were beneficiaries under the will even before my time as Treasurer. The will was contested for some time, however, and there were separate parts of the bequest – jewellery and so on. It all came to a head, as it were, in my time as Treasurer and we had to learn how to invest and how to exploit the talents of our Finance Committee, who greatly helped us. They included Ian Potter, the sharebroker – he was very influential not only in that capacity but also through the Potter Foundation and his contacts – and Meredith Ryan, secretary to AMP, and Sir John Wilson, of the paper manufacturers APM. He too was a very shrewd businessman. Also, Ros Greenwood, who came at that period, was a tremendous help with the investment side. That was my biggest task at that time.
The Australian Foundation for Science has gone from strength to strength, hasn’t it?
Yes. The Foundation was separate from the Becker estate. It had been in the mind of the previous President, David Curtis, but it took shape in my Presidency. In fact, that’s the major thing we were about. We made inquiries widely and we got professional help from the National Fund Raising Counsel of Australia for a funding campaign.
We had to do a lot of legwork trying to influence big companies to help us. Keith Boardman was very often with me when we did that. Our very first approach was to CRA, and by a stroke of the greatest good fortune John Ralph said yes and gave us $125,000. We could hardly believe that this was fundraising – this was munificence of a high order – but it never happened again. We did the rounds of many, many firms, but although they were all interested and many have since supported us by way of project finance, that has not been untied finance such as CRA gave us. That was marvellous.
We have had some successes, and in the course of that Presidency we had Primary Investigations getting under way and Environmental Science, both of which have been very successful. I really think the Foundation was what I was most interested in and concerned with, and it’s going very well.
Besides the behind-the-scenes interaction that there has always been between the Academy, through its senior officers, and government, you were also on the Prime Minister’s Science and Engineering Council and a member of the QEII Fellowship Scheme. When were you on the Executive of CSIRO?
That was from 1989 to ’95. That was a big task, one I enjoyed very much. I was involved in the health and safety problems, because one of the staff – at Fishermens Bend, I think – had died from exposure to some chemical or other and Barry Jones, the then Minister, insisted that there be a proper health and safety investigation by a committee. I was made chairman of that committee, and we had some very good people, outsiders, on it. We went to most of the CSIRO Divisions and came up with recommendations which were really quite severe, but I was pleased that the Executive adopted most of them and they’ve been put in place. When I came to finish my term on the Executive I had a nice letter from Barry Jones which said, ‘On your having now reached 65, I can no longer appoint you to the Executive – unless you can change your age or become a woman.’ So my term with the CSIRO ended.
Did you have any exciting times on the PMSEC?
It was a time when that Council was establishing itself as influential, although its influence has fluctuated since. Bob Hawke, who was the Prime Minister at that time, was almost always present at Council meetings for most of the day and he did take account of what people were offering by way of suggestions. The members were then a mix of industry and academic and university people, and you got a lot of very interesting opinions thrown up. There were subcommittees appointed, which reported back, and I do think it was influential.
And the QEII Fellowship Scheme has done a tremendous amount of good work.
Yes, that was very good. It was eventually subsumed into a government scheme, to my regret, but we did have excellent conditions to offer. The salary was good, the tenure was quite long, and we got very good people applying, many of whom have since gone on to important positions. That was very satisfying. When it became incorporated into a wider government scheme that had different levels, it kept the name QEII for the top level of it. You can still get a QEII Fellowship.
Honours, a citation classic and a scientific retirement
For that work and for your eminence as a scientist generally, in 1985 you were made an Officer of the Order of Australia. Your distinctions include a DSc from the University of London, an honorary doctorate from the University of Sydney and, somewhat unusually, an honorary doctorate from Bologna. Tell us about that.
Well, I had had a long association with that university. There was a lot of to-ing and fro-ing and I had a number of their staff as my students or postdocs – Carlo Zauli was one in particular, a most able man. I had a lot to do with Bologna, one way and another, and I went to their 900th anniversary, celebrating their establishment in 1086. Also, there had been this early connection with Ingold and Mangini, who I think always had a soft spot for Ingold’s people. His department is very powerful. It’s called the Department of Industrial Chemistry, oddly enough, but a lot of its work is as fundamental as you could have, and there are some very good people there.
Mangini himself was a great figure in Italian science, which is run on rather unusual lines – professors are appointed not by their universities but by a Commission which sits in Rome, and for life. If you are just a young man and recommended to a professorship, you’re sent off to some lesser place, some smaller university, and then as you grow older and more wise you come up the line and finally you get to Bologna or Rome or somewhere like that. It’s a very interesting system, where the universities’ influence on those promotions is really very small and you’ve got to be a member of the Commission to have power. But they’re quite well funded – the equipment is there.
Your CV includes a long, impressive list of prizes, awards and visiting lectureships, but I won’t embarrass you by reading them all out. Your publication list includes a 1982 Current Contents article cited as a ‘citation classic’. What does that mean?
If a paper is quoted often enough in the Citation Index they treat that as a citation classic. They send you a very nice bit of paper and ask you to submit an account of how the work was done, which is rather good.
What was the paper upon which that was based, and why does it get cited so much?
It was the paper that I did together with Nyholm, Maccoll and Leslie Orgel, who’d been a pupil of Leslie Sutton in Oxford. It was to do with the overlap integrals between atoms using d orbitals in their binding. Overlap integrals you could do nowadays in a very short time, including programming, but at that time it was a lot of work and we had to make sure we got the same results in Oxford and London.
I think the paper was cited so often because it was the basis of an improved picture of bonding, with elements like sulphur, the heavier elements, in which not only the p orbitals and the s ones are used – as they are in oxygen and nitrogen, for example – but the d orbitals as well. And to get a picture of how important they are, you need some measure of their ability to overlap with the orbitals of adjacent atoms. You need to know how well the p orbital of oxygen overlaps with the s orbital of sulphur, for example. So we worked out all those tables which people used, and we gave our view of which compounds this sort of thing was going to be important in, both transition metal compounds and inorganic compounds of other kinds.
After your retirement, a number of years ago now, you were first of all a University Fellow at the ANU for a three-year term, weren’t you? You’ve continued as a Visiting Fellow in the Department of Chemistry, and you still write papers and generally carry on with your science interests.
Rather thinly spread papers, let’s put it that way! But I do keep an interest in electrodynamics, particularly, which I think is fascinating, and I’m very interested in the interaction of optically active materials, which underlie so much of life. You get a very good handle on that sort of thing using the methods that I now use in molecular quantum electrodynamics. So that really is the basis of my interest there.
What is your title at University College? Do you still visit there?
Yes. I am a Visiting Professor. I used to go back every year but now it’s every couple of years.
Well, that’s about where we will draw it to a close. Thank you very much, David, for a fascinating interview.
Thank you, Bob, for your good eliciting.
Dr Joel Mackay, biochemist
Dr Joel Mackay interviewed by David Salt in 2002. Dr Joel Mackay studied organic chemistry at the University of Auckland, receiving a BSc and an MSc. In 1990 he won a Commonwealth Scholarship to study at Cambridge University, where he looked at the mechanism of the action of antibiotics at the molecular level.
Dr Joel Mackay studied organic chemistry at the University of Auckland, receiving a BSc and an MSc. In 1990 he won a Commonwealth Scholarship to study at Cambridge University, where he looked at the mechanism of the action of antibiotics at the molecular level. Having received his PhD from Cambridge in 1993, Dr Mackay worked for a year as an experimental scientist at the CSIRO Food Research Laboratory. He began his present association with the University of Sydney in 1995, initially as a postdoctoral fellow, then as a research fellow, and now as a senior lecturer in the School of Molecular and Microbial Biosciences.
Interviewed by David Salt in 2002.
Contents
- Following a natural path into science
- Encouraged by a mentor and people 'down the corridor'
- Fundamentals: the role of protein molecules in DNA transcription
- Can protein shapes be usefully modified?
- Looking indirectly at protein shapes
- Protein pictures in exquisite molecular detail
- Designing drugs for specific clinical uses
- Australian contributions in molecular biochemistry
- Leading and managing a laboratory
- Leaving the lab behind – sometimes
- Pathways toward the excitement of discovery
Following a natural path into science
Joel, you were the first person in your family to go to university. What led you into science?
I guess I have always been interested in science. When I look back to my youth I remember being curious, spending a lot of time looking around me and reading about things, and always asking questions – sometimes to my parents’ frustration. Probably that was why I so often got encyclopaedias as presents! I’ve always had an interest in understanding how things work and trying to figure out things that people don’t already know. I always wondered, ‘Can you find out new things?’
At the age of 34, you are now the head of your own laboratory and recognised as one of Australia’s leading young molecular scientists. What pathway led you to this point?
It has all seemed very natural to carry on with the path from my undergraduate degree, to research at the University of Auckland, and then a move to England and later back to Australia. I enjoyed keeping on with research all the time, and people were prepared to support me, to pay me to do it. It always seemed so natural, and I can't think of any alternative that I would have enjoyed more.
Encouraged by a mentor and people ‘down the corridor’
Have any mentors influenced your science career?
I think the first person that really had a serious influence on me as a scientist was a teacher in my last year at high school in Auckland. The school was a good one, and most of the teachers were good, but this guy stood out because of his passion for what he was teaching. He was an exchange teacher from England, which was unusual, but the most unusual thing was that he had a PhD.
Most science teachers have done a bachelor’s degree in science, maybe an honours degree as well, but because they then go into a school their interaction with real science, with research science at the cutting edge, is relatively limited. It’s not their fault; that’s just the way it generally is if you are a full-time teacher. This guy, though, had done the three or four years of his PhD and then had been out in industry, doing research himself. He had been at the forefront of science, doing new work and making new discoveries, and I think that was why he was able to make things more relevant and provide much more context to us than someone that had just come out from an undergraduate degree and gone into teaching. He had much more of the excitement of science in him, and he was really able to communicate that to the students.
You studied for your PhD at Cambridge University, one of the world’s finest institutions. Did you gain from being there with other researchers?
When I was at Cambridge, I didn’t think much about the research being done by any of the people ‘down the corridor’. They were just there. But I realise now what an incredible hotbed of intellectual discovery Cambridge was. Some of those guys down the hallway were in contention for Nobel Prizes; many were already world leaders in the sort of research they were doing. Not until I stepped back from being part of the place did it become clear how incredibly invigorating it was. You can see now that the people you got to meet, and the people that were always coming through your department from other places, and also the people you were working with, many are now starting to lead their own fields, in their own chosen areas. It was a great opportunity to make contacts, to meet interesting people and just to be involved in this community of such high-profile people.
Fundamentals: the role of protein molecules in DNA transcription
How would you describe your type of science?
The work we do is very much trying to understand processes that happen in the bodies of all organisms. We want to understand them right down at the most fundamental level, at the basic molecular level, to find out how individual protein molecules and individual pieces of DNA actually interact with each other and how their interactions allow all of the functions that go on inside us to be carried out.
We focus on one particular area, DNA transcription, trying to understand how that works. You can think of that as part of the process by which different cells in different parts of your body are able to carry out different functions. Every cell in our bodies contains exactly the same sequence of DNA, and the sequence of DNA that we have – our genome – is a blueprint that describes everything about us. And one of the fundamental questions in biology is how all these different types of cells can arise when they all contain the same information. A cell in your heart and a cell in your brain both contain exactly the same DNA, but clearly they have very different functions, they look very different from each other and a lot of the chemistry that they carry out is very different. So for some time now our interest has been in understanding how this differentiation can occur.
Can protein shapes be usefully modified?
What types of projects are you currently involved in? Maybe you could give us some examples of your lab’s work.
One of the things we focused on very early is how specific protein molecules can attach themselves to DNA and to other protein molecules, how these large complexes of proteins can be built up surrounding pieces of DNA, and how they can then control how certain genes are switched on and switched off. You can understand processes like that at all sorts of different levels; we are trying to understand at a very fundamental level how these individual molecules can interact with each other – how strong these interactions are, and how specific, and also, when these interactions take place, what effects they have on which genes are expressed and which are not.
One thing we have been interested in is the development of blood cells, because that is one of the best understood developmental processes within mammals. So we have focused a lot of our work on how specific proteins that are involved in blood cell development interact with each other and with DNA to control the development of blood cells.
That work then has led us on to looking at how some of these specific types of proteins are suitable for the processes that they carry out, such as for binding to DNA, or for interacting with other proteins. We know proteins all have different, very specific shapes that allow them to carry out their functions, so we have tried to understand why these specific structural motifs – these specific shapes – are suitable.
Some of these shapes seem to be very, very robust and able to tolerate lots of mutations (changes in their amino acid sequence). And so we have realised that these different structures may be actually very useful as a kind of designer drug system. That is, you can take a specific protein shape – a molecular scaffold, if you like – and introduce changes onto its surface so that the scaffold is then able to interact with a target such as some sort of protein or other molecule that has gone haywire and is giving rise to a disease condition, for example. Indeed, a lot of cancers are based around one or more proteins doing something they are not supposed to be doing, or doing far too much of whatever they normally do. So if we can make specific designer molecules to target those recalcitrant proteins, we might have a good chance of blocking their bad effects and the diseases they are causing.
Looking indirectly at protein shapes
How do you figure out the shape of a protein, of a molecule? They are too small for you to take a picture of them by microscope, aren’t they?
That’s right. They are about 10 times smaller than the scale that the most sophisticated microscopes – electron microscopes – can look at. There are basically two experimental methods that can be used to determine the shapes of proteins by ‘looking’ at them indirectly. One method is X-ray crystallography: essentially, X-rays are fired at a sample of your protein, which is in a crystalline form, and the way those X-rays are scattered can tell you the shape of the protein.
We have used another method, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) – for which Kurt Wütrich was awarded the Nobel Prize in Chemistry this year, in 2002 – because it has been the most suitable for the proteins we’ve been looking at. In a way it is more complex to understand, but it works by taking advantage of the fact that a protein molecule may contain thousands of hydrogen atoms. If we irradiate the protein with radiofrequency radiation – basically radio waves – the individual hydrogen atoms will respond and absorb some radiation. And then we are effectively able to measure that absorption.
The key feature is that we are able not only to measure the absorption of radiation by an individual hydrogen atom, but also to see correlations, or connections, between pairs of hydrogen atoms that are close to each other in the structure of the protein. Now, imagine that a protein has thousands or hundreds of thousands of hydrogen atoms all over its surface and all over its inside as well, and that you can create a map that tells you the distances between each pair of those atoms. Essentially, that allows you to describe the shape or the structure of the protein. And that’s the method that we use by choice.
It sounds like working out the sizes of jigsaw puzzle pieces, and how they might fit together.
That is an extremely good analogy. It’s a cross between a jigsaw puzzle and a logic puzzle. You have a whole wealth of information in front of you, and you have to sift through that information and make connections between, in this case, pairs of hydrogen atoms or a larger series of hydrogen atoms. You have to try and find an answer to the problem of identifying which hydrogen atoms are which, and which ones are interacting with which others, and you have to find a solution that is entirely self-consistent.
You start off by saying, ‘Let’s suppose for a moment that this hydrogen atom is such-and-such. If that’s the case, that leads me to conclude that this one must be something else, and this one must be something else again.’ And you are led through this series of deductions, until either you find an inconsistency and you have to go back because one of your assumptions wasn’t correct, or you come to an entirely self-consistent solution in terms of the identities of these hydrogen atoms and the connections between them. So it is very much like a jigsaw puzzle.
Protein pictures in exquisite molecular detail
Do nuclear magnetic resonance and X-ray crystallography produce actual pictures showing the molecules?
Ultimately yes, and you do get to see what the shape of that protein molecule is like. As to the sort of information that arises initially from NMR spectra, the NMR images that we obtain are initially not direct images but a list of connections between pairs of the hydrogen atoms contained within the protein. So if your protein has a thousand hydrogen atoms in it, analysing NMR data will allow you to extract a whole list of distances between pairs of them. You will be able to say, for example, that hydrogen atom A in the protein is about five Ångstroms – 0.5 nanometres, which is 0.5 times 10-9 metres – away from hydrogen atom B, and hydrogen atom X is five or six or seven Ångstroms from hydrogen atom Y.
You can feed a list of hundreds or thousands of those individual pieces of information into a computer program, together with the amino acid sequence of the protein. (Remember, a protein is a linear polymer containing a whole series of amino acids.) And if you tell your computer program, ‘This is the amino acid sequence, and hydrogen atom A is next to hydrogen atom B, and X is next to Y,’ and so on, the computer program will use that information to fold up the protein chain – to take this linear chain and contort it into a three-dimensional shape that satisfies all of the individual pieces of information that you have provided. Hydrogen atom X ends up being five Ångstroms from hydrogen atom Y, and so on. And what comes out of that is your picture of the protein molecule.
And these pictures are the basis on which you will create designer drugs?
That’s right. Probably 80 or 90 per cent of the drugs that are available now have been discovered by random screening events, where a particular target is simply screened against a library of thousands or tens of thousands of different potential drugs – and, simply, the ones that have an effect are chosen. In that sense it is not a rational design system but a random system. There is nothing wrong with that. It has produced almost all of the drugs that we use at the moment.
But the alternative, rational approach, involves knowing in exquisite molecular detail the shapes of the proteins that are your targets. This is because, if you know the shape of your target, you can alter the shape of the scaffold that you want to use as your drug so that it fits in to a specific cavity or a specific groove on the surface of your target. And one way to do that efficiently is to know the molecular structures of both the target and the drug that you want to make, and see how they fit together.
Designing drugs for specific clinical uses
Where do you think this work might go over the next 10 years?
There are two branches to what we are interested in. On the more applied branch – working towards discovering designer drugs – a clinically useful product is probably still more than 10 years off. I would hope, though, that by the end of 10 years we would have a very good understanding of these specific protein structures and how we can manipulate them to make them interact with specific targets.
Meanwhile, we want to get in place a whole wealth of information for a complete picture of how these structures are able to be changed, how they are able to tolerate change and how they are able to be modified to interact with specified partners. I think that will put us in a very good position to attack specific targets of clinical interest, and I hope that over a 10-year time frame we will be able to start actually targeting specific clinical problems.
Could you give us some examples of some clinical problems – diseases, cancers – that this might be solving?
Cancer is certainly a very good candidate, because a lot of different types of cancer, particularly blood-cell cancers like leukaemias and lymphomas, are often caused by one or more proteins being ‘over-expressed’ – made in much larger quantities than they are supposed to be. The effect of this over-expression is normally to stop cells from differentiating into the specific types of cells they are supposed to be, such as red or white blood cells. They are held in an immature stage where they just keep dividing and dividing, and basically this uncontrolled division is what cancer is. Because these cancers are so often caused by one or more specific proteins, which in many cases have been identified, we have good targets to aim at. For example, it is known that a specific protein called BRCA1 is very strongly implicated in causing breast cancer. So there you have a molecular target which you can potentially design your designer protein drug to inhibit.
Australian contributions in molecular biochemistry
You have chosen to work here. How does Australia rate in molecular biochemistry?
I think Australia does well. Some research fields, obviously, involve enormous capital outlays which to some extent will inhibit Australia in competing, but in an area like molecular biology or structural biology, which I’m involved in, Australia is certainly in a position to make a substantial, significant contribution. We have a set-up at the University of Sydney which is as good as many of the other institutes that I have visited around the world. We’ve gained access to a whole host of different experimental techniques that are essential if we are to figure out what the structures of individual proteins are like and how those proteins work.
I see no reason in principle why I can’t make a contribution here as large as those of many people from other places in the world. In this day and age it is so easy to collaborate with people overseas – I have a number of collaborations with people in the United States and in New Zealand, for example – that there is really nothing to stop you from becoming involved in high-profile work that is being carried out on the other side of the planet. So I don’t see Australia’s geographical position as a great hindrance these days.
In fact, the most high-profile drug so far to have come out of the designer drug type discovery system was discovered right here in Australia: the anti-influenza drug RelenzaÔ. That drug was discovered by Biota, a small biotechnology company based in Melbourne, who looked at a particular protein that is essential for the life cycle of the influenza virus. Because they were able to examine its shape in atomic resolution detail using X-ray crystallography, they were able to see the shape of a particular cavity on that protein’s surface and to design a specific small molecule that would fit precisely into that cavity. It then made a whole series of specific interactions that inhibited that protein, an enzyme, from carrying out its normal function. That really is one of the first from the generation of designer drugs. And it was quite nice that the work for it was based right here in Australia.
Leading and managing a laboratory
You are not only doing science, you are managing a team of researchers. What is it like to lead a laboratory?
I find that leading a laboratory is fabulous fun. There is the opportunity to be constantly involved with PhD students and postdocs, people who are young (not that I consider myself particularly old) and bright and enthusiastic. They’re not there because it’s going to make them a lot of money or because the profession brings some sort of status, but because they want to be there. They want to be doing research, to be discovering new things. And to me the excitement you get when you discover something, when one of your students discovers something, is definitely not to be missed.
You have got a deep experience and training in science. Do you find you need extra skills in order to manage people?
Certainly I was trained as a scientist, but once you start to run a lab you end up being a manager as well and that requires a completely different set of skills – skills that, obviously, I haven’t had any formal training in. But formal training probably isn’t really the answer to something like that. It’s probably something much more natural. You may be someone who has an affinity with your students and with people in your lab, someone who can gauge their moods and what needs to be done to encourage them or to keep them interested or happy. Some people will be able to do that but some people may just not be very good at it. I don’t think formal training would necessarily make much of a difference.
To some extent, probably, you will find that successful labs are run by people who enjoy being with the people there. They aren’t managing a group of people because they’ve been told to, but because they enjoy having those people there and interacting with them. I think that’s very important.
Leaving the lab behind – sometimes
Joel, you are into long-distance running. As you are running along, are you planning your next experiment or do you leave the lab behind?
I guess it’s a combination of the two. It very much depends on what day it is. Some days, it is a great opportunity to not think about anything at all but just look at the scenery – I prefer running in the bush. Often, especially if it’s technical running, you are spending enough time trying to concentrate where your feet are going without thinking about anything else. So it’s a nice way to switch off. But in other situations it is a nice way to just mull over things, and not infrequently something will pop into your head that you wouldn’t have thought about if you had been sitting at your desk, surrounded by a load of different distractions.
What else do you do when you get away from the lab?
A lot of sport, I guess. I play quite a bit of indoor soccer, and I do a lot of rogaining, which is like a long-distance version of orienteering, out in the bush looking for specific checkpoints from a topographical map over a period of 6 or 12 or 24 hours. I quite enjoy doing that. And bushwalking and cycle touring are two of the other outdoor things that I like doing.
Pathways toward the excitement of discovery
If a young student was considering a career in science and was keen on getting into research, what sort of course would provide the best base?
There is a variety of different ways you can go. In our Department of Biochemistry there are some people with very strong chemistry backgrounds, some with strong physics backgrounds, and others with strong biology and genetics backgrounds who have done relatively little chemistry or physics. It very much depends on the area you’re interested in, but certainly if you are trying to understand things at a molecular level, if you really want to zoom in on the fundamental processes at a very, very basic level, then courses in chemistry, physics and maths are very important.
You can almost get by as a biochemist without having done any undergraduate biochemistry. I am pretty much in that situation myself. But when you have a basis of chemistry, physics and the like it is much easier to come into something like biochemistry or biology, which is relatively descriptive, than it is to try and go the other way – to start from a biological background and become more chemical or more physical. So in some sense I would recommend a path that included chemistry and physics, but there is no question that people are very successfully doing great science in biochemistry without having backgrounds like that.
For me the great thing about science is discovering things that have never been seen before. I really try and reinforce that point to the students working in my lab, because sometimes when you’re working from day to day on a project you get caught up in the small picture, in making very small, incremental steps towards discovering something. I try and remind the students, ‘When you discover something, when you do get a result, basically you’re looking into a part of the world that no-one has ever seen before. You’re seeing something for the very, very first time. No-one in the history of the world has seen what you’ve just seen.’ It’s a very exciting thing to be looking into the face of nature, into a place where no-one has ever looked before.
Dr Moira O'Bryan, medical scientist
Dr Moira O’Bryan interviewed by Ms Nessy Allen in 2001. Dr Moira O’Bryan, despite her youth, has already made a major contribution in the area of molecular reproduction and endocrinology. She started her career at St Vincent’s Hospital, in Fitzroy, Melbourne, working on the characterisation of an immune regulator in the male reproductive tract, and its effect on infertility.
Dr Moira O’Bryan, despite her youth, has already made a major contribution in the area of molecular reproduction and endocrinology. She started her career at St Vincent’s Hospital, in Fitzroy, Melbourne, working on the characterisation of an immune regulator in the male reproductive tract, and its effect on infertility. Awarded a Mellon Foundation fellowship at the Population Council Centre for Biomedical Research at the Rockefeller University in New York, she worked there on the endocrinology behind male fertility for three years. She then returned to Australia, to the Centre for Molecular Reproduction and Endocrinology at the Monash Institute of Reproduction and Development, Monash University, in Melbourne. Here she heads a large research group, the main projects of which revolve around identifying components of the mammalian sperm tail, identifying their function and determining if they are associated with human male infertility.
Interviewed by Ms Nessy Allen in 2001.
Contents
- Introduction
- Family influences
- The dawning challenge of scientific research
- Honours project: clusterin interactions with the immune system
- PhD project: clusterin, male fertility and highly motivated patients
- Mentors and a mind-blowing place to work
- Enjoying collaboration
- Research projects, teaching and student assistance
- Sharing experience, exchanging insights
- Pure and applied research: equally important but inevitably divergent
- The search for a funding balance
- Exciting times, essential changes of focus
- The skills that matter, the gender issues that don't
- Whither tomorrow?
Introduction
Moira O’Bryan, despite her youth, has already made a major contribution in the area of molecular reproduction and endocrinology. She started her career at Melbourne's St Vincent’s Hospital, working on the characterisation of an immune regulator in the male reproductive tract and its effect on infertility.
Awarded a Mellon Foundation fellowship, she worked at Rockefeller University in New York on the endocrinology behind male fertility. After three years she returned to Australia, to the Centre for Molecular Reproduction and Endocrinology at the Monash Institute of Reproduction and Development, Monash University, in Melbourne. Here she heads a large research group, the main projects of which revolve around identifying components of the mammalian sperm tail, identifying their function and determining if they are associated with human male infertility.
Family influences
Moira, where were you born, and when?
I was born in 1966 in Berriwillock – a very small town of about 100 residents – in the Victorian Mallee about four hours north of Melbourne. I have one sister and two brothers, all younger than I am.
And your parents?
They had lived up there most of their lives. My father was a shearer, from a farming family. My mother was a teacher, and came from a teaching family. They were both avid readers and many was the day I came home to find that Mum had been reading all day, with a big stack of books next to her.
My parents, particularly my mother, were very supportive of education. We didn’t have the option of going onto the family farm, so I think from a very early age we knew that we would go to university when we turned 18, and we would probably move to the city. That was fine, we were all very excited about the idea.
Were your parents supportive of science in particular?
They had a very strong interest in it, probably Earth sciences rather than laboratory sciences. My mother and my grandfather certainly had a very strong interest in geology. They were both keen gardeners and we would often go on Mum’s ‘nature walks’ – we hated them at the time, but in retrospect I suppose we began to notice things and learnt quite a lot.
Mum was from a very large family of 11 children, and one of her younger brothers, Patrick, was actually a geneticist. He would have only been about seven years older than me, and through him I encountered genetics, which I found very exciting. I can remember going into the laboratory where my uncle was doing his PhD when I was maybe 13 or 14, and thinking that what he was doing was fabulous. (I can’t remember what the experiment was, but I know he was counting flies with red eyes and flies with white eyes.) He was ‘discovering’ things, whatever that was!
But I suspect the strong influence on me came from the family, rather than one person in particular.
The dawning challenge of scientific research
What science subjects did you take at school?
At secondary school I did all of the standard ones – mathematics, chemistry, biology, physics. The school was very small so there was a fairly narrow range of subjects available, but I took all the science I could, rather than, say, accounting and so on.
Were the teachers encouraging?
One in particular, Alan Marshall, was very supportive. When I found science quite easy at school he went out of his way to challenge me, giving me extra assignments and interesting books to read, for example. Fortunately for me, the classes in such a small school were also very small – in my HSC physics class there were three people – so I had a lot of individual attention, which was fabulous.
Did you know what you would want to do at university?
When I finished high school I knew in general that I wanted to do science. I remember saying I wanted to be a biochemist but I didn’t really know what that was, and it wasn’t until I actually went to university that I found biology the most enjoyable of the four basic areas of science. Perhaps that’s why I found it easier and stood out in it. That was when I realised I would probably end up being in biology, and fairly early in my university career I became certain I wanted to do research.
Honours project: clusterin interactions with the immune system
You read for your Honours in 1988 at St Vincent’s Hospital, in Fitzroy. Why there?
I remember sitting in a meeting where all the potential supervisors read out the projects – some sounded terrible but several sounded interesting, particularly the one at St Vincent’s with Dr Brendan Murphy. In the end I took that project because when I went to his laboratory to see him, he made me feel very welcome, giving me papers to read, introducing me to people, and I felt comfortable with him. So that’s really why I went to that lab.
Can you explain the work you did for your Honours thesis?
I had to purify, from blood and also from seminal plasma, a protein called clusterin, which Brendan Murphy had discovered a few years earlier. After purifying that protein we then had to find out how it interacted with the immune system. And we showed how it did, which was lovely – we went on to write that up into a paper which was published. I was very proud of the fame!
Did you then go straight on to your PhD?
No. I organised to do my PhD but to delay it while I took a year off. For about six months I worked as a research assistant in that same laboratory, actually on the same project, but after that I went travelling for six months, to Nepal, Thailand and Malaysia. I had a fabulous time. And I now recommend to my students that they take some time off, get a bit of distance. That year gave me time to decide this was what I really wanted to do, so when I came back I was motivated, I was pretty fresh, I’d had a break – I knew why I was there.
PhD project: clusterin, male fertility and highly motivated patients
What did you work on for your PhD?
My PhD was again on clusterin, characterising where it was made in the body – specifically in the male reproductive tract – and just how it was involved in normal male fertility and how it was changed with different types of infertility. That involved a mixture of pure biochemistry, where I was purifying things, using big columns and what not, and quite a lot of clinical work. I had to go and see the patients of my other supervisor, Gordon Baker, talk to them about what had gone wrong with their fertility, get samples and then go back to them and say, ‘This is what I think is wrong,’ or ‘This is the information I’ve found out.’ I hoped that would help them, but I don’t know if it did. They were always very appreciative, though.
To have such face-to-face contact with patients was a very satisfying part of that project. They were a very highly motivated group of people, who did the most amazing things to try and achieve having children.
At about the end of 1993 you were awarded a postdoctoral fellowship.
Yes. It was a fellowship from a United States foundation supporting research into population control. So I went to the Population Council, at Rockefeller University, on Manhattan in New York – a fabulous place to work. My project was to purify a cell type from the testis, grow it and then look at what these cells were making. Again it involved a lot of biochemistry and a lot of growing cells and so on. It was a great time. I loved being there.
Mentors and a mind-blowing place to work
Did you have any mentors during your university years, or in New York?
My two supervisors, Gordon Baker and Brendan Murphy, were excellent mentors, in that they were very kind men who really went out of their way to help me. They cleared a lot of paths and put me in contact with the right people. Perhaps they saw abilities in me that I hadn’t realised I had.
In New York I don’t think I had a mentor, but Rockefeller was a very inspirational place to work. It is quite an amazing university – no undergraduate research but perhaps a thousand postdoctoral scientists, mostly from outside of America. At that time there were six Nobel Laureates on staff. It was absolutely mind-blowing to be in an environment of scientists working at such a pace, in such a well-respected place with so much money. It was a very contagious place to work: you wanted to work harder, to achieve more. I think that’s when I got hooked on science!
Enjoying collaboration
In 1996 you were awarded a National Health and Medical Research Council Peter Doherty Fellowship to return to Australia. Where did you take that up?
I came back to Monash Institute of Reproduction and Development, specifically to the group headed by Professor David de Kretser at Monash University, in Clayton. The Institute has grown in its 10 years from maybe 30 people to over 200, and it continues to grow. I may be a bit too close to the Institute to judge, but I think it’s a rising research centre that is becoming more and more important in Australia. Like Rockefeller, it is a very vibrant place to work – a lot of energy to get things done, a lot of collaborations between people, and a real pride in actually producing things at the end of the day.
I love collaborating with people. There are several scientists I work with constantly, and I think it’s true that two minds are better than one for a lot of things, particularly when you have students involved. Students can take up a lot of time and they do need – and deserve – a lot of attention, so if you have two supervisors or two people collaborating on a project, that is certainly better than one.
In just five years since returning, you have been promoted to senior scientist within the Institute, and I believe you now head a large research group of your own.
Yes. It certainly keeps me very busy. I currently have four PhD students, two research assistants, a postdoctoral fellow and a visiting clinician. Most of them are working on areas involving how sperm tails develop and how they move, but there is a spread of interests across reproductive biology. The PhD students are not as much work as they might have been, because they are very clever, they work very hard and they help each other – which is great for me.
Research projects, teaching and student assistance
What types of projects are you working on, and what do they involve?
I decided to divide the research into two main areas. Most of my students and staff work on rodent models of infertility, trying to find the genes that are important to enable sperm to be made. We will look for mutations in these genes and see how they affect sperm movement, for example, or sperm number. As a natural progression, we want to find out whether those proteins we have identified in the rat or mouse are important within human males. The clinical fellow and I spend a lot of time screening infertile men for mutations, to see if we can actually tie the rodent work with the human work for a story that fits together nicely. It happens sometimes that it does.
You mentioned PhD students. Do you teach at all?
I do very little undergraduate teaching. All of my teaching is for Bachelor of Science (Honours) students, in their fourth year, or PhD students. I very much enjoy working with them, particularly Honours students. They have a lot of theoretical knowledge from their lectures but they have spent very little time in laboratories, so when they first get in there, they are amazed by how much fun it is. And the first time they find a result that they’re the first person to know, they get so excited.
I sit on a postgraduate student committee. I’ve been quite lucky that there haven’t been any problems yet with my students, but with so many PhD and Masters students going through the Institute, problems are going to happen sooner or later. The committee monitors how the students are progressing: are they getting enough supervision, are they trying to do experiments that are impossible, are they likely to be able to write up papers, will they get jobs when they’re finished? And, of course, personality problems can always pop up as well. So the committee is important in watching for problems and trying to solve them, or at least to find a way around them.
Sharing experience, exchanging insights
Are you involved in many committees and societies?
Well, I sit on lots of committees within the University. As for societies, one that springs to mind is the Australian Society for Medical Research, which was formed to represent the interests of medical scientists throughout Australia. It monitors things like pay scales, and gives information to government, but one of its most important roles is to help explain medical research to the public. It’s very easy when you are a scientist to get tied into your chemicals and your fancy names, but the public – which is investing so much money in medical research – has a right to know what is actually being done and to insist that it will eventually help public health. So this society is there to increase public awareness and explain some of the difficult situations.
I’m also a member of several research societies, including the Endocrine Society of Australia and the Australian Fertility Society. They usually have a conference once a year which I go to with my students and they will present their work.
So you are acting as a mentor to them?
I suppose I am, in some ways. I’m not sure they enjoy it, though!
Aren’t you convening a large medical research symposium to be held in December?
I am. It is called ‘Reproductive Genomics’, and concerns the way the whole genome – every gene in your body – affects how fertility is manifest. We are looking at both male and female fertility. Setting up this conference has been a real exercise in organisation: some things I felt would be easy have been hard, and vice versa. I have been very pleased that when I have invited some very high-profile national and international scientists, they have almost uniformly said, ‘Yes, I will be there. Just tell me what you want.’ It’s been a lovely experience.
Pure and applied research: equally important but inevitably divergent
Do you see a great difference between pure and applied research?
I think up to a certain point they are exactly the same thing – you must have the pure or discovery research to actually get some applied research. After a certain point, however, they can diverge, as we have found a couple of times. Your research instinct may say, ‘Right, I’ve finished this chapter, I’ve written my paper – tick. Let’s go and work on another little bit,’ but with the applied research you need to develop a test so a doctor in the clinic can measure the same thing you have done in a laboratory. Similarly, you may need to move into clinical trials or to test on something else. Both pure and applied are equally important, there are just different skills, and it all depends on the time and the project.
How would you describe your own research?
At the moment, it is mostly basic research – finding out a little bit of biology and extending on it again and again. But increasingly, particularly with the association to the clinic, it is becoming applied. I have to develop tests for mutations that someone else can do in the room down the corridor, or in a hospital across the country. And I have to package them in forms that will work every time, not just in the right lab on the right day.
I am interested in the practical applications of my research. I still enjoy dealing with patients, particularly in male infertility. Very few doctors actually know a great deal about it, so if we can develop products or tests that can help treat infertile men in Darwin or central Australia, that’s fantastic.
A major emphasis of Moira's group is to identify such mutations and determine the consequences for overall fertility and on any children conceived through assisted reproductive technologies.
The search for a funding balance
Where do you get your funding from?
It is virtually all from the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia, the major funding body for medical research in the academic community. We also have a little bit from Andrology Australia, which was set up to look at research areas within men’s health, spanning prostate cancer to infertility to heart disease and public education. And we get smaller amounts of money from international funding bodies like the Wellcome Fund and some American foundations.
How do you see research being funded in Australia in the future?
Although there have been some significant improvements with the National Health and Medical Research Council and also the Australian Research Council, doing basic research in Australia has become much more expensive – largely because of all the new technologies that have arisen out of the Human Genome Project. The techniques are incredibly beneficial and you get huge amounts of information out of one experiment, but they are also incredibly expensive, so unfortunately for scientists the government probably can’t fully fund research projects. We are virtually being forced to go and talk to industry and look for offshore – or onshore – investors, moving more and more towards a commercial setting.
That is likely to be a good thing, but totally commercial-based funding could be very bad: you wouldn’t discover accidental things while you were doing the research, ‘playing’, if you like. It is important to keep a balance of the two. And I think there will be some big changes in the next five years. Hopefully, they will be for the better, but I really don’t know.
Exciting times, essential changes of focus
I think you and some colleagues are in the process of setting up a biotech company to explore commercial applications of your work.
We are. We argue daily about the name, so there is no name yet! The company would be based on the intellectual property that is generated from our academic research. We are at the stage where we are putting it into a neat package, and within the next six months we will look for both investment partners and other academic partners – in Australia and overseas. We want to be big enough to form a critical mass, to be able to make products that can be tested and marketed effectively. So it is an exciting time.
The company will most likely end up mixing research with being a commercial outlet for our work. Most of the research we have done through the Institute is at a point where a little bit more needs to be done before it can be channelled into a commercial stream. So the company I imagine will do a little bit of basic research and from there do product development and testing.
Do you think the setting up of such a company will make a difference to the type of research you are doing?
It probably will. It has pluses and negatives. I think it will make my research more efficient, in that there is a real benefit in setting solid goals that people can strive for, particularly if you can give a bonus when they actually get to that. There could be a negative for some of the research that might have resulted in interesting peripheral findings – someone like me might come along and say, ‘That’s not going to end up as a product. You have to drop it.’ It’s early days, so we are still working it out. I’m not sure if it’s going to be a good thing or bad, but they’re new tricks and I think they are essential things for us to do.
The skills that matter, the gender issues that don’t
What skills do you think are needed in science these days?
Good computer skills are essential. I have a student who is a fabulous scientist, an excellent geneticist who did genetics and Arts at university, with a little computing stuff in the middle. You need computer skills more and more, and you need to be organised and also to be able to look across disciplines. I think the days of being someone who works on one molecule for your entire career are gone. You must be able to link things together and work in teams – being a team player is very helpful.
Have you found that being a woman scientist has made any difference?
No. That may be luck, in that it absolutely hasn’t been an issue for either my PhD supervisors or the professor I work for now. I can’t remember feeling any form of discrimination against me. If anything, being female has actually helped me – certainly some older female scientists have really gone out of their way to help me.
Whither tomorrow?
Where do you see yourself in 10 years’ time?
It’s a very hard question. I think the next couple of years will decide where I am. If the company has any success I may move further into the commercial stream. I love doing bench research, getting in and doing experiments, but those days could well be numbered. I may end up sitting in an office all day. I really don’t know. But I would be loath to give up doing the occasional experiment.
Moira, it is clear that you have achieved a great deal in a very few years in your discipline. Thank you very much for participating in this interview, and whatever you decide to do, all the very best in your future career.
Thank you, Nessy.
Dr Rohan Baker, molecular geneticist
Rohan’s early curiosity, fostered by his scientist father, led him from studying organic chemistry to a passion for molecular biology during his university years. A leading researcher at the John Curtin School, he continued to focus on the protein ubiquitin’s role in protein regulation, cancer and integrating advanced molecular techniques to understand cell function and disease. Interviewed by Mr David Salt in 2002.
Dr Rohan Baker
Introduction
Dr Rohan Baker received a PhD in 1988 from the John Curtin School of Medical Research at the Australian National University. It was here that he discovered and analysed a gene sequence for human ubiquitin. Ubiquitin is a small protein that serves as a universal signal for the degradation of other proteins to which it is attached. He has continued to research the ubiquitin pathway since then.
During 1988-91 he was a postdoctoral fellow in the Department of Biology at Massachusetts Institute of Technology in the USA, where he investigated how cells select proteins for degradation and go about attaching ubiquitin to them.
In 1991 Baker returned to the John Curtin School as a Research Fellow in the Molecular Genetics Group. He is now Head of the Ubiquitin Laboratory, where research centres on the role of ubiquitin in the destruction of other proteins (proteolysis) in the cell and how defects in the ubiquitin system affect the cell.
Interviewed by Mr David Salt in 2002.
Rohan, was it something in your early life that steered you toward science?
Probably it was my family life. My father is a research scientist and he always encouraged us to be inquisitive, asking us questions about the environment and our surroundings, and getting us to think about what was going on in our lives and in the world. I guess that awakened an interest in asking questions.
What pathway in your education led you to become a molecular biologist?
Well, although I was born in Townsville, North Queensland, and lived there till I was 11, we then moved down to Sydney and I did high school there. I went on to undergraduate studies at the University of New South Wales, intending to become an organic chemist like my father. But at university I took some biology and, ultimately, biochemistry subjects to fill in my subject load, and became very interested in biochemistry as a combination of organic chemistry and biology – defining how molecules interact inside a cell, the physical properties of organic molecules and how they function in different life processes.
In my last year of undergraduate studies the subject of molecular biology was just being introduced at the University of New South Wales, and that sparked my interest so much that I carried on to do honours in molecular biology. So you see, during my undergraduate degree I gradually changed my interests from organic chemistry to biochemistry and then to molecular biology.
Yes, except for a postdoctoral fellowship of three and a half years at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology after I finished my PhD. I've been back at the John Curtin School for 10 or 11 years since my postdoc.
You now lead a laboratory in molecular biology at the John Curtin School. What is the connection between molecular biology and medical research?
Molecular biology enables us to study how molecules interact – the biology of molecules. Interactions within the cell and then within an organism underpin our normal health, and defects in those interactions can underlie many disease conditions. So understanding how molecules interact and their biology is very important to understanding what has gone wrong in many disease states.
Most people connect molecular biology with genetics. Are they the same thing, or is one a subset of the other?
I guess genetics is a more classic discipline which follows the hereditary nature of genes – of phenotypes, of how things behave. Molecular biology is connected with genetics in the sense that it is partly a study of DNA, the molecule that makes up your genes: a piece of DNA is inherited through any sort of genetic offspring. There is certainly a connection between molecular biology and genetics, but they are different disciplines. In a way, molecular biology these days is more of a technique that underpins a lot of modern research. We can use it to study many different disciplines, be they genetics or biochemistry or physiology.
Most of your scientific career has been devoted to studying the protein ubiquitin. What is it, and why is it so important?
Ubiquitin is a fairly innocuous-looking protein. It's very small, as proteins go, containing 76 amino acids – an amino acid being the basic building block of a protein. It doesn't seem to have any enzyme activity of its own, but it is very important because the cell uses it as a mechanism to mark or signal other proteins for destruction in the cell. The cell takes this little ubiquitin molecule and attaches several moieties of it (several units of ubiquitin) to a protein; that targets the protein for degradation at a large proteolytic complex inside the cell, called the proteasome. That is a collection of proteases that specifically bind to the ubiquitin component and then destroy the protein to which ubiquitin is attached. So it is not an enzyme in itself, but it serves as a universal signal for degradation of proteins.
I stumbled into it early in my PhD, when I was working in a laboratory at the John Curtin School with Philip Board to study glutathione transferase proteins. They are proteins in a cell that detoxify carcinogens we might take in from our diet or from insults like tobacco smoke. I actually obtained a gene for ubiquitin as a false positive in the first lot of screens I was doing. At the time, nobody had isolated a human ubiquitin gene, or the DNA that codes for ubiquitin in humans – there was only one paper reporting a sequence from yeast – so it was a very new area. A bit of biochemical study on ubiquitin had shown that it was involved in protein degradation, but it wasn't yet realised how fundamental this process was in controlling the activity of many proteins in the cell.
I was very lucky that the research environment I was in, with Phil Board and the Human Genetics Department, encouraged me to go off on this little tangent. Discovering the ubiquitin sequence was rather serendipitous in the first place, but it has kept me interested for the last 17 years.
What does the name 'ubiquitin' mean?
I guess the names that scientists give things must seem funny sometimes, but essentially this is called 'ubiquitin' because of its ubiquitous distribution and conservation. It's in every organism except the very simple bacteria. It is in the simple eukaryotes such as yeast, right through to ourselves, in every cell in our body. And it is the most strongly conserved protein known, the one that has changed the least during evolution. That is because it has this very fundamental role in destroying – very selectively – proteins in the cell.
Crucial roles for the ubiquitin pathway
We would all have heard that an important part of the way a cell works is by making lots of proteins. Is the destroying of the proteins as important?
It is absolutely critical. In a closed system such a cell, you can't keep synthesising new molecules without destroying the old ones. (Eventually the cell might build up and explode!) You need more synthesis than degradation because as a cell is dividing it needs to generate new material for the daughter cells it makes.
The ubiquitin pathway involves picking out, and specifically destroying, one protein from perhaps 1000 or 2000. Some of the proteins it destroys are molecules that are essential for regulating cell growth, division and development. It is critical that those proteins are produced at the right time and active, but it is just as critical that they are destroyed when the cell no longer requires them to be active. Just as the absence of a certain enzyme could be detrimental to cell growth, the overabundance or overactivity of a molecule could be detrimental to cell function, so it is critical to have a balance between synthesis and degradation. My view, perhaps biased, is that even these days the degradation aspect is a little bit overlooked. But I think it is being realised more and more how important the selective destruction of proteins is to the cell.
Might a knowledge of ubiquitin's role in this lead to any applications?
Oh definitely. In my lab my main interest is in the area of cancer research. Many of the proteins that ubiquitin is involved in destroying are ones that we might call oncogenes. They are proteins that would cause cancer if they were present at too high a level in the cell, so it is critical for the ubiquitin pathway to remove them from the cell, to stop them functioning.
One example from my research is that one of the enzymes we work on can snip ubiquitin back off a protein (one that we haven't identified yet). If we overproduce that enzyme in a cell, it can actually cause cancer; it will cause tumours in mice. So our model is that this enzyme, by snipping ubiquitin off the protein, is preventing degradation or destruction of the protein and keeping it at too high a level in the cell. And the protein goes on to promote unregulated cell growth, which is cancer.
So I'm interested in two aspects. One is the fundamental mechanisms of how ubiquitin is attached and removed from proteins, and how that regulates degradation of proteins. The other is research into cancer and other diseases where you have defects in cell growth or cell division because proteins are not destroyed before they promote too much cell growth.
Opportunities for innovative, integrative science
Is the John Curtin School of Medical Research a good place for a researcher in your field to be?
Definitely. When I first came to talk to people at the John about doing a PhD I was encouraged by the breadth of expertise and of the research questions that were being asked there. That may not have been so important 15 or 17 years ago, but now it is becoming very important that we integrate as many aspects of biological research as we can to address a question. I think the days are gone when you could just focus on your favourite technique, your favourite protein, and ignore other aspects of cell physiology. You have to integrate as many different approaches and techniques as possible, and the knowledge and expertise of other people.
The John Curtin School is an ideal place, I believe. It covers quite a broad range of research fields and its breadth means there is always someone whose door you can go and knock on to ask a few questions about something that's out of your own area. There's a lot of expertise in there that you can rely on. And there's a freedom to explore and investigate, which often leads to extremely important findings.
Where does Australia stand, then, in the field of molecular biology?
Australia is definitely out there at the forefront. I think we can hold our heads high in that respect. We've had many of the early pioneers in molecular biology, including researchers from ANU, and we stand very well in the world scene in modern molecular biology, molecular genetic research.
This field is becoming very expensive, especially to do the large-scale projects such as genome sequencing. Probably Australia can't cope financially with those. But we have contributed to the Human Genome Project – mainly through Grant Sutherland, in Adelaide – and we can certainly benefit by getting onto the more functional questions that arise from it. Now that we have the blueprint, we have to go in and find out how it all fits together and makes an organism function. Australia has always been very good at asking the right questions, the clever questions, and getting answers.
Your research is largely done in test tubes, outside the cell. How does this relate back to what is actually happening inside the cell?
That's a good question. I think a lot of research is very reductionist. Certainly biochemistry and molecular biology are guilty of that. You are purifying one or two components and then studying those in a test tube to see how they might interact, what consequence mutating or changing a single amino acid building-block in a protein might have for its function in a test tube. The important thing now is to put all that knowledge back together and look at the function of enzymes within the whole cell. This new, more holistic approach is the so-called functional genomics or functional proteomics.
In my research we're moving back into the whole cell, into cell biology. There are great techniques now for studying the location and movement of proteins within a living cell. We're studying how the enzyme that we know can cause cancer in mice actually moves, at certain times during cell growth, from the cytoplasm of the cell – the region outside the nucleus – into the nucleus and then out again. We're trying to understand what mechanisms regulate those movements, and where the enzyme's important function in the cell is. Is it most critical that it's in the nucleus at a certain time to function there, to prevent unregulated cell growth, or is it functioning out in the cytoplasm of the cell and just popping into the nucleus to be out of the way?
We have to understand how enzymes operate within the whole soup of a cell, which is composed of many thousands of different proteins and different mechanisms for moving proteins around. We can find out a lot of important things in a test tube, at the reductionist level, but we have to be able to then put that back into the context of the whole cell, the whole system, and understand how an enzyme or protein or DNA molecule works in that context. That's the critical area that biology is moving into.
The cell sounds like an incredibly complex place.
It certainly is. I'd love to be a 'fly on the wall', sitting inside a cell and just watching what's going on. To some extent we can already do that in living cells under the microscope, by attaching fluorescent labels to certain proteins and watching them move in the cell. We are gaining wonderful insights into protein localisation and translocation, movement around within a cell.
There are fantastic techniques available to address these questions and there's an incredible amount still to discover. Although we don't know yet know how all the blueprint information we have goes together, we can at least make a very good guess at what the various component parts of a cell would be. Now we have to go in and ask the questions. How do all those components interact in different cell types – muscle, liver, kidney? How are all those components produced at the right time? How do they function together and interact to give us the ultimate outcome of a living cell and then a living organism? This is a wonderfully exciting and challenging time to be a molecular biologist or geneticist.
You said you have been studying ubiquitin for 17 years. Some people would say that's a long time to be studying one molecule, one protein. What drives you?
Well, it's always changing. Even though I've been working on the one protein itself and the pathway it is involved in, every new discovery – whether by us or by other people working in the field – highlights more complexities in the system.
The original aspect of my ubiquitin research, for instance, was my PhD work on structure: how the DNA that codes for ubiquitin is arranged in humans, how it is expressed as the cell turns those genes on to make ubiquitin protein, and under which conditions. Then my postdoctoral fellowship work moved to the functional aspects: how the cell selects proteins for degradation and goes about attaching ubiquitin to them. And ultimately I got interested in enzymes that can actually cleave the ubiquitin back off proteins. They could not reverse degradation but they could reverse the signal attachment in the ubiquitin and thus perhaps prevent proteins getting degraded.
My research has always been on the ubiquitin pathway, because it is such an important, fundamental pathway. But the focus changes as new research aspects emerge, and that's what inspires me and keeps me involved.
Should pure research like this be commercialised?
It's a very important goal to have; I'm certainly interested in it and I have several patents coming from my research. I'm just not sure that it should be the focus of our research. To me, the more important focus is to understand fundamental mechanisms in cell biology so we can really understand how a cell works in the normal situation. Then we have a great base from which to study diseases, working out what's gone wrong between the normal state and the disease state, which we can then try to address. We must know about the normal state of not only our pathway but every other pathway in the cell, because if we manipulate a certain pathway in disease, we don't want a detrimental effect on other pathways. So it's important that we have a very thorough, basic knowledge of cell function.
We should certainly commercialise any aspect of our research that we can, but not as a primary research goal. Rather, it is the accumulation of knowledge that will help us down the road.
What skills are necessary for a scientist to make it these days?
Many skills, I guess. You need to be fairly dedicated to the work, especially when you are driving your own research program. You need the ability to focus your efforts on a problem. And these days there's more and more information to be aware of, so you must be able to seek and find information, by the internet or from other sources.
Most of all, you need the ability to put together lots of different pieces of information into a coherent story, a nice set of questions to follow in a coherent research program – and that requires diligence and dedication.
You said that discovering the ubiquitin sequence was quite unexpected. Is it an important aspect of science to be able to follow a clue, a chance discovery, to see where it might take you?
Oh definitely. I think of Pasteur's famous quote about chance favouring a prepared mind. You do need some focus in research, but you have to keep your mind open to other possibilities in what you are discovering, and even go off on a tangent at times.
What would you advise a keen young student of science to do if they want to get into the field of molecular biology?
I believe you've got to get out there and knock on doors, try and get yourself into a laboratory and experience getting your hands wet, getting them dirty. I've found a big difference between doing a biochemical practical class at university and actually being out in a research lab and working. Most universities and institutes run some sort of summer scholarship or work experience program. Because my father worked in a research company I was lucky enough to get work at the bench in my summer breaks from university, and now in my own lab I take as many vacation scholars, summer scholars, as I can. It's a great opportunity for people to try the science for themselves and see if they like it – very different from learning about it at university.
Is it important for a scientist to spend time overseas as a part of training for a research career?
I'd strongly recommend it. For me, going to MIT was a great opportunity. It opened my eyes to a big research institution and how things are done elsewhere in the world. MIT was a fairly high-pressure place, with a lot of high-profile scientists, very big names in their field. Indeed, the whole Boston environment was good to experience, with Harvard and Tufts Medical School and various other schools. A lot of good people come in giving seminars, and being there is a very good way to keep up to date on cutting-edge research.
It also gives you the chance to appreciate what a good place Australia is, and I must say I was very happy to come home to Australia and continue my research here. There are certainly goods and bads about both systems, but there's no place like home.
Have you had any mentors? Have any people made a big difference to your career?
I think scientists on the whole are very good at helping each other – mentoring, if you like, giving a shoulder to lean on and being there to give advice and opinions and help when you need them.
But two people have stood out in my career development, I'd say. My father encouraged me to get into science, and to ask questions in general and think about things around me. And I have mentioned that Phil Board allowed me the opportunity to pursue my own interests in his lab, which wasn't really working on ubiquitin at all. He realised the potential of this pathway's importance in regulating cell metabolism, and gave me the freedom to investigate that.
You are a director of the Australian Society for Medical Research. What does it do, and why are you associated with it?
The Australian Society for Medical Research (ASMR) is the peak body in Australia to promote the awareness of medical research, both to the community and to government. That is a very important aspect of doing research but is often overlooked.
I think we should see it as part of our job as scientists, and also an obligation, to get out and communicate our results to the public. Often they fund our research through their tax dollars and, after all, in medical research we are working in the hope of curing or treating different diseases. But as well as communicating our progress, we need to communicate that it's not an easy path to follow – it's an incremental set of steps to find how to cure diseases. Just as important is convincing the government of the need to fund medical research in Australia to an adequate level. It's financially beneficial, anyway, because prevention is always better than cure.
I see the Australian Society for Medical Research as a very important vehicle in that lobbying and communicating, so I am one of the board of directors of the society and we are very active in promoting medical research, both to government and to the public.
What are your other interests away from the lab?
The first one would be my family. I've been married to my high school sweetheart, Chelsey, for 17 years – ever since I started my PhD. We now have two young children (Merryn and Jackson), aged five and two. It's always great to go home to them. It really lets you unwind. You can forget about the pressures of the lab or what didn't work today, and just have fun with your family. I'm also lucky to have much of my larger family in Canberra, and my Mum has been a great support to us.
I'm quite interested in music, and at work we've started a band called 'The Major Groove' – a very poor pun on the double helix structure of DNA. (The two DNA strands give you a minor and a major groove.) That's just a bit of a release, I suppose. We've started playing a few after-dinner dances on the scientific conference circuit, and it's fun to have a bunch of scientists up on stage playing to another bunch of scientists.
Also, I have a love of carpentry and I tuck myself away in the workshop and make bits of furniture and things like that.
You've been enormously successful in your career to this point. Where do you think you might be in 10 years' time?
Well, I hope that in 10 years' time I'll still be a full-time researcher. It is getting more difficult to secure sufficient funding for all the things that I want to do, but I am quite certain that I want to go on being a research scientist. I imagine I'll still be in the ubiquitin field somewhere and driving my own research lab.
I guess there are times when you feel a bit down about it, mainly because of the uncertainties in obtaining sufficient funding – not just for yourself but for the people in your lab as well. You need funding for postdoctoral fellows and lab technicians, and it's very uncertain for them too. So yes, there are days when I think about what else I'd be doing, about packing it in. (Maybe if I wasn't in science in 10 years I'd be a music-playing carpenter!) But no, really I'm sure I will still be here.
© Australian Academy of Science
Dr Alec Costin, alpine ecologist
Alec grew up exploring Sydney’s bushland, which sparked a lifelong passion for ecology and led to pioneering research on soil conservation and alpine environments. His career spanned roles in the Soil Conservation Service, CSIRO, and ANU, where he advanced understanding of vegetation, water yield, and land management, influencing conservation policy and practice across Australia.
Interviewed by David Salt in 2006.
Dr Alex Costin
Dr Alec Costin is an ecologist who has more than fifty years experience in the research and management of ecological environments with particular emphasis on high mountain and high latitude ecosystems. After obtaining his degree he accepted an honours placement to study the Australian Alps. This was an auspicious career choice, as in the mid 1940s very little was known about the ecology of the area. In the early 1950s his research took him interstate and overseas until 1955, when he began a 19 year career at CSIRO Division of Plant Industry. After CSIRO he was a visiting fellow at the Australian National University until 1977.
Interviewed by David Salt in 2006.
Alec, you were born in 1925 in Roseville, on Sydney's North Shore. What are your memories of your childhood?
Of running wild, I guess. We lived in a Depression street of returned ex-servicemen, very few of whom had jobs, but we had a wonderful time because we were right on the edge of the Castle Cove-Castlecrag bushland and we came to know the bush intimately. I think I recognised every plant, but I never knew the name of anything other than when we wanted a bit of pocket money, especially at Christmas time, when we'd pick the flannel flowers, Christmas bush and Christmas bells which grew there in huge profusion. Not much bush is left in those parts now, though.
Do you think this love of the bush perhaps set your life course toward an understanding of ecology?
Oh, those experiences must have had some effect. I've never felt lost in the bush, even when I'm 'lost'. It's always been part of what's there.
What schools did you go to?
I went to Roseville Public School for my primary education, and later to North Sydney Boys' High School. At that time there were very few high schools in Sydney – a secondary education normally didn't go beyond third year, when most people went into technical courses. North Sydney High School was the only full high school on the whole North Shore, apart from the so-called Great Public Schools.
In 1942 you accepted a cadetship with the recently formed New South Wales Soil Conservation Service. Why did you choose to join that Service?
My main reason was that if I wanted any tertiary education I would have to get some support, and the most attractive support took the form of the very few Public Service cadetships sponsored by some of the main government departments in Sydney – Agriculture, Forestry, Water, Public Works et cetera. I was advised to have a go at one of these cadetships, and I applied for one in forestry.
In a subsequent interview as one of the people that were short listed, I was told that I'd missed out on the forestry cadetship (subsequently I've been very happy about that). However, Clunies Ross, who was Professor of Veterinary Science in Sydney University, offered me a cadetship in vet science. I wasn't interested in vet science, so then Sam Clayton, the Soil Conservation Commissioner, told me there was a cadetship available in agriculture but from the Soil Conservation Service of New South Wales. That's how I started my university course in agricultural science.
What was the aim of the Soil Conservation Service? Was it to help farmers?
It was, but actually it was the brainchild of Sam Clayton, the first Commissioner, who was a senior agronomist at that time with the New South Wales Department of Agriculture. In his opinion there was enough land degradation to justify a big soil conservation component in extension work of the Ag Department, but the department was not interested.
Then Clayton got a scholarship to the United States during the time following the dustbowl/Depression years where conditions were described in The Grapes of Wrath by Steinbeck. He came back all fired up that something had to be done. Again the department was not interested, but because of Clayton's friendship with the Minister for Mines the legislation was enacted in 1938 and the Soil Conservation Service did come into existence – at first with a very small group of people who had a lot of miles on the clock. And from the time I was given the cadetship, at the start of my agricultural course in Sydney University, I was already a fairly senior public servant – not that being senior meant anything to me.
You studied for a Bachelor of Science in agriculture at the University of Sydney.
Do you have any memories of that first degree?
Oh, lots of memories, especially of the introductory lecture that all the prospective first year agriculture students were given by Robert Dickie Watt, the foundation Professor of Agriculture. Essentially, he said, 'Look, agriculture is a service, a profession. If you're here to make money I don't want to see you here tomorrow.' This was during wartime and I think everyone felt a need for some giving, as well as getting, in what you were doing.
Initially I found things very difficult. For most males at that time biology was never part of the high school course – it tended to be science and maths – and so I wrestled with biology for the first couple of years, finding it very hard work. But after a while I started to enjoy it and to get on top of it. The course was, in the end, very fulfilling.
For your honours year you studied the ecology of the Australian Alps, didn't you?
Yes. I did quite well during my four years' pass course, and it was suggested by Noel Beadle, a lecturer in botany who was already a colleague of mine, and by Gordon Hallsworth, a lecturer in soils in the Agriculture Faculty, that I should consider an honours year in agriculture or botany. I really didn't have much idea of what I could or should do, but it had to be in the general framework of the course subjects in the Faculty of Agriculture. Then the Botany Department pointed out that I could have a go at the Australian Alps, where they said very little work had been done and where in particular virtually nothing at all was known about the soils.
That suggestion got the green light from Sam Clayton, who was already deeply concerned about the condition of high mountain catchments in New South Wales and had participated in quite extensive field inspections of Kosciuszko which led to legislation enacted in 1944, setting up the State Park there. And although there was a recreational basis for setting up the park, the primary reason for doing it was catchment protection, so that early legislation was soon followed by the first moves to reform snow lease grazing in the mountains. Clayton, then, was more than happy that I should start an honours year in an area that he himself was concerned with.
Had you had any experience of working in the high country?
None whatsoever. I'd only seen snow once, I think at Katoomba, and I had no idea of what was ahead. But I find that the more you get involved in a subject, the more it sucks you into it, and that was especially so from the soils and vegetation points of view. The country was just magnificent, and because almost everything that one looked at was new – there was so little known, and not much help in the literature – this was a real voyage of discovery. Almost everywhere you looked or anything you did, it was a challenge to follow up and find out a bit more.
It was a good time to be undertaking these studies, in that you weren't following in other people's footsteps but creating your own.
Absolutely. I felt incredibly lucky.
Following your degree, I think, you had to pay back your cadetship with service.
Oh yes, for every gift there's always 'a quart of blood and a pound of flesh'. The Public Service Board, which administered the cadetships, insisted that any cadets should remain in the service of the department that had succoured them for at least as many years as those of the cadetship. In my case it was more than five by the time I had completed an honours year. So I was stuck with the Soil Conservation Service – which didn't worry me at all. My first assignment was to open up the soil conservation station at Cooma, which was to be my base for continuing the survey work that I had started in my honours year.
Cooma would have been a fairly small town at that time, in the late 1940s.
That's correct. It was a small, very stable, very inbred, very interesting place to be.
And I think you had the first bulldozer in the area.
Yes. This was just post-war and there was very little earthmoving equipment in Australia, but the Soil Conservation Service managed to latch on to a couple of bulldozers. One of them was sent down from Goulburn, where there was a main regional office of the Service, to start up a bit of work around Cooma. In particular, there was some very badly eroded land at Bredbo, and what Sam Clayton was very keen to do – and he did it well – was to set up demonstrations in soil conservation on highways et cetera where the public couldn't help noticing them. So a little bit of my work was involved with that, but essentially I was meant to continue the vegetation, soil and land use surveys that I had started.
I believe that despite being regarded as a senior Public Service figure so early in your career, you were not all that good at filling in forms. But you did have a very good use for red tape.
I've never been good at filling in forms, but I used to preserve all my botanical specimens – which became the basis of an herbarium which is still in existence – with many yards of red tape. This was ideal for tying around the bundles of plant specimens. I really got into trouble once when I requisitioned for some 100 yards of red tape, because I was thought to be very insolent to run the Public Service down to that extent. And so I went.
With this capacity to deal with red tape, however, you were destined for senior management, weren't you?
Well, one day my life was interrupted by a call from head office to present myself in Sydney as soon as possible for an interview during which I was told that being very senior in the Soil Conservation Service I had to come to Sydney to accept some administrative responsibilities, because soon I might be sitting in another seat. I said I didn't like the idea of that at all, because I was very involved in my work and it was opening up to the extent that I had to stay with it in order to get the best out of it. As soon as I got back to Cooma I wrote my resignation and proceeded to look for employment that would keep me in that same sort of job.
Sam Clayton, who was head of the Service, rather regarded you as a protégé. It would have been very disappointing to him that you chose to resign.
Whether he regarded me as a protégé or whether, because I was one of the first cadets, he wanted to make sure that he got the best from me, I do think he was a bit upset about it. He certainly didn't do anything – it was perhaps out of his control – to lean on the Public Service Board to go easy on the amount of bond money I had to repay because I left the Service several years before my cadetship terms were up. But eventually he and I did reinstate our relationship.
In the early 1950s you benefited from a couple of research grants, the Lawrance Pawlett scholarship and the Australian Services Canteens fellowship, to maintain your studies of the high country. What were these about?
I had chosen not to go to that comfortable chair in Sydney because I wanted to finish the work I was doing, and in particular to carry out a huge backlog of soil analyses on soil samples that I'd accumulated. That required some funding, but rather than look for another job, which would have had its own constraints and requirements, I managed to get a couple of scholarships. The first one was the Thomas Lawrence Pawlett fellowship, from the Faculty of Agriculture in Sydney University, and I then worked for a while from the university.
Also, as I was enlarging my interest in high mountain ecology, it was suggested that I ought to see as much as I could of mountain environments elsewhere, and to work with overseas ecologists who were more familiar with them than I was. In particular, a visiting Swede, Professor Carl Skottsberg (the director of the Rijksmuseum) urged me to get over to Europe as soon as I could and said he'd arrange for me to get experience. I was lucky enough to get one of the well-endowed Australian Services Canteens scholarships that had just been initiated, and I was off.
I had no commitments other than a rucksack and the same suit of clothes that I wore all the time, so I could move wherever I wanted. That was a very enlightening time. Not only did I see what was going on in many of those mountain areas but I was able to work with some of the world's leading ecologists. This was invaluable to me, because ecology was undergoing lots of changes. Australia was still lumbered with the old-fashioned Clementian approach to ecology that was rife in North America for a long time. The ecologists in Europe, by contrast, were far more dynamic.
Also of significance to me, because I had already been trying to work in this direction, was that the ecosystem concept was just emerging – though not yet as a practical entity. Tansley, in Britain, was the first to use it, again more on a theoretical basis.
How did the high country overseas compare with Australia's high country?
That's a big question. As far as ecology is concerned, the overseas mountains were generally much steeper, much younger as the result of more recent uplifts, and also much younger as regards the development of soils et cetera. Mostly the environments that the overseas mountains presented you with had developed since the Ice Age, whereas most of our mountains survived glaciation. Although they were severely periglaciated, much of their periglaciated material still exists for vegetation and soils.
As far as land use was concerned, almost all of those mountains had been used for transhuman grazing for centuries and so many of them had developed a quasi-equilibrium, but almost without exception they were obviously grossly disturbed. Those in the Australian Alps showed very much less disturbance. For instance, most of the British mountains used to be forested but are now covered with heathland. Most of the European Alps used to be forested, and one reason they are so prone to snow slides and avalanches is that most of the timber is gone. So, from the point of view of land use and its effects, the Australian Alps were substantially different from most of those I worked in overseas.
Seeing these things overseas reassured me a little bit. In my reports up till that time, especially in the Monaro ecosystems book, I had trodden very lightly indeed, being very cautious about cause and effect and about the relation between high country grazing and catchment deterioration. I now realised I had been soft-pedalling, and this had a big influence on what I did later – not that I was trying to prove anything, but future work needed to recognise that the controlling factors in what had to be done were human as well as natural.
Back in Australia, your next move was to begin working with the Victorian soils authority, focusing this time on the Victorian high country.
Well, toward the end of my time overseas I was married, so I needed some money and wasn't able to freelance as much as before. I got a job with the Victorian Soil Conservation Authority to run their little research group, but my particular responsibility was catchment areas in Victoria, particularly the high country – essentially an extension of the Kosciuszko Park into the Victorian Alps. Because I had the background from Kosciuszko to work on, it was not very difficult (although a bit physically extending) to do a reconnaissance survey of the whole of the Victorian Alps in the time that I was with the Authority.
These were the same highlands as before, in effect, but you were now part of a different state jurisdiction. Was that of any importance to you?
I was more interested in the basic ecology, which was generally similar to that of Kosciuszko. The major land use difference related to the steeper terrain of the Victorian Alps, apart from the Bogong High Plains, and was reflected in the fact that cattle grazing, rather than sheep grazing, was more prominent in the Victorian Alps than in Kosciuszko. But essentially the associated problems were the same.
From a water catchment point of view, the big problem with all rangeland grazing – whether you start from an alpine area and go right through to a desert area or to a monsoon tropical area – is that the grazing is incredibly selective. In fact, in terms of plants and places that are frequented by livestock, the effective stocking rates can be considerably higher than the actual stocking rates on highly improved pastures where the whole pasture is grazed virtually like a lawn. The selectivity of rangeland grazing plays a major part in the initiation of degradation. And, as those degraded areas continue to be selectively grazed, the degradation grows.
As far as nature conservation is concerned, and national parks set up to protect nature in its natural condition, the selective grazing is unreservedly deleterious because it changes the botanical composition and structure of the very community that is the object of conservation.
So, whilst there were differences between the Kosciuszko environment and the Victorian Alps, in principle the problems were much the same.
After your Victorian experience, in 1955 you joined CSIRO. How did that come about?
It was rather serendipitous. By about the end of my first year with the Victorian Soil Conservation Authority, two or three years after the Snowy Mountains Hydro-Electric Scheme had started in 1949, construction work for the scheme was under way. So I took leave to pay a flying visit to the Kosciuszko region, especially the Island Bend-Guthega area where the Snowy scheme was actually getting going.
During that time I revisited some of my original sites on the Main Range, where right from the beginning I'd been very careful to keep permanent records – initially photographic records and later transect and quadrat measurements that were repeated over a long period of years. These sites had been taken out of grazing almost as soon as the Kosciuszko legislation was passed, so they were already protected from the main disturbing agent. But I found that in the few years since I first saw them the amount of degradation had increased incredibly, simply reflecting the fact that if environments are near the edge of stability and you just tip them over the edge, their condition will continue to go downhill.
I sent a short report with the photographic evidence on this to the Victorian Soil Conservation Authority. A copy was sent to Sam Clayton, who was very angry that someone from a state Public Service was working over the border, in another state. And a copy went to the Snowy Mountains Authority, which received it quite well despite the inclusion of some criticisms of the Authority's own works at the time. So for some reason – perhaps a feeling of some responsibility – I decided that maybe I should look for another job in the Kosciuszko region.
It is said that fools rush in where angels fear to tread. Anyway, I presented myself to Clunies Ross, who was by then chairman of CSIRO in Melbourne, and said I thought he should give me a job there. He must have passed this on to the Division of Plant Industry, because I was offered a job in the mountains with quite specific terms of reference to investigate the relations between vegetation and water yield. That was the start of many years of mountain work – some of which is continued today, although by other people.
How heartening to hear that a report you made to the Snowy Mountains Authority was received favourably, and acknowledged, and a national research organisation took up your suggestion that you could offer some value in a specific region. I can't see that happening in either case these days.
I can't either. I guess that, for one thing, the starting up of the Snowy Mountains scheme provided a big crunch because hydro-electricity generation relies on water availability. For another, there was still not much known about the high mountain areas, and even a little additional knowledge was better than none.
And that additional knowledge came mostly from your setting up the study sites. I imagine that at first you may not have realised quite how long they would go for.
That's true, but in CSIRO the main lines of work that I followed (with colleagues such as Dane Wimbush) were still the same: the relationships between water yield and the different vegetation types in the mountains. Water can be regarded as a crop, which like other crops has various components to its yield. The main components of water yield – quality, quantity and distribution in time – were examined in a series of experiments that ran for years.
The quality component of water yield in the mountains is affected essentially by soil erosion, so we investigated the relations between plant cover, infiltration and surface run-off. This was done through a series of experimental plots, with natural and artificial rainfall, and we found that the minimum cover requirements to get maximum infiltration and minimise soil loss in the mountains were roughly 100 per cent ground cover at approximately 10 tonnes per hectare. This concept of cover standards has been taken up all around the country now.
The quantity component of water yield in these mountains had previously attracted interest because this was a snow country environment. Much of the yield in the mountains is from snow, and one of the many things affecting it is simply surface roughness. The rougher and the taller the vegetation, the more down draughts it causes; snowfall comes with it and that snow tends to last longer among the rough vegetation, improving continuity of yield – and therefore distribution in time.
The quantity of water yield is related also to very finely divided rain and cloud, at near freezing point. This brought me into contact with CSIRO's early rainmaking experiments in the mountains, particularly in relation to rime – much cloud comes in as supercooled droplets, and whenever it touches anything under those conditions it ices out. So the vegetation there has quite a big effect in increasing both the amount of water yield and its continuity.
To translate this to catchment condition: generally speaking, a fairly natural vegetation with scattered trees to produce down draughts, turbulence et cetera, with a continuous grass cover underneath at the rate of about 10 tonnes per hectare, is the optimum for water yield. It took quite a long time to develop that.
In contrast to many lower environments, where the tree cover has deeper root systems and so tends to use more water than herbaceous cover, we didn't find there was any 'water penalty' in having trees in the high country. With its deep soils you've got a reasonable amount of soil moisture available to plants for most of the time, and retaining the native cover caused no offsetting greater loss by evapotranspiration.
So that tended to set a standard which might be related to whether land uses involving burning and snow lease grazing would satisfy the water yield requirements.
Was your CSIRO work in the mountains related entirely to water yield, or to conservation of that environment as well?
Well, although nature conservation in the mountains around Kosciuszko could perhaps be seen to start with the establishment of the State Park in 1944, at that time water and water catchment were all-important. It wasn't until the National Parks and Wildlife Act in New South Wales was passed in the mid-1960s that the emphasis began to change from catchment to nature conservation. And it just so happened that a lot of the work we did on water yield was of direct relevance to nature conservation, particularly because rangeland grazing is so selective in terms of plants – and of plant communities like sphagnum bogs – which are important for nature conservation. So the work had relevance for both water catchment and nature conservation purposes.
It was during this time that we realised the importance of having permanent reference areas and areas that we documented over a long period of time. Sooner or later people will say, 'Oh well, you say it was like that, but prove it. It could easily have been due to this or that.' The long-term vegetation measurements which Dane Wimbush and I started – and which Dane and, later, university people continued after I had left CSIRO – have proved extraordinarily valuable. Their use exemplifies a rather interesting change of emphasis from water conservation to nature conservation. Those long-term measurements have been exceedingly important to national park management, in so far as we have not only documented the changes that have occurred exactly here and there but we have been able to relate them to environmental factors like heavy snow years, light snow years, cold winters, the occasional drought.
Renewed attempts to increase snowfalls by cloud seeding (if they prove effective) could upset these long-term measurements, however, by introducing another variable.
I believe that at those long-term study sites you developed a number of innovative ways of capturing the information, such as by stereophotography.
That's true. To set this in context: the prerequisite to any ecological work in the field is equivalent to the three Rs, Reading, wRiting and aRithmetic. You've got to have the basics right. It is essential to know the plant species properly, to know the soils properly, and to know the main components of the environment that you are dealing with. This sort of knowledge accumulates as you go on.
Collecting the information is enormously time consuming and you have to streamline everything you do, in order to handle it. For example, during my time in the Victorian Alps, long-term recording work similar to the work I've been describing was beginning on the Bogong High Plains. But it was incredibly detailed, involving many, many university students, and we realised there was no way that with our very small resources we could handle that sort of thing up in the mountains. So we had to look for different techniques, although the detailed botanical work was still necessary.
In our CSIRO line transect work we developed methods of tape recording in the field and transcribing all the information in the evening, and we had one of the early computer people work with us so that this went onto computer tape. So all this is available now and it will always be available. And we realised that photographic evidence is very important to decision makers so Dane Wimbush, in particular, developed very simple means of stereoscopic photography on permanent quadrants.
Does this stereoscopic measurement give you a three-dimensional view of the area?
Yes. It just involves a frame on which a camera, say with a broad-angle lens a metre or more above the ground, can be moved from position A to position B to give a stereoscopic pair of photos which you then examine through an ordinary stereoscope. If you want to make it really quantitative you can superimpose any kind of detailed grid on what you are looking at, and map the changes in extreme detail.
The resulting reference material has proved absolutely invaluable, because even if people were to say that a particular spot was atypical of anything else, the facts of life could be shown to be that that's what was there, those are the changes that have occurred, and that's where it is at the present time.
Did any further research avenues open up from your mountains work for CSIRO?
Yes. From the initial survey work, the catchment work, the detailed quadrat and transect work, there were all sorts of spin-offs – the paragenesis effect of periglacial activity in soil formation, the Kosciuszko Alpine Flora which a group of us were able to bring out to make our knowledge of the plants more generally available, and many other examples. I think many of my former colleagues would agree with me that this was a very good feature of working in CSIRO at that time. Of course you were expected to do what you were employed to do, but there was plenty of scope and encouragement for taking this avenue, and another one, and another, provided the extra work was vaguely related to the main job.
That is how I got involved in Quaternary ecology and some of the earliest carbon-14 dating that was done in the mountains, which established the general contemporaneity between glacial and post-glacial events in the Australian Alps and in the Northern Hemisphere. That was a pretty remote offshoot from the main work, but it all started with the recognition that some of the soils were deep peats, and some of those peats obviously were pretty old, being on glaciated or periglaciated surfaces. And there were many other cases like that, for instance the role of atmospheric dust coming in from the dry parts of Australia to the mountains. Sometimes the snow is quite red; in drought times out west more comes in than during good times. This is one of the important sources of particulate matter in the mountain soils in the Alps, and people are investigating the possibility of using the amount of these deposits in some of the peats deposited year by year as an index of aridity in drier parts of the continent.
You said that eventually you reinstated yourself with Sam Clayton. How did that come about?
By the time I went to the CSIRO and resumed my work in the mountains, the Snowy Mountains scheme had started, the snow lease controversy was on, and my work became involved in the controversy.
During that time there was one inspection after the other, including several by senior New South Wales public servants and even one by George Enticknap, the Minister for Conservation – who had to decline participation in the horseback part of an inspection because he had only one leg, having lost the other in the First World War.
Sam Clayton kept away from me during all those inspections but one crucial inspection, probably the one that clinched the final removal of grazing from the Kosciuszko National Park, was made by the Catchment Areas Protection Board, of which Clayton was chairman. We spent most of the week in the southern and central parts of the Kosciuszko park, the last part of the inspection being in the north of the park around Rules Point and then Currango Plain. On our way out, I took them over to the Brindabellas – and although that's physiographically very different from the Kosciuszko area, there was a particularly good bog, the Ginini Bog, which we visited.
The contrast between the Ginini Bog and all of the bogs and swamp communities we had seen in the Kosciuszko park was overwhelming, reflecting simply the fact that the Cotter, because of human health considerations related to the water supply, had been taken out of grazing and public occupation ever since Canberra was set up, so the Ginini Bog was in a pristine condition. There was good regeneration of snowgum and other things too.
That inspection decided the day as far as the Catchment Areas Protection Board was concerned. And, humorously, I can still remember that big hand thumping me on the shoulder as Clayton said, 'Alec, you can call me Sam.' So yes, I did reinstate myself.
I think that people like Clayton are extremely important because of what they stand for. In those days many of the state and federal departments – especially those concerned with resources – had permanent heads who were outstanding in their professions. They stuck to their guns; they not only believed in what they were doing but tried to achieve what they wanted done. In a sense they were above politics. You know, for generations we've had a battle between bureaucracy and politics. At that time, I think, the bureaucrats were on the winning side; these days certainly it's the politicians who are winning, because there are very few permanent heads and because department heads often have very little background in the profession they're associated with. Clayton was a good role model, in that he really believed in what he was doing and he tried to have it done.
When you started at CSIRO you headed up the Alpine Ecology Unit, based up at Island Bend.
That's true. It was the central camp that was responsible for the Guthega development, the first development in the Snowy scheme. Island Bend doesn't exist now, though.
Living and working at Island Bend, did you feel isolated from the rest of the world?
That's a very interesting question, which bears on much of what we've been talking about. There had of course been earlier work than mine at Kosciuszko, especially by geologists. Most of it was hit-and-run work where a person is up there for a few days, does a bit of work, and bang, there's a publication on it. This was the way of things for a very long time.
But as soon as someone was working there and could take visitors around, the feedback that occurred was incredible. I had so many visitors I didn't know how to handle them. More and more came, not only from Australia but from overseas, swarms of them. The overseas people, especially, were very interested in coming to a place whose counterparts they were familiar with in the Northern Hemisphere. There is a great paucity of high mountain environments in the Southern Hemisphere in the mid latitudes that the Snowy Mountains occur in, those mid latitudes being mostly ocean, so this very small amount of Australia has attracted a lot of attention. And the mere fact of having someone there that could help them get around resulted in a big spate of scientific work all over the place. It didn't in any way reflect the quality of the Alpine Ecology Unit but simply the fact that it existed. It is a great pity that it no longer exists, but other organisations are now well involved.
Not all of your 19 years with CSIRO were spent at Island Bend. You actually lived in Canberra for most of those years, didn't you?
Oh well, we had six young kids that were still babies, it became unsustainable and I was transferred to Canberra. Dane Wimbush and another offsider continued at Island Bend for quite a long time, and then occupied premises supplied by the National Parks and Wildlife Service at the foot of the mountain.
The Canberra move did me a lot of good. I still commuted to the mountains almost every week and participated in what was going on, but what I hadn't had before then was working in a group of scientists. In particular, the editorial system, the critical review that went into papers prior to publication in Plant Industry, was exceedingly good.
What are some memories of your time at the Black Mountain laboratories in Canberra?
They relate largely to my exposure to other activities in which I participated. One of those was catchment work at Ginninderra, where most of our grazing work was carried out, looking at cover standards in the same way as we did in the mountains. This confirmed generally that, say in the tableland-type environment, the typical grazing environment, you need to have at least 70 per cent ground cover before you've got effective soil protection. And this just stands to reason, because at such cover rates the vegetation is essentially the continuous network and the bare ground is the discontinuous part of the system, and you have a reasonably stable situation. But once the cover is reduced below about 70 per cent, it is then the bare spaces that start to become the continuous parts of the system, and that's when the trouble really sets in. In effect, that's what happened right up on the top of Kosciuszko: once a little bit of bare ground was exposed, the causative processes continued to enlarge it and soon produced a greater expanse of bare ground. Continuous selective grazing has that effect as well.
We also examined the longer-term sustainability (a word which I use rather apologetically) of current improved pastures in the Southern Tablelands environment. We had to measure everything that went in to the experimental area at Ginninderra and everything that came out of it, and because we wanted to make it bigger than on a plot scale we had to instrument a catchment there of several acres, setting up water measuring equipment combined with automatic and manual sampling equipment to measure suspended sediment as well as nutrient losses.
The long and the short of it was that with a fairly good stocking rate of about five dry sheep equivalents to the acre, and given a well-established phalaris/subterranean clover pasture – which is not the most productive pasture but is certainly a sustainable one – that sort of grazing system seemed okay. There were minimal losses of nutrients. The loss that was most serious then, and seems likely to be most serious in future, was simply the losses of phosphorus if superphosphate was applied just before a heavy rain, when it would wash off. And bear in mind that most phosphate in soils is fixed in the surface soil. Any area that is prone to surface erosion is therefore prone to losing a lot of its phosphorus along with the surface soil.
That work had interesting side effects. Work on Scrivener Dam was proceeding and we had queries from the National Capital Development Commission to the effect of, 'Good God, when we've built this dam, is it ever going to be filled with water?' On the basis of some of the catchment results when big rains gave big percentage run-offs we simply said, 'No worries, mate. You'll wake up one morning and the dam will be full.' And that's just how it was.
Another activity in those Canberra days was the development of the Australian rangelands research program, which was meant to be a wonderful research project that brought together not only CSIRO research but research in universities and in the various state departments, like the Queensland Department of Primary Industries – all groups involved in arid zone research. It started fine, with a lot of cooperation, but inevitably the power seeking happened and it went off in the wrong direction. Participants lost interest and although part of the rangeland program continued, it never lived up to its expectations.
One of my other jobs was to reorientate the staff of the Riverina Irrigation Laboratory from irrigation research to dryland research. That was successfully done, despite quite a lot of trauma in the staff, and it resulted in some extremely good work on grazing diet selection. The principles are the same whether you're dealing with arid zone areas or with alpine, but some very good dryland research work came out of that.
I think some of your activities at CSIRO have carried over to later years.
That's true. One example was in relation to national parks in New South Wales. Because of my continuing efforts in Kosciuszko, I became a member of the Kosciuszko National Park's advisory committee, and continued with that long after I left CSIRO. Also, in about the mid to late '60s, the New South Wales National Parks and Wildlife Service was set up under Tom Lewis, the Minister. Lewis was very effective on the Kosciuszko committee – he knew what he wanted but was always ready to listen to reasons for doing something else. And one of the first things he did was to ask Harry Frith and me, 'How can we best get a representative group of parks set up in New South Wales?' We told him he could do it quite quickly if he had two or three people on it whom we named, but he would have to accept that he was getting an answer that was 90 per cent correct rather than 99 per cent correct. This proceeded like a house on fire, and the meetings we had were very effective indeed – until every Tom, Dick and Harry in terms of interest groups wanted to get on the committee. In no time flat it got so bogged down that no decisions were possible because there was always something else that needed investigating, investigating, investigating.
One of the huge tragedies of that, from a conservation point of view, was the way the woodchip business got off the ground in New South Wales. Geoff Mosley was on that committee too, and Geoff and I had the job of attempting to define the coastal environments in New South Wales that merited coming into the National Parks and Wildlife system. We could do this quite readily from parks we knew, but to be on the safe side we then had to look at all the areas which were still Crown land, and because they were so important in all sorts of ways our recommendation simply was, 'Get the lot. Have all of the still available Crown lands.'
That was the time, however, when the meetings were starting to bog down, and that's when woodchips arrived. Not only state forests but other areas of uncommitted Crown land were brought into the woodchip system. And that's how New South Wales lost much of what could have been a magnificent belt of parkland, right down the coast of New South Wales.
Another important activity which continued to be important after I left CSIRO was an endeavour to look at a relatively undeveloped area, within stone's throw of Canberra, which was of value for water production and still had some degree of flexibility as regards current and future land uses which could conceivably have some effect on water yield – if water yield were given a high priority. The area that more or less selected itself was the upper Shoalhaven catchment, where the Sydney Water Board for donkey's years had been progressively buying up land, adequately compensating farmers, and leasing the land back to them until such time as the dam was built. That dam has now become a no-no. It was to be built in the 1990s but the waters of its tributary zone are now being utilised to supplement Sydney's water supply.
Anyway, it was an ideal area to examine the effects of different land uses under different climatic, soil and slope conditions, in terms of water yield.
Another activity took place at about the time when systems ecology started to take off, when we appointed one of the first systems ecologists outside the CSIRO computing section. We first got a student of Bill Williams, one of the early people in the CSIRO computing system, and subsequently we got Alan Ashton. Using the old-fashioned computing techniques then available, they were able to develop realistic models incorporating all the components of the landscape, climate et cetera, in terms of water yield. And we were able to test this quite well against actual run-off data held by the Sydney Water Board. This was quite a success story.
As in the Snowy days, essentially we examined water as a crop, and one could show quite definitely that, in certain environments, its value as a crop exceeded the value of developing those particular environments for pastures or pine forests. It was better to leave those environments not only in their existing eucalypt conditions, but – this is the interesting thing – with a lot of the semi-cleared land and so on just as it was. The low carrying capacity of its pasture was offset by a relatively low water use and a high water yield. Those recommendations would still stand, because the Water Board was pretty keen on them at the time, but I don't think it will ever come to anything more than an academic exercise, because the economic pressures to develop have been too strong.
That group was, effectively, broken up during changes in the Division of Plant Industry. A lot of the writing up still had to be done, and it's one of the things that I was able to continue with later.
You say the economic pressures to develop made that, in effect, an 'academic' exercise, yet it sounds like an 'economic' one. You were considering opportunity costs of different land uses, which I would have thought were specifically what government would be using for its decisions.
Well, I guess it was an academic exercise in terms of individual farmers, who could always push down a few more trees. That was still a time when the application of superphosphate was cheap because of the superphosphate bounty et cetera. And as long as you can make a quick quid, there's always a case for doing it.
All this sounds like an analysis of ecosystem services, to use the current term.
No-one called it ecosystem services at that time. But I was brought in contact again with Sam Clayton by an ecosystem services sort of issue. It was in the days when Canberra's water supply was getting dirtier and dirtier after heavy rains, and more and more attention was given to whether pine forests in the ACT were contributing to this. Of course, the forestry lobby said, 'No way,' but other people weren't so sure.
Pine forestry in the ACT started essentially as a rabbit control and weed control measure round Uriarra, where there was a lot of eroded land. But its success there led to its progressive extension into the Cotter catchment. Whilst the gentler slopes of the Cotter catchment were being developed everything was okay, but when there were no more of the gentler slopes the development got onto steeper and steeper slopes, such as under Mount Coree, where there was some horrendous erosion. By contrast, I have been told that before the Second World War there was no problem in using water direct from the Cotter for laboratory work, it was just so good.
Anyway, Sam Clayton was called down from Sydney and I went in from CSIRO, and we looked at quite a lot of these areas. I had an MSc student, Don Gilmour, working with me, using the same techniques that we used in the Snowy to measure run-off and soil loss, both with artificial rains and with natural rains, and believe it or not Don Gilmour's data was the only really firm data showing where most of the soil was coming from. In fact, Professor Teakle, the then Professor of Agriculture in Brisbane, used it when he was called down to Canberra by the NCDC as their special consultant to look into Canberra's water supply. And that data has, I think, helped say no to any more pines in the ACT – or at least, if there were to be more pines, to look elsewhere to plant them.
In all, that part of my CSIRO life was satisfying in some ways, because it was somewhere between research and application. You could see that what had been found on a small, experimental scale made sense in the real world, was worth doing.
You left CSIRO in 1974. What lay behind that departure?
I was never a good administrator, and I should not have gone into administrative positions. I think that sums it up. It was also at a time when the Division was in something of a turmoil, in that it was very large and there were quite disparate groups working under the same broad umbrella. It was also a time of extreme competition for positions and resources. A lot of CSIRO's research was being done with industry money, particularly wool money, and people were in permanent positions that depended entirely on industry funds – until wool money started becoming very hard to get and an awful lot of competition for funds and resources developed.
Without in any sense having a chip on my shoulder, I must say that ecology was not then regarded as top-rate science. There were strong pressures all the time within CSIRO to reuse ecology positions and resources, and particularly to close down or at least reduce the extent of field activities, which are usually more expensive than entirely laboratory based ones.
It was certainly that competitive atmosphere, and the realisation that ecological work was going down the drain, that led to some illnesses that I had. And so, when the medical officer said I'd be better out of it than in, I left CSIRO.
For the next few years you were a Visiting Fellow at the Australian National University. I believe this was a time of consolidation and restoration.
What put me on my feet again, both physically and mentally, was the fact that my late wife and I took on a 1500 acre farm in the upper Shoalhaven catchment, near where our group had done the systems work in conjunction with the Water Board. The extremely hard physical yakka that that involved, together with the fact that when a problem arose I couldn't find someone else to fix it but had to do it myself, was of great benefit to me.
Something else occurred which was very satisfying and helped restore my faith in myself a little. In taking on the property, I developed it according to the accepted prescription of entire farm planning that had been pushed for a long time by the Soil Conservation Service, but with the additional constraint of superimposing water conservation, and especially wildlife and shelter conservation, needs upon the soil conservation that up till that time had been the priority consideration.
The simple, effective way of doing that is still the McHarg overlay technique, where you have a map showing the soil and slope resources of the farm and you superimpose a map showing the areas best suitable for agriculture, then superimpose one for pasture, and so on. It's simply a restatement of the land use capability approach that's been around for a long time, except that instead of only one possible land use, agriculture, having top priority, every land use has top priority if it is most suited to the particular site.
This is really the way we approached national parks, beginning with a zoning plan at Kosciuszko. We had to incorporate hydro power and also certain tourist development, but it was possible to stratify the whole area in terms of those uses for which it was not only most suitable but often the only site that was suitable. So this is in a nutshell what I tried to do on the upper Shoalhaven. And it seemed to work.
This is where the shot in the arm came. I suddenly found, to my complete surprise, that I'd been awarded the prestigious McKell Medal for outstanding work in land and water conservation in Australia. That bucked me up quite a lot.
So it was a time of physical reclamation and restoration, and I was soon again dealing with much of the carry-on work from Kosciuszko. I was able to do quite a lot of work finalising Kosciuszko Alpine Flora.
At first it was Donald Walker, in the ANU Research School of Pacific Studies, who gave me a room to do that. I'd be in for a couple of days a week and up at the farm for the rest of it. Frank Fenner later enabled me to work in the Centre for Resource and Environmental Studies, CRES.
So I was able to finalise quite a lot of the work that I'd started at Kosciuszko. If it weren't for that break, I don't think any of the long-term transect work with Dane Wimbush would have ever seen the light of day, because Dane by that time had been transferred to Canberra and pulled onto other stuff. So it was a bit of luck, actually.
It is the writing up that really makes it of worth, isn't it?
Absolutely. A very interesting outcome while I was at CRES arose because at that time the late Colin Williams, a wonderful bloke, was the soil chemist in Plant Industry and one of his main interests was phosphorus. Most phosphorus is fixed in the surface soil, and increasing intensification of agriculture and pasture causes more and more of the goodies to become increasingly concentrated in the topsoil, which is the vulnerable part of any soil erosion that might occur.
So Colin and I brought out Phosphorus in Australia, which was essentially a book of specialists in different branches of phosphorus – natural occurrence, mining et cetera. If there is one resource that is very limited in nature but which we are using very fast, extravagantly and probably irreplaceably, it's phosphorus. In fact, a book by a colleague of mine entitled Feed or Feedback takes phosphorus as something that might stymie world agriculture in the future.
Also, I have mentioned the Shoalhaven work which was discontinued before it had been finally written up. I was able to incorporate that, using a fellowship from the Reserve Bank which I took out at CRES, to produce a publication on the Shoalhaven with the title Harvesting Water from Land.
Another important outcome at that time, although the first part of it had been done when I was still in Plant Industry, was a very good book by a group of us simply called Conservation. It was based on a series of TV productions outlining the situation with respect to soil, water, national parks, wildlife et cetera – the main natural resources in Australia. The series went off very well and the book was widely used in schools. A second edition was brought out when I was with Frank Fenner in CRES, and we were lucky enough to have a chapter in it by Nugget Coombs, who looked at conservation from the social aspects as well as the more particularly scientific aspects that we had looked at it from.
That time at the ANU was great. Even though it was only a stone's throw from where I used to be in Plant Industry, I wasn't cluttered up, and I enjoyed that enormously. In fact, I had to make a big decision about whether to stay on at CRES after Frank Fenner retired as Director and a new Director, Stuart Harris, the economist, took over. I was tempted very much to stay on, although my interest in the farm was the thing that was pulling me. By that time I'd had to sell the farm at Braidwood and I'd moved down to where we are now at the coast, at Bodalla.
The thing that would have kept me, because I tried very hard to get it off the ground – and a couple of years ago I tried again – was one of my dreams in ecology. The object was to have a group of senior ecologists that knew a bit about every one of Australia's main land use environments. We were building a small but pretty good group of specialists. Len Webb was the Australian expert on rainforests; I knew a bit about the high country, Richard Groves about grassland, and Edmund Gill about forests; John Leigh had come in from Deniliquin on the semi-arid and arid zone; we had Ted Moore on temperate woodlands, and Ted Coaldrake on coasts. By means of a series of seminars that would probably go on for about 10 years, each specialist in his field would organise appropriate symposia, the outcome of which would be, 'That's the way it is, and that's what the best scientific, considered opinion thinks we ought to be doing about it.' It would have provided a consolidated picture of land use in Australia.
Well, the group split up and it didn't come to anything, but if it had come to something I would have liked to stay on. There was a lot of support for it, but not in the right places. I think it's an objective that is even more necessary now than it was then, because more and more irreversible steps are being taken in resource use every day now.
Frank Fenner was head of CRES when you were there. But I believe your association with Frank went back well before that time at ANU. Can you tell us a bit about it?
It went back a long time, perhaps even a bit earlier than my first acquaintance with Frank, because when I arrived at Island Bend, soon followed by my wife and four babies and another two shortly to arrive, there was a very kind visit by wives of CSIRO and ANU people including, I think, Bobbie Fenner. But very soon after that I first made my contact with Frank – on the rabbit issue, of course. Frank and others working in his group considered rabbits that had never been exposed to the myxoma virus to be necessary for further experiments, but pretty well all the rabbits that you could catch anywhere had been exposed to the myxoma virus somewhere or other. There was a possibility, however, that as the main vector, mosquitoes, petered out with altitude, if you could find populations of rabbits high up above the mosquito level you might get the virgin rabbits that had never been exposed to the virus. And that's how my first association with Frank started.
When snow fell in the high country, rabbits tended to go up the roads and tracks and establish, but big snow would wipe them out. A huge snow in 1956 – I don't think there's been a bigger one since – covered the ground with deep snow, but on this occasion a couple of warrens had managed to dig themselves out and the rabbits were still there. I was able to identify these with Frank, and so he came up with his blokes to catch a few. It was one of the amusing nights of my life when big fellows with butterfly nets and torches kept disappearing down wombat holes, trying to chase rabbits to take back to Canberra. But it was a successful time, Frank got his rabbits.
Almost right from the beginning, then, Frank was at least in the wings with regard to land use problems in the mountains, and he always kept very close to that issue so indirectly I was associated with him.
The next main association was just before CRES was set up in the ANU. Fred Morley and I – he was, like me, an assistant chief in Plant Industry, but more on the agronomic side – had a phone call from Margaret Mahoney, Frank's secretary in those John Curtin School days, to come over for lunch with Frank. Our very interesting conversation with him concerned the university's idea that it might set up a school of agricultural sciences, cashing in on the availability of a large amount of good research work in the CSIRO laboratories at Black Mountain and at Wildlife. Frank said, 'Well, the university's considering this, but what do you think about a school of natural resources instead of the school of agricultural sciences?' Fred was quite a good conservation thinker and we both said that sounded terrific.
I came closer to Frank because of my involvement in some early Academy of Science reports, but it wasn't until I'd left CSIRO, gone to Ballalaba on the Shoalhaven and then started to get my work going again that I really got to know him. That was when he invited me to go over to CRES and to make use of its facilities, at first to finalise the Kosciuszko Alpine Flora, but also to do all the work on the Shoalhaven, because that's where the Reserve Bank fellowship was to be held.
One reason why CRES was so good for that work was that one of its early appointees was Peter Young, a wizard in systems ecology, and he left behind a couple of very good people who were there when I came. But I then had some of the most intellectually difficult moments of my life; I just couldn't get into the Shoalhaven work. I remember saying to Nugget Coombs, 'Look, I'm just not going to handle this, I can't seem to break it. I ought to give the money back to the Reserve Bank, because they're not going to get anything out of this.' He said, 'Oh no, stay with it. It'll be all right. And anyway, the computing side is starting to come out.'
So I stayed for another couple of years, and because I was pretty well established then I enjoyed it. I was able to do other things as well, including the Phosphorus in Australia. And I got to know Frank a lot.
You have mentioned Nugget Coombs a couple of times. What did you think of him?
One reason I value that time at ANU is that it brought me in contact with Nugget Coombs, who was a great bloke. We had a joint secretary who ruled us both, and she was absolutely marvellous. Nugget has helped me a lot in my life, particularly in my scientific life, because he once said to me that his guiding principle when he was Governor of the Reserve Bank was, 'Do I turn left or do I turn right?' He said, 'I'm not worried about the peripherals and the ins and outs. I know that if I am generally pointing in the right direction, I'll be able to home in anywhere I like within an angle of 180°. But if I go in the opposite direction, there's no way on Earth I'll ever be able to turn 360° and start again.'
For me that's an important principle in science, particularly in ecology, because it is a broad picture. There is so much detail in ecology that you can get flummoxed with, yet much of the ecological work now is done with detail and the detail becomes important. You proceed both by refining the detail and by enlarging the picture – it's not that one is mutually exclusive to the other – but the essential thing is to get that broad picture right and to know generally the direction in which you're heading.
One of the little papers I was involved in is simply called 'Replaceable and irreplaceable resources and land use', and tends to prioritise the resource that you're dealing with in terms of whether there's plenty of it so to all intents and purposes it's inexhaustible; whether there is a limited amount of it and once you've used it you've used it; or whether there's a limited amount of it but you can keep recycling it and using it. To look at resources in those basic terms helps in deciding on those steps which can be taken with safety and those steps which can't. It certainly reinforces the precautionary principle in all resource use: if you're in doubt, don't, until you really know what you're talking about.
A key scientist in the original myxomatosis work with Frank Fenner was Francis Ratcliffe, head of the Wildlife Survey Section at CSIRO. I believe he was a very good friend of yours as well, and you both had a lot to do with the establishment of the Australian Conservation Foundation.
Yes. Francis was a very good friend before the embryonic days of the Australian Conservation Foundation. As with Frank Fenner, it was really the rabbit business that brought Francis and myself into contact. Francis was overwhelmed by the spread of myxomatosis, which strained all the resources he had in the Wildlife Survey Section when he just wanted to be working on Australian native fauna. So occasionally he would come up to the mountains, more often than not with Lindsay Pryor, who was then superintendent of parks and gardens and became Professor of Forestry at the ANU. Lindsay would come to look for hybrid eucalypts, and Francis just to get away from rabbits. So I first got to know Francis more or less in his escape role, getting away from the responsibilities of rabbits and into work that he liked doing.
Soon after I came to Canberra, Harry Frith took over the Wildlife Survey Section and Francis came back to his old haunts, having been originally within the Division of Entomology. He was given a tin shed midway between the Entomology building and Plant Industry, and we often used to meet there to have lunch and Francis would talk about his hoped-for popular movement of conservation in Australia. He was very much guided, I suppose, by the achievements of the American Conservation Foundation, and he spent his retirement in that tin shed trying to work out ways and means of getting this off the ground in Australia. I think Francis needed someone to talk to, and quite frankly there weren't many other people around for me to talk to either, because there weren't many people professedly in conservation at that time.
It developed that perhaps the American model was the way to go, and a planning meeting in Sydney was arranged with the head of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia plus quite a few wealthy VIPs; I think Garfield Barwick was there early in the piece; and we had Geoff Downes, who was one of the few people really into soil conservation, and Dunbavin Butcher, from Victoria. The intent was to raise money, but shortly afterward the Commonwealth Bank man died and without his initiative the thing lapsed.
Francis, however, kept going at it. His first assistant to help him with his writings and what have you was a retired major – an Army man, an adventurer and great in the Outward Bound movement, but offering no real intellectual contact with Francis. So that didn't work at all. Later though, Geoff Mosley (who had recently completed his PhD on wilderness in Tassie) came in to give Francis a hand.
With considerable difficulty the ACF did get going, with funding from the federal government for several years until such time as the Foundation, through its subscription membership, was able to develop its own revenue. At first it had no accumulated work on resource issues to make a good impact on the public. So Francis' idea was to take known success stories of resource issues and publish them as 'viewpoints' to get through to the public. The first viewpoint concerned the Cape Barren goose – the way cray fishermen used it for bait et cetera, and the success story that, if there is a reserve where the habitat is looked after, the habitat will look after the species. A bit later Geoff Mosley and I did a viewpoint on the Australian Alps. So this was using information that was already available.
But the ACF didn't really prosper. It moved from Canberra to Melbourne but was still not regarded as a popular organisation and didn't make much of a public impact. The first director, Dick Piesse, had considerable experience in tourism but never hit it off with Francis.
In Canberra I was asked by Fred White to have lunch with some people from CSIRO head office to discuss the ACF. A group of very senior public servants were also there, including one from Treasury who said bluntly that the ACF had had its money and from now on had to stand on its own feet. Fred White asked me to sum up what I knew about the ACF and whether I thought it should be continued, and how. I said, 'It's obviously trying to do a job that has to be done in Australia. It's something that the federal government should be looking at. And to look at it right now it would cost the government far more than the value of the grants that go into the ACF.' The government did then give the money for them to continue, which the subscriptions and the expired grant hadn't provided.
At the next annual general meeting, in the Academy building in Canberra, Garfield Barwick was in the chair and when the time came to elect the next director, he said in his usual autocratic way, 'There'll be no other nominations. Mr Piesse will be director again.' But Geoff Mosely – who was already assisting Francis and working with Dick Piesse as well – was nominated on the spot and then elected virtually unanimously. I think people realised that he knew about conservation and was one of the leaders in wilderness issues who could really do some good.
From that time on, Geoff threw himself into the ACF and made a huge difference to it. I'm still closely in touch with him. We both tried repeatedly to get the Australian Alps listed as World Heritage, and eventually it started to become a popular thing and did get off the ground.
You were made a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science in 1980. The Academy is our body of elder science statesmen, the Brains Trust for Australia. Could it fulfil the role of the expert group you wanted to form?
I don't think it has enough ecology in it. It has a marvellous array of specialists, an incredible strength of specialists, but I don't think ecology has been a particular highlight of Academy activities in recent times. In retrospect rather disappointedly I think I was able to do more before I joined the Academy, in terms of those activities that the Academy took on, than after. I think one of the reasons is that in the early days the Academy took up issues as issues rather than issues in terms of specialities.
An example arose while I was working with the CSIRO at Island Bend. One of the early conservation activities of the Academy of Science was a report by an Academy committee on snow lease grazing in the Victorian and Australian Alps, including Kosciuszko, and on the interests of the Snowy Mountains Authority and the possible effects of the Snowy scheme on catchment and national park values.
A group of us soon followed up one of the report's suggestions, that the completion of the Guthega project should be closely re-examined because indisputably it would cause quite severe, irreparable damage to some of the above-treeline parts of the park. This was opposed by the Snowy Mountains Authority, but Otto Frankel as chief of the Division at the time, and Fred White as chairman of CSIRO, didn't give me the sack because of it. And behind the scenes they supported a person's right to speak out on what they believed in.
By the way, I believe this was another outstanding feature of working with CSIRO at the time. If a person had something worth while to say and they had the evidence to back it up, okay, they could have a go at it.
While I was with CSIRO in Canberra the Academy of Science took an important role in the International Biological Program with respect to identifying the main plant communities in Australia, as a basis for their conservation. Ray Specht was the convenor of that, but I was convenor of the New South Wales group. That operation of the Academy I think was very successful.
You have referred to leadership roles being played by scientists who know about natural resources, ecology and ecosystems. What role should scientists and organisations like the Australian Academy of Science and CSIRO have when it comes to Australia appropriately managing its natural resources?
They should have a very important role. And I think Australian science is doing its duty in that role when it comes to some of the global issues of natural resources, like global warming. Many of the most important issues in natural resources concern almost the day-to-day decisions that are made in their use, but there is an irreversibility principle that once something is done, theoretically you can undo it but practically you're committed and you've got to go with it. I think there is an absence in Australia of extremely well-informed groups of scientists that at short notice can speak out publicly, without necessarily being asked as the Prime Minister's Chief Scientist seems to be. There is a big need for select groups of senior scientists to be on tap, their prime role being to respond to day-to-day issues; if they don't have the information themselves, they have the contacts to get it immediately – even if they have to look all around the world.
My colleague Robert Carrick (long since dead) called what he visualised for CSIRO and the Academy a 'phantom Division': a small group of very good people, the prime purpose of which is to give scientific information at that stage of knowledge, not pretending that's the last word but saying, 'This is the state of knowledge about this right now,' without having to set up committees that go for years before getting anywhere.
I think that's a role that even the Academy, with all its specialist scientists, could well consider. It's got the infrastructure, it's got a big secretariat, and this phantom group would not necessarily consist of the same people all the time. People could almost nominate or the Academy could second them, or, when a particular issue comes up, the Academy could go to two or three people and, for that issue, say, 'We want an answer in the next week. What's the best you can do?' I feel there is a big need for the expression of scientific opinion on day-to-day issues as well as the more remote global ones.
What do you see as your greatest contribution in your life's work? Is it those long-term data sets that you established, or perhaps the synthesis afterwards?
That's hard to say, because people have different opinions. I'm struck by my sheer good luck that when, almost by default, I went into ecological work in the Australian high country, virtually nothing else had been done. It was an open field. Later it attracted interest simply because some work was being done and someone was there. There is now a remarkable increase in the amount of effort that goes into getting information. So I suppose having had some role in achieving that is good.
Something came right out of the blue concerning that original book of mine on the ecosystems of the Monaro, which has all sorts of things wrong with it – not so much in the content except that that is obviously grossly incomplete in many places, but in the quality of production as an early Government Printer Sydney job, with photographs that were taken with a little Box Brownie camera and leave much to be desired. Not much more than a year ago a group of my colleagues got together and, quite unknown to me, had this book republished, just a limited edition of about 50 or 100 copies. It was a shot in the arm for me, that people would think that worth doing.
Oh, I have been lucky, despite a lot of heartache in it, that I happened to arrive in the conservation scene when it was just coming into its own. A lot had happened before that, for instance in parks: we had early parks that were there because of their scenery. Most of the earlier work on plants and animals was based on the conservation of individual species, with all sorts of regulations against picking wildflowers as a protected plant, and animals et cetera. But it really wasn't until during and after the Second World War that ecosystem ecology started to emerge, and almost whatever natural resource you're dealing with now, you have to look at it in an ecosystem context.
To that extent I've enjoyed my involvement in work that might appear to be primarily for water, or for soil conservation, or for nature conservation, because it is really part of the whole system. And you need to see it in that context, not in order to get it right to the last little angle but at least to start off getting it 180° right. Having gone in that right direction, you can home in, change direction. It's a good position to be in.
Are we, as a nation, going in the right direction in natural resource management?
No. Take soil conservation. Maybe 30 years ago, and then 20, the Standing Committee on Soil Conservation in Australia brought out two reports documenting the extent of soil degradation at each of those times. That was a powerful document saying how much needed spending on it and where. No action. Now we don't even have Soil Conservation Services. They have been amalgamated with these rather amorphous departments of natural resources, where the identity of the profession is lost. On the one hand, I think more for bureaucratic and political reasons, we seem to be more aware of the whole natural resource system, because we do have departments of environment and of natural resources. But I do believe that increasingly they have been emasculated and deprofessionalised, in terms of the key groups in them.
You can say this about water. In New South Wales, just as we used to have Soil Conservation Service, so we used to have a Water Conservation and Irrigation Commission. Okay, it was primarily an engineering thing, but it knew a lot about water. Some of those people still exist, as do some of the soil conservation people, but not as professionals in their own profession. What we're seeing happening in water right across Australia – and this is the key answer to your question, I think – is the privatisation of natural resources. In my opinion, without being communist or socialist or anything like that, these are resources of which we have to take incredible care; we have to be incredibly careful not to make irreversible steps. We have the principle of irreversibility in public affairs, just as in ecological affairs. If you go too far, theoretically you can get back but you have got Buckley's chance.
Water is one of the best examples of what we are doing in our key natural resources. We have virtually given water away, we have privatised it. Irrigators now have huge amounts of water as rights. Snowy Hydro has huge amounts of water as rights. Corporatisation of Snowy Hydro must mean that water is increasingly used for what appears to be at most value at the present time. Environmental flows are right at the bottom. To achieve them while water is a public resource is really a political decision, and hopefully it should be based on the best technical information that politicians can get. But the only way that we can get such water in the future is to buy it back from the people we've given it to, and this is going to make environmental water management more and more difficult because it is going to be increasingly expensive.
In effect we've done the same thing with our forests. New South Wales Forests, like ACT Forests, has effectively been privatised. Inevitably its emphasis is on money rather than maintenance or improvement. We forget that the worldwide role of forestry 100 years ago, say, was not so much of timber production but of watershed protection, amenity, multiple purposes. It's difficult to see us getting back to that.
I think we are tending to privatise national parks. We are permitting big commercial developments in national parks – admittedly within a 'development zone', but without doing anything much to prevent the edge and spillover effects of those big developments.
So one of the disappointing things is that whilst there appears to be a much greater interest in conservation, this greater interest seems to have been accompanied by a loss in professionalism in the management of our resources, and a loss of the sort of people in top places that can ensure future interest.
That's a commentary on existing trends. Maybe a comment now about the future. What do you think the prospects of the high country are, with the coming climate change that everyone has been talking about?
I think you've really got to divide that question up into a number of questions, looking at the broad picture of the Australian Alps and the scenario we are confronted with: slightly increasing temperature which may reflect itself in all sorts of ways.
Because of an interest in historical ecology – what's happened there, what's happened over the last few thousand years, what's happened over the last few tens of thousands of years – one is impressed by the fact that the environment always sorts itself out. And one is impressed that the time scale available to environments to do this is much more forgiving than the time scale we think is important to us.
Looking at the Australian Alps from a vegetation point of view, I feel pretty sure that one way or another the plant communities, and particularly the species in them, will sort themselves out. One of the things we forget as far as so-called global warming is concerned is that wherever you have a diverse environment – and it's magnified in steep places like the mountains, where there may be several degrees latitude and several degrees of mean annual temperature difference between an exposed, sunny slope and a protected, shady slope right next to each other – the elasticity that is available just in the sheer physical diversity of the environment will enable at least most of the species to take care of themselves. This doesn't mean to say that some species might not be knocked out of some communities and have to move into others.
One also has to realise – for example regarding Kosciuszko alpine flora, with 200-odd species, 20 per cent endemics, a high degree of endemicism – that stress is often what stimulates speciation. Take the genus Ranunculus, of which there are several endemic species at Kosciuszko all growing near each other: this one in this site, this one in another site, all within a few metres of each other. So any stress situation may in fact stimulate speciation as well as act against it.
Climate is another aspect. The Australian Alps are marginal in terms of semi-permanent snow cover. But bear in mind that the area has very high precipitation, even by world standards; a lot of moisture comes down there. And, in contrast to so many of the world's mountains, where the accumulation of snow is the result of small additive increments of small snowfalls one after the other, under low temperatures, gradually building up a snow pack, the characteristic of our snowfalls is that they come in big dumps. A big snow year might mean only three or four big dumps. You might get innumerable small snowfalls but that doesn't make much of a snow season. It's not really a matter only of temperature. It's when one of those lows happens to come up that's just right, and bang. So I'm undecided about that one.
From the land use point of view, the combined effect of land use pressures and climatic change pressures could certainly produce undesirable effects. For example, progressive light snow years are likely to do more harm to the vegetation than heavier ones, because under light snowfall conditions plants and soils are exposed to freezing temperatures, whereas with a protective snow cover they are insulated. So this again is a time scale thing. Those things may well happen.
But there is another side to the equations. It's interesting to look at the controlling factors in, say, the distribution of many species in Australia. Take the eucalypts. Most of the eucalypts in south-eastern Australia are limited by rainfall, by this, by that, but more often than not their limiting factor seems to be low temperature. In other words, if it got a bit warmer, they would do better. So I think much of the vegetation would handle that all right. And if things got a little bit warmer in other parts of the world, huge parts of what is now tundra in Alaskan North America, Russia, Mongolia, Iceland, would become productive as far as economic land use is concerned. By and large there are some parts of the world that would benefit from it and other parts of the world that wouldn't.
To come back to your question: I think the mountains will handle climate change all right, although it might be uncomfortable for us.
You've been on this farm at Bodalla for the last 20 years, I believe. Have you maintained contact with your scientific colleagues in the highlands over that time?
Oh yes. For example, I have mentioned Dane Wimbush several times today. He started off at CSIRO as a university student during his long summer vacations. There was no way that, even with our speedier methods of vegetation recording, one or two people could do it so we had to pull in two or three university students. Dane was one of the first to come, and he stayed on. He lives at Bermagui now and we're still in close contact. There are also other high country contacts that I've developed through contacts down here.
What's the nature of that contact? Have you been involved in consulting, or advocating certain views, or is it more of a social interaction?
Well, there's certainly some social interaction. But it's more to do now with the land use problems associated with the use of mountain resources. More demands are being made on one and the same resource. One example is sustainable tourism. Quite a lot of the projects are supported by tourism money, so they are to examine whether such and such a thing is okay. I have got my tongue in my cheek with a lot of those, because the more basic issue of whether such activities should be occurring there at all is not being looked at.
But one of the most absorbing problems now is the huge and growing one of so-called hazard reduction burning, which I believe has taken over as the major dominating activity in most of our forest lands in eastern Australia, even including the more sparsely forested ones in the marginal snow country. That problem is one on which I'm having a lot of contact with colleagues at the present time.
There is also an ongoing debate about the role that grazing might have in managing or reducing fire risk in certain areas.
Yes, this is rearing its head again, despite the absolutely overwhelming evidence that rangeland grazing, particularly together with fire – which accentuates the pressure of high grazing selectivity – has no part in our higher mountain catchments, and no part whatsoever in any of these areas which are national park, because the effects of selectivity on change away from natural are enormous.
So, if there is such a thing as a primary truth, those important truths are still there. Yet there will always be people trying to get back in. It is said that the price of peace is eternal vigilance, lest sooner or later something slips in and gets you. Of the threats we have been discussing, the hazard reduction burning is by far the most important.
Incidentally, the hazard reduction burning ignores one of the most fundamental resource equations that exist with respect to our natural and near-natural lands: fuel = catchment protection = habitat. We are now so dominant with respect to reduction of fuel, some of which is quite unjustified anyway, that inevitably we are drastically reducing catchment protection and drastically reducing habitat. Here again, if we had the good professionals around in those resources that we are talking about – soil and water, wildlife et cetera – we would not see such nonsense.
Don't let me go on record, even by inference, as saying that I don't believe there should be any hazard reduction burning. I'm not saying that at all. But a great deal of hazard reduction burning – which used to be called protective burning, and before that control burning – is absolutely inappropriate in most of our back country.
Firstly, it never achieves what it is supposed to achieve, the reduced occurrence of devastating wildfires such as we've had. They are absolutely under the control of prevailing meteorological conditions combined with a preceding year or more of incredibly dry weather. If any fire starts under those conditions, let alone fires that are started by 20 or 30 or 50 almost simultaneous lightning strikes, there is no chance of doing anything with it until either it burns itself out – in other words, there is no more to burn – or there is a change in weather conditions. This has been the history of wildfires in Australia and it will continue. So some of these areas are going to get burnt anyway, but at nowhere near the frequency with which they are being burnt at the present time.
A lot of the ecological communities that we are seeing now are communities that need 100 or 150 years' protection from fire. If you look at the demography of communities in the forests, say in snowgum woodland, you will find that possibly less than 5 per cent of the entire community is old growth forest. The rest of it is succession forest in different stages – some burnt a few years ago, some from 1926 fires, '39 fires and so on. But the occurrence of old growth stands is diminishing. Simply, that is not because we're not having big wildfires. We are having a few of them, but if the area is big enough then the statistics are on your side. If you put fires through again and again and again, the statistics are not on your side. So we are losing the very naturalness which is one of the primary objectives in all our national park legislation.
To come back to sustainability: in trying to define sustainability – and this is why I think national parks and what's in them are so important – you look for communities that have been able to sustain themselves. Why are they there, why have they been able to persist, and what lessons can we learn from them?
Well, they've been able to persist because they haven't been disturbed for a long time, although we might not think that's a very good criterion. But also they have been able to exist because they are largely living on their interest, not on their capital. Once they get to that stage, it's mostly leaf fall et cetera that is maintaining the community with respect to nutrients and so on. By contrast, in most of our more economic uses we're living on capital, not on interest. As well, old growth things are great conservers and they're very possessive. There's a huge biomass tied up in that big tree we can see from here, and in the absence of something like a wildfire that destroys most of it, it's not going to let go. Its foliage, its trunk and its roots are great reservoirs of carbon and nutrients, from which the old growth communities draw only interest.
So, when we are talking about sustainability in our natural systems, we have to give special attention to the old growth components, and the processes and properties which enable them to be there. That's another reason why I think our hazard reduction burning is very ill advised.
Nevertheless, around buildings, around townships and so on there will always be a need for more localised protection. Some of my colleagues and I, increasingly and very strongly, advocate for a change away from widespread hazard reduction burning to sacrificing areas in frequent hazard reduction burning around settlements et cetera, combined with intense fire hygiene around every township and community. Even with the Canberra fires one is aware of houses which survived, the next one went, the next one survived. The story has been told in earlier inquiries too, as in Hobart years ago, as in the '39 fires, that there are always places which escaped. Intense fire hygiene is a very important component of how we should proceed with the work of burning.
On your way here today you would have seen a lot of smoke arising. That burning is being done to protect a big extension of the Bodalla township into the Bodalla Park Estate, an extension into forest land right next to a state forest. Where you have this situation, what alternative do you have? But that doesn't mean that all the back country, miles back in the mountains, should be subject to the same process.
You have spoken of old growth forest. You yourself are part, I suppose, of our scientific old growth, having found lifelong sustenance in understanding the ecosystems around you, particularly the high country. Would you advocate that those beginning a scientific career in ecology, ecosystem services, should follow a career path of seeking knowledge from the ground up, as you did?
I think there's now more and more interest in the term 'services', as in ecosystem services, and that's an exceedingly important area to get into. It's combined with the so-called footprint now: the size or weight of a footprint on a resource. I mean, how many hectares of the Cotter catchment does each Canberra resident need to provide the service of water, to provide the service of local recreation et cetera? Whatever the career path, the three Rs of ecology – to know the plant species properly, to know the soils properly, and to know the main components of the environment that you are dealing with – are all-important. A good basic education in resources is a prerequisite for being able to look at any part of the whole system in context.
As just one example of what I have seen happen, I think forestry in Australia is still suffering from the fact that much tertiary forestry education in this country has been dominated by commercial forestry, and therefore the timber aspects of forestry are still dominant. And when the Parks and Wildlife Service was set up in New South Wales, it suddenly became big and there were not enough dedicated and trained parks people to fill the positions; there was naturally a career movement of public servants from other departments, including Forestry. I feel that the Parks and Wildlife Service is still getting over that.
I do think there is a big career path in ecosystem services, but there is something else that is also important. I have found in life and still do, every single day – like the way that apostle birds, white-winged choughs, have turned up here today for the first time, probably because of the fires just over the way – that with a soundly based ecosystem education you can always relate to something. It's part and parcel of being able to enjoy the world that you're in, no matter what part of it you are in. It wouldn't matter if I was in South America, I'd recognise Nothofagus and I'd relate to it. And I remember in the '50s attending a little kindergarten school in Denmark where all the kids were being taught real 'nature study' – a term which we now deride as old-fashioned but which in effect says what the ecosystem business is all about. It's a return to nature study but by defining the components of the nature that you are studying, understanding the processes, how they fit together.
Are you optimistic about the world and our chances as a race?
No, I don't think I am. I feel mankind's main problems are still almost Malthusian ones of overpopulation and therefore the inevitable pressures on resources. That's the key to everything. Even if nuclear technology and the availability of cheap fuel and the ability to get fertiliser out of seawater were ever to come off, overpopulation would still be the number one problem. The results of overpopulation are increasing demands on natural resources, particularly on land and water resources, with respect to soil erosion and water. So it's population, soil and water which to my mind are still top priorities, and until you start solving those problems – of which population is the essential one – it's a bit hard to see a big future for saving the world.
Let's come back to the theme that it is so incredibly important: to retain, wherever we can, examples of largely unspoiled nature, because they are the only permanent reference points we have of what can be done. That old tree in the paddock is a big tree at 30 metres, 100 feet. The tallest trees in the world now are only 300 feet. In von Mueller's time, in the mid 1800s, Gippsland trees were 550 feet. Unless we have big enough reserves to preserve those examples, we lose sight of what's possible. When mankind does get on the right track – if it ever does – these possible achievements are no longer possible because they are beyond the personal experience of anyone.
I believe that in the context of Australia, unlike so many other countries, we still have the chance to preserve such examples. This is the IBP thing that the Academy took on years ago, and we have done very well with the reservation system of largely natural environments throughout Australia. We are not doing at all well with management, however, except in places like south-west Tasmania, where we have been able to achieve World Heritage status so they now have international protection as well as state and federal protection. Groups of us have been trying for years to achieve World Heritage protection for the Australian Alps, but there is so much opposition from vested interests.
It's good that we do have parks to start with. At the present time I feel that unless we can get those existing parks recognised as international icons, like World Heritage, we've still a long way to go in our state and federal system before we're really protecting them.
Thanks for your time today and for sharing your views on the world.
© Australian Academy of Science
Professor Lesley Rogers, neurobiologist
Professor Lesley Rogers interviewed by Professor John Bradshaw in 2001. Lesley Rogers was born in Brisbane in 1943. She received a BSc (Hons) from Adelaide University in 1964, where she investigated the physiology of long-necked tortoises.
Lesley Rogers was born in Brisbane in 1943. She received a BSc (Hons) from Adelaide University in 1964, where she investigated the physiology of long-necked tortoises. From 1965 to 1966 she was a teaching fellow at Harvard University and from 1967 to 1968 she was a research assistant in the Gastroenterology Department of the New England Medical Center Hospital in Boston. In 1971 Rogers received a DPhil from Sussex University in the UK.
Rogers returned to Australia in 1972 when she was appointed as a senior tutor in the Physiology Department at Monash University. From 1976 to 1977 she was a senior research fellow at the Australian National University. From 1978 to 1985 she was in the Pharmacology Department at Monash University, appointed initially as a senior tutor, then ARC research fellow and finally as a lecturer. Rogers joined the Physiology Department of the University of New England in 1985 as a lecturer. She received a DSc from Sussex University in 1987 for her thesis entitled Neuroethological Studies of Brain Development and Behaviour. In 1987 she was appointed senior lecturer and in 1989 was appointed associate professor. She was appointed to a personal chair in 1993 and is now Professor of Neuroscience and Animal Behaviour. In 1997 she received the Vice-Chancellor’s Award for Excellence in Research. Her particular research interests include the structural and functional lateralisation in the brain and the effects of early experience and hormones on brain development.
Interviewed by Professor John Bradshaw in 2001.
Contents
- Childhood steps toward science
- Choosing a career interest: the path to biochemistry and zoology
- Political by-ways on the road to a PhD
- A change of scenery: via cancer research to a new PhD opportunity
- Researching the isthmo-optic nucleus and the effects of testosterone
- Learning new approaches to scientific inquiry
- A return to Australia for a new direction in research
- The chick model delivers insights into memory and lateralisation
- How does lateralisation occur? An exciting explanation
- Is lateralisation of behaviour significant for survival?
- What determines how lateralisation works?
- Appreciating the grey areas as well as the black-and-white
- Rejoicing in the broadening of knowledge
- Distinguishing between biological science and convenient explanations
- The scientist as researcher, teacher and administrator
- Resolving identity problems in scientific disciplines
- Transcending stereotypes to follow a passion for science
- The best environments for the best research efforts
- Widening the audience for scientific knowledge
- Giving the Eureka moments a chance to occur
- Research funding: taking all the potentials into account
- Satisfactions and setbacks: social responsibility in science
- Drawing the line in acceptable research
- Enjoying life's fascinations
Childhood steps toward science
I wonder, Lesley, whether something in your early days set the stage for your interest in science.
I wouldn't say my earliest memories had much to do with science. The first thing I remember, from when I was a babe in arms, is seeing a huge crack in our terrazzo verandah looming up at me as my brother accidentally dropped me. And I remember being in a pram on the front lawn of our house in Adelaide, with a gum tree moving against the sky.
My mother's sister was a science teacher, and also my immediate family had some interest in science which I suppose must have had an impact on me. My brother, who was eight years older than me, was particularly fascinated by ants and how their colonies organised themselves, and I used to share some of that interest as well as my family's love for animals in general. We spent a lot of time every holidays camping in the bush, and we would often spend several days down at the mouth of the River Murray, where my father owned an old boat. We would go past the mouth of the river from Goolwa down into the Coorong, which at that time could only be reached by boat. I used to roam the sandhills there and observe nature.
I think your love for animals made you interested in going into zoo keeping.
When I was very young it was my aim to become a zoo keeper, but not in any academic way. I used to organise little zoo displays, getting together all the children in the neighbourhood and lining up their pets along the front footpath for various adults to look at as they passed. Actually, in retrospect that was not a very great career to have aspired to – I'm now quite opposed to zoos except for certain species.
Did you study much science at high school?
Well, if you were interested in going to university it was two maths, two languages – I took French and Latin – English, physics and chemistry. I loved physics, it was my favourite subject. But I read beyond the school curriculum, which wasn't terribly entertaining. I wanted to do biology as well, but that wasn't open to girls unless they were seen to be not university material.
Those years at Norwood Girls High School were an interesting time, because the girls and the boys were kept separate. There was a white line painted down the middle of the school, and the girls had to stay on one side and the boys on the other. In fact, if you were caught putting your toe over the white line during school hours you got quite severe punishment. In the final year (called Leaving Honours) there were so few students that boys and girls were put together, but until then physics was taught separately for girls and boys. We had excellent teachers, however, and in retrospect I think we were rather special. The selective school was actually Adelaide High, but Norwood High was extremely good.
Choosing a career interest: the path to biochemistry and zoology
Did you have some idea at the back of your mind that at university you'd eventually switch to the biological sciences if possible, and perhaps go into veterinary science?
I would have done vet if it had been open to me, but in Adelaide there was and still is no veterinary school, so it would have meant going to Melbourne or to Sydney – which in those days wasn't the sort of thing that was ever considered for a girl, particularly from my background. Also, I needed to have a scholarship, and when you applied for the scholarship it was always to the university in your home town.
So I went to Adelaide University, set to become a physicist. I took what they called Physics I, which was the one leading on to further study. There were about 180 students in the class, of which two of us were girls. It was a frightful experience, because I was the only young woman in my tutorial group and the lecturer always asked me to solve the problems, do the theorems on the board and so on. Years later I discovered that the lecturer asked me because he knew I could do them, but in those days I was terribly nervous and thought it was just to show me up. He used to laugh and then the boys in the class would laugh, and I was totally demoralised. (The other girl student and I were not a support to each other, which was also typical of a time when women were not well accepted.)
About halfway through the year I decided, 'If this is what physics is, it is not a career for me,' and I actually dropped back to do general physics – a terrible thing to decide, because in the entrance exam I had come fourth in the state in physics and the general physics was really just a catch-up course for people who couldn't do physics. But by then I'd met encouraging people in zoology, which tied in with my love of animals, and I took up biochemistry and did my honours in zoology.
For my honours I worked on the long-necked tortoise. These tortoises migrate over quite long distances in dry conditions, and the question was how they maintained their water levels. I discovered that their urine just concentrates in the bladder and the water gets resorbed into the body. Later it was shown that many frogs – and some mammals – do the same. My findings were published, I might add.
Political by-ways on the road to a PhD
After honours you began a PhD, didn't you?
Yes. First of all I was accepted to do a PhD in Adelaide, at Waite Agricultural Research Institute. That was looking at metamorphosis in tadpoles and changes in enzyme levels and so on, but it didn't work out terribly well and I got the idea it would be better to go overseas. In those days you weren't respected as a scholar in Australia unless you'd either come from overseas or been to Britain or America.
I was awarded the George Murray Scholarship from Adelaide University, and took it to Harvard University. The problem was that although the money might have been sufficient to support you through living in the UK, you couldn't have lived on it at Harvard, and also the fees there were very high. So I had to take up a teaching fellowship as well, which meant teaching 20 hours a week plus doing a full-time course. That is how I made a second start – not really wanting to have to – at a PhD.
I didn't finish my PhD at Harvard, however. By then it was the mid-'60s, and even before I left Adelaide I had been an active member of the anti-nuclear campaign and had moved on into the early anti Vietnam war movement. When I got to the United States I was on some of the first demonstrations in Boston, in Harvard Square, where there'd be about 60 of us marching. (Of course later it got to be thousands and thousands.) If you were heard to have a foreign accent, you were given 24 hours to leave the country, but I survived by carrying placards and being careful not to speak.
But then I also worked to get the vote against the war through the city council in Cambridge, which was the first place in America that actually voted as a people against the war, and my involvement in those political activities clashed with my studies at Harvard. Foreign students were not supposed to be involved in all these things, and in fact I was told to leave Harvard. I was pretty devastated, because I had been brought up in a family who were, on my mother's side, very strongly left-wing and very outspoken about their political views, and I'd just been continuing what I was used to.
Your PhD supervisor was a well-known person. Didn't he support you?
My supervisor was George Wald, who shared the Nobel Prize for vision. (That was two years after I had left Harvard.) He was against the war and eventually became one of the leaders of the whole anti-Vietnam movement. In fact, he came to Australia and led big marches here. But being young and flamboyant, I came out in favour of the National Liberation Front, NLF. He saw me as a threat to the middle-of-the-road approach and we clashed in a fairly fiery way. I could have followed Seymour Levine's advice to fight against being thrown out of Harvard for such a reason, but by then the scholarship was in jeopardy and I had financial problems, so I didn't think it was an option. In retrospect it should have been, but these things just carry you along.
A change of scenery: via cancer research to a new PhD opportunity
What did you do when you had to leave Harvard?
I avoided deportation by finding a job at the New England Medical Center Hospitals (associated with Tufts University) as a research assistant to Marshall Kaplan, and they filed the papers that allowed me to stay in the United States.
We were working with alkaline phosphatase, which comes in various iso-enzymic forms. Until then, finding where a tumour might be located in the body required an operation and a biopsy. We developed a method of taking blood samples and separating the iso-enzymes so you could tell whether the iso-enzyme of alkaline phosphatase came from bone or liver, and so where the cancer might be located. The idea of doing this technique came from Marshall Kaplan, but I did the actual working-out of it for him. It was really just cookery: you had to fiddle and get each of the concentrations right. By then I had had quite a lot of training in biochemistry, but you needed to use a bit of intuition about what to add to what. And if it works, it works.
Actually, this became a major technique, even a classic. When I went back to Tufts a year or two later, I was surprised to find that the red carpet went out and everything. There had been more than 1,000 requests for the paper in the first year, and largely as a result Marshall Kaplan had been made Director of the New England Medical Center Hospitals.
Did you think of continuing that work as PhD research?
They did try to encourage me and would have given me a scholarship and so on, but by then I had decided that adding one colourless liquid to another and putting it into a machine to be read was not really what I wanted to do. But at Harvard I had taken a course in animal behaviour, and my interests in that had grown; then I met somebody who had worked for Richard Andrew at Sussex University and she suggested that I try to get in to do a PhD there.
Actually, I first went to London and worked as a teacher in a secondary modern school in the Notting Hill Gate area. That was an experience – the students were like the girls of St Trinian's. I had enjoyed reading those stories, but that was when I realised such girls did exist! When I met Richard Andrew, he did offer to take me on for a PhD, so I continued teaching for a while – about nine months altogether – to get some money, and then took up the PhD at Sussex.
How were you funded?
Well, having lost the George Murray Scholarship I was a bit high and dry. Sussex gave me a scholarship that waived the fees and I had a living allowance, but to help out I taught part-time at the Open University, which was newly started, and did some demonstrating on campus and so on. Also, from time to time my parents sent me a little money, as much as they could afford. So I managed to live, even if very frugally.
Researching the isthmo-optic nucleus and the effects of testosterone
What work did you do with Richard Andrew at Sussex?
There were two aspects of the PhD work. I started off looking at the effects of lesioning the isthmo-optic nucleus in the chick brain. The isthmo-optic nucleus sends efferent nerves to the retina, and the bird brain is a great place to study that because there is a clear nucleus with a tract going to the eye, whereas in humans and even in amphibia and so on the origin is more diffuse, and, in those species nobody knew exactly where they came from. So, along with Fred Miles, who is now at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) in Washington, we looked at the effects of lesioning that nucleus. He was looking at the electrophysiology, the whole feedback loop, and I was looking at some of the behavioural effects.
That was not an easy task. Any kind of lesion you make in a visual system, particularly of that nature, tends to be compensated for, so it's really hard to tease out what the visual lesion is. After working for about a year with indications but nothing particularly concrete, I shifted to look at the effects of testosterone on attention. But I later came back to the isthmo-optic nucleus and did solve it, and got a paper that has recently started to be cited again as people have really got interested in that.
The major part of the thesis, though, was on the effects of testosterone, again given to the chick as a model. I discovered that when you elevate the levels of testosterone, the chicks become attentionally persistent. As a simple example, if you give them red and yellow grains to peck at, the control chick will peck a few times at each colour, switching around, whereas the testosterone treated chick tends to start on, say, yellow, doing a very long run of pecking on that, and then switches to a long run on red. So there was quite clearly a difference in attention switching.
Would these levels of testosterone be higher than normally occur in male chickens in their breeding cycle?
Well, the actual work I did was on young chickens, in which they were certainly very artificially high. But later, when I came back to Monash, I looked at adult roosters – some which were castrated versus those that weren't – and that showed the same attentional persistence in the ones with the higher level of testosterone. So it worked with natural levels.
Presuming that roosters, like the passerines, have elevated levels of testosterone at certain times of the year, in accordance with their breeding cycle, might a linkage between those levels and attention be related to the normal behaviour patterns to do with mating and breeding?
Yes. Richard Andrew showed later, again with the young chick, that one reason why they may show elevated copulation and attack levels when they're given testosterone is that they just lock on to an object. If you give them a cup, say, they will look at it, lock on to it and actually try to attack it, to copulate with it. Of course there is a threshold effect in these elicited behaviours. But another part of the motivation would be that once you've got locked on to an object you are more likely to do something about it. Maybe an adult rooster will lock on to whatever hen it wants to copulate with at that time.
Learning new approaches to scientific inquiry
Role models are often thought to be important for young scientists. Did you find that working with Richard Andrew enabled you to learn much from him?
Richard was an enormously important role model for me. He is one of the true intellectuals, well educated in the arts as well as the sciences, and he thinks very creatively. He was terribly important to me at that stage of my career because he'd see a little thing happening that I might have tended to throw away and not pay attention to, and he'd build on that. I had to learn to realise that, if not all the animals do the same thing, it may be those few that are doing a different thing that can really tell us more. It was quite a step in my thinking, because previously I had been caught up in the number crunching – 'If X of them do that; that's what they do' – whereas in fact it's some of those that diverge from the expectations that we follow up. Richard taught me to recognise that as part of the art of science.
I know he is retired, but have you continued to collaborate with him?
Yes. In fact, we've just finished editing a book on comparative vertebrate lateralisation. He's very much not retired; like so many people in his situation these days, he finds that retirement has given him time to think and his ideas seem to have moved on to a very new level as a result.
A return to Australia for a new direction in research
What brought you back from Britain to Australia after your PhD?
For the PhD I took three years, so with the teaching I was in Britain for close to four years overall – seven years away from home. I hadn't any intention, really, to come back. Many of the students who go overseas these days can afford to come back, but in those days it was out of the question. When you left you set sail, in effect, and that was it until you'd finished.
By the time my PhD was finished I had found a niche in England and had become very much an expatriate. Richard Andrew had offered me a good position and I could see a very good career ahead of me in England. But I had a responsibility to my parents, and if I was going to come back it had to be then. It might sound odd to feel responsible in that way at such an age, but I was the last survivor among my parents' three children, so there was an enormous feeling that I should be around for them.
I came back to Monash University, however, not Adelaide. I was offered a lectureship at the University of Tasmania but I didn't take that up – perhaps I was silly not to, but coming back to Australia seemed to be far enough and Tasmania, nice as it is, seemed to be the other end of the earth. But Richard Mark, in Physiology at Monash, offered me a senior tutorship. That was not tenured but it seemed to be research oriented, and Richard had a good reputation and had visited Sussex. Although I didn't actually know him, Richard Andrew did and was very encouraging for me to join him.
And so it was, in 1972, that we first met, when I used to consult with Richard Mark. You and I have known each other for nearly 30 years!
The chick model delivers insights into memory and lateralisation
Is that when you started to work on memory?
Yes, in a way. Richard had developed, along with Marie Gibbs (his PhD student prior to my coming there), a model using the chick to look at the biological correlates of memory formation. Because of my experience with the chick I took that up and looked at protein synthesis inhibitors and blockage of long-term memory – the 'in' topic at the time.
I found, however, that if you gave cycloheximide, blocking the protein synthesis in the chick, not only did you block the memories that might have formed about the time of the injection but the chick never learnt as well thereafter. So there was an added effect, not just on memory but as some brain damage that resulted from the treatment.
Was the cycloheximide technique something that you or Richard had developed, or was it fairly standard in those days for manipulating consolidation in memory?
Richard and Marie were already using the technique before I came to the lab, having picked it up from Art Cherkin in the United States, I think, so it was a rather new technique using the chick as the model. The chick has now become one of the classic models for studying memory, and that sort of technique is still used – I believe that your colleagues at Monash, John, still use the chick and cycloheximide, as does Steven Rose at the Open University. He had made big progress in looking at the cascade of biological events that occur.
What led you to realise that there were lateralisation effects with memory? Did you already suspect this, or was it a chance observation?
It was a chance observation that you got this long-term effect which I was then teasing out and looking at in more detail: what actually had gone wrong, what was causing it and so on. But Richard Mark had worked with Sperry – which would be your common interest with him too on the lateralisation – and so one day he said, 'Well, why don't you just try injecting cycloheximide into the left or right hemisphere separately?'
Together with my honours student Judith Anson, who is still working in Canberra, I tried that technique and found that on the task of searching for grains on a background of pebbles, long-lasting effects of the cycloheximide were caused only by injecting the left hemisphere. There was no effect at all if you injected the right. (It turned out later that other functions are associated and affected when you inject the right.) So on that one particular task the asymmetry was discovered. Actually, it was at that time pretty revolutionary, apart from Fernando Nottebohm's demonstration that a number of species of songbirds have the centres for singing in the left hemisphere. The syrinx, the musculature, is also lateralised in the songbird. At that stage he had only shown it by cutting the nerves supplying either side of the syrinx; he had not yet taken it to the central nervous system.
Up to that time, lateralisation had been thought to be unique to humans – in fact, seen as the thing that gave us our wonderful superiority of language and consciousness and tool use – and there are still some people around today who think that. But Victor Denenberg, at more or less the same time, was showing laterality in the rat brain.
How does lateralisation occur? An exciting explanation
Having discovered and documented that asymmetry, you went on to develop Denenberg's point that environmental influences can also modulate laterality. You were the first, perhaps, to note and to develop the interaction of the environmental factors with the genetic print.
After I had discovered this lateralisation, when I was following it up and looking at exactly what things are lateralised, people used to say to me, 'Oh, it's all genetically pre-programmed.' Being a bit of a devil's advocate and, perhaps because of my whole political perspective, my dislike of the idea of these things being pre-programmed, I wished I could show there was some environmental influence. Then one day, when I was just thumbing through Freeman and Vince's very important book on development of the avian embryo, I noticed they had a series of pictures of the embryo in the egg – in the final stages before hatching, the embryo is turned so that the left eye is occluded but the right eye can be stimulated by light that can come through the shell and membranes. And I thought, 'Ah! Perhaps that's it.'
The first experiment, then, was to incubate eggs in the dark and compare them with ones that had been exposed to light during the last stages of incubation, when the visual pathways to the forebrain are becoming functional. Lo and behold, when they were incubated in the dark there was no lateralisation for the behaviours I was looking at: the pebble-grain laterality and also the laterality for attack and copulation. (Now, of course, many years later, we know some lateralities are still present; those are non-visual modalities.)
Later we found that by taking the air sac end off the egg at the stage when the chick's beak has penetrated into the air sac membrane so that it's now breathing air, you can just ease the membrane across, pull the head out gently and put it back into the incubator, but with the head now lying out. Then you can let light go to both eyes or else you can occlude the right eye instead of the left, and the lateralisation follows accordingly.
I know that in mammals you have a small percentage of left-right reversal of the viscera and indeed a number of other structures. Are there any such instances of situs inversus in the chicken?
I believe it occurs, but it's a very rare occasion and, unlike the work done in rats, where people have selected actual lines for that so you can work with it as a model, you could not predict where it is going to occur. I can think of only once when I have opened the egg and found the embryo oriented the other way around. There may have been more that I haven't seen, but it's very rare. And in any case, you could still have the chick oriented the same way but the viscera the other way around.
Is lateralisation of behaviour significant for survival?
What advantages might accompany lateralisation – or, conversely, what might be the disadvantages of its absence? Why is the vertebrate brain lateralised?
I hope to be able to tell some of the answer to that in a couple of years' time, because it is now my main theoretical interest. And again the chick model turns out to be terrific, because I can make more- or less-lateralised chicks by incubating them in the dark or the light, and then compare the cognitive abilities of those two groups.
Are unlateralised chicks in any way disadvantaged, either in the lab or in other settings?
In the lab we've done one experiment, giving the chick two things to do, which hints at that. The idea was to challenge it by asking its two hemispheres to do two different things at the same time. In the chick, the left hemisphere – and, incidentally, the right eye, because they have completely crossing optic nerves – is used preferentially for finding these pebbles versus grain in pecking to feed. And Chris Evans and Peter Marler showed that if you play to a chicken the alarm call for its own aerial predator, it looks up and scans overhead using its left eye (and hence its right hemisphere). So I designed a test where the chick is pecking on the floor using its right eye-left hemisphere, and then a little model predator comes over the top. It should then look up, using its right hemisphere-left eye for that. Once the dark-incubated, less lateralised chicks started pecking, they were slower to respond to the predator coming overhead. In a natural situation, that slower response could well be a disadvantage.
Is this where you expect your experimental, empirical interests to be directed most?
Well, one thing is to try to follow up more, in a laboratory setting, the advantage of having a lateralised brain – going ahead with these tasks that require competing input from the hemispheres and moving to other sensory modalities. But the other challenge is to ask whether what we are looking at in the lab is just an esoteric thing. Or does it for animals, as we know it does for humans, actually relate to their behaviour in the natural environment? Can you even see it in the natural environment? And now we have some evidence that, yes, animals do show lateralised behaviours in the natural environment.
Some really nice work with fish has been done in Italy by Angelo Bisazza and Giorgio Vallortigara, outside the collaborative work I do with them. Looking at various species of fish, they found laterality in some and not in others. Then they applied to the fish an idea I had, that laterality might have something to do with coordinating social behaviour.
They put one or two fish in a little internal tank and looked at how close the others came to it, so they could get an objective measure of their degree of schooling. Then they looked to see which species are lateralised or not: when a fish swims up to a barrier behind which it sees various stimuli, does it go left or right? It turned out that the ones that school are also lateralised – if they've got a population bias to go one way, then they tend to be a schooling species. (Certainly, to have that bias would keep the shoal together.) Of the ones that didn't school so much, some were lateralised but the majority weren't. So the consistent population bias of lateralisation was present in those species that have a sort of social order in their movement. But of course each different kind of lateralisation might be associated with a different selective pressure, or a different advantage. We should not talk as if it were unitary; it is probably much more complex than that.
What determines how lateralisation works?
Does some underlying common denominator distinguish the left side of the brain from the right side of the brain in most species – communication versus emotion or, perhaps, spatial processing? And if a final common denominator exists, does one side pre-empt processing at the expense of the other? If so, the big question would be which side, which function, which feature, which aspect of behaviour is the primary one. What are your thoughts on that?
Richard Andrew and I developed a model which we think applies to all vertebrate species, and certainly applies to those studied so far. The left hemisphere seems to be used to control responses that have to be considered, whereas the right hemisphere is more for immediate responses that are given without the pros and cons being weighed up.
In order for the left to fill its role, it has to suppress the spontaneous responses of the right, which is, as you mentioned, for expression of intense emotions and for spatial processing of the kind that uses a map. There are other, added aspects of function in the hemispheres, but as a general model one might say that feeding responses which require the animal to manipulate things or to inhibit pecking at a pebble in order to peck at a grain are left hemisphere: you've got to think about what you do before you respond. But if you're going to just lob an attack peck or strike at an animal – something unspecific which you have to do quickly – that's right hemisphere.
In some recent experiments I did when I was in Italy last, we looked at where a chick strikes. You put two chicks in together which haven't seen each other before. They tend to do attack pecks – not very damaging; some people call them social pecks – at each other. If you look at where they lodge those, you see that they are primarily in the left lateral field, which means right hemisphere. So, left side for attack, right side for feeding responses that have to be considered. And we have shown that the same is true in the toad. When toads strike at prey, they do so in the right hemifield, and if they make a conspecific attack strike, it's on the left. In other work, gelada baboons, if they attack the conspecific, tend to do the one on the left. Deckel, in the United States, has now shown this to be true in lizards also. There is a surprising similarity across many different vertebrates, so it seems to be a fairly basic property.
If the left and the right sides of the brain are different, how do you stand with respect to the currently popular 'educate the right side of your brain' literature? Is it drawing a long bow?
Perhaps there is something in it, but I think it is mostly a waste of time. There is no way you can force that. There may be useful psychological experiments where you really do put information in, presenting it tachistoscopically – with rapid flashes – so that people are looking straight ahead and the information is actually in the peripheral field and they're not turning the eyes to look at it. But that is not how these techniques go on; instead they get people to do all sorts of motor things.
Appreciating the grey areas as well as the black-and-white
I suppose most of us at some time look back and think, 'Perhaps I shouldn't have published that.' In your long career as a research scientist, Lesley, have there been any papers or findings that you now feel you shouldn't have reported because they went beyond the data, or the mathematics or the technique was wrong, or hindsight suggests a different conclusion?
No, there's nothing I regret having published. There have been odd mistakes in a paper where a label's wrong or a word is spelt wrongly; they always stand out and hit you in the face, and they make me feel very angry. But I don't publish unless I've got tons and tons of data to support my conclusion. One's ideas do move on, though.
For example, from the earliest discovery of light affecting lateralisation I said the light exposure and the orientation of the embryo determined visual lateralisation, full stop, because all the things I had chanced to look at were affected by that. Now I have been looking at some other visual behaviours that are not affected by that experience, and since not all of the visual behaviours are affected in that way, what seemed before to be a black-and-white issue is a little greyer. I would not have stated it so strongly then, had I seen as many as I have now. But that's an evolution of the idea, not the idea being incorrect. It has just been given some more substance.
Rejoicing in the broadening of knowledge
On the more positive side, is there one paper, one discovery, finding, insight that you are most proud of and would like to be remembered for?
It probably sounds quite trivial to say this, but the work showing the role of light in establishing the asymmetry in the embryo was a breakthrough in thinking, a paradigm shift, I guess. If you say to people that you've discovered such a thing for the chick embryo, they are likely to wonder why the heck it matters. But in fact it's a model system and a way of thinking about how things work. I think that was my biggest single leap.
Do you have students still working in that area, or are you much more now in the behavioural side?
More behavioural, and with many other species. We have a colony of marmosets at the university so I'm doing a lot of work on their lateral preferences and the effects on them of ageing. Also, we have shown very similar laterality in our famous cane toads and in a number of different species, even going off to Sabah in east Malaysia to work on orang-utans in the wild. So the range of species has broadened and the work is applied to what's going on in the natural world – as well as the continued lab work.
It is very hard to get students interested in chickens these days. If you've got primates in the offing, they'll go for those instead. I don't agree with that, myself. You need to ask the question and then think about the best species to use to answer that question, but you get a lot of young people today on the doorstep saying, 'I want to work on orang-utans' or some other species they have latched on to. Perhaps it comes from the television and the documentaries. It's not necessarily a bad thing to take these focus species, but it is important to come from the discipline and ask a question: 'I want to study memory,' or 'Why does this particular molecular system' – or this particular behaviour – 'function in this way?' All too often today it comes not from a theoretical concept but from, 'Oh, that's a nice species. I'd like to work with that.'
Do you have any very good students who want to look at aspects other than lateralisation?
Yes. For example, because of legislative requirements the marmoset colony has for the first time gone outside, and one student that Gisela Kaplan and I co-supervise is actually looking at their stress responses, both physiological and behavioural, to that. He wants to eventually go into the whole thing about animals in captivity and enrichment and so on. I do have other projects going on, with students whom I've either supervised or co-supervised working on them. I think that's terribly important.
Distinguishing between biological science and convenient explanations
What are your views on sociobiology and the ideas of E O Wilson – this new fad of evolutionary psychology?
I am very opposed to these developments. In fact, my book Sexing the Brain looked at what poor implications that has had for our attitudes to gender, for example. As to Hamer's whole idea of finding a small number of genes or even a gene sequence to explain homosexuality, he claims that even homelessness is on the genome. Yet we all know that homelessness is a much more complex thing than that. There are many societal reasons why people don't have a roof over their heads.
Well, we are down now to 30,000 genes – whatever a gene may be – rather than the 100,000 of about six months ago.
That's right. I am not detracting from the revolution of that; it's quite amazing how the whole field has moved along. The problem occurs, however, when you start to look at complex behaviours, animal or human, and try to use science for a political objective. This is not new but it's certainly on the rise, and evolutionary psychology is not only banal but quite dangerous when it tries to say that certain kinds of human behaviours come from our animal past and are built into our genome. It is used to implement certain social practices which we know from the history of humanity have been to the disadvantage of many groups. It is no different from the thinking that the Nazis used.
There is a very worrying trend in our society to rely on these biological 'explanations' of why one group has more than another or why one group has access to education and jobs when another doesn't. These explanations fail to distinguish between association and causation, but upper-rung people, particularly, like to hear them because they provide a nice pat answer and people don't have to think about anything else. They can just go along being oppressive to those below.
Would you say, then, that the nature/nurture debate is a black-and-white issue, or is the dichotomy invalid – do the two interact at so many levels that one can't separate them?
Yes, exactly. I would agree with you that it is not one extreme or the other. The developmental processes of genetic and environmental influences are quite intertwined. Unfortunately, with the new revolution in molecular technology and the development of evolutionary psychology coming together in quite impossible, rather sinister ways, people are now falling back on genetic explanations for even very complex human behaviour.
The scientist as researcher, teacher and administrator
As a professor, one has a number of commitments – research, teaching, an increasing amount of administration. Have you enjoyed administering such a large department?
Well, not only was I head of department but I was also, until last year, Deputy Chair of the Academic Board. I decided not to go on to be Chair of the Academic Board because I don't particularly enjoy administration. To be perfectly honest, I do administration because it has to be done; I don't enjoy it at all, so I certainly would not see myself moving into an entirely administrative position.
It was very useful to spend time being head of department, though, because for the first time I saw that many decisions, rather than having some sort of right and logic to them, are pretty random and arbitrary. The way the system works is not always through meritocracy; it is often a matter of who bumps into whom, where and when. I suppose I don't spend enough time working on that approach. Perhaps my future, in terms of climbing up the ladder and the monetary aspects, would have been a lot easier had I found it interesting to do those sorts of things, but I don't. I'm much happier to be with my animals and in my laboratory.
In your research, do you see yourself as somebody who paddles her own canoe, or as a team player? The British philosophy, as I see it, is that graduate students are thrown in the deep end and have to be their own salvation, whereas in America they very much play a role in the overall strategy of the lab or the lab's leader. How should one educate one's graduate students in research?
I guess I'm more inclined towards the British model. It suits my personality more. I like to see students come up with their own ideas. Obviously, there is some guidance and my students tend to be working on laterality, but not all of them are. If they come with a good idea that I think should be supported, I'll go with it. But very often they come without an idea, and then they get put into things that I might suggest to them.
In a way, I do paddle my own canoe. I collaborate with people overseas, particularly in the lab in Italy, but in Australia there is nobody else working directly in my area so doing my own thing is partly a necessity. Also, I probably enjoy it better.
And teaching? Perhaps you would take us through your teaching responsibilities at Monash University and the departments you've worked in.
I was initially in the Physiology Department, later Pharmacology, and I was teaching science and medical students – at first, mostly the medical students. Initially that was quite interesting, because I had done some physiology before, but I had actually been more of a zoologist cum animal behaviourist so I had to do a lot of learning. That was good; I don't regret it by any means.
I also got involved in organising the teaching of sexuality at Monash. In those days it was suddenly realised that a lot of problems that humans have when they go to doctors concern sexual issues and they're afraid to discuss them, and if they do, doctors don't know quite to do. So a number of people from Monash met once a week – over a considerable period of time, actually – in the hospital in Melbourne and even at retreats, and discussed how this program would come into operation. In those days it was seen as a really big thing to teach about sexuality at the university! I was quite actively involved in getting that program going, and then used to do some of the lectures in it. I was teaching physiology every day, with a few lectures thrown in here and there to psychology students, and so on.
Resolving identity problems in scientific disciplines
You have expertise in physiology, in pharmacology and also in animal behaviour. When did your interests in the more behavioural aspects of lateralisation take on?
It's a strange thing: once I discovered lateralisation it got me hooked. I'm still fascinated by it. I did do other things as well, such as looking at effects of 2,4,5-T on the developing brain, but lateralisation has been an abiding interest ever since the day I got into it. In a way, it has just gone on from one stage to the next: from teasing out the interaction with experience, I got onto looking at the role of hormones and how they interacted with it, and developing the model, going from behaviour to looking at visual pathways and how they develop. But now I am interested in what it actually means ecologically for animals in the natural environment.
And that has brought you back to your very early days when you were interested in zoo keeping, zoology in the broad sense. So do you see yourself as a psychologist, a primatologist, a behaviourist, a physiologist, all of these things? Or are these artificial boundaries that we should be forgetting in the 21st century?
For me they are. I think I've always had an identity problem in science. I wasn't really a standard physiologist and certainly not a standard pharmacologist, and now I'm not a standard zoologist. I think the strength of my work is to be able to integrate various things and I have tried to move intellectually with that.
I firmly think we should have discipline training, so that people know how to think in certain logical ways. I'm opposed to what is happening in the current education system, where people don't come out with a good training in a discipline but just shop around and grab at little ideas.
Should those disciplines be the traditional ones, like physics, chemistry, biochemistry, physiology and pharmacology, or are we carving nature at an inappropriate set of joints these days? Should we be looking for other ways of directing research and the modelling of the world?
There are two levels there. When we talk about modelling of the world I think we do need to move and change, but when it comes to teaching I'm very old-fashioned and think an undergraduate course should have the traditional structures. People should come out of a university able to profess their discipline. There should be physical sciences, biological sciences and social sciences, but I look with dismay at the disappearance of the need to do physics and chemistry in a regular science degree. I know that a lot of people have to be drawn along to those lectures kicking and screaming, but they are part of a way of thinking, a very important part of understanding that leads you to other areas. Without that good strong basis in the fundamental sciences you'll never have the flexibility and power of thinking that you need later on. I am all for having environmental sciences and other things taught in universities, and they should be part of a package that students can do, but there is a need for training as scientists first. Those other things can be taught, obviously – they are science – but there is a manner of thinking that you can only get by going to some of the fundamental subjects.
Transcending stereotypes to follow a passion for science
Have you found science so worthwhile and stimulating that you would encourage a close relative of yours to follow in your footsteps?
Yes. I always tell students that the important thing is to find out what you feel passionately about and do it, no matter what the opposition is. It doesn't have to be science; it could be in any other area. We only have one life to live, and the important thing is to live it passionately and do something with it, not do something just because your parents or your teacher thinks it would be good. It's got to come from within. Science can be extremely fulfilling, but if you're passionate about it there are opportunities – and of course they are increasing.
What words of advice would you give a girl who said she was passionate about following a research career in science?
I would say, 'Do it, and don't be steered off by any opposition you meet'. Actually, when you look at who does science, you see that there are more women than men: at the laboratory bench, working as research assistants or in the lower levels of the academic career. But when we look at who actually makes the decisions in science, we see that women have a very low representation. That is what we need to change. We need more women in science and we need to change the face of decision making control in science. I would like a lot of those women who get a degree and then just go off doing other people's science as research assistants to say at some point in their lives, 'Look, I'd like to follow my own ideas. Let's go beyond this'.
Do you think things like this series of videos play a useful role in countering the gender stereotypes and encouraging girls, particularly, to take up science?
I don't know. Certainly it is important that students who are contemplating a career in science see there is a career there for women. But it is still not an easy one.
The best environments for the best research efforts
Things have changed enormously in the 30 years that you and I have worked in our respective disciplines. Is there a future for universities in the next 30 to 50 years – for the lab as we know it, even for pure blue-sky research as we know it?
I certainly hope, John, that we turn back to that. I say that not only because those are the interests I have and there are young people who will be coming along with similar interests that need to be nurtured, but because it is important for the long-term future of a country that this occurs. It is in Australia's interest to continue to be like that. Australia has been a world leader in many areas in science – medical science, in particular – but we have let much of that fall away. Some of the countries that moved into much more applied research even earlier than we did are now saying it was a mistake and going back to the older models. So I'm hoping that's just round the corner for Australia too, and not too much damage is done before we pick up those important threads. I would also like to see funding go back to supporting individuals, encouraging them to row their own boat, rather than only supporting team research.
It used to be easier than now to publish as an individual. What do you think about the development of the 'invisible college', whereby a group in America, Italy, Britain, loosely collaborates for a particular topic, a particular area, a particular technique?
That's not a bad thing, you know. With the Web and so on, communication opens up. I have always seen science as an international thing, not just national, and I think that is very much in Australia's interest too, given our position in the world.
There has been some talk lately of thrusting people within an institution together: 'if they're not working together they should be made to work together'. I think that's a disaster. If people work together, they do so, it just grows. It's an organic thing. Much of research collaboration or writing books together involves finding not only the right sort of academic person but also people you can get on with. It must have in it something to do with the human element. You may work with the brightest mind in the field in your area, but if you don't get on you won't share anything.
Widening the audience for scientific knowledge
You mentioned writing a book with Richard Andrew. I know you've written a number of popular and semi-popular works as well. How might you make such books available to a wider audience?
Well John, I should add that having left Richard Andrew's lab (although I've never really felt I have, because I've kept in close contact with him over the years) I was very fortunate in going to Richard Mark's lab. Richard Mark has many of those similar qualities. He too practises science as an art form, and he writes beautifully. He taught me how to write, really. He first taught me how to write scientific papers, when I was working with him, and from there I've moved on over the years. And you taught me how to write books – I would never have written a book if you hadn't asked me to write one with you. It was a great honour for me that you asked, but it was also a new step in my life, because although I had mastered papers and could do them, writing a book seemed to be in the blue sky somewhere. It was by working with you that I realised doing it was a possibility. Then I got onto the idea of writing more popular science books, which I've thoroughly enjoyed. It is actually much harder – for me, anyway – than writing scientific papers, because I've got to think about how I write. I would not by any means say I have really mastered that art, but I have enjoyed trying to do so and I continue to.
So what will the next book be?
The next book, which is coming out next month, is actually by Gisela Kaplan and Lesley Rogers – I'm the second author on that – with the title Birds: Their Habits and Skills. It takes into account many years of work with birds by each of us, in different ways, and it tries to put those ideas in a more general context to appeal to a broad readership. And the next one after that is going to be on wild dogs!
Giving the Eureka moments a chance to occur
I have been struck by the role that chance has played in my career, at least. So many things have happened unexpectedly. Chance probably does 'favour the prepared mind', but how much has your scientific career depended on your happening to be the right person at the right place, at the right time?
Perhaps all the way along the line there has been an element of chance. I think it does depend on who you meet and where the ideas fall into place. For example, the significance of the orientation of the chick in the egg suggested itself because I just happened to be going through the books at the ideal time. And again, discovering that it wasn't only behaviour that was lateralised but there was actually a neural structure we could find was a result of chance. A visitor to my lab, doing some labelling of neural pathways with these tracer dyes, happened to think, 'Well, let's give it a go.' And when we saw it, that was a Eureka moment. Yet it was chance – he happened to come, he was looking at something entirely different, I offered him the place in the lab, we then decided to just give it a go, and it turned out.
To me there is a similarity between the arts and the sciences – the chance aspect, the human aspect, the creative aspect, the thought that floats into one's mind, often at inopportune times, and has to be captured before you lose it. Is this how you've seen your science developing?
Yes. Connections like that, between people and ideas, have to just grow of their own accord. They can't be imposed upon scientists and research, or any other discipline, in my opinion. If you give better communication – as I said before, the Web's there and can be used in that way – something will emerge out of that. But to say, 'We will only fund science if you've got this or this mould that it fits into,' is a death knell to it.
Research funding: taking all the potentials into account
At a time when it's very difficult to be an expert even in a single narrow discipline, I think you could be regarded as an expert in a number of disciplines. Has this breadth of activity ever proved a problem in getting funding or recognition?
Oh, it has probably been an advantage, because the more you've acquired different areas, the more likely you are to come up with a new idea in bridging them.
Yet we are increasingly being asked by government and grant giving bodies to justify our research. In view of such questions, what would you say have been the spinoffs, the applications, the 'utilitarian' aspects of your findings?
The laterality work has been pure research, although it does have potential application in the sense of providing a model which we can look at. As you well know, many dysfunctions of the human brain relate to laterality, so if we can study it in animals and we have developed a model, we have the tool to do that.
As far as the development of neurones goes, and the work I've done on the interaction between experience and hormones in their development – how they grow and die off in response to those influences – that is important in our understanding of the development of the brain. I mentioned that I am now, using the marmosets as a model, looking at what happens to laterality as an animal ages. And even though I would not say you can apply these models directly to humans, they do give us a basis to start thinking about whether the same things happen in humans.
It has certainly been thought that the dysfunctions associated with Alzheimer's might be preferentially lateralised.
Yes. It has been a bit fashionable to think of laterality as relevant to every kind of problem, including schizophrenia. That seems a bit over the top, but there probably are some elements that will be terribly important. Certainly discovering lateralisation in the chick brain has led to an important step for the people working on memory, very often using the chick as a model. They would use one side of the brain as the control for the other, thinking, 'Well, I've trained the animal monocularly, so I've trained its contralateral hemisphere. I now can look at what the biochemical events are in that one and compare them with the other side where I haven't trained it, because I've put a patch over that eye.' This is what Steven Rose's lab and various others had been doing. When I discovered the laterality in the brain, Steven Rose said to me, 'What are you wasting your time doing that for? What's the point of it?' but I could tell him, 'Well, in your own work you use one side as the control for the other, but if the left and the right hemispheres are in fact different, they cannot be a control, one for the other.' (He didn't ever say I was right, but he doesn't work like that any more.)
Satisfactions and setbacks: social responsibility in science
What are your views on social responsibility, the role of science in society generally?
I have very strong views that science should be for the people in general. In fact, I started a Science for the People group when I was in Melbourne, before I moved to the University of New England [in New South Wales]. While that group was in operation we did some quite interesting things, getting into the whole question of spraying 2,4,5-T to control blackberries in national parks and so on. We had some demonstrations and some lectures on that, at the time when the whole issue of the use of Agent Orange had come to a head.
In fact, you were an expert witness, were you not, for the Vietnam veterans?
Yes. While I was in the Pharmacology Department at Monash, an honours student came to me saying she'd like to work on toxic chemicals in the environment. Geoff Bentley, who was Associate Professor in the department at that time, said, 'Well, why don't you try 2,4,5-T on the chick eggs and see what happens?' I thought, 'Mm, it's a bit of a nasty thing to do, but it could be important,' so we went ahead and did that. We showed that there were behavioural abnormalities caused by doses one-hundredth the kind that were known to cause the physical deformations. That was taken up by the media and I got into all sorts of political hoo-ha.
Do you think it was in any way an impediment to your career?
Yes, I think it was. It was published in Science and so on, but it was an impediment because the political forces at that time were not in favour of it. (The government was trying to get out of having to pay compensation to Vietnam veterans.) And something quite fascinating happened. After that was in the papers in Australia, I was getting phone calls from farmers as well as Vietnam veterans, saying they suffered from these and these symptoms. First of all I'd say, 'Oh but look, my work's on chickens; I don't have anything to do with humans.' But after several phone calls and just listening to these people I thought, 'These symptoms are the same.' Then a farmer from Sale phoned up when I had been talking to a veteran from Sydney. I said, 'Look, why don't you two talk to each other, because the effects you're talking about sound mighty similar.' It was just a chance thing; I don't see myself all that instrumental in what followed, except the penny dropped. That gave rise to the Vietnam veterans' movement, which eventually led to the Royal Commission where I gave evidence.
Drawing the line in acceptable research
I am sure you would feel some areas of science should not be investigated. On the other hand, the knowledge gained from your work on toxicity and chickens enabled us to draw vital conclusions about human involvement. Where should we draw the limits? Are there any aspects of pure knowledge that we shouldn't research?
All new knowledge has the potential to be abused. It is the responsibility of the scientist to think about that before taking part in it. In retrospect, if I had been in a position to direct where money for research would be spent, I would not have wanted the scientists to work in developing the atom bomb. Of course times change and you can look at these things differently afterwards, and even today I think a lot of the areas of research that get huge amounts of money are not necessarily where it ought to be going. Research, we have to accept, is big business as well as a pure seeking of knowledge for human good, and that concerns me greatly.
I am also concerned at the present idea in Australia and elsewhere in the world that we have to be much more applied. Many of the breakthroughs in science have occurred with nobody ever thinking about what they could end up with, but this is what we are seriously losing in Australia – and have actually lost, to a large extent. We'll have to go back to it if we want to be at the forefront.
How to draw the line between acceptable and unacceptable research is a difficult one, though. You do need to monitor that; you do need bodies of informed people. But perhaps, rather than government having a major role in directing research, it could be done along lines such as we have now for animal ethics, with committees that have representatives not only from science but from many different bodies. In some senses we have that now, but I think it could become much more influential in how things are funded. Instead we are moving rapidly away from any of those models to dollar driven research. And, unfortunately, most of that research is very short-lived.
Enjoying life's fascinations
When you're not engaged in science, what are your interests, recreations, relaxation?
With a friend I have a rainforest property, an absolutely beautiful place, in northern New South Wales. The idea is to preserve some of Australia's wonderful bush, with a long-term aim of protecting it in various ways and then, hopefully, handing it over to the government. But also, in a very non-altruistic way, I am personally fascinated by learning more about plants and insects, species about which I know very little now. I'm just getting into exploring all that. That has become a very involved hobby – and an expensive one.
I think that as a child you learned to fish. Do you still do that?
No, I don't, because I don't like killing fish. I like the experience of fishing, but once when I had caught a fish I was told that I'd better kill it myself, and that was the end of fishing for me.
But I used to enjoy playing the cello – even if nobody particularly enjoyed listening to me. I used to play with the local community symphony orchestra. In the last four years of my father's life, when he was totally blind, I just couldn't keep all that up. Although I've let it fade away and I don't play the cello at all any more, I've got it sitting right alongside my desk and there will be a day, I hope not too far away, when I'll go back to it (even if I have to start all over again).
Will you ever retire, Lesley?
I won't retire from living until I have to, and they take it away from me! But I always want to do research at a different level. I will certainly retire from the university system and I'll probably retire from being 100 per cent of my time in the laboratory. I would like to do a lot more looking at animals in the natural environment, and I think during retirement I'll develop more of my field interests.
Thank you, Lesley, for giving us this interview.
Thank you, John. It was a great pleasure.
Dr Sabine Piller, medical research scientist
Dr Sabine Piller interviewed by Ms Marian Heard in 2001. Sabine Piller was born in 1970 in Vienna, Austria. In 1991 she completed a degree at the University of Vienna, majoring in zoology, botany, chemistry and physics. She moved to the USA for further studies and in 1993 received an MSc from the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) where she researched the gill physiology of marine crabs.
Sabine Piller was born in 1970 in Vienna, Austria. In 1991 she completed a degree at the University of Vienna, majoring in zoology, botany, chemistry and physics. She moved to the USA for further studies and in 1993 received an MSc from the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) where she researched the gill physiology of marine crabs. From 1993-94 Piller worked in the Department of Neurobiology at the University of Vienna.
Piller continued her studies of ion channels at the Australian National University, working on a protein of HIV named Vpr. Her PhD research, completed in 1998, was important in that it was the first time any HIV protein had been shown to function as an ion channel. From 1998-2000 Piller returned to UAB as a postdoctoral fellow in the Center for AIDS Research. Piller returned to Australia in 2000 when she was awarded a Young Investigator Award from the Centre for Immunology (CFI), the research campus of St Vincent's Hospital, Sydney. As a senior research officer/group head she is working on several projects involving Vpr and gp41. In addition to her work at CFI she is simultaneously adjunct lecturer in the Department of Medicine of the University of New South Wales and visiting fellow in the Division of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology at the John Curtin School of Medical Research (JCSMR).
Interviewed by Ms Marian Heard in 2001.
Contents
- An early fascination with marine biology
- Transatlantic differences in universities
- A marine biology project leads to proteins as ion channels
- The PhD project: moving to ion channels in viruses
- Linking ion channels to AIDS dementia: an exciting hypothesis
- Learning to study fully infectious HIV safely
- Is Vpr really linked to AIDS dementia? Testing the hypothesis
- How does HIV become resistant to drug treatments?
- Exploring the implications of a truncated gp41 strain
- Science commercialisation: development flow versus information drought?
- Science and life: interests, challenges and rewards
- Building a future on skills and passion – and funding
An early fascination with marine biology
Sabine, where were you born?
I was born in Vienna, Austria, on 8 January 1970, as the oldest daughter in a blue-collar family – my Dad is an airplane engineer, and my Mum was a secretary and then stayed home after my sister was born.
What early experiences influenced your decision to go into science?
Probably one of the most exciting experiences was when I was two years old and my parents took me to the Mediterranean. For the first time I had a snorkelling mask on my face and got to see the underwater world, which from then on was a real fascination.
I remember that at the age of six, in my first year of primary school, we had to write an essay on what we would like to be when we were older. I wrote that I wanted to become a ‘deep-sea diver’, and although that later changed to ‘marine biologist’, it basically was the same thing. And my parents fostered that interest in marine biology, taking us on holidays to the Mediterranean almost every summer so I could go snorkelling and continue my passion for the underwater world.
I learnt scuba diving at the age of 14. (Normally the German federation of scuba divers only allows you to start scuba diving at 16, so to start early I had a special permit.) That was also a very important experience in my life. My mother was very worried about me; my father thought if I went in and did this first dive I would never ever do it again. But I came out totally fascinated. Diving and marine research were what I wanted to do for the rest of my life.
Transatlantic differences in universities
After finishing high school, you went on to study science at the University of Vienna. What were your subjects there?
In the Austrian university system, for an undergraduate degree you have to get a really good background. In the first part of your studies you can’t choose your subjects, so I covered the whole lot: chemistry, physics, general biology – botany, zoology, genetics, microbiology, the whole biology field. You have to take all these classes. But I do have quite a strong physics and chemistry background because in high school I specialised in physics and chemistry, and probably also because my Dad is an engineer.
While you were studying at university, you made a trip to the United States to visit a friend. That became a turning-point for you, didn’t it?
Absolutely. It came about because I needed one more lab to finish up the first part of my studies, and basically the students who had been studying the longest time got selected first. Having to wait a whole year to get into that lab was a really bad experience, because I was on track with my studies and it felt like the lazy students got favoured.
In the United States, visiting my friend, I sat in on a two-hour class, late in the evening. Everybody was tired, so the instructor told us to have a break and then we convened back after 15 minutes. I thought, ‘Oh well, it will still finish at the full hour, so we only have 45 minutes left now.’ But he continued for an extra 15 minutes. He just said, ‘You paid for a full two hours, and you should get your money’s worth.’ The whole attitude of teachers there, the student-teacher relationship, was quite different from what I was used to in Austria. Students were openly asking questions and were encouraged to ask them, whereas in Austria you were usually told, ‘Well, you’re supposed to know this.’ It was a really great experience for me, and I decided that I wanted to go overseas and study in America because I didn’t like the Austrian system any longer.
So when I came home I applied to the Austrian Ministry of Science and Research, and got a six-month scholarship to study in America. I was then further funded to continue my Master of Science research at the University of Alabama at Birmingham.
A marine biology project leads to proteins as ion channels
What work did you do for your Masters degree at the University of Alabama?
I wanted to get into marine biology, so I worked in the Biology Department with Professor David Kraus and his wife Jeannette Doeller on two very closely related marine crab species, Callinectes sapidus and Callinectes similis. (They are like your blue swimmer crabs here – which you actually get to eat, as well.)
These crabs live in an estuarine environment, where the fresh water from rivers comes into the ocean and meets the salt water, so they experience regular changes in the salinity of the water. Every time it rains and more fresh water comes in, the salt concentration changes. The two species have the same preying behaviour, what they eat. So why can one of the species survive in fluctuating salt concentrations, while the other one is much more restricted, needing a certain salt concentration and unable to survive in fluctuating salinities? That was my topic.
I found differences in the gill tissues with which the crab species breathe. Towards the end of my project it turned out that these tissues, which also regulate the salt concentration in the crabs’ body fluids, differed in the proteins that can form ion channels – basically a protein that goes across a membrane and can shuttle ions, charged particles, across. That lab was not set up to study ion channels, but after the end of this project I wanted to go on and learn, somewhere, more about those specialist proteins that form ion channels.
The PhD project: moving to ion channels in viruses
After you completed your Masters, you returned to Austria for a year to earn some money. Then you applied to do your PhD in a number of places around the world. You turned down an opportunity to work in Alaska, in favour of taking up a PhD scholarship at the Australian National University.
I had the offer of an Overseas Postgraduate Research Scholarship, but before deciding on it I came and visited the John Curtin School of Medical Research at the ANU to meet with my prospective supervisors, Professor Peter Gage and Professor Graeme Cox, basically just for a chat. I had originally applied for the scholarship because I knew they were doing ion channel research. But before coming around the world to do my PhD here, I wanted to know what they were working on and if I wanted to do that type of research. I was very fascinated by Professor Graeme Cox. His enthusiasm as a researcher really captured me and he was probably the reason why I decided to take up the project.
Professor Peter Gage is a neuroscientist whose group works on studying ion channels in the human brain. They’re made out of several sub-units and are very complicated to study. He is trying to work out exactly how the ions move across a membrane barrier through those channels. At the time that I joined, he had just started to look at proteins from viruses that also can form ion channels. They are much smaller proteins and the idea was, ‘If we can understand how the ion channels work in viruses, in a much simpler system, maybe that will give us a clue to how they work in the brain.’ So he had a student studying an ion channel from the influenza virus.
Graeme Cox is basically the biochemist of the team. He was going through several other viral proteins from all kinds of different viruses, deciding from similarities in their structure whether any could possibly also form ion channels. Out of the proteins on the list, I picked the virus protein Vpr, from HIV virus – I thought, ‘Well, if I work on viruses, HIV sounds really exciting.’ And having decided on that first trip out here what I wanted to work with, I then came back a couple of months later to take up my scholarship and start working on that project.
Linking ion channels to AIDS dementia: an exciting hypothesis
Why was your PhD work important?
It was very important because we showed that that particular protein of the HIV virus, Vpr, does form an ion channel – the first time any HIV protein has been shown to function like that. We went on to identify which part of the protein forms the ion channel, and then, because this ion channel’s characteristics were quite different from those of the ion channel in the influenza virus, we speculated that this one might be involved in the AIDS dementia of HIV patients. Many HIV patients in their late stages become demented and have problems with motor control and cognitive problems but it is so far not understood how this disease comes about and why it affects some patients and not others.
Since I have shown that this viral protein from HIV forms an ion channel, we have used neurons, brain cells, from rats to show that if this protein is present on the outside of neurons it can actually form an ion channel in the membrane of the neurons, and completely abrogates the normal functioning of the brain cells by interrupting the ion gradients across there. That is very exciting: if we can prove that that is taking place in the patients, perhaps drugs can be developed to alleviate the horrible AIDS dementia problems that they face.
Learning to study fully infectious HIV safely
What did you do after your PhD?
I returned to the US, to a different department of the University of Alabama at Birmingham. I worked in the lab of Eric Hunter, the director of the Center for AIDS Research. I basically went there because by the end of my PhD thesis work I was quite fascinated by how the HIV virus works but I had only worked with one part of that virus, one protein, and I had never come into contact with the entire virus. And to learn more about the entire virus I needed to learn how to work with a fully infectious virus. So part of my postdoc project in the US was to learn all the techniques that I needed for that. I learned how to work with all the proteins together in the live virus, under special physical containment facilities at what is called the PC3 level.
While I was there I studied a different protein of the HIV virus, a glycoprotein called gp41. It is on the outside of the virus, and it is very important in making the virus infectious. If the protein isn’t there or is truncated, the virus is non-infectious. And so it is interesting to study. Also, that particular protein has a very unusual long part on one end of it, and we made mutations in the protein by changing certain of its building blocks, to see what effect those changes would have.
People are quite concerned about the chance of contracting AIDS. Did you think about the risks of working with the fully infectious virus?
HIV is quite a safe virus to work with in a laboratory setting. The virus has a lipid bilayer around it. Normal bleach and detergents can actually remove that lipid bilayer and the virus is then non-infectious. Also, the whole training that goes with certification to work with the infectious virus is very strict. You work under very safe conditions. I feel that it’s much safer to work with it in a laboratory setting, where you know the risks and what you are working with, than it is in a hospital setting, where you work with patients’ blood samples that may contain all kinds of much more infectious viruses like hepatitis B and hepatitis C. So I believe that knowing the risk and actually controlling for it, and working under very safe conditions in those facilities, is quite safe – otherwise I really wouldn’t have done it!
Is Vpr really linked to AIDS dementia? Testing the hypothesis
What brought you back to Australia after your postdoc, and what are you currently working on?
Well, my husband is Australian and he really wanted to come back. (He absolutely didn’t like it in the US.) The other reason is that I was awarded a Young Investigator Award from the Centre for Immunology on the research campus of St Vincent’s Hospital, in Sydney.
At the moment I have three main projects running, two of them still on the virus protein Vpr that I worked on in my PhD, and one on the protein that I worked on through my postdoc. We are just starting to write up publications from these very exciting projects.
For one of the Vpr projects we have a collaboration with Dr Bruce Brew, who is a neurologist. He has stored away about 4000 samples from patients who have developed AIDS dementia, and now I’m in a unique position to answer the question that came up during my PhD: whether the viral protein Vpr is actually causing AIDS dementia, or has anything to do with that part of the disease. We are trying to set up an assay to find out if the viral protein Vpr is present in the brain fluids, because that has so far not been shown at all. Vpr is known to be normally present inside the virus; it is packaged into the virus. However, for Vpr to form an ion channel into neuronal cells (as I showed in my PhD research), it needs to be present outside of the virus, in the blood and/or the brain fluids.
We are trying not only to find out if Vpr is present in the brain fluids but also to quantitate how much of it is present, and then to correlate that to the disease stage. Is it possible that patients who develop AIDS dementia have more Vpr in their brain fluids than patients that do not develop the disease? That’s very exciting, and we are hoping to get funding for this. We basically have the assay developed and hopefully by next year we should be able to screen Professor Brew’s 4000 patient samples. He has just got a grant from the National Institutes of Health (NIH) – the US funding agency equivalent to the National Health and Medical Research Council here – so that we will be able to receive additional patient samples from all over the world, and to come up in the next couple of years with a very sound statistical analysis to check for a link of that protein to AIDS dementia.
How does HIV become resistant to drug treatments?
The second Vpr project includes collaboration with another MD, Professor David Cooper, and his group. They have identified HIV patients who are resistant to the current drug treatment, called Highly Active Anti-Retroviral Therapy. Two enzymes in the virus are blocked by the drugs, but mutations, changes, in those enzymes are causing the virus to be able to emerge and be resistant to the drugs. For a long time now, physicians have been ordering a screen of the genes to see if those changes in the particular two proteins of the virus have taken place. Then our collaborators identified patients who did not respond to the therapy but did not have those changes in the two proteins. When they tried to work out if there are other regions in HIV that influence becoming resistant, they found some interesting changes in the protein responsible for incorporating Vpr into the virus particle.
This is where I came in with my experience of working on Vpr, and we collaborated on trying to work out if those patients have Vpr incorporated into the virus particle. When we made recombinant viruses – that is, we took part of the virus from the patients it had been isolated from and put it into a lab strain to work out what effects the changes have – we found that Vpr is not incorporated in the recombinant virus. However, the patients have that protein incorporated. That is very interesting, because it shows that Vpr is very important in vivo, and that if changes occur which would prevent the incorporation of the protein, the virus changes Vpr itself to again get it incorporated. It is really the first time that the incorporation of Vpr has been shown to be important in vivo. And that’s about to be published. It’s very exciting.
Exploring the implications of a truncated gp41 strain
The project on gp41 arose from something we stumbled across when we were setting up my lab at the Centre for Immunology. I have a very good research assistant, Darren Jones, who started to run initial screening tests with some of the assays that we do with antibodies, to see which of the proteins are present in the virus. And when I looked at those assays I saw that in one HIV strain the gp41 – the particular protein I had worked on in the US so I was quite used to looking at it – seemed to be shorter than in the other strains. We have tried to follow up what could be the reason for it to be smaller, and it turns out that a truncation has occurred, a stop codon has been inserted. That protein is about 100 amino acids shorter, so it is 100 of the building blocks shorter than normal. That has happened in a strain that is very widely used as a reference strain by researchers all across the world.
We received that strain from the NIH, which has a Reference Reagent Program that supplies HIV reagents all over the world for free. (You just pay shipping costs.) It appears that the truncation has happened at the NIH, most likely several years ago through continuous passage. It is very exciting to have discovered this, because at the moment that strain is used in particular as a reference strain in research with drug-resistant strains, so it is possible that researchers could come to incorrect conclusions because they are working with something that is not what they think it is. So that is also being submitted for publication next week. And it will be exciting to follow up what that truncation actually does to the virus.
Science commercialisation: development flow versus information drought?
What do you think about the potential commercialisation of the science that you’re involved in?
The research has potential for drug development later on, and if it does lead to drug development, that’s great. Obviously, one of the aims is to find a way to fight or even cure HIV. But I am an old-school scientist, I guess: I think that all the knowledge we create and all the things we find out should not be commercialised, should not be owned by anybody. I am very wary about all this commercialisation that is going on, and about people selling off their ideas and patenting things like genes. Everybody should have free access to all the information that is found out in research at universities. It shouldn’t be owned by any company, because that keeps the information away from other researchers to build on – and that’s not a very good idea.
Science and life: interests, challenges and rewards
Sabine, as well as your science you have many other interests, some of which go back a long way.
Among my other interests was underwater rugby – a very, very exciting sport which again involves snorkelling. (Everything I did had to be underwater!) It’s the only game I know of that is played in a three-dimensional playground: the ball is filled with salt water, so it sinks, and you have baskets at the bottom of a pool. It is rather rough. I played with the national men’s team in Austria, and it was a great time. It kept me fit and also it improved my snorkelling
skills a lot.
I still enjoy snorkelling and scuba diving. I’m a real outdoors person, and I enjoy bushwalking and also rock climbing, which my husband introduced me to. Motor cycles are my real passion. I’ve been riding them since I was 16 and I have had a motorbike on every continent I have lived on – in Austria, in the US, and here. And I have a one-year-old son now, Christopher, who is absolutely keeping me busy. He is also very curious. It is definitely a challenge to be a first-time mum and to keep a science career, but it has been very rewarding.
What have you found the most rewarding aspects of a career in science?
Even in my early childhood I always asked questions about how and why things work, and it’s really like putting pieces of a puzzle together. It has been my passion during my whole life to try to understand how, exactly, things are working. And finding out one more answer, one more piece, and adding it to the puzzle is the most rewarding experience in science.
Another thing that I really enjoy is teaching, passing on the knowledge to students. That’s also very rewarding.
Building a future on skills and passion – and funding
What skills are most needed in taking up a career in science today?
It’s increasingly important to be able to keep up with all the information that is out there, so computer skills and knowing the internet, knowing where to get information, are important. Good communication skills and writing skills are also very important.
But the very most important thing for a career in science is to just have a love for it. You have to have a passion for the job, because there is not much funding for science and not much money in it. So you really have to love what you’re doing – you have to be curious about what you’re doing. That, I think, is what gets you there.
Sabine, having achieved such a lot in such a short career, where do you see yourself in 10 years’ time?
On good days, I’d love to be still in research in 10 years, with a bigger lab, more students and more research assistants. But on bad days, when our grants aren't successful, I think I might be teaching scuba lessons or working for a museum, or be a stay-at-home Mum – I have no idea. I’ll have to look at something else if I don’t get funding!
Professor Sam Carey, geologist
Professor Sam Carey was interviewed by Professor Pat Quilty in 2000. Professor Sam Carey received a DSc from the University of Sydney in 1939 for his work on the tectonic evolution of New Guinea and Melanesia. He worked in the petroleum industry in New Guinea and then served with the Australian Infantry Forces from 1942-44.
Professor Sam Carey received a DSc from the University of Sydney in 1939 for his work on the tectonic evolution of New Guinea and Melanesia. He worked in the petroleum industry in New Guinea and then served with the Australian Infantry Forces from 1942-44. After the war he became chief government geologist in Tasmania and later was appointed foundation professor of geology at the University of Tasmania.
Carey supported the theory of continental drift, explaining the movement of the continents through a model in which oceanic crust was formed at mid-ocean ridges and old oceanic crust underwent subduction at deep ocean trenches. The University of Tasmania became a leading university in tectonics and in 1957 he organised the Continental Drift Symposium, which influenced many scientists about the importance of continental drift.
More information about Professor Carey is available on the Academy's website at Biographical memoirs - Samuel Warren Carey, 1911-2002.
Interviewed by Professor Pat Quilty in 2000.
Contents
- Background and education
- Memories of Edgeworth David and Mawson
- Flotsam: drifting continents and a wayward thesis
- Friend or foe?
- Setting a southern course for geology
- Attracting attention to tectonics
- Dropping anchor in the right place
- A question of best fit: the expanding Earth
- Valued recognition and the art of recommendation
Background and education
Professor Carey, could you tell us a little bit about your family background and perhaps your schooling?
My father was a printer, but he went overseas and became a public lecturer. My mother was born in Australia, of Australian ancestry. I had two sisters and four brothers. One brother was killed by the Japanese during the war.
We lived on a farm three or four miles out of Campbelltown, in New South Wales, and when I started school I had to walk three and a half miles to get there and then walk back again – right from the age of five.
So you were fit from a very early age?
Well, I was fit enough to walk to school and back every day, until we moved almost into the centre of town.
Your interest in science was initially in the area of physics. What was it that got you interested in science, and when was that?
I was interested in science all through high school, because of a good science teacher. In fact, he was teaching physics. The system was that at school you could do physics or chemistry but not both, but I went to university intending to do physics and chemistry. And, although I went there with no chemistry whatsoever, I came top in first year.
To enrol in science at university I had to do mathematics, of course, but I didn’t have a fourth subject. When I asked my physics teacher what to do for a fourth subject, he said, ‘Well, try geology. I did geology under Professor Edgeworth David and I enjoyed it very much.’ I thought, ‘What’s geology?’ but I enrolled in it – and I came top that year!
As the years went by, you were very strong on the role of physics in geology. What changed you from physics itself?
I had no idea of becoming a geologist when I went to university, but I think it was the fieldwork – in geology, it interleaved with the lab work – which caught me. I enjoyed fieldwork, which you didn’t do in physics and chemistry, of course. By the end of first year I had no doubt about it: I was going to be a geologist, a rock-hopper.
What were some of your successes at the University of Sydney?
One of the things I started was the student geology club, the first one in Australia. They then moved for them in all universities. I suppose you could say I was a leader among students.
I understand that when you were going through university you didn’t have a great deal of money, and you took on some other activities to tide you over financially.
I did about 16 hours coaching a week.
Wasn’t there also a role as a magician there somewhere?
That’s right, I used to give magic shows. And they were well paid.
I remember an occasion when my wife Helen and I were going out for dinner one Friday night. We came into your room at the university with our two little boys, who were about five and three. They had been told to behave themselves and sit quietly, but you must have noticed that they were behaving too well. You pulled coins out of their ears and within five minutes the kids were out of control.
The coins would have been shillings. I loved pulling money out of ears, especially my own ear.
Memories of Edgeworth David and Mawson
What memories do you have of Edgeworth David? I noticed you always had a photograph of him in your room at the university.
I knew him quite well and saw a lot of him. When I formed the student geological club I invited him to give the inaugural lecture, which he did. He was already so famous that the theatre overflowed. Several rows of extra seats were brought in. And he came to inspect my rocks when I brought them back from fieldwork, to make sure I had identified them correctly and see how they correlated with others he was working on. David was a very gentle man, very kind and not obtrusive in any way. He wasn’t a big, bull-at-a-gate sort of man at all.
I wonder how David and Mawson would have got on. They were very different personalities. Did you ever meet Mawson?
Oh yes, I knew Mawson quite well. He was one of David’s students, and they would have got on perfectly well. The first time Mawson went to the Pole it was under David, who had gone to the Pole and then asked Mawson to take over, halfway through. Of course, David was a much older man. One of the strange things was that, as dominant a man as Mawson was and as dominant a woman as his wife was, they clicked perfectly – never any quarrels. They always got on very beautifully, although they were so obviously both leaders and obviously different.
Flotsam: drifting continents and a wayward thesis
When you graduated, you went to New Guinea and got involved in tectonics. Why?
Why New Guinea? I had no intentions of that. I intended to go to Cambridge after I had got my Master of Science. But when I was halfway through my year, G.A.V. Stanley turned up from New Guinea, looking for recruits. The only one that was available besides me was scared of the idea of going to New Guinea – he wouldn’t go. So the Professor said, ‘Well, there’s only one other man, that’s Carey. Try him.’ When I said, ‘Oh well, I’m going to Cambridge,’ Stanley said, ‘Come down to our office and look at our maps.’ I went down and looked at all the maps and things they were doing with the natives and so forth – and I was converted. I came home that night to tell my mother I was going to New Guinea.
In New Guinea I was doing ordinary fieldwork, mapping on streams, which were the only place you could get good outcrops. We had another team with a surveyor who worked on the ridges, but my work in New Guinea was entirely in the rivers. I had no idea then of going into tectonics as such; I was just mapping geology, a geologist pure and simple. I hadn’t worked out that I was interested in the tectonics in New Guinea. When I came back I started working on that.
When did you graduate with your Masters degree, and then your Doctorate?
I graduated in the minimum time for Masters – and minimum time for the Doctorate. Nobody has had a doctorate granted in Sydney, even since, in such a short time from graduation. There was no supervisor of any kind for my DSc. People who go for a doctorate now at university have a supervisor. I wrote my DSc thesis entirely myself. I paid a typist – she was very good, actually – and a draughtsman, and paid for my own thesis.
I thought I’d lost the thesis. Because I was writing on New Guinea, they wanted somebody who knew something about it as one of the examiners. They appointed a Dutchman who had worked all his life in New Guinea and in Timor, mainly. My thesis went to him by sea all the way to Holland, but when it got there he was in Timor. So it went by sea all the way back to Timor. By the time it got there, he was in Jakarta – Batavia as it was then – and so it went by sea all the way to Jakarta. And eventually it had to go back to Holland to catch him. But once you’ve appointed an examiner, he is the examiner.
I’d gone back to New Guinea, assuming that I had failed. But in 1938, after about 18 months, after those months of my thesis travelling backwards and forwards across the seas, I heard that my DSc had been granted.
How many examiners did you have?
There were just three examiners: Dr Woolnough, from Western Australia, this man from Holland, and the head of my department, Leo Cotton. He was a good man.
A very famous name in Australian science. How did you make that step from being a field geologist to going into a DSc and an interest in tectonics?
Well, the war pulled me out of New Guinea. All the women were evacuated, and every male in New Guinea had to enlist in the Army, but I and one other were sent back to work on rocks in the Gulf of Papua, looking for oil. It was thought that we might be cut off from American oil, and so we weren’t allowed to enlist. The rocks that we were working on were the ones that finally produced oil, but not there, further up on the highlands – in the same beds, but slightly different facies.
Friend or foe?
You did get involved in the war, becoming a bit of hero as one of the Commandos.
I was no hero. I ended up in Z Special Unit, whose job was to work deep behind the lines. Z was a thousand miles further north of the fighting; it would go along ahead of the front line. But McArthur had come from some other islands up there, had been kicked out of them. He had the island-hopping idea: he was all for going north, right up to Japan – so he changed the pattern of things. He would hop ahead, and once he started doing that, he made Z redundant. I resigned before the end of the war, because Z was no longer needed.
Tell us about putting dummy limpet mines on the American fleet when you were in Z.
That was in Cairns. A limpet is a charge attached to a magnet. The Americans didn’t believe in limpets, but oh, we’d show them that they worked. So we did the lot. Afterwards, the Admiral invited me to come aboard in the evening with such of my officers as I chose. Two other officers and I went aboard. Of course, we’d limpeted every one of his ships, and they would have been dead – sunk – by dawn. But he said, ‘Oh, you didn’t do anything. You couldn’t attach on my ship.’ ‘Oh, couldn’t we?’ I called Captain Cardew, who, being military, responded, ‘Sir!’ and introduced him: ‘My good friend, my 2IC.’ I said, ‘You personally limpeted this ship last night?’ ‘Sir!’ ‘Have you got anything for the Admiral?’ So he went down and de-limpeted the Admiral’s ship while he watched! We had wonderful fun out of that.
There was a lot of activity in science following the war, with a rush of key papers on geology being written in the early 1950s; for example, Anderson’s application of gravity to the classification of faults, and your own rheidity, folding, continental reconstructions. Would these ideas have been going over in your mind, and other serving people’s minds, during the war?
I expect so, but I wasn’t aware of it. I never thought positively about it. You can be unaware of things that are happening in your thinking. They don’t come right to the surface, but they’re still bubbling along in your mind.
Setting a southern course for geology
Near the end of the war, in 1944, you went to Tasmania. Where were you when you applied for the job there?
I was in Melbourne. I resigned from the Army to become Chief Government Geologist in Tasmania. There was an advertisement and I just applied for the job.
While I was Chief Government Geologist, I was appointed to the University of Tasmania's Faculty of Science as an external member, with no idea I would ever become a professor myself. There was no geology department then, or geophysics or anything like that, and I advocated the start of a geology school in the university. When eventually a school was started, in 1946, I applied for the Chair but without any illusions that I would get it. But I did get it and was the first Professor of Geology and Geography.
Geography was part of my department for a couple of years. A lot of school-children did geography to avoid mathematics, so there was a heavy enrolment and eventually geography was separated out. The man who had been my lecturer in geography, Peter Scott, resigned when they announced there was going to be a Department of Geography, so that he could apply from outside. He became the first professor. But he would have been even if he had not resigned, because I was on the selection committee and I knew he was a good man who could lecture well. He had plenty of ability. There was a big field. I think five of those people who were applicants at that time later became professors.
As Chief Government Geologist and then at the University of Tasmania, how did you work with the bureaucracy?
I had no problems, I just fitted in. That didn’t worry me.
Being an independent thinker, did you sometimes have problems with them?
I did what I wanted to! I set the rules.
You were at the university during some of its very turbulent years.
I didn’t know very much about the turbulence at first, because I was down at Sandy Bay and the main university was up at the Domain.
Between 1948 and 1965, the university did change quite dramatically, didn’t it?
Well, it grew, and shifted entirely to Sandy Bay. But I wasn’t deeply concerned about matters of staff appointments or the university’s reputation outside. I just made sure that the Department of Geology and Geography ran well. The two were together then.
Attracting attention to tectonics
You were interested in tectonics in the 1930s, and in Tasmania that became your specialty. Would you like to tell us a bit about the people you attracted to tectonics, people whose minds you changed?
I don’t know whose minds I changed. I know some have changed mine. A person who greatly affected me was Harry Hess, a professor from Yale. He came to Tasmania for the International Symposium I had conceived and organised and invited me to go to Yale. I had a year as professor at Yale, and during that time I lectured at practically every other university in the United States – I’d been invited around.
And then you attracted some students from Yale to Tasmania.
Yes, a few came – Kugler, Jan Smith, some others.
Tasmania was, because of your influence, a leading university in tectonics. In 1957 you had the Continental Drift Symposium. Would you like to talk about how you put that symposium together and some of the people you brought to it?
Oh well, I thought it was the right time to have a symposium on structural geology and tectonics, and we had one. Some people wanted to come but couldn’t. An important man who did come was Longwell, from Yale. That resulted in my being invited to Yale as professor.
That symposium was very, very important. By pulling all of those people together, you started to have an influence in tectonics on the rest of the world. The English-speaking world had not really taken on the idea of continental drift.
They did then. The symposium is still quite heavily quoted, and they made reprints of the volumes – just recently, another reprint.
Dropping anchor in the right place
Of the main characters who came to that 1957 meeting, you’ve referred to Chester Longwell. Was Tuzo Wilson there? I think you had a big influence on him.
He was invited to the meeting but I don’t think he was there. I probably did have an influence on him. He resented it at first and we quarrelled academically on a number of things. But he came round.
Another important person you met was Lewis Weeks, at Princeton University. It was Weeks who put Esso and BHP on to the exploration in Gippsland Basin, which has contributed enormously to Australia’s oil and gas production. He has said that you drew a map of projected anticlines out into Gippsland Basin for him in 1959.
I remember Lewis Weeks very well. I certainly influenced him, and he influenced me.
It is important for professors to know the leaders in other universities, so they can send their students there, but a lot of our professors don’t. They haven’t been there themselves. I don’t know how you can arrange for university men to go round the other universities and see what they are doing. They do so now via literature.
You must have had many opportunities to move to other parts of the world.
Yes, I’ve had many. I was invited to go to Yale, Princeton and California, and perhaps I should have. But no, when I came to the University of Tasmania I said in my application, ‘If I’m appointed, I will not be tempted to go anywhere else.’ And I have stuck to that.
Tasmania has benefited greatly from it. What do you think are some of the advantages of being in a university in a small, isolated state like Tasmania?
I don’t think it’s got any advantages, particularly – unless you make them.
So how did you generate the advantage of being here?
Oh, I don’t know – just by inspiring students.
That has been one of the really strong points in your career. You were very effective in attracting good students to geology, with an unusually high recruitment rate from first year into second year. Why do you think that was?
They must have liked the subject. Anyway, there hadn’t been a geology department and they wanted to get away from mathematics!
I think it is fair to say that you and the staff you recruited were responsible for the very good reputation for geology which your university had, right around Australia.
Perhaps, yes. And Tasmania had a good variety of rocks around, compared with poor old Sydney or Brisbane.
A question of best fit: the expanding Earth
The other thing that you’ve done – and you’re still a bit of a rebel in this regard – is to propose the question of the expanding Earth.
No longer a rebel – they now believe it! At least, they all will eventually. It takes some people a while to catch up.
What made you think of an expanding Earth as the explanation for what you saw? Was it purely that you were fitting the continents together and it didn’t fit?
Well, I put the continents together and there was a big hole. I had to have that or more than half the world as ocean. It seemed to be a better solution, because there was a great area where I believed the edges of those things belonged to each other, across the Pacific. And the north Pacific had rims which belonged to each other.
Valued recognition and the art of recommendation
You retired in 1976, roughly 24 years ago.
Correction: I was retired.
Okay – through the bureaucracy again. What have you been doing with yourself since? 24 years is almost time for another career.
I agree with you there. I am still a member of all the societies and get all their journals, which I read. I don’t throw them away after that; I present them to the university. In fact, quite a number of journals that the university have been getting for years are ones I’ve given to them. They haven’t subscribed. They’ll have to subscribe when I peg out!
During your career you’ve received many awards and been recognised by many different geological societies. Which are the awards that you value most?
I don’t know. There was the Geological Society of London, the Geological Society of India, where I was quoted quite a bit. I have travelled there and had quite a lot of Indian students. As to which I value most – the Geological Society of Australia, probably. I was there when that was first formed.
One of those Indian students was Ahmad, who played a role in a paper – now regarded as a classic – which you wrote on glacial marine sedimentation. In it you referred to Prydz Bay, in Antarctica, as an example of the environment that probably existed during some of the Permian sedimentation in Tasmania. What was Ahmad’s role in that study?
He was my student. I used to advise him perhaps every day. We had long discussions and that came out of them.
You maintained very close ties with industry, in both minerals and petroleum. It was very important to the careers of many young geologists that you recommended them to the various companies.
That’s right. I’d been in petroleum for years in New Guinea and also here, and so it was natural that I still had connections with these companies, and that was an advantage. I had been President of the Institute of Mining and Metallurgy. My background had been through the companies entirely. I started off with Oil Search Ltd – it’s still going now – and I was one of their geologists for a good number of years. I’ve always had contact with the industry. I agree that it was important because I could write to Mr X, in charge of that industry, ‘Such and such a student is a good man.’
It must have been difficult on occasions, though, because industry would have asked you for opinions about some students that weren’t necessarily your highest flyers. How did you handle those difficult situations?
Oh, I would give an honest assessment of their good points. If companies were very careful they would really look for omissions in my statements. The statements would be only of people’s good points, but if you hunted you’d find omissions. That’s the only way to deal with that. You can’t raise it, it’s not to the student’s advantage, but you omit saying anything about it.
You accepted Fellowship of the Australian Academy of Science a long time after it was first offered to you.
Yes. They invited me to become a Fellow but I was in disagreement with them about something I had done. But a good many years later, when they invited me again to become a Fellow, I accepted.
I would just like to say, as one who worked with you in the 1960s and who has kept in contact with you since – as many of your students have – that we look back with a great deal of affection to the role of Professor Carey in our lives. Thank you very much for your efforts this morning.
Thank you. Glad to help if I can. I was fond of my students at times. I tried to help them if I could.
And you were very successful.
Professor Athel Beckwith, organic chemist
Professor Athel Beckwith was a pioneering Australian organic chemist renowned for his research on the structure and behavior of organic free radicals, earning international recognition. His life story reflects a blend of scientific brilliance and resilience, from overcoming severe childhood illness to shaping modern radical chemistry and stereoelectronic theory, while maintaining deep interests in music, education, and social issues. Interviewed by Professor Bob Crompton in 2003.
Professor Athel Beckwith
Professor Athel Beckwith is an organic chemist whose work has covered a number of areas ranging from theoretical calculations to the synthesis of complex molecules. He is best known for his research into the structure and behaviour of organic free radicals. He is a Fellow of the Royal Society and of the Australian Academy of Science and is also a Fellow and Past President of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute. In the course of his research career he has been the recipient of many prestigious awards and honours.
Interviewed by Professor Bob Crompton in 2003.
Athel, may we begin with your family background?
My parents were both born in Western Australia. My father, Laurence Beckwith, grew up in Katanning, a small town about 200 kilometres from Perth, where his father was a builder and carpenter. My mother (Doris Johnson) grew up in Perth; her father was a joiner and cabinet-maker. At the age of 12 my father, having gained an entrance into Perth Modern School, moved to Perth to stay with his aunt. He never lived in Katanning again.
I guess I'm both Australian and very multicultural – all of my grandparents were born in Australia, but of my eight great-grandparents three were Scotch, one German, one Swiss, one Scandinavian, and two English. They seem to have come to Australia in the 1840s or '50s, the German group moving to the Barossa Valley and the rest to Victoria. My maternal great-grandfather's Scandinavian family owned a trading ship. As they happened to arrive in Melbourne at the time of the gold rush my great grandfather promptly left the family and went to Ballarat. He was never successful as a miner and he became involved with the ringleaders of the Eureka Stockade. He later became a successful professional musician.
I believe that when you went to Europe you delved into your family's history.
We know most about the Beckwiths – I have a detailed history of them back to the 1600s. They lived mainly in Leeds. In Yorkshire there are still many Beckwiths, apparently all descended from one lady, Catherine Beckwith. She had Anglo-Saxon aristocratic roots while the Norman next door had money and land but was not distinguished, so when they married (in Knaresborough, in about the 12th or 13th century) he took her name. The bells in York Minster are the 'Beckwith bells', down in the Minster crypt there are pieces of silver made by a John Beckwith in the 13th century, and there is a village of Beckwithshaw nearby.
Coming to the present Beckwiths, where were you born and when?
I can tell you precisely – on 20th February 1930, in Nurse Stockley's Nursing Home, Havelock Street, Perth. It is so deeply imprinted on my memory because whenever my mother took me, as a child, into Perth by tram down Havelock Street she would say 'That is where you were born'.
What sort of early childhood memories do you have?
I had a very happy childhood. Both my parents were gifted. My mother won a scholarship to go to university in Paris but because of the depression she didn't take it up. My father was awarded one of the few entrance scholarships to the University of Western Australia but he didn't take that up either, because he preferred to study pharmacy. They were good linguists and were very interested in reading and music. Both were excellent musicians. My father performed frequently on the ABC and with various choirs. As a child I was exposed to lots of music, including singing around the piano. My parents read to me in bed, and as I attended a good kindergarten I could already read when I entered primary school.
My maternal grandparents lived with us because of the Depression – both grandfathers had lost their businesses. My maternal grandfather had a great influence on me. He taught me how to use my hands, to do carpentry, to build models, to fish. When I was very young I spent many happy days fishing at Fremantle Wharf.
Where we lived is nowadays part of an inner Perth suburb, but at that time it was at the edge of nowhere. Between our house and the sea there was nothing but bush, where we could wander for hours on end. I came to know the Western Australian flora well and could name all the wildflowers. I fell in love with the Australian bush, and have remained so ever since.
So I spent my childhood building model aeroplanes, swimming, exploring the bush and doing all the things that kids do. It was a very good time, a very easy time.
Was all your primary schooling in Perth?
No. In 1942 families who lived close to the sea were evacuated because of the danger of invasion, so my mother, my grandmother, my two brothers and I went to live in the Porongurups, a beautiful part of Western Australia. I attended Mount Barker School, where a remarkable teacher, Mr Best, taught 6th, 7th, 8th and 9th standards, all in the one classroom. That was very good for us students. We were continually exposed to what was happening elsewhere, and although I was in 6th standard I picked up a lot of algebra, geometry and other subjects taught to higher classes.
Mr Best was the first person to show me a science experiment. He placed a four-gallon kerosene tin with some water in it over a Bunsen. When the water boiled, he quickly put the top on the tin and turned off the Bunsen. As we watched, the tin collapsed – an astonishing event! Air pressure. That first experiment left a lasting impression.
The tiny Mount Barker School had remarkable success in the Scholarship Examination taken by most Western Australian children in their 12th year. I was one of a number of pupils awarded a scholarship to go to Modern School.
As you entered secondary school you suffered a severe illness that could have cost you your life. It had a profound effect on you physically – it left you with persistent lameness – and on your philosophy of life.
That's right. It happened very suddenly. I went to school feeling well, intending to captain the basketball team, but by lunchtime I felt ill. By the afternoon I was virtually delirious and by evening I was unconscious. Because of the pain in my leg it was assumed I had poliomyelitis – infantile paralysis, as it was called – of which there was a serious epidemic at that time, and I was placed in quarantine in the infectious diseases hospital. That was something of a tragedy because by the time my doctors discovered it wasn't poliomyelitis but osteomyelitis, a staphylococcal disease in the bone, they couldn't get me out again. I lay in the infectious diseases hospital for about four weeks before treatment for the osteomyelitis could start, and during those weeks a great deal of damage occurred. I was then taken to the Mount Hospital and had a number of operations. I fell ill on April Fools' Day, 1943, and I did not get out of bed until Christmas Day, 1944.
What drugs were available for your treatment?
When I became ill all that was available in Australia for the treatment of osteomyelitis were sulfa drugs, and although they were partially effective, they were dreadful things to take. Meanwhile penicillin had been developed; if it was taken immediately osteomyelitis could be cured within a fortnight. But it was too late for me, because enormous damage had already occurred and a great deal of bone had to re-grow. Nevertheless, an American serviceman who was billeted with us was able to obtain some US Navy penicillin. It was used at home, under great secrecy because, of course, it was highly illegal (I suspect I may have been the first civilian in Australia to have penicillin – courtesy of the US Navy). It helped, but the disease kept recurring. It was about seven years before it was completely eliminated.
In the end it taught me two things. Having found out how close to death I was I have come to value every day that is available to me. I might not be here, so I should make the most of it. And going through such a great deal of pain has made me very careful about causing pain to any person or any creature. To endure that much pain at age 13 for something like two months leaves its mark.
When you were able to return to Perth Modern School, you did very well, I believe.
The headmaster wanted to put me back a year because I had lost so much time, but he didn't realise that whilst in bed I had busily been doing correspondence classes and reading a splendid book called Wonders of Modern Science, and hence had kept relatively up to date. My mother, who was usually a very mild person, could be rather aggressive regarding the rights of her children. After she had firmly told the headmaster I should stay in the correct class for my year they came to a deal that if I went into that class and succeeded in first term, I could remain there. Because of the schooling I had while in bed, I did remarkably well – apart from Latin. I stayed in the correct class for my age.
Modern School was a marvellous school. When it was called 'Modern' at the time of its creation in the early part of the century it must have seemed extraordinarily modern and it was still modern in the '40s. There was no corporal punishment, it was completely co-educational, a lot of the study was done individually as independent study, and all science was taught in a laboratory. That was really wonderful; I came to realise that the best way to appreciate science is to do it, or to see it being done, rather than simply to hear about it. At that stage I started doing my own science at home, because having a father who was a pharmacist gave me ready access to all the things one needs for the sorts of experiments that young chaps like doing – thermite mixture and explosions, smells, and bangs.
You had an outstanding final year result, didn't you – except for Latin, I suppose!
I dropped Latin as soon as possible, and concentrated on science and mathematics. In those days it was necessary to study English and Art, and I also took music for Matriculation. I obtained Distinction in all seven subjects – the only person to do so in that year. It was a rare event.
You formed many friendships at secondary school, some of your friends later becoming very well known in business and many other fields. And during those years your love of music turned toward jazz, didn't it, Athel?
Yes. I had studied music from about the age of six, and had become quite proficient as a classical pianist. Indeed, I could play Mozart's sonatas much better at age 12 than I can now! It was when I was about 14 or 15 that I became interested in jazz. I studied composition for a while, being taught by a friend of my parents. Knowledge of harmony is a splendid aid to improvisation. I might say that jazz was of great assistance at parties and occasions of that sort. That's the age when one is beginning to be interested in young ladies, and young ladies become interested in pianists who can play jazz!
Later you moved on from the piano to the clarinet.
Yes. Not much later on, probably about the time that I matriculated, I saw a film version of the life of George Gershwin, and I heard the marvellous opening glissando of the Rhapsody in Blue. I thought it was wonderful, and so I took up the clarinet. I was very fortunate in studying privately with Alan Rule, the principal clarinettist in the Western Australian Symphony Orchestra.
Later I joined the ABC Training Orchestra. It had been set up by the Australian Broadcasting Commission to give young people practice in orchestral playing, with the expectation that some of them would later become professional musicians. There were two second clarinets and two firsts, of whom all but myself did indeed become professional musicians.
I loved playing the clarinet, but strangely enough, although it is a jazz instrument, I was never as good at jazz on clarinet as I am on the piano. I often played in dance bands on the piano, but only once on the clarinet. When I left Adelaide, the Chemistry Department gave me a big farewell party, including a jazz band with which I played during the evening.
If only I'd known that, Athel, I would have brought a piano in here and you could have performed for us!
In the orchestra we played with top-class conductors. With Henri Krips we played the standards of classical music: Beethoven, Mozart, Dvorák, and so on. Another well-known conductor, Rudolf Pekarek, introduced us to light music such as operetta, and I came to realise that sometimes music which is regarded as 'light' is often very difficult to play well. I learnt a great deal about music through playing in that orchestra. I continued to play the clarinet in small groups or bands until a few years ago but I never played with a symphony orchestra again.
From secondary school you went on to the University of Western Australia. Can you tell us something about the people there who influenced your interests and career?
The staff of the University of Western Australia included a number of outstanding people. The Chemistry Department was particularly fortunate in having as its head Noel Bayliss, a physical chemist of high international reputation. Doug White, an organic chemist, was an extremely good lecturer who inspired us all by bringing into the lecture theatre samples of natural products, particularly those with interesting odours. He showed how high and low concentrations of compounds can sometimes have completely different odours and how the detection of odours varies from one individual to another. I loved his lectures. Doug White had grown up in the traditional mould and taught us a lot of classical chemistry, but Joe Miller, who had worked at University College with Sir Christopher Ingold, was well versed in the more modern electronic theory of organic chemistry. Robin Stokes, who became a Fellow of the Academy, was also in the Department. So we were very fortunate. It would have been difficult to find a better place in Australia for a chemical education.
It was in fact a particularly good time to be in that Department. During my Honours year Andy Cole came back from Canada, where they were developing the very new technique of infrared spectroscopy, and Doug White had recently been on sabbatical in Zürich where he mastered the new technique of chromatography. So we learnt both classical chemistry and modern theoretical chemistry, we were introduced to new techniques, and we did a lot of practical chemistry. I really liked experimental work – it was a joy to make compounds that had not previously been described. One wondered whether those atoms had ever before been assembled in precisely that way. Watching crystals form in a flask added a very aesthetically pleasing aspect.
You mentioned the electronic approach to organic chemistry. What is that?
The traditional approach to chemistry was to conduct experiments, to determine the nature of the products, and then to try to deduce what had happened. But very little was known of why it happened. Various typical types of reactions could be recognised; treatment of a compound of a known class according to an established recipe would be expected to give a certain type of product. What wasn't known was why one expected it. What were the underlying rules that govern the chemical behaviour of molecules?
Then Robinson and Ingold in the UK developed the notion that chemical behaviour is linked to electronic factors. Since most organic molecules are held together by chemical bonds comprising electron pairs, they suggested that the way in which an organic reaction proceeds is determined by where the charge lies and the way the electrons move. That is, when a new bond is formed electrons move in to form the new bond and away from bonds undergoing fission. Once one understands the electronic approach to chemistry, one can develop predictive rules for molecular behaviour. Instead of just remembering what happens in chemistry, one can predict what will happen and why it happens. That was a very important andvance in the development of modern organic chemistry.
I believe that another important approach you met at university was White's First Rule. What was that?
Doug White was very interested in practical chemistry, and I must say he made us work hard at the bench. We learnt lots of techniques students don't learn nowadays, like glassblowing, and of course all our experiments were done with gas heating and ordinary water baths (fires in chemistry laboratories were quite frequent!). Doug's First Rule was: 'All the best chemistry goes down the sink.' What he meant was that the most interesting chemistry occurs when there is an unexpected outcome. There is a tendency among young students to set up an experiment and then, if the expected outcome isn't obtained, to regard the experiment as a failure and to dispose of the reaction mixture.
Doug said, 'If something has happened that is not what you expect, that is what is really interesting. It may indicate something new. This is how new chemistry is found.' So he would come around and ask, 'Have you had an unexpected result?' If we said the experiment was a failure, he'd say, 'No, it wasn't a failure. There was an unexpected outcome. Tell me exactly what you did. What did you see? What do you think it meant?' He taught us to be curious, to look for the unexpected. I now tell all my students: 'An experiment that you think is a failure may indeed reward you with the greatest find of your life – if you look.'
After those interesting experiences it was on to Honours. Did you do that in WA?
Yes. My Honours project was in two parts. First I worked with Doug White on natural product chemistry, a traditional area of chemistry that was very popular and interesting. One learnt how to handle very small quantities of material, and to purify them by chromatography. This experience was very important for me later on.
One of the great attractions of natural product chemistry was the collection of samples; plants that grow in attractive places were usually carefully chosen. I worked on Pittosporum phillyraeoides, for which the best source near to Perth was Rottnest Island. That necessitated a trip to Rottnest every second weekend to collect more of the plant material.
I enjoyed working with Doug White very much indeed. We made some useful advances – a few papers came out of this work – and it was exciting. But after a couple of months Doug went back to Switzerland and I shifted to a new project with Joe Miller involving research on reaction mechanisms.
The new project fascinated me – I discovered this was really what I wanted to do. Because Joe was mainly interested in the theoretical and electronic aspects of organic chemistry, working with him involved trying to discover why and how reactions occur; to identify God's rules, so to speak, for molecules and atoms. What are the laws that govern their behaviour? How can one use them predictively? These are essentially the type of questions I have pursued for most of my working life.
You got your First Class Honours at the end of 1951 and then became a graduate assistant in your old department. Why didn't you do a PhD instead?
In those days the PhD degree was unavailable in many Australian universities including the University of Western Australia; one could do a Masters degree but not a PhD. I had decided I would probably take a Masters degree anyway. One of the easy ways to do this was to take a graduate assistantship – an academic position, but lowly paid. We did some teaching, including quite a lot of laboratory supervision, but we were also allowed to conduct independent research. It was very good experience.
I decided to keep on working on the mechanisms of reactions. I explored a reaction of some commercial importance, one of the ways by which dyes are manufactured; namely, reactions of substances called diazonium salts with various reagents. Although it was quite successful, there was a serious problem when a particular reagent was used. When one is studying reaction mechanisms, the reproducibility of the experiment is very important. When one measures how fast reactions occur one expects that there should be little variability. But in this case I repeated the experiment many times with completely different results on each occasion – it was utterly irreproducible. I couldn't understand what was going on. Later I returned to this problem.
Among the great joys of being in that university and in that department at that time was the interaction with interesting colleagues. In the university at large there were many returned servicemen from the Second World War. They were mature and gave the university a completely different feeling. My colleagues in our department included Lloyd Zampatti, Geoff Watkins, who then went to work in Great Britain and is now a Fellow of the Royal Society, Don Watts, who is well known in Australia as an academic administrator, Jim Parker, who became a professor at the Australian National University, and Brian Bolto, who became a leading figure in CSIRO. They provided a very a stimulating atmosphere in which to work.
While you were still a graduate assistant, you got a scholarship offer to go overseas. Was that a University of Western Australia scholarship?
Yes. Winthrop Hackett had left a vast bequest to the university, which his executor had thoughtfully tripled before it was used, so the university was relatively rich. It charged no fees and was able to offer overseas scholarships, called Hackett Scholarships. I won one of these to study natural product chemistry for the PhD with Derek Barton at Birkbeck College in London.
But towards the end of that year, before I took up the scholarship, Professor Bayliss told me that he had received a letter from Professor Macbeth saying that he would like me to come to Adelaide as a junior lecturer. Bayliss strongly recommended that I accept this offer. So I did. I wrote to Barton to say I wouldn't be coming to London after all, turned down the scholarship, and prepared to go to Adelaide.
By the time you went to Adelaide you had a wife to accompany you. And you have just recently celebrated your golden wedding anniversary. Tell us about your wife.
Kaye's maiden name was Marshall. She is even more Australian than I. Not only were all of her grandparents born in Australia but also many of her great-grandparents. In fact, one of her ancestors was born in Sydney in 1802, and her family goes back to Captain Cook. At the celebrations of the first centenary of Australia her great aunt was a guest of honour.
Kaye was a secretary and then an accountant. We had very similar interests. We both loved swimming and spent as much time as we could on the beach – hence my skin these days is not as good as it should be. We loved music. At that time I was still playing a lot, as well as singing in various choirs. We both liked books, we enjoyed walking in the bush and we were very keen on the environment. I think one of the reasons we have been very happy together is that we share so many mutual interests.
Kaye later became professionally involved with the environment, being employed as a field officer by the Nature Conservation Society in Adelaide. Then she became interested in local government and was elected as the first woman councillor in the city of Mitcham, and later as the first woman alderman. Those elections provided all of us with interesting times. As well as electioneering, I used to act as a scrutineer and was able from time to time to point out that a bundle of votes had been put on the wrong pile. You've got to watch these council elections! Kaye was very successful as a local councillor and later on it was difficult for us to decide to come to Canberra, because she had to leave all her community work behind.
Did you go by train to Adelaide to take up your new position?
No, we went on the MV Westralia. I don't know why I came later to enjoy sea travel, because that was really not a very good voyage. At that time, however, it was the easiest way as any of getting across the Bight to Adelaide.
The sea was extraordinarily rough. Every meal was served on wet tablecloths and the seats were tied down. Even when one lay on the deck there was a danger of rolling overboard. One passenger, like us, was on his honeymoon but without his wife, because she had become so ill en route from Adelaide to Perth that she had to return by train!
You had a very gracious introduction to academic and social life in Adelaide, I think.
Oh yes, much more gracious than it would be nowadays. On the first day I went in to the Chemistry Department to meet my new Professor, Killen Macbeth, who said, 'Well, before we get down to mundane matters like teaching and so on, I have some important things for you to do. I have an appointment for you with the Vice-Chancellor, who would like to meet his new member of staff, and then you should go to Government House to sign the Visitors' Book, because the Governor always likes to invite people from the University to come to dinner. And then you should take tea with Hedley Marston.'
So I did all of those things. It was very nice to meet the Vice-Chancellor, we were invited to receptions at Government House, and I was very pleased to meet Hedley Marston, one of this country's most colourful scientists. Perhaps I had an introduction to him because his division of CSIRO was next door to the Chemistry Department, and there was a good deal of collaboration between them.
What was it like to teach at Adelaide in those days, Athel?
My teaching load wasn't particularly heavy but it was a shock, because I came as an organic chemist but Professor Macbeth asked me to teach third-year inorganic chemistry and third-year spectroscopy. The spectroscopy was not too much trouble – I had received good training in that – but inorganic chemistry was probably the weakest branch of chemistry in Western Australia, and I knew little about it. So I kept one lecture ahead, leafing through Emeléus and Anderson, the textbook of the time. Also, I was so relatively young that many of the people in the class were older than me and it was pretty daunting. Not only were there ex-servicemen but also a number of refugees who had come to Australia to avoid the turmoil in Europe. One of them, Tom Kurucshev, who was certainly older than I, later became my best friend, and quite a distinguished physical chemist in Adelaide.
Round about this time you realised that you really ought to have a PhD.
Yes. During that time in Adelaide, almost two years, my own research went quite well. I continued to do natural product chemistry and some mechanistic work involving completely new systems. We found new ways of making some important compounds related to thyroxin, the natural hormone that occurs in the thyroid gland. That work was very interesting and also quite significant. But towards the end of the first year I decided that if I intended to continue with academic work, I really should go overseas to take a PhD.
I successfully applied for a CSIRO overseas scholarship (the expectation by CSIRO was that, in return, I would come back to work with them). Part of the deal was that I should discuss with the appropriate authorities in CSIRO what I wanted to do, so I went to Melbourne to see Ian Wark, Chief of the Division of Industrial Chemistry. He gave me some extraordinarily valuable advice.
First he asked just what I intended to do during my scholarship. I told him that I thought I should work with Derek Barton. I had already turned him down once. He was one of the great chemists of this century. Ian asked, 'And what will be your research area?' to which I replied that I would study natural product chemistry.
But Wark went on, 'Is there anything else you're interested in?' 'Yes' I said, 'I conducted some experiments during my Honours year that gave completely irreproducible results, and I am beginning to think they might involve free radicals. I wouldn't mind learning more about them at Oxford, with Professor Waters.' Wark said, 'Take my advice. Go to Oxford. In science you should always choose the new, the more adventurous area. Natural product chemistry is a well-ploughed field where many people have gone before. If you work on free radicals, you will be at the beginning of something new. It's dangerous, because nothing may ever come out of it. But if you want to do something really useful in science, always choose the field that is innovative and at the birth of a new area rather than at its middle age.' So I decided to follow his advice – it was a wise choice.
Perhaps this is the time to ask you to explain what is meant by free radical chemistry.
Free radicals, in solution, were first described in 1900, by an amazing pioneer called Moses Gomberg. Chemists had tried for years beforehand to make free radicals without success and had concluded that they didn't exist. Then Gomberg announced that he had successfully generated them, and indeed we now know that he had. He is also famous for a memorable footnote to the first paper, which was published in 1900 in the American Chemical Society Journal. Having described these new species, these free radicals, he notes, 'This work will be continued and I reserve the field for myself.'
In fact, he needn't have worried, because nobody else was very interested. Most scientists didn't believe he had actually generated organic free radicals in solution. And even at the time that I was entering the field, there were still many chemists who had similar doubts. There were a great many polemical articles in the scientific literature, with some chemists maintaining that organic radicals can't exist in solution. Others were convinced that they could. There were very few people seriously working in the field of organic radicals in solution – a couple in Great Britain, a couple in America – I suppose six people, in all, in the world.
Free radicals are very reactive molecules. All the more familiar organic compounds, such as sugar, alcohol and acetone, are stable; they can be stored for long periods without change. They are stable because they possess an even number of electrons arranged in pairs. The bonds between the atoms consist of pairs of electrons; a pair of electrons is a stable arrangement. Furthermore, around most of the atoms in such molecules there are eight electrons in four pairs. This is a very stable configuration.
However, if one of the two-electron bonds in such a molecule is broken by irradiation of a sample with light or by otherwise applying energy then one of the ways a bond may break is by each half taking one electron. There will then be two new molecules each of which has an odd number of electrons. Inevitably one of those electrons must be unpaired and that is a very unstable state. These newly formed highly unstable, and hence highly reactive, molecules are free radicals.
Are there now two free radicals, or one?
If a bond in an ordinary stable molecule is broken symmetrically, two free radicals are generated. Each new molecule has an unpaired electron, and the formal description of a free radical is 'any atom or molecule that contains an unpaired electron'. Hence any species that has an uneven number of electrons must be a free radical. Indeed any species that has an even number of electrons but has, for some reason or another, has two of the electrons unpaired is also a free radical (a diradical).
Because free radicals have an unpaired electron, they are inherently extremely reactive. To return to a stable state the unpaired electron must couple with another electron to form an electron-pair. One of the great virtues of free radicals is that they will often react with organic molecules at positions that are normally resistant to attack.
So your task in Oxford was to find out more about free radical chemistry?
Yes. The electronic theory that I have already mentioned was initially based on studies of ionic substitution reactions of aromatic compounds such as benzene. My obvious goal was to determine what happens when free radicals attack aromatic compounds. It was known that the reaction mixtures would be very complex but nobody knew exactly why, and there was great confusion about the precise reaction mechanism. That was my problem, and I think I solved it in the course of my DPhil work. The mechanism of radical aromatic substitution was more or less clarified.
You did extraordinarily well, getting your DPhil after two years.
This is where my background training became so important. Doug White had taught me all about chromatography during my Honours year. It was, however, still a fairly new technique when I went to Oxford and I found that I knew far more about it than any of the other members of the group. Without that technical expertise I think we would not have made the progress that we did. It is the method par excellence for separating the types of aromatic compounds we were dealing with. As they fluoresce under ultraviolet light they were easily detected on a chromatographic column.
Did you say you went to work with Professor Waters?
Yes. At that time there were two chemists in the UK working mainly on organic free radical chemistry. Waters had published a book in 1946 and a little later a review with Donald Hey. Both generated considerable controversy because they claimed that many well-known reactions in common use were actually free radical reactions. Many chemists didn't believe them, and there was a vigorous argument about it in the literature. Even in the department in Oxford there were some people who thought we were way out on the left field. Sir Robert Robinson, Nobel Laureate, one of the great men of organic chemistry said when he first met me, 'You're another one of these idiots who believe in free radicals.' What an introduction!
Waters was very knowledgeable and a wonderful supervisor to work with. By and large he left one alone as long as things were going well. He encouraged you to think for yourself. We would meet only once a week because he was busy with his college duties and his teaching. Every Saturday morning he would wander round and talk to each of the students separately about his research. The group that worked with Waters in an area that was regarded as rather dubious by some in the department was tight-knit, with a very good collegiate spirit. Many of them later became well-known chemists.
What were your impressions of Oxford?
It was wonderful. There were many interesting activities available, and many interesting people. Bob Hawke was there – I've known Bob since the age of nine when we were close friends at primary school. He was a year ahead of me at Perth Modern School, and was also at the University of Western Australia while I was there. In Oxford we went to many social events together.
My wife and I loved college life. Kaye became a 'licensed boarding-house keeper' so that we could keep one or two students there as boarders. They helped out financially, as the scholarship didn't go very far, and they were built-in sitters for our baby daughter, which meant we were able attend a variety of interesting cultural events in Oxford. We became very fond of Oxford City and the Oxfordshire countryside.
Was that the time when you gave your first talk to a fairly prestigious gathering?
Yes, that was at the Chemical Society and occurred straight after my time at Oxford. I finished my DPhil work and the degree was conferred somewhere about October 1956. We had arranged to come back on the Strathaird, leaving London in about November. We left Oxford with clothes for two weeks, having sent all the rest on ahead as we intended to have a final holiday in London before we sailed to Australia.
We had been in London for about three days when the Suez War broke out. The P&O Company wrote to me to say that the Strathaird was stranded in the Red Sea and that we couldn't expect to leave London for a considerable time. The CSIRO was very good and kept my scholarship going while we waited in a London flat. I started to work again. I used to commute to Oxford to work with Dick Norman and with Prof Waters, and I also worked at home in London.
During that period the Chemical Society wrote informing me that a special meeting was to be held in London and inviting me to attend to describe my DPhil work and related chemistry. That was the first time I addressed an important audience.
We didn't leave London until some time in February, so in many ways we were 'down and out in London'– it was an expensive place even then. We lived in a little flat in Chiswick. Rolf Harris, who I had known at secondary school, used to visit us fairly frequently and we would sit in the kitchen, all with our feet in the oven to keep warm! It became rather essential for us to get to know every free, warm place in London; the hothouses at Kew Gardens, the Butterfly House at the Zoo, and of course all the art galleries. My small daughter became very well trained in art appreciation.
At that time many students had volunteered to help the Hungarian Revolution. We joined the cause by raising money. We did quite a deal of doorknocking around London and through this became friends with many interesting people, including some politicians. We were invited to the House of Commons.
Eventually the Strathaird did take you to Australia?
Yes, but very slowly. We broke down on the way and had to spend a week in Cape Town when the Apartheid era was at its height. It was an interesting but depressing experience. We saw the flora of South Africa, which is very colourful, and visited the coast.
When you returned to Australia and got to CSIRO, what research did you do?
I worked in a team headed by Dr H H Hatt. My task was to find commercial uses for wool wax. He suspected, quite rightly, that wool wax would be very useful if one could find a way of functionalising it (ie, replace some of the hydrogen atoms with oxygen atoms, or other non-carbon atoms) at positions in the wax molecule remote from the normal reactive group. Typically a wax molecule is a long chain, comprised mainly of carbon atoms and hydrogen atoms with an acid or an ester group (the reactive group) at one end. Hatt wanted me to devise a method to replace a hydrogen atom at the remote end of the molecule with an oxygen substituent.
Now, that's a really difficult problem, because a wax molecule contains a large number of hydrogen atoms. Why should any reactant selectively displace only one hydrogen atom at the end far from the existing reactive group? We tried all sorts of ways of doing this, and were quite unsuccessful. But I did make one interesting discovery, which later turned out to be rather significant.
There are many components in wool wax, but perhaps the best known of them is lanosterol a compound rather similar to cholesterol, a large molecule consisting of carbon and hydrogen atoms with only one oxygen atom at one end. Browsing through the literature I found the surprising report that cholesterol, after prolonged storage, often contains 25-hydroxycholesterol, a compound that contains two oxygen atoms, one at each end of the molecule. The question was why should cholesterol on ageing be converted selectively into such an unexpected product. This was an unprecedented and quite astonishing transformation. Was the report accurate?
So I wrote to friends around Australia saying, 'Please have a look in your store. If you have any cholesterol in a sealed bottle please send me some, with the date when it was purchased.' I analysed all these samples of cholesterol by means of spot tests and paper chromatography and found that indeed most of them did indeed contain 25-hydroxycholesterol. Furthermore, the amount of 25-hydroxycholesterol increased with age.
I conducted experiments to see how this unexpected product could be formed. Since I considered that the reaction must occur on the surface of the cholesterol, we treated crystalline cholesterol with pure oxygen and radical precursors under forcing conditions, using UV light. I had some absolutely spectacular explosions while doing this. It was quite dangerous work. I found that 25-hydroxycholesterol was formed. We had, as it were, accelerated an oxidation process involving attack of oxygen at an unexpected position remote from the existing oxygen. When conducted under normal conditions, reactions of cholesterol in solution proceed at positions adjacent to the existing substituent – never at the remote end. Why should this reaction of crystalline cholesterol be so different?
The structure of crystalline cholesterol provided a clue. The crystals are long, very flat, and very thin and the surface layers comprise cholesterol molecules with their unsubstituted tails sticking out. You can imagine the surface as closely packed molecules, side by side, each with the normally reactive end within the bulk of the crystal, and the other end exposed. It then occurred to me that reactions of crystalline cholesterol with oxygen occur at the normally unreactive end (the 25-position) because that is the only part of the molecule that the gaseous reagent can approach.
This work led to two important conclusions. One that I pursued later is that reactions on solid surfaces can often be quite different from reactions in solutions. This has important implications. The second was that oxygen-centred free radicals (formed by UV irradiation) are capable of removing a hydrogen atom from an unactivated carbon-hydrogen bond, that is one remote from an activating substituent. This is a most useful feature of free radicals that distinguishes them from other reagents. The big problem with most radical reactions is to persuade them to selectively attack the chosen hydrogen. The experiments with crystalline cholesterol showed one of the ways in which it can be done, that is by having each molecule closely packed on a crystal surface with each sheltered, as it were, by its neighbours.
Despite that success you didn't stay very long in CSIRO, did you?
No. I'm not too sure why I moved, except that CSIRO had rather restrictive rules about lab work and when one could come and go. I was used to the academic approach – when one had a bright idea, even if it was at 7 o'clock at night, one could hop in the car, go to work and do an experiment. So when it was made clear to me that I would have a strong chance of getting a good job at Adelaide, I applied, and was appointed. I moved back to Adelaide in early 1958, this time as a lecturer, a fully tenured staff member.
This second sojourn in Adelaide, from 1958 to 1981, was longer than the first. Your research interests at this time, I gather, were in the general area of the properties and behaviour of reactive intermediates. What are reactive intermediates?
A reactive intermediate is a molecule that is much more reactive than normal, and will usually occur only as an intermediate in a chemical reaction. It is halfway between two stable molecules, the starting material and the product. A free radical is a typical intermediate. Organic free radicals typically have lifetimes in solution of something like 10-4 to 10-9 seconds. That's an extremely short time when compared with ordinary stable molecules.
Many reactive intermediates are electron deficient. A free radical is electron deficient by having one electron missing. Other reactive intermediates such as carbenes and nitrenes lack two electrons – they have only six electrons in the outer shell of the reactive atom. The electrons can be arranged in three pairs, in which case there are two missing from the outer shell, or in two pairs and two single electrons. In each case the intermediate is electron deficient. They are still highly reactive because essentially they seek to attain a stable configuration with eight electrons in four pairs.
Not every reactive intermediate is a free radical. Only those intermediates in which the electrons are unpaired are free radicals. For example, if a carbene has six electrons as three pairs, with one empty orbital, it is not a free radical – it doesn't have an unpaired electron. Alternatively, if a carbene has two orbitals, each with a pair of electrons, and two more orbitals each containing one electron it is a radical. In fact, it is a diradical. It has two unpaired electrons and hence exhibits radical behaviour.
I have a special interest in your early years in Adelaide, as we were contemporaries and I knew the people in your department, Badger and Jordan. How did your research progress?
It went pretty well. I had come back from Oxford imbued with the idea of free radical research. We studied new types of radicals, and were particularly interested in radicals containing sulfur. One reason was that they are of great theoretical interest. Another was their possible implication in the induction of cancer. Geoffrey Badger was very interested in carcinogenesis – the process by which some aromatic hydrocarbons, particularly the larger ones like benzpyrene, have the property of inducing cancer in the skin of an experimental animal (or, for that matter, of humans). The question was how does this come about.
Our first experiments showed that sulfur radicals have the capability of binding very quickly to such polycyclic hydrocarbons, and we began to wonder whether this was the basis of their carcinogenicity. So we carried out quite an extensive study. We found that aromatic hydrocarbons do indeed react very rapidly with thiols (sulfur-containing compounds) in the presence of oxygen by a radical mechanism, and that this reaction is not limited to simple chemicals but extends to naturally occurring compounds that contain thiol groups, like glutathione, cysteine (one of the amino acids), and proteins such as bovine serum albumin. Perhaps carcinogenicity arose somehow because of such bonding to sulfur in components of the skin. Our subsequent experiments showed that carcinogenic aromatic compounds do indeed react very well with naturally occurring thiols.
Eventually we found that such reactions are not involved with carcinogenesis. However, when we returned to this work later these reactions proved to be very useful synthetically. Also they were related to important biological processes.
Were you working closely with Badger in those days?
Not particularly closely but we did have similar interests. At that stage he was very interested in pyrolysis, and how carcinogenic compounds are formed at high temperatures possibly via radical intermediates, because it was known by then that tars and smokes have the capacity to cause cancer. For this reason chimney sweeps were very prone to cancer.
A somewhat lighter episode occurred at the University of Adelaide, concerning Vice-Chancellor Rowe. Would you like to tell us about that incident?
I was a fairly lowly member of staff so I don't suppose Mr Rowe affected me very much, but I do know that his ideas for changing the way in which the university operated aroused considerable resentment among many staff and students. I think he had managed to put the students off side by being quite rude to them at a meeting.
At that time there were scare stories in the media about the Abominable Snowman, a strange animal that supposedly lived in the Himalayas and left footprints in the snow. So the students called Mr Rowe the Abominable Roweman. One morning when I came to work, there was a great kerfuffle – people standing around everywhere, the Registrar looking very upset – because leading from the Vice-Chancellor's house (which in those days was on campus) were some large white footprints. They went from his house through the campus, dropped in at the ladies' lavatory, came out again, followed one of the paths and then went right up the side of the Bonython Hall. And, on the top of the little tower above the Hall, there was the Jolly Roger flying!
The Registrar said, 'Ah! We've got 'em!' and there was a great hue and cry up the stairs, but nobody was found in the tower. There was just an ingenious mechanism for hoisting the Jolly Roger, and some time later the ropes, ladders and other apparatus that had been used was found in the ceiling. It must have been a very dangerous exploit, painting the wall of the Bonython Hall in the middle of the night. I don't know to this day who actually did it, but at the time it was thought to be one of the better student japes.
Late in 1961 you felt it imperative to become acquainted at first hand with the work of Barton at Imperial College, London, so you applied for and were awarded a Nuffield Foundation grant. What was so exciting about his work?
Barton was a really outstanding scientist, one of the great chemists of his time. Only Woodward, from Harvard, could compare with him. Barton had a fresh way of looking at chemistry. He was a good theoretician and very intuitive. He had a comprehensive knowledge of chemistry, and great powers of deduction.
For example, after I joined his group I heard a visiting lecturer explain how he had been attempting for many years to deduce the structure of a certain natural product. He said he had not yet been successful but he would show us all his results to date. Barton said at the end of the lecture, 'I've considered all your results and I can now tell you what the structure is.' He then drew the correct structure on the board. The visitor had worked on this problem for many years without success, but Barton was able, in the course of a single lecture, to solve it.
Barton shared a Nobel Prize for introducing the concept of stereochemistry. We had all become accustomed to drawing chemical structures on paper and hence to seeing them in two dimensions. Similarly we would see a cyclic molecule such as cyclohexane (A) as a flat ring with the hydrogen atoms around it as being equivalent. Barton, together with a couple of other scientists, pointed out that this was wrong.
One has to envisage a molecule in three dimensions (structure B). When one does that, you observe that the hydrogen atoms are not all the same. Some are above the ring, some below, and some approximately in the plane – they are spatially different and hence they are chemically different.
Barton pointed out that this chemical difference really exists. He showed, using three-dimensional models, that the hydrogen atoms bonded orthogonally to the general plane of the molecule – called axial (Hax) – have reactivity different from that of the equatorial atoms (Heq) which are within the plane. This had profound implications. So I went to study with Barton to
learn more about stereochemistry and his approach to chemistry. His laboratory was a very exciting place in which to work.
After your year in Imperial College you came back to Adelaide. Was that when you first met Ian Ross?
Yes, indeed. I was working with carbenes at that time. Although during my life I have worked mainly with free radicals, from time to time I have examined other reactive intermediates such as carbenes and nitrenes. I explained to you a few moments ago that these compounds can exist in two forms – the singlet, which is still very reactive but has all its electrons in pairs, or the diradical form, the triplet. I found that I could generate these intermediates in one form or the other, depending on the experimental conditions, and hence could study the difference in reactivity between them.
We soon noticed that one form changed relatively slowly into the other. I consulted with Ian Ross, a spectroscopist and expert theoretician who was in Canberra at that time, to help me decide what controlled the rate of change. We reached interesting conclusions about the energy relationship between one form and the other.
In Adelaide you received rapid promotion to Senior Lecturer and then Reader, and finally – aged only 35 – to full Professor and Head of the Department of Organic Chemistry, replacing Geoff Badger. You introduced quite revolutionary innovations in departmental governance. Did your changes coincide with a general move in the University of Adelaide toward more democracy, under the leadership of Badger when he returned from his brief period at CSIRO in Canberra to become Vice-Chancellor? Or did you lead the charge?
I wouldn't say that I led the charge – I am not sure that there was a charge; it was more a single-handed approach. But I thought, being new to the Chair, that it was time to do things differently, and in particular to involve the staff much more in decisions about how the department was organised, how we taught, what we bought and, and so on. I set up a departmental committee that met about once a month to discuss all matters concerning the running of the department. Some decisions were relatively important, such as the ordering of chemicals, the siting of laboratories, and the buying of large equipment, but others were quite minor – entertaining visitors for example.
I took the view, which I still hold, that these sorts of committees should be advisory. I believe that if you are the head of an organisation you accept the responsibility for it. You take the blame for what goes wrong, so the final decision must be yours. But, although these were advisory committees, there were very few occasions when I didn't agree with what the committee recommended.
In 1968 you had a year's study leave in York, where you were introduced to electron spin resonance – yet another technique that became very important to your work.
That's right. Electronic spin resonance spectroscopy was a wonderful technique that had been developed immediately after the war. Essentially, it enables one to see the positions of unpaired electrons in radicals and to determine the nature of their environment. An electron spin resonance (ESR) spectrometer contains a very large magnet and a klystron, a device for generating microwaves that are led down a waveguide into a 'cavity'. The cavity is the area within the magnetic field where the sample goes. The results are recorded on a computer and can be printed.
The basis of ESR is that an unpaired electron can be regarded as a minute spinning electric charge and hence has its own magnetic field. In accordance with quantum theory, once an electron is placed in an external magnetic field it can take up only two orientations, either parallel to the external field or antiparallel, which have different energies. If an electron is irradiated in a specific magnetic field with microwaves of exactly the right frequency, some of the electrons in the lower energy form absorb microwave energy and move to the higher energy form. The ESR spectrometer detects the resulting absorption of energy.
The important thing from our point of view, however, is not just detecting a single electron. That gives only one absorption. In typical radicals there are many types of atoms that are also magnetic. The proton, for example also has a magnetic field, and hence assumes two energetically different orientations in an external magnetic field. The magnetic field of the proton affect the magnetic felt by the single electron. It will be sensitive to all of the nearby magnetic nuclei. Typically, in an organic radical these will be protons, deuteriums, carbon-13, oxygen-17 and others. Hence the microwave absorption spectrum reveals the molecular environment of the unpaired electron. This is a wonderful technique. Not only did it resolve for all time the arguments about the existence of certain organic radicals in solution but it also revealed details of the structure, shape, configuration and electron distribution that had not previously been available. A typical ESR spectrum, which is a plot of absorption of energy against magnetic field, has a multitude of lines.
Not frequency?
No. The spectrometer contains a large main magnet, which is set at a predetermined field, and some small subsidiary magnets, which allow this field to be changed. Normally the field is slowly increased over time, while the sample is exposed to microwave radiation led down the waveguide. When the field strength is exactly that required for the microwave energy to match the energy difference between the two orientations of the free electron absorption occurs, is detected, and is displayed as a plot of absorption against field strength. For various technical reasons it appears as a first derivative curve. The plot might then show, for instance, just two absorption peaks indicating that the unpaired electron is adjacent to a single proton. In other cases the plot can be very complicated.
The ESR spectrum of the allyl radical provides an illustration of the utility of the technique. The structure of the allyl radical is often depicted as having a double bond at one end and the unpaired electron (depicted as a small black dot) confined to the other terminal carbon atom (Structure A). However, ESR spectrometry shows very clearly that the unpaired electron interacts with a single proton (Ha), with a pair of equivalent protons (Hb), and with a second pair of equivalent protons (Hc). Hence in agreement with theory the true structure of allyl radical is planar and the unpaired electron is delocalised, that is to say it is spread over three atoms but resides mainly on the two terminal atoms. The two C-C bonds are equivalent (Structure B).
ESR spectrometry led to some enormous advances in radical chemistry. Not only did it confirm that radicals can exist in solution, but it also revealed their lifetimes, their compositions, their shapes, on which atoms the unpaired electron resides, and what reactions they can undergo. In short it revolutionised research on the structure and reactions of organic free radicals
Just before you returned from York, you were awarded a Carnegie Fellowship and made a very extensive tour in the United States, going to about 30 universities and giving lectures at nearly all of them. It must have been an exhausting time. You went to Canada too. Was that when you met Ingold for the first time?
Yes. On that trip I met many people who became close colleagues. One was Cheves Walling, from Columbia, and another one was Keith Ingold of the National Research Council in Canada who I met at a meeting at Santa Barbara. I was already aware of his work – we found that we had very similar interests and have worked closely together ever since.
Then it was back to Adelaide in 1969. Your work took a new direction now, because you could bring knowledge of this new technique. You had to buy an ESR spectrometer, which I am sure didn't cost tuppence ha'penny. How did you do it?
In those days, I seem to remember, one could submit ARGC applications more frequently than one can now. I suppose it must have been about March when I put in an application for an electron spin resonance spectrometer. Only a few weeks later I had a meeting with Bob Robinson, the Chairman of the ARGC. He said, 'This seems to be an important project. It just so happens we have some money left over from last year, so how would you like to go and buy a spectrometer now? Have the deal finished by June.' And I did. With the availability of the spectrometer we were able to explore many new aspects of radical structure and reactivity. It was a very productive time.
Your work in Adelaide collided unexpectedly with radical student politics, didn't it?
Yes. Before I went to York, I had discovered a completely new reaction involving lead tetra-acetate. It was one of those cases where White's Rule applied, where something completely unexpected happened and it turned out to be extremely useful synthetically. This was rearrangement chemistry, not free radical chemistry. Anyway, I published some papers – in fact, they were sent off for publication while I was in York.
When I arrived back to Australia there was a letter from the Maumee Chemical Co., in America, saying essentially that they were very interested in this work. If I were agreeable, they would take out the patent in my name so that I wouldn't have to do all the hard work of preparing it, and then I would assign the patent to them. There would be a nominal fee by law to you of exactly US$1, but they would make appropriate payments to the Department and the University. I asked the university authorities what I should do, and they said that I should first of all explore the possibility of this discovery being used in Australia. I did that, but the market for these chemicals was really a world-scale market and a world-scale plant would be needed to make them. As this was simply not feasible in Australia the University agreed to proceed with the deal with Maumee. So we did. The patent was prepared and sent to the University to be signed off.
At just this time, however, in response to a great deal of activism by the Students for Democratic Action, and other left-wing radical student groups, the University had decided it would open its Council meetings for the first time – observers would be allowed to attend (I should add that when we were in England and America in 1968 we had noticed a lot of student radicalism) 'But,' the University told the students, 'You must understand that some matters will be commercial-in-confidence. We will place those items on the agenda but you will not hear the discussion or the full details.'
The students at this time were very upset about the 'industrial-military complex', the way in which universities were 'helping the forces of evil'. And when they attended their very first open Council meeting, expecting to find out the worst, the first thing they saw on the agenda which was labelled 'Confidential' was an item: 'Agreement between Professor Beckwith of the Organic Chemistry Department and an un-named American company.' There was no way I could escape!
The activists attacked me ferociously and they attacked the Organic Chemistry Department. We had to introduce special security measures. I was defamed in the student newspaper. No matter what I said, they just didn't believe me. Even some of our own students became involved. It is interesting that when I asked one of my students, 'Why are you being so rude about this?' he said, 'Oh, you know we don't really mean it. We like you very much indeed, Professor, but the fact is that you are a symbol of authority.' One couldn't win. I was often in court standing bail for students from my own department who had become involved, but that didn't make the slightest difference. Eventually it all settled down when they found better targets to attack.
And so another five years went by. In 1974 you went on study leave again – back to Oxford, this time to Sir Ewart Jones. What drew you to him?
Well, by now a lot of advances had been made in our understanding of radical chemistry and we were able to carry out a variety of novel radical reactions. I have already mentioned the ability of radicals to attack unactivated carbon-hydrogen bonds, a reaction which is very difficult to do in any other way. We had now found out how to achieve this process with high selectively.
Meanwhile, in the wider world of chemistry, it had been found that many useful transformations could be carried out with microorganisms. By that time, for example, almost all the corticosteroids were made from simple steroids, by incubating them in a fermentation broth with microorganisms that have the capacity to selectively introduce oxygen into molecules in unexpected places. I thought such transformations looked rather like free-radical chemistry, and decided we should investigate them further.
Sir Ewart Jones was an expert in this sort of work. He had microbiologists working with him in Oxford who were examining such microbiological reactions. I decided to go there and learn all about them. I greatly enjoyed working with Sir Ewart. He was a magnificent man, a chemist of the old school – a scientist and a gentleman.
We studied a variety of molecules and found it was certainly true that micro-organisms have the capacity to bring about transformations such as we had previously observed with 25-hydroxycholesterol – the selective insertion of an hydroxyl group at an unexpected centre far away from the usual position of reactivity. This was very interesting in so far as it interacted with the work we had been doing on surfaces.
It was not in this instance an example of radical chemistry, was it?
No, I don't think so, although one can't be certain. If radicals are involved they must be linked to enzymes. Obviously, there are some very reactive intermediates involved.
The work was new and interesting, but I do not think it led to a major change in direction for your research interests.
No. I came back to Adelaide intending to continue similar work, but it was too difficult to conduct microbiological experiments without a trained microbiologist on hand. What it did encourage me to do, however, was return to the sort of early work I had done with cholesterol at CSIRO, involving reactions of molecules as close-packed films on surfaces. We found out that this worked very well and was quite useful synthetically – many such experiments gave results remarkably similar to those obtained with microbiological systems. This remains an area to be explored further.
As you entered your last five or six years as head of Organic Chemistry at Adelaide, what was the main thrust of your work? Was it still free radicals?
Yes, there remained some important outstanding problems especially concerning selectivity. In chemistry there are three types of selectivity. One is chemoselectivity, the ability to attack a specific group in a molecule. That is very easy to achieve. Another is regioselectivity, the ability to carry out a reaction at a predetermined point in a molecule. That is much more difficult, particularly if one hopes to attack a specific carbon-hydrogen bond, when there are normally many of them. Finally, there is stereoselectivity, the ability to attack a molecule not only at the chosen centre but also from the chosen direction in three-dimensional space.
By this time, radical chemistry was becoming more popular and some unexpected new phenomena were being recorded. Most chemical reactions, other things being equal, afford the most stable possible product. For example, radical ring formation, which may occur when the radical contains a suitably placed double bond, would be expected on these grounds to favour the most stable possible ring. In fact many experiments with suitable radicals showed the reverse outcome. For example when there was a choice between the formation of a five-membered or a six-membered ring the five-membered products were usually formed even though they were clearly less stable than the six. Other examples of free radical reactions that gave the less stable possible product were found. Why should this be so?
We wondered whether it might reflect the way in which new chemical bonds are formed by creating a new electron pair. Electrons don't always occupy spherical orbitals – often the orbitals have directions in space. So one could imagine that these unexpected products might be favoured because of the actual direction, in three-dimensional space, by which one reactive centre approaches another.
Leo Radom, a theoretical chemist, provided assistance. He examined how a new bond is formed by attack of a radical on a double bond and found that the preferred structure of the intermediate – the transition state – requires maximum overlap of the orbitals involved in bond formation. These are the orbitals of the double bond and that containing the unpaired electron of the radical. As shown below the acceptor double bond orbitals are orthogonal to the plane of the molecular framework. The required overlap seen here in cross section is readily attained for five-membered ring formation but not for six.
Clearly, if the radical approaches in the wrong direction it can't form a bond. If it approaches in the right direction it is possible to form a transition structure for five-membered ring formation. It is also possible to envisage formation of a six-membered transition structure but the energy is greater because of the strain engendered. Transition structures are intermediate energy states in chemical reactions – they define the eventual outcome. A chemical reaction normally involves an increase in energy as the reactants approach each other followed by a decrease as bond formation is completed.
In a review in 1970 I had initially suggested that such five-membered ring formation was favoured over six because of stereo-electronic effects. It is stereo because it has to do with three-dimensional space; it is electronic because it involves the interaction of electrons in molecular orbitals. We then set about determining the validity of this hypothesis both for ring formation and for many other reactions. The more experiments we conducted, the more support we found.
In this period you did a fairly major survey of the field with Ingold, I believe.
Yes, we published a major review on rearrangements of excited states. We visited each other frequently, we had some wonderful times together, and we experienced the real joy of making new discoveries.
There was one occasion I shall never forget. We had conducted similar experiments in Ottawa and Adelaide that that gave quite unexpected selectivity. The reactions occurred on only one face of certain molecules containing oxygen. Why was this so? One night, at dinner with our wives at a fish restaurant in Adelaide – a dinner at which we probably drank rather a lot – we discussed whether the unexpected selectivity of these reactions had something to do with the interaction of the orbitals. When we arrived home, we thought about it some more, and by midnight we were sure this was the case. These reactions were under stereoelectronic control.
This is a really wonderful time in science, the moment when suddenly one sees the solution to a difficult problem! And it is usually so simple. Most important problems seem to have simple solutions, and you kick yourself because you haven't seen them years before. Ingold said, 'Let's write the paper now.' So we did. We wrote until 3.30 or so in the morning. When we arose next morning we wondered what sort of rubbish we had written. To our surprise it was just fine and went into the literature almost without change.
During your final years in Adelaide you went again to Oxford for some months, in 1979, and made some other visits while you were overseas. Why Oxford this time?
It was becoming increasingly clear that radicals are very important outside of the test tube as well as in it, and particularly in natural systems. One of the things I used to ask my students was, 'Why don't we go rancid?' It's a good question. Our bodies contain lots of fat. If one leaves a bit of fat lying out in the sun for a couple of days, it smells to high heaven. Why don't you and I go rancid? Well, we now know that fats go rancid because of free radical attack. Indeed, free radicals are everywhere. Whenever a chemical bond is broken by ultraviolet light, cosmic rays or beta radiation free radicals are formed. So radicals are ubiquitous. When they attack fats oxidative processes involving oxygen occur. The reason we don't go rancid is that we are protected while we are alive by natural anti-oxidants such as vitamin E and vitamin C. Because of this I became very interested in the mechanisms of metabolic reactions possibly involving the attack of radicals on the constituents of living organisms.
Jack Baldwin, the Professor of Organic Chemistry at Oxford, was interested in penicillin production. Even though it is so important, the way in which penicillin is formed in nature was completely unknown. The starting material, a simple dipeptide, had been identified but all attempts to identify the intermediates between it and penicillin had failed. What was going on? Baldwin asked me to set up some experiments to see whether radicals might be involved.
Those particular experiments gave ambiguous results, but we were so enthused with this work that with Jack's agreement I continued it when I came to Australia, and we did find evidence that radicals might be involved. The most recent biogenetic scheme now indicates that the formation of penicillin does indeed involve enzyme controlled radical reactions.
In your last two years in Adelaide you wrote some very influential papers, one of which led to the recognition of 'Beckwith's Rules', as they are called. What are they?
They are about using stereoelectronic ideas to develop guidelines – we never called them rules – that explain how and why free radical reactions behave as they do, and that can be used to predict their outcomes. We said that virtually all free radical reactions involve the interaction of the unpaired electron with some acceptor molecular orbitals and that this occurs under stereoelectronic control. It must occur in such a way that the orbitals involved achieve maximum overlap.
We had already started to deal with this hypothesis theoretically, by using what are called force field calculations. They supported the original hypothesis of stereoelectronic control. We set down the guidelines for radical reactions in four simple papers which showed the expected course of such processes as ring formation, ring opening, the abstraction of hydrogen atoms from stable molecules, and regiospecific atom-transfer processes. As outlined above, they predicted that if cyclic products are formed the smaller ring will often form more easily than the larger even though it is not the thermodynamic product, or that if a reaction occurs next to an oxygen atom it will usually proceed selectively on one face of the molecule. The predictions agreed with experimental observations thus indicating the utility of the guidelines in designing selective syntheses. Later, after I had moved to the Australian National University (ANU), we set about showing what all these rules meant in an extensive series of different reactions.
In 1981, after 22 years in Adelaide, you felt it was time to look for fresh pastures. You were successful in your application for one of the two chairs of chemistry at the ANU, in the Research School of Chemistry, where you followed immediately on the retirement of Professor Birch. You remained there until you retired in 1995. Did you find that the facilities available to you in Canberra were different from in Adelaide?
The facilities were better, there was more up to date equipment including better gas chromatographs and a new ESR spectrometer that was much more powerful than the one in Adelaide, and there was a large number of highly proficient and extremely helpful technical staff.
We started a number of new projects and made great progress. During 1981, for the first time a well-known synthetic chemist, Gilbert Stork, used free radical chemistry in synthesis. I was pleased that our results were being noticed and used but I also recognised that there would now be much more competition – and there was. Our work immediately began to attract the attention of a large number of synthetic chemists and I spent a lot of time travelling and speaking. It also meant that our work now took the direction of discovering new radical reactions that would be useful in synthesis. We began to examine the application of our rules to the preparation of complex molecules.
Did you propose, from what you knew, the way to go about getting a particular reaction, and then prove it yourself? Or did you just suggest it for somebody else?
Oh no, we always tried to prove it, but we didn't always conduct a complete synthesis of complex molecules such as alkaloids. Sometimes we were satisfied if we could efficiently prepare the essential framework of the molecule by radical methods. Also we showed that radical chemistry could be very specific – we could achieve very high stereoselectivity, and we observed outcomes that were quite unexpected.
Your contributions to science have included attendance at many international conferences, including a series on the chemistry of organic free radicals. The first of those took place in the mid-1970s, and I think you have been to most of them.
Yes, I've been to almost all of them. The last one, the Gomberg centenary conference in 2000, was very important. I was due to give a plenary lecture there, but I was unable to do so because of ill health.
You have given plenty of plenary talks at those conferences!
Yes. It was really very important in the early days to escape from the isolation in Australia, where for a long time I was the only person doing organic free radical chemistry. Later, one of my Adelaide colleagues, Frank Hewgel, joined the field and we met frequently. I would go to those early conferences with a map of the world upside-down and I would say, 'Well, all of the other people at this conference represent the bottom half, the northern hemisphere, while I am the sole representative of the top.' And that was true – for many years I was the only Australian at those international conferences.
When was the first of the Gordon conferences you went to?
I was invited to my first Gordon conference in 1978. It was on free radical chemistry, and it was really wonderful. There was a conference every two years on free radical chemistry, alternating with conferences on radical ions. Because our ideas were becoming so popular I was invited to all of them. I was in America at least once a year giving a plenary lecture at one or the other of these conferences. They were very invigorating and stimulating, and I made lots of friends. And, of course, I was no longer scientifically isolated.
Since you entered the field of radical chemistry it has grown from about six people working on it in the whole world, to a great community of interested people. You have said that from the beginning of your research career the overall aim has been not only to show that radicals could be involved in some organic reactions but also to develop the use of radical chemistry in complex organic synthesis. Would you care to elaborate on that?
Well, I think we have done that. We have used radical chemistry as key synthetic steps in ways that we would earlier never have dreamed possible. For example, we have recently used radical methods for making new amino acids that are not only stereochemically pure but also enantiomerically pure. This means they can be specifically prepared in either the right-handed form or the left-handed form. Also we have found completely new reaction mechanisms that proceed through transition structures where the electron is delocalised over a five-membered ring. And we have played our part in making free radical chemistry well known to the whole community. Nowadays free radicals are commonly mentioned in the media – we know how important anti-oxidants are; we know that free radicals can induce cancer; we know that free radicals are absolutely essential for some metabolic processes such as the synthesis of prostaglandins; and we now know a great deal about the mechanisms of such processes.
I suppose not many people can set out at the beginning of their career wondering if anything will come of their chosen field and then watch it slowly develop into a whole new area of science – in this case from a small, neglected byway of science that was barely believed by the scientific majority, to a major area with profound implications for chemistry, biology, environmental science and medicine.
One very pleasant recognition of your scientific achievement and contribution was your election to this Academy in 1973.
That was a great honour, and quite unexpected. I had given a major lecture to the Chemical Institute some time previously. A senior Australian organic chemist who was there said afterwards, 'That was a great lecture. I didn't realise that radicals could be so important. Maybe there will be a place for you in the Academy.' I thought no more of it, but one day I came home from work to find on the outside of our house a large notice reading, 'Welcome home, FAA'. My wife had heard that I'd been elected! (In those days potential candidates were not advised that their names had been put forward for election.) I was thrilled.
A crowning recognition of your achievement surely was your election to the Royal Society in 1987.
It was indeed. On this occasion we had forewarning that I might be elected and so we planned a party on the appropriate day and I awaited the telex to confirm my election.
At that time the only telex machine was in the chancelry. At 9 o'clock in the morning I went to the front office to see if a telex had been delivered, but there was none. I went again at 10, and still there was none. At 11 there was none. I was getting a bit worried. At 1pm I rang up my wife and said, 'We might have to cancel this party. Something's gone wrong. It's now 3am in London, the election is over, and I haven't heard a thing.'
And then there was a phone call from my brother in Western Australia to offer congratulations as he had just heard on the ABC that I had been elected to the Royal Society. Eventually the telex did turn up – it had arrived overnight in the chancelry, it had been read, placed in an envelope addressed to the Research School of Chemistry, sent in the ordinary mail, and delivered at about half past 2 in the afternoon. The Royal Society had done their part but the chancelry of the ANU had been somewhat lethargic. Anyway, we had a good party.
Throughout your career you have been prodigiously active in science and tertiary education, but you have also had many other interests. We have heard a bit about some of them – environment and local government, including electioneering, the radical student movement, to which I suspect you were probably a contributor as well as trying to deal with it, and your contribution to this Academy. You have also been heavily involved with other professional societies, particularly the Royal Australian Chemical Institute (RACI) and the Federation of Australian Scientific and Technological Societies (FASTS). We have also your interaction with industry, your involvement with the Wine Research Committee, your commitment to indigenous affairs, and your interests in music – which we've touched on – literature, opera, theatre, ballet and politics. Would you like to pick up on just a few of the things we have not yet discussed?
I will briefly mention the Royal Australian Chemical Institute, because I have been involved with it all my working life. I think I have occupied every position one can possibly hold, having been Assistant Secretary, Secretary, State President, Federal President and Vice-President and so on. I think the most important thing I did in the Chemical Institute was to democratise it. Elections for the presidency became real rather than just determined within the council. We tried to make all the statutes and bylaws gender neutral, and we introduced other reforms.
One thing I have been very proud of is my association with the Science Olympiad. It does a tremendously important job. It also coincides with my interests in indigenous affairs, because through the Science Olympiad I discovered how much one of our sponsors, Rio Tinto, does for Aboriginal communities.
My wife and I have been closely concerned with indigenous affairs since we became interested in Aboriginal art during our Adelaide days. I guess Kaye became one of Australia's major experts in Aboriginal art. Through her work we came to know many Aborigines in Adelaide and we found out a great deal about the troubles that they experience.
The Carrington Hotel, in central Adelaide, was virtually the only meeting place in Adelaide for indigenous people. One of the more interesting things I did in the early 1970s was to go down to the Carrington every Friday night with a friend to see what was happening. Usually we were the only whites in the place. The police would come in, walk up to an Aborigine in a very confrontational way until they were only six inches or so apart, and just stand and stare at him. When someone intrudes on your space like that, inevitably you push him or her away. This was regarded as an assault! The police would then arrest large numbers of Aborigines. It was very discriminatory. As my friend said, 'Good heavens, if the police tried to do that in a hotel in Port Adelaide, the lumpers would slaughter them!'
When the police realised that we were watching them, this behaviour stopped. We discussed the situation with the Minister for Justice in the Dunstan government. New laws were passed. That was the start, I think, of our interaction with indigenous people. We've been interested and involved in Aboriginal affairs ever since.
You have been given many talents and you have used them all to the maximum possible extent. An interview of this length cannot possibly do justice to all your achievements, both within science and outside it. Although we have dwelt mainly on your involvement with and contribution to science, and where that has taken you, I hope that this interview has revealed not only the scientist but the person as well. Thanks for spending the time with us, Athel.
© Australian Academy of Science