The status and quality of year 11 and 12 science in Australian schools
A report commissioned by the Office of the Chief Scientist to deliver a clear appraisal of science in year 11 and 12 classrooms, as well as the ideal picture and recommendations to achieve this.
The purpose of the study was to develop a clear understanding of Year 11 and 12 science in Australian schools and the potential issues involved. The research approach develops two pictures.
The first picture captures the best of what we want for our science students; the ideal. This ideal picture should embrace our high but realistic aspirations for Year 11 and 12 students.
The other picture is a clear appraisal of what is actually happening in Year 11 and 12 science classrooms at the present time throughout Australia.
Ideal picture
Students and their curriculum
- The science curriculum is relevant to the needs, concerns and personal experiences of the students.
- The teaching and learning of science is centred on inquiry. Students investigate, construct and test ideas and explanations about the natural world.
- Assessment serves the purpose of learning and is consistent with and complimentary to good teaching.
Teachers and their profession
- The teaching-learning environment is characterised by enjoyment, fulfilment, ownership and engagement in learning and natural respect between teacher and students.
- Teachers are professionals who are supported so that they can reflect and build the understanding and competencies required of best practice.
- Teachers of science including Year 11 and 12 have a recognised career path based on sound professional standards endorsed by the profession.
Resources for teaching and learning science
- Excellent facilities, equipment and resources support teaching and learning.
- Sufficient time is available by which teachers can prepare, teach and assess student science learning.
The value of science education
- Science and science education are valued by the community, have high priority in the school curriculum and science teaching is perceived as exciting and valuable, contributing significantly to the development of persons and to the economic and social well-being of the nation.
Actual picture
The students
One of the disturbing results is the fall in the collective number of students studying science. The general picture that emerges is that fewer students are studying science but these fewer students enjoy the science they experience and it is in keeping with their expectations for the future. Science students have a very positive view about science and its importance in broader society.
The science curriculum
The view of teachers and students as derived from the surveys and focus groups is that Year 11 and 12 science is constructed to prepare students for university study. This university preparation perspective has resulted in an overcrowded content-laden curriculum. With the amount of content to be covered there is little room for flexibility from either the teacher or student. The science courses are perceived to be conceptually difficult with an emphasis on theoretical abstract ideas.
Science teaching and learning
The content-laden curriculum encourages science in Year 11 and 12 to be taught in a traditional way using the transmission model. This approach is revealed by the fact that 73% of science students indicated that they spend every lesson copying notes from the teacher while 65% never or seldom have choice in pursuing areas of interest. Teacher demonstrations are common, with 79% of science students suggesting this occurs often, very often or always in a lesson. The practical work tends to be ‘recipe based’ with students required to follow specific instructions to achieve known results. In some states there are assessable open-ended student investigations. From the focus group discussion with teachers there was a concern about these investigations. The investigations were placing significant demands on both students and teachers.
Year 11 and 12 science teachers
Science in Year 11 and 12 is taught by the most qualified and most experienced science teachers. In the telephone survey, three quarters of the interviewed teachers indicated they had a Bachelor of Science. Only 7% had no science qualifications.
Resources
The heavy content curriculum puts significant pressure on teachers as they attempt to help their students. The most common factors that teachers listed as limiting their teaching were time (36%) and resources (23%).
Recommendations
- Science courses of biology, chemistry, Earth and environmental science and physics need to include a realistic amount of content for the time available. All the three strands of Science Understanding, Science as a Human Endeavour and Science Inquiry Skills need to be adequately covered in the content.
- Support a program like Science by Doing to recapture the interest of students in Years 7 to 10 science.
- Develop a set of guidelines to provide quality advice to Year 10 students considering selecting Year 11 and 12 science subjects.
- Provide more professional learning opportunities for senior science teachers to expand their teaching skills including the latest scientific developments.
- Develop a suite of digital curriculum resources for the new national curriculum subjects that will assist teachers.
- Increase the number of paraprofessionals, especially laboratory technicians, to support teachers.
- Relevant boards of study need to evaluate the value, impact and implementation of large scale student investigation assessment activities.
- Re-examine the various pathways by which people may train (or retrain) to become teachers. The intention should be to increase options by removing barriers while maintaining quality. In particular, employing authorities should be encouraged to acknowledge the relevant skills and knowledge that new teachers bring with them from previous work experience in determining salaries.
About the study
This study was commissioned by the Office of the Chief Scientist and funded by the Australian Government Department of Innovation, Industry, Science, Research and Tertiary Education.
Enrolment information in this report is based on data supplied by the Australian Government Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations (DEEWR). It was updated in January 2012 based on public statements made by DEEWR.
Searching the deep earth: the future of Australian resource discovery and utilisation
Recommendations on Australian minerals exploration from the 2010 Theo Murphy High Flyers Think Tank.
The 2010 Theo Murphy High Flyers Think Tank participants propose that future exploration success can be realised through an innovative, well-defined and nationally coordinated strategy.
They recommend bringing together the relevant expertise into a coherent, collaborative research network, working within a well-designed strategic framework or ‘roadmap’, to address the fundamental needs of the exploration industry.
The proposed road map would be underpinned by the following six initiatives:
- A national map of the depth and character of the cover of Australia that will prioritise new areas for exploration and new directions for research.
- A national map of the deep crust and adjacent upper mantle that will employ innovative methods to acquire new geophysical and geochemical data. This map will be supported by a competitive crustal drilling program to constrain the interpretations resulting from these new data.
- A national ‘distal footprints’ program to detect the far-field signatures of giant ore systems in ancient land surfaces now buried by cover.
- A national four-dimensional (3D plus time) metallogenic map that relates Australia’s major mineral deposits to the geodynamic contexts in which they formed.
- A national research network to bring the exploration community together and ensure we understand and exploit the available synergies.
- A national education and technology transfer program to foster rapid uptake and application of the results and ensure exploration success.
These initiatives will open up new frontiers for mineral exploration and enable the private sector to undertake Australia’s next phase of exploration competitively.
The data and knowledge created through these initiatives will also assist in further defining our water, energy and land resources.
Science literacy in Australia
Results of a survey among Australians to determine their level of science literacy and how it changed between 2010 and 2013.
The questions in this survey were first asked of Australians in July 2010 and were based on a previous survey conducted by the California Academy of Sciences.
The second survey was undertaken online and conducted between 7 and 10 May, 2013. Respondents were drawn from a professional social and market research panel.
Key findings
Although most Australians have a basis grasp of key scientific facts, there are still large numbers who answer important scientific questions incorrectly.
- For example, 59% knew the Earth takes one year to orbit the sun.
- 70% of Australians think that evolution is currently occurring.
- 73% of Australians think people are influencing the evolution of other species.
These results are broadly similar to those in 2010 however there were some small, but statistically significant decreases, in the proportion of Australians who were aware of some key scientific facts.
- There was a 4% reduction in the proportion of people who knew that 3% of the earth’s water that is fresh (down to 9%).
- There was a 4% reduction in the proportion of people who believe humans are influencing the evolution of other species (down to 73%).
Generally younger respondents, men and those with a higher education level were more likely to answer the questions correctly.
- For example, 68% of men knew the Earth takes a year to orbit the sun compared to 50% of women. While 78% of university educated respondents knew that evolution is still occurring compared to 63% of those with just a high school education.
However, knowledge levels amongst young people have dropped more than other groups over the last 3 years.
- For example, there was a 12% reduction in the proportion of 18–24 year-olds who know the earth orbits the sun in a year (down to 62%).
- There were also tentative, but less significant falls in the proportion of 18–24 year olds who believe that evolution is occurring or that humans are influencing the evolution of other species.
There remains a high acknowledgement that science education is important to the Australian economy.
- 79% of Australians say that science education is absolutely essential or very important; almost the same proportion as 2010.
About the study
The overall sample size was 1,515, segmented and weighted to be nationally representative of Australia’s population by gender, age and residential location.
The accuracy of the results at an overall level is +/-2.5% at the 95% confidence interval. This means, for example, that if the survey returns a result of 50% to a particular question, there is 95% probability that the actual result will be between 47.5% and 52.5%.
Note: All percentage figures in this report are rounded. Accordingly, totals may not add up to 100%.
Research and innovation in Australia: a policy statement
Ten recommendations aimed at increasing the chances of Australia realising its potential as a major contributor to a global, knowledge-based economy.
The nation’s future socio-economic and environmental prosperity will be underpinned by science, technology and innovation.
Without urgent attention to education, research and innovation policies, Australia may find its current competitive advantages in the international marketplace rapidly eroded.
Alternatively, strategic investment in science, technology and innovation will open up new and exciting opportunities to strengthen the quality of life for all Australians.
Recommendations
- That Australia increases its support for the national R&D effort to ensure that it retains an internationally competitive science capability to underpin the nation’s industrial, commercial, environmental and economic position among leading world economies.
- That Australia examines the implications of the continuing relatively low level of private sector investment in R&D and creates policy settings that encourage greater innovation.
- That Australia further addresses the critical lack of suitably qualified science and mathematics teachers, and expands programs to encourage high school students to study science and mathematics.
- That Australia maintains a long-term commitment to basic research funding in universities, and ensures that the Research Quality Framework (RQF) results in additional funds for high-quality research.
- That Australia continues to invest in the future by building on the Higher Education Endowment Fund (HEEF) for capital works and research infrastructure in universities.
- That Australia provides support for publicly funded research organisations sufficient to maintain their core capabilities, on which their competitiveness as world-class research providers depends.
- That Australia increases its level of support for existing research centre schemes and develops new ‘International Research Centres’, and that the research fellowship awards be substantially expanded, particularly for early- and mid-career researchers.
- That Australia makes a long-term commitment to maintaining first class national research infrastructure facilities and promotes Australian access to international facilities.
- That Australia gives urgent attention to nurturing rewarding and secure career paths for talented early-career researchers.
- That Australia recognises the importance of engagement with the international scientific community and uses science more effectively as a tool in foreign policy.
National nanotechnology research strategy
Outlining a bold vision for a nanotechnology-enabled Australian economy with eight key recommendations.
This research strategy highlights Australia’s research strengths across a broad range of nanotechnology disciplines and identifies opportunities for these strengths to be leveraged over the coming decade. It includes eight recommendations and 10 case studies.
Nanotechnology is transforming industries and everyday life by exploiting unique properties of materials at the nanoscale, enabling breakthroughs in medicine, electronics, energy, water treatment, and manufacturing.
The technology offers solutions to national challenges such as healthcare, clean energy, food security, and defence.
Progress depends on overcoming barriers such as sustained funding, interdisciplinary collaboration, international partnerships, and effective translation of research into industry, alongside addressing safety and ethical concerns.
Recommendations
- Maintain and expand Australia’s nanotechnology research infrastructure (human and capital) through the provision of stable, long-term financial support.
- Foster and support interdisciplinary research.
- The Australian Research Council and National Health and Medical Research Council need to be provided with additional resources to facilitate their expanded role of supporting interdisciplinary research.
- Promote Australian nanotechnology on the international stage.
- Establish an expert panel (comprising academia, industry and government) to develop a national framework for translating nanotechnology research.
- Expand training and reskilling programs to support and develop new nanotechnology-based industries in Australia.
- In the interest of ‘ethically responsible science’ the nanotechnology research community should establish mechanisms to effectively engage with the public on the benefits and risks of nanotechnology, including social impact, regulation and ethical issues.
- Establish and fund a national nanotechnology coordinating body to provide leadership for the discipline at all scales and a mechanism for implementing the preceding recommendations.
About the strategy
The National nanotechnology research strategy was launched by Senator the Hon Kate Lundy on 7 December 2012.
Preparation of the strategy included broad consultation with the research community, including release of an exposure draft and hosting stakeholder engagement workshops around the country.
The strategy was prepared by the Academy with funding received from the National Enabling Technologies Policy Section in the Department of Industry, Innovation, Science, Research and Tertiary Education.
Nanotechnology benchmarking report
Australian nanotechnology researchers are producing high-quality work, but there is evidence that we are not advancing our capabilities as quickly as the rest of the world.
This project pilots a benchmarking methodology for assessing emerging areas of science and technology in Australia by assessing Australia's capability in nanotechnology.
It identifies strengths, gaps and strategic opportunities for national advancement.
The study found that Australian nanotechnology researchers are producing high-quality work across all areas of nanotechnology, but there is evidence that Australia is not advancing our capabilities as quickly as the rest of the world. The findings also suggest that Australia may fall further behind in the future unless nanotechnology is maintained as a national research priority and funded accordingly. It is recommended that Australia's nanotechnology research performance be regularly evaluated using the methodology established in this study.
This project was funded under the Australian Research Council's (ARC) Learned Academies Special Projects grant scheme.
Preliminary findings of the benchmarking project were presented at the Sir Mark Oliphant Conference 'Scaling down to a nano-materials world' in Melbourne on 1–4 December 2003.
Nanotechnology in Australia: trends, applications and collaborative opportunities
Characterising Australia's nanotechnology capacity and capabilities.
Nanotechnology is already having a profound impact upon major industries worldwide, including electronics, computers, communications, defence, energy, biomedical, transport and manufacturing. It has emerged as a critical field with the potential to impact nationally significant issues as diverse as health, water and energy.
Nanoscale science and technology is multidisciplinary, involving physicists, chemists, biologists, materials scientists, chemical, mechanical and electronics engineers and medical scientists.
This report characterises Australia's nanotechnology capacity and capabilities and makes recommendations to support nanotechnology research, addressing barriers to industry partnerships and commercialisation, international collaboration, and infrastructure and operational costs.
Recommendations
- Produce a National Strategic Plan for Nanotechnology Research in consultation with the research community.
- Allocate long-term funding to an integrated nanotechnology network that simultaneously represents research and industry needs.
- Develop a single, centralised, national support mechanism for international collaborations and linkages at all scales.
- Allocate funding for existing nanotechnology infrastructure and equipment, and in the long-term incorporate operational costs, such as maintenance and the provision of technical staff, into infrastructure funding models.
- Continue to support basic research in nanotechnology while also encouraging ‘market-driven, problems-based’ research.
- Establish a nanotechnology entrepreneurial fellowship scheme.
- Maintain support and funding mechanisms for Australian-based nanotechnology collaborations, with dedicated schemes for postgraduate students and early-career researchers.
- Continue efforts to integrate with research, industry and business in the development of science-based regulation and direct community engagement on nanotechnology issues.
Mid-term review of the Australian astronomy decadal plan 2006–2015
Setting out the priorities of the Australian astronomy community for the second half of the 2006–2015 decadal plan period in light of successes and challenges.
Australian astronomy is riding a wave of discovery powered by new technology. This technology has increased the sensitivity of existing telescopes and enabled the construction of new telescopes that can see wider and further than ever before.
This is the mid-term review of New horizons: a decadal plan for Australian astronomy 2006–2015.
It reaffirms the key goals of the decadal plan, and acknowledges both the Government’s significant investment in astronomy facilities over the past five years and its recognition of astronomy as a flagship Super Science area.
Download the mid-term review plan
Download the mid-term review issues paper
Maximising the benefits from Australia’s formal linkages to global scientific activities
An inventory of significant global scientific organisations and collaborative opportunities, mapped against Australia's engagement and resulting benefits.
Science by nature is an international enterprise. Contributing to progress in science, developing excellence in Australian science, and maximising the benefits of science requires that Australia participates fully in this enterprise.
This report assembles an inventory of significant global scientific organisations and collaborative opportunities in which Australian scientists and scientific institutions might reasonably be expected to be involved, and maps the extent to which Australia is currently engaged in these programs and the benefits that flow from that engagement.
The report finds that Australia is reasonably well engaged with global scientific activities.
Approximately 100 major global scientific organisations are identified, along with many more significant activities and organisations under these.
Several clear benefits from Australia’s formal engagement with global scientific organisations are identified, including leadership opportunities, scientific conferences, collaborations, and political influence.
The study also identified several strategically important gaps and recommended that Australia rejoin some organisations.
To live within Earth’s limits: an Australian plan to develop a science of the whole Earth system
Advancing the science needed to address the growing globalisation of human impacts on the environment.
This precious and beautiful blue planet on which we live is complex beyond measure, so complex that a whole new science – an integrative science of the Earth system (Earth System Science or ESS) – is needed to understand it.
This report, prepared by the National Committee for Earth System Science, lays out a systematic and coherent plan to create an Australian scientific enterprise – combining inputs from the natural and social sciences, economics, and the humanities – which is devoted to understanding the planet’s life support systems.
Its primary aim is to discover the Earth’s biophysical limits and how to live within them.